Jai Mala vs State Of Haryana And Anr.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

1
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 16.11.2026

SMT. JAI MALA .......Appellant(s)
Vs
STATE OF HARYANA AND ANR. ....Respondent(s)

1 The date when the judgment was reserved 25.08.2026
2 The date when the judgment is pronounced 16.11.2026
3 The date when the judgment is uploaded on the 16.11.2026
website
4 Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or whether the full judgment is
pronounced
Full
5 The delay, if any, of the pronouncement of full Not applicable
judgment, and reasons thereof.
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARKESH MANUJA

Present: Mr. C.L. Sharma, Advocate
for the appellant.

Mr. R.P.S. Brar, Asstt. A.G., Haryana.

HARKESH MANUJA, J.
1. By way of the present appeal, the appellant-plaintiff has assailed the
judgment and decree dated 18.05.2006 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Rewari (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Trial Court’), as well as the
judgment and decree dated 11.10.2006 passed by the learned District Judge,
Rewari (hereinafter referred to as the ‘First Appellate Court’), whereby the
dismissal of the suit for declaration was upheld. Thus, the present appeal is
directed against the concurrent findings recorded by the learned Courts below.
2. Briefly stated, the plaintiff was B.A., B.Ed. with Sanskrit and English
subjects. She had studied Hindi as one of her subjects in B.A.-I and B.A.-II and
with Sanskrit in B. A.-III. She received an interview letter dated 10.12.1998from
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

2
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

Haryana Staff Selection Commission, Chandigarh (in short, the Commission)
Ex.PW2/1. She appeared for interview on 22.10.1998 along with all the
certificates. She received another letter dated 2.6.1999, Ex.PW2/2, from the office
of District Education Officer, Rewari. Complying with the same, she reached the
office along with all the certificates on 10.6.1999. After perusal of the certificates,
defendant No.2 orally asked her to join as Sanskrit teacher in Government Middle
School, Khera Murar but the next day she was denied any written appointment
letter. She wrote to defendant No.2 for issuance of her appointment letter. Her case
was referred to the Director Senior Secondary Education, Haryana, Chandigarh for
clarification. Thereafter, plaintiff came to know that Director Senior Secondary
Education Haryana, Chandigarh has given clarification in favour of plaintiff but no
heed was made to the application dated 06.06.2000. After serving a notice under
section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure, she filed the suit seeking declaration
that plaintiff is entitled to be appointed as Sanskrit teacher in any of the school
under the defendants at Rewari w.e.f 10.6.19999 with all arrears of pay and
allowances alongwith interest on the arrear @ 18% per annum.
3. Upon notice, suit was contested by the defendants. The various pleas
of the plaintiff were controverted. It was averred that the plaintiff failed to show
any certificate that she had knowledge of Hindi up to matric standard which was
pre-requisite for appointment of a teacher. She was not having sufficient
qualification for the post of a Sanskrit teacher. The mark-sheets submitted by the
plaintiff did not indicate whether she had taken Hindi subject in BA-I and BA-II.
According to Service Rules and Advertisement for the post of Sanskrit teacher,
knowledge of Hindi upto matric standard was required. The plaintiff never
submitted any certificate that she had knowledge of Hindi up to matric standard.
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

3
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

The suit was also contested on the grounds of maintainability, joinder of necessary
parties and estoppel.
4. Replication was filed controverting the allegations made in the written
statement and reiterating those made in the plaint.
5. On the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were framed by
the learned Trial Court on 14.5.2001:-
“1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to be appointed as Sanskrit Teacher
under the defendants, in District Rewari? OPP

2. If the answer to issue no.1 is in affirmative then whether the plaintiff
is entitled to arrears of pay and allowances alongwith interest from
10.6.1999? OPP

3. Whether the suit is not maintainable in the present form?OPD

4. Whether the suit is bad for non joinder of necessary parties? OPD

5. Whether the plaintiff is estopped by her own act and conduct to file
the present suit? OPD
6. Relief”

6. Upon hearing learned counsel for the parties and appreciating the
evidence on record, the learned Trial Court, vide judgment and decree dated
18.05.2006, dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiff.
7. Aggrieved thereof, plaintiff preferred appeal which also came to be
dismissed by the learned First Appellate Court vide judgment and decree dated
11.10.2006, thereby affirming the dismissal of the suit of the plaintiff. Hence the
present regular second appeal has been preferred by the appellant-plaintiff.
CONTENTIONS
ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT-PLAINTIFF

8. Impugning the judgments and decrees passed by the learned Courts
below, learned counsel for the appellant-plaintiff submits that the findings recorded
therein are contrary to the evidence on record, particularly certificates Ex.PW2/6
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

4
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

and Ex.PW2/7, which have been misread. It is contended that the subjects in the
said certificates are mentioned serial-wise, with the maximum marks and marks
obtained reflected in the adjoining columns. A correct perusal thereof clearly
establishes that the plaintiff secured 106 out of 200 marks in Hindi in B.A. Part-I
and 89 out of 200 marks in Hindi in B.A. Part-II. Thus, the finding that the plaintiff
had not passed Hindi at the B.A. level was contrary to the documentary evidence
on record.
8.1 Learned counsel further submits that although the plaintiff had not
passed Hindi in her matriculation examination, she subsequently cleared the
subject in both parts of her B.A., which is a higher qualification. It is argued that a
candidate possessing a higher qualification than the minimum prescribed cannot be
held ineligible for appointment on that ground. Accordingly, it is contended that
the impugned judgments and decrees warrant interference and the suit deserves to
be decreed.
ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS-DEFENDANTS
9. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submits that the
judgments passed by the learned Courts below been based on proper appreciation
of facts, pleadings and evidence on record, thus called for no interference.
DISCUSSION AND REASONING
10. I have heard learned counsels for the parties and perused the paper-
book. I find substance in the arguments raised on behalf of learned counsel for the
appellants.
11. In the present case, as per Haryana Government Gazette Notification
dated 12.05.1998, the following qualifications were prescribed for appointment to
the post of Sanskrit Teacher:
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

5
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

(i) Shastri/B.A.(Hons in Sanskrit) from a recognised University;

(ii) L.T.C/OT in Sanskrit conducted by the Haryana Education
Department or an equivalent qualification recognised by the Haryana
Education Department
OR
BT/B.Ed. with Sanskrit as teaching subject from a recognised
University,
Note:- in case, the candidates of above qualifications are not available then
B.A. with Sanskrit as an Elective Subject with B.T./B.Ed. from a recognised
University with Sanskrit as а teaching subject shall be considered.

(iii) Knowledge of Hindi up to Matric standard.

11.1 There is no dispute with regard to the qualifications prescribed under
clauses (i) and (ii). The controversy essentially centres around clause (iii), namely,
whether the appellant-plaintiff, who admittedly had not studied Hindi at the
Matriculation level but had subsequently studied the subject in B.A. Part-I and
Part-II, could be treated as fulfilling the said requirement. The respondents-
defendants resisted her claim on the ground that she did not possess Hindi up to the
Matriculation standard. The learned Courts below accepted the aforesaid
contention and, while holding the appellant-plaintiff ineligible, also recorded that
there was nothing on record to establish that she had studied Hindi in her B.A.
examination. However, in the humble opinion of this Court, learned courts below
erred in arriving at the aforesaid finding.
12. A perusal of the certificates Ex.PW2/6 and Ex.PW2/7 reveals that the
appellant-plaintiff appeared in the First Year and Second Year B.A. examinations
and secured Second Division, with Sanskrit as a special subject and Hindi and
Philosophy as Optional Subjects-I and II, respectively. A further perusal of the said
certificates makes it evident that the plaintiff secured 106 marks out of 200 in
Hindi in B.A. Part-I, as reflected in the 10th column of the last row of certificate
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

6
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

Ex.PW2/6, and 89 marks out of 200 in Hindi in B.A. Part-II, as reflected in the
corresponding column of certificate Ex.PW2/7. Thus, the documentary evidence
on record clearly establishes that the plaintiff had studied Hindi as a subject in both
parts of her B.A. examination. In view of the above, the finding recorded by the
learned Courts below that there was nothing on record to establish that the plaintiff
had passed Hindi in B.A. Part-I and Part-II is clearly the result of an erroneous
reading of the aforesaid certificates. Consequently, the learned Courts below fell
into error in recording a finding against the plaintiff on this aspect.
13. Once it stands established that the appellant-plaintiff had studied Hindi
in both B.A. Part-I and Part-II, the next question that arises for consideration is
whether, despite possessing Hindi as a subject at the B.A. level, she could still be
held ineligible on the ground that she had not studied the subject at the
Matriculation level, particularly when the prescribed qualification was merely
knowledge of Hindi up to Matriculation standard.
14. In this regard, this Court deems it apposite to refer to the instructions
bearing letter no. 34/93/78-5-GS-I dated 16.6.1979 issued by the State of Haryana,
the relevant portion of which is reproduced hereunder:
“I am directed to refer to the subject noted above and to state that a
question had come up for consideration by the Government whether a
person possessing qualifications higher than those prescribed for a post,
but not those actually prescribed for it, should be considered eligible for
such a post. The matter has been carefully considered and it has been
decided that if a candidate possesses higher qualifications in the same line
and has passed such higher examination in the same division or class as
prescribed for the minimum qualifications applicable to a particular post,
then he should-be considered eligible for that post.
2. To illustrate, if the minimum educational qualification prescribed
for a post is Matric First Division and if candidates with higher
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

7
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

qualifications, such as Higher Secondary or B.A. have applied for it, then
such candidates as have passed the higher examination would be eligible
although they may not have passed the Matric examination in the First
Division.”

A plain reading of the aforesaid instructions leaves little room for
doubt that the State Government itself has recognised the eligibility of candidates
possessing higher qualifications in the same line, notwithstanding their not having
acquired the minimum qualification in the precise form in which it has been
prescribed. The illustration in paragraph 2 further reinforces this position by
clarifying that a candidate possessing a higher qualification would remain eligible
even if the prescribed standard of division or class was not attained in the lower
examination.
14.1 Applying these instructions to the facts of the present case, the
notification dated 12.05.1998 merely prescribed knowledge of Hindi up to the
Matriculation standard, without stipulating any particular division or class therein.
The appellant-plaintiff, admittedly, had studied Hindi in both B.A. Part-I and Part-
II and cleared the examinations, securing Second Division in her B.A. The study of
Hindi at the university level, therefore, represents an academic attainment higher
than the knowledge of Hindi up to the Matriculation standard stipulated under the
advertisement. Once the appellant-plaintiff had acquired such higher academic
qualification in the very subject for which knowledge was prescribed, the mere fact
that she had not studied Hindi at the Matriculation level could not, by itself, have
rendered her ineligible for the aforesaid post. The instructions dated 16.06.1979
clearly support her claim, and the respondents-defendants, therefore, could not
have rejected her candidature on the aforesaid ground.
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

8
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

15. Further, reference may be made to the case of ‘ Bimla Devi v. State of
Haryana’ and others reported as “ 1999 (1) RSJ 263 , wherein the issue arose in the
context of selection to the posts of Hindi Teachers, for which the prescribed
qualification was Prabhakar with Honours in Hindi. The petitioner therein, who
possessed the higher qualification of M.A. in Hindi, was denied selection.
Aggrieved thereof, she approached this Court by way of a writ petition. A Division
Bench of this Court, while considering the issue and allowing the petition,
observed as under:-
“ 6. In our opinion, denial of appointment to the petitioner
against the vacancy which has remained unfilled due to non-joining of
one of the selected candidates has resulted in violation of her
fundamental right to equality in the matter of employment granted to her
by Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India and we agree with Shri
Sangwan that the petitioner, who possesses qualifications higher than
those notified in the advertisement, cannot be denied appointment on the
ground that she has not passed Prabhakar (Honours in Hindi ). In Seema
Nagpal's case (supra), reference has been made to the order passed in Civil
Writ Petition No. 18427 of 1994, Smt. Saroj Bala v. State of Haryana and
others. In that case, this Court took cognizance of the fact that candidates
possessing the qualification of B.A. with Hindi have been treated as eligible
for appointment as Hindi Teachers because the government has treated the
said qualification to be equivalent to Prabhakar (Honours in Hindi) and a
number of candidates possessing the qualification of B.A. with Hindi have,
in fact, been appointed as Hindi Teachers. The learned Deputy Advocate
General has not been able to controvert the fact that the candidates
possessing the qualifications of B.A. with Hindi and B.Ed. with Hindi as
teaching subject have been appointed on the posts of Hindi Teachers. Thus,
the decision of the respondent No. 2 not to appoint the petitioner as Hindi
Teacher cannot be sustained.”
(emphasis supplied)

MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

9
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

15.1 The aforesaid judgment, though rendered in the context of a different
teaching post, recognises the principle that a candidate possessing a higher
qualification in the same subject cannot ordinarily be denied consideration merely
because the lower qualification, in its prescribed nomenclature, has not been
acquired. The significance of the said judgment lies not merely in the fact that the
petitioner therein possessed a higher qualification, but also in the recognition
accorded to B.A. with Hindi as an acceptable qualification for appointment as a
Hindi Teacher. The principle underlying the said decision lends support to the
claim of the appellant-plaintiff, who has admittedly studied Hindi at the B.A. level.
16. Likewise, in the CWP No. 10926 of 2007 titled as Ashok Kumar and
others v. State of Haryana , decided on 21.12.2007, wherein the required
qualification for the post of Sanskrit teacher inter alia, included Shastri/B.A
(Hons.) in Sanskrit whereas petitioners possessed M.A in the subject of Sanskrit,
this Court while allowing the writ petition, had relied upon the abovesaid
instructions dated 16.06.1979 and the judgment rendered in the case of Bimla Devi
(supra) to hold that the petitioners possessed higher qualification in the same line
and were, therefore, eligible for the posts of Sanskrit teacher. Although the
controversy therein related to the prescribed qualification in Sanskrit, the principle
applied by this Court assumes significance in the present case as well, particularly
in view of the Government’s own instructions recognising higher qualifications in
the same line.
17. The legal position now stands settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Jyoti K.K and others v. Kerala Public Service Commission
reported as 2010(15) SCC 596 . In that case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court while
dealing with the similar controversy observed as under:
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

10
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

“9. It is no doubt true, as stated by the High Court that when a
qualification has been set out under the relevant rules, the same cannot be
in any manner whittled down and a different qualification cannot be
adopted. The High Court is also justified in stating that the higher
qualification must clearly indicate or presuppose the acquisition of the
lower qualification prescribed for that post in order to attract that part of
the rule to the effect that such of those higher qualifications which
presuppose the acquisition of the lower qualifications prescribed for the
post shall also be sufficient for the post. If a person has acquired higher
qualifications in the same faculty, such qualification can certainly be
stated to presuppose the acquisition of the lower qualifications prescribed
for the post . In this case it may not be necessary to seek far. Under the
relevant rules, for the post assistant engineer, degree in electrical
engineering of Kerala University or other equivalent qualification
recognised or equivalent thereto has been prescribed. For a higher post
when a direct recruitment has to be held, the qualification that has to be
obtained, obviously gives an indication that such qualification is definitely
higher qualification than what is prescribed for the lower post, namely, the
post of sub-engineer.
10. In that view of the matter the qualification of degree in electrical
engineering presupposes the acquisition of the lower qualification of
diploma in that subject prescribed for the post, shall be considered to be
sufficient for that post. In the event the Government is of the view that only
diploma holders should have applied to post of subengineers but not all
those who possess higher qualifications, either this rule should have
excluded in respect of candidates who possess higher qualifications or the
position should have been made clear that degree holder shall not be
eligible to apply for such post. When that position is not clear but on the
other hand rules do not disqualify per se the holders of higher
qualifications in the same faculty, it becomes clear that the rule could be
understood in an appropriate manner as stated above. In that view of the
matter the order of the High Court cannot be sustained. In this case we are
not concerned with the question whether all those who possess such
qualifications could have applied or not. When statutory rules have been
published and those rules are applicable, it presupposes that everyone
concerned with such appointments will be aware of such rules or make
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

11
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

himself aware of the rules before making appropriate applications. The
High Court, therefore, is not justified in holding that recruitment of
appellants would amount to fraud on the public.”

The legal position emerging from the aforesaid decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court is that where a candidate possesses a higher qualification
in the same faculty or subject, it presupposes the acquisition of the lower
qualification prescribed for the post; such higher qualification can be treated as
sufficient for the purpose of eligibility. The Court has further clarified that where
the relevant rules do not expressly exclude candidates possessing higher
qualifications, such candidates cannot be disqualified merely because they do not
possess the lower qualification in its prescribed form.
17.1 Applying the aforesaid principle to the facts of the present case, the
appellant-plaintiff had studied and cleared Hindi in both B.A. Part-I and Part-II,
whereas the prescribed requirement was merely knowledge of Hindi up to
Matriculation standard. It is also significant that the post in question was that of
Sanskrit Teacher, for which the appellant-plaintiff possessed the requisite subject-
specific qualification in Sanskrit. In the humble opinion of this Court, the
requirement of knowledge of Hindi was an additional language requirement and
not the principal academic qualification for the post. In such circumstances, where
the appellant-plaintiff had admittedly acquired higher academic proficiency in
Hindi itself, insistence upon her having studied the subject specifically at the
Matriculation level would amount to adopting an unduly restrictive interpretation
of the prescribed qualification. Thus, her subsequent study of Hindi at the B.A.
level constitutes a higher qualification which sufficiently presupposes the
acquisition of the lower qualification, namely, knowledge of Hindi up to
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

12
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

Matriculation standard. Consequently, the fact that she had not studied Hindi at the
Matriculation level cannot be a ground to deny her eligibility, particularly when
she had subsequently acquired a higher academic qualification in the same subject.
17.2 It is also pertinent to note that the notification dated 12.05.1998
prescribing requisite qualifications for the post of Sanskrit teacher does not contain
any stipulation expressly excluding candidates who have acquired knowledge of
Hindi at a higher academic level but had not studied the subject at the
Matriculation level. Had the intention of the State been to restrict eligibility only to
candidates who had studied Hindi at the Matriculation level, such a condition could
well have been incorporated in the notification in clear terms. Rather, the
Government instructions dated 16.06.1979, issued after due consideration of the
very question of eligibility of candidates possessing higher qualifications, clarify
that a candidate possessing a higher qualification in the same line is to be
considered eligible even if he does not possess the prescribed lower qualification in
its specific form. Read in the light of these instructions, the requirement of
knowledge of Hindi up to Matriculation standard cannot be construed so narrowly
as to exclude the appellant-plaintiff, who had subsequently studied and cleared
Hindi at the B.A. level. Such an interpretation would defeat the very object
underlying the Government’s own instructions and would unjustifiably deny to the
appellant-plaintiff, the benefit of a higher qualification acquired in the same
subject.
18. At this stage, this Court would like to point out one more fact. It is
pertinent to notice that the appellant-plaintiff was called for interview by the
Commission vide letter dated 10.12.1998 (Ex.PW2/1). Thereafter, vide
communication dated 02.06.1999 (Ex.PW2/2), she was called upon by the office of
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

13
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

the District Education Officer, Rewari, along with her certificates. Upon perusal of
the documents produced by her, she was orally asked to join as Sanskrit Teacher at
Government Middle School, Khera Murar. However, despite the aforesaid
direction, no formal appointment letter was issued to her and she was denied
appointment. The respondents’ conduct in asking the appellant-plaintiff to join and
thereafter withholding the formal appointment order is a relevant circumstance
which further lends support to her case; reflecting a lack of due diligence on their
part, inasmuch as the appellant-plaintiff, despite being asked to join, was
ultimately denied a formal appointment letter.
19. In view of the aforesaid discussion and the legal position emerging
from the cases of Bimla Devi (supra), Ashok Kumar (supra) and Jyoti K.K.
(supra) this Court is of the considered opinion that the appellant-plaintiff
possessed the requisite qualifications for appointment to the post of Sanskrit
Teacher. The learned Courts below have not only misread the documentary
evidence comprising Ex.PW2/6 and Ex.PW2/7 but have also failed to appreciate
the effect of the Government instructions dated 16.06.1979 referred to
hereinabove. The concurrent findings recorded by the learned Courts below,
therefore, cannot be sustained, as the same suffer from an erroneous appreciation
of the evidence and an incorrect interpretation of the applicable eligibility
requirement.
20. Consequently, the present appeal is allowed . The judgments and
decrees dated 18.05.2006 and 11.10.2006 passed by the learned Trial Court and the
learned First Appellate Court, respectively, are hereby set aside. The suit filed by
the appellant-plaintiff is decreed and she is held eligible for appointment to the
post of Sanskrit Teacher. The respondents-defendants are accordingly directed to
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

14
RSA No.4235 of 2006 (O&M)

grant her appointment to the said post with effect from 10.06.1999, along with
consequential benefits, in accordance with law. Decree sheet be prepared
accordingly.
21. Pending miscellaneous applications if any shall stand disposed of


(HARKESH MANUJA)
November 16, 2026 JUDGE
Atik

Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
MOHMED ATIK
2026.11.17 11:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document