Neelam Sharma vs Amita Passan

Court
Supreme Court

REPORTABLE
2026 INSC 913

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) No.31540 of 2025)


NEELAM SHARMA AND OTHERS …APPELLANTS

VERSUS

AMITA PASSAN AND OTHERS …RESPONDENTS



J U D G M E N T


N.V. ANJARIA, J.


Leave granted.
1.1 Heard learned counsel Mr. Amit Aggarwal for the
appellants and learned Senior Counsel Mr. Manoj Swarup
for the respondents.
2. The appellants herein are the original plaintiffs. The
present appeal is directed against order dated 19.05.2025
passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at
1
Chandigarh in Civil Revision Petition No. 2778 of 2022
(O&M). Thereby, the High Court allowed the Revision
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
SNEHA DAS
Date: 2026.08.22
20:09:01 IST
Reason:

1
Hereinafter, “High Court”

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 1 of 13

Petition and set aside the order dated 12.04.2022 passed by
the Court of Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division),
2
Panchkula .
2.1
The Trial Court dismissed the application under
3
Order VII Rule 11, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 , filed by
defendant No. 2 in Civil Suit No. 379 of 2017. In the said
application, the ground raised seeking rejection of the plaint
was that, having regard to the nature of the suit and the
prayers, the plaintiffs were liable to pay ad-valorem court fee
on the plaint. The Trial Court negatived the said contention,
however, the High Court allowed the Revision Petition by
recording a finding that the plaintiffs were required to affix
ad-valorem court fee. The High Court granted time to the
plaintiffs to pay the ad-valorem court fee, to further provide
that failing the same, the plaint shall stand rejected.
3. Noticing the facts relating to the suit of the
plaintiffs, what was asked for in the suit was a decree of
declaration that plaintiffs, defendant No.1 as well as
defendant No.2, were the co-owners of the suit property

2
Hereinafter, “Trial Court”
3
Hereinafter, “CPC”

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 2 of 13

described as House No. 417, Ground Floor, Sector 11,
th
Panchkula and had 1/4 share each therein. The further
prayer was to declare that defendant No.1 got the house
transferred by playing fraud on plaintiffs and that the
transfer was null and void. The plaintiffs prayed for separate
th
possession to the extent of 1/4 share each in the suit
property. The plaintiffs also prayed for consequential relief
of permanent injunction.
3.1 In the aforementioned suit, defendant No.2 moved
an application under Order VII Rule 11, CPC, seeking
rejection of the plaint, contending inter-alia that the
plaintiffs had claimed separate possession by partition of the
suit property, and since the plaintiffs were neither the owner
nor were in possession, they were required to affix ad-
valorem court fee on the market value of the suit house. It
was contended that the plaintiffs having not paid the ad-
valorem court fee, the plaint was liable to be rejected on that
ground.
3.2 The said application for rejection of the plaint was
resisted by the plaintiffs stating that the suit property was

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 3 of 13

an inherited property and that the plaintiffs were co-owners.
It was the case of the plaintiffs that they were not the party
in the transfer deed which they had challenged. The ad-
valorem court fee was not required to be paid but only fixed
stamp duty was payable, it was contended. It was also
contended that since defendant No.1 had transferred the
property without paying any stamp duty on the same, and
that the alleged transfer deed did not reflect any value of the
property, the ad-valorem court fee was not required to be
paid for that reason also.

3.3 The Trial Court, while rejecting the application of
defendant No.2 under Order VII Rule 11, CPC, rested on the
position of law that while deciding application under Order
VII Rule 11, CPC, the court could look into the averments in
the plaint only and that the plaint cannot be rejected on the
basis of allegations made in the written statement of the
defendant. The Trial Court, upon perusal of the averments
in the plaint as well as having regard to the nature of relief
prayed for, observed that the plaintiffs had been seeking
relief of declaration and separate possession, claiming that
they were in joint possession of the property.

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 4 of 13

3.4 It was observed that the plaintiffs had been claiming
th
1/4 share each in the entire suit house and had further
challenged the letter of allotment stated to have been
fraudulently received in respect of the suit property
practicing fraud and misrepresentation upon the plaintiffs
in which letter of allotment value of the property was not
indicated nor any court fee was paid.
3.5 The Trial Court relied on the decision of this Court
in Suhrid Singh alias Sardool Singh vs. Randhir Singh
4
and Others and on the basis of proposition of law laid down
therein, the Trial Court stated that the plaintiffs were not
executant of the document namely transfer deed/letter of
allotment nor were party to the same, and for all those
reasons they were not liable to pay ad-valorem court fee.
3.6 The High Court, while allowing the civil revision
petition at the instance of defendant No.2, took the contrary
view to proceed to hold as under,
“A perusal of the heading of the plaint, the prayer
made therein and the averments made in the plaint
show that it was the pleaded case of the
respondents-plaintiffs that they were not in
possession of the suit property and, therefore, they

4
(2010) 12 SCC 112

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 5 of 13

had prayed for separate possession as per their
share. The Trial Court, in the considered opinion of
this Court, erred in coming to the conclusion that
no prayer for possession had been made.

Once the possession had been prayed for, the
respondents-plaintiffs were liable to affix ad
valorem Court fee as per their share, in accordance
with the provisions of the Court Fees Act, 1870.

In view of the above, the revision petition is
allowed. The impugned order dated 12.04.2022 is
set aside. The application under Order 7 Rule 11
CPC is allowed and is directed that the requisite
Court Fees be deposited within a period of two
weeks failing which, the plaint shall stand
rejected.”

3.7 According to the High Court, the averments in the
plaint showed that the plaintiffs were not in possession of
the suit property, therefore, they had prayed for separate
possession and in that view, once the possession had been
prayed for, the plaintiffs were liable to affix the ad-valorem
court fee, as per their share in accordance with the provision
5
of the Court Fees Act, 1870 .
4. While appreciating the correctness or otherwise of
the observations and findings of the High Court, it would be
worthwhile to look into the case of the plaintiffs in the suit.
The case of the plaintiffs was inter-alia that one late Pushpa

5
Hereinafter, “Act”

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 6 of 13

Sharma, wife of late Ved Parkash Sharma and grandmother
of plaintiffs Nos. 2 to 4 and 6 to 8, purchased the suit
property out of the joint funds of the family and from her
Stridhan . It was averred that after some years, Nishikant
Sharma, husband of plaintiff No.1 and father of plaintiff
Nos.2 to 4 shifted to Chandigarh and started tuition work
and that plaintiff Nos.5 to 8 were also shifted to Ludhiana
after some years. It was stated that defendant No.1 along
with his family remained in the same house with late
Pushpa Sharma who died on 01.09.2007. Pushpa Sharma
never executed any Will nor transferred the house to
anybody during her lifetime, it was stated.
4.1 It was the further case of the plaintiffs that they
came to know that one of the family members Rajeev
Sharma used to take signatures of his mother Pushpa
Sharma on blank papers under one or another pretext. It
was averred that somewhere in August 2016, Rajeev
Sharma had got the suit property transferred in his name in
collusion with defendant No.2 and other persons, by forging
false documents and producing the same at the Haryana
Housing Board office. The fraud was perpetuated against the

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 7 of 13

plaintiffs by taking a loan of Rs.1,50,00,000/- from Yes
Bank by mortgaging the suit property and subsequently not
making the re-payment. The plaintiffs’ case was that they
were the co-owners in joint possession of the suit property
in capacity of heirs of late Pushpa Sharma.
4.2 The following averments were made in paragraph 4
of the plaint asserting residence in and possession of the
suit property along with the defendants, quoted hereinbelow
to be precise,
“4. That after the purchase of the said house, the
plaintiffs and defendants started residing in the
MIG-A, House No. 417, Sector 11, Panchkula (i.e.
suit property) as the said property was the joint
properties of the plaintiffs and defendants. That it
is pertinent to mention here that the plaintiffs and
defendants invested the amount in the said house
in the repair and extension of the house from time
to time”


4.3 Both the Trial Court and the High Court referred to
the decision of this Court in Suhrid Singh (supra) on the
question of payment of court-fee, the Trial Court taking the
view that the ad-valorem court fee was not payable, whereas
the High Court held otherwise and conditionally rejected the

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 8 of 13

plaint if the ad-valorem court fee is not paid within the
stipulated time.
5. It is well-settled principle that while considering the
prayer in the application under Order VII Rule 11, CPC, the
court has to consider the averments in the plaint only. Given
this trite position of law, when in the instant case, the
averments in the plaint are looked at in their entirety, more
particularly, in paragraph 4 of the plaint quoted
hereinabove, there is no gainsaying that it is stated by
plaintiffs that after purchase of the suit property, along with
defendants they resided therein, thereby pleading
unequivocally that they were in joint possession. The whole
suit and the prayers were based on the possession of the
plaintiffs of the suit property. Prima facie , therefore, no
aspect existed which would have persuaded the court to
reject the plaint at the threshold by accepting the case of
defendant No.2 in his application under Order VII Rule 11,
CPC, that the ad-valorem court fee was payable.
5.1 Now, the payability of court fee in the States of
Punjab and Haryana is admittedly governed under the
provisions of the Act. Suhrid Singh (supra) was the case

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 9 of 13

which dealt with the provisions of the very Act. The facts
before the court inter-alia were that the plaintiff in suit had
sought for declaration that the sale deeds were void and not
binding on the co-parcenery. A consequential relief of joint
possession was sought for. This Court noticed that there
was no prayer for cancellation of the sale deeds and the
prayer was for declaration that the deeds did not bind the
co-parcenery and that there was a joint possession.
Furthermore, it was highlighted that the plaintiff in the suit
was not the executant of the sale deeds.

5.2 It was accordingly held that the court fee was
computable under Section 7(iv)(c) of the Act, and the plaintiff
was required to pay the merely fixed court fee under Article
17(iii) of the Second Schedule of the Act. If the plaintiff was
seeking possession and not merely a declaration, he would
be required to pay the court fee on ad-valorem basis.
5.3 The position was explained in paragraph 6,
“Where the executant of a deed wants it to be
annulled, he has to seek cancellation of the deed.
But if a non-executant seeks annulment of a deed,
he has to seek a declaration that the deed is invalid,
or non est, or illegal or that it is not binding on him.
The difference between a prayer for cancellation
and declaration in regard to a deed of

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 10 of 13

transfer/conveyance, can be brought out by the
following illustration relating to A and B , two
brothers. A executes a sale deed in favour of C .
Subsequently A wants to avoid the sale. A has to
sue for cancellation of the deed. On the other hand,
if B , who is not the executant of the deed, wants to
avoid it, he has to sue for a declaration that the
deed executed by A is invalid/void and non
est/illegal and he is not bound by it. In essence
both may be suing to have the deed set aside or
declared as non-binding. But the form is different
and court fee is also different. If A , the executant of
the deed, seeks cancellation of the deed, he has to
pay ad valorem court fee on the consideration
stated in the sale deed. If B , who is a non-
executant, is in possession and sues for a
declaration that the deed is null or void and does
not bind him or his share, he has to merely pay a
fixed court fee of Rs. 19.50 under Article 17( iii ) of
the Second Schedule of the Act. But if B , a non-
executant, is not in possession, and he seeks not
only a declaration that the sale deed is invalid, but
also the consequential relief of possession, he has
to pay an ad valorem court fee as provided under
Section 7( iv )( c ) of the Act.”
(Para 6)

6. Now, considering the suit averments and the suit
prayers in the instant case, as also the proposition of law
emanating from the decision in Suhrid Singh (supra), the
Court is of the view that looking to the suit averments, the
plaint is not liable to be rejected on the ground pleaded
under Order VII Rule 11, CPC. The Trial Court was justified
in law in refusing to reject the plaint. The High Court,
however, fell in error in issuing the impugned directions.

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 11 of 13

6.1 While the case of the plaintiffs in the plaint about
they being in joint possession and the assertive statements
on that score would not justify the rejection of the plaint
even on the ground stated in the application under Order
VII Rule 11, CPC. The question of payment of court fee will
have to be looked into in segregation, for, the same would
depend upon not only the possession aspect or the prayer in
that regard, but also the aspects relating to the sale deed
claimed to have been executed and the other facts relevant
thereto. They are the issues to be threshed out on evidence.
Therefore, the question of payment of court fee, whether ad
valorem or fixed court fee, could be addressed and
considered only upon establishment of such germane facts
upon leading of evidence in the suit.
6.2 In the light as aforesaid, the Court is of the view that
the question of payability of the court fee is required to be
deferred to be considered and shall depend upon the
evidence which may finally be led establishing the
determinative facts in that regard.

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 12 of 13

6.3 For the foregoing discussion and reasons, the
impugned order of the High Court dated 19.05.2025 passed
in Civil Revision Petition No. 2778 of 2022 (O&M) is hereby
set aside. The order of the Trial Court refusing the prayer to
reject the plaint under Order VII Rule 11, CPC, is upheld,
however, subject to the modification that the question of
payment of court fee would be considered and decided, after
and on the basis of the evidence that may be led in the suit.
7. The present appeal is allowed in the aforesaid terms
and directions.
Any interlocutory application, as may be pending, shall
not survive in view of disposal of the main appeal.


.………………………...J.
[S.V.N. BHATTI]



………………………….J.
[N.V. ANJARIA]
NEW DELHI;
AUGUST 21, 2026.

Civil Appeal @ SLP (C) No. 31540 of 2025
Page 13 of 13