RAMAPPA S/O BEEMAPPA BURUD vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKAAT DHARWAD
TH
DATED THIS THE 4 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
WRIT PETITION NO.101182 OF 2026 (S-REG)
BETWEEN:
1. RAMAPPA S/O. BEEMAPPA BURUD,
AGE: 64 YEARS, OCC: HAMALI,
R/O: BAVANA, SAVADATTI – 591 126,
TQ: RAIBAG, DIST: BELAGAVI.
2. NARAYAN S/O. BABU SATTENNAVAR,
AGE: 55 YEARS, OCC: HAMALI,
R/O: PANTHBALEKUNDRI (KURD) – 590 001,
TQ: BELAGAVI, DIST: BELAGAVI.
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. D.J. NAIK,ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,
REPRESENTED ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE,
VIDHAN SOUDHA,
BENGALURU – 01.
2. AUDIT GENERAL (GE6A),
BENGALURU, KARNATAKA – 01.
3. COMMISSIONER COMMERCIAL TAX,
COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICE, GANDHI NAGAR,
BENGALURU – 01.
Digitally signed
by RAKESH S
HARIHAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
4. JOINT COMMISSIONER (INTELLIGENCE),
COMMERCIAL TAX, BELAGAVI – 590 001,
COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICE, BELAGAVI.
5. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF COMMERCIAL
TAXES (INTELLIGENCE),
NORTH ZONE, BELAGAVI – 590 001.
6. DEPUTY LABOUR COMMISSIONER,
BELAGAVI REGIONAL, BELAGAVI,
DIST: BELAGAVI – 590 001.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. GIRIJA S. HIREMATH, HCGP FOR R1)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO, ISSUE
WRIT OF MANDAMUS DIRECTING THE RESPONDENT NO.3 TO
REGULARIZE THE PETITIONERS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
ORDER DATED 20.02.2025 PASSED BY THE FILED BY THE
RESPONDENT NO.3 VIDE ANNEXURE-D. TO ISSUE WRIT OF
MANDAMUS DIRECTING THE RESPONDENT NO.3 TO RELEASE
ALL THE CONSEQUENTIAL BENEFITS AND WAGES ACCORDING
TO THE MINIMUM WAGES ACT AND ARREARS AND ETC.
THIS WRIT PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
ORAL ORDER
The petitioner is before this Court seeking the following
reliefs:
“a) Issue writ of Mandamus directing the respondent No.3
to regularize the petitioners in accordance with the order
dated 20-02-2025 passed by the filed by the respondent
No.3 vide Annexure- D.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
b) Issue writ of Mandamus directing the respondent No.3
to release all the consequential benefits and wages
according to the minimum wages Act and arrears.
c) Pass such other order as this Hon'ble court deems fit
and proper under the facts and circumstance of the case
to meet the ends of justice and equity.”
2. Heard the learned counsel Sri. D.J. Naik appearing
for the petitioners and the learned High Court Government
Pleader, Smt. Girija S. Hiremath appearing for respondent No.1.
3. Facts, in brief, germane are as follows:
st
Respondent Nos.3 to 5 appoint the 1 petitioner as a
nd
Hamali on 25.11.1992 and the 2 petitioner comes to be
appointed as a Hamali on 19.11.1994. Some persons who were
also appointed as Hamalis approach the Karnataka
Administrative Tribunal, Belagavi (‘the Tribunal’ for short), on
the score that they are working for 30 years on daily wage basis.
The Tribunal directed regularization of the services of those
persons who had been working for 30 years. Respondent No.3
passes an order on 20.02.2025 regularizing the services in
accordance with the direction of the Tribunal. The petitioners
now seek a direction to consider regularization of their services.
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners would submit
that petitioner No.1 was appointed in the year 1992 and retired
on attaining the age of superannuation after completing more
nd
than 30 years of service as a Group-D employee and the 2
petitioner was also appointed in the year 1994 and has
completed more than 30 years of services. Therefore, they were
entitled to be considered for regularization on the principle of
parity of treatment. The petitioners seek a direction to consider
their case for regularization and would place reliance on a
plethora of judgments rendered by the Apex Court and this
Court, all of which would bear consideration qua their relevance
in the course of the order.
5. The learned High Court Government Pleader would,
however, contend that the petitioners were discontinued from
service but were taken back pursuant to the orders of the
Labour Court granting reinstatement and continuity of service.
Therefore, the judgments relied on by the petitioners would not
become applicable.
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
6. I have given my anxious consideration to the
submissions made by the respective learned counsel and have
perused the material on record.
7. The afore-narrated facts, link in the chain of events
are a matter of record. The petitioners were appointed on
25.11.1992 and 19.11.1994 and have completed more than 30
years of service. The submission of the learned High Court
Government Pleader that the petitioners were discontinued and
they were taken back pursuant to the orders of the Labour
Court, and therefore the judgments relied on by the petitioners
would not become applicable is a submission that is noted only
to be rejected.
8. The issue now would be, whether the case of the
petitioners for regularization of services can be considered or
otherwise. The Division Bench of this Court, in the case of
GEETA RAMAPPA TERDAL v. COMMISSIONER, CITY
1
MUNICIPALITY , while considering whether the services of a
retired employee can be regularized, has held as follows:
1
Writ Appeal No.100680 of 2025, decided on 16.10.2026
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
“…. …. ….
8. The issue now is, whether the appellant is
entitled to seek regularization of services,
notwithstanding the fact that the appellant was
appointed on daily wages and retires on attaining
the age of superannuation being a daily wage
employee for 34 years?
8.1. The sheet anchor of the defence projected by
the respondents-State is the judgment of the Constitution
Bench of the Apex Court in the case of UMADEVI supra ,
wherein, according to the State, regularization of
employees engaged on daily wages, dehors the regular
process of recruitment, is impermissible, more so when
such employees have already attained the age of
superannuation while continuing as daily-wage
employees. The State would thus seek to place the
judgment in the case of UMADEVI as an insurmountable
legal impediment to the claim of the appellant. The
submission, though seemingly formidable, requires
examination in the light of the law declared in the
case of UMADEVI, the exception carved out therein,
and the subsequent exposition of its principles by
the Apex Court.
8.2. The judgment in the case of UMADEVI cannot
be read as though it were a charter for perpetuating
irregular employment, nor can its declaration of law be
divorced from the constitutional philosophy that animated
it. The Constitution Bench sought to prevent the backdoor
entry into public employment; it did not intend to confer
upon the State an unbridled licence to extract labour
against sanctioned posts for decades together and
thereafter disown the legitimate claims of those very
employees by invoking the doctrine against
regularization. Equally, the exception recognized in the
judgment cannot be employed to defeat the constitutional
mandate of equality in public employment. The distinction
between an illegal appointment and an irregular
appointment, the existence of a duly sanctioned post, the
manner of initial engagement, the qualifications
possessed by the employee, and the length and continuity
of service are all facets that assume significance in the
consideration of a claim of this nature.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
8.3. The issue, therefore, is not whether every
daily-wage employee acquires an indefeasible right to
regularization by the mere passage of time. The issue is
whether an employee who entered service through the
Employment Exchange against a sanctioned vacancy,
continued to serve the State for decades, received
recommendations for regularization, and witnessed
similarly situated employees being regularized, could be
denied even consideration of her claim solely because she
had, in the meantime, attained the age of
superannuation . To answer this question, it becomes
necessary to traverse the trajectory of the law from
UMADEVI to the judgments that followed, for the
law must be understood not merely by its
declaration at one point in time, but by the manner
in which its principles have subsequently been
explained, distinguished and applied.
9. It is, therefore, germane to notice the evolution
of the law on regularization, beginning with the judgment
of the Constitution Bench in UMADEVI and proceeding to
its judicial aftermath.
UMADEVI AND ITS AFTERMATH
9.1. The Apex Court, in its judgment in the case of
UMADEVI supra , considers appointments that are illegal,
irregular and persons who have been working for the last
10 years as on the date of the judgment i.e., on 10-04-
2006, all can be considered for regularization. However, it
was noticed that an appropriate scheme could be framed
even otherwise. The Apex Court in the case of UMADEVI
has held as follows:
“…. …. ….
53. One aspect needs to be clarified.
There may be cases where irregular
appointments (not illegal appointments) as
explained in S.V. Narayanappa [(1967) 1
SCR 128 : AIR 1967 SC 1071] , R.N.
Nanjundappa [(1972) 1 SCC 409 : (1972) 2
SCR 799] and B.N. Nagarajan [(1979) 4 SCC
507 : 1980 SCC (L&S) 4 : (1979) 3 SCR 937]
and referred to in para 15 above, of duly
qualified persons in duly sanctioned vacant
posts might have been made and the
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
employees have continued to work for ten
years or more but without the intervention
of orders of the courts or of tribunals. The
question of regularisation of the services of
such employees may have to be considered
on merits in the light of the principles
settled by this Court in the cases above
referred to and in the light of this judgment.
In that context, the Union of India, the State
Governments and their instrumentalities
should take steps to regularise as a one-
time measure, the services of
such irregularly appointed, who have
worked for ten years or more in duly
sanctioned posts but not under cover of
orders of the courts or of tribunals and
should further ensure that regular
recruitments are undertaken to fill those
vacant sanctioned posts that require to be
filled up, in cases where temporary
employees or daily wagers are being now
employed. The process must be set in
motion within six months from this date. We
also clarify that regularisation, if any
already made, but not sub judice, need not
be reopened based on this judgment, but
there should be no further bypassing of the
constitutional requirement and regularising
or making permanent, those not duly
appointed as per the constitutional scheme.
54. It is also clarified that those decisions
which run counter to the principle settled in this
decision, or in which directions running counter
to what we have held herein, will stand denuded
of their status as precedents.
55. In cases relating to service in the
Commercial Taxes Department, the High Court
has directed that those engaged on daily wages,
be paid wages equal to the salary and allowances
that are being paid to the regular employees of
their cadre in government service, with effect
from the dates from which they were respectively
appointed. The objection taken was to the
direction for payment from the dates of
engagement. We find that the High Court had
clearly gone wrong in directing that these
employees be paid salary equal to the salary and
allowances that are being paid to the regular
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
employees of their cadre in government service,
with effect from the dates from which they were
respectively engaged or appointed. It was not
open to the High Court to impose such an
obligation on the State when the very question
before the High Court in the case was whether
these employees were entitled to have equal pay
for equal work so called and were entitled to any
other benefit. They had also been engaged in the
teeth of directions not to do so. We are,
therefore, of the view that, at best, the Division
Bench of the High Court should have directed
that wages equal to the salary that is being paid
to regular employees be paid to these daily-wage
employees with effect from the date of its
judgment. Hence, that part of the direction of the
Division Bench is modified and it is directed that
these daily-wage earners be paid wages equal to
the salary at the lowest grade of employees of
their cadre in the Commercial Taxes Department
in government service, from the date of the
judgment of the Division Bench of the High
Court. Since, they are only daily-wage earners,
there would be no question of other allowances
being paid to them. In view of our conclusion,
that the courts are not expected to issue
directions for making such persons permanent in
service, we set aside that part of the direction of
the High Court directing the Government to
consider their cases for regularisation. We also
notice that the High Court has not adverted to
the aspect as to whether it was regularisation or
it was giving permanency that was being directed
by the High Court. In such a situation, the
direction in that regard will stand deleted and the
appeals filed by the State would stand allowed to
that extent. If sanctioned posts are vacant (they
are said to be vacant) the State will take
immediate steps for filling those posts by a
regular process of selection. But when regular
recruitment is undertaken, the respondents in
CAs Nos. 3595-612 and those in the Commercial
Taxes Department similarly situated, will be
allowed to compete, waiving the age restriction
imposed for the recruitment and giving some
weightage for their having been engaged for
work in the Department for a significant period of
time. That would be the extent of the exercise of
power by this Court under Article 142 of the
Constitution to do justice to them.”
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
After the said judgment of the Apex Court in
UMADEVI , the judicial thought process has undergone a
change owing to the fact of exploitation of human labour
at the hands of the State projecting the judgment of the
Apex Court in the case of UMADEVI .
9.2. The Apex Court in the case of AMARENDRA
KUMAR MOHAPATRA v. STATE OF ORISSA [(2014) 4
SCC 583] , had held as follows:
“…. …. ….
42. The decision in Umadevi (3) case
[State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4
SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753], as noticed earlier,
permitted regularisation of regular appointments
and not illegal appointments. Question, however,
is whether the appointments in the instant case
could be described as illegal and if they were not,
whether the State could be directed to regularise
the services of the degree-holder Junior
Engineers who have worked as ad hoc Assistant
Engineers for such a long period, not only on the
analogy of the legislative enactment for
regularisation but also on the principle underlying
para 53 of the decision in Umadevi (3) case
[State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4
SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753].
43. As to what would constitute an
irregular appointment is no longer res
integra. The decision of this Court in State of
Karnataka v. M.L. Kesari [(2010) 9 SCC
247 : (2010) 2 SCC (L&S) 826], has examined
that question and explained the principle
regarding regularisation as enunciated
in Umadevi (3) case [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753]. The decision in that
case summed up the following three
essentials for regularisation : (1) the
employees have worked for ten years or
more, (2) that they have so worked in a
duly sanctioned post without the benefit or
protection of the interim order of any court
or tribunal, and (3) they should have
possessed the minimum qualification
stipulated for the appointment. Subject to
these three requirements being satisfied,
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
even if the appointment process did not
involve open competitive selection, the
appointment would be treated irregular and
not illegal and thereby qualify for
regularisation. Para 7 in this regard is
apposite and may be extracted at this
stage: (M.L. Kesari case [(2010) 9 SCC
247 : (2010) 2 SCC (L&S) 826], SCC p. 250)
“7. It is evident from the above
that there is an exception to the
general principles against
‘regularisation’ enunciated in Umadevi
(3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi
(3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S)
753], if the following conditions are
fulfilled:
(i) The employee
concerned should have worked for 10
years or more in a duly sanctioned
post without the benefit or protection
of the interim order of any court or
tribunal. In other words, the State
Government or its instrumentality
should have employed the employee
and continued him in service
voluntarily and continuously for more
than ten years.
(ii) The appointment of
such employee should not be illegal,
even if irregular. Where the
appointments are not made or
continued against sanctioned posts or
where the persons appointed do not
possess the prescribed minimum
qualifications, the appointments will be
considered to be illegal. But where the
person employed possessed the
prescribed qualifications and was
working against sanctioned posts, but
had been selected without undergoing
the process of open competitive
selection, such appointments are
considered to be irregular.”
44. It is nobody's case that the
degree-holder Junior Engineers were not
qualified for appointment as Assistant
Engineers as even they possess degrees
from recognised institutions. It is
also nobody's case that they were not
appointed against the sanctioned post.
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
There was some debate as to the actual
number of vacancies available from time to
time but we have no hesitation in holding
that the appointments made were at all
relevant points of time against sanctioned
posts. The information provided by Mr.
Nageswara Rao, learned Additional Solicitor
General, appearing for the State of Orissa,
in fact, suggests that the number of
vacancies was at all points of time more
than the number of appointments made on
ad hoc basis. It is also clear that each one of
the degree-holders has worked for more
than 10 years ever since his appointment as
ad hoc Assistant Engineer. It is in that view
difficult to describe these appointments of
the Stipendiary Engineers on ad hoc basis to
be illegal so as to fall beyond the purview of
the scheme envisaged in Umadevi (3) case
[State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4
SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753].
45. The upshot of the above
discussion is that not only because
in Umadevi (3) case [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] this Court did not
disturb the appointments already made or
regularisation granted, but also because the
decision itself permitted regularisation in
case of irregular appointments, the
legislative enactment granting such
regularisation does not call for interference
at this late stage when those appointed or
regularised have already started retiring
having served their respective departments,
in some cases for as long as 22 years .”
9.3. The Apex Court in the case of SHEO NARAIN
NAGAR v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [(2018) 13
SCC 432] , holds as follows:
“…. …. ….
6. The learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the respondent has relied upon para 44
of the decision in Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753], so as to contend that it
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
was not the case of irregular appointment but of
illegal appointment; there was no post available
on which the services of the appellants could
have been regularised and appointment were in
contravention of the reservation policy also; thus,
termination order was rightly issued and, in no
case, the appellants were entitled for
regularisation of their services.
7. When we consider the prevailing
scenario, it is painful to note that the
decision in Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] has not been
properly understood and rather wrongly
applied by various State Governments. We
have called for the data in the instant case
to ensure as to how many employees were
working on contract basis or ad hoc basis or
daily-wage basis in different State
departments. We can take judicial notice
that widely aforesaid practice is being
continued. Though this Court has
emphasised that incumbents should be
appointed on regular basis as per rules but
new devise of making appointment on
contract basis has been adopted,
employment is offered on daily-wage basis,
etc. in exploitative forms. This situation was
not envisaged by Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753]. The prime
intendment of the decision was that the
employment process should be by fair
means and not by back door entry and in the
available pay scale. That spirit of
the Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi(3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] has been ignored
and conveniently overlooked by various
State Governments/authorities. We
regretfully make the observation
that Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] has not been
implemented in its true spirit and has not
been followed in its pith and substance. It is
being used only as a tool for not
regularising the services of incumbents.
They are being continued in service without
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
payment of due salary for which they are
entitled on the basis of Articles 14, 16 read
with Article 34(1)(d) of the Constitution of
India as if they have no constitutional
protection as envisaged in D.S.
Nakara v. Union of India [D.S. Nakara v. Union of
India, (1983) 1 SCC 305 : 1983 SCC (L&S)
145 : AIR 1983 SC 130], from cradle to grave.
In heydays of life they are serving on
exploitative terms with no guarantee of
livelihood to be continued and in old age
they are going to be destituted, there being
no provision for pension, retiral benefits,
etc. There is clear contravention of
constitutional provisions and aspiration of
downtrodden class. They do have equal
rights and to make them equals they require
protection and cannot be dealt with
arbitrarily. The kind of treatment meted out
is not only bad but equally unconstitutional
and is denial of rights. We have to strike a
balance to really implement the ideology
of Umadevi (3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi
(3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S)
753]. Thus, the time has come to stop the
situation where Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] can be permitted to
be flouted, whereas, this Court has
interdicted such employment way back in
the year 2006. The employment cannot be on
exploitative terms, whereas Umadevi (3) [State
of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] laid down that there
should not be back door entry and every post
should be filled by regular employment, but a
new device has been adopted for making
appointment on payment of paltry system on
contract/ad hoc basis or otherwise. This kind of
action is not permissible when we consider the
pith and substance of true spirit in Umadevi (3)
[State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4
SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753].
8. Coming to the facts of the instant case,
there was a direction issued way back in the year
1999, to consider the regularisation of the
appellants. However, regularisation was not
done. The respondents chose to give minimum of
the pay scale, which was available to the regular
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
employees, way back in the year 2000 and by
passing an order, the appellants were also
conferred temporary status in the year 2006,
with retrospective effect on 2-10-2002. As the
respondents have themselves chosen to confer a
temporary status to the employees, as such
there was requirement at work and posts were
also available at the particular point of time when
order was passed. Thus, the submission raised by
the learned counsel for the respondent that posts
were not available, is belied by their own action.
Obviously, the order was passed considering the
long period of services rendered by the
appellants, which were taken on exploitative
terms.
9. The High Court dismissed the writ
application relying on the decision in Umadevi (3)
[State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4
SCC 1: 2006 SCC (L&S) 753]. But the
appellants were employed basically in the
year 1993; they had rendered service for
three years, when they were offered the
service on contract basis; it was not the
case of back door entry; and there were no
Rules in place for offering such kind of
appointment. Thus, the appointment could
not be said to be illegal and in contravention
of Rules, as there were no such Rules
available at the relevant point of time, when
their temporary status was conferred w.e.f.
2-10-2002. The appellants were required to
be appointed on regular basis as a one-time
measure, as laid down in para 53 of Umadevi
(3) [State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4
SCC 1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753]. Since the
appellants had completed 10 years of
service and temporary status had been
given by the respondents with retrospective
effect from 2-10-2002, we direct that the
services of the appellants be regularised
from the said date i.e. 2.10.2002,
consequential benefits and the arrears of
pay also to be paid to the appellants within
a period of three months from today.”
9.4. The Apex Court in the case of NARENDRA
KUMAR TIWARI v. STATE OF JHARKHAND [(2018) 8
SCC 238] , holds as follows:
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
“…. …. ….
7. The purpose and intent of the
decision in Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] was therefore
twofold, namely, to prevent irregular or
illegal appointments in the future and
secondly, to confer a benefit on those who
had been irregularly appointed in the past.
The fact that the State of Jharkhand
continued with the irregular appointments
for almost a decade after the decision
in Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] is a clear indication
that it believes that it was all right to
continue with irregular appointments, and
whenever required, terminate the services
of the irregularly appointed employees on
the ground that they were irregularly
appointed. This is nothing but a form of
exploitation of the employees by not giving
them the benefits of regularisation and by
placing the sword of Damocles over their
head. This is precisely what Umadevi (3)
[State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006)
4 SCC 1: 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] and Kesari
[State of Karnataka v. M.L. Kesari, (2010) 9
SCC 247 : (2010) 2 SCC (L&S) 826] sought
to avoid.
8. If a strict and literal interpretation,
forgetting the spirit of the decision of the
Constitution Bench in Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753], is to be taken into
consideration then no irregularly appointed
employee of the State of Jharkhand could ever be
regularised since that State came into existence
only on 15-11-2000 and the cut-off date was
fixed as 10-4-2006. In other words, in this
manner the pernicious practice of
indefinitely continuing irregularly appointed
employees would be perpetuated contrary
to the intent of the Constitution Bench.
9. The High Court as well as the State
of Jharkhand ought to have considered the
entire issue in a contextual perspective and
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
not only from the point of view of the
interest of the State, financial or otherwise -
the interest of the employees is also
required to be kept in mind. What has
eventually been achieved by the State of
Jharkhand is to short circuit the process of
regular appointments and instead make
appointments on an irregular basis. This is
hardly good governance.
10. Under the circumstances, we are of
the view that the Regularisation Rules must be
given a pragmatic interpretation and the
appellants, if they have completed 10 years of
service on the date of promulgation of the
Regularisation Rules, ought to be given the
benefit of the service rendered by them. If they
have completed 10 years of service they
should be regularised unless there is some
valid objection to their regularisation like
misconduct, etc. ”
9.5. A three Judges Bench of the Apex Court
considering the case of UMADEVI supra and subsequent
judgments, in the case of PREM SINGH v. STATE OF
UTTAR PRADESH [(2019) 10 SCC 516] , holds as
follows:
“…. …. ….
36. There are some of the employees who
have not been regularised in spite of having
rendered the services for 30-40 or more years
whereas they have been superannuated. As they
have worked in the work-charged establishment,
not against any particular project, their services
ought to have been regularised under the
Government instructions and even as per the
decision of this Court in State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC
1 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 753]. This Court in the
said decision has laid down that in case
services have been rendered for more than
ten years without the cover of the Court's
order, as one-time measure, the services be
regularised of such employees. In the facts
of the case, those employees who have
worked for ten years or more should have
been regularised. It would not be proper to
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
regulate them for consideration of
regularisation as others have been
regularised, we direct that their services be
treated as a regular one. However, it is
made clear that they shall not be entitled to
claiming any dues of difference in wages
had they been continued in service regularly
before attaining the age of superannuation.
They shall be entitled to receive the pension
as if they have retired from the regular
establishment and the services rendered by
them right from the day they entered the
work-charged establishment shall be
counted as qualifying service for purpose of
pension .”
9.6. The Apex Court in the case of CHANDER
MOHAN NEGI v. STATE OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
[(2020) 5 SCC 732], holds as follows:
“…. …. ….
13. It is true that in the initial
schemes notified by the Government, there
was a condition that such appointees should
not seek regularisation/ absorption but at
the same time for no fault of them, they
cannot be denied regularisation/absorption.
It is in view of the requirement of the State,
their services were extended from time to
time and now all the appointees have
completed more than 15 years of service.
For majority of the appointed Teachers
under the various schemes, benefit was
already extended and some left over
candidates were denied on account of
interim orders passed by this Court. With
regard to Primary Assistant Teachers, it is stated
that all the candidates have completed Special
Teacher Training Qualifying Condensed Course
and also had obtained special JBT certificate after
5 years' continuous service in terms of the
Himachal Pradesh Education Code, 1985. The
judgments relied on by learned counsel Shri
Prashant Bhushan also would not render any
assistance to the case of the appellants herein for
the reason that there was unexplained and
inordinate delay on the part of the appellants in
approaching the High Court and further having
regard to explanation offered by the State about
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
the need of framing such policies to meet the
immediate requirement to fill up single teacher
schools which were vacant for a very long time,
having regard to topographical conditions, which
is not even controverted by way of any rejoinder
before the High Court. In such view of the
matter, taking the totality of peculiar
circumstances of these cases, we are of the
view that the view expressed by this Court
in the judgments relied on cannot be applied
to the facts of the case on hand. All the
appointed candidates are working for the
meagre salaries pursuant to schemes
notified by the Government. Except the
vague submission that such schemes were
framed only to make backdoor entries, there
is no material placed on record to buttress
such submission. Further it is also to be
noted that though such schemes were
notified as early as in 2003, nobody has
questioned such policies and appointments
up to 2012 and 2013. The writ petition i.e.
CWP No. 3303 of 2012-A was filed in the year
2012 without even impleading the appointees as
party respondents. In the writ petition, there was
no rejoinder filed by the writ petitioners disputing
the averments of the State as stated in the reply-
affidavit.Having regard to the nature of such
appointments, appointments made as per policies
cannot be termed as illegal. Having regard to
material placed before this Court and having
regard to reasons recorded in the impugned
order [Pankaj Kumar v. State of H.P., 2014 SCC
OnLine HP 5944] by the High Court, we are of
the view that no case is made out to interfere
with the impugned judgment [Pankaj
Kumar v. State of H.P., 2014 SCC OnLine HP
5944] of the High Court.”
9.7. The Apex Court in the case of SUKHENDU
BHATTACHARJEE v. STATE OF ASSAM [2026 SCC
OnLine SC 909] , while following the earlier judgments in
the cases of JAGGO v. UNION OF INDIA reported in
2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826 ; SHRIPAL v. NAGAR
NIGAM, GHAZIABAD reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC
221 and DHARAM SINGH v. STATE OF UTTAR
PRADESH reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1735, has
held as follows:
“…. …. ….
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
54. There is no dispute that the appellants
had been engaged as Work Charged/Muster Roll
st
workers much prior to 1 April, 1993 and had
continuously discharged their duties over a
prolonged period of time. Their position is, in no
manner, distinguishable from those Work
Charged/Muster Roll workers whose services
were regularized pursuant to the Cabinet decision
nd
dated 22 July, 2005. The appellants were left
out from the exercise of regularization owing to
inadvertent mistakes, clerical errors and
administrative discrepancies on the part of the
State. Hence, the appellants cannot be faulted for
denial of the benefits flowing from the aforesaid
Cabinet decision under which nearly 30,000
similarly situated workers were regularized. The
core question, therefore, which arises for
consideration is whether, in the aforesaid
circumstances, the appellants can be denied
the benefit of regularization solely on the
ground that they were not appointed
against sanctioned posts and that the
decision in Umadevi (supra) prohibits such
regularization.
55.The key reason assigned by the
Division Bench in overturning the judgment
of the learned Single Judge was that the
employees were not appointed against duly
sanctioned vacant posts and, therefore, did
not satisfy the requirements of the
exception carved out in paragraph 53 of
Umadevi (supra). The Division Bench held
that regularization is permissible only in
cases of irregular (and not illegal)
appointments of duly qualified persons
working against sanctioned vacant posts for
ten years or more without the protection of
Court orders. Since, according to the State,
none of the respondents therein were
appointed against sanctioned posts, the
benefit of the one-time measure
contemplated in Umadevi (supra), and
explained in M.L. Kesari (supra), was held to
be inapplicable to them.
56. Paragraph 53 of Umadevi (supra)
would be relevant for consideration of the lis and
the same is reproduced hereinbelow:—
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
“ 53. One aspect needs to be
clarified. There may be cases where
irregular appointments (not illegal
appointments) as explained in S.V.
Narayanappa (supra), R.N.
Nanjundappa (supra), and B.N.
Nagarajan (supra), and referred to in
paragraph 15 above, of duly qualified
persons in duly sanctioned vacant
posts might have been made and the
employees have continued to work for
ten years or more but without the
intervention of orders of Courts or of
tribunals. The question of
regularization of the services of such
employees may have to be considered
on merits in the light of the principles
settled by this Court in the cases above
referred to and in the light of this
judgment. In that context, the
Union of India, the State
Governments, and their
instrumentalities should take steps
to regularize as a one time
measure, the services of such
irregularly appointed, who have
worked for ten years or more in
duly sanctioned posts but not
under cover of orders of the Courts
or of tribunals and should further
ensure that regular recruitments
are undertaken to fill those vacant
sanctioned posts that require to be
filled up, in cases where temporary
employees or daily wagers are
being now employed. The process
must be set in motion within six
months from this date. We also clarify
that regularization, if any already
made, but not subjudice, need not be
reopened based on this judgment, but
there should be no further bypassing of
the constitutional requirement and
regularizing or making permanent,
those not duly appointed as per the
constitutional scheme.”
(Emphasis supplied)
57. The one-time exception as carved out
in paragraph 53 of Umadevi (supra) was further
elaborated and explained in M.L. Kesari (supra)
wherein this Court observed as follows:—
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
“9. The term ‘one-time
measure’ has to be understood in
its proper perspective. This would
normally mean that after the
decision in Umadevi, each
department or each
instrumentality should undertake a
one-time exercise and prepare a
list of all casual, daily-wage or ad
hoc employees who have been
working for more than ten years
without the intervention of Courts
and tribunals and subject them to
a process verification as to
whether they are working against
vacant posts and possess the
requisite qualification for the post
and if so, regularize their services.
10. At the end of six months
from the date of decision in Umadevi ,
cases of several daily-wage/ad-
hoc/casual employees were still
pending before Courts. Consequently,
several departments and
instrumentalities did not commence
the one-time regularization process.
On the other hand, some
Government departments or
instrumentalities undertook the
one-time exercise excluding
several employees from
consideration either on the ground
that their cases were pending in
Courts or due to sheer oversight.
In such circumstances, the
employees who were entitled to be
considered in terms of Para 53 of
the decision in Umadevi, will not
lose their right to be considered for
regularization, merely because the
one-time exercise was completed
without considering their cases, or
because the six month period
mentioned in para 53 of Umadevi
has expired. The one-time exercise
should consider all daily-
wage/adhoc/those employees who
had put in 10 years of continuous
service as on 10.4.2006 without
availing the protection of any
interim orders of Courts or
tribunals. If any employer had held
the one-time exercise in terms of
para 53 of Umadevi, but did not
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
consider the cases of some
employees who were entitled to
the benefit of para 53 of Umadevi,
the employer concerned should
consider their cases also, as a
continuation of the one-time
exercise. The one time exercise
will be concluded only when all the
employees who are entitled to be
considered in terms of Para 53 of
Umadevi, are so considered.
11. The object behind the said
direction in para 53 of Umadevi is two-
fold. First is to ensure that those who
have put in more than ten years of
continuous service without the
protection of any interim orders of
Courts or tribunals, before the date of
decision in Umadevi was rendered, are
considered for regularization in view of
their long service. Second is to ensure
that the departments/instrumentalities
do not perpetuate the practice of
employing persons on daily-wage/ad-
hoc/casual for long periods and then
periodically regularize them on the
ground that they have served for more
than ten years, thereby defeating the
constitutional or statutory provisions
relating to recruitment and
appointment. The true effect of the
direction is that all persons who
have worked for more than ten
years as on 10.4.2006 (the date of
decision in Umadevi) without the
protection of any interim order of
any Court or tribunal, in vacant
posts, possessing the requisite
qualification, are entitled to be
considered for regularization. The
fact that the employer has not
undertaken such exercise of
regularization within six months of
the decision in Umadevi or that
such exercise was undertaken only
in regard to a limited few, will not
disentitle such employees, the
right to be considered for
regularization in terms of the
above directions in Umadevi as a
one-time measure.”
(Emphasis supplied)
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
58. What can be deduced from
paragraph 53 of Umadevi (supra), as
clarified in M.L. Kesari (supra), is that the
Union of India and the State Governments
were directed to undertake a one-time
exercise to regularize employees who had
worked for ten years or more in duly
sanctioned posts, without the protection of
Court or tribunal orders. This direction was
to be implemented after the decision in
th
Umadevi (supra), i.e. , after 10 April, 2006.
The exception carved out in paragraph 53
was therefore intended to operate
prospectively and within the framework laid
down therein.
59. In our considered view, the reliance
placed by the Division Bench on Umadevi (supra)
and M.L. Kesari (supra) was misplaced in the
facts of the present case. Paragraph 53 of
Umadevi (supra) carved out a limited
exception for those employees who had
worked for more than ten years in duly
sanctioned posts without the protection of
Court orders. However, the appellants were
not seeking regularization on the basis of
that one-time exception. Their claim is
nd
rooted in the Cabinet decision dated 22
July, 2005, by which the State consciously
decided to regularize the services of Work
Charged and Muster Roll workers engaged
st
prior to 1 April, 1993, and pursuant to
which nearly 30,000 similarly situated
employees were in fact regularized by
creation of posts. The appellants claimed
parity with that very class and sought equal
treatment under Article 14 of the
Constitution. The issue, therefore, is not one
of invoking the limited exception carved out
in Umadevi (supra), but of ensuring that
employees who stand on the same footing
are treated alike.
60. It is a settled principle that equals
must be treated equally, and if persons
similarly placed are treated differently
without a rational basis, it would amount to
a violation of Article 14 of the
11
Constitution . If two sets of employees
stand on the same footing in terms of date
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
of engagement, nature of duties, length of
service and eligibility under a declared
policy, the State cannot extend a benefit to
one large group and deny it to the smaller
group without demonstrating a valid
distinction. Equality does not allow selective
or partial implementation of a policy. Once a
policy decision is taken to benefit a defined
class, it must be applied uniformly to all
who satisfy the prescribed conditions.
61.In the present case, the State
itself framed a policy in 2005 to regularize
Work Charged and Muster Roll workers
st
engaged prior to 1 April, 1993. Pursuant to
the aforesaid policy decision, approximately
30,000 workers were regularized. The
appellants belong to that very category.
They were engaged prior to the cut-off date
and have rendered long and continuous
service in the same manner as those who
were regularized. There is no distinguishing
feature shown which separates them from
the beneficiaries of the 2005 decision. Once
the State chose to regularize such a large
body of workers forming one identifiable
class, it was under a constitutional
obligation to treat all eligible members of
that class alike. The remaining workers who
were left out, though otherwise eligible,
cannot be excluded and denied the same
benefit. It is crucial to note that the
exclusion of the appellants from being
granted the benefit of the 2005 decision is
not attributable to the appellants but is
rather predicated in the actions of the State
machinery which, on account of inadvertent
errors or clerical mistakes, did not include
the appellants in the list of beneficiary
covered by the said government decision.
62. Recently, in Pawan Kumar v.
12
Union of India this Court considered a
similar situation wherein certain employees
had been regularized but others, though
similarly placed, were left out. This Court
held that such differential treatment was
discriminatory and accordingly granted the
same relief to the excluded employees.
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
63.Once the State confers a benefit
upon a particular class, it cannot arbitrarily
deny the same benefit to others who are
identically situated. Applying the principle in
the present case, the State, having
regularized nearly 30,000 workers under its
own policy decision, could not refuse to
regularize the remaining eligible workers
who stood on the same footing. To do so
amounts to treating equals unequally, which
is impermissible under Article 14 of the
Constitution.
64. The present appeals could have been
allowed on the basis of discussion made
hereinabove, as the unequal and arbitrary
treatment meted out to the appellants is
apparent on the face of the record. However, the
facts and circumstances of the present case
necessitate certain observations regarding the
manner in which the State has handled the issue
of regularization. The way in which assurances
were extended, policies were formulated and
partially implemented, and thereafter altered,
warrants closer scrutiny so as to ensure
adherence to the standards of fairness and
accountability expected of the State and its
instrumentalities.
65. It is not in dispute that nearly 30,000
workers were regularized pursuant to the Cabinet
nd
decision dated 22 July, 2005. However, as
noted above, due to administrative lapses and
clerical omissions on the part of the State,
several eligible workers, including the appellants,
were left out of the exercise. This led to the filing
of multiple writ petitions before the High Court.
In those proceedings, particularly in Ramani
Deka (supra) and connected matters, the State,
through affidavits sworn by the Chief Secretary
and other senior officers, expressly acknowledged
that a substantial number of workers engaged
st
prior to 1 April, 1993 had been left out in the
exercise of regularization. The Court was
informed that the Government was actively
considering their cases and that an appropriate
policy would be framed within a stipulated period,
with the outcome likely to be in favour of such
workers. Acting upon these categorical
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
representations, the High Court passed an order
requiring the State to take consequential steps.
66. In this backdrop, the subsequent filing
of a Miscellaneous Application seeking nod from
the High Court to implement the very policy
under consideration, on the ground that the law
laid down in Umadevi (supra) created a legal
embargo on such regularization, appears wholly
unwarranted. It is not as though the State
was unaware of the decision in Umadevi
(supra) at the time it furnished
undertakings before the High Court. The
judgment in Umadevi (supra) had already
been delivered in April 2006. The
undertakings given by the State before the
High Court, acknowledging the existence of
a large number of left-out workers and
committing to frame a policy for their
regularization, were furnished much
thereafter. This clearly indicates that the
State was fully conscious of the decision in
Umadevi (supra) and its implications at the
time it made those representations. If the
State genuinely apprehended any legal
impediment arising from Umadevi (supra),
it ought to have raised such concerns at the
first instance. Instead, it continued to
assure the Court that a policy for
regularization of left-out workers was under
active consideration. It was only in 2012
that the State sought leave of the Court,
citing Umadevi (supra) as a hurdle. The
2012 O.M. appears to have been designed in
a manner that effectively defeats and
dilutes the very object and purpose of the
nd
Cabinet decision dated 22 July, 2005. Once
the Cabinet had taken a considered decision
and acted upon it for a large number of
employees, it was incumbent upon the State
to act in furtherance thereof fully, and not
to introduce measures that undermine or
circumvent it. The State which is expected
to act as a model employer cannot be
permitted to resile from, or seek shelter
against its own decisions through
subsequent executive decisions. To allow
such a course would be contrary to
principles of administrative fairness,
consistency, and good governance.
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
67.The conduct of the State must also
be examined in light of its status as a model
employer. The State is under a higher
constitutional obligation to ensure that its
actions are just, reasonable and non-
arbitrary. Recently, this Court in Bhola Nath
13
v. State of Jharkhand reiterated that the
State, as a model employer, bears a
heightened constitutional obligation in the
discharge of its functions. It must act with
probity, fairness and candour, and cannot
cloud the disputes involving its employees
under narrow technical grounds divorced
from their broader constitutional context. A
model employer is expected to uphold the
dignity of its employees more so who are at
the lowest pedestal of the hierarchy and to
avoid exploiting their vulnerability or
precarious position. This obligation flows
directly from the Constitution and is not
discretionary. Constantly giving
undertakings before a constitutional Court
and thereafter resiling from them does not
comport with the standards expected of a
model employer. An undertaking recorded
by a Court is not a casual statement, but is a
solemn representation on the basis of which
judicial orders are passed. The State cannot
approbate and reprobate. It cannot, on the
one hand, secure time and indulgence from
the Court on the assurance that a policy will
be implemented and, on the other, avoid
implementation by citing precedents that
were already in existence at the time the
undertakings were furnished.
68. The repeated undertakings given
by the State before the High Court, coupled
with the earlier implementation of the
Cabinet decision in favour of nearly 30,000
similarly situated workers, clearly gave rise
to a legitimate expectation in the minds of
the appellants who were deprived of the
benefits of the policy. In the maze of
administrative deficiencies, they were
entitled to expect that the policy decision
would be implemented in a fair, complete
and non-discriminatory manner, and that
their cases would also be considered as part
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
of the same exercise. Though legitimate
expectation does not create a vested right,
it is firmly rooted in the principles of
fairness and non-arbitrariness that flows
from Article 14 of the Constitution.
69. A three-judge bench of this Court in
National Buildings Construction Corporation v. S.
14
Raghunathan explained the doctrine of
legitimate expectation in the following terms:—
“The doctrine of “legitimate
expectation” has its genesis in the field
of administrative law. The
Government and its departments,
in administering the affairs of the
country, are expected to honour
their statements of policy or
intention and treat the citizens
with full personal consideration
without any iota of abuse of
discretion. The policy statements
cannot be disregarded unfairly or
applied selectively. Unfairness in
the form of unreasonableness is
akin to violation of natural justice.
It was in this context that the
doctrine of “legitimate
expectation” was evolved which
has today become a source of
substantive as well as procedural
rights. But claims based on “legitimate
expectation” have been held to require
reliance on representations and
resulting detriment to the claimant in
the same way as claims based on
promissory estoppel.”
(Emphasis supplied)
70. The principle laid down in the
aforesaid decision applies to the present
case as well. The State’s own policy decision
and subsequent undertakings before the
High Court constituted clear representations
that the cases of the left-out workers would
be duly considered. The State could not
thereafter retract from its earlier position in
a selective or inconsistent manner.
71.Even otherwise, as correctly
observed by the learned Single Judge, there
was no requirement for the State to seek
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
permission of the Court to implement its
own policy decision. The Full Bench in
Jitendra Kalita (supra) had itself observed
that any solution to the issue of
regularization must be undertaken by the
State as a policy measure. Regularization,
where permissible in law, is an executive
function. It falls within the domain of policy
and administration. Courts do not grant
prior approval to executive decisions. The
role of the Court is confined to judicial
review, that is, to examine whether a policy
or action is constitutionally valid, fair and
reasonable. It is not for the Court to
authorise the executive to exercise powers
which already vest in it.
72. We find merit in the observation
of the learned Single Judge that seeking
permission in the manner done by the State
amounted, in effect, to a surrender of its
executive authority. The executive cannot
abdicate its responsibility by placing the
burden upon the Court to approve or
disapprove the implementation of its own
policy. Once a Cabinet decision had been
taken and implemented in major
proportions, and once undertakings had
been given before a constitutional Court, the
State was expected to act in furtherance of
its intent expressly declared in the policy,
subject of course to constitutional confines.
The course adopted by the State, in the
facts of the present case, was neither
necessary nor justified.
73. As regards the contention of Shri
Gupta that after the decision in Umadevi
(supra) no regularization can be effected in
respect of employees who were not
appointed against duly sanctioned posts, we
are unable to accept such a sweeping
proposition in the facts of the present case.
The submission proceeds on the premise
that Umadevi (supra) lays down an absolute
and inflexible embargo against all forms of
regularization irrespective of the
surrounding circumstances. Such an
interpretation, in our considered view, does
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
not reflect the true scope and ratio of the
decision.
74.This Court in Jaggo (supra),
deprecated the tendency of the State to take
mechanical shelter under Umadevi (supra)
to deny relief to employees who had been
performing work of a permanent and
essential nature for long years. This Court
observed as follows:—
“12. Despite being labelled as
“part-time workers,” the appellants
performed these essential tasks on a
daily and continuous basis over
extensive periods, ranging from over a
decade to nearly two decades. Their
engagement was not sporadic or
temporary in nature; instead, it
was recurrent, regular, and akin to
the responsibilities typically
associated with sanctioned posts.
Moreover, the respondents did not
engage any other personnel for
these tasks during the appellants'
tenure, underscoring the
indispensable nature of their work.
13. The claim by the
respondents that these were not
regular posts lacks merit, as the
nature of the work performed by
the appellants was perennial and
fundamental to the functioning of
the offices. The recurring nature of
these duties necessitates their
classification as regular posts,
irrespective of how their initial
engagements were labelled. It is
also noteworthy that subsequent
outsourcing of these same tasks to
private agencies after the appellants’
termination demonstrates the inherent
need for these services. This act of
outsourcing, which effectively replaced
one set of workers with another,
further underscores that the work in
question was neither temporary nor
occasional.
19. It is evident from the
foregoing that the appellants' roles
were not only essential but also
indistinguishable from those of
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
regular employees. Their sustained
contributions over extended
periods, coupled with absence of
any adverse record, warrant
equitable treatment and
regularization of their services.
Denial of this benefit, followed by their
arbitrary termination, amounts to
manifest injustice and must be
rectified.
20. It is well established
that the decision in Uma Devi
(supra) does not intend to penalize
employees who have rendered long
years of service fulfilling ongoing
and necessary functions of the
State or its instrumentalities. The
said judgment sought to prevent
backdoor entries and illegal
appointments that circumvent
constitutional requirements.
However, where appointments
were not illegal but possibly
“irregular,” and where employees
had served continuously against
the backdrop of sanctioned
functions for a considerable period,
the need for a fair and humane
resolution becomes paramount.
Prolonged, continuous, and
unblemished service performing
tasks inherently required on a
regular basis can, over the time,
transform what was initially ad-
hoc or temporary into a scenario
demanding fair regularization . In a
recent judgment of this Court in Vinod
Kumar v. Union of India , it was held
that held that procedural formalities
cannot be used to deny regularization
of service to an employee whose
appointment was termed “temporary”
but has performed the same duties as
performed by the regular employee
over a considerable period in the
capacity of the regular employee.
22. The pervasive misuse of
temporary employment contracts,
as exemplified in this case, reflects
a broader systemic issue that
adversely affects workers' rights
and job security. In the private
sector, the rise of the gig economy has
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
led to an increase in precarious
employment arrangements, often
characterized by lack of benefits, job
security, and fair treatment. Such
practices have been criticized for
exploiting workers and undermining
labour standards. Government
institutions, entrusted with upholding
the principles of fairness and justice,
bear an even greater responsibility to
avoid such exploitative employment
practices. When public sector
entities engage in misuse of
temporary contracts, it not only
mirrors the detrimental trends
observed in the gig economy but
also sets a concerning precedent
that can erode public trust in
governmental operations.
25. It is a disconcerting reality
that temporary employees, particularly
in government institutions, often face
multifaceted forms of exploitation.
While the foundational purpose of
temporary contracts may have been to
address short-term or seasonal needs,
they have increasingly become a
mechanism to evade long-term
obligations owed to employees. These
practices manifest in several ways:
• Misuse of “Temporary”
Labels : Employees engaged for work
that is essential, recurring, and integral
to the functioning of an institution are
often labeled as “temporary” or
“contractual,” even when their roles
mirror those of regular employees.
Such misclassification deprives workers
of the dignity, security, and benefits
that regular employees are entitled to,
despite performing identical tasks.
• Arbitrary Termination:
Temporary employees are frequently
dismissed without cause or notice, as
seen in the present case. This practice
undermines the principles of natural
justice and subjects workers to a state
of constant insecurity, regardless of
the quality or duration of their service.
• Lack of Career
Progression : Temporary employees
- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
often find themselves excluded from
opportunities for skill development,
promotions, or incremental pay raises.
They remain stagnant in their roles,
creating a systemic disparity between
them and their regular counterparts,
despite their contributions being
equally significant.
• Using Outsourcing as a
Shield: Institutions increasingly resort
to outsourcing roles performed by
temporary employees, effectively
replacing one set of exploited workers
with another. This practice not only
perpetuates exploitation but also
demonstrates a deliberate effort to
bypass the obligation to offer regular
employment.
• Denial of Basic Rights and
Benefits : Temporary employees are
often denied fundamental benefits such
as pension, provident fund, health
insurance, and paid leave, even when
their tenure spans decades. This lack
of social security subjects them and
their families to undue hardship,
especially in cases of illness,
retirement, or unforeseen
circumstances.
26. While the judgment in
Uma Devi (supra) sought to curtail
the practice of backdoor entries
and ensure appointments adhered
to constitutional principles, it is
regrettable that its principles are
often misinterpreted or misapplied
to deny legitimate claims of long-
serving employees. This judgment
aimed to distinguish between
“illegal” and “irregular”
appointments. It categorically held
that employees in irregular
appointments, who were engaged
in duly sanctioned posts and had
served continuously for more than
ten years, should be considered for
regularization as a one-time
measure. However, the laudable
intent of the judgment is being
subverted when institutions rely
on its dicta to indiscriminately
reject the claims of employees,
- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
even in cases where their
appointments are not illegal, but
merely lack adherence to
procedural formalities.
Government departments often
cite the judgment in Uma Devi
(supra) to argue that no vested
right to regularization exists for
temporary employees, overlooking
the judgment's explicit
acknowledgment of cases where
regularization is appropriate. This
selective application distorts the
judgment's spirit and purpose,
effectively weaponizing it against
employees who have rendered
indispensable services over
decades.
27. In light of these
considerations, in our opinion, it is
imperative for government
departments to lead by example in
providing fair and stable employment.
Engaging workers on a temporary
basis for extended periods,
especially when their roles are
integral to the organization's
functioning, not only contravenes
international labour standards but
also exposes the organization to
legal challenges and undermines
employee morale. By ensuring fair
employment practices, government
institutions can reduce the burden
of unnecessary litigation, promote
job security, and uphold the
principles of justice and fairness
that they are meant to embody.
This approach aligns with
international standards and sets a
positive precedent for the private
sector to follow, thereby
contributing to the overall
betterment of labour practices in
the country. ”
(Emphasis supplied)
75. Recently, this Court in Bhola Nath
(supra) while relying on the judgment of Jaggo
(supra), Shripal (supra), and Dharam Singh
(supra) observed as follows:—
“13.6. This Court has, on
several occasions, deprecated the
- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
practice adopted by States of engaging
employees under the nominal labels of
“part-time”, “contractual” or
“temporary” in perpetuity and thereby
exploiting them by not regularizing
their positions. In Jaggo v. Union of
India , this Court underscored that
government departments must
lead by example in ensuring fair
and stable employment, and
evolved the test of examining
whether the duties performed by
such temporary employees are
integral to the day-to-day
functioning of the organization.
13.7 In Shripal v. Nagar
Nigam , and Vinod Kumar v. Union of
India , this Court cautioned against a
mechanical and blind reliance on
Umadevi (supra) to deny regularization
to temporary employees in the absence
of statutory rules. It was held that
Umadevi (supra) cannot be
employed as a shield to legitimise
exploitative engagements
continued for years without
undertaking regular recruitment .
The Court further clarified that
Umadevi itself draws a distinction
between appointments that are
“illegal” and those that are merely
“irregular”, the latter being amenable
to regularization upon fulfilment of the
prescribed conditions.
13.8. In Dharam Singh v. State
of U.P. , this Court strongly deprecated
the culture of “ad-hocism” adopted by
States in their capacity as employers.
The Court criticised the practice of
outsourcing or informalizing
recruitment as a means to evade
regular employment obligations,
observing that such measures
perpetuate precarious working
conditions while circumventing fair
and lawful engagement practices.
13.9. The State must remain
conscious that part-time
employees, such as the appellants,
constitute an integral part of the
edifice upon which the machinery
of the State continues to function.
- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
They are not merely ancillary to
the system, but form essential
components thereof. The equality
mandate of our Constitution,
therefore, requires that their
service be reciprocated in a
manner free from arbitrariness,
ensuring that decisions of the
State affecting the careers and
livelihood of such part-time and
contractual employees are guided
by fairness and reason .”
(Emphasis supplied)
76.What emerges from the principles
enunciated in the aforesaid decisions is that
the State cannot rely upon the mere form of
engagement to deny fair and equitable
treatment to employees who have served it
for long years. The consistent thread
running through these judgments is that
Umadevi (supra) cannot be invoked as a
blanket barrier to justify prolonged and
continued engagements of a temporary or
ad hoc nature, especially where the
employees have been discharging essential
and recurring functions of the State. The
Court has repeatedly emphasised that the
distinction between “illegal” and “irregular”
appointments must be kept in view, that
long and continuous service is a relevant
consideration, and that the State, as a
model employer, is under a constitutional
obligation to act with fairness, consistency
and reasonableness. The practice of
retaining employees for decades under
deceptively titled designations, while
simultaneously extracting regular work
integral to the administration, has been
disapproved consistently.
77.Applying these principles to the
present case, it is evident that engaging
workers on muster rolls was a consistently
employed policy of the State which
continued for prolonged period of time. The
appellants were not engaged for sporadic or
seasonal purposes but were taken on
muster rolls and have rendered continuous
service for decades in departments
- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
performing regular governmental functions.
The State itself acknowledged the
magnitude of the issue and framed a
Cabinet policy to regularize similarly
situated workers, acting upon it in respect
of nearly 30,000 employees. In such
circumstances, to deny consideration to the
fraction of remaining eligible workers
including the appellants, by taking shelter
under a rigid reading of Umadevi (supra)
would defeat the very principles of fairness
and non-arbitrariness that this Court has
consistently upheld.
78. In the aforesaid backdrop, we are
unable to accept the contention of the State
that the appellants cannot be granted
regularization on the ground that they were
not initially appointed against duly
sanctioned posts. The State, having engaged
st
the appellants prior to 1 April, 1993,
utilised their services continuously for
decades, and having itself framed and
implemented a Cabinet policy regularizing
nearly 30,000 similarly situated workers,
cannot now exclude the appellants by taking
shelter behind a rigid or technical reading of
Umadevi (supra). In absence of any cogent
distinction or reasoned decision justifying
such exclusion, the action of the State is
manifestly arbitrary. It is inconsistent with
its obligation to function as a model
employer and does not withstand scrutiny
under Article 14 of the Constitution.”
The said judgment was rendered on 21-05-2026.
9.8. Subsequent to the said judgment, the Apex
Court, again, in the case of BHIKHANI DEVI v. UNION
OF INDIA [2026 SCC OnLine SC 1055] , while
considering whether a temporary status casual labourer
would be entitled to pensionary benefits on
superannuation in the absence of a formal order of
regularization, observes as follows:
“…. …. ….
32. Having heard the counsel for both the
parties and on perusal of pleadings and material
- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
on record, the issue that arises for
consideration can be carved out as follows:
‘Whether temporary status casual
labourer, in the absence of a formal order of
regularisation, would be entitled to
pensionary benefits on superannuation or
not?’
33. Before adverting to the above
question and interpreting the Scheme involved in
the present factual matrix, we find it apposite to
delineate the legal framework governing the
rights of casual and temporary employees. This
Court has over the years developed jurisprudence
concerning rights of casual labourers and
temporary employees which needs to be
adverted to.
34.In Jagrit Mazdoor Union (supra),
this Court held that upon conferment of
temporary status and completion of three
years of continuous service, casual
labourers are to be treated at par with
Group ‘D’ employees and would thereby be
entitled to such benefits admissible to
regular employees. The Court observed that
there could be no justification in
withholding benefits from such employees
and emphasised the obligation of the State,
as a model employer, to act in consonance
with the Directive Principles of State Policy
as provided in the Constitution of India.
35.Further, in Vinod Kumar (supra),
this Court recognised that where employees
have rendered continuous service,
performing duties indistinguishable from
those discharged by regular employees, the
distinction between temporary and
permanent employment becomes
substantively illusory and the failure to
recognise the true nature of such service
would be contrary to the principles of equity
and fairness.
36.In Jaggo (supra), this Court
reiterated that employees labelled as
temporary or part-time, but who have in
fact rendered continuous and essential
- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
service over long periods, cannot be denied
benefits available to regular employees
merely on account of nomenclature. The
Court held that such engagement is neither
sporadic nor casual, but is in the nature of
regular employment, thereby necessitating
extension of all corresponding service
benefits.
37.In this context, the principle laid
down by this Court in Yashwant Hari
Katakkar v. Union of India 6 also assumes
significance, wherein this Court held that
where an employee has rendered long years
of service and there is no justifiable reason
for not conferring permanent status, it
would be a travesty of justice to deny
pensionary benefits merely on the ground of
absence of formal regularisation, and such
an employee is liable to be treated as having
attained permanent status.
38. Perusal of the above decisions of
this Court establish a consistent judicial
approach that long-serving employees,
whether casual or temporary, particularly
those who have been conferred a
recognised status and extended benefits
akin to regular employees, cannot be denied
corresponding benefits including social
security and pensionary benefits. The
emphasis must be on ensuring that the
State does not retain such employees in a
precarious condition while extracting
services identical to those performed by
regular employees.
39.This approach is firmly rooted in
the constitutional mandate of equality
enshrined under Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. Any classification,
resulting in denial of any benefits to a class
of employees who are otherwise similarly
situated in terms of duties and
responsibilities would fall foul of
constitutional ethos.Further, the Directive
Principles of State Policy, particularly
Articles 38, 39 and 43, cast a positive
obligation upon the State to ensure social
and economic justice, fair conditions of
- 41 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
work, and a decent standard of life for
labourers. Pension, in this context, is not a
gratuitous benefit but a facet of social
welfare and economic justice.
40. The concept of the State as a
model employer, read in conjunction with
the aforesaid constitutional mandate,
reinforces the obligation upon the State to
extend fair and equitable treatment to
employees who have rendered long and
continuous service and that the State
cannot extract services of a permanent
nature while denying corresponding
benefits.
41. At this stage, it is also necessary
to note that pension is not a bounty but a
vested and enforceable constitutional right.
This Court in State of Jharkhand v. Jitendra
Kumar Srivastava 7 has categorically held
that pension is a hard-earned benefit
amassed by an employee by virtue of long
and continuous service and is in the nature
of “property” within the meaning of Article
300A of the Constitution of India.
42. Once pension is recognised as a
constitutional right in the nature of
property, it cannot be taken away except by
authority of law. A statutory right cannot be
rendered illusory on account of inaction of
the employer, and such inaction cannot
defeat or deny a constitutional right. It is in
the light of this above discussed judicial
approach of this Court over a period of time,
the provisions of the Scheme and the
subsequent applicable circulars must be
read, understood and interpreted.
43. Let us, now, turn to the Scheme that
is applicable to the facts of the present case. The
principles emanating from Jagrit Mazdoor
Union (supra), as discussed hereinabove,
are directly incorporated in formation of the
said Scheme. The relevant portion of the
decision is reproduced herein:
“… After rendering three
years of continuous service with
- 42 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
temporary status, the casual
labourers shall be treated at par
with temporary Grade ‘D’
employees of the Department of
Posts and would thereby be
entitled to such benefits as are
admissible to Group ‘D’ employees
on regular basis. ”
( emphasis supplied )
…. …. ….
55. It may be noted here that the
Respondents contend that temporary status
casual labourers are extended only the benefits
that are specified in the Scheme and Circular
dated 30.11.1992 and are not entitled for
pensionary benefits. The said submission, in our
considered opinion, is misconceived. The
expression “ benefits admissible to
temporary Group ‘D’ employees such as ”,
made use of in the circular is of
considerable importance. The utilisation of
the words “such as” clearly indicates that
the benefits enumerated therein are
illustrative and neither restrictive nor
exhaustive. This is also evident from the
observations in Jagrit Mazdoor Union
(supra), which form basis of the Scheme
and Circular dated 30.11.1992, and provides
to extend all benefits as admissible to
temporary Group ‘D’ employees without any
restrictions.Therefore, the circular, as
earlier observed, being a beneficial
legislation, cannot be read and understood
in a restrictive manner rather the correct
approach of interpretation would be to
analyse it in the letter and spirit of the
legislative and administrative intent i.e. to
extend all benefits as are available to
temporary Group ‘D’ employees, to
temporary status casual labourers including
pensionary benefits.
56. Before proceeding further, it becomes
necessary to deal with another contention
advanced on behalf of the Respondents that
Clause 6 of the Scheme contemplates counting of
50% service rendered under temporary status
towards retirement benefits only after formal
regularisation as Group ‘D’ employee and,
- 43 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
therefore, in the absence of regularisation, no
pensionary benefits can be granted. The said
submission cannot be accepted in the manner
sought to be canvassed. Clause 6 cannot be read
in isolation divorced from the principles and
purpose underlying the Scheme and the circular
dated 30.11.1992. The judgment of this Court
in Jagrit Mazdoor Union (supra), which
forms the basis of the Scheme itself,
categorically directed that upon completion
of three years of continuous service under
temporary status, casual labourers ‘would
thereby be entitled to benefits as are
admissible to Group ‘D’ employees on
regular basis’. The circular dated
30.11.1992 further clarifies that such
employees would be entitled to counting of
service for pension and terminal benefits as
admissible to temporary Group ‘D’
employees.
57.The expression “after
regularisation” occurring in Clause 6 cannot
be construed in a narrow or restrictive
manner so as to defeat the beneficial object
underlying the Scheme and must be
construed in its proper context. Clause 6 does
not create the pensionary entitlement itself,
rather, it provides an additional benefit by
directing that half of the service rendered under
temporary status to be counted towards grant of
retirement benefits upon regularisation. The
pensionary entitlement of temporary status
employees who have completed the prescribed
period of service flows independently from the
Scheme and the circular dated 30.11.1992.
Clause 6 has to be interpreted harmoniously and
would construe to mean that in cases where
formal orders of regularisation are passed, 50%
of the service rendered under temporary status
would be liable to be counted towards retirement
and pensionary benefits as additional benefit
apart from the benefits as available under the
rules which become applicable to a regular
government employee. Consequently, while
Clause 6 may operate to confer an additional
advantage in cases where regularisation takes
place, the absence of formal regularisation
cannot be construed as extinguishing or
- 44 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
defeating the underlying entitlement to
pensionary benefits.
58. At this stage, it also becomes
necessary to appreciate the distinction between
different categories of employees engaged within
the service framework in the Department of
Posts. Broadly, four categories of employees
emerge from the statutory and administrative
work structure involved in the matter at hand,
namely: (i) casual labourers; (ii) temporary
status casual labourers; (iii) temporary
Government employees; and (iv) regular
Government employees.
59. A casual labourer is merely a daily-
rated worker engaged on need basis and is
entitled only to daily wages for the period during
which work is performed. Such employee does
not possess any structured service status nor
entitled to any service benefits ordinarily
available to Government employees.
60. The second category is that of a
temporary status casual labourer. The
conferment of temporary status not only initiates
the process of integration of such employee
within a structured service framework but
extends certain service protections and benefits
under the Scheme. Nevertheless, such employee
remains a temporary status casual labourer and
does not become a temporary Government
servant.
61. The third category is that of
temporary Government employees which are
governed by the CCS (Temporary Service) Rules,
1965, while the fourth category comprises of
regular Government employees governed by the
regular service rules applicable to permanent
Government servants.
62. It is to be noted that these aforesaid
four categories are not to be conflated as stages
required to be gone through to become a regular
employee. It may be pointed here that a casual
labourer can directly become a regular employee,
if the Scheme provides for such transition. A
temporary Government employee, however,
definitely has two stages leading to permanent
- 45 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
employment i.e. initial appointment as temporary
Government employee and upon confirmation in
service, his status is changed to regular
government employee.
63. For casual labourers, the Scheme
provides for a progression to regular
employment. Initially the employee enters
service as a casual labourer. Thereafter, upon
satisfying the conditions prescribed under Clause
1 of the Scheme, he/she is conferred temporary
status and continues under such status. Upon
completion of the prescribed conditions and
subject to the applicable Recruitment Rules, the
employee becomes eligible for regularisation
against Group ‘D’ posts and ultimately
regularized and appointed as regular employee
on availability of vacancies.
64. The Scheme, in question, which
provides for grant of temporary status and
regularisation for casual labourers recognises
four categories of employees operating within the
service structure, however, the progression
contemplated therein essentially unfolds in three
stages i.e. engagement as a casual labourer,
conferment and continuance of temporary status,
and eventual regularisation against Group ‘D’
posts.
65. It is apposite to highlight and
emphasize that although under the Scheme
the temporary status of casual labourers
continues till his regularization in service,
however, on completion of the period of
three years, the service conditions are
materially changed as he is treated at par
with temporary Group ‘D’ employees and
extended all benefits that are admissible to
such employees.
66. The submission advanced on behalf of
the Respondents, that under the Scheme the
employees continue merely as temporary status
casual labourers and are distinct from the
temporary Government servants, and so would
be the pensionary framework applicable. At first
blush, this contention appears to be correct to an
extent. However, on due consideration and
deliberation of the Scheme and its various
- 46 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
clauses as a whole, the submission aforesaid is
found to be misplaced.
67.Although, it may be correct to say
that conferment of temporary status on a
casual labourer under the Scheme does not
ipso facto transform such employee into a
temporary Government servant, however,
what falls short from the aforesaid
submission is that while the status of such
employee continues unchanged i.e., of a
‘temporary status casual labourers’, the
Scheme consciously and specifically extends
to such employees benefits admissible to
temporary Group ‘D’ employees upon
completion of three years of continuous
service under temporary status. The service
conditions, at this juncture, of the casual
temporary status employee under the
Scheme gets substantially changed and
carries all the benefits that are available to
temporary government employees.
Therefore, while the nomenclature and
category of their service status remain
unchanged, the nature and extent of
benefits now available to them stand
significantly enlarged and aligned with
those admissible to temporary Government
employees, blurring the distinction between
both categories as far as benefits available
to them are concerned. The distinction that
remains is one relating to nomenclature,
formal status and mode of regularisation
but not to the nature of extended benefits.
68. In other words, the Scheme
nowhere provides that upon completion of
three years' service under temporary status,
the employee becomes a temporary
Government servant. What it specifically
provides is that such employee shall be
treated at par with temporary Group ‘D’
employees for purposes of extension of
admissible benefits. The parity
contemplated under the Scheme is thus
parity in service benefits and not identity of
service status.
69.Once the Scheme and the circular
dated 30.11.1992 consciously extend
- 47 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
benefits admissible to temporary Group ‘D’
employees, the Respondents cannot rely
solely upon the nomenclature of ‘temporary
status casual labourer’ to deny those very
benefits. The entire framework of the
Scheme proceeds upon extension of
substantive service benefits despite
continuance of the original nomenclature as
temporary status casual labourer.
70. As already discussed hereinabove, the
Scheme and the circular dated 30.11.1992
extend to temporary status employees all the
benefits that are available to temporary Group ‘D’
employees. Now, it becomes necessary to
examine the nature of pensionary benefits
available to such temporary Government
employees under the statutory framework.
71. The services of the temporary
Government servants are governed by the CCS
(Temporary Service) Rules, 1965. It is not
disputed that a temporary Government servant is
entitled to terminal benefits including pension
and on his death family pension. Rule 10(1-B) of
the said Rules specifically provides that where a
temporary Government servant retires on
attaining the age of superannuation after
rendering temporary service of not less than ten
years, such employee shall be entitled to
superannuation pension and retirement gratuity
and on death family pension in accordance with
the provisions of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
Rule 10(1-B) is reproduced herein:
“ 10. Terminal gratuity
payable to temporary Government
servants.
xxx xxx xxx
(1-B) In the case of a
temporary Government servant who
retires from service on attaining the
age of superannuation or on his being
declared to be permanently
incapacitated for further Government
service by the appropriate medical
authority, after he has rendered
temporary service of not less than 10
years or who has sought voluntary
retirement by giving three months'
- 48 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
notice in writing on completion of 20
years' service, provisions of sub-rule
(1) shall not apply and in accordance
with the provisions of the Central Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1972-
(i) such a Government servant
shall be eligible for the grant of
superannuation, invalid or retiring
pension, as the case may be, and
retirement gratuity; and
(ii) in the event of his death
after retirement, the members of his
family shall be eligible for the grant of
family pension.
xxx xxx xxx”
72. As is apparent from the above,
the statutory framework governing
temporary Government employees itself
accepts and acknowledges entitlement of
pensionary benefits and that the same are
not confined only to regular permanent
employees but are also available to
temporary Government servants upon
completion of the prescribed qualifying
service. The CCS (Temporary Service) Rules,
1965 thus constitute the statutory source
recognising pensionary entitlement of
temporary employees who have rendered
specified and continuous service.
73.The contention of the Respondents
that the Appellants were paid out of
contingencies and therefore stood excluded
from the purview of the CCS (Temporary
Service) Rules, 1965 also cannot be
accepted in the particular facts of the
present case. Such exclusion may have
relevance at the stage of initial engagement
as casual labourers. However, the service
conditions of the Appellants underwent a
substantial transformation upon extension
of benefits admissible to temporary Group
‘D’ employees. The continued reliance by
the Respondents upon the original mode of
engagement, while simultaneously
extending pay parity, increments, GPF
facilities, leave benefits and other service
entitlements akin to temporary Group ‘D’
- 49 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
employees, would amount to selectively
accepting one part of the Scheme while
disregarding the other. Such an approach
would defeat the very object underlying the
Scheme and the circular dated 30.11.1992.
Once parity in service benefits with
temporary Group ‘D’ employees is
consciously extended under the Scheme,
pensionary benefits flowing under Rule
10(1-B) of the Rules of 1965 cannot be
selectively denied by ignoring or
overlooking the statutory right.
74.The argument founded upon
financial burden is equally untenable.
Pension is not a matter of grace dependent
upon the financial convenience of the
employer, but a deferred wage earned
through long years of service. As already
noticed hereinabove, this Court has
recognised pension as a constitutional right
in the nature of property protected under
Article 300A of the Constitution of India as
held in Jitendra Kumar Srivastava Case
(supra) and it, therefore, cannot be denied
on the plea of financial burden.
75.From the above discussion what
follows is that when the statutory
framework including CCS (Temporary
Service) Rules, 1965 is read in conjunction
with the Scheme and the circular dated
30.11.1992, the inescapable conclusion
which emerges is that a casual labour, on
being conferred the temporary status, upon
completion of three years of continuous
service as temporary status casual labourer
becomes entitled to benefits admissible to
temporary Group ‘D’ employees, which
necessarily includes pensionary benefits
available under Rule 10(1-B) of the CCS
(Temporary Service) Rules, 1965 subject, of
course, to fulfilling the eligibility criteria
provided therein. This right is not dependent
on regularisation. What is conceived is
conferring of additional benefit of previous
service under the Scheme as would be
available to an employee on regularisation
apart from the benefits conferred under the
- 50 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
rules becoming applicable on this now
acquired new status of a regular employee.
76. The question as framed in para 32
above stands answered as follows:
‘A temporary status casual labourer
would be entitled to pensionary benefits on
superannuation even in the absence of
regularisation.’
77. What remains to be seen now is
whether the Appellants, in the cases before us,
fulfil the eligibility criteria under Rule 10 (1-B) of
CCS (Temporary Service) Rules, 1965 so as to be
entitled for pensionary benefits.
78. The service trajectory of Late Suraj
Sah as per the material placed on record, thus
falls into three distinct phases: (i) service as a
casual labourer from 1972 till 29.11.1989; (ii)
service as a temporary status casual labourer
from 29.11.1989 till 30.11.1992; and (iii)
continuance as a temporary status casual
labourer with entitlement to benefits admissible
to temporary Group ‘D’ employees from
30.11.1992 till his superannuation on
31.12.2008.
79. From the above what emerges is
that Late Suraj Sah was initially engaged as
a casual labourer in the year 1972 and
continued as such till 29.11.1989. During
this period, he remained a daily-rated
worker and was not entitled to any service
benefits. Upon introduction of the Scheme,
he was conferred temporary status with
effect from 29.11.1989. Thereafter, upon
completion of three years of continuous
service under temporary status on
30.11.1992, though his formal status
continued to remain that of a temporary
status casual labourer, he became entitled
to the benefits admissible to temporary
Group ‘D’ employees. Thus, while his
nomenclature remained unchanged, his
service benefits thereafter stood aligned
with those admissible to temporary Group
‘D’ employees as per the Scheme and the
circular dated 30.11.1992. He ultimately
superannuated on 31.12.2008 while
continuing as a temporary status casual
- 51 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
labourer. So from 30.11.1992 till the date of
superannuation i.e. 31.12.2008, the period
being more than the minimum of 10 years,
he became entitled for benefits under Rule
10(1-B) of the CCS (Temporary Service)
Rules, 1965 read with the CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1972. Thereby making him entitled to
grant of superannuation pension and other
retirement benefits as admissible under the
above rules.
80. The service records of Bahuru
Sahu and Pitamber Jha would also reflect
that they were, after initial appointment as
casual labourers, conferred temporary
status, w.e.f. 29.11.1989 till 30.11.1992 and
continued as temporary status casual
labourers till their date of superannuation
30.04.2008 and 31.10.2015 respectively.
The period being in excess of minimum
qualifying service of ten years for
entitlement of pension, they would be
entitled to grant of all retiral benefits as
available under the Rules.
81.Insofar as the contention of the
Respondents with regard to delay and
laches is concerned, it is well settled that
pensionary benefits constitute a continuing
cause of action, and a claim for pension
cannot be defeated solely on the ground of
delay. At the same time, the claim for
arrears is required to be balanced with
settled principles governing limitation. In
the present case, nothing has been brought
on record to indicate that the Appellants had
raised any claim for pensionary benefits
prior to filing of the respective Original
Applications before the Tribunal. In such
circumstances, while the entitlement of the
Appellants to pensionary and consequential
retiral benefits stands established, the
arrears thereof, wherever applicable, shall
remain confined to the period of three years
and two months preceding the date of filing
of the respective Original Applications
before the Tribunal, consistent with settled
principles governing service jurisprudence. ”
(Emphasis supplied at each instance)
- 52 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
10. In AMARENDRA KUMARMOHAPATRA
supra, the Apex Court undertook a detailed reconciliation
of UMADEVI with STATE OF KARNATAKA vs.
M.L.KESARI reported in (2010) 9 SCC 247 , elucidating
why regularization must necessarily follow once an
employee has completed 10 years of service while being
otherwise qualified.
11. The first discernable departure from the
rigid contours of UMADEVI was in the case of SHEO
NARAIN NAGAR, supra, where the Apex Court
lamented that UMADEVI was being wielded as a
convenient instrument to perpetuate injustice, by
continuing employees in service without
regularization and in some cases, even without
payment of lawful wages. Noting that the appellants
therein had been in service since 1993 and had
completed 10 years well prior to UMADEVI , the Court
held that denial of regularization would be wholly
unjustified. This exposition was further amplified in
NARENDRA KUMAR TIWARI supra , where the Apex
Court cautioned that the pernicious practice of
indefinitely continuing employees appointed
through irregular means if allowed to persist, would
subvert the very intent of the Constitution Bench in
UMADEVI. The Court observed that where
employees had rendered 10 years of continuous
service to the State of Jharkhand, they observed
regularization barring the existence of any valid
impediment such as misconduct or lack of
eligibility. The reasoning finds further affirmation in the
case of PREM SINGH supra.
12. The Apex Court carried forward the
jurisprudence in CHANDER MOHAN NEGI supra ,
wherein the Apex Court was dealing with the case of
teachers, exhorted the State forthwith to frame an
appropriate policy for regularization.
13. Thereafter, in JAGGO supra, the Apex
Court after an exhaustive consideration of rival
submissions, holds that the employees who had
rendered uninterrupted service extended far
beyond a decade, could not be nonchalantly
discarded by the facile label of ‘part time’ or
- 53 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
‘contractual’. The Apex Court underscored that the
true essence of employment lies in the sustained
contribution rendered, the integral nature of work
performed and the absence of allegation that the
entry was tainted by illegality or subterfuge. The
Apex Court requesting plight of employees who had
toiled for a decade or two, without career
progression or equal remuneration holding that
such treatment amounted to denial of basic human
right and a perpetuation of exploitation of human
labour. The culmination of this judicial evaluation is
reflected in SHRIPAL supra, where the Apex Court after
surveying the entire spectrum of law, unequivocally
holds that the UMADEVI cannot be pressed into
service as a shield to justify exploitative
engagements continuing for years without the
employer undertaking lawful recruitment.
Consequently, the regularization was directed for
employees who had completed 10 years of service.
14. The line of reasoning attained further
crystallization in DHARAM SINGH supra, rendered in
August 2025 wherein, the Apex Court holds that the
appellants who had already retired were
nevertheless entitled to regularization with effect
from the date on which they completed 10 years of
service. The Apex Court further directed re-
calculation and disbursement of pension, gratuity
and other terminal benefits within three months
from the date of the said judgment. Significantly,
even in respect of the deceased appellants, the
Apex Court held where death occurred during the
pendency of the claim of regularization, the legal
heirs would be entitled to arrears of terminal
benefits, in accordance with law.
15. What unmistakably emerges from the
afore-quoted pronouncements is that the
employees regardless of the nomenclature attached
to their engagement, whether temporary,
contractual or daily wage or even on consolidated
pay, once they have completed 10 years of service
and were otherwise qualified to hold the post, are
entitled to consideration for regularization. Any
denial thereof would reduce the appointment to an
exploitative engagement. The Apex Court has further
- 54 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
cautioned that replacement of one set of temporary or
contractual employees with another similarly placed set,
would offend even the ratio of UMADEVI itself. As such,
the conduct on the part of the State, cannot be
countenanced.
16. In so far as the retired employees are
concerned, the Apex Court has authoritatively held
that retirement during the pendency of the claim
for regularization does not extinguish such claim.
The submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the
appellant, merits acceptance as the petitioner in the
present case retired while her claim for
regularization subsisted and during the pendency of
the writ petition, the right to consideration does not
evaporate on attainment of age of superannuation.
The Apex Court has gone a step further to hold that even
in cases of deceased employees who asserted their claim
for regularization during their lifetime and whose claim
remained pending either before the State or before this
Court or competent Judicial Fora , such claims must still
be examined and granted, if otherwise permissible.
17. In the case of SUKHENDU BHATTACHARJEE,
the Apex Court considers the interplay between the
Constitution Bench judgment in UMADEVI , the exception
carved out in paragraph 53 thereof, and the constitutional
guarantee of equality under Article 14. The controversy
arose when nearly 30,000 work-charged and muster-roll
employees were regularized pursuant to a policy decision
of the State, while several identically situated employees
were excluded owing to administrative lapses and clerical
omissions.
17.1. The Apex Court holds that UMADEVI cannot
be construed as imposing an absolute and inflexible
embargo upon regularization in every conceivable
circumstance. The object of UMADEVI was to prevent
illegal appointments and backdoor entries into public
employment, and not to furnish the State with a
convenient shield to perpetuate arbitrary treatment of
employees who had rendered long and continuous
service.
- 55 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
17.2 The Apex Court draws a distinction between a
claim founded upon the one-time exception under
paragraph 53 of UMADEVI and a claim founded upon
equal treatment under an existing policy of regularization.
Where the State has consciously regularized one class of
employees, it cannot arbitrarily exclude other employees
who are identically situated in the matter of appointment,
nature of duties, length of service and eligibility. Such
selective regularization would fall foul of Article 14.
17.3. The Apex Court further emphasizes that the
State, as a model employer, cannot extract labour for
decades, hold out assurances of regularization and
thereafter invoke technicalities to defeat the legitimate
expectations of its employees.
18. In BHIKHANI DEVI, the Apex Court considers
whether a casual labourer who had been conferred
temporary status and had subsequently attained
superannuation without formal regularization could be
denied pensionary and retiral benefits. Tracing the
development of service jurisprudence through JAGRIT
MAZDOOR UNION (REGD.) v. MAHANAGAR
TELEPHONE NIGAM LTD. reported in 1990 Supp SCC
113 ; VINOD KUMAR v. UNION OF INDIA reported in
(2024) 9 SCC 327; JAGGO supra and YASHWANT
HARI KATAKKAR v. UNION OF INDIA reported in
(1996) 7 SCC 113 , the Apex Court holds that the
nomenclature attached to an employee's engagement
cannot, by itself, determine the substantive benefits to
which such employee is entitled. The Apex Court observes
that pension is neither a bounty nor an act of
governmental generosity. It is a hard-earned benefit
flowing from qualifying service and, where legally
accrued, constitutes property protected under Article
300A of the Constitution of India.
19. On a conspectus of the law declared by the
Apex Court in the afore-quoted judgments, what
would unmistakably emerge is that the
nomenclature attached to an employee's
engagement, be it temporary, contractual, daily-
wage or on consolidated pay, cannot, by itself,
become the determinative factor in considering the
claim for regularization. Where an employee,
- 56 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
otherwise qualified to hold the post, has rendered
ten years or more of continuous service against a
duly sanctioned vacancy, without the protective
umbrella of orders of Courts or Tribunals, the claim
for regularization warrants consideration within the
parameters delineated in UMADEVI and its
subsequent exposition. The constitutional
philosophy underlying these judgments is that the
State cannot, on the one hand, extract the labour of
an employee for decades together, discharging
duties which are perennial and integral to its
functioning, and, on the other, deny even
consideration of regularization by taking refuge
under the nomenclature of the engagement. The
State cannot have the benefit of permanent labour
under the guise of temporary employment, nor can
it convert the vulnerability of an employee into a
perpetual instrument of administrative
convenience. To deny consideration of
regularization merely because the employee has, in
the meantime, attained the age of superannuation,
would be to permit the State to reap the fruits of
decades of labour and thereafter wash its hands of
the obligations that may have accrued during the
subsistence of such employment. Such an approach
would lend judicial imprimatur to an exploitative
engagement of human labour, a course that would
be wholly antithetical to the constitutional ideals of
fairness, dignity and social justice.
20. The Apex Court, in the afore-quoted
judgments, has underscored that the mere attainment of
the age of superannuation cannot, by itself, become a
reason to defeat accrued service-related entitlements or
to decline consideration of a claim that had arisen during
the currency of employment. The right to seek
consideration of regularization, where otherwise
available in law, does not evaporate into thin air
upon the employee crossing the threshold of
superannuation. Retirement may bring the
relationship of employment to an end; it does not
necessarily bring to an end the legal consequences
of an unlawful denial of benefits during that
employment. An employee who has devoted the
prime of her youth and the greater part of her
- 57 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
working life to the service of the State cannot be
shown the door at the twilight of her career, with
nothing to show for decades of toil, merely because
the State chose to perpetuate her engagement on
daily wages. Such treatment, where the employee
was otherwise entitled to regularization, would be
unfair in its conception, unjust in its operation and
unconscionable in its consequences. It would
reduce public employment to an arrangement under
which the State secures the labour of an employee
during the most productive years of her life, but
denies the attendant security and benefits when
they are most needed. The judgment in UMADEVI
cannot be pressed into service as an all-purpose shield to
justify such prolonged precarious engagements. It was a
judgment intended to preserve constitutional discipline in
public recruitment, not a licence to perpetuate
exploitation under the protective cloak of constitutional
legality. The State, which is expected to be a model
employer, cannot be permitted to transform a
constitutional safeguard against illegal
appointments into a weapon against employees
whose services it has continuously utilized for
decades.
21. If the facts obtaining in the case at hand are
considered on the bedrock of the principles so enunciated
by the Apex Court, the arbitrariness in the treatment
meted out to the appellant becomes writ large. The
appellant did not enter service through any backdoor
arrangement. Her name was drawn from the list
maintained by the Employment Exchange, pursuant to a
process initiated by the respondent-State. The
appointment was against a duly sanctioned and vacant
post, with the policy of reservation being given effect to,
as the appellant belongs to the Scheduled Caste
community. The appellant thereafter continued to
serve the Municipality for 34 long years,
discharging duties in different capacities, including
those of a Typist and a Computer Operator. The
Municipality itself found her services worthy of
regularization and forwarded recommendations to
that effect .
- 58 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
22. The recommendations did not remain
wholly unacted upon, for, out of 26 employees
whose names were forwarded, 12 were extended
the benefit of regularization. The appellant,
however, was left behind, notwithstanding her long
years of service and the recommendation made in
her favour. The State thus drew a line between
employees who stood on the same footing,
extending the benefit of regularization to some
while leaving the appellant to languish in the
uncertainty of daily-wage employment. No
justifiable distinction warranting such differential
treatment is forthcoming from the material placed
before this Court. The conduct of the State, which
ought to have been a model employer, falls
woefully short of the constitutional standards of
fairness and non-arbitrariness.
23. The learned Single Judge, in the
considered view of this Court, ought to have
examined these circumstances rather than non-
suiting the appellant on the solitary ground that she
had attained the age of superannuation. The
appellant's retirement did not erase the 34 years of
service rendered by her; neither did it obliterate the
claim that had arisen long before her retirement.
The learned Single Judge, therefore, fell into error
in declining to examine the claim on its merits
merely because the appellant had superannuated.
24. The cumulative effect of the afore-narrated
facts, viewed through the prism of the law declared by
the Apex Court, leaves little room for doubt that the
appellant has made out a case for relief. The appellant's
entry into service through the Employment Exchange, her
appointment against a sanctioned vacancy, the
uninterrupted service rendered for 34 years, the
recommendations made for regularization, and the
extension of that very benefit to similarly situated
employees constitute circumstances which, taken
together, demonstrate the manifest arbitrariness of her
exclusion. This is not a case where an employee seeks to
secure regularization merely by invoking the length of
service. It is a case where the State, having initiated the
process of appointment, utilized the services of the
- 59 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
appellant for decades, recommended her regularization
and regularized others similarly situated, seeks to deny
her the same benefit by invoking the very passage of
time during which her claim remained unattended.
25. In the peculiar and compelling circumstances
obtaining in the case at hand, this Court is of the
considered view that a mere mandamus directing the
respondents to reconsider the claim of the appellant
would be an inadequate remedy. Such a direction would
only consign the appellant, now a superannuated
employee, to yet another round of administrative
consideration and, possibly, another journey to the doors
of this Court. The law does not demand that a litigant,
who has already spent decades pursuing a legitimate
claim, be condemned to an endless cycle of
representations, rejections and litigation. Justice, to be
meaningful, must not merely recognize a wrong; it must,
where the facts and law so warrant, furnish an effective
remedy for that wrong. The appellant is, therefore,
entitled to a direction for regularization of her services
with consequential service and retiral benefits, to be
worked out in accordance with the applicable rules.
26. Before parting, this Court deems it
necessary to remind the respondent-State of its
solemn obligation as a model employer. The State
must not become an exemplar of the very
exploitation which the Constitution commands it to
prevent. It cannot retain employees on daily wages
for the greater part of their working lives, deny
them the security of regular employment, and
thereafter compel them to spend the evening of
their lives in the corridors of Courts seeking
recognition of services rendered over decades. The
respondents would do well to ensure that such
instances do not recur, for constitutional
governance demands not merely obedience to
judicial directions after litigation, but fairness in
administrative action before litigation becomes
inevitable.”
(Emphasis supplied)
- 60 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18006
WP No. 101182 of 2026
CNR: KAHC020026682026
In the light of the afore-quoted judgment of the Division Bench
of this Court, the petitioners are entitled for their case to be
considered for the regularization of their services. It is a matter
of record that the services of other employees have been
regularized by the respondents. The petitioners having
completed more than 30 years of service are entitled to be
considered for regularization of their services on the principle of
parity of treatment.
9. For the aforesaid reasons, the following:
ORDER
(i) The writ petition is allowed.
(ii) Mandamus issues to the respondents to
consider the case of the petitioners for
regularization of their services as a Group-D
employee, as has been done in the case of
others, within an outer limit of 12 weeks from
the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
Sd/-
(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE
VNP/CT: ASC
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 6