SHANTAVVA BALANNAVAR vs GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD


TH
DATED THIS THE 6 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF

WRIT PETITION NO.107383 OF 2024 (T-IT)

BETWEEN:

SHANTAVVA BALANNAVAR,
AGE. 65 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. NIRALKERI, TQ. BADAMI,
DIST. BAGALKOT.
PAN NO. GJFPB4441A

…PETITIONER

(BY SRI. H.R. KAMBIYAVAR, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF FINANCE,
INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT,
THE PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF
INCOME TAX, NAVANAGAR, P.B. ROAD,
HUBBALLI-580025.

2. THE INCOME TAX OFFICER,
WARD-I, NAVANAGAR,
BAGALKOT-587101.











Digitally signed by
THEJAS KUMAR N
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench

3. THE PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX,
NAVANAGAR, HUBBALLI-580025.
…RESPONDENTS

(BY SMT. ROOPA ANVEKAR, ADVOCATE A/W
SRI. ARAVIND V.CHAVAN, ADVOCATE)

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024


THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO I.
ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI OR A DIRECTION IN THE
NATURE OF A WRIT OF CERTIORARI QUASHING THE
IMPUGNED ORDER BEARING NO.ITBA/COM/F/17/2024-
25/1067796072(1), DATED 21.08.2024, VIDE ANNEXURE-D,
PASSED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.3, TO THIS WRIT PETITION.
II. ISSUE A WRIT OF MANDAMUS OR A WRIT IN THE NATURE
OF MANDAMUS DIRECTING THE RESPONDENT NO.3 HEREIN TO
CONSIDER THE REPRESENTATION FILED BY THE PETITIONER,
DATED 24.12.2023, VIDE “ANNEXURE-B” TO THIS WRIT
PETITION, AND TO ALLOW THE CLAIM OF REFUND MADE BY
THE PETITIONER; III. THIS HON’BLE HIGH COURT MAY BE
PLEASED TO ISSUE SUCH OTHER WRIT OR WRITS OR
DIRECTIONS IN THE NATURE OF A WRIT AS THIS HON’BLE
HIGH COURT MAY DEEM IT FIT TO GRANT IN THE FACTS AND
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE PETITIONER’S CASE.

THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
IN 'B' GROUP, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS
UNDER:


CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024


ORAL ORDER
This Writ Petition is filed by the petitioner with the
following reliefs:
i. Issue a Writ of Certiorari or a direction in the
nature of a Writ of Certiorari quashing the
impugned order bearing
No.ITBA/COM/F/17/2024-25/1067796072(1),
dated 21.08.2024, vide Annexure-“D” , passed
by the respondent No.3, to this writ petition.
ii. Issue a Writ of Mandamus or a Writ in the nature
of Mandamus directing the respondent No.3
herein to consider the representation filed by the
petitioner, dated 24.12.2023, vide “ ANNEXURE-
B” to this Writ Petition, and to allow the claim of
refund made by the petitioner;
iii. This Hon’ble High Court may be pleased to issue
such other writ or writs or directions in the nature
of a writ as this Hon’ble High Court may deem it
fit to grant in the facts and circumstances of the
petitioner’s case.

2. Learned counsel Sri. H.R. Kambiyavar submits
that he is not pressing the second relief sought in the Writ
Petition, to the extent of consideration of his
representation dated 24.12.2023, vide Annexure-B,
wherein he has sought several requests. His submission is
taken on record.

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024



3. He further submits that if the benefits granted
under the order dated 04.11.2025 in W.P.No.105667/2024
and connected matters, is extended to him, the petitioner
would be satisfied.

4. Learned counsel appearing for the Revenue
submits that the petitioner may be permitted to file
revised returns in terms of the order passed by this order.
The same will be considered in accordance with law,
keeping all contentions open to both the parties.

5. Both the submissions are taken on record.

6. The case of the petitioner is that his lands were
acquired and compensation has been paid after deducting
TDS. Though they have filed ITR for the year 2022-23 for
grant of refund, the same has not been considered and
order at Annexure-B came to be passed rejecting their
application, vide order dated 21.08.2024.

7. Learned counsel Sri. H.R.Kambiyavar submits
that, in an identical matter, this Court in

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024


W.P.No.105667/2024 and connected matters, stated
supra, allowed the Writ Petition, quashed the impugned
order and permitted the assesses therein to file the
returns in a time-bound manner and the authorities
concerned are directed to consider the same on merits,
keeping all the contentions open for consideration. The
order passed by Coordinate Bench of this Court reads as
under:
”Heard Sri.H.R.Kambiyavar, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioners, Sri.M.Thirumalesh, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents and have perused
the material on record.
2. Petitioners-the Assessees are before this
Court in the subject petitions calling in question the order
dated 29.07.2024 passed by respondent No.3-Principal
Commissioner of Income Tax and have sought a
consequential direction by issuance of a writ in the nature
of mandamus to consider the representation and allow
the claim for refund. For the sake of convenience, facts
obtaining in W.P.No.105667/2024 would be narrated.
3. The petitioner is an agriculturist. Government
of Karnataka is said to have acquired lands for the
purpose of mining dolomite and limestone. The Karnataka

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024


State Mineral Corporation was authorized to acquire the
said lands from the petitioners-the agriculturists for the
said project. Accordingly, huge extent of land was
acquired between 2001-2002. As a consequence whereof,
the petitioners lost their lands and were awarded
compensation in terms of the Land Acquisition Act.
Compensation was paid to these petitioners for the
Assessment Years 2022-23 for acquisition of the said
lands. Since there was delay in disbursement of
compensation, interest was also paid to these petitioners.
While filing returns, the amount that was received as
compensation along with interest was disclosed in the
income tax returns but the compensation that is received
was exempt from tax was ignored by the petitioners-the
agriculturists and included the amount of compensation
and the interest while filing the returns for the
Assessment Year 2022-23. The petitioners realizing that
they are entitled to exemption from tax as obtaining
under Section 10(37) of the Income Tax Act, 1961,
submitted a representation to respondent No.3. The
respondent No.3 has rejected the representations on the
ground that the return was filed with delay. Therefore,
the petitioners are before this Court.
4. Learned counsel Sri.H.R.Kambiyavar
appearing for the petitioners would vehemently contend
that the petitioners are entitled to refund of the TDS
amount as the same is a product of compensation that
was granted to the land loser in terms of law. The time
prescribed for filing the return of income under Section

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024


139 of the Act should not be imposed upon these
petitioners who at all times were entitled to the refund of
a tax that was paid which was exempt from income tax.
5. Per contra, learned counsel
Sri.M.Thirumalesh representing the respondents would
submit that the tax deduction at source should be claimed
within the time stipulated and therefore, there is no
warrant of interference in the case at hand. He would
however leave a decision to the hands of this Court. The
only issue now that falls for consideration is whether
respondent No.3 should be directed to consider the
representation by the assessee being permitted to file his
return of income. To consider the said issue, it becomes
apposite to refer to a judgment of this Court reported in
SRI.A.BALAKRISHNAN vs. THE GENERAL MANAGER,
1
HINDUSTAN MACHINE TOOLS LTD. AND ANOTHER ,
wherein the Coordinate Bench has held as follows:
“16. The filing of the returns under the Income-tax Act
1961, is now governed by the provisions of section 139
of the said Act. A perusal of the provisions of section
139 does not indicate that the authorities are barred
from processing a return filed under the Act just
because it is not filed within the time stipulated either
under section 139(1) or 139(4) of the Act.
17. While it may not be open to the Income-tax
Department to bring to tax any income beyond the
period permitted in terms of section 147 of the Act if
within that time either a return is filed whether within
the time stipulated under section 139(1) or 139(4) or
otherwise, it can be looked into and there is no
embargo as such.

1
2007 SCC OnLine Kar 43,

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024


18. In the present case, the petitioner having filed the
return though beyond the time permitted, it is not as
though the return is one which is per se prohibited to
be processed by the Income-tax authorities under the
statutory provisions. It is for this reason, with great
respect, I am not inclined to follow the decision
rendered by the Calcutta High Court in Minabati's case
[1971] 79 ITR 278.
27. In the present case, it is obvious that respondent
No.2 is not inclined to process the return as the
petitioner may become entitled for refund if the return
is processed and orders passed thereon. If it were to be
a case where the petitioner was to pay some tax which
he had not paid earlier, perhaps the respondents would
have been more than willing to even issue a notice
under section 147 of the Act and call upon the assessee
to file a return or a revised return as the case may be
and proceed to take further action under the Act. The
test is if a return pursuant to the notice under section
147 of the Act could be processed, there is no reason
as to why return filed otherwise cannot be processed.
The defence put up by the respondents for not
processing the return filed by the assessee in Form No.
2D (copy annexure D) is not supported by any
provision of the statute and can only amount to inaction
on the part of the respondents.
28. The time stipulation prescribed for filing a return of
income in terms of section 139 of the Act is operative
on a person who is compelled to file a return in terms
of section 139(1) of the Act. It is a person who has
income over and above the exempted limit and whose
income is taxable under the Act, who is required to file
the return and while so, is bound to follow the period.
The extended periods in terms of several sub-sections
are also applicable to such persons.
29. Likewise, the notice in terms of section 147 and the
time stipulation for issue of notice, etc., are also in
respect of a person who has taxable income and whose
taxable income has either not been offered to
assessment at all or who has not declared full
particulars of his income. For a person like the
petitioner, if his taxable income is nil, in the sense that
he has no obligation to file a return, the time
stipulations also equally cannot apply. Therefore, to say
that the Income-tax authorities are disabled from
scrutinising the return filed by the petitioner, in view of

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024


the time stipulation in terms of section 153 for
processing such return may not be correctly apply at
all. On the other hand, the employer having deducted
certain amount from the petitioner as deduction at
source on the payment of salary/retiral benefits and
having remitted it to the account of the Income-tax
Department and this deduction being in terms of the
provisions of the Act and if the assessee is not
otherwise enabled to claim refund of this amount under
any other statutory provisions and if he is not actually
liable to pay the kind of income- tax deducted at source
nor learned counsel for the respondent having pointed
out to any enabling statutory provision, the only other
way the petitioner can seek for refund of the amount is
by filing a return of his income and as a result of the
assessment if it is found the tax liability of the
petitioner is nil, the Assessing Officer may take note of
the amount already deducted from out of the amount
paid to the petitioner by his employer and remitted to
the Income tax Department and direct refund of that
amount to the assessee as part of the assessment
order. For not performing this exercise, the
respondents cannot bind the time stipulation indicated
in section 139 of the Act as a defence.
30. For the very reason, reference to the provisions of
section 192(1B) of the Act and on which reliance is
placed by learned counsel for the respondents is also
not tenable, as it is only such assessee who is seeking
for an extension of the time stipulation or a
condonation of delay in compliance, who may invoke
the provisions section 119(2)(a) of the Act. If no time
stipulation was in the first instance applicable to the
return that is filed by the petitioner, the provisions of
section 119(2)(b) are also not needed at all.
31. Viewed from another angle also, the respondents
cannot decline to process the return as the exemption
of payment as terminal benefit and exceeding a sum of
Rs. 5.00 lakhs in terms of section 10(10C) of the Act is
also one on a claim by the assessee as an amount
received which qualifies for this exemption. This again
can be done only in a return filed by the assessee and
not elsewhere. It may be noticed that if the assessee is
not entitled for this benefit of section 10(10C) then the
income becomes taxable and it can be brought to tax
by the Assessing Officer by invoking the provisions of
section 147 of the Act. At least for determination of this
position, it will be necessary for the Assessing Officer to

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024


process the return and finalise the same and if need be
by invoking the provisions of section 147 also. Even
without looking into the return, it will not be possible
for the Assessing Officer to conclude that as there is no
taxable income, no need to process the return, etc.
Therefore, in either view of the matter, it will be
necessary for the Assessing Officer to process the
return and to pass orders in accordance with the
provisions of the Act and not to justify the inaction.
32. It is the duty of the functionaries under the
Income-tax Act to implement the provisions of the Act
in accordance with law. A return filed is bound to be
processed by the Income-tax authorities for which
purpose they are meant unless there is an embargo
placed. Learned counsel for respondent No. 2 has not
been able to point out a specific statutory provision
which places an embargo and on the other hand is only
pointing out to other possibilities of invoking relaxation
etc., which by itself does not place an embargo to
process the return.
33. It is rather unfortunate that the Income-tax
Department has taken such an adamant and stubborn
stand only to deny a possible refund to the petitioner.
An amount which would have been otherwise due to
the petitioner if it is retained by the Income-tax
Department without any justification, then inaction
cannot be put up as a defence for retention of an
amount. I say this because the amount which can be
realised even by way of Income-tax from any assessee
can only be in accordance with the statutory provisions,
as is mandated under article 265 of the Constitution of
India.
34. In terms of the law laid down by this court in the
case of CIT v. P. Surendra Prabhu [2005] 279 ITR 402 ;
[2005] 59 KLT 609 on which reliance is placed by
learned counsel for the petitioner it does point out that
in respect of any payment received by a person seeking
voluntary retirement the first five lakhs rupees is
exempt under section 10(10C) of the Act and in respect
of balance of the amount, the tax deducted is not
justified as the balance amount is one which entitles for
exemption within the permissible limit.
35. It is not necessary for this court to go into these
details. If such is perhaps the factual position, retention

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024


of the amount can be obviously in violation of law and
as one without proper authority.
36. Though a writ of mandamus could have been issued
even for refunding of the amount, as this aspect of the
matter has not been examined by the authorities, it is
but proper to issue a mandamus directing the second
respondent to ensure that the return filed by the
assessee is duly processed in accordance with law and
appropriate orders are passed on the same within three
months from today.
37. The petitioner having been put to the ordeal of not
processing his return, declining an amount which he
would have earned by his toil, the respondents are
bound to compensate and I am of the view it calls for
commensurate cost to be paid to the petitioner. Cost is
also increased to make the respondents realise the
effect of it, as this court cannot appreciate an inaction
on the part of a public authority being put forth as a
defence for not performing the duty and that in turn
resulting in harassment and hardship to a hapless
citizen like the petitioner, who is compelled to approach
this court for relief.”
The said judgment was tossed before the Division Bench
and the Division Bench rejects the appeal against which a
Special Leave Petition is preferred and Special Leave
Petition also comes to be rejected. In the light of the law
laid down by the Coordinate Bench, these petitions
deserve to succeed albeit in part.
6. For the aforesaid reasons, the following:
i. All these petitions are allowed .
ii. The impugned order vide Annexure–D stands
quashed.
iii. The order passed by the Principal Commissioner of
Income Tax-Respondent No.3, is hereby quashed.
iv. The assessees are permitted to file their return of
income, which shall be assessed in accordance

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024


with law, without reference to limitation, and
necessary orders shall be passed thereon in
accordance with law.
v. The petitioners shall file their return of income
within eight (8) weeks from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order.
vi. In the event, the return of income is filed within the
said period of eight (8) weeks, the same shall be
considered on its merits.

vii. All contentions urged before this Court are left
open, and the petitioners are at liberty to urge
them before the appropriate forum.”

8. Learned counsel for the Revenue submits that,
since fresh returns required to be filed are time barred, the
assessee shall file an application seeking condonation of delay
in filing the returns. In the event, the application is filed along
with the returns, the same shall be considered in accordance
with law in terms of the order passed by the Coordinate Bench
of this Court in the Writ Petition stated supra . Accordingly, this
Court proceeds to pass the following:
ORDER

i. The Writ Petition is allowed .

ii. The impugned order at Annexure-B stands quashed.

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18334
WP No. 107383 of 2024


CNR: KAHC020209142024



iii. The assessee is permitted to file return of income.
However, along with an application seeking
condonation of delay in filing the returns within a
period of eight weeks from today. In the event, the
returns are filed within the time period stated supra
along with the application, the same shall be
assessed in accordance with law and appropriate
order shall be passed on merits.

iv. All contentions are left open to both the parties and
the matter be considered as expeditiously as
possible, keeping in mind the assessment year,
however, within an outer limit of three months from
today.

Sd/-
(T.M.NADAF)
JUDGE



RKM
CT: UMD
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 62