SRI R GOVINDARAJU vs SRI K MUNIYAPPA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.

CRIMINAL REVISION PETITION NO. 1658 OF 2024

(397(Cr.PC) / 438(BNSS))

BETWEEN:

1. SRI R GOVINDARAJU
S/O LATE. RAMABHADRAIAH
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
TALUK JANATADAL PRESIDENT,
R/AT NEAR T.B CIRCLE, T.B NARAYANASWAMY
LAYOUT, DODDABALLAPURA TOWN,
DODDABALLAPURA-561203
…PETITIONER








(BY SRI. T.USMAN, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. SRI K MUNIYAPPA
S/O LATE. KARIYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
R/AT OBADENAHALLI VILLAGE,
KASABA HOBLI, DODDABALLAPURA TOWN,
DODDABALLAPURA-561203
…RESPONDENT




(BY SRI. SIJI MALAYIL.,ADVOCATE)
THIS CRL.RP IS FILED U/S 397 R/W 401 CR.PC (FILED
U/S 438 R/W 442 BNSS) BY THE ADVOCATE FOR THE
PETITIONER PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT DATED
29.11.2024 VIDE ANNEXURE-A DISMISSING
CRL.A.NO.10001/2022 AND ALSO TO SET ASIDE THE
JUDGMENT OF CONVICTION DATED 14.12.2021 VIDE
ANNEXURE-B PASSED BY THE PRL.CIVIL JUDGE AND J.M.F.C
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 2 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


AT DODDABALLAPURA IN C.C.NO.898/2015 FOR THE OFFENCE
P/U/S 138 OF N.I ACT.
THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
28.10.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER
THIS DAY, THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.

CAV JUDGMENT
This is the revision petition filed under Section 397
and 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short
'Cr.P.C') by the revision petitioner/accused challenging the
judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated
14.12.2021 passed in CC No.898/2015 on the file of
Principal Civil Judge and JMFC, Doddaballapur (in short
'trial Court') which is confirmed in Criminal Appeal
No.10001/2022 dated 29.11.2024 on the file of IV
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Doddaballapur,
Bengaluru Rural District (in short 'appellate Court').

2. The parties would be referred with their ranks, as
they were before the trial court for the sake of
convenience and clarity.

3. The complainant has filed the private complaint
under Section 200 Cr.P.C., before the trial Court praying
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 3 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


for taking cognizance of the offence under Section 138 of
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (in short the 'N.I. Act')
against the accused.

4. The case of the complainant in nutshell is that
the accused approached the complainant to secure hand
loan of ` 30,00,000/- for his family necessity. The
complainant and the father of accused were close friends;
the complainant and the accused were known to each
other. Hence, the complainant agreed to lend
` 30,00,000/- and lent the said amount to the accused .
Accused has issued post-dated cheque bearing No.35543
dated 15.02.2015 drawn on Axis Bank, Doddaballapur
Branch. As per request of the accused, the complainant
presented the cheque on 12.05.2015 through his banker-
Canara Bank, Doddaballapur Branch. The said cheque was
dishonoured with an endorsement 'funds insufficient' dated
13.05.2015. The complainant has issued the legal notice
dated 09.06.2015 to the accused. The notice was received
by the accused on 13.06.2015 but he has not given reply
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 4 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


to notice and not paid the cheque amount. Hence, he filed
the complaint on 06.07.2015.

5. After recording the sworn statement of the
complainant, the trial Court has taken cognizance of the
offence by registering the case against the accused and
issued summons to the accused.

6. After service of summons, the accused appeared
through his counsel. He pleaded not guilty of the offence
when accusation levelled against him was read over and
explained to him. Then the complainant was cross-
examined in length by the accused. Then the statement of
accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C., was recorded wherein
he denied the case of complainant in toto . Accused has let
in defence evidence.

7. After hearing arguments, the trial Court
concluded that the accused has committed the offence
under Section 138 of NI Act and convicted him for the
same; sentenced to pay a fine of ` 45,02,000/-; out of
which ` 45,00,000/- shall be payable to the complainant as
the compensation.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 5 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024



8. Aggrieved by the same, the revision
petitioner/accused has preferred the appeal before the
appellate Court. After hearing, the appellate Court
dismissed the appeal by confirming the judgment of the
trial Court. Aggrieved by the same, the revision
petitioner/accused is before this Court.

9. The learned counsel for the revision
petitioner/accused Sri T. Prakash would submit that only in
the cross-examination, the complainant has stated the
date of lending as November-2014 but not mentioned the
date of lending in the legal notice, in the complaint and
examination in chief.

10. The learned counsel for the accused would
further submit that from the cross-examination of the
complainant, he has elicited several facts, which clearly
establish that there was no financial capacity to the
complainant to lend a sum of ` 30,00,000/-. It is a huge
sum during 2014-15. However, lending is not mentioned in
the IT returns of the complainant. Furthermore, no
document is produced to show that as on the date of
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 6 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


lending, the complainant possessed such huge amount.
His bank statement does not establish the said fact. Thus,
there was no financial capacity to the complainant to lend
such huge amount. Thus, presumptions in favour of
complainant were rebutted.

11. In this regard, he places reliance on the
judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Rajaram
(since deceased) t hrough L.Rs. v/s Maruthachalam
1
(Since deceased) through L.Rs. and Basalingappa vs.
2
Mudibasappa
.

12. The learned counsel for revision petitioner would
submit that without prejudice to his contention of denying
the transaction; if the Courts comes to the conclusion that
the conviction of the accused is to be confirmed; then, the
fine amount imposed by the trial Court is exorbitant and
without properly appreciating it, the appellate Court
confirmed it and the fine amount be reduced.

13. The learned counsel for the respondent-Sri Siji
Malayil would submit that the complainant has produced

1
AIR 2023 SC 471
2
AIR 2019 SC 1983
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 7 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


relevant materials before the trial Court to prove his
financial capacity. He has produced his bank statement to
show that during 2013, about ` 2,00,00,000/- amount was
transferred to his bank account because of the acquisition
of the land belonged to the complainant by KIADB. The
wife and daughter of the complainant have contested for
elections at Zilla Panchayat and Village Panchayath
respectively. Even the complainant contested for the
elections and became member of Zilla Panchayat during
2005 from Doddabelavangala and it is from JDS party;
during 2010-2011, he contested from BJP for Taluk
Panchayat elections from Bashettyhalli. According to the
evidence of accused, before 2005, the complainant was in
Congress party. The alleged case between the complainant
and Smt. Manjula Devi was settled long back. The alleged
transaction between the complainant and Smt.Manjula
Devi is June-2015 i.e., subsequent to the present
transaction between the complainant and the accused. He
would further submit that the accused is habitual offender;
there were 2-3 cases filed against him by Chennigappa
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 8 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


and also by KSFC. The accused has not given reply to the
legal notice, even though it is served upon him. In the
cross-examination, the accused accepted several material
allegations against him which establishes that the accused
failed to rebut the presumptions in favour of the
complainant. These facts were appreciated by the trial
Court and the appellate Court in an appropriate manner.

14. When there is concurrent finding, this Court
under revisional jurisdiction, cannot interfere with it unless
and until it is grossly erroneous. No such gross erroneous
observation by the trial Court and the appellate Court is
forthcoming. In this regard, he places reliance on the
judgment of Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of
3
Smt. Latha B M v/s Sri N Nagesh & Others .

15. As far as financial capacity of the complainant is
concerned, the respondent’s counsel places reliance on the
judgment of Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Ashok
4
Singh v/s State of Uttarpradesh & Anr. .

3
Crl.R.P.No.1293/2023 dd 01.04.2026
4
2025 INSC 427
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 9 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024



16. When the accused has not at all rebutted the
initial presumptions in favour of the complainant, the
Courts have rightly convicted the accused. In this regard,
he places reliance on Rajesh Jain v. Ajay Singh, in SLP
(Crl) No.12802/2022 and also the judgment of Hon'ble
Apex Court in the case of Kuntegowda v. Thurubaiah in
SLP (Crl.) No.2247/2024.

17. Learned counsel for respondent would submit
that proper reasons are assigned by the trial Court and
discussed by the appellate Court while confirming the
sentence of ` 45,00,000/- because there is an inordinate
delay in disposal of the appeal and if it is reckoned as on
today, it would be 11 years. Hence, prayed for
confirmation of the sentence.

18. Having heard arguments of both sides, verifying
the revision petition papers, the trial Court and the
appellate Court records , the point that arises for
consideration is:
"1.Whether the revision petitioner/s establish
perversity or grossly erroneousness in the judgment
of the trial Court and appellate Court or the judgment
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 10 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


of the trial Court and appellate Court is glaringly
unreasonable or wholly unreliable or untenable and
the judgment of the trial Court and appellate Court
considered immaterial or irrelevant material or no
material or non-consideration of any relevant material
or judicial discretion has been exercised arbitrarily or
capriciously ?"
2. Whether imposition of sentence by the trial
Court, confirmed by the appellate Court, requires
interference?"


19. The finding of this Court on point No.1 is in
'Negative' and point No.2 is in the ' Affirmative' for the
following:
REASONS

20. The revisional jurisdiction of this Court is very
limited. In this regard, this Court places reliance on the
Judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Kuntegowda v/s Thurubaiah in Criminal Appeal
No.3654/2026, (Arising out of Special Leave Petition
(Criminal) No.2247 of 2024 dated 04.08.2026
reported in 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1485 . In the aforesaid
judgment, the Hon'ble Apex Court at paragraph Nos.7.1.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 11 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


to 7.3 has discussed the revisional jurisdiction of this
Court, which reads as follows:
" 7.3. The contours for exercise of revisional
jurisdiction has been well settled by the judicial
dicta of this Court wherein time and again it
has been observed that the High Court shall not
interfere with the orders of the lower Court
unless:
i. The order or finding of the lower Court is
perverse, grossly erroneous, glaringly
unreasonable or wholly unreliable or untenable
in law.
ii. The lower Court has passed the impugned
order after considering an immaterial or
irrelevant material or no material at all.
iii. There is a non-consideration of any relevant
material or the judicial discretion has been
exercised arbitrarily or capriciously."

21. Thus, only if the judgment of the trial Court
confirmed by appellate Court is perverse or grossly
erroneous, or grossly unreasonable, or wholly unreliable,
or wholly untenable, or the trial Court considered an
immaterial or irrelevant, material or no material or not at
all relevant material or judicial discretion has been
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 12 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


exercised arbitrarily and capriciously, the revisional Court
can interfere with such judgment.

22. The alleged offence in this case is the offence
under Section 138 of NI Act; to attract the offence under
Section 138 of NI Act, the complainant has to satisfy the
following ingredients:
(i) that there exists legally enforceable debt;
(ii) that the cheque was drawn from the account of
bank of the accused for the discharge in whole or in
part of any debt or other liability;
(iii) that the cheque has been presented to the bank
within a period of six months from the date on which
it is drawn or within the period of its validity,
whichever is earlier;
(iv) that cheque so issued has been returned due to
insufficiency of funds;
(v) the payee or the holder in due course of the
cheque makes a demand for the payment of the said
amount of money by giving a notice in writing to the
drawer of the cheque, within 30 days of the receipt
of information by him from the bank regarding the
return of the cheque as unpaid;
(vi) the drawer of such cheque fails to make
payment of the said amount of money to the payee
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 13 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


or the holder in due course of the cheque within 15
days of the receipt of the said notice;
(vii) Filing of the complaint within a month from the
date of expiry of the grace period of fifteen days
before a Metropolitan Magistrate or a Judicial
Magistrate not below first class."



23. If the aforementioned ingredients are satisfied,
then there shall be a presumption under section 139 of the
N.I. Act. Always, the cheque is a bill of exchange and thus
there shall be a presumption under Section 118 of the NI
Act. There is also statutory presumption under Section 139
of NI Act that there exists legally recoverable debt and the
cheque is issued for recovery of legally recoverable debt
either wholly or in part. But the presumptions available
under Section 118 and 139 of the NI Act are rebuttable
presumptions.

24. With this background, the facts of the present
case are to be analysed and to verify whether the trial
Court and the appellate Court have not examined the
records produced by either party or erroneously
appreciated the evidence.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 14 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024



25. In the cross-examination, the accused
categorically admitted his signature on the subject cheque
and admitted that said cheque is from his bank account.
According to the complainant, Ex.P.1-cheque for a sum of
`
30,00,000/-bears the date 15.02.2015; he presented the
same for encashment and endorsement that 'funds
insufficient' was received on 13.05.2015; the complainant
has issued the legal notice dated 09.06.2015, which was
served upon accused on 13.06.2015, but the accused has
not given any reply to it. Then the complainant has
presented the present complaint on 06.07.2015.

26. The above facts clearly establishes that the
complainant has established ingredient c lause No.(iii) to
(vii) of Section 138 of NI Act as stated above.

27. When the complainant establishes the aforesaid
facts, then the presumption will be in favour of the
complainant under Sections 118 and 139 of NI Act that the
cheque was issued for consideration; it was issued on the
date mentioned in it; there exists legally recoverable debt
or liability and to discharge the said liability either in part
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 15 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


or in whole, the subject cheque was issued. However,
these presumptions are rebuttable in nature.

28. The accused can rebut these presumptions by
giving reply to the legal notice or by cross-examining the
complainant or by leading defence evidence or by all the
above three modes.

29. In this case, the accused has not given reply to
the legal notice but he cross-examined the complainant
and also let in defence evidence. Thus, what is elicited in
the cross-examination of the complainant by the accused
is to be looked into to say whether he rebutted the
presumption or not.

30. In the cross-examination of the complainant, it is
elicited that both the complainant and the accused are in
politics. Initially, the complainant was in JDS during 2005
then he changed his political party to BJP. The
complainant contested for the election and he became
member of the Zilla Panchayat during 2005 from JDS;
during 2010-11 he contested from BJP to Bashettyhalli
Taluk Panchayat; it is also elicited that the wife and
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 16 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


daughter of the complainant also contested for Zilla
Panchayath and Village Panchayath respectively.

31. According to the complainant, he lent
` 30,00,000/- in cash to the accused. It is an established
fact that both the complainant and the accused have been
close friends since from their childhood. It is the case of
complainant that he received about ` 2,00,00,000/- for
acquisition of his lands from KIADB. To substantiate it, he
has produced his bank statement and documents of
KIADB. They reveal that during 2013, huge amount was
credited to the bank account of the complainant due to
acquisition of his lands. The bank statement also
establishes that the complainant has withdrawn those
amounts gradually in 2013 and in the beginning of 2014.

32. In the complaint, evidence and in the legal
notice, the complainant has not stated the date of lending.
However, in the cross-examination for the first time he has
deposed that he lent the amount during November-2014.
It is to be noted here that at that time, the amount in the
bank account of the complainant is very less. It is only of
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 17 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


some thousands and not ` 30,00,000/-. However, it is not
the case of the complainant that at the time of lending he
has withdrawn the said amount.

33. The contention of the accused is that the
complainant himself has taken loan from third parties and
cases are registered against him in that regard and thus,
the complainant had no financial capacity.

34. To substantiate it, the accused has produced
Exs.D.1 and D.2 i.e., the private complaint lodged by one
Smt. Manjula Devi against the complainant. Based on said
complaint, the criminal case was registered against
complainant as per the order dated 25.11.2017. Summons
issued to the present complainant in that case. However,
the subsequent order sheet is not produced to say that on
which date the summons of said case was served upon the
present complainant. In this regard, the present
complainant in his cross-examination held on 11.06.2018
has denied the suggestion that Smt. Manjula Devi has
lodged the complaint against him.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 18 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024



35. Several cases are lodged against the accused by
Chennigappa and KSFC. The accused admitted about those
cases filed against him. Totally, 2 cases were lodged
against accused by one Chennigappa, alleging the offence
under Section 138 of NI Act and KSFC has also filed case
against him that he became defaulter of the loan.

36. In the cross-examination, the complainant has
deposed that the present lending transaction to accused is
not mentioned in the Income-tax returns.

37. In Rajaram's case cited supra at paragraph
No.20, it is held as follows:
"20. After analyzing all these pieces of evidence, the
learned Trial Court found that the Income Tax
Returns of the complainant did not disclose that he
lent amount to the accused, and that the declared
income was not sufficient to give loan of Rs.3 lakh.
Therefore, the case of the complainant that he had
given a loan to the accused from his agricultural
income was found to be unbelievable by the learned
Trial Court. The learned Trial Court found that it was
highly doubtful as to whether the complainant had
lent an amount of Rs.3 lakh to the accused. The
learned Trial Court also found that the complaint had
failed to produce the promissory note alleged to have
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 19 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


been executed by the accused on 25th October 1998.
After taking into consideration the defence witnesses
and the attending circumstances, the learned Trial
Court found that the defence was a possible defence
and as such, the accused was entitled to benefit of
doubt. The standard of proof for rebutting the
presumption is that of preponderance of
probabilities. Applying this principle, the learned Trial
Court had found that the accused had rebutted the
presumption on the basis of the evidence of the
defence witnesses and attending circumstances."

38. In Basalingappa's case cited supra at
paragraph Nos. 26, 27 & 28, it is held as follows:
"26. There is one more aspect of the matter which
also needs to be noticed. In the complaint filed by
the complainant as well as in examination-in-chief
the complainant has not mentioned as to on which
date, the loan of Rs.6 lakhs was given to the
accused. It was during cross-examination, he gave
the date as November, 2011. xxx.
27. Thus, there is a contradiction in what was initially
stated by the complainant in the complaint and in his
examination-in-chief regarding date on which loan
was given on one side and what was said in cross-
examination in other side, which has not been
satisfactorily explained. The High Court was unduly
influenced by the fact that the accused did not reply
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 20 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


the notice denying the execution of cheque or legal
liability. xxx.
28. We are of the view that when evidence was led
before the Court to indicate that apart from loan of
Rs.6 lakhs given to the accused, within 02 years,
amount of Rs.18 lakhs have been given out by the
complainant and his financial capacity being
questioned, it was incumbent on the complainant to
have explained his financial capacity. Court cannot
insist on a person to lead negative evidence. xxx."

39. In the judgment of the co-ordinate bench of this
5
Court in H.R.Sheshadri v/s U.V.Nataraj at paragraph
Nos.21 and 22, it is held as follows:
"21. In the light of ratio in APS forex, it is for the
complainant to prove that at the time when he
allegedly gave hand loan of Rs. 4,15,000/-he had
financial capacity to lend the said amount. On this
aspect, during his cross-examination, the
complainant has deposed that he is a coffee planter
and he was having cash in respect of sale of coffee
since 2-3 years. He is not assessee to Income tax.
During his cross-examination a suggestion is made to
the complainant that he has taken loan for raising
coffee crop which he has admitted. Though this
suggestion indicates that he is having coffee

5
Crl.R.P.No.573/2019 dd 18.01.2024
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 21 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


plantation, the complainant has not chosen to
produce any documents to show the exact income by
coffee plantation. He could have produced some
documents to show the sale of coffee to ascertain his
probable income. That the complainant has not only
failed to prove that the subject cheque bears the
signature of the accused and also that at the relevant
point of time he had sufficient income to lend a sum
of Rs. 4,15,000/-to the accused.

22. Without examining these aspects, the trial Court
as well as the Sessions Court have proceeded to
convict the accused solely on the ground that
presumption is operating in favour of the
complainant and that accused has failed to rebut the
presumption. The judgment and order of the trial
Court as well as the Sessions Court have caused
gross miscarriage of justice and suffers from
manifest illegality and perversity calling for
interference by this Court. In the result, the petition
succeeds and accordingly the following. XXXX"


40. In the judgment of the co-ordinate bench of this
6
Court (Dharwad) in Jadesha Reddy v/s G.Chandranna
at paragraph No.14, it is held as follows:

6
Crl.A.No.100114/2014 dd 24.02.2023
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 22 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


"14. No doubt the complainant is a holder of the
cheque in due course and the initial presumption is in
his favour. But it is required to be noted here that he
is a public servant and handling cash without
permission from the higher officers. Further his
financial capacity itself establishes that he is not in a
position to pay such a huge amount of Rs.
6,00,000/-that too by way of hard cash. Under such
circumstances, the presumption under section 139 of
the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, is not
available to the complainant and the complainant is
required to prove his transactions by leading cogent
evidence. But except the self interested testimony of
the complainant, there is no material placed and
hence the same cannot be accepted in view of the
cross-examination of the complainant and Ex.D.1."

41. In the judgment of the co-ordinate bench of this
Court (Dharwad) in N.Vijay Kumar v/s Vishwanath
7
Rao N at paragraph Nos.11 and 12, it is held as follows:
"11. Considering the sum total of the above, we find
that the probable defence on the part of the
Accused has been established. Once such a defence
is established, the burden again shifts upon the
complainant to now establish his case beyond a

7
Crl.A.No.5305/2024 dd 22.04.2025
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 23 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


reasonable doubt, for after all, the effect of Section
138 of the N.I. Act is a criminal conviction.

12. In our considered view, the complainant has
failed to discharge this burden. In his cross-
examination, the complainant has stated as follows.

During the year 2002, I have paid loan to the
Accused on 7-8 times. I have maintained the
account on which dates I have paid the loan to the
Accused. In that regard, I have subscribed my
signatures in the book which was with the Accused.
Accused issued cheques for having obtained 7-8
times loan from me. I have paid the amount to the
Accused two times in my house and 5-6 times in my
lodge. I have not obtained the receipt for having
received the loan amount by the Accused.

It has also come on record that the cheque, subject
matter of controversy, was given to the complainant
in the presence of common well-wishers. However,
none of the above statements stands scrutiny. The
alleged well-wishers who could have proved the
discussion and context in which the cheque was
given, remained unexamined. As stated by the
complainant himself, there is no official record, such
as income tax documents which would show that
such an amount was extended by way of a loan to
the Accused, neither have the books of account,
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 24 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


which the complainant allegedly maintained, being
produced to evidence the seven or eight
transactions inter se the parties totalling the claimed
amount."


42. In Smt.Latha B.M's case cited supra at
paragraph No. 21, it is held as follows:
"21. This court also takes judicial notice of the fact
that some district courts and some High Courts are
not giving effect to the presumptions incorporated in
sections 118 and 139 of the Negotiable Instruments
Act, and are treating the proceedings under the
Negotiable Instruments Act, as another civil recovery
proceedings and are directing the complainant to
prove the antecedent debt or liability. This court is of
the view that such an approach is not only
prolonging the trial but is also contrary to the
mandate of Parliament, namely, that the drawer and
the bank must honour the cheque, otherwise, trust in
cheques would be irreparably damaged.

No documents and/or evidence led with regard to the
financial incapacity of the appellant."


43. In Ashok Singh's case cited supra at paragraph
Nos. 21, 22 & 24, it is held as follows:
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 25 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


"21. One of the grounds, which weighed heavily with
the High Court to acquit the respondent no.2 was
that the appellant was unable to prove the source of
Rs.22,00,000/- (Rupees Twenty-Two Lakhs) given to
the respondent no.2 as loan. Admittedly, the
signature on the cheque is of the respondent no.2
himself. The decision in Rohitbhai Jivanlal Patel v.
State of Gujarat, (2019) 18 SCC 106 can be
profitably referred to:

18. In the case at hand, even after
purportedly drawing the presumption under
Section 139 of the NI Act, the trial court
proceeded to question the want of evidence
on the part of the complainant as regards
the source of funds for advancing loan to
the accused and want of examination of
relevant witnesses who allegedly extended
him money for advancing it to the accused.
This approach of the trial court had been at
variance with the principles of presumption
in law. After such presumption, the onus
shifted to the accused and unless the
accused had discharged the onus by
bringing on record such facts and
circumstances as to show the
preponderance of probabilities tilting in his
favour, any doubt on the complainant's
case could not have been raised for want of
evidence regarding the source of funds for
advancing loan to the appellant-accused.
The aspect relevant for consideration had
been as to whether the appellant-accused
has brought on record such
facts/material/circumstances which could
be of a reasonably probable defence.

Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 26 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


19. In order to discharge his burden, the
accused put forward the defence that in
fact, he had had the monetary transaction
with the said Shri Jagdishbhai and not with
the complainant. In view of such a plea of
the appellant-accused, the question for
consideration is as to whether the
appellant-accused has shown a reasonable
probability of existence of any transaction
with Shri Jagdishbhai? In this regard,
significant it is to notice that apart from
making certain suggestions in the cross-
examination, the appellant-accused has not
adduced any documentary evidence to
satisfy even primarily that there had been
some monetary transaction of himself with
Shri Jagdishbhai. Of course, one of the
allegations of the appellant is that the said
stamp paper was given to Shri Jagdishbhai
and another factor relied upon is that Shri
Jagdishbhai had signed on the stamp paper
in question and not the complainant.
XXX
20. Hereinabove, we have examined in
detail the findings of the trial court and
those of the High Court and have no
hesitation in concluding that the present
one was clearly a case where the decision
of the trial court suffered from perversity
and fundamental error of approach; and
the High Court was justified in reversing
the judgment of the trial court. The
observations of the trial court that there
was no documentary evidence to show the
source of funds with the respondent to
advance the loan, or that the respondent
did not record the transaction in the form
of receipt of even kachcha notes, or that
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 27 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


there were inconsistencies in the statement
of the complainant and his witness, or that
the witness of the complaint was more in
the know of facts, etc. would have been
relevant if the matter was to be examined
with reference to the onus on the
complaint to prove his case beyond
reasonable doubt. These considerations
and observations do not stand in
conformity with the presumption existing in
favour of the complainant by virtue of
Sections 118 and 139 of the NI Act.
Needless to reiterate that the result of such
presumption is that existence of a legally
enforceable debt is to be presumed in
favour of the complainant. When such a
presumption is drawn, the factors relating
to the want of documentary evidence in the
form of receipts or accounts or want of
evidence as regards source of funds were
not of relevant consideration while
examining if the accused has been able to
rebut the presumption or not. The other
observations as regards any variance in the
statement of complainant and witness; or
want of knowledge about dates and other
particulars of the cheques; or washing
away of the earlier cheques in the rains
though the office of the complainant being
on the 8th floor had also been irrelevant
factors for consideration of a probable
defence of the appellant. Similarly, the
factor that the complainant alleged the
loan amount to be Rs 22,50,000 and seven
cheques being of Rs 3,00,000 each leading
to a deficit of Rs 1,50,000, is not even
worth consideration for the purpose of the
determination of real questions involved in
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 28 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


the matter. May be, if the total amount of
cheques exceeded the alleged amount of
loan, a slender doubt might have arisen,
but, in the present matter, the total
amount of 7 cheques is lesser than the
amount of loan. Significantly, the specific
amount of loan (to the tune of Rs
22,50,000) was distinctly stated by the
appellant-accused in the aforesaid
acknowledgment dated 21-3-2017.
(emphasis supplied)

22. The High Court while allowing the criminal
revision has primarily proceeded on the presumption
that it was obligatory on the part of the complainant
to establish his case on the basis of evidence by
giving the details of the bank account as well as the
date and time of the withdrawal of the said amount
which was given to the accused and also the date
and time of the payment made to the accused,
including the date and time of receiving of the
cheque, which has not been done in the present
case. Pausing here, such presumption on the
complainant, by the High Court, appears to be
erroneous. The onus is not on the complainant at the
threshold to prove his capacity/financial wherewithal
to make the payment in discharge of which the
cheque is alleged to have been issued in his favour.
Only if an objection is raised that the complainant
was not in a financial position to pay the amount so
claimed by him to have been given as a loan to the
accused, only then the complainant would have to
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 29 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


bring before the Court cogent material to indicate
that he had the financial capacity and had actually
advanced the amount in question by way of loan. In
the case at hand, the appellant had categorically
stated in his deposition and reiterated in the cross-
examination that he had withdrawn the amount from
the bank in Faizabad (Typed Copy of his deposition in
the paperbook wrongly mentions this as 'Firozabad').
The Court ought not to have summarily rejected such
stand, more so when respondent no.2 did not make
any serious attempt to dispel/negate such
stand/statement of the appellant. Thus, on the one
hand, the statement made before the Court, both in
examination-in-chief and cross-examination, by the
appellant with regard to withdrawing the money from
the bank for giving it to the accused has been
disbelieved whereas the argument on behalf of the
accused that he had not received any payment of
any loan amount has been accepted. In our decision
in M/s S. S. Production v. Tr. Pavithran Prasanth,
2024 INSC 1059, we opined:

8. From the order impugned, it is clear that
though the contention of the petitioners was
that the said amounts were given for
producing a film and were not by way of
return of any loan taken, which may have
been a probable defence for the petitioners in
the case, but rightly, the High Court has taken
the view that evidence had to be adduced on
this point which has not been done by the
petitioners, Pausing here, the Court would
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 30 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


only comment that the reasoning of the High
Court as well as the First Appellate Court and
Trial Court on this issue is sound. Just by
taking a counter-stand to raise a probable
defence would not shift the onus on the
complainant in such a case for the plea of
defence has to be buttressed by evidence,
either oral or documentary, which in the
present cases, has not been done. Moreover,
even if it is presumed that the complainant
had not proved the source of the money given
to the petitioners by way of loan by producing
statement of accounts and/or Income Tax
Returns, the same ipso facto, would not
negate such claim for the reason that the
cheques having being issued and signed by
the petitioners has not been denied, and no
evidence has been led to show that the
respondent lacked capacity to provide the
amount(s) in question. In this regard, we may
make profitable reference to the decision in
Tedhi Singh v Narayan Dass Mahant, (2022) 6
SCC 735:

'10. The trial court and the first appellate
court have noted that in the case under
Section 138 of the NI Act the complainant
need not show in the first instance that
he had the capacity. The proceedings
under Section 138 of the NI Act is not a
civil suit. At the time, when the
complainant gives his evidence, unless a
case is set up in the reply notice to the
statutory notice sent, that the
complainant did not have the
wherewithal, it cannot be expected of the
complainant to initially lead evidence to
show that he had the financial capacity.
To that extent, the courts in our view
were right in holding on those lines.
However, the accused has the right to
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 31 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


demonstrate that the complainant in a
particular case did not have the capacity
and therefore, the case of the accused is
acceptable which he can do by producing
independent materials, namely, by
examining his witnesses and producing
documents. It is also open to him to
establish the very same aspect by
pointing to the materials produced by the
complainant himself. He can further,
more importantly, achieve this result
through the cross examination of the
witnesses of the complainant. Ultimately,
it becomes the duty of the courts to
consider carefully and appreciate the
totality of the evidence and then come to
a conclusion whether in the given case,
the accused has shown that the case of
the complainant is in peril for the reason
that the accused has established a
probable defence.'
(emphasis supplied)'
(underlining in original; emphasis
supplied by us in bold)

24. Accordingly, for reasons aforesaid, the appeal is
allowed. The Impugned Order is set aside. Though
the natural consequence would entail revival of the
conviction and sentence imposed upon the
respondent no.2 i.e., one year simple imprisonment
and fine of Rs.35,00,000/- (Rupees Thirty-Five
Lakhs), but having regard to the parting submissions
of learned senior counsel for the accused/respondent
no.2, to the effect that considering his age, he may
be only subjected to fine and not imprisonment, we
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 32 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


are inclined to modify the sentence to only payment
of a fine restricted to Rs.32,00,000/-(Rupees Thirty-
Two Lakhs). Acceding to the request by the learned
senior counsel, such fine be paid within four months
from today to the appellant, failing which the
sentence in entirety, as awarded by the Trial Court
and upheld by the Appellate Court, will stand
restored, with the added modification that the entire
fine of Rs.35,00,000/- (Rupees Thirty-Five Lakhs)
will be payable to the appellant."


44. In Rajesh Jain's case cited supra at paragraph
Nos. 36, 37 & 38, it is held as follows:
"36. The Court will necessarily presume that the
cheque had been issued towards discharge of a
legally enforceable debt/liability in two
circumstances. Firstly, when the drawer of the
cheque admits issuance/execution of the cheque and
secondly, in the event where the complainant proves
that cheque was issued/executed in his favour by the
drawer. The circumstances set out above form the
fact(s) which bring about the activation of the
presumptive clause. [Bharat Barrel Vs. Amin Chand]
[(1999) 3 SCC 35]

37. Recently, this Court has gone to the extent of
holding that presumption takes effect even in a
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 33 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


situation where the accused contends that 'a blank
cheque leaf was voluntarily signed and handed over
by him to the complainant. [Bir Singh v. Mukesh
Kumar]. Therefore, mere admission of the drawer's
signature, without admitting the execution of the
entire contents in the cheque, is now sufficient to
trigger the presumption.

38. As soon as the complainant discharges the
burden to prove that the instrument, say a cheque,
was issued by the accused for discharge of debt, the
presumptive device under Section 139 of the Act
helps shifting the burden on the accused. The effect
of the presumption, in that sense, is to transfer the
evidential burden on the accused of proving that the
cheque was not received by the Bank towards the
discharge of any liability. Until this evidential burden
is discharged by the accused, the presumed fact will
have to be taken to be true, without expecting the
complainant to do anything further."


45. On careful perusal of the principles noted in all
the above said citations, it is to be noted here that the
accused can discharge the initial burden on him with the
standard of proof of preponderance of probability and not
beyond reasonable doubt. Once the accused by the
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 34 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


standard of proof of preponderance of probability has
raised the probable defence, then the burden shifts upon
the complainant to establish that he lent ` 30,00,000/- to
the accused by placing cogent evidence. Until and unless
the burden is not shifted, the presumptions will be in
favour of the complainant.

46. In this case the facts established are that
according to the complainant he lent ` 30,00,000/- in cash
to the accused; it is not mentioned in his IT returns.
According to the accused, he has lent ` 16,00,000/- in cash
to the complainant at the time of elections of the
complainant but the complainant has not repaid it. No
document is produced to establish it.

47. The contention of the accused is that he has
given the cheque to the complainant only for the purpose
of discounting and not towards repayment of any loan.
However, his said contention is not established by the
accused by producing any cogent evidence. The said
contention is denied by the complainant in his cross-
examination.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 35 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024



48. Considering all these evidence in an appropriate
manner, the trial Court convicted the accused which is
confirmed by the appellate Court. The jurisdiction of
revisional Court is very limited as discussed above. The
trial Court has not ignored any material evidence and has
not considered irrelevant evidence. There is no gross
erroneousness in coming to the finding that the
complainant has lent a sum of ` 30,00,000/- to the
accused. Even though, in the bank account of the
complainant at the time of alleged lending, there was no
`
sum of 30,00,000/- but it is established that the
Complainant has withdrawn more than said amount from
his bank from 2013 onwards. The accused has not
produced any evidence to show that at the time of this
alleged lending, the complainant was in financial difficulty.
The case filed by Smt. Manjula Devi against the
complainant is in respect of the transaction of June-2015
but the transaction between the complainant and the
accused was far earlier to said date. Hence, these facts are
not helpful to the accused to discharge the burden on him.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 36 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


When the accused failed to discharge the burden, the
presumptions in favour of the complainant will be intact
that accused has issued the subject cheque for repayment
of existing legally recoverable debt or liability either in part
or in whole. Considering these facts, trial Court convicted
the accused confirmed by the appellate Court which
requires no interference in this revision.

49. As far as imposing sentence is concerned, the
cheque amount is ` 30,00,000/-; the trial Court has
imposed a fine of ` 45,02,000/-; out of which ` 45,00,000/-
shall be payable to the complainant as compensation. No
reason is assigned for imposing such sentence by the trial
Court except stating that in the facts and circumstances of
the case, the Court feels that if the amount was utilized by
the complainant, he would have more and by stating so,
the trial court imposed the fine including the cheque
amount plus 50% of the cheque amount.

50. In this regard appellate Court has observed that
the trial Court has not imposed twice the cheque amount
as fine but only imposed fine of ` 45,00,000/- and interest
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 37 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024


at 9% could have been imposed which is also not imposed.
Hence, the said contention was not appreciated and
confirmed the judgment of trial Court.

51. The transaction between the complainant and
the accused is not a commercial transaction but because
they were close friends, the complainant has lent
` 30,00,000/- to the accused. The transaction was of the
year 2015 and we are in the year 2026. This is not a civil
suit.

52. Considering the submission of both sides and
verifying the papers, this Court opines that imposing fine
of ` 45,00,000/- was exorbitant and thus, the fine amount
is reduced to ` 38,00,000/-. Except this alteration, the
other portion of the judgment of trial Court, confirmed by
the appellate Court, is unaltered.

53. Hence, this Court passes the following:
ORDER

I. The Criminal Revision Petition is allowed in part.
Digitally Signed By:
K B GEETHA

- 38 -
CRL.RP No. 1658 of 2024



II. The fine amount imposed by the trial court at
` 45,00,000/- is reduced to ` 38,02,000/-; out of
which ` 38,00,000/- shall be payable as
compensation to the complainant and ` 2,000/- shall
be defrayed to the State. Except this alteration, the
other portion of the judgment of trial Court,
confirmed by the appellate Court, is unaltered.
Digitally Signed By:

K B GEETHA

(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE



SPV/ rs