SUKUMAR DEYASHI AND ANR vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present : The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
&
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi
W.P.L.R.T. 102 of 2026
Sri Sukumar Deyashi and Anr.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal and Ors.
For the petitioners : Mr. Ram Chandra Guchhait, Adv.
For the State : Mr. Nilanjan Bhattacharjee,
Senior Standing Counsel,
Ms. Jayita Dhar Chakraborty,
Mr. Suman Banerjee, Advs.
Heard on : November 20, 2026.
Judgment on : November 20, 2026.
Md. Shabbar Rashidi , J. :
1.
The present writ petition has been filed by the petitioners
assailing a judgment and order passed by the West Bengal Land
2
Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal in OA no. 150 of 2012 (LRTT) on
May 13, 2026.
2.
The present petitioners trace their title from one Harimati Dasi,
who was recorded as a possessor in the CS Records of Rights in
respect of the suit properties. Subsequently, the said Harimati Dasi
was recorded as a raiyat in the RS ROR in respect of the suit
properties. It has been submitted that the said Harimati Dasi settled
the suit properties by way of two separate deeds of settlement as
well as a deed of gift. After acquiring such properties through the
ways indicated above, the present petitioners became owners in
respect of the suit properties.
3.
It is further submitted by the advocate for the petitioners that
subsequently the State started a proceeding under Section 44(2a)
of the West Bengal Estates Acquisition Act, 1953. By an order
passed in the said proceeding, the RS Records of Rights in respect
of the suit properties were rectified. It was alleged in the said
proceeding that the suit properties were transferred after the vesting
of the suit properties to the State. It was contended that the present
petitioners were post-vesting transferees of the suit land and as
such, they did not acquire any right, title and interest in respect of
the same.
3
4.
Learned advocate for the petitioners further submit that after
acquiring the suit properties by the deeds of gift as well as the
settlement, the petitioners approached the authorities for recording
their names in respect of the suit properties in the LR Records of
Rights. Subsequently, the petitioners also filed a civil suit before a
Civil Court praying for declaration of their right, title and interest in
respect of the suit properties. The State was a party to such suit.
The State appeared in the suit and filed its written statement.
However, subsequently, the State did not contest the suit.
Accordingly, the suit was decreed ex parte in favour of the present
petitioners, declaring their right, title and interest in respect of the
suit properties.
5.
Learned Senior Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of the
State submits that the State was entitled to rectify the entries in the
Records of Rights in terms of the provisions contained in Section
44(2a) of the Act of 1953.
6. Learned Senior Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of the
State further submits that in any case, the original owner Smt.
Harimati Dasi did not submit her option in Form B to retain the suit
properties. He further submits that the suit for declaration of title
filed on behalf of the petitioners was in effect a suit for correction of
4
the Records of Rights which is barred under Section 57B of the Act
of 1953.
7.
Having heard the submissions on behalf of the learned advocate
for the petitioners as well as the learned Senior Standing Counsel
appearing for the State, it appears that the suit property was initially
recorded in the CS Records of Rights in the name of the
predecessor-in-interest of the petitioners i.e. Smt. Harimati Dasi as
a possessor thereof. Subsequently, her name was recorded in the
RS ROR as a raiyat in respect of the suit properties. The present
petitioners acquired the entire suit properties by dint of the deed of
settlement as well as the deed of gift executed by the successor-in-
interest of the said Harimati Dasi.
8.
In the impugned judgment and order, the learned Tribunal, while
considering the application of Section 57B of the Act of 1953, held
as follows:-
“Borrowing wisdom from the ratio of the decision referred to
above, we do conclude that there is no scope to consider the
judgment and decree of the Title Suit being No. 60 of 1993, for
correction of record-of-rights in respect of the subject land,
particularly when the applicants are post vesting transferees. As a
logical corollary, we do hold that question of inaction in the matter
5
of correction record-of-rights does not arise, when the prescribed
Authority has no scope to take action for correction of record-of-
right in respect of the subject land which had vested to the State.
So we are not inclined to issue any abortive order in connection
with alleged inaction. Hence, the Original Application being OA No.
150 of 2012 is dismissed on contest. No costs of hearing.”
9. Apparently, the name of the predecessor-in-interest of the
present petitioners was recorded in respect of the suit properties in
the CS Records of Rights as well as RS Records of Rights. The
said Records of Rights and more specifically, the RS Records of
Rights has been sought to be corrected on behalf of the State in
terms of a proceeding initiated under Section 44(2a) of the Act of
1953.
10. Section 44(2a) of the Act reads as follows:-
“44 (2a) An officer specially empowered by the State
Government may, on application within nine months, or of his own
motion within [sixty years], from the date of final publication of the
record-of-rights or from the date of coming into force of the West
Bengal Estates Acquisition (Second Amendment) Ordinance, 1957
(West Ben. Ord. X of 1957), whichever is later, revise an entry in
the record finally published in accordance with the provisions of sub
6
section (2) after giving the persons interested an opportunity of
being heard and after recording reasons therefor:
Provided that nothing in the foregoing paragraph shall be deemed
to empower such officer to modify or cancel any order passed
under section 5A, while revising any entry:
Provided further that no such officer shall entertain any application
under this sub-section or shall of his own motion take steps to
revise any entry, if an appeal against an order passed by a
Revenue Officer on any objection made under sub-section (1), has
been filed before the commencement of the West Bengal Estates
Acquisition (Second Amendment) Ordinance, 1957, before a
tribunal appointed for the purpose of this section, and,
notwithstanding anything in this section, any such appeal may
continue and be heard and disposed of as if the West Bengal
Estates Acquisition (Second Amendment) Ordinance, 1957, had
not been promulgated.”
11. As it transpires from the provisions of Section 44(2a), it clearly
stipulates that the State may revise an entry in the records finally
published in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (2) after
7
giving the persons interested an opportunity of being heard and
after recording reasons thereof.
12.
It has been specifically stated in the case at hand that no notice
whatsoever was ever served upon the petitioners or the original
owners in respect of such proceeding. They were denied the
opportunity of being heard as stipulated in the provisions of Section
44(2a).
13. The petitioners approached for declaration of their right and title
over the suit properties before a civil court. A competent civil court
passed a decree for declaration of right and title over the suit
properties in favour of the present petitioners. The learned Tribunal
proceeded to impose a bar under Section 57B of the Act of 1953
after a valid decree for declaration of right and title of the petitioners
over the suit properties was passed by a competent civil court. We
do hold that a bar under Section 57B of the Act of 1953 is not
applicable in respect of a suit for declaration of title and
consequential reliefs.
14. In that view of the matter, the learned Tribunal acted beyond
jurisdiction by sitting in judgment over a decree passed by a
competent civil court declaring the right and title of the present
petitioners in respect of the suit properties.
8
15. Accordingly, the impugned judgment and order passed by the
learned Tribunal is hereby set aside. The Block Land and Land
Reforms Officer, Amta, Howrah is directed to incorporate the name
of the applicants in the Records of Rights in respect of the suit
properties.
16. W.P.L.R.T. no. 102 of 2026 is accordingly allowed by setting
aside the impugned judgment and order passed in OA 150 of 2012
(LRTT).
17. There will be no order as to costs.
18.
Urgent photostat certified copies of this judgment, if applied for,
be supplied to the parties upon compliance of all requisite
formalities.
I agree. ( Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J .)
( Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J .)
AD-7
Ct No.16
(SSS)