P.DURAIRAJ (FOR HIMSELF & ON vs SANTHAKUMARI
- Court
- Madras High Court
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
Reserved on : 27-10-2026
Delivered on : 13 -11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE THIRUMAGAL
CHANDRASEKAR
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
CNR:{HCMD010841982014}
and MP(MD).No.1 of 2014
P.Durairaj
(for Himself & On Behalf Of Devotees Of Sree
Moola Esakki Amman Temple),S/o. P.Pauliyan
..Appellant / plaintiff
Vs.
Santhakumari
W/o. Tharmaraj, Puthukkaduvettivilai, Moolachel,
Mekkamandapam Post, Thuckalay Village,
Kalkulam Taluk, Kanyakumari District.
.. Respondent / defendant
Prayer: Second Appeal filed under Section 100 CPC against the judgment
and decree dated 11.09.2013 passed by the Subordinate Court,
Padmanabhapuram made in A.S.No.8 of 2013 confirming the impugned
Judgment and decree dated 18.12.2012 passed by the Additional District
Munsif Court, Padmanabhapuram made in O.S.No.280 of 2009.
For Appellant :Mr..A.P.Rajan
For respondent : Mr.R. Sriram
for M/s. P. Kalaiyarasi Bharathi
__________
Page 1 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
JUDGMENT
This Second Appeal has been filed against the judgment and decree
dated 11.09.2013 made in A.S.No.8 of 2013 on the file of the Subordinate
Court, Padmanabhapuram confirming the impugned Judgment and decree
dated 18.12.2012 made in O.S.No.280 of 2009 on the file of the
Additional District Munsif Court, Padmanabhapuram
2. The brief facts of the case are as follows :
(i) The case of the plaintiff is that the suit 'A' and 'B' schedule
properties originally belonged to the common ancestor, Padmanabhan
Nadar, who divided the 'A' schedule property into two equal portions and
settled the western portion in favour of the plaintiff's father, Palaiyyan,
and the eastern portion in favour of the defendant's father, Chellaiyan,
under separate documents. Accordingly, both parties' fathers were in
possession and enjoyment of their respective shares. Subsequently, the
defendant's father gifted his eastern share in favour of the defendant, who
has been enjoying the same.
(ii). According to the plaintiff, the 'B' schedule property, measuring
an extent of 8¼ cents in Re-survey No.253/12 of Thuckalay Village,
__________
Page 2 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
comprises Sri Moola Isakki Amman Temple and Isakki Amman Temple,
which were constructed by the plaintiff's ancestors about 170 years ago.
The members of both families have been worshipping the deities in the
said temples from time immemorial. The plaintiff claims to be the present
President of the Temple Committee and states that daily poojas and
festivals are being conducted under his administration. It is alleged that
the defendant, who had converted to Christianity, developed hostility
towards the plaintiff and interfered with the temple administration.
Though the defendant is entitled to worship in the temple, she has no
right to interfere with its administration. The plaintiff further alleged that
the defendant, along with certain persons, trespassed into the temple
premises on 30.03.2009 and damaged the compound wall, causing a loss
of Rs.10,000/-. Despite a police complaint dated 31.03.2009 and the
matter being referred to the Revenue Divisional Officer, the defendant
allegedly again trespassed into the premises on 28.06.2009 and damaged
the eastern compound wall, store room and shed, causing further damage.
Hence, the plaintiff instituted the suit in a representative capacity on
behalf of the devotees of Sri Moola Isakki Amman Temple, seeking a
decree of permanent injunction restraining the defendant from interfering
with the temple administration and its properties, together with a decree
for recovery of damages.
__________
Page 3 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
(iii) The defendant resisted the suit by denying the plaintiff's claim
regarding the existence and ownership of the temples and disputing the
extent of the suit properties. According to the defendant, the extent of the
property was only 42 cents and not 33.750 cents as stated in the plaint,
and there were no idols or temples in the suit property. The defendant
contended that the original owner, Padmanabhan Nadar, had executed
separate gift deeds in favour of the fathers of the plaintiff and the
defendant on the same date, and that the extent and boundaries allotted to
each were specifically demarcated in the plans annexed to the respective
documents. Therefore, neither party could claim any right beyond the
respective portions allotted to them. It was further contended that the
ancestors of both families merely offered the first yield obtained from the
trees in the 'A' schedule property to their deity at a particular place
situated on its southern side and that no temple or idols existed in any
portion of the property. The defendant alleged that, taking advantage of
her absence while residing at her parental home, the plaintiff had
encroached upon her portion and constructed compound walls and other
structures in April 2009 without her knowledge. She denied having
caused any damage to the structures and contended that the allegations of
trespass and damage were false. According to her, the present suit had
__________
Page 4 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
been instituted with an ulterior motive to grab her property under the
guise of temple administration. She also questioned the maintainability of
the representative suit and contended that the suit was bad for non-joinder
of necessary parties. On these grounds, she sought dismissal of the suit.
(iv) During trial, the plaintiff examined himself as P.W.1 and one
Rajakumar as P.W.2, and marked Exs.A1 to A10. On the side of the
defendant, the defendant was examined as D.W.1, her father Selvam as
D.W.2 and the Advocate Commissioner as D.W.3, and Exs.B1 to B8 and
Exs.C1 to C3 were marked.
(v) The Trial Court, upon consideration of the oral and
documentary evidence, dismissed the suit. Aggrieved by the same, the
plaintiff preferred an appeal, which was also dismissed by the First
Appellate Court.
3. Challenging the concurrent findings of the Courts below, the
appellant / plaintiff has preferred the present Second Appeal.
4. The Second Appeal was admitted on the following substantial
questions of law:-
__________
Page 5 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
a) Whether the existence of a Temple in the suit B
schedule property can be taken to be proved on the
basis of Ex.A.1 and upon the categorical admissions
made by the defendant in her evidence?
b) Whether Ex.A.1, resurvey plan for field
No.253, a revenue record issued under taken into
Government authority can be consideration for
establishing the factum of possession and availability of
Temple in the property, particularly in addition to the
report of the Commissioner marked as Ex.C.1 and the
plans marked as Exs.C.2 and C.3?
c) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the limited
minimum relief of decree of prevent permanent
injunction to the defendant from demolishing the entire
Temple by taking low into her hands?
d) Whether the Courts below mis-directed
themselves in seeking to decide the title over the
property in the absence of issues framed for the same
and without any demand for such relief?
5. The case of the appellant / plaintiff is that the suit 'A' and 'B'
Schedule properties, comprised in Re-Survey No.253/12, originally
belonged to the common ancestor, namely, Padmanabha Nadar, who was
the grandfather of both the appellant / plaintiff and the respondent /
defendant. According to the appellant / plaintiff, the 'A' Schedule
property, measuring an extent of 33.750 cents, was divided into two equal
portions, namely, the western portion measuring an extent of 16.875
cents, which was settled in favour of the appellant / plaintiff's father,
Palaiyyan, and the eastern portion measuring and extent of 16.875 cents,
__________
Page 6 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
which was settled in favour of the respondent / defendant's father,
Chellaiyan, under separate settlement deeds. He further contended that
the 'B' Schedule property, measuring an extent of 8.250 cents in Re-
Survey No.253/12, comprised Sri Moola Isakki Amman Temple, which
had been constructed by their ancestors about 170 years ago. The
members of both families had been worshipping the deities in the said
temples from time immemorial. The appellant / plaintiff claimed that he
was the President of the Temple Committee and was administering the
temple by conducting daily poojas and annual festivals.
6. According to the appellant / plaintiff, though the respondent /
defendant was entitled to worship the deity, she had no right to interfere
with the administration of the temple. However, owing to certain disputes
between the parties, the respondent / defendant allegedly trespassed into
the temple premises on 30.03.2009 and damaged the compound wall,
causing a loss of Rs.10,000/-. Despite a police complaint dated
31.03.2009 and subsequent proceedings before the Revenue Divisional
Officer, the respondent / defendant allegedly again trespassed into the
temple premises on 28.06.2009 and damaged the eastern compound wall,
store room and shed, causing further damage. Hence, the appellant /
plaintiff instituted the suit in a representative capacity on behalf of the
__________
Page 7 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
devotees of Sri Moola Isakki Amman Temple, seeking the aforesaid
reliefs.
7. The respondent/defendant resisted the suit by denying the very
existence of the temple in the 'B' Schedule property. According to the
respondent / defendant, the appellant / plaintiff had wrongly described the
suit property and its extent. The total extent of the property was 42 cents
and not 33.750 cents as stated by the appellant. The original owner,
Padmanabha Nadar, had executed separate gift deeds in favour of the
fathers of the appellant / plaintiff and the respondent / defendant, allotting
21 cents each, which were specifically demarcated in the plans annexed
to the respective documents.
8. The respondent / defendant further contended that the property
was divided into two separate portions, namely, Plot 'A' and Plot 'B',
measuring an extent of 21 cents each, and that the southern and northern
portions were allotted to the respective beneficiaries under the gift deeds.
According to the respondent / defendant, there was no temple or idol in
the suit property. The ancestors of both families had merely offered the
first yield obtained from the trees to their deity at a particular place
situated in the property. Taking advantage of the respondent / defendant's
__________
Page 8 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
absence, the appellant / plaintiff had recently encroached upon the
respondent / defendant’s portion and constructed a temple, compound
wall and other structures without her consent. The respondent / defendant
denied having caused any damage to the said structures and contended
that the suit had been instituted with an ulterior motive to grab her
property under the guise of temple administration. She also questioned
the maintainability of the representative suit and contended that the suit
was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties.
9. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant / plaintiff
would submit that Sri Moola Isakki Amman Temple, along with the
Vinayagar deity, has been in existence in the suit 'B' Schedule property
for more than 170 years. The temple was constructed by the ancestors of
the appellant / plaintiff's family and has been continuously administered
by the family members. The existence of the temple is also reflected in
Ex.A1, the Re-Survey Plan relating to Survey No.253/12. He further
contended that the respondent / defendant herself had admitted the
existence of a place of worship where the ancestors of both families used
to offer the first yield obtained from the trees. Therefore, the existence of
the temple cannot be disputed. The Advocate Commissioner's report and
the accompanying plans, marked as Exs.C1 to C3, would also establish
__________
Page 9 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
the existence of the temple and its structures. In such circumstances, the
appellant / plaintiff is entitled for a limited relief of permanent injunction
restraining the respondent / defendant from demolishing the temple or
interfering with its administration. The Courts below have failed to
appreciate the documentary and oral evidence in their proper perspective
and prays for allowing this Second Appeal.
10. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent /
defendant would submit that the appellant / plaintiff has not produced any
title document or other acceptable documentary evidence to establish the
existence of the temple in the suit 'B' Schedule property. The appellant /
plaintiff's entire claim is based upon Ex.A1, which is merely a Re-Survey
Plan and cannot, by itself, establish either title or lawful possession over
the disputed property. He would further submit that Exs.B1 and B7,
which are the registered gift deeds executed in favour of the respondent /
defendant's father and the appellant / plaintiff's father respectively, clearly
establish that the original property measuring an extent of 42 cents was
divided into two equal portions of 21 cents each. The boundaries and
measurements of the respective portions were specifically described in
the documents and the plans annexed thereto. Neither of the documents
contains any recital regarding the existence of a temple or the reservation
__________
Page 10 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
of any portion of the property for temple purposes. The Advocate
Commissioner's report also indicates that the temple structure was of
recent origin. Therefore, the concurrent findings of the Courts below do
not warrant any interference in the Second Appeal.
11. Heard Mr. A.P. Rajan, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant / plaintiff and Mr.R. Sriram, learned senior counsel appearing
for Ms. P. Kalayarasi Bharathi learned counsel for the respondent /
defendant and perused the materials available on record
12. The principal issue that arises for consideration is whether the
appellant / plaintiff has established the existence of an old temple in the
suit 'B' Schedule property and whether he is entitled to seek an injunction
against the respondent / defendant in respect of the said property.
13. The appellant / plaintiff's specific case is that the total extent of
the property was divided into two equal portions of 16.875 cents each and
that a separate extent of 8 ¼ cents was earmarked as the 'B' Schedule
property for the temple. However, the respondent / defendant has
disputed the very description and measurement of the property and
contended that the total extent was 42 cents, which was divided into two
__________
Page 11 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
equal portions of 21 cents each.
14. In order to substantiate her contention, the respondent /
defendant has produced Ex.B7, the registered gift deed dated 10.09.1984
executed by Padmanabha Nadar in favour of Palaiyyan, the father of the
appellant / plaintiff. The relevant recital in the said document reads as
follows:
"10.09.1984 ஆம் தே தி தக்கலை யில் ,
மருவூர்கோ ணம் தே சத்து வடசேரிவிளை யில்
வசிக்கும் பத்மநாப நாடாரின் மகனான , சுமார் 45
, 90
வயதுடைய பாலை யன் என்பவருக்கு சுமார்
வயதுடைய வே டமுத்து நாடாரின் மகன் சொ ஸ்தம்
என்பவரான பத்மநாப நாடார் எழுதிக் கொ டுத்த
இஷ்டதானப் பத்திரம் என்னவெ ன்றால் :
நான் எனது இரண்டாவது மகனாகிய உமக்கு ,
,
என்மீது உமக்குள்ள பற்றுதலை யும் எனக்கு
உம்மீது ஏற்பட்டுள்ள வாஞ்சையை யும் ,
ஆதரவை யும் கருத்தில் கொ ண்டு , உமது
,
வருங்கால நலனை க் கருதியும் உமது
ஜீவனத்திற்காகவும் காலட் சேபத்திற்காகவும் , கீழ்க்
குறிப்பிடும் பட்டியல் சொ த்துகளை ச் சில
நிபந்தனை களுக்கு உட்பட்டு , அரசு தீர்வை யை யும்
செலுத்தி , நீர் சுவாதீனமாக வை த்துக் கொ ண்டு
அனுபவித்து வருவதற்காக இத்துடன்
இணை க்கப்பட்டுள்ள பிளானின்படி எழுதிக்
.
கொ டுக்கிறே ன்
, - .253/12-
மே ற்படி சொ த்து ரீ சர்வே எண் ல்
அமை ந்துள்ள 42 சென்ட் நிலத்தில் , பிளான் ' பி”
21 8 50
பகுதியில் சென்டுக்கு இணை யான ஏர் சதுர
மீட்டர் நிலமாகும் ."
15. A reading of the above recital in Ex.B7, together with the
__________
Page 12 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
property schedule and the plan annexed thereto, indicates that the
property was dealt with as part of the larger extent of 42 cents and that an
extent of 21 cents was allotted to the appellant / plaintiff's father. The
corresponding gift deed in favour of the respondent / defendant's father is
also relied upon by the respondent / defendant. Exs.B1 and B7, read
together, disclose that the original owner had divided the property into
two equal portions and settled the respective portions in favour of the
fathers of the parties.
16. Significantly, there is no recital in either Ex.B1 or Ex.B7
indicating that any separate extent of land had been earmarked or
excluded for the purpose of constructing or maintaining a temple. There
is also no reference in the said documents to the existence of an
independent temple or to any dedication of the property in favour of the
deity. On the other hand, the appellant / plaintiff has not produced any
registered document, settlement deed, partition deed or other acceptable
documentary evidence to establish that the alleged 'B' Schedule property,
measuring an extent of 8 ¼ cents, had been separately earmarked for the
temple. No patta or other revenue record standing in the name of the
temple or deity has been produced. The appellant / plaintiff, in his cross-
examination, has also admitted that, except Ex.A1, he has no
__________
Page 13 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
documentary evidence to establish the existence of the temple in the suit
'B' Schedule property.
17. The appellant / plaintiff has placed considerable reliance upon
Ex.A1, the Re-Survey Plan, to establish the existence of the temple.
However, a revenue survey plan, by itself, cannot confer title upon a
person or establish the legal dedication of a property for temple purposes.
Even assuming that a particular structure or place has been indicated in
the survey plan, the same cannot be treated as conclusive proof of the
antiquity of the temple, its ownership or the extent of land claimed by the
appellant / plaintiff. It is true that the respondent / defendant, in her
evidence, has referred to the practice followed by the ancestors of both
families of offering the first yield obtained from the trees to their deity at
a particular place in the property. However, such an admission would not,
by itself, establish that a permanent temple with idols and separate temple
properties had been in existence for more than 170 years. The
performance of religious worship at a particular place and the existence
of a permanent temple with a separately identifiable extent of land are
two different aspects which have to be established by acceptable
evidence.
__________
Page 14 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
18. The appellant / plaintiff has also relied upon the report of the
Advocate Commissioner, marked as Ex.C1, and the plans marked as
Exs.C2 and C3. On a perusal of the Commissioner's report, it is seen that
the Commissioner has noted the existence of the temple structure and
other constructions in the disputed property. However, the Commissioner
has also recorded that the age of the temple structure appeared to be
approximately one year at the time of inspection. It is settled law that
the report of an Advocate Commissioner is intended to assist the Court in
understanding the physical features and location of the property. The
Commissioner cannot decide questions of title, ownership or the
historical existence of a structure. The report and plan can be considered
along with the other evidence, but they cannot independently establish the
appellant / plaintff's claim that the temple had existed in the disputed
property for about 170 years.
19. In the present case, the documentary evidence produced by the
respondent / defendant, particularly Exs.B1 and B7, indicates that the
original extent of 42 cents was divided into two equal portions and
separately gifted to the fathers of the parties. The appellant / plaintiff has
not produced any acceptable documentary evidence to establish that an
extent of 8 ¼ cents was excluded from the said division and separately
__________
Page 15 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
dedicated for the temple. Further, the appellant / plaintiff has not
established that the temple was in existence in the disputed portion prior
to the execution of the gift deeds or that the property had been separately
dedicated for religious purposes. In the absence of such evidence, the
appellant / plaintiff cannot claim an independent right over the
respondent / defendant's portion merely on the ground that a place of
worship was allegedly used by the ancestors of both families.
20. It is also relevant to note that the respondent / defendant's
specific case is that the appellant / plaintiff had constructed the temple
and the compound wall during her absence and without her consent. The
Commissioner's report, indicating the recent nature of the construction,
lends support to the respondent / defendant's contention. The appellant /
plaintiff has not placed any convincing material to dislodge the said
finding. The appellant / plaintiff has further contended that, even
assuming that the respondent / defendant has a right over the disputed
property, she cannot take the law into her own hands and demolish the
temple. In this regard, it is to be noted that the relief of permanent
injunction is an equitable relief and the person seeking such relief must
establish a legally sustainable right and the necessary factual foundation
for granting the injunction.
__________
Page 16 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
21. In the present case, the appellant / plaintiff has failed to
establish that the temple existed in the disputed property as an
independent religious institution or that the particular extent claimed in
the 'B' Schedule property had been dedicated for temple purposes. The
mere fact that the appellant / plaintiff claims to be administering the
temple or conducting poojas cannot, by itself, confer a legal right over the
disputed property, particularly when the respondent / defendant has
established her claim based upon the registered gift deeds. The question
of whether the respondent / defendant is entitled to demolish any
structure or whether the appellant / plaintiff is entitled to protect any
independently established right is not required to be decided beyond the
scope of the present suit. On the evidence available, the appellant /
plaintiff has failed to establish the necessary legal right and possession to
obtain the permanent injunction sought for. Consequently, the claim for
damages of Rs.20,000/- also cannot be sustained, particularly in the
absence of acceptable evidence establishing that the respondent /
defendant had caused the alleged damage.
22. The appellant / plaintiff, having sought the relief of permanent
injunction, was required to establish his lawful possession and
__________
Page 17 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
entitlement to protect the disputed property against the alleged
interference. The Courts below have considered the relevant documentary
and oral evidence and arrived at a concurrent finding that the appellant /
plaintiff had failed to establish his case. This Court does not find any
perversity or material illegality in the appreciation of evidence by the
Courts below. The substantial questions of law framed in this Second
Appeal are answered against the appellant / plaintiff.
23. In the result, the Second Appeal is dismissed , confirming the
judgment and decree passed by the Courts below. There shall be no order
as to costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition, is closed.
13-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
To
1. The Subordinate Court, Padmanabhapuram.
2. The Additional District Munsif Court, Padmanabhapuram
3. The Section Officer,
VR Section,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court,
Madurai.
__________
Page 18 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
THIRUMAGAL CHANDRASEKAR, J.
T. RAJAPRABA
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
13-11-2026
__________
Page 19 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )
2026:MHC:4568
SA(MD) No. 176 of 2014
__________
Page 20 of 20
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:22:13 pm )