Pandav Kumar vs The State of Bihar
- Court
- Patna High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.15066 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC010975022026
======================================================
1. Pandav Kumar S/o Bishnu Dev Ram, R/o Village and P.O.- Munger Ganj,
P.S.- Nagar, District - Begusarai, at present posted and working on the post
of Panchayat Teacher at Government Primary School Pathlatol, Block-
Shamho Akha Kurha, District -Begusarai.
2. Sadanand Sah, S/o Sita Ram Sah, R/o Village and P.O.- Pokhrail, P.S.-
Maheshkhunt, District - Khagaria, at present posted and working on the post
of Panchayat Teacher at Government School Pachraha, Block - Alouli,
District - Khagaria.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through the Additional Chief Secretary, Education
Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2. The Additional Chief Secretary, Education Department, Government of
Bihar, Patna.
3. The Director, Primary Education, Education Department, Government of
Bihar, Patna.
4. The Chairman, Bihar School Examination Board (Senior Secondary) Budh
Marg, Patna - 01.
5. The Bihar School Examination Board (Senior Secondary), through its
Secretary Budh Marg Patna - 01.
6. The Secretary, Bihar School Examination Board (Senior Secondary) through
its Secretary Budh Marg Patna - 01.
7. The Examination Controller, Bihar School Examination Board (Senior
Secondary) Budh Marg Patna - 01.
8. The Principal Sant Binobo Intermediate College, Bharat Khand, Khagaria,
P.O. -Bharatkhand Dyodhi, P.S.- Bharatkhand District Khagaria.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Mrityunjay Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Mukesh Kumar Singh, Advocate
Mr. Arinjay Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Shivam Kumar, Advocate
For the State : Mr. Prakash Chandra Agarwal, GA 5
Mr. Abhiyuday Anand, AC to GA 5
For the BSEB : Mr. Siddharth Prasad, Advocate
==================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RITESH KUMAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 29-09-2026
Patna High Court CWJC No.15066 of 2026 dt.29-09-2026
2/11
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners, the learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the State and learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the Bihar School Examination Board
(BSEB).
2. The present writ petition has been filed for the
following relief(s):-
"(i) For issuance of a writ in the
nature of Certiorary or any other appropriate
writ/order/direction to quash/set aside the
order contained in Letter No.
BSEB(SS)/COE/177/2018, dated 13.03.2018
passed and issued by the Secretary, Bihar
School Examination Board, Patna (Respondent
No.-06) whereby and whereunder the
petitioners have been declared failed in the
Intermediate Examination held by then Bihar
Intermediate Education Council, Patna in the
year 1994 for the Academic Session 1992-94
on the ground of delay and refuse to make
necessary correction in the Marksheet and
issue Marksheet and certificate afresh to the
petitioner in want of evidence.
(ii) Further, for issuance of a writ in
the nature of Mandamus directing the
respondents Bihar School Examination Board
to make necessary correction in the result of
Intermediate (Science) held by then Bihar
Intermediate Education Council, Patna in the
Patna High Court CWJC No.15066 of 2026 dt.29-09-2026
3/11
year 1994, for the Academic Session 1992-94
and maintain in electronic device and further
to issue Marksheet and original certificate
declaring them pass.
(iii) Further, for issuance of a writ in
the nature of Mandamus directing the
respondents to declare the petitioner as pass in
the Intermediate Science Examination held by
the erstwhile Bihar Intermediate Education
Council in the year 1994 for the Session 1992-
94.
(iv) Further, for any other
order/order(s) as your Lordships may find fit
and proper under given facts and
circumstances of the case."
3. The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that
after passing their matriculation examination in the year, 1992 and
1990 respectively the petitioners took their admission in
intermediate in Science subject in Sant Binova Inter College,
Bharatkhand, Khagaria in Academic Session 1992-94. The
petitioners after completing their course from the concerned
college filled the examination form from the college, to register
their names and to appear in the Examination. Admit cards were
issued to the petitioners for appearing in the examination in the
year, 1994. Both the petitioners, along with other candidates
appeared in the examination held in the month of April, 1994 and
Patna High Court CWJC No.15066 of 2026 dt.29-09-2026
4/11
finally result was published by the Bihar Intermediate Education
Council, wherein the petitioner No. 1 obtained 556 marks and the
petitioner No. 2 obtained 569 marks. Both were declared pass with
first division. The mark-sheet was provided to the petitioners
through their college. College Leaving Certificate was also issued.
Altogether, 389 students appeared in the year, 1994 from the
concerned college. In the year, 2006, the State Government framed
the Bihar Panchayat Elementary Teachers (Employment and
Service Condition) Rules, 2006. Applications were invited from
the candidates, who possessed requisite qualification of
intermediate, for the post of Panchayat Teacher. The petitioners
were appointed as Panchayat Teachers on 30.11.2006 and
19.04.2007 respectively and they joined on the post on 30.11.2006
and 27.04.2007 respectively. The petitioners participated in the
Teachers Efficiency Test (TET)-2010 and were declared qualified.
They also passed their in-service Teachers Training Course of
Diploma in Primary Education (D.P.E.) and have also
completed/passed six months Enrichment Programme from the
Indira Gandhi National Open University. The petitioners appeared
and requested the authorities of the Bihar Intermediate Education
Council/Bihar School Examination Board for issuance of original
certificate, however, the same was not provided. Thereafter, the
Patna High Court CWJC No.15066 of 2026 dt.29-09-2026
5/11
petitioners, along with some others preferred CWJC No. 19083 of
2016. The writ petition was disposed of with a direction to the
Secretary, Bihar School Examination Board to consider the
genuineness of those documents which were brought on record in
the said writ petition and it was further directed that if the Board is
satisfied that such mark-sheets were issued by the Board, the
Board shall issue to the petitioners, duplicate certificate/certificates
as the case may be, after fulfilling their requisite formalities. It was
further directed that the Secretary of the Board will ensure that an
enquiry is made and decision is taken on the grievance of the
petitioners within a period of two months.
4. The learned counsel for the petitioners next submits
that the petitioners submitted their representation before the Board
and when the order of the Hon'ble Single Judge dated 23.01.2018
passed in CWJC No. 19083 of 2018 was being not complied with,
the petitioners preferred MJC No. 2130 of 2021. In the said
contempt petition a show cause was filed on behalf of Bihar
School Examination Board wherein the order dated 13.03.2018
was brought on record, by which the claim of the petitioners was
rejected. The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that for
the first time the petitioners came to know about the order dated
13.03.2018, when the Board filed show cause in the contempt
Patna High Court CWJC No.15066 of 2026 dt.29-09-2026
6/11
petition, therefore, the contempt petition was disposed of vide
order 05.05.2025 with a liberty to the petitioners to assail the order
dated 13.03.2018. He submits that in view of the liberty given by
this Hon'ble Court in MJC No. 2130 of 2021, the present writ
petition has been filed. The learned counsel for the petitioners
submits that the respondents have rejected the claim of the
petitioners and have not recorded any finding that the petitioners
did not appear in the Examination in the Session 1992-94 from the
concerned College and there is no finding by the respondents to
the extent that the admit cards and the mark-sheets of the
petitioners are forged documents. He submits that unless the mark-
sheets are declared as forged, the respondents-Bihar School
Examination Board cannot reject the claim of the petitioners for
issuance of the original passing certificates. Learned counsel for
the petitioners next submits that the order dated 13.03.2018 is fit to
be set aside on the ground that the entire communication was made
between the Examination Board and the concerned college and if
the details of the petitioners were not forwarded by the concerned
college, it was incumbent upon the Bihar School Examination
Board to have communicated at that point of time to resolve the
issue, therefore, the Board cannot escape merely by saying that
after lapse of 23 years, it is not possible to prepare the result as the
Patna High Court CWJC No.15066 of 2026 dt.29-09-2026
7/11
same would cause grave and irreparable prejudice and loss to the
petitioners, who are employed as teachers and are at a very
advanced stage of their lives. The learned counsel for the
petitioners further submits that the reasons assigned by the Board
are not correct and they have taken an extreme hard step by
declaring the petitioners absent in the examination. The learned
counsel for the petitioners next submits that it was the duty of the
Board to have resolved the dispute by issuing average marks to the
petitioners and to have declared them successful, which would
have served the purpose of the petitioners and the interest of
justice. He submits that the Board cannot take unilateral decision
without affording any opportunity to the petitioners, before
declaring them fail in the examination and therefore, the order
passed by the Board on 13.03.2018 is violative of the principle of
natural justice.
5. Per contra , the learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the State submits that it is the Board who is the contesting
respondents and therefore, he cannot make any comment on the
orders pass by the Board, since the same is concerned with the
Bihar School Examination Board. The learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the Board submits that the petitioners, after almost 22
years came before this Hon'ble Court earlier by filing a writ
Patna High Court CWJC No.15066 of 2026 dt.29-09-2026
8/11
petition. An Hon'ble Singh Judge while recording about the delay
and its non explanation by the petitioners, directed the Board to
enquire into the matter and to take necessary decision. In
compliance thereof the Secretary of the Board after a detail
enquiry rejected the claim of the petitioners. He submits that there
is no infirmity in the orders passed by the Secretary of the Board.
6. Having considered the rival submissions and after
going through the records, it appears that initially the petitioners
along with others preferred CWJC No. 19083 of 2016 before this
Hon'ble Court whereby they claimed that they have passed the
Intermediate of Science Examination held by the erstwhile Bihar
Intermediate Education Council in the year, 1994 for the session
1992-94 and their grievance was that despite lapse of more than 23
years, their original certificates of having passed the said
examination have not been dispatched to the School, where the
petitioners had studied the said course. It was further contended in
the said writ petition that the mark-sheets were issued and the
copies of the said mark-sheets were brought on record in the said
writ petition. The Hon'ble Single Judge in paragraph no. 3 of the
order dated 23.01.2018 observed that after 22 years of the
petitioners having passed the said examination, it is difficult for
this Court to issue such direction in the absence of any plausible
Patna High Court CWJC No.15066 of 2026 dt.29-09-2026
9/11
explanation for delay in approaching this Court, however, disposed
of the writ petition with a direction to the Secretary, Bihar School
Examination Board to consider the genuineness of those
documents which were brought on record in the said writ petition
and it was further directed that if the Board is satisfied that such
mark-sheets were issued by the Board, the Board shall issue to the
petitioners, duplicate certificate/certificates as the case may be,
after fulfilling their requisite formalities. It was further directed
that the Secretary of the Board will ensure that an enquiry is made
and decision is taken on the grievance of the petitioners within a
period of two months. It appears that, in the meantime, on the
directions given by this Hon'ble Court in CWJC No. 19083 of
2016, the Secretary of the Board after considering the entire aspect
and after recording the details with regard to the
documents/Tabular Register, which was not available in the Board
and which was also not provided by the college and after
verification from the Records Room of the Board, passed a
reasoned order contained in Letter No.
BSCB(SS)/COE/177/A/2018 dated 13.03.2018 whereby it was
recorded that after lapse of 23 years and on the basis of enquiry it
is not possible to declare the result of the petitioners in absence of
any documents to suggest that the petitioners were declared
Patna High Court CWJC No.15066 of 2026 dt.29-09-2026
10/11
successful and accordingly, they were declared to have failed. The
petitioners did not assail the said order and after three years of
passing of the said order preferred contempt petition bearing MJC
No. 2130 of 2021. In the contempt petition, a show cause was filed
on behalf of the Bihar School Examination Board wherein the
order passed by the Secretary was brought on record. The
contempt petition was disposed of with a liberty to the petitioners
to assail the order dated 13.03.2018 passed by the Secretary, Bihar
School Examination Board. Again, the petitioners slept over their
right for more than one year and now have filed the present writ
petition.
7. In the considered opinion of this Court, after almost
lapse of thirty years the present writ petition has been filed. At this
stage, it would not be possible to direct the authorities of the Board
to again make an enquiry and to come to the conclusion that
whether the petitioners had passed or not. Since the said enquiry
has already been done by the Board in view of the direction given
by this Hon'ble Court vide order dated 23.01.2018 passed in
CWJC No. 19083 of 2016 whereby the Hon'ble Single Judge also
recorded the delay and no explanation for approaching this
Hon'ble Court with delay, however, taking a sympathetic view a
direction was issued to the Board to take a decision. In compliance
Patna High Court CWJC No.15066 of 2026 dt.29-09-2026
11/11
thereof a decision has already been taken after recording the
reasons for non publication of result and for declaring the
petitioners as fail, therefore, by differing with the said finding this
Court cannot direct the Board again to make enquiry again and to
declare the petitioners passed, that too after thirty years.
8. Considering the above, this Court finds no merit in
the present writ petition and accordingly, the same is dismissed.
(Ritesh Kumar, J)
Vikash/-
AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE N/A
Uploading Date
Transmission Date