Pallo Devi & Anr vs Rahish Pal & Ors
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
FAO-6093-2014 (O&M),
FAO-10440-2014 &
FAO-5419-2013 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
i) FAO-6093-2014 (O&M)
Pallo Devi and another ...Appellants
Versus
Rahish Pal and others ...Respondents
ii) FAO-10440-2014
Pallo Devi and another ...Appellants
Versus
Rahish Pal and others ...Respondents
iii) FAO-5419-2013 (O&M)
National Insurance Company Limited ...Appellant
Versus
Pallo Devi and others ...Respondents
Reserved on: 17.11.2026
Pronounced on: 18.11.2026
Pronounced fully/operative part: Fully
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK GUPTA
Argued by: Mr. Brijender Kaushik, Advocate for the appellants.
Mr. Lalit Garg, Advocate for the Insurance Company.
DEEPAK GUPTA, J.
This common order shall dispose of three appeals arising out of
the common award dated 16.08.2013 passed by the learned Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Panchkula (hereinafter referred to as 'the Tribunal'), whereby
two claim petitions under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for
short, 'the Act'), relating to the deaths of Peer Diya and Mamta Devi in the
same motor vehicular accident, were decided.
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 14:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 1 of Total 9 Pages
FAO-6093-2014 (O&M),
FAO-10440-2014 &
FAO-5419-2013 (O&M)
2. Two appeals [FAO-10440-2014 & FAO-6093-2014] have been
preferred by the claimants seeking enhancement of compensation, whereas
the third appeal [FAO-5419-2013] has been filed by the insurance company
challenging the multiplier adopted by the Tribunal in the case relating to the
death of Peer Diya.
3. Briefly, on 15.08.2011, Peer Diya and Mamta Devi were travelling
on a motorcycle towards village Sunderpur. At about 3:30 PM, when they
reached near Sangam Poultry Farm in the area of village Mouli, a truck bearing
registration No.HP-12-C-4386, driven by respondent No.1 rashly and
negligently, struck the motorcycle, resulting in fatal injuries to both of them.
Mamta Devi died at the spot, whereas Peer Diya succumbed to his injuries at
PGI, Chandigarh. The claimants, namely Pallo Devi and Dharam Pal, being the
parents of Peer Diya and parents-in-law of Mamta Devi, instituted separate
claim petitions seeking compensation.
4. The Tribunal, on appreciation of the evidence, held that the
accident had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the offending truck.
In the case relating to Peer Diya, aged 32 years, the Tribunal assessed his
monthly income at ₹5,000/-, added 30% towards future prospects, deducted
one-half towards personal expenses and applied multiplier of 16.
Compensation of ₹6,54,000/- was awarded. In the case relating to Mamta
Devi, aged about 25 years, the Tribunal awarded compensation of merely
₹75,000/-, comprising ₹50,000/- towards compensation for her death and
₹25,000/- towards funeral and last rites expenses. Interest at the rate of 7.5%
per annum from the date of filing of the respective claim petitions till
realisation was also awarded.
5. Seeking enhancement, Learned counsel appearing for the
claimants submits that the compensation awarded in both cases is inadequate.
It is contended that Peer Diya was working as a mason and earning ₹12,000/-
per month, but the Tribunal assessed his income at a substantially lower
figure. Besides, future prospects were wrongly restricted to 30%. In the case
relating to Mamta Devi, it is submitted that she was a young home-maker and
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 14:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 2 of Total 9 Pages
FAO-6093-2014 (O&M),
FAO-10440-2014 &
FAO-5419-2013 (O&M)
was also earning approximately ₹8,000/- per month by selling milk from
buffaloes. The Tribunal, however, failed to recognise the economic value of
her household services and restricted compensation to a nominal amount
merely because the claimants were her parents-in-law. Reliance is placed upon
N. Jayasree and others v. Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company
Limited, (2022) 14 SCC 712.
6. On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the insurance
company supports the assessment of compensation and submits that no
reliable evidence regarding the alleged earnings of either deceased was
produced. It is further contended that, in the case relating to Peer Diya, the
Tribunal ought to have applied multiplier of 11 corresponding to the age of his
mother, instead of multiplier of 16 based on the age of the deceased.
Regarding Mamta Devi, it is argued that the claimants, being her parents-in-
law, were not proved to be financially dependent upon her and, therefore, no
compensation towards loss of dependency is payable. Reliance is placed upon
ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Limited v. Minakshi Shantilal
Valand (Sharma), SLP(C) No.2918 of 2022, decided on 15.05.2025, and New
India Assurance Company Limited v. Anand Pal and others, SLP(C) No.7805 of
2022, decided on 04.12.2023.
7. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and examined the
award, this Court finds that the primary questions requiring consideration are
the correctness of the multiplier adopted in the case relating to Peer Diya and
the adequacy of compensation awarded in both claim petitions.
8. The finding regarding rash and negligent driving of the offending
truck, as also the liability of its driver, owner and insurer, has not been
challenged on any other ground and, therefore, calls for no interference.
Appeal relating to the death of Peer Diya -
9. The contention raised on behalf of the insurance company
regarding selection of multiplier is no longer res integra. In Sarla Verma and
others v. Delhi Transport Corporation and another, (2009) 6 SCC 121, the
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 14:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 3 of Total 9 Pages
FAO-6093-2014 (O&M),
FAO-10440-2014 &
FAO-5419-2013 (O&M)
Hon'ble Supreme Court standardised the selection of multiplier with reference
to the age of the deceased. The said principle was subsequently affirmed by
the Constitution Bench in National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay
Sethi and others, (2017) 16 SCC 680 . Further, in Munna Lal Jain and another v.
Vipin Kumar Sharma and others, (2015) 6 SCC 347 , it was specifically clarified
that the multiplier is to be selected with reference to the age of the deceased
and not that of the dependents.
10. Thus, the submission that multiplier of 11 ought to have been
applied on the basis of the age of the mother of Peer Diya is contrary to the
settled legal position. The deceased was aged 32 years at the time of the
accident. Accordingly, multiplier of 16, as adopted by the Tribunal, is correct
and does not warrant interference. The appeal [FAO-5419-2013] filed by the
insurance company, therefore, deserves dismissal.
11. Coming to the claimants' appeal, the Tribunal assessed the
income of Peer Diya at ₹5,000/- per month, treating him as a daily wager,
notwithstanding the assertion that he was working as a mason and earning
₹12,000/- per month. Admittedly, no documentary evidence regarding his
actual earnings was produced. In the absence of reliable evidence establishing
higher earnings, the assessment of ₹5,000/- per month made by the Tribunal
cannot be termed unreasonable for the accident of the year 2011 and is,
therefore, maintained.
12. However, the Tribunal added only 30% towards future prospects.
In view of the law laid down in Pranay Sethi (supra), a person below 40 years
of age, being self-employed or on fixed wages, is entitled to an addition of 40%
towards future prospects. Consequently, the monthly income of the deceased,
for the purpose of computation, is reassessed at ₹7,000/- (₹5,000 + 40%).
13. The deceased was married, but his wife Mamta Devi died in the
same accident. His mother was the sole claimant in the claim petition relating
to his death. The deduction of one-half towards personal and living expenses,
as adopted by the Tribunal, is accordingly maintained. Applying multiplier of
YOGESH MEHTA 16, the loss of dependency comes to ₹6,72,000/-.
2026.11.18 14:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 4 of Total 9 Pages
FAO-6093-2014 (O&M),
FAO-10440-2014 &
FAO-5419-2013 (O&M)
14. Both parents of deceased Peer Diya are entitled to filial
consortium of ₹40,000/- each, notwithstanding that only the mother was
found financially dependent upon him. The entitlement to filial consortium is
distinct from compensation towards loss of dependency. In view of the
principles laid down in Magma General Insurance Company Limited v. Nanu
Ram alias Chuhru Ram and others, (2018) 18 SCC 130, and United India
Insurance Company Limited v. Satinder Kaur alias Satwinder Kaur and others,
(2021) 11 SCC 780, compensation of ₹40,000/- each is allowed to the parents.
15. Having regard to the accident having occurred on 15.08.2011, the
conventional amounts are retained at ₹40,000/- towards consortium and
₹15,000/- each towards loss of estate and funeral expenses, without applying
subsequent periodical enhancement.
16. As such, the compensation is reassessed as follows:
Head Amount
Monthly income ₹5,000
Future prospects (40%) ₹2,000
Monthly income after addition ₹7,000
Deduction towards personal expenses (50%) ₹3,500
Annual dependency ₹42,000
Loss of dependency (₹42,000 × 16) ₹6,72,000
Filial consortium (40,000 x 2) ₹80,000
Loss of estate ₹15,000
Funeral expenses ₹15,000
Total compensation ₹7,82,000
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 14:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 5 of Total 9 Pages
FAO-6093-2014 (O&M),
FAO-10440-2014 &
FAO-5419-2013 (O&M)
Compensation awarded by Tribunal ₹6,54,000
Enhancement ₹1,28,000
17. Accordingly, the compensation in the case relating to the death of
Peer Diya is enhanced from ₹6,54,000/- to ₹7,82,000/-.
Appeal relating to the death of Mamta Devi -
18. The appeal relating to the death of Mamta Devi requires separate
consideration. The Tribunal noticed that she was aged about 25 years and was
engaged in household activities. It was also pleaded that she was earning
approximately ₹8,000/- per month by selling milk from buffaloes. However,
the Tribunal declined to assess any pecuniary loss on the ground that the
claimants were her parents-in-law and could not be treated as financially
dependent upon her. Consequently, compensation was restricted to ₹75,000/-
. The approach adopted by the Tribunal, in the considered opinion of this
Court, is unduly restrictive.
19. In Arun Kumar Agrawal and another v. National Insurance
Company Limited and others, (2010) 9 SCC 218 , the Hon'ble Supreme Court
recognised the substantial economic value of services rendered by a home-
maker. The said principle was reiterated in Kirti and another v. Oriental
wherein it was held that the
Insurance Company Limited, (2021) 2 SCC 166,
contribution of a home-maker cannot be treated as having no monetary value
merely because such services are rendered without remuneration. The
assessment of notional income in such cases is permissible, and future
prospects may also be added thereto.
20. Learned counsel for the claimants has relied upon N. Jayasree
and others v. Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Limited,
(2022) 14 SCC 712. In the said case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court recognised the
entitlement of a mother-in-law, who was residing with and dependent upon
the deceased, to be treated as a legal representative for the purpose of
claiming compensation. It was emphasised that the expression 'legal
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 14:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 6 of Total 9 Pages
FAO-6093-2014 (O&M),
FAO-10440-2014 &
FAO-5419-2013 (O&M)
representative' under the Act is not to be construed narrowly and that the
actual relationship and circumstances of the family are relevant
considerations.
21. On the other hand, learned counsel for the insurer has relied
upon ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Limited v. Minakshi
Shantilal Valand (Sharma) and others, Civil Appeal No.6860 of 2025, arising
out of SLP(C) No.2918 of 2022, decided on 15.05.2025 , wherein compensation
towards loss of dependency was disallowed in favour of a married sister in the
absence of established financial dependency. Reliance has also been placed
upon New India Assurance Company Limited v. Anand Pal and others, Civil
Appeal arising out of SLP(C) No.7805 of 2022, decided on 04.12.2023, wherein
the Hon'ble Supreme Court declined to recognise older married brothers,
having separate families and residences, as dependents merely on account of
occasional assistance received from the deceased.
22. There can be no dispute with the proposition that the status of a
legal representative does not automatically establish financial dependency.
However, the aforesaid judgments relied upon by the insurer are
distinguishable on facts. Those cases concerned claims founded upon alleged
dependency on the earnings of the deceased. The present case additionally
involves the economic value of services rendered by a young home-maker. The
absence of proved monetary earnings cannot, by itself, justify treating her
contribution as nil. At the same time, the fact that Mamta Devi rendered
household services does not automatically establish that the entire economic
value of those services represented a loss suffered by her mother-in-law. The
extent of such loss must be assessed reasonably on the circumstances
established.
23. Mamta Devi was admittedly a home-maker. Apart from attending
to domestic responsibilities, it was asserted that she was also engaged in
selling milk from buffaloes. Although the precise earnings from the latter
activity were not established, the evidence regarding her household activities
cannot be ignored. The Tribunal did not examine the economic value of those
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 14:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 7 of Total 9 Pages
FAO-6093-2014 (O&M),
FAO-10440-2014 &
FAO-5419-2013 (O&M)
services and rejected the claim principally on the ground of relationship and
absence of financial dependency. That approach cannot be sustained. The
claimant-mother-in-law's entitlement to compensation for loss of household
services must, however, be distinguished from an automatic entitlement to
the deceased's entire notional income.
24. Having regard to the age of Mamta Devi, the accident having
occurred in 2011, and the nature of her domestic responsibilities, her notional
income is reasonably assessed at ₹5,000/- per month. An addition of 40%
towards future prospects is permissible in view of Kirti (supra). Since the
deceased was aged about 25 years, multiplier of 18 is applicable. For assessing
the pecuniary loss attributable to household services available to the claimant-
mother-in-law, one-half of the assessed value is taken as a reasonable
measure, rather than treating the whole of the notional income as her
personal loss.
25. The claimant-mother-in-law is also entitled to consortium in
accordance with the principles recognised in Magma General Insurance
Company Limited (supra) read with Satinder Kaur (supra) . Compensation
towards loss of estate and funeral expenses is also admissible.
26. The compensation is accordingly reassessed as follows:
Head Amount
Notional monthly income ₹5,000
Future prospects (40%) ₹2,000
Monthly income after addition ₹7,000
Portion attributable to claimant's loss of household
₹3,500
services (50%)
Annual pecuniary loss ₹42,000
Multiplier 18
Loss of household services (₹42,000 × 18) ₹7,56,000
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 14:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 8 of Total 9 Pages
FAO-6093-2014 (O&M),
FAO-10440-2014 &
FAO-5419-2013 (O&M)
Consortium to claimant-mother-in-law ₹40,000
Loss of estate ₹15,000
Funeral expenses ₹15,000
Total compensation ₹8,26,000
Compensation awarded by Tribunal ₹75,000
Enhancement ₹7,51,000
27. Accordingly, the compensation in the case relating to the death of
Mamta Devi is enhanced from ₹75,000/- to ₹8,26,000/-.
Conclusion
28. In view of the foregoing discussion, the appeal filed by the
insurance company is dismissed, whereas the two appeals filed by the
claimants are partly allowed. The compensation awarded on account of the
death of Peer Diya is enhanced from ₹6,54,000/- to ₹7,82,000/-, while the
compensation awarded on account of the death of Mamta Devi is enhanced
from ₹75,000/- to ₹8,26,000/-.
29. The enhanced amounts shall carry interest at the rate of 7.5% per
annum from the date of filing of the respective claim petitions till actual
realisation, as awarded by the Tribunal. The liability to satisfy the awards shall
remain as determined by the Tribunal. The amounts already paid or deposited
shall be adjusted. The enhanced compensation shall be released to the
entitled claimants in accordance with law.
30. All three appeals stand disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand disposed of. A
photocopy of this order be placed on the file of connected cases.
18.11.2026 (DEEPAK GUPTA)
Yogesh JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
YOGESH MEHTA Uploaded on: 18.11.2026
2026.11.18 14:48
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 9 of Total 9 Pages