Mahak Singh vs State of U.P.
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 6817 of 2022
Mahak Singh
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P.
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Lokesh Kumar, Mumtaz Ali, Yogendra
Pal Singh
Counsel for Respondent(s) : G.A.
A.F.R.
RESERVED ON 15.10.2026
DELIVERED ON: 16.11.2026
Court No. - 88
HON'BLE ABDUL SHAHID, J.
1. Heard Sri Mumtaz Ali and Sri Shad Khan, learned counsel for the
appellant, and Sri Manoj Kumar Singh, learned A.G.A. for the State.
2. The present appeal has been filed against the impugned judgment and
order dated 24.08.2022 passed by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge/Special Judge, POCSO Act, Court No. 2, Muzaffarnagar, in
Session Trial No. 1175 of 2015 (State Versus Mahak Singh), arising out
of Case Crime No. 158 of 2015, under Sections 366 and 376 I.P.C., Police
Station Adarsh Mandi, District Shamli.
3. Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the incident is
dated 01.06.2015 as per the prosecution's statement, whereas an N.C.R.
was filed on 08.06.2015 with a significant delay.
4. As per the prosecution's case, the witness Pappan saw the occurrence
on the day of the incident itself. The N.C.R. was converted into an F.I.R.
on 26.06.2015, after which the appellant was arrested on 27.06.2015. The
charge sheet was filed on 30.07.2015, and charges were framed on
03.03.2016, although the victim had not been recovered until then. The
victim was recovered on her own on 08.05.2016; she was not recovered
from the company of the appellant/accused, but at her father's home. The
age of the victim is 22 years. She had been married twice previously, and
both of her previous husbands had left her. It is submitted that at the time
of the incident, the victim was residing at her paternal house.
5. It is further submitted by the learned counsel for the appellant that the
victim did not support the prosecution story in her statements recorded
CRLA No. 6817 of 2022
2
under Sections 161 and 164 Cr.P.C.
6. Learned counsel for the appellant has further submitted that P.W.-1
(father of the victim) is not an eyewitness. The statement of the victim,
who is a major as per her own testimony, has been recorded as P.W.-2.
There are a series of contradictions in the statements of P.W.-1 and P.W.-
2 (the father of the victim and the victim herself, respectively). The victim
had been married twice prior to the alleged incident; hence, it cannot be
presumed that she did not understand the nature and consequences of her
acts. If any incident occurred, the consent of the victim cannot be ruled
out.
7. It is further submitted by learned counsel for the appellant that the
appellant was arrested on 27.06.2015 and was subsequently released on
bail during the trial. After his conviction and sentencing, he has been in
continuous custody since 23.08.2022. He has further submitted that the
doctor who examined the victim found no external or internal injuries on
her body. As per her radiological age estimation, she was found to be a
major, aged above 18 years. It is further submitted by learned counsel for
the appellant that the appellant has no criminal antecedents. Moreover, in
his statement recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the appellant stated that
he is impotent and has been falsely implicated in the present case due to
enmity.
8. Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the findings
recorded by the learned trial court are false and perverse, and the
impugned judgment and order are liable to be set aside. He further
submitted that the appellant is entitled to be acquitted of the charges and
that the criminal appeal deserves to be allowed.
9. Per contra, Sri Manoj Kumar Singh, learned A.G.A., has submitted that
there is specific evidence of the victim being "last seen" with the
appellant. He contended that the learned trial court has passed a well-
reasoned order and that the findings recorded therein are legal and in
accordance with law, hence, the criminal appeal liable to be dismissed.
10. It is true and correct that the alleged incident occurred on 01.06.2016,
whereas the N.C.R. was lodged on 08.06.2016, despite the victim's father
having knowledge of the incident from its very inception. This delay has
not been properly explained.
11. The N.C.R. was subsequently converted into an F.I.R. and registered
as Case Crime No. 168 of 2015 under Section 366 of the I.P.C.
12. The medical examination of the victim was conducted on 10.05.2016,
assessing her age to be 21 years, as specifically recorded in Exhibit Ka-7.
Furthermore, in the Gazette Notification regarding the missing victim
CRLA No. 6817 of 2022
3
issued by the Sub-Inspector/Investigating Officer of Police Station
Aadarsh Mandi (District Shamli), exhibited as Exhibit Ka-9, her age is
recorded as 25 years. Across all prosecution documents, the victim is
established to be a major, aged approximately 21 to 25 years.
13. According to the recovery memo dated 08.05.2016, the victim was
recovered from her own house, and no other person was present at the
scene. In her statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C., the victim
specifically stated:
"My marriage was solemnized with Jaiveer approximately one year ago.
As my husband used to beat me severely, I left his home and returned to
my paternal house in Shekhupura. Since last June, I have been residing of
my own free will at the house of Sukhpali, the daughter of my elder uncle
(Tau), in Gannaur, where I earned my livelihood by working as a
labourer. No person has enticed, kidnapped, or subjected me to any bad
act. My age is 21 years. This statement has been recorded as dictated by
me."
14. She reiterated in her Section 161 Cr.P.C. statement that she is 21 years
of age, that she left her matrimonial home voluntarily due to domestic
abuse by her husband, and that she subsequently returned to her paternal
home. She explicitly affirmed that since last June, she had been residing
with Sukhpali, the daughter of her elder paternal uncle (Tau).
15. The statement of the victim was recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C.
on 13.05.2016 before the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division),
Muzaffarnagar, which is marked as Exhibit Kha-1. In her statement, she
deposed that her marriage was solemnized with Jaiveer approximately
one year ago. She stated:
"I resided at my matrimonial home (sasural) for a period of two months
and eight days. He kept me comfortably for the first two months, but
thereafter, he started beating me. Due to the said harassment, I returned
to my paternal home as my husband does not like me. I resided at my
paternal house for 15 days, after which, without informing anyone at
home, I went to the house of Sukhpali, the daughter of my elder paternal
uncle (Tau) in Gannaur. As my family members were pressuring me to
return to my matrimonial home, I left of my own accord. I resided in
Gannaur for 8 to 9 months. No one took me away by enticement. The
house of Mahak Singh (appellant) is adjacent to my house; my family
members assumed that he took me away, whereas no conversation ever
took place between me and Mahak Singh. I went to the house of my
CRLA No. 6817 of 2022
4
cousin/sister of my own free will, and no other person had any role in it."
16. The victim, being a major and a married woman, left her house of her
own free will and consent, without any interference or support from any
other person. She did not attribute any role to the appellant/accused
regarding her alleged enticement. Furthermore, in her medical history
recorded during her medical examination on 10.05.2016, she informed the
concerned doctor that her husband used to beat her, which led her to leave
her matrimonial home and return to her own house voluntarily.
Subsequently, she moved of her own will to the house of her paternal
uncle's daughter in Gannaur where she resided. As per the statement of
the victim, no sexual assault was ever committed against her.
17. The concerned Medical Officer opined that there were no physical or
genital injuries present, and noted an old, torn, and healed hymen. An X-
ray examination and radiological ossification test were conducted to
determine the age of the victim. As per the report and certificate issued by
the Chief Medical Officer (CMO), the victim's age is approximately 20
years. The victim is thus a major, a fact fully supported by the evidence
available on record.
18. The learned Chief Judicial Magistrate released the victim to go of her
own free will vide order dated 13.05.2016, specifically assessing and
recording her age as above 20 years. This further confirms that, from the
very inception of the case, the victim has been a major.
19. P.W.-1 (father of the victim) is not an eyewitness to the incident. He
stated that Mahak Singh took away his daughter on 01.06.2016 at 8:00
A.M., and that his co-villager, Pappan, saw it and informed him after the
report was registered. The victim returned home after several days.
However, no proper explanation has been offered as to why, despite
knowing that his daughter had been missing since 01.06.2016, he waited
until the next day to take action.
20. It is held by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dilawar Singh Versus State of
Delhi, 2008 (3) SCC (CRI) 330, that if there is delay in either coming
from the police or before the court, the courts always view the allegation
with suspicious and look for satisfactory explanation. If no such
satisfaction is formed the delay is treated as fatal to the prosecution case.
21. In his cross-examination, he admitted that he did not see Mahak Singh
taking his daughter away. He stated that the appellant’s name was
disclosed to him by Pappan, Parvind, and Jogendra on 08.06.2015. He
further testified that the first marriage of the victim was solemnized with
Sonu at Kairana, but the marriage was not materialized; he could not state
whether any child was born out of the said wedlock. The dissolution of
CRLA No. 6817 of 2022
5
her first marriage was settled through a Panchayat and was not legally
finalized by a court.
22. P.W.-1 further stated that his granddaughter told him that the victim
had gone away alone. She returned home after 6–7 months, though he
could not recall the exact date of her return. He also stated that he
solemnized the victim’s second marriage with Jaiveer at Lisadh, which
also ended in a separation settled before a Panchayat rather than through a
formal court decree of divorce. She had resided with Jaiveer for about one
to one-and-a-half months.
23. According to his testimony, the victim is a major. He specifically
admitted during cross-examination that there is no mention of the offence
of rape in his written complaint.
24. There are inconsistencies in the testimony of P.W.-1 (father of the
victim). Furthermore, having duly admitted that the victim was married
twice prior to the alleged incident, the question of her being a minor does
not arise; nor can it be disputed that she was fully capable of
understanding the nature and consequences of her acts.
25. The victim was examined as P.W.-2 on 12.07.2017, wherein she
testified that three years ago, she went with Mahak Singh of her own will,
without any force, pressure, or coercion. On the date of her examination
(12.07.2017), the victim herself stated her age to be 23 years, whereas the
alleged incident occurred on 01.06.2015. Thus, even by her own
statement, she was a major at the time of the occurrence.
26. She stated that no co-villager met her on the way, but subsequently
claimed that Pappan (son of her uncle) and Parvinder (grandson of her
elder uncle/Tau) saw her with Mahak Singh. She further testified that
Mahak Singh first took her to Shamli, then to Meerut, where he kept her
for four days, and thereafter to his cousin’s matrimonial home in Village
Jagas, Haryana. She alleged that Mahak Singh forcibly committed rape
upon her for two days at that location, after which Mahak Singh, Raj
Singh, and Jaivinder brought her to the Police Station and handed her
over to the police. Whereas, no person other than Mahak Singh has been
charge-sheeted in the present offence.
27. The victim significantly improved and modified her version before the
Court, which is contrary to her previous statements recorded under
Sections 161 and 164 Cr.P.C. She further testified that her first marriage
was solemnized with Sonu one year ago to the alleged incident. She
alleged that Sonu and his mother used to beat her and demanded dowry,
including Rs. One lakh. Her father had lodged a police report regarding
the matter; however, accused Sonu did not go to jail, as a settlement was
CRLA No. 6817 of 2022
6
arrived at within the police station itself, and an agreed amount was paid
to her father. No formal decree of divorce was granted by a court, as the
separation was effected through a mutual agreement before a Panchayat.
She also gave contradictory statements regarding who saw her: while she
stated that no villager met her on the way, she also claimed that her
brother saw her. It is highly improbable and unbelievable that if the
victim’s brother had seen her with another person, he would neither object
nor attempt to rescue his sister. Additionally, she stated that she left her
house at 8:00 A.M. and testified that her second marriage was solemnized
with Jaiveer in Village Lishadh one year prior to the incident.
28. Initially, the victim deposed that her marriage was solemnized with
Sonu one year prior to the incident; however, she subsequently stated that
her marriage was solemnized with Jaiveer one year prior to the incident.
These statements are mutually contradictory, mathematically improbable,
and completely lack truthfulness. This clearly demonstrates that the
victim has not deposed truthfully before the Court, rendering the
credibility of her evidence highly doubtful and un-trustworthy.
29. It is held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kuldip Yadav and others
, that credibility of witness is
v. State of Bihar, 2011 (2) SCC (Cri) 632
must, if there are discrepancies in the statements of the witnesses and
their depositions, the conviction on the basis of that kind of testimonies is
unsustainable.
30. In her testimony, she stated that she resided with Jaiveer for 3 to 4
months and is currently residing with her father rather than her husband.
She alleged that Jaiveer refused to stay with her claiming she had two
daughters, despite her contradicting herself by stating she has no children.
She admitted that Jaiveer never demanded dowry, but claimed he beat her
continuously because of her daughters, she never made a complaint of it
before any authority. She also stated that she resided with Jaiveer for two
years. She later denied that Jaiveer disliked her, yet specifically admitted
that he used to beat her, stating, "In my first marriage as well as my
second marriage, I was beaten."
31. She further admitted that she does not remember how many days after
the incident she returned home, and no formal settlement regarding her
marriage ever took place, though Jaiveer is unwilling to take her back.
She has stated that it is belied to state that she has received Rs. 95,000/-
during her first marriage settlement and Rs. 60,000/- during her second.
She alleged that she resided with Mahak Singh at Village Jagas, Haryana,
where he allegedly kept her behind closed doors. However, the evidence
reveals that she travelled and visited to several public places. Being a
twice-married woman and a fully mature major, she neither raised any
alarm or voice of protest nor sought assistance from anyone at any point
CRLA No. 6817 of 2022
7
during her movement. Ultimately, she returned to her own house
voluntarily.
32. It is held by the Four Judges Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
,
Rajak Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2018) 9 SCC 248
where the prosecutrix staying at Kullu with the appellant for 12 days.
Moving freely, meeting several people but not making any complaint.
Doubt about correct age of prosecutrix at relevant time. Prosecution not
successful in showing that prosecutrix was minor. Possibility of
prosecutrix being a consenting party cannot be ruled out. Benefit of doubt
must go to appellant. A radiologist working in the civil Hospital,
Nalagarh who had given an opinion that the age of the prosecutrix was
between 17 to 18 years. While it is correct that the age determined on the
basis of radiological examination may not an accurate determination and
sufficient margin either way has to be allowed, yet the totality of the facts
stated above read with the report of the radiological examination leaves
room for ample doubt with regard to the correct age of the prosecutrix.
The benefit of doubt of the aforesaid doubt, naturally, must go in favour
of the accused.
33. It is held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Paramjit Singh Bedi v.
State of Punjab, 2026 INSC 1054 (SC) , that while it is true that on the
basis of the sole testimony of the prosecutrix, an accused can be convicted
of rape but for such a conviction, it would also require that such statement
of the prosecutrix must inspire the confidence of the court. It is further
held that the prosecutrix denial of consent must be seen in the overall
context of her testimony. If her evidence is taken as a whole, certainly a
view can be taken that her version that the accused had sexual intercourse
with her forcefully without her consent does not merit acceptance. The
version the prosecutrix is not believable at all.
34. In the present case, P.W.-2 (the victim) absenting herself from her
house for 5–6 days, only to travel voluntarily to various places with the
accused and stay with him, makes it virtually impossible to accept that the
accused forcefully committed sexual intercourse with her without her
consent.
35. Pappan deposed as P.W.-3 and stated that he saw the victim along
with the accused on 01.06.2015 at 8:00 A.M. However, despite allegedly
witnessing this, he neither informed the members of her family nor took
any effective steps at the relevant time.
36. The statement of Dr. Vineet Kaushik (Radiologist) was recorded as
P.W.-4. He verified the X-ray report of the victim and explicitly opined,
based on the radiological examination, that her age is approximately 18
years. The doctor specifically concluded that she is a major.
CRLA No. 6817 of 2022
8
37. Dr. Manorama Gopal was examined as P.W.-6. She specifically
verified that when the victim appeared before her, the victim stated that
she was married and her husband used to beat her. Consequently, she left
her matrimonial home (sasural) and went to her cousin's/sister's house in
Gannaur, where she had been residing.
38. As per the statement of the victim, no physical or sexual assault was
committed upon her. There was no mark of any injury either external or
internal found on the victim's body. P.W.-6 also confirmed that the family
members of the victim accompanied her during the examination. In her
cross-examination, the doctor explicitly confirmed that there were no
injury marks on the victim's private parts nor on any other part of her
body. She affirmatively opined that there was no sign indicating that the
victim had been subjected to rape.
39. In view of the aforesaid statements and evidence recorded before the
learned trial court, there is a total lack of consistency and corroboration
between the prosecution story, the eyewitnesses, and the expert medical
witnesses. The victim has been married twice and has voluntarily left her
husband's home on two separate occasions. She is undeniably a major, as
established beyond any doubt.
40. Furthermore, the victim did not support the prosecution's case during
her medical examination or in her statements recorded under Sections 161
and 164 Cr.P.C. P.W.-2 specifically admitted in her testimony that she left
her home of her own will and visited several public places without raising
any alarm or seeking help from anyone.
41. Considering the age of the victim, the medical evidence, and the
entirety of the facts and circumstances of the case, it is categorically clear
that the victim is a major who was fully cognizant of and well-capable of
understanding the nature and consequences of her acts.
42. There are no external or internal injuries on any part of the victim's
body. Not an iota of credible evidence supporting the prosecution story
has emerged from the entire record.
43. It is held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Uday Versus State of
Karnataka, 2003 SCC (Cri.) 775, that the court must in each case apply
judicial mind, while considering the question of consent. The court must
in each case, consider the evidence before it and the surrounding
circumstances, before reaching a conclusion, because each case has its
own peculiar facts which may have a bearing on the question whether the
consent was voluntary, or was given under a misconception of fact.
44. It is held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Paramjeet Singh @
Pamma vs. State of Uttarakhand, AIR 2011 SC 200 , in the criminal
CRLA No. 6817 of 2022
9
trial case, the evidence under section 101 and 104 of the Indian Evidence
Act, 1872, the burden of proof is also always on the prosecution. More
serious the crime more stricter proof is required.
45. Consequently, the prosecution has utterly failed to prove its case
beyond a reasonable doubt. The findings recorded by the learned trial
court are neither legal nor in accordance with the established principles of
law, and deserve to be set aside as perverse.
46. In view thereof, the impugned judgment and order dated 24.08.2022
passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge/Special Judge, POCSO
Act, 2012, Court No. 2, Muzaffarnagar, in Session Trial No. 1175 of 2015
(State Versus Mahak Singh), is hereby set aside.
47. The appellant/accused is hereby acquitted of all the charges.
48. The criminal appeal is allowed.
49. The appellant is in jail. He shall be released forthwith, if not required
in any other case.
50. A copy of this judgment shall be sent by e-mail to the learned District
and Sessions Judge, Muzaffarnagar, for immediate compliance by the
Registrar (Compliance).
51. A copy of the judgment alongwith the original trial court record shall
be sent to the learned trial court immediately for necessary compliance.
November 16, 2026
K.K. Maurya
(Abdul Shahid,J.)
Digitally signed by :-
KAMLESH KUMAR MAURYA
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad