M/S THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED vs N BABU
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 6292 OF 2013 (MV-I)
C/W
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 4392 OF 2012 (MV-I)
IN MFA No. 6292/2013
BETWEEN:
SRI N. BABU
S/O N. NARAYANAPPA
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS
R/AT VEERANJANEYA NAGAR,
KOLAR - 563 101.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI VENKATA REDDY C.M, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. SRI B. RAJENDRA
S/O BODEPPA
R/AT NO. 38, C/O CODANDA
B BLOCK, B SANDKEERNA
KSRTC QTRS., KORAMANGALA
BANGALORE - 560 034.
2. THE MANAGER
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
YETHIRAJA MUTT BUILDING,
NO.199, 2ND MAIN ROAD
SAMPIGE ROAD, MALLESHWARAM
BANGALORE - 03.
…RESPONDENTS
Digitally signed
by ANUSHA V
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
(BY SRI B.S. UMESH, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
VIDE ORDER DATED 12.12.2017, NOTICE TO R1 - B.G.
RAJENDRA - HELD SUFFICIENT & SERVED)
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 21.09.2011 PASSED IN MVC
NO. 31/2008 ON THE FILE OF THE PRINCIPAL, CIVIL JUDGE &
MACT, KOLAR, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR
COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF
COMPENSATION.
IN MFA NO. 4392/2012
BETWEEN:
M/S. THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED,
YEHTIRAJ MUTT BUILDING, # 199,
2ND MAIN ROAD, SAMPINGE ROAD,
MALLEHWARAM, BANGALORE - 560 003
THROUGH ITS REGIONAL OFFICE,
LEO SHOPPING COMPLEX, NO. 44/45,
RESIDENCY ROAD, BANGALORE - 1,
REPRESENTED BY ITS REGIONAL MANAGER.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI B.S. UMESH, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. N. BABU
S/O LATE NARAYANAPPA
AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS,
RESIDENT OF VEERANJANEYA NAGAR, KOLAR.
2.
R. RAJENDRA
S/O BODEPPA
AGED MAJOR,
R/O NO. 38, C/O CODANDA,
B BLOCK, B SANKEERNA KSRP QTRS.,
KORAMANGALA, BANGALORE.
...RESPONDENTS
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
(BY SRI C.M. VENKATA REDDY, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
VIDE ORDER DATED 25.08.2016, NOTICE TO R2 -
R. RAJENDRA - HELD SUFFICIENT)
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST
THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 21.09.2011 PASSED
IN MVC NO.31/2008 ON THE FILE OF THE PRINCIPAL
CIVIL JUDGE, MACT, KOLAR, AWARDING A COMPENSATION
OF Rs.80,000/- WITH INTEREST @ 6% P.A. FROM THE
DATE OF PETITION TILL REALIZATION.
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI
ORAL JUDGMENT
Challenging judgment and award dated 21.09.2011
passed by Prl. Civil Judge & M.A.C.T., Kolar ( Tribunal ), in MVC
no.31/2008, these appeals are filed.
2. While M.F.A.no.4392/2012 is filed by insurer,
M.F.A.no.6292/2013 is filed by claimant.
3. Brief facts leading to these appeals as per claimant
were that at 10:00 p.m., on 02.11.2007 when claimant was
standing with his friends by side of Tekal road, rider of
motorcycle no.KA-01/EE-5912 drove it in rash and negligent
manner and dashed against claimant. In accident, claimant
sustained grievous injuries and despite treatment at hospital,
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
he sustained disability and loss of earning capacity. Claiming
compensation for same, he filed claim petition under Section
166 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 ( MV Act ) against owner and
rider of motorcycle.
4. On contest, wherein, claim petition was opposed on
all grounds. Tribunal framed following issues:
i. Whether the petitioner proves that he sustained
injuries in the road traffic accident occurred on
02.11.2007 at about 10.00 p.m. near Bapuji
School, Tekal Main Road, Kolar, due to rash and
negligent riding of Pulsar motorcycle bearing
reg.no.KA-01/EE-5912 by its rider?
ii. Whether petitioner is entitled for compensation? If
so, from whom and how much?
iii. What relief?
5. Claimant along with another deposed as PWs.1 and
2 and got marked Exs.P1 to P13. Respondent examined its
official as RW.1 and got marked Exs.R1 and R2. On
consideration, tribunal held issue no.1 in affirmative, issue no.2
partly in affirmative and issue no.3 by assessing total
compensation of Rs.80,000/- and held insurer liable to pay
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
same. Aggrieved thereby, insurer was challenging award on
false implication of insured vehicle for purposes of claim and
while claimant was seeking for enhancement of compensation.
6. Sri Venkata Reddy, learned counsel for claimant
submitted that as on date of accident, claimant was 22 years of
age working as 'mason' and earning Rs.15,000/- per month. In
accident, claimant sustained two grievous injuries including
fracture of right occipital area with EDH and SAH; and mild
cerebral edema, for which claimant took 26 days treatment as
inpatient and produced medical bills for more than
Rs.1,74,000/-. However, tribunal awarded Rs.10,000/- towards
loss of earnings, Rs.15,000/- each towards injuries and
Rs.20,000/- only towards medical expenses, Rs.10,000/-
towards loss of amenities and Rs.10,000/- only towards pain
and suffering, which was grossly inadequate.
7. It was submitted that claimant was entitled for
enhancement of compensation on each of these sets, apart
from loss of income during laid-up period, which was not
awarded. On said ground, sought for allowing appeal.
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
8. On other hand, opposing claimant's appeal, Sri
B.C.Umesh, learned counsel for insurer submitted that as per
claimant, accident occurred at 10:00 p.m. on 02.11.2007 and
immediately after accident, he was taken to SNR Hospital, Kolar
and after first aid referred for higher treatment at Abhaya
Hospital, Bengaluru. It was submitted that patient admission
record of SNR Hospital, Kolar produced as Ex.R1 would reveal
history of injuries as ' self fall' and said record was signed by
Nagaraj K., examined as PW.2, who instead of explanation
about entry in record, merely denied knowledge of contents.
But discrepancy when considered in light of fact that
complaint lodged by claimant's mother was after 21 days of
accident would lend credence to insurer's contention that
insured vehicle was falsely implicated for purposes of claim. It
was further submitted that claimant admitted that owner of
motorcycle was his friend. Combined effect of above would be
that a false claim petition was sought to be foisted against
insurer. In support of his submission, learned counsel relied
upon following decisions and sought for allowing appeal and for
dismissal of claim petition:
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
i. Smt. Arathy & Another v. S.M.Umesha and
Another in M.F.A. no.7025/2011
(D.D.09.11.2015);
ii. Veerappa & Another v. Siddappa &
Another , reported in CDJ 2010 Kar HC 094;
iii. New India Assurance Co.Ltd., v. Jegadeesh
Reddy & Another in M.F.A.no.962/2007
(D.D.12.03.2009); and
iv. Manju v. R.R.Ravi & Another in
M.F.A.no.3651/2010 c/w. M.F.A.no.8416/2010
(D.D.16.09.2020)
9. In reply, learned counsel for claimant sought to
oppose insurer's appeal by contending that hospital admission
records would show that claimant was unconscious for upto 10
days after accident and besides, PW.2 had stated that he was
unaware about contents of Ex.R1. In view of fact that claimant
had sustained two grievous injuries to his head, there would be
no justification in drawing adverse inference. It was submitted
that tribunal had considered matter in proper perspective and
passed award, and therefore, sought for dismissal of insurer's
appeal.
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
10. Heard learned counsel and perused impugned
judgment and award and material on record.
11. Since both insurer as well as claimants are in
appeal, points that would arise for consideration are :
i. Whether tribunal erred in not noticing false
case being foisted against insurer?
ii. Whether assessment of compensation by
tribunal calls for modification?
Pont no.i:
12. To establish actionable negligence against
owner/insurer, claimant relied upon FIR, complaint, spot
mahazar, Motor Vehicle's report, certified copy of ordersheet in
C.C.no.77/2008 and chargesheet marked as Exs.P1 to P6.
13. Perusal of Exs.P1 and P3 would indicate that FIR
was registered on basis of complaint given by mother of
claimant. There is statement that due to claimant being under
treatment there was delay in filing complaint. But explanation
offered does not appear to be trustworthy. I say so for reason
that at time of accident even as per claimant he was
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
accompanied with friends. Ex.R1 would in fact indicate that
PW.2 had accompanied claimant to SNR Hospital. First record
about accident is entries in SNR Hospital. Ex.R1 would show
history of injuries as due to self-fall with entry being endorsed
by thumb impression as well as signature of PW.2. Despite
same, PW.2 in his cross-examination feigned ignorance of
contents of Ex.R1. There is no explanation as to why complaint
was not filed by any of claimant's friends. That apart, Ex.P7 -
Wound Certificate issued by Abhaya Hospital, Bangalore, on
other hand would mention history of injuries as due to RTA.
Strangely, admission of claimant is not recorded as a Medico
Legal Case (MLC), there is no explanation about same. Even
failure to produce any record from NIMHANS Hospital would
also attract suspicion. On top of above, it is seen that claimant
did not examine any doctor in support of his claim. This would
tilt issue in favour of insurer in light of ratio laid down in
decisions relied by insurer. Hence, point no.i is answered in
favour of insurer.
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
Pont no.ii:
14. In view of finding on point no.1, no finding would be
necessary on point no.2. Further, claimant failed to examine
any doctor. Claim for compensation is by relying on medical
records. Ex.P7 and other medical records would indicate that
claimant sustained linear fracture of right occipital area. In case
of any consequential effect on normal functioning of claimant, a
CT Scan report or deposition of Neurologist/Psychologist would
be required. Even in absence of failure to examine any doctor,
Rs.
Tribunal has granted compensation of 10,000/- towards loss
of earning; Rs.15,000/- towards each of injuries (without
specifying whether it is towards loss of earning or pain and
suffering); Rs.20,000/- towards medical expenses; Rs.10,000/-
towards loss of amenities and Rs.10,000/- towards pain and
suffering. When effect of injuries on earning capacity is not
established, award of Rs.40,000/- towards injuries and loss of
earning capacity would not be justified. Likewise in case of loss
of amenities. However, claimant would be justified in
contending that compensation of Rs.10,000/- awarded towards
pain and suffering in view of skull fracture would be
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62354
MFA No. 6292 of 2013
C/W MFA No. 4392 of 2012
CNR: KAHC010310352013
inadequate. But as it is seen, when compensation awarded
under various heads is unjustified, same would off-set scope for
enhancement. In any case, point no.2 would have to follow
finding on point no.1. Consequently, following:
ORDER
i) MFA no.6292/2013 filed by claimant is
dismissed .
ii) MFA no.4392/2012 filed by insurer is
allowed in part , j udgment and award
dated 21.09.2011 passed by Tribunal in
MVC no.31/2008 is set-aside .
iii) Claim petition filed by claimant is
dismissed .
iv) Amount in deposit in Insurer's appeal is
ordered to be refunded to insurer.
Sd/-
(RAVI V HOSMANI)
JUDGE
HNM,GRD
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 15