Shekhar Sharma vs The Institute Of Chartered Accountant Of India & Anr.
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~150
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
th
% Date of Decision: September 28 , 2026
# CNR No. DLHC010466122026
+ W.P.(C) 14305/2026
SHEKHAR SHARMA .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Aayush Agarwala &
Mr. Gaurav Verma, Advs.
versus
THE INSTITUTE OF CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT OF
INDIA & ANR. .....Respondents
Through:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
AMIT MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1. The present petition is filed assailing communication dated
27.07.2026 issued by Respondent No.1 conveying the decision of its
Board of Discipline taken in its 391st Meeting held on 19.06.2026,
whereby the Board has declined to concur with the prima facie Opinion
dated 13.03.2018 of the Director (Discipline) holding Respondent No.2
guilty of 'Other Misconduct' under Section 22 read with Item (2) of Part
IV of the First Schedule to the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949, and
closed the Petitioner's complaint bearing Reference No. PR-38/2017-
DD/51/2017.
2. Briefly stated, the petitioner had filed a complaint against
Respondent No.2, a Chartered Accountant, alleging that Respondent
No.2 had facilitated unauthorised access to and alteration of the
petitioner’s Income Tax account. The Director (Discipline), upon
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
Signing Date:29.09.2026
20:19:43
W.P.(C) 14305/2026 Page 1 of 5
consideration of the complaint and the material on record, formed a
prima facie opinion dated 13.03.2018 holding Respondent No.2 guilty
of “Other Misconduct” under Section 22 read with Item (2) of Part IV
of the First Schedule to the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949. The
Board of Discipline (hereinafter ‘ Board ’), however, did not concur
with the said opinion and closed the complaint. The Petitioner thereafter
approached this Court on two occasions, in W.P.(C) 202/2018 and
W.P.(C) No.10170/2023 .
3. By order dated 24.04.2023 in W.P.(C) 202/2018 , a Co-ordinate
bench of this Court noted that the earlier decision of the Board did not
furnish any reasons for disagreeing with the view of the Director
(Discipline) and ordered Respondent No.1 to furnish the reasons for its
decision. Upon being unsatisfied with the reasons furnished the
petitioner challenged the decision again by W.P.(C) 10170/2023.
4. By judgment dated 18.03.2026 in W.P.(C) 10170/2023 , a Co-
ordinate bench of this Court set aside the earlier decision of the Board
and remanded the matter for fresh consideration. It was observed that
Respondent No.2 was unable to refute the finding that Respondent No.2
had accessed the Petitioner’s personal information without his consent.
It was further observed that the mere fact that the complaint related to
a family dispute could not be a ground to reject allegations concerning
violation of statutory norms.
5. Pursuant to the remand, the Board again declined to concur with
the prima facie opinion and closed the complaint by its decision taken
in the 391st Meeting held on 19.06.2026 and communicated the same
to the petitioner vide the impugned communication.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
Signing Date:29.09.2026
20:19:43
W.P.(C) 14305/2026 Page 2 of 5
6. Aggrieved thereby, the present petition has been filed.
7. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the Board
ought to have considered that Respondent No.2 admittedly permitted
the petitioner’s wife to access his laptop and furnished the OTP for the
petitioner’s income tax account in order to allow her to access and alter
his account. He submits that such conduct would undeniably fall within
the definition of “Other Misconduct” under Item (2) of Part IV of the
First Schedule to the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949.
8. He submits that “Other Misconduct” under Item (2) of Part IV of
the First Schedule to the Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 expressly
extends to conduct bringing disrepute to the profession whether or not
related to professional work and thus, absence of any fiduciary
relationship between the petitioner and Respondent No.2 would be
immaterial. He further submitted that the pendency of criminal
proceedings could not oust the independent disciplinary jurisdiction of
the Board.
9. Per Contra , the learned counsel for Respondent No.2
vehemently opposes the present petition. He submits that the present
complaint arises out of a matrimonial dispute between the petitioner and
Respondent No.2’s cousin sister. He submits that the petitioner holds a
personal grudge against Respondent No.2 and has, therefore, filed a
frivolous complaint against him.
10. At the outset, it is necessary to bear in mind the limited scope of
interference by this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution. The Court does not sit in appeal over the orders
passed by the authority and is concerned primarily with the legality of
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
Signing Date:29.09.2026
20:19:43
W.P.(C) 14305/2026 Page 3 of 5
the decision-making process. This Court cannot substitute its own view
for that of the statutory authority.
11. In the present case, the principal submission of learned counsel
for the petitioner is that Respondent No.2 admittedly permitted the
petitioner’s wife to use his laptop and furnished the OTP received on
his mobile in connection with the petitioner’s Income Tax account, and
that such conduct, by itself, constituted “Other Misconduct”.
12. The Board, upon consideration of the material before it, has taken
into account the circumstances in which the laptop came to be used and
has specifically noted that Respondent No.2 was unaware of the
matrimonial dispute between the petitioner and his wife at the relevant
time. The Board accordingly found that the material did not justify an
inference of mala fide intent or deliberate facilitation. The Board has
arrived upon the aforesaid findings after appreciating the evidence on
record, this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction cannot reappreciate
evidence merely because another view may be possible.
13. The Board also took into account that the parties had no
professional relationship and that the allegation of Respondent No.2
being the Petitioner’s tax consultant was denied by both parties. It was
further noted that the Director (Discipline) while giving its prima facie
opinion had proceeded on the basis that Respondent No.2 was the
Petitioner’s tax consultant, whereas such relationship was denied by
both the parties.
14. While the absence of a fiduciary relationship may not, by itself,
exclude the applicability of Item (2) of Part IV of the First Schedule,
once the Director (Discipline) has given its prima facie opinion of guilt
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
Signing Date:29.09.2026
20:19:43
W.P.(C) 14305/2026 Page 4 of 5
proceeding on the premise of a fiduciary relationship existing between
the parties, absence of the same assumes significance in establishing
that the Director (Discipline) erred in making the prima facie opinion
of guilt against Respondent No.2.
15. As regards the pending criminal proceedings, their pendency did
not, by itself, oust the Board’s disciplinary jurisdiction. However, the
Board has not merely exonerated Respondent No.2 because criminal
proceedings for the allegations of hacking were pending but has
specifically observed that the same was not supported by cogent
evidence so as to punish Respondent No.2 for misconduct.
16. In view of the above, this Court is of the opinion that the view
taken by decision of the Board is a plausible view based on the material
before it. Merely because another view may be possible is not a ground
for interference in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
17. Accordingly, no grounds have been made out in the present case,
so as to warrant exercise of extraordinary and discretionary jurisdiction
by this Court.
18. The present petition is, therefore, dismissed.
19. Pending applications (if any) also stand disposed of.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
SEPTEMBER 28, 2026
“SS”
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:SHIKHA
SEHGAL
Signing Date:29.09.2026
20:19:43
W.P.(C) 14305/2026 Page 5 of 5