Central Bureau Of Investigation vs Anil Dixit
- Court
- Supreme Court
Reportable
2026 INSC 1064
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Criminal Appeal No.4618 of 2026
(Arising out of SLP (Crl) No.17158 of 2026)
Central Bureau of Investigation ...Appellant
Versus
Anil Dixit ...Respondent
O R D E R
Leave granted.
2. The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) challenge
the orders directing it to produce some documents,
specifically ‘unrelied’ upon documents, at the stage of
framing of charges. The accused, the respondent herein,
filed an application under Section 91 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (CrPC), seeking for certain documents,
which was allowed as per Annexure P2 dated 21.09.2019, by
the Special Judge No.1, CBI, Ranchi.
3. The CBI filed a compliance report producing certain
documents, resisting the production of certain others and
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
VISHAL ANAND
Date: 2026.09.29
14:48:43 IST
Reason:
asserting that some of them are not in their possession, as per
Annexure P13. A further application filed by the accused
Page 1 of 8
resulted in an order dated 18.07.2022, produced as
Annexure P5, which is affirmed in the impugned order;
challenged by the CBI.
4. We heard Sri Suryaprakash V. Raju, learned
Additional Solicitor General appearing for the appellant-CBI
and Sri Arvind Kumar Gupta, learned Senior Counsel for the
respondent-accused.
5. The respondent has filed an affidavit pursuant to our
order dated 07.09.2026 that they are not seeking the source
of information received by the CBI and the case diaries. The
accused otherwise, relies on a decision of this Court in Sarla
1
Gupta and Another v. Directorate of Enforcement , while
the CBI on the other hand, relies on an earlier decision of a
Coordinate Bench in State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath
2
Padhi .
2
6. Debendra Nath Padhi held that ‘insofar as the accused
is concerned, his entitlement to seek order under Section 91
CrPC, would ordinarily not come till the stage of defence’ (sic.
1
para25) , whereas in Sarla Gupta and Another , a co-ordinate
Bench found that these observations are in the context of what
constitutes ‘the record of the case for the purpose of Section
1
(2025) 7 SCC 626
2
(2005) 1 SCC 568
Page 2 of 8
227 CrPC’ (sic-para44). However, in paragraph 68.4, Sarla
1
Gupta also holds as under:
‘......Though the accused will be entitled to a list of
documents, objects, exhibits, etc. that are not relied
upon by the ED at the stage of framing of charge, in
ordinary course, the accused is not entitled to seek
copies of the said documents at the stage of framing
of charges.’
7. Be that as it may, we need not look at the aforesaid
decisions but would only proceed on the premise that the
accused is entitled to the documents available with the
prosecuting agency to shape its defence; but at what stage
could the documents be sought for, is the question arising,
which has to be looked at on the specific documents sought
for.
8. We see from the order dated 21.09.2019 that there
were documents sought for, as serially numbered from (a) to
(j), which are extracted hereunder:
‘(a) Photocopies of all seizure memos. Through which
documents have been seized by the I.O during
investigation from various departments/authorities.
(b) Photocopies tor Daily Dairy Register and FIR
Register maintained in the office of SP, CBI/HOB,ACB,
Ranchi for the month of October/November, 2014.
(c) Photocopies of letter Dispatch Register of the office
of the SP/CBI/HOB,AGB, Ranchi for the month of
October/November, 2014.
(d) Photocopies of Source information Report (SIR) of
case no RC No.12A/2014-R and its SIR verification
Page 3 of 8
report both are public document and mandatory part
of FIR itself.
(e) Photocopier of all the documents, seized by the I.O.
but not relied upon in the charge sheet.
th th th th th
(f) Photocopies of minutes of 8 , 9 , 10 12 , 13 and
th
14 Building Committee as frequent Reference of these
meetings are appearing in the Charge-sheet arid
Relied Upon Documents at number places. This
establishes the pick and Choose theory of documents
as blatantly followed by prosecution documents, in
supports of the defence have been withheld by the
prosecution with malafide intentions.
(g) Videography/ Photography of evaluation
committee meetings for Finalization of Master Plan
dated 16 and 17/12/2011 and another meeting held on
dated 21/1/2012 for finalization designs for individual
Buildings.
(h) Photocopies of minutes of the meeting held on
21.01.2012 for Finalization of Individual Buddings
designs, with the signed attendance sheet.
(i) Photocopies of Expression of Interest and the
Technical bid as submitted by the applicant, while
applying for the process of selection in response of
Expression of Interest.
(j) Appointment files of M/s Grey Parikh Architects Pvt.
Ltd. and M/s Sandeep Shirke Architects’ & Associates
Pvt. Ltd. the two accused with were named In FIR but
dropped the charge sheet.’
9. The compliance report filed by the CBI is at Annexure
P13, which responds in the following manner:
a) Photocopies of all seizure memos of this case,
through which documents have been seized by the IO
during Investigation are being submitted along with
this petition.
Page 4 of 8
b) The reply concern with this para it is submitted that
daily dairy register and FIR register maintain in the
office of the SP CBI is not related with this case as such
the copy of FIR of this case has already been supplied
to the defence petitioner.
c) The information sought with regards to letter
dispatch register of this branch, it is submitted that it is
not concern with this case and hence it cannot be
supplied.
d) The case no.RC. 12/A/2014-R is registered on the
basis of source information. As per law, details/identity
of the cannot be disclosed. As such this is the
confidential documents which may not be supplied.
e) The unrelied upon documents are voluminous.
However, If the petitioner so wishes, they may inspect
these documents seized in this case with the permission
of this Hon'ble Court. After inspection, he may give a
certificate of inspection in this regard.
f) In the chargesheet the only reference of Building
Committee Meeting is that of the 11th meeting dated
27.01.12 which has already been supplied to the
accused petitioner as relied upon document which is
concerned in this case. Apart from this, no other
reference of any Building Committee meetings are
concerned with this case.
g) The videography/photography of evaluation
committee meetings for Finalization of Master Plan, was
not collected during the investigation in this case and,
hence, the same could not be supplied. As such no any
recording is available with CBI in this case.
h) As regards photocopy of minutes of meeting held on
21.01.2012 for finalization of Individual Buildings
designs, with the signed attended sheet, the same is not
available with CBI.
i) Relied upon document was marked D-2 which
contains EOI, has already been supplied to the
petitioner. Technical bid as submitted by the applicant,
while applying for the process of selection in response
Page 5 of 8
to Expression of Interest, is not available in the file
collected from CUT by CBI.
j) That M/s Grey Parikh Architects Pvt. Ltd and M/s
Sandeep Shirke Architects and Associates Pvt. Ltd are
not Charge sheeted in this case. During investigation
no any criminality found against both the companies
and hence not Charge sheeted in this case.’
10. Hence, the seizure memos covered under clause (a)
have been produced. With respect to (b), (c) and (d), those
are the registers maintained by the CBI and the source
information, which cannot be divulged. The accused also has
not insisted upon it having withdrawn his request for the
same.
11. Insofar as clause (e) is concerned, the CBI has
permitted examination of such documents, since it is
voluminous. The accused could examine such documents
and seek for production of the specific document required at
the appropriate time, when the appropriate witness is being
examined either by the prosecution or the defence, for which
purpose the CBI shall keep the files ready at the time of trial.
Or in the alternative, the CBI could permit the accused or his
authorised representative to specify the particular document
required, at the time of inspection; reduced to writing and
signed by both parties, which shall also be produced before
Page 6 of 8
the Trial Court without any delay, which documents specified
alone need be kept available, in the Court at the time of trial.
12. With respect to clause (f), it is stated by the CBI that
th
only the Minutes of 11 meeting is relied upon in the case.
The respondent’s contention is that there are other Minutes
which would absolve him from criminal culpability as alleged
against him. The said documents are sought for by specific
dates mentioned, as is seen from the above extract from the
first order passed by the Special Court and if they are
available in the voluminous records which have been
permitted to be examined by the accused, then necessarily
the production could be sought for as directed by us, herein
above, at the appropriate stage. If the same is not available
with the CBI, then the accused would be entitled to procure
the same and prove it in his defence evidence; either by
resort to the Right to Information Act, 2005, or by producing
a suitable witness at the time of defence. The evidentiary
value of which will have to be assessed by the Trial Court.
13. As far as clause (g), (h) and (i), the CBI categorically
states that those are not available with them. With respect to
the documents sought for in clause (j), it is the submission of
the CBI that those persons were not arrayed as accused and
their appointments, if at all, would not in any manner
Page 7 of 8
exculpate the accused. Those which are not available with
the CBI necessarily cannot be produced by them.
14. The Trial Court shall proceed in accordance with the
directions above. The impugned orders are set aside to
facilitate an expeditious trial.
15. The appeal is disposed of.
16. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand rejected.
.......…….……………………. J.
(J. B. PARDIWALA)
....……….……………………. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)
NEW DELHI;
SEPTEMBER 25, 2026.
Page 8 of 8