Ram Bilas Yadav vs State of U.P.

Court
Allahabad High Court

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
LUCKNOW
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 1921 of 2011
Ram Bilas Yadav
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P.
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Naveen Kumar Pandey, Alok Kumar
Yadav
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Govt. Advocate

Court No. - 13
HON'BLE SUBHASH VIDYARTHI, J.
1. When the appeal was called out for hearing in the revised call of the cause
list, Sri Alok Kumar Yadav, the learned counsel for the appellant, requested
for an adjournment of the hearing on the ground that he has recently been
engaged in the case and he needs some time to prepare his submissions. He
has filed his vakalatnama in the case on 16.07.2026. The appeal is pending
since the year 2011 and it was listed on 20.07.2026, 22.09.2026 and
16.10.2026 also. In these circumstances, the failure of the learned counsel
for the appellant to prepare his submissions even after a period of four
months since he has filed his vakalatnama, cannot be appreciated. As the
appeal is pending for the past more than 1 ½ decade, the court finds the
request for adjournment to be unreasonable and turns down the same and in
the interest of justice, proceeds to decide the appeal after perusing the record
with the assistance of Smt. Sudha Sharma, the learned Additional
Government Advocate appearing on behalf of the State.
2. By means of the instant appeal filed under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C., the
appellant has challenged the validity of a judgment and order dated
12.10.2011, passed by Sri. Ahmad Naseem, the learned Sessions Judge,
Shrawasti in Sessions Trial No.121 of 2008: State Vs. Ram Bilas Yadav,
arising out of Case Crime No.794 of 2007, under Section 354 I.P.C. and
Section 3(1) (xi) of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (which will hereinafter be referred to as
'the SC/ST Act'), Police Station Sonwa, District Shrawasti whereby the
appellant has been convicted for the aforesaid offences and he has been

CRLA No. 1921 of 2011
2
sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for a period of one year for the
offence under Section 354 IPC and rigorous imprisonment for two
years and a fine of Rs.5,000/- for the offence under Section 3(1)(xi) of the
SC/ST Act.
3. The aforesaid case was instituted on the basis of a written complaint dated
02.12.2006 given by the complainant Prem, son of Pheru stating that when
his wife was going out of her home at about 5:00 a.m. on the aforesaid date,
to attend nature's call, the appellant, who resides in a house adjacent to the
complainant's house, caught hold of the complainant's wife at a spot towards
north of the village, near the canal and he pushed her down on the ground
with an intention of insulting her. When the complainant's wife raised her
voice, the complainant, his brother Radhe and his cousins Jawahar and
Ramvilas reached on the spot and thereafter, the appellant set the
complainant's wife free and tried to escape. The complainant and other
persons chased the appellant, caught hold of him and took him to the police
station and they gave the complaint.
4. On the basis of the aforesaid complaint, an FIR bearing Case Crime No.
794 of 2007 was registered on the same day for the offences under Sections
354 IPC and 3(1)(xi) of the SC/ST Act. The investigating officer prepared a
site plan (Exhibit A-4) which showed the place of incident to be a pit
between the canal and the agricultural land of Nanhu Kairati. After
investigation, the investigating officer submitted a charge-sheet dated
04.12.2007 against the appellant for the aforesaid offences.
5. The complainant was examined as PW-1 and he reiterated the FIR
version. He further stated that after the appellant was caught while trying to
escape from the spot of the incident, he was taken to the complainant's
house. The complaint was inscribed by a villager. A Sub-Inspector of Police
reached the village after a short while upon receiving a telephonic
information of the incident given by the Village Pradhan and he took the
complainant and the appellant to the police station. The complainant gave
the complaint at the police station and thereafter, the FIR was lodged. He
stated that the Sub-Inspector had sent his wife to Government Hospital,
Bhinga for a medico-legal examination.
6. During cross-examination, PW-1 stated that when his wife had gone to
attend nature's call at about 05:00 a.m., he and his brother were awake and

CRLA No. 1921 of 2011
3
they were looking after the paddy in khalihan at a distance of about 100
steps from the place of the incident. Ram Milan and Jawahar were also
present nearby. They had heard the azaan from the village mosque, from
which they understood that it was 5:00 a.m. PW-1 stated that he had seen
Ram Bilas going alone towards the eastern side of the canal. His wife had
shouted and he reached the spot when the appellant was running away. He
and Radhey had reached two minutes after hearing the voice of his wife and
Jawahar reached there after five minutes. Ram Milan had also reached on the
spot, but as he was a person of advanced age, he could not catch hold of the
appellant. PW-1 denied the suggestion that the appellant was caught from
the latter's house. He stated that the appellant was caught at about 5:30 a.m.
PW-1 stated that he had not seen the appellant committing the offence, he
had merely seen him running away. No other villager had reached there and
villagers gathered at his home after PW-1, Radhey, Jawahar and Ram Milan
had taken the appellant to the complainant's house.
7. The victim of the offence (the complainant's wife) was examined as PW-
2. She stated that she had gone towards the bank of the canal in the north of
the village to attend nature's call. As soon as she got ready to ease herself,
the appellant caught hold of her from behind and pushed her down with the
intention of insulting her. She cried, whereupon her husband Prem and
Jawahar, Radhe, Ram Milan, etc. came running. They chased the appellant
while he was trying to escape, caught hold of him at some distance and took
them to the victim's house. The Sub-Inspector reached there after some time,
as someone had made a telephone call to the police. The Sub-Inspector took
the complainant, the appellant and other persons to the police station and
after some time PW-2 also went to the police station. She stated that she was
medically examined in the government hospital.
8. During cross-examination, PW-2 stated that her husband had gone to
the khalihan in the preceding evening. She had seen her husband in
the khalihan while going to attend nature's call and her husband had also
seen her on the way. The khalihan was visible from the place where she had
gone to attend nature's call. The appellant caught hold of her from behind,
she cried and her husband reached there before other persons. When her
husband reached, the appellant was catching hold of her. Her husband
scolded the appellant, but he did not beat him. The appellant tried to escape,
but her husband chased him and caught hold of him near a culvert on the
canal. She stated that Radhey is her husband's younger brother, Jawahar is

CRLA No. 1921 of 2011
4
her husband's elder brother and Ram Milan is her father-in-law and all of
them live in the same house and all of them had run after her husband. When
the appellant was caught on the culvert, the police had reached there at the
same time. She was medically examined on the date of the incident. She
denied the suggestion that her husband, brothers-in-law and father-in-law
had taken the appellant from his house at 3:00 a.m. She admitted that her
husband and other persons had not seen the incident and they had reached
there upon hearing her cries.
9. Jawahar, brother of the complainant was examined as PW-3 and his
statement during his examination-in-chief was similar to the statements of
PW-1 and PW-2. During cross-examination, PW-3 stated that he was
sleeping in the khalihan along with Habib, Ram Milan, Nanhu and Fariyati.
As soon as he woke up at 6:30 a.m., he heard the cries of the victim and he
ran towards the canal. Radhey was following him and Ram Milan and
several other persons also followed. He stated that the khalihan was clearly
visible from the spot of the incident. When they were running towards the
spot of the incident, the appellant had pushed the victim on the ground, but
when they reached there, the appellant was running away. They had caught
hold of the appellant within two minutes of the incident. The police had
reached the spot of the incident within 20 minutes and had taken the
appellant and the complainant to the police station. No other person had
gone to the police station. He admitted that he had not seen the incident, but
he had merely seen the appellant running away. He denied the suggestion
that he had given a false testimony because of animosity against the
appellant.
10. The Constable who had registered the FIR was examined as PW-4 and
the Investigating Officer was examined as PW-5. No other prosecution
witness was examined.
11. One Jameel was examined as DW-1. He stated that there is one house
between his house and the house of Prem. The incident took place at about
7-7:30 a.m. He saw that Prem, Radhey, Jawahar and Ram Milan, son of
Guru Prasad, were beating the appellant Ram Bilas Yadav at the
complainant's house. Thereafter, the Village Pradhan Keshavram made a
phone call to the police and the police came there at about 9-9:30 a.m and
took away the appellant with them. There was an old animosity between the
appellant and the complainant because of a haata where cattle were tied and

CRLA No. 1921 of 2011
5
for this reason, some altercation had taken place between the appellant and
the complainant about one week ago. The Village Pradhan had an
acquaintance with the police and, therefore, the complainant lodged the FIR
in connivance with the Village Pradhan, whereas the appellant had not done
any obscene activity with the victim. He stated that he had seen Prem etc.
beating the appellant. The appellant had suffered injuries because of the
beating.
12. Kamaruddin, another neighbor of the appellant, was examined as DW-2.
He stated that the complainant and the other persons came to the appellant's
house at about 7-7:30 a.m. and they dragged the appellant to their house
while beating him. Upon hearing the hue and cry, he and some other
villagers reached there. The Village Pradhan also came there. He made a
phone call and called the police. The police came there at about 9-9:30 a.m.
and took away the appellant with them. There was an old animosity between
the appellant and the complainant regarding a haata and an altercation had
taken place between them due to this reason about one week ago and
because of this animosity, the complainant falsely implicated the appellant in
connivance with the village pradhan.
13. In the statement of the appellant recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C., he
denied all the allegations and stated that he had been falsely implicated
because of the animosity.
14. On the basis of the aforesaid material, the trial court held that the
appellant was guilty of the offence under Section 354 IPC and 3(1)(xi)
SC/ST Act and convicted and sentenced him accordingly.
15. Section 354 I.P.C. reads as follows: -
"354. Assault or criminal force to woman with intent to outrage her
modesty. —Whoever assaults or uses criminal force to any woman,
intending to outrage or knowing it to be likely that he will thereby outrage
her modesty, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description
for a term which shall not be less than one year but which may extend to
five years, and shall also be liable to fine."
16. Section 3(1)(xi) SC/ST Act (as it was at the relevant time, prior to its
substitution by Act 1 of 2016), read as follows: -
" 3. Punishments for offences atrocities- (1) Whoever, not being a

CRLA No. 1921 of 2011
6
member of a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe,-
*
(xi) assaults or uses force to any woman belonging to a Scheduled Caste
or Scheduled Tribe with intent to dishonour or outrage her modesty."
17. The prosecution case is that the appellant had caught hold of the
complainant's wife from behind and pushed her on the ground with an
intention of insulting her. There is absolutely no allegation that the alleged
act was committed with an intention to outrage her modesty or with the
knowledge that it was likely to outrage her modesty. There is absolutely no
allegation that the appellant committed any obscene activity which may
outrage the modesty of the victim. Every insult cannot be taken to be an act
outraging the modesty of a woman. Moreover, PW-3 specifically stated that
he had reached on the spot of the incident soon after hearing the cries of the
victim and the victim had told that the appellant wanted to insult her by
pushing her down. Merely wanting to commit an act, which may amount to
commission of an offence, cannot make out the offence.
18. Besides the victim, the other witnesses have categorically stated that they
did not see the incident and they reached the spot upon hearing the cries of
the victim and found the appellant running away. Therefore, the sole
testimony regarding the incident is the statement of the victim herself. The
victim stated that while she had gone to attend nature's call at about 5-5:30
a.m., the appellant came there, caught hold of her from behind and pushed
her down with an intent to insult her. She stated that the place of incident
was clearly visible from the khalihan and the khalihan was also clearly
visible from the place of the incident. Her husband and brother-in-law were
present in the khalihan. She cried immediately upon the occurrence, but still,
PW-1 and PW-3 stated that they did not see the incident, they reached the
spot upon hearing the cries of the victim and found the appellant running
away.
19. The victim (PW-2) stated that when her husband reached the spot, the
appellant was catching hold of her and her husband had scolded the
appellant. However, the victim's husband PW-1 stated that when he reached
the spot, the appellant had already run away and he chased and caught the
appellant within 2 minutes. PW-3 stated that when he reached on the spot,
the appellant was keeping the victim pushed down on the ground. Thus the

CRLA No. 1921 of 2011
7
prosecution witnesses have given self-contradictory statements.
20. The victim (PW-2) stated that when her husband had caught the
appellant near the canal, the police had reached there at the same time,
which is highly improbable and doubtful. The victim's husband (PW-1)
stated that the appellant was caught and brought to the complainant's home
and the sub-inspector had come there. These contradictions give rise to a
reasonable doubt against the correctness of the testimonies of the witnesses.
21. PW-2 has categorically stated that she was examined medically, but no
medical report is available on the record of the trial court and the doctor who
had allegedly conducted the medico-legal examination of the victim has not
been examined as a prosecution witness. The absence of medical evidence
leads to an inference that the victim did not suffer any injury when the
appellant allegedly pushed her down on the ground.
22. DW-1 and DW-2 have stated about an old animosity between the
complainant and the appellant because of a haata, due to which the
complainant and his family members came to the appellant's house, beat him
up and dragged him to their house and thereafter, the Village Pradhan called
the police and the police took the appellant to the police station. No
significant discrepancy came to light in the cross-examination of DW-1 and
DW-2.
23. The trial court disbelieved the testimony of DW-1 and DW-2, merely
because they stated that the appellant was beaten up, whereas the appellant
did not say so in his statement recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
24. The appellant has merely replied to the questions put to him during the
recording of his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. No question was put to
the appellant to verify the statements of DW-1 and DW-2, that whether he
had been beaten up and, therefore, non-mention of the fact of his having
been beating up in the statement of the appellant recorded under Section 313
Cr.P.C. cannot be a ground to disbelieve the testimonies of DW-1 and DW-
2.
25. In Anand Ramchandra Chougule v. Sidarai Laxman Chougala: (2019)
8 SCC 50 , the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that: -
" 10. The burden lies on the prosecution to prove the allegations beyond
all reasonable doubt. In contradistinction to the same, the accused has

CRLA No. 1921 of 2011
8
only to create a doubt about the prosecution case and the probability of
its defence. An accused is not required to establish or prove his defence
beyond all reasonable doubt, unlike the prosecution. If the accused takes
a defence, which is not improbable and appears likely, there is material
in support of such defence, the accused is not required to prove anything
further. The benefit of doubt must follow unless the prosecution is able
to prove its case beyond all reasonable doubt. "
(emphasis added)
26. In Vaibhav v. State of Maharashtra: (2025) 8 SCC 315 , the Hon'ble
Supreme Court held that: -
"29. In criminal jurisprudence, it is a time-tested proposition that the
primary burden falls upon the shoulders of the prosecution and it is only
if the prosecution succeeds in discharging its burden beyond reasonable
doubt that the burden shifts upon the accused to explain the evidence
against him or to present a defence. In the present case, the version of the
prosecution suffers from inherent inconsistencies and doubts, as
discussed above, and in such a scenario, the inability of the appellant to
explain certain circumstances could not be made the basis to relieve the
prosecution from discharging its primary burden.
*
31. In law, there is a significant difference in the evidentiary burden to be
discharged by the prosecution and the accused. Whereas, the former is
expected to discharge its burden beyond reasonable doubt, the latter is
only required to prove a defence on the anvil of preponderance of
probabilities. If the accused leads defence evidence in the course of a
criminal trial, the same ought to be tested as probable or improbable in
the facts and circumstances of the case. "
(emphasis added)
27. The discrepancies and contradictions in the statements of the prosecution
witnesses create a reasonable doubt against the truthfulness of their
testimonies. The testimonies of the defence witnesses further tilts the
preponderance of probabilities against the prosecution and in favour of the
accused.
28. In view of the foregoing discussion, I am of the considered view that the
prosecution had miserably failed to prove the charges under Section 354
I.P.C. and Section 3(1)(zi) SC/ST Act against the appellant. The trial Court

CRLA No. 1921 of 2011
9
has committed a grave error in convicting and sentencing the appellant for
the aforesaid offences. The impugned judgment and order passed by the trial
Court convicting and sentencing the appellant for the offences under Section
354 I.P.C. and Section 3(1)(XI) SC/ST Act is unsustainable in law and is
liable to be set aside.
29. Accordingly, the criminal appeal is . The impugned judgment
allowed
and order dated 12.10.2011 passed by Sri. Ahmad Naseem, the learned
Sessions Judge, Shrawasti, in Sessions Trial No.121 of 2008: State Vs. Ram
Bilas Yadav, arising out of Case Crime No.794 of 2007, under Section 354
I.P.C. and Section 3(1) (xi) of the SC/ST Act, Police Station Sonwa, District
Shrawasti whereby the appellant has been convicted and sentenced for the
aforesaid offences, is hereby . The appellant is of all the
set aside acquitted
charges.
30. The appellant is directed to comply with the provisions of Section 437-A
Cr.P.C. by furnishing a personal bond within a period of two weeks from
today, undertaking to appear before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case any
appeal is filed against this order and the Hon'ble Supreme Court issues
notice of the appeal to the appellant. Such bond shall remain in force for a
period of six months from today.
November 18, 2026
Ram.
(Subhash Vidyarthi,J.)
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: No


(Subhash Vidyarthi,J.)

Digitally signed by :-
RAM SINGH
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,
Lucknow Bench