GANGULY EVERA DEVELOPERS LLP AND ANR vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.

Court
Calcutta High Court

Form No.J(2)

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :

The Hon’ble Justice Raja Basu Chowdhury

WPA 30761of 2026
Ganguly Evera Developers LLP & Anr.
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the petitioners : Mr. Saptansu Basu, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Supratim Dhar, Sr. Advocate
Mrs. Madhu Priya
Mr. Dhananjay Nayak

For the State : Mr. D. N. Ray, Ld. GP
Mr. Souvik Nandy, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Guddu Singh
Mr. Bikramjit Mondal

For the Municipality : Mr. Mir Anuruzzaman

For the added respondent: Mr. Srijib Chakraborty
Mr. Dipanjan Dutt
Mr. Aditya Mondal
Mr. Kamran Hussain

Heard on : 28.10.2026 & 17.11.2026

Judgment on : 17.11.2026

Raja Basu Chowdhury, J (Oral):
1. The instant writ petition has been filed, inter alia, challenging the
th
order dated 9 October, 2026, passed by the Executive Officer,
Rajpur-Sonarpur Municipality.

2
WPA 30761 of 2026
2. The genesis of the order lies in a communication made by the
private respondent to the Member of Legislative Assembly (MLA)
which was later forwarded to the municipality.
3. The records would reveal that the private respondent had lodged a
complaint regarding statutory, environmental and building bylaw
violations by the developer of “4 sight Florence phase III” in Garia
with the MLA (hereinafter, people’s representative). As per the said
complaint the private respondent had pointed out certain
deficiencies, inter alia, including road access, widening, gift deed
default, suppression of material facts, fraudulent procurement of
approvals, illegal water-body conversion, classification tampering,
land area mismatch, FAR irregularities, boundary declaration,
setback, splay discrepancies, environmental, forest, statutory
clearances by (PCB/DFO/AAI) and RERA and master plan
discrepancies. The private respondent in the aforesaid complaint
had also made the following prayer:-
“8. PRAYERS & ACTION REQUIRE
In light of the above severe violations of municipal bylaws, land
conversion laws, and urban planning norms, we earnestly
request your esteemed office to:
1. Take Immediate Penal Action: Initiate strict administrative
and penal action against the developer with immediate effect
regarding the illegal and unauthorized building height
extensions.

3
WPA 30761 of 2026
2. Conduct Physical & Revenue Inspection: Order a
comprehensive physical and revenue inspection regarding the
illegal conversion of land status, specifically concerning water
bodies like Dag No. 640.
3. Scrutinize Technical Metrics: Thoroughly verify FAR
calculations, boundary lines, setbacks, and access road gift
deeds before considering or granting any Occupancy
Certificate or Completion Certificate.
4. Issue Show-Cause Notice: Issue a formal Show-Cause
Notice to the developer demanding an explanation for material
misrepresentation, suppression of facts. and non-compliance
with municipal bylaws and RERA regulations.
5. Direct Demolition: Order the immediate stoppage and/or
demolition of all illegal, unauthorized, and non-compliant
structures raised in violation of sanctioned plans and
statutory provisions.
6. Pass Further Orders: Pass such other order or orders as
your authority may deem fit and proper in the interest of
justice, equity, and law”.
4. Records would reveal that the peoples representative did not act on
the basis of the aforesaid complaint for obvious reasons and did not
lodge any complaint. He had only forwarded the same to the
municipality. The municipality based on the aforesaid, had passed
the order impugned where under it recorded that the petitioners

4
WPA 30761 of 2026
had obtained permission/approval of the building plan by coercion
which seems to be of material fact. Accordingly, a stop work notice
was issued and the petitioners were directed not to initiate work
until further order. The petitioners were also directed to appear
before the Assistant Engineer, Rajpur-Sonarpur municipality on
any working day during office hours with all relevant documents in
original for verification of the same.
5. When the writ petition was moved the petitioners had sought for
leave to file supplementary affidavit. Today, at the time of hearing,
the supplementary affidavit has not been filed and Mr. Basu,
learned Senior Advocate has insisted for proceeding with the writ
petition without the supplementary affidavit and accordingly, the
writ petition is taken up for consideration. He has drawn attention
of this Court to Section 220 of the West Bengal Municipal Act, 1993
(hereinafter referred to as the “said Act”) and would submit that the
powers conferred on the Chairman to issue a stop work notice is
circumscribed under the aforesaid Section. According to him,
unless, the construction is either unauthorized or unlawful such
power cannot be exercised by the Chairman.
6. Mr. Charkaborty, learned advocate appears for the private
respondent. According to him the petitioners having made false
submission, the writ petition ought not to be entertained. He has
drawn attention of this Court to paragraphs 26 and 28 of the writ
petition and would submit that the writ petition was filed on the

5
WPA 30761 of 2026
premise that copy of the complaint was not served on the
petitioners, however, in the supplementary affidavit, a copy whereof
has been served on the private respondent, the petitioners have
acknowledged receipt of the complaint. It is also submitted that the
private respondent was interested in acquiring a flat and for
reasons whereof had approached the developer, however, upon
ascertaining the discrepancies as aforesaid the private respondent
had lodged a complaint with the people’s representative. In
response to a query from the Court Mr. Chakraborty has been
candid enough in submitting that apart from the complaint lodged
with the people’s representative no other complaint had been lodged
to any other statutory authority, far less, to the municipality.
7. Learned Government Pleader appears for the State. He submits that
on the basis of the complaint, the State proposes to make an
enquiry in the matter. He, however, is candid enough in submitting
that till this date no enquiry has been made. It is submitted that if
this Court grants leave to the State, the State shall proceed with the
enquiry.
8. The municipality is represented and is heard.
9. Having heard the learned advocates appearing for the respective
parties and having considered the materials on record, I find that it
is not in dispute that there is a sanctioned building plan issued in
respect of the development project. The municipality has permitted
the project land to be developed. It is not the case of the

6
WPA 30761 of 2026
municipality that there is any deviation in construction or in
execution of the project as per the sanctioned building plan. At least
nothing has been brought before this Court in that regard. The
municipality has, however, independent of any individual complaint
has acted on the basis of a complaint being forwarded by the
people’s representative though no formal complaint was lodged by
the people’s representative. Mr. Chakraborty has been candid
enough in submitting that it is not the private respondent’s case
that the petitioners had obtained the building plan on the basis of
coercion. I, however, find in the complaint lodged before the people’s
representative, the private respondent has used the term
suppression of material facts and procurement of fraudulent
approval, particulars of the nature of such fraudulent activities to
the extent indicated therein are extracted hereinbelow:-
“ 2. Suppression of material facts and fraudulent procurement
of approvals.
Issue: Dag Nos. 602 and 643 are partially under the
ownership/acquisition of third party.
In respect of RS Dag No. 602 approximately 2.63 decimals out
of a total of 35 decimals stand recorded in the name of other
owners.
In respect of RS Dag No. 643 approximately 8.26 decimals out
of a total of 16 decimals stand recorded in the name of other
owners.

7
WPA 30761 of 2026
Violation : Despite this vital encumbrance and division of title,
the developer deliberately suppressed and concealed these
material facts from both the Rajpur-Sonarpur Municipality
and WBRERA, fraudulently obtaining statutory approvals
and permissions to which they are not lawfully entitled” .
10. From the above, it is apparent no contention was raised by the
private respondent as regards the petitioners obtaining plan on the
basis of coercion. Going by the materials on record it would
transpire that it has been alleged that the permission/approval of
building plan was obtained by coercion. There is no supporting
documents or complaint made by any individual or by the people’s
representative in that regard. Ordinarily, the term coercion means
and includes committing, or threatening to commit, any act
forbidden by the Indian Penal Code or the unlawful detaining, or
threatening to detain, any property, to the prejudice of any person
whatever, with the intention of causing any person to enter to an
agreement. No particulars have been provided either in the
complaint or in the order passed by the Executive Officer as regards
manner in which the petitioners had coerced the municipality and
obtained approval of the sanctioned building plan. Independent of
the above, noting the manner in which the municipality has
proceeded to issue stop work notice without any independent
enquiry or representation being made by the private respondent
only upon a notice being forwarded by the people’s representative

8
WPA 30761 of 2026
leaves several questions unanswered. Though a statutory authority
is obliged to accept correspondences from a people’s representative
the authority is bound to apply its mind as regards such
correspondence before taking any decision. As noted above no
particulars of how the petitioners had coerced the respondents to
grant the permission/approval plan had been disclosed. The stop
work notice which is based on the ground of coercion in absence of
disclosure of particulars is an outcome of non-application of mind.
11. Be that as it may, in the peculiar facts, in my view the
municipality ought not to have directed stop work notice without
there being any prima facie basis for the same. Nothing has been
disclosed by the municipality to demonstrate that the petitioners
had obtained the approval by suppression. It also, as noted above,
does not appear to be an unlawful construction.
12. Although, learned Government Pleader would submit that they
are in the process of taking steps in the matter and would seek
leave of the Court to proceed, I am of the view in the given facts
when diverse allegations have been levelled it is only natural that
the complainant files appropriate complaint before the statutory
authority at the first instance. No such complaint has been lodged.
The complaint has only been forwarded by the people’s
representative to the municipality. No independent complaint has
been lodged based on the above complaint, by the people’s
representative. Since there is no complaint before the State, no

9
WPA 30761 of 2026
leave can be granted by this Court for the State to proceed. The
State shall, however, be at liberty and is always at liberty to
independently and suo motu enquire into the matter, however, the
same cannot be at the instance of the private respondent who has
only purported to write to the people’s representative instead of
making any formal complaint before any other authority.
13. The writ petition is accordingly allowed by setting aside the
th
impugned stop work notice dated 9 October, 2026.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
made available to the parties upon compliance of requisite
formalities.

(Raja Basu Chowdhury, J . )
sb
A.R. (Court)