Tanu Jain vs Union Of India And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

120
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH

CWP No. 20141 of 2026 (O&M)

Tanu Jain
… Petitioner
Versus
Union of India and others
… Respondents

1. The date when the judgment is reserved 28.10.2026
2. The date when the judgment is pronounced 20.11.2026
3. The date when the judgment is uploaded on
the website
20.11.2026
4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or whether the full judgment is
pronounced
Operative
5. The delay, if any, of the pronouncement of full
judgment, and reasons thereof
Not applicable

CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK SIBAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUNISH BINDLISH

Argued by: Ms. Aakriti, Advocate, for the petitioner.
Mr. Ranvijay Singh, Senior Standing Counsel,
for the respondents-Income Tax Department.

SUNISH BINDLISH, J.


1. The petitioner, an individual assessee, has invoked the writ
jurisdiction of this Court under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India for
issuance of a writ of certiorari quashing, for Assessment Year 2013-14:

(i) the notice dated 08.05.2026 issued under Section 148A(b) of the
Income Tax Act, 1961 (“the Act”) (Annexure P-15);

(ii) the order dated 25.06.2026 passed under Section 148A(d) of the Act
(Annexure P-16); and

(iii) the consequential notice dated 25.06.2026 issued under Section 148
RATTAN PAL SINGH
of the Act (Annexure P-17).
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 2


2. The controversy lies in a narrow compass. The petitioner’s assessment
for Assessment Year 2013-14 was sought to be reopened by a notice dated
30.03.2021 issued under Section 148 of the Act, as it then stood, on the allegation
that income of Rs.26,40,000/- had escaped assessment. As the notice was
dispatched to the petitioner on or after 01.04.2021, it came to be treated as a show
cause notice under Section 148A(b), in terms of the judgment of the Supreme Court
in Union of India v. Ashish Agarwal , (2023) 1 SCC 617, and the order of this Court
dated 30.04.2026 in CWP No. 2710 of 2022. While proceeding on that notice, the
Assessing Officer confronted the petitioner with a further item of Rs.36,05,000/-,
aggregated the two items, and held that income of Rs.62,45,000/- had escaped
assessment. On the strength of that aggregate, he invoked the extended period of
ten years under Section 149(1)(b), which is available only where the escaped
income amounts to Rs.50 lakh or more. The question is whether this was
permissible in law.


FACTS

3. The facts, as borne out from the record, are largely undisputed.

4. The petitioner filed her return of income for Assessment Year 2013-
14 on 26.03.2014, declaring an income of Rs.25,40,450/-. The return was
processed under Section 143(1) of the Act. No scrutiny assessment under Section
143(3) was framed.

5. A notice dated 30.03.2021 under Section 148 of the Act, as it stood
prior to its substitution by the Finance Act, 2021, was issued to the petitioner
(Annexure P-1). It is the petitioner’s case that no real-time alert was sent for the
notice, and the Revenue has accepted, as recorded in the order of this Court dated
30.04.2026, that the notice was dispatched to the petitioner on or after 01.04.2021.
By notice dated 30.06.2021 under Section 142(1) (Annexure P-2), the petitioner
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 3

was required to file a return in response, which she did on 12.07.2021 (Annexure
P-3). By her communications dated 29.07.2021 and 16.12.2021 (Annexures P-4
and P-6), she sought the reasons for reopening, in terms of GKN Driveshafts (India)
Ltd. v. Income Tax Officer , (2003) 1 SCC 72.

6. The reasons were supplied for the first time on 23.12.2021 (Annexure
P-7). They record that, as per information received from the Investigation Wing,
the petitioner had claimed exempt long-term capital gain under Section 10(38) in
Financial Year 2012-13 on the strength of fabricated contract notes; that the shares
had been purchased through entities controlled by entry operators, transferred to
her account by off-market transfers and sold within a few days; and that, in this
manner, her own unaccounted money “i.e. Rs. 26,40,000/-” had been camouflaged
as exempt long-term capital gain. Paragraph 6 of the reasons concludes that “an
amount of Rs. 26,40,000/- received on account of bogus LTCG/STCL as well as
other income which comes to the notice during the course of assessment
proceedings” had escaped assessment. No other item or amount finds mention in
the reasons.

7. By notice dated 05.02.2022 (Annexure P-8), the petitioner was called
upon to furnish her reply. On 14.02.2022, she instead approached this Court by
way of CWP No. 2710 of 2022, contending that a notice issued after 01.04.2021
could be issued only after following the procedure under Section 148A. By order
dated 14.02.2022 (Annexure P-9), the petition was directed to be heard along with
CWP No. 14886 of 2021 ( DLF Gayatri Developers v. Assistant Commissioner of
Income Tax ), and interim orders were passed in the same terms as in that case. The
reassessment proceedings remained in abeyance thereafter.

8. On 04.05.2022, the Supreme Court in Ashish Agarwal (Annexure P-
10), in exercise of its power under Article 142, directed that such notices be deemed
to have been issued under Section 148A and be treated as show cause notices under
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 4

Section 148A(b). The Assessing Officers were required, within thirty days, to
“provide to the assessees the information and material relied upon by the Revenue
so that the assessees can reply to the notices within two weeks thereafter”. The
enquiry under Section 148A(a) was dispensed with as a one-time measure, and all
defences available to the assessees under Section 149, under the Finance Act, 2021
and in law were kept open.

9. CWP No. 14886 of 2021 was disposed of by this Court on 18.04.2026
(Annexure P-13). The petitioner’s CWP No. 2710 of 2022 was disposed of on
30.04.2026 (Annexure P-14), recording the concession of the Revenue that the
notice dated 30.03.2021, dispatched to the petitioner on or after 01.04.2021, be
treated as a notice under Section 148A(b). The Revenue was directed “to proceed
from the stage of the afore notice, in terms of the procedure laid down under
Section 148A(b) of the Act”, and the petitioner was left at liberty “to raise all
possible pleas/defences that may be available to her, in accordance with law”.

10. By letter dated 08.05.2026 (Annexure P-15), the Income Tax Officer,
Ward 7(1), Ludhiana, referring to the notice dated 30.03.2021 and the order dated
30.04.2026, enclosed “the requisite information and material relied upon for
initiating the proceedings u/s 147/148” and called for the petitioner’s reply by
22.05.2026. The Insight Portal extracts enclosed with it disclosed two items, both
uploaded on 07.03.2021:
Item Source Nature of information Amount
(Rs.)
Dayanand Singh
1
(PAN
AAHPG1822F)
Fictitious Profits in Equity/Derivative Trading; remark: 26,40,000/-
“Information already sent to AO”


Mahanivesh
(India) Ltd.
(PAN
AAACM1750C)
Information of beneficiaries of bogus LTCG/STCL for
FY 2012-13; Sale of Shares; remark: “Sell Trades
Quantity is higher than Buy Trades Quantity”
36,05,000/-
2.

RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 5

Item 1 corresponds in amount to the reasons dated 23.12.2021, and it

is the only item marked as “Information already sent to AO”.

11. The petitioner did not file a reply. By order dated 25.06.2026 under
Section 148A(d) (Annexure P-16), the Assessing Officer, noticing the absence of
a reply, aggregated the two items and held that income of Rs.62,45,000/- had
escaped assessment. Treating the transactions as an “asset” within the Explanation
to Section 149(1), he invoked the extended period of ten years under Section
149(1)(b). The notice under Section 148 of even date (Annexure P-17) followed,
with the prior approval of the Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, NWR,
Chandigarh, dated 23.06.2026.

12. Aggrieved, the petitioner filed the present petition on 03.07.2026.

SUBMISSIONS

13. Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that:

(i) The notice dated 30.03.2021 was founded solely on information of
Rs.26,40,000/-, as the reasons dated 23.12.2021 show. It is that notice
which was saved by Ashish Agarwal and the order dated 30.04.2026.
Neither authorised the Department to enlarge its scope or to
commence proceedings afresh.

(ii) The item of Rs.36,05,000/- was put to the petitioner for the first time
on 08.05.2026. It is, in substance, a second show cause notice. Even
on the outermost period of ten years under the substituted Section
149(1)(b), no notice could be issued for Assessment Year 2013-14
after 31.03.2024. The impugned action, to that extent, is therefore
barred by limitation and without jurisdiction.
In the replication and in the course of arguments, it was further

contended that:
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 6



(iii) The mere availability of information on the Insight Portal on
30.03.2021 does not mean that it was relied upon. The reasons
supplied on 23.12.2021 did not refer to the second item.

(iv) Since Rs.26,40,000/- is below Rs.50 lakh, the ten-year period under
Section 149(1)(b) is not attracted. The item of Rs.36,05,000/- was
brought in only to take the total past the Rs.50 lakh mark and so open
up the extended period of limitation.

(v) The interim protection in CWP No. 2710 of 2022 operated only on
the proceeding then pending. The exclusion of time under the third
proviso to Section 149(1) cannot enure to an item that was never part
of that proceeding.

14. Learned Senior Standing Counsel for the respondents, relying on the
reply, contended that:
(i) No demand has been raised or enhanced. The figure of Rs.62,45,000/-
is only the aggregate quantification of information suggesting
escapement of income. No assessment has been framed, no

computation made, and no tax, interest or penalty levied.
(ii) The letter dated 08.05.2026 does no more than discharge the direction
in clause (i) of Ashish Agarwal and the order dated 30.04.2026.
Nothing was amended and nothing was issued afresh; the notice under

Section 148A(b) is, and remains, the notice dated 30.03.2021.
(iii) Nothing new was introduced in 2026. As the petitioner’s own
annexures show, both items were uploaded on the Insight Portal on
07.03.2021, before the notice dated 30.03.2021, and formed part of
the Assessing Officer’s record. Both pertain to the same assessee, the
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 7

same assessment year and the same subject matter, namely dealings
in shares routed through entities controlled by entry operators. They

do not constitute two separate causes of action.
(iv) Section 148A(b) and the rule of audi alteram partem required the
whole material to be disclosed. Withholding part of it would have

invited a challenge on the ground of reliance on undisclosed material.
(v) Having accepted the legal fiction that the notice dated 30.03.2021 is
a notice under Section 148A(b) for the purpose of escaping the pre-
amendment regime, the petitioner cannot repudiate the same fiction
for the purpose of limitation and contend that the reference date is

08.05.2026. A legal fiction must be carried to its logical conclusion.
(vi) The question of limitation is concluded by Union of India v. Rajeev
Bansal , (2024) 469 ITR 46 (SC): (a) the validity of the notice under
Section 148 is to be tested with reference to the deemed notice dated
30.03.2021; (b) shares are an “asset” under the Explanation to Section
149(1), and since Rs.62,45,000/- exceeds Rs.50 lakh, the ten-year
period under Section 149(1)(b) is available; (c) the first proviso to
Section 149(1) is satisfied, as the six-year period under the
unamended Section 149(1)(b), which expired on 31.03.2020, stood
extended to 30.06.2021 by the Taxation and Other Laws (Relaxation
and Amendment of Certain Provisions) Act, 2020 (“the Relaxation
Act”); and (d) under the third proviso to Section 149(1), the period
from 14.02.2022 to 30.04.2026, the period between the deemed notice
and the supply of material, and the two weeks allowed to the assessee
to reply, are all excluded. The petitioner’s assertion that limitation

expired on 31.03.2024 ignores the third proviso altogether.
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 8

(vii) In any event, Section 147 empowers the Assessing Officer to assess
or reassess income in respect of any issue which comes to his notice

subsequently in the course of the proceedings.
(viii) The petitioner did not file even a single reply despite the liberty
reserved to her. The petition raises disputed questions of fact and is
premature, as she has an efficacious alternative remedy before the

Assessing Officer and thereafter in appeal.

15. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the paper
book, the reply and the replication.

16. The following questions arise for determination:
(i) Whether, upon the notice dated 30.03.2021 being treated as a show
cause notice under Section 148A(b), the Assessing Officer could
introduce an item of escaped income that did not form the basis of that

notice?
(ii) Whether the proceeding in respect of Rs.36,05,000 is barred by

limitation under Section 149?
(iii) Whether the proceeding can survive on the basis of Rs.26,40,000

alone?
(iv) Whether the petitioner ought to be relegated to the alternative

remedy?


Question (i): Scope of the deemed show cause notice

17. The Supreme Court in Ashish Agarwal did not bring into existence a
new notice. It preserved the notices already issued and altered only their character:
a notice issued under the unamended Section 148 was to be read as a show cause
notice under Section 148A(b). The Assessing Officer was required to supply “the
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 9

information and material relied upon by the Revenue”. The expression looks
backward. It refers to the material on which the notice already issued was founded,
and not to material that the Assessing Officer may choose to add at a later stage.

18. The order of this Court dated 30.04.2026 is to the same effect. The
Revenue was directed “to proceed from the stage of the afore notice”. The starting
point was thus the notice dated 30.03.2021 as it stood, and not a fresh exercise.
Nothing in the order permitted the Revenue to amend or enlarge that notice.

19. It is well settled that a legal fiction is to be confined to the purpose for
which it is created and cannot be extended beyond it. A fiction must no doubt be
carried to its logical conclusion, but only within the bounds of that purpose. The
fiction in Ashish Agarwal was created to save notices issued under the wrong
procedure by enabling the assessees to answer them under the correct one. It was
not intended to give the Revenue a fresh opportunity, beyond the period of
limitation, to reopen an assessment on grounds not taken earlier. Carried to its
logical conclusion, the fiction carries the notice dated 30.03.2021 forward as it was,
with its foundation and its inherent limitations. The petitioner, who accepts the
fiction in that sense, does not approbate and reprobate. It is the Revenue that seeks
to stretch the fiction beyond its legitimate scope.

20. The foundation of the notice dated 30.03.2021 is to be found in the
Department’s own reasons dated 23.12.2021 (Annexure P-7). Under the regime in
force when that notice was issued, a reopening could rest only on the reasons
recorded before the notice was issued, and its validity had to be tested on those
reasons alone. The reasons cannot be supplemented later by fresh material or by
affidavit. The reasons in the present case identify a single amount, Rs.26,40,000/-
as having escaped assessment. The item of Rs.36,05,000/- finds no mention in
them. Significantly, the Insight Portal extract enclosed with the letter dated
08.05.2026 itself marks only the first item as “ Information already sent to AO ”.
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 10


21. The reasons do conclude with the words “as well as other income
which comes to the notice during the course of assessment proceedings ”. Those
words do not widen the foundation of the notice. They anticipate the power, once
an assessment has been validly reopened, to assess other income that comes to
notice in the course of the reassessment. They identify no information, no item and
no amount. They cannot, therefore, be a basis on which jurisdiction is assumed or
a monetary threshold under Section 149 is satisfied.

22. The respondents contend that both items were uploaded on the Insight
Portal on 07.03.2021, before the notice was issued. The upload date does appear
on record. However, the availability of information in the Department’s system is
distinct from reliance upon it. The relevant question is not what the Department
possessed, but what the Assessing Officer acted upon when he issued the notice.
That is found in the reasons, which are confined to Rs.26,40,000/-. The description
in the letter dated 08.05.2026 of both items as material “ relied upon for initiating
the proceedings ”, made more than five years later, cannot displace the
contemporaneous reasons.

23. The two items cannot be treated as one just because they deal with the
same topic. Both relate to share dealings in Financial Year 2012-13, but they are
separate pieces of information. They come from different sources, have different
upload IDs, describe different transactions and involve different amounts. Each
one is a separate claim that income escaped assessment, and each could, by itself,
either justify or fail to justify a reopening. The fact that both describe a similar
method of operation does not make one a part of the other.
The reasons for reopening do speak generally about bogus long-term
capital gains arranged through entry operators, but that does not change the
position. The reasons put the escaped income at Rs.26,40,000/-, and that figure
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 11

matches only the first item. If the respondents’ argument were accepted, any later
information of a similar kind could be added to a reopened assessment without any
time limit. Section 149 does not allow this.

24. The plea founded on natural justice is equally misconceived. The
obligation under Ashish Agarwal and Section 148A(b) was to disclose the
information on which the existing notice was founded, so that the assessee could
answer it. That obligation cannot be converted into a power to enlarge the notice.
Disclosure of the material underlying the first item would have fully met the
requirement. There was no question of suppressing anything, since the second item
was never part of the case which the petitioner was called upon to meet.

25. The contention that no “demand” has been raised also does not
advance the respondents’ case. The challenge is not to a demand but to the
jurisdiction of the Assessing Officer to reopen the assessment for this year. The
order under Section 148A(d) records a finding that Rs.62,45,000/- has escaped
assessment, and that finding is the sole basis on which the extended period of
limitation has been invoked. It is a jurisdictional finding, by whatever name it is
described.

26. Reliance on Section 147 is also misplaced. The power to assess
income in respect of an issue which comes to the notice of the Assessing Officer
subsequently in the course of the proceedings is exercisable only in a reassessment
under Section 147, after a valid notice under Section 148 has been issued. It cannot
be invoked at the stage of Section 148A to found jurisdiction, or to satisfy the
monetary threshold prescribed by Section 149.

27. Question (i) is accordingly answered in the negative. The deemed
show cause notice could carry only the case relating to Rs.26,40,000/-.



RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 12

Question (ii): Limitation qua Rs.36,05,000/-

28. As the item of Rs.36,05,000/- did not form part of the notice dated
30.03.2021, it cannot take shelter under that notice. It was put to the petitioner for
the first time on 08.05.2026. To that extent, the letter dated 08.05.2026 is, in
substance, a fresh show cause notice, and its limitation must be tested with
reference to that date. The respondents’ contention that the reference date is
30.03.2021 holds good for the matter covered by the deemed notice; it does not
extend to a new item introduced later.

29. So tested, the item of Rs.36,05,000/- is barred on every view. For
Assessment Year 2013-14, the period of three years under the substituted Section
149(1)(a) expired on 31.03.2017. The extended period of ten years under Section
149(1)(b), which is the outermost period under the substituted provision and is
available only where the escaped income amounts to Rs.50 lakh or more, expired
on 31.03.2024. The item of Rs.36,05,000/- is itself below Rs.50 lakh, so the
extended period is not available to it on its own. But even if it were, a notice issued
in May 2026 is beyond 31.03.2024. The first proviso to Section 149(1) leads to the
same result: under the unamended Section 149(1)(b), the six-year period expired
on 31.03.2020 and, even as extended by the Relaxation Act, came to an end on
30.06.2021.

30. The third proviso to Section 149(1) does not come to the aid of the
respondents. It excludes the time allowed to the assessee under a show cause notice
issued under Section 148A(b), and the period during which the proceeding under
Section 148A is stayed by an order or injunction of any court. The only proceeding
pending and stayed between 14.02.2022 and 30.04.2026 was the one founded on
Rs.26,40,000/-. No proceeding in respect of Rs.36,05,000/- was in existence, and
there could be no stay of a proceeding that did not exist. The exclusion of the period
between the deemed notice and the supply of material, recognised in Rajeev
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 13

Bansal , operates on the same principle. It restores to the Revenue the time lost in
respect of the notice actually issued, and does not extend that time to a new item.
Moreover, the stay began on 14.02.2022, well after the six-year period under the
unamended provision had come to an end on 30.06.2021.

31. Question (ii) is accordingly answered in the affirmative. The
proceeding in respect of Rs.36,05,000/- is barred by limitation.

Question (iii): Whether the proceeding survives on Rs.26,40,000/-

32. Once the item of Rs.36,05,000/- is excluded, the order under Section
148A(d) rests on Rs.26,40,000/- alone. As held in Rajeev Bansal , on which the
respondents themselves rely, a notice deemed to have been issued on or after
01.04.2021 for an assessment year preceding 2021-22 must satisfy both conditions
in the first proviso to Section 149(1): it must have been within time under the
unamended Section 149, and it must also be within the time prescribed by the
substituted Section 149(1). For Assessment Year 2013-14, more than three years
had elapsed well before 01.04.2021. Under the substituted Section 149(1)(b), a
notice beyond three years could be issued only where the income escaping
assessment, represented in the form of an asset, amounts to or is likely to amount
to Rs.50 lakh or more.

33. The respondents point out that the six-year period under the
unamended Section 149(1)(b), which expired on 31.03.2020, stood extended to
30.06.2021 by the Relaxation Act. The petitioner too has stated in her replication
that the notice dated 30.03.2021 was within the prescribed limitation. Assuming
the notice was dispatched within the extended period, that satisfies the first
condition. But it answers only half the question. The second condition is
independent and must also be met. Rs.26,40,000/- is far below the threshold of
Rs.50 lakh. The extended period was invoked in the order dated 25.06.2026 only
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 14

by aggregating the two items to arrive at Rs.62,45,000/-. The second item being
impermissible, the jurisdictional condition for the ten-year period is not satisfied.

34. The statement in the replication does not stand in the way of this
conclusion. Read in context, it relates to the unamended provision; in the same
paragraph the petitioner expressly denied that the ten-year limb was available,
because the information on which the notice could have been issued was only
Rs.26,40,000/-, which is less than Rs.50 lakh. In any event, a concession on a
question of law, particularly one going to jurisdiction, does not bind the party
making it or the Court. Ashish Agarwal and the order dated 30.04.2026 kept open
all defences under Section 149. The point was specifically raised, and the
respondents have met it: their entire case on the extended period rests on the
aggregate of Rs.62,45,000/- exceeding Rs.50 lakh.

35. The petition, as framed, assails the impugned action as time-barred
insofar as the escaped income has been enhanced, and also seeks any other
appropriate writ, order or direction. The order under Section 148A(d) and the
notice under Section 148 dated 25.06.2026 are single jurisdictional acts founded
on the aggregate of Rs.62,45,000/-. Once that foundation fails, and the remaining
amount cannot sustain the extended period, nothing survives that could be severed
and saved. Remitting the matter for a fresh order under Section 148A(d) confined
to Rs.26,40,000/- would be an empty formality, since any such order would be
barred on its face. The relief must be moulded accordingly.

36. Question (iii) is, therefore, answered in the negative.


Question (iv): Alternative remedy

37. The existence of an alternative remedy is no bar to the exercise of writ
jurisdiction where the authority has acted wholly without jurisdiction ( Whirlpool
Corporation v. Registrar of Trade Marks , (1998) 8 SCC 1). The bar of limitation
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 15

under Section 149 goes to the root of the jurisdiction of the Assessing Officer. The
respondents’ plea that the petition raises disputed questions of fact is not well
founded. The dates, the reasons dated 23.12.2021, the Insight Portal extracts and
the impugned order are all documents on record and are not in dispute; the
controversy turns only on their legal effect, which is a pure question of law. Nor
does the petitioner’s failure to reply to the letter dated 08.05.2026 disentitle her to
relief. Silence on her part cannot confer a jurisdiction which the statute denies, and
her pleas were in any case expressly preserved by the order dated 30.04.2026.
Relegating the petitioner to the Assessing Officer would only compel her to face
proceedings which are not sustainable in law. The objection is accordingly
rejected.


CONCLUSION

38. In light of the above discussion, we hold as follows:
(i) Where a notice is deemed to be a show cause notice under Section
148A(b), by virtue of Ashish Agarwal and this Court’s order dated
30.04.2026, it remains confined to the grounds on which it was
originally issued. The Assessing Officer may furnish the material on
which the original notice was based, but cannot use that opportunity

to bring in a fresh item of income alleged to have escaped assessment.
(ii) The notice dated 30.03.2021 was based only on the amount of
Rs.26,40,000/-. The amount of Rs.36,05,000/- was raised for the first
time on 08.05.2026. Raising a new item at that stage is, in substance,
the issue of a fresh notice, and its limitation must be tested with
reference to 08.05.2026, not 30.03.2021. So tested, it is barred on
every view: the ten-year period for Assessment Year 2013-14 expired
on 31.03.2024, and the six-year period under the unamended
RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.20141 of 2026 (O&M) 16

provision, even as extended, ended on 30.06.2021. The exclusion of
time under the third proviso to Section 149(1) does not help the
Revenue, because that benefit attaches only to the matter covered by
the original notice and cannot be extended to a new item introduced

later.
(iii) Once the amount of Rs.36,05,000/- is excluded, the income alleged to
have escaped assessment is only Rs.26,40,000/-. This falls short of the
Rs.50 lakh threshold under Section 149(1)(b), which, as held in
Rajeev Bansal , a deemed notice for an earlier assessment year must

satisfy. The reassessment proceedings, therefore, cannot be sustained.


39. Consequently, the writ petition is allowed. The notice dated
08.05.2026 issued under Section 148A(b) (Annexure P-15), the order dated
25.06.2026 passed under Section 148A(d) (Annexure P-16), and the notice dated
25.06.2026 issued under Section 148 (Annexure P-17) are hereby quashed, along
with all consequential proceedings for Assessment Year 2013-14.

40. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.

41. There shall be no order as to costs.



( DEEPAK SIBAL )
JUDGE
( SUNISH BINDLISH )
JUDGE
November 20, 2026
rps
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No

RATTAN PAL SINGH
2026.11.20 15:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document