SMT. NAGARATHNA vs SRI. SHIVARAJU C

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU


TH
DATED THIS THE 8 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 6880/2023 (FC)
C/W
REV.PET FAMILY COURT NO. 240/2023

IN MFA No. 6880/2023:

BETWEEN:

SMT. NAGARATHNA
W/O SRI SHIVARAJU C
AGED 39 YEARS,
R/AT NO.552, SECOND STAGE,
KESERE, R.S.NAIDU NAGAR,
N.R. MOHALLA, MYSURU - 570 007.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. RANGARAMU.V.,ADVOCATE)

AND:

SRI. SHIVARAJU C
S/O LATE CHIKKEERAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
R/AT MIKKERE VILLAGE,
MALAVALLI TALUK,
MANDYA DISTRICT,
KARNATAKA – 571 424.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. AJIT KALYAN.,ADVOCATE)

THIS MFA FILED UNDER SECTION 19(1) OF FAMILY COURT
ACT, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 06.03.2023
PASSED IN M.C.NO. 636/2022 ON THE FILE OF THE II ADDITIONAL
PRINCIPAL JUDGE, FAMILY COURT, MYSURU, ALLOWING THE
PETITION FILED UNDER SECTION 9 OF THE HINDU MARRIAGE ACT.











Digitally signed
by B VEENA
KUMARI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

IN RPFC NO. 240/2023:

BETWEEN:

1. SMT. NAGARATHNA
W/O SRI SHIVARAJU C
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS,

2. KUM CHANDANA M S
D/O SRI SHIVARAJU C
AGED ABOUT 17 YEARS,

3. MAST. ADARSHA M S
S/O SRI SHIVARAJU C
AGED ABOUT 15 YEARS,

THE PETITIONERS NO.2 & 3 ARE MINORS,
REP BY THEIR NATURAL GUARDIAN MOTHER
SMT. NAGARATHNA I.E., FIRST PETITIONER
ND
ALL ARE R/AT NO 552, 2 STAGE,
KESERE, R S NAIDU NAGAR,
N R MOHALLA, MYSURU 570 007.
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. RANGARAMU V.,ADVOCATE)

AND:

SRI. SHIVARAJU C
S/O LATE CHIKKEERAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
R/AT NO 191, FIRST FLOOR,
TH
10 CROSS, ARVINDA NAGAR,
BEHIND BUS DEPOT, MYSURU,
KARNATAKA 570 023.
PRESENTLY WORKING AT KSRTC BUS DRIVER
BADGE NO.21069.
UNIT 2, KUVEMPUNAGAR DEPOT,
MYSORE – 570 023.
...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. AJIT KALYAN.,ADVOCATE)

THIS RPFC FILED UNDER SECTION 19(4) OF THE FAMILY
COURT ACT, AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 06.03.2023 PASSED
IN CRL.MISC NO.593/2021 ON THE FILE OF HON’BLE II
ADDITIONAL PRINCIPAL JUDGE, FAMILY COURT, MYSURU,
PARTLY ALLOWING THE PETITION FILED UNDER SEC.125 OF
CR.P.C. FOR MAINTENANCE.

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

THIS MFA AND THIS RPFC ARE COMING ON FOR ADMISSION,
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN

ORAL JUDGMENT

(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)

M.F.A.No.6880/2023 is filed by the wife challenging the
judgment and decree dated 06.03.2023 passed in
M.C.No.636/2022 by the II Additional Principal Judge, Family
Court, Mysuru (' the Family Court '), whereby the Family Court
allowed the petition filed by the husband under Section 9 of the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, seeking restitution of conjugal rights
and directed the wife to join her husband and to lead marital
life whereas, RPFC No.240/2023 is filed by the wife and
children challenging the order dated 06.03.2023 passed in
Crl.Misc.No.593/2021 by the II Additional Principal Judge,
Family Court, Mysuru, whereby the Family Court had rejected
the claim of the wife for maintenance by allowing maintenance
to the children.

2. Since both M.F.A.No.6880/2023 and RPFC
No.240/2023 though arise out of different cases, but the

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

matrimonial proceedings is between the same parties and
concerns certain connected issues, both are clubbed together
and disposed of by this common judgment.

3. For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred to as per their rankings before the Family Court.

In M.C.No.636/2022
(i) FACTS OF THE PETITIONER:

4. The petitioner and the respondent are husband and
wife. Their marriage was solemnised on 16.11.2003 at
N.R.Kalyana Mantapa, Bannur Village, Mysuru District, in
accordance with Hindu customs and rituals. Out of the wedlock,
they have two children, a daughter born on 01.01.2005 and a
son born on 04.08.2006. According to the petitioner, the
parties initially resided at Mikkere Village, Malavalli Taluk. In
the year 2008, with a view to providing better educational
facilities to the children, he shifted the family to Mysuru and
arranged accommodation in a mortgaged house. He was
employed as a KSRTC bus driver at Kuvempunagar Depot,
Mysuru.

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

5. The petitioner's grievance was that, after shifting to
Mysuru, the respondent began quarrelling with him frequently,
suspecting his fidelity and making allegations against his
character on account of the telephone calls he received in
connection with his work. He further contended that the
respondent was not cooperating in maintaining the matrimonial
household and was also creating disputes over family matters.
According to him, the complaint lodged by the respondent
before the Women Police Station, Mysuru, on 02.09.2021 was
found to be false upon enquiry and the police advised her to
resume matrimonial life.

6. Nevertheless, on 09.04.2022, the respondent left
the matrimonial home along with the children and household
articles and went to her parental house. Having failed in his
efforts to bring her back, he instituted M.C. No.636/2022 on
30.06.2022 under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955,
seeking restitution of conjugal rights.

(ii) DEFENCE OF THE RESPONDENT:
7. The respondent admitted the marriage and the birth
of the two children, but denied the allegations made by the

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

petitioner. Her specific case was that the parties had lived
together for about five years at Mikkere Village and that, after
shifting to Mysuru in 2008, the petitioner started subjecting her
to physical and mental harassment, demanding additional
dowry and neglecting her and the children. She alleged that the
petitioner had developed relationships with other women, failed
to discharge his responsibilities towards the family and,
whenever questioned about his conduct, abused and assaulted
her. She also contended that several panchayaths were
convened through elders and family members, but the
petitioner did not change his conduct.

8. It was her further case that she was ultimately
driven out of the matrimonial home on 10.06.2021 along with
the children and was compelled to take shelter at her parental
house. In that connection, she relied upon the complaints
lodged before the Women Police Station, Mysuru, including the
complaint dated 02.09.2021, and alleged that no effective
action was taken. She also instituted Crl. Misc. No.593/2021
before the Family Court seeking maintenance for herself and
the children, contending that the petitioner, though employed

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

as a KSRTC driver and having other sources of income, had
neglected to maintain them. She opposed the petition for
restitution of conjugal rights as an attempt to avoid his
maintenance obligations and sought its dismissal.

(iii) POINTS FRAMED BY THE FAMILY COURT:
9. On the basis of the pleadings, the Family Court
framed the following points for consideration:
(i) Whether the petitioner proves that the respondent
has withdrawn from his society?

(ii) Whether the respondent proves that there has
been reasonable excuse for withdrawing from the
society of the petitioner?

(iii) Whether the petitioner is entitled for the relief of
restitution of conjugal rights as prayed?

(iv) What Order or Decree?

10. The Court also considered the evidence of PW.1
and RW.1 and the documentary evidence produced by both
parties, including the police complaint, the proceedings in Crl.
Misc. No.593/2021, the CD containing voice recordings and
the certificate issued by Kishan Digital Studio.

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

(iv) JUDGMENT OF THE FAMILY COURT IN
M.C.NO.636/2022:

11. The Family Court, by judgment dated 06.03.2023,
allowed M.C. No.636/2022. The petitioner examined himself as
PW.1 and produced Exs.P1 to P7, while the respondent
examined herself as RW.1 and produced Exs.R1 and R2. The
Court noticed that the respondent was residing separately with
the children and, on examining her cross-examination, found
that she was not willing to join the petitioner at Mikkere Village
and was insisting upon a separate rented house at Mysuru,
besides certain conditions relating to property and monetary
matters. The Court also noticed that the suggestion put to PW.1
that the respondent was apprehending danger to her life had
not been established through the evidence.

12. On appreciation of the evidence, the Family Court
held that the allegations of physical and mental cruelty,
additional dowry demand and illicit relationship had not been
satisfactorily established. It found that the complaint dated
02.09.2021 contained general allegations without particulars of
specific incidents and that the voice recordings in Ex.R1,

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

though indicating a conversation with another woman, were not
sufficient to establish an illicit relationship.

13. The Court also relied upon the respondent's
admission regarding the educational expenses of the children
and the circumstances in which the parties shifted to Mysuru. It
ultimately held that the respondent had failed to establish
reasonable excuse for withdrawing from the petitioner's society.
Accordingly, the petition under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage
Act was allowed and the respondent was directed to join the
petitioner and lead marital life at Mikkere Village, Malavalli
Taluk. No order as to costs was made.

14. Aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated
06.03.2023 passed in M.C. No.636/2022, the respondent-wife
has preferred the present appeal, inter alia, contending that the
Family Court failed to properly appreciate the pleadings, oral
evidence and documentary material placed on record.

(v) GROUNDS URGED IN THE APPEAL:
15. It is urged that the Court overlooked the complaints
lodged before the Women Police Station, Mysuru, the

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

allegations of dowry harassment and cruelty, the CD and voice
recordings produced as Ex.R1 and the circumstances which
compelled her to leave the matrimonial home along with the
children. The appellant further contends that the petition for
restitution of conjugal rights was instituted only to avoid
payment of maintenance, particularly when she had already
initiated Crl. Misc. No.593/2021 seeking maintenance for
herself and the children.

16. According to her, the Family Court failed to consider
the admissions elicited in cross-examination, the material
placed by her regarding the petitioner's income and neglect,
and the effect of the pending criminal proceedings arising out of
her police complaint. It is therefore contended that the decree
directing her to resume matrimonial life at Mikkere Village,
without properly examining the circumstances in which she had
left the matrimonial home, is unsustainable and liable to be set
aside.

17. We have heard Sri.Ranga Ramu V., learned counsel
appearing for the appellant/wife and Sri.Ajit Kalyan, learned
counsel for the respondent/husband. Upon consideration of the

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

pleadings, the records placed before this Court and the
submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioner and
respondent, the following point arises for our consideration:
Whether the petitioner has made out any ground
warranting interference with the judgment and
decree dated 06.03.2023 passed in
M.C.No.636/2022 by the II Additional Principal
Judge, Family Court, Mysuru?

(vi) REASONS AND ANALYSIS:
18. The material on record, particularly the evidence of
RW.1 and the admissions elicited in her cross-examination,
does not support the case sought to be made out by the
respondent. The marriage between the parties was solemnised
on 16.11.2003 and they have two children. It is not in dispute
that the parties shifted from Mikkere Village to Mysuru in the
year 2008 and continued to reside together thereafter. The
dispute arose much later. The respondent lodged a complaint
before the Women Police Station, Mysuru, on 02.09.2021,
nearly eighteen years after the marriage, alleging dowry
harassment and physical and mental cruelty from the beginning
of the matrimonial relationship.

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

19. The Family Court, on examining Ex.P4, noticed that
the complaint contained general allegations and did not refer to
any specific incident of assault, cruelty or demand for dowry.
No contemporaneous material was placed to substantiate those
allegations. The fact that a complaint has been lodged cannot,
by itself, establish the truth of its contents, particularly when
the allegations are disputed and the evidence led in support
thereof does not inspire confidence.

20. The respondent's further case was that she had
been driven out of the matrimonial home on 10.06.2021. The
petitioner, on the other hand, specifically pleaded that she
voluntarily left the matrimonial home on 09.04.2022 along with
the children and household articles. The evidence also discloses
that after the parties shifted to Mysuru in 2008, they continued
their matrimonial life in the rented accommodation until the
separation in 2021-2022. The respondent has not placed
satisfactory evidence to establish that she was forcibly
dispossessed or that the petitioner had refused to provide her
and the children with basic necessities.

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

21. Significantly, the respondent had disputed the
petitioner's contention that the matrimonial home at Mysuru
was established to facilitate the education of the children.
However, she had herself pleaded the same fact in Crl.Misc.
No.593/2021. Further, during the cross-examination of PW-1,
the respondent contended that her mother had contributed
Rs.1,50,000/- towards securing the house at Srirampura and
Rs.2,50,000/- towards discharge of the mortgage liability for
obtaining the house at Aravindanagar. However, these alleged
contributions remain unsubstantiated. Moreover, in Exhibit P6,
the respondent had herself stated that her mother did not have
the financial capacity to maintain the family. In the absence of
any supporting material, the respondent's contention regarding
her mother's financial contributions cannot be accepted.

22. Another circumstance which deserves consideration
is the evidence relating to the alleged illicit relationship of the
petitioner with other woman. The respondent relied upon
Ex.R1-CD containing certain voice recordings and Ex.R2, the
certificate issued by Kishan Digital Studio. The Family Court has
not ignored this material. It examined the conversations

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

between the petitioner and the concerned lady and noticed that
the recording indicated a degree of familiarity, but did not
establish an illicit relationship. The conversation, by itself, was
insufficient to conclude that the petitioner was maintaining an
adulterous relationship or that he had neglected his wife on
that account.

23. Equally relevant are the recordings relating to the
conversation between the petitioner and his elder sister and
another conversation with his friend. Those recordings disclose
the petitioner's concern over the respondent's refusal to join
him and the dispute concerning the mortgaged house at
Mysuru and his decision to return to Mikkere Village. The
conversation also refers to his investment of Rs.64,000/- in a
fixed deposit, with his elder sister Nagamma as nominee. The
Family Court has considered these recordings in their proper
context. It cannot be said that the Court has ignored Ex.R1
merely because the respondent sought to draw a different
inference from its contents.

24. More importantly, the respondent's own cross-
examination gives a clear indication of the real nature of the

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

dispute between the parties. The relevant portion, as extracted
in the judgment of the Family Court, reads as follows:
“   ಅ ರ
ನನ ಷರ ಗಳ ಒ  ಂಡ
 ೕಗ ತ  ! ೕ" . #ೕಗ$ ದ ಹಣವ  ನನ
ಮಗಳ *ಸ , -ೕವ. ಇ01 2ೕ  34, ಮ" 5ಡ2ೕ6

ಮ78 9ೕತನದ :;ಯ  ನನ *ಸ , ಜಂ> :;
5ಡ2ೕ6 . ಊ ನ@A ಅ ರ, Bೕ ದ ಮ" ಮ78

ಜCೕ ಗDಲA F ನನ ಮ78 ಅವರ *ಸ , ಜಂ> :;
ಆಗ2ೕ6 ........ ನನ ಷರ78 ಗಳ  ರ7ಪ4I

ಅ ರ
ನನ  ಮ78 ಮಕK ಳ  ಕ LಂM
ೕN O ೕP QRS ಸTಂದ Uೕ4 ಳV  ತ ! 

ಅಂದ    ಅವರ WೕX ನನ, ನಂYZ ಇ[A ಎಂL
*ೕ]^8  .”


25. The substance of this admission is that the
respondent was willing to join the petitioner only if her
conditions concerning a separate rented house, deposit of the
mortgage amount in the daughter's name, joint operation of
the salary account and joint ownership of the properties were
fulfilled. She also stated that she had no confidence in the
petitioner. The Family Court was therefore justified in
examining whether her refusal to join the petitioner was really
on account of any proved threat or cruelty, or whether the
disagreement was essentially concerning the place of residence
and the financial and property conditions insisted upon by her.

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

26. It is also significant that, during the cross-
examination of PW.1, the suggestion that the respondent was
refusing to join him because of a threat to her life was not
established.

27. The law declared by the Supreme Court in K.
1 2
Srinivas v. K. Sunita and K. Srinivas Rao v. D.A. Deepa ,
is relevant while considering the effect of unsubstantiated
criminal complaints and allegations made against a spouse. The
Supreme Court has recognised that false and unfounded
criminal accusations against the husband and his family
members, depending upon the facts and circumstances, may
amount to matrimonial cruelty. The principle cannot be applied
mechanically to every complaint lodged by a wife, nor can a
genuine grievance be discarded merely because the criminal
proceedings have not culminated in conviction.

28. In the present case, however, the complaint dated
02.09.2021, the absence of particulars regarding specific
incidents, the lack of corroborating evidence and the
admissions made by the respondent in her cross-examination

1

(2014) 16 SCC 34
2

(2013) 5 SCC 226

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

have to be considered together. The Court is not required to
treat the mere lodging of a complaint as proof of the allegations
contained therein. The respondent had the burden, under the
Explanation to Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, to establish
reasonable excuse for withdrawing from the society of the
petitioner. That burden has not been discharged by merely
repeating the allegations made in the police complaint and in
the objection statement.

29. Viewed in its entirety, the evidence does not
establish that the respondent was compelled to leave the
matrimonial home because of any proved act of cruelty or that
her continued separation was supported by a reasonable
excuse. The fact that she has been residing with her parents
since the separation, and that the parties have been living
apart for a considerable period, cannot by itself furnish
justification for refusing to resume matrimonial life.

30. The petitioner instituted M.C.No.636/2022 on
30.06.2022, whereas the respondent had already initiated
Crl.Misc.No.593/2021 seeking maintenance. The timing of
these proceedings, by itself, does not establish that the petition

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

for restitution was filed to defeat the claim for maintenance.
The Family Court made an effort to reconcile the parties, both
in M.C.No.636/2022 and in the maintenance proceedings, but
the efforts did not succeed. It also examined the oral evidence,
the police complaint, the maintenance proceedings and the
recordings produced by the respondent before arriving at its
conclusion.

31. We find no material error in that appreciation. The
findings that the respondent withdrew from the petitioner's
society without reasonable excuse and that the petitioner was
entitled to restitution of conjugal rights are supported by the
evidence on record.

32. The grounds urged in the appeal do not make out a
case for interference with the judgment and decree dated
06.03.2023. Consequently, M.F.A.No.6880/2023 is liable to be
dismissed.

(vii) In RPFC NO 240/2023:
33. It is also relevant to notice that the respondent-wife
has preferred RPFC No.240/2023, challenging the order passed

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

in Crl.Misc.No.593/2021, instituted under Section 125 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, seeking maintenance for herself
and her minor children.

(viii) CASE OF THE PETITIONERS:
34. The petitioners, namely, the wife and her two minor
children, instituted Crl.Misc.No.593/2021 on 18.09.2021 before
the II Additional Principal Judge, Family Court, Mysuru, under
Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, seeking
maintenance from the respondent-husband. Their marriage was
solemnised on 16.11.2003 at N.R.Kalyana Mantapa, Bannur
Village, Mysuru District, and out of the wedlock a daughter was
born on 01.01.2005 and a son on 04.08.2006. According to the
wife, after the family shifted to Mysuru in 2008, the respondent
started subjecting her to physical and mental harassment,
demanding additional dowry and neglecting her and the
children, besides maintaining illicit relationships with other
women.

35. She alleged that she was ultimately driven out of
the matrimonial home on 10.06.2021 along with the children
and had to reside at her parental house. The petitioners

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

contended that the respondent was working as a KSRTC bus
driver, drawing a salary of more than Rs.40,000/- per month,
apart from rental and agricultural income. They accordingly
sought maintenance of Rs.20,000/- per month for the wife,
Rs.15,000/- each for the two children and litigation expenses of
Rs.50,000/-.

(ix) DEFENCE OF THE RESPONDENT :
36. The respondent/husband admitted the relationship
and the paternity of the two children, but denied the allegations
of cruelty, dowry demand and neglect. His specific defence was
that the wife was not cordial with him and his family members
from the beginning of the marriage and used to pick up
quarrels even over trivial matters. He contended that, at her
insistence, he had arranged a separate house at Mysuru, but
she continued to quarrel and ultimately voluntarily left the
matrimonial home on 01.08.2021 along with the children and
household articles.

37. He further stated that, despite his efforts to bring
her back, she refused to resume matrimonial life and also
prevented him from meeting the children. A legal notice dated

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

14.09.2021 was issued calling upon her to join his company,
but she neither complied with the request nor sent any reply.
On these grounds, he sought dismissal of the maintenance
petition, particularly the wife's claim.

(x) POINTS FOR CONSIDERATION IN C.MISC.593/2021:
38. On the basis of the pleadings and the rival
contentions, the Family Court framed the following points for
consideration:
(i) Whether the petitioners are entitled for the
maintenance as claimed?
(ii) What order?


39. The wife examined herself as PW.1 and produced
Exs.P1 to P20, whereas the respondent/husband examined
himself as RW.1 and produced Exs.R1 to R17. The Court also
noticed that reconciliation efforts were made in
Crl.Misc.No.593/2021 as well as in the connected proceedings
in M.C.No.636/2022, instituted by the husband on 30.06.2022
under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, but the efforts did
not result in any settlement.

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

(xi) JUDGMENT OF THE FAMILY COURT:
40. The Family Court relied upon the admissions elicited
from PW.1 during her cross-examination. She admitted that the
respondent was bearing the educational expenses of the
children and was also providing grocery items in accordance
with the list prepared by her, marked as Ex.R17. She also
admitted that during the COVID-19 pandemic she had
attempted to run a grocery shop. Her evidence regarding the
conditions subject to which she was willing to join the
respondent, namely, a separate rented house, deposit of the
mortgage amount in the name of the daughter, a joint salary
account and joint rights in the properties, was also taken note
of. The Court found that she had not established any justifiable
reason for residing separately from the respondent.

41. Upon examining the salary slip for November 2021,
showing gross salary of Rs.41,484/- and net salary of
Rs.19,804/-, and the material concerning his immovable
property, the Court directed the respondent to pay
maintenance of Rs.5,000/- each per month to the two minor
children from 18.09.2021 till they attain majority, besides

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

bearing their entire educational expenses from the academic
year 2021-22. Litigation expenses of Rs.3,000/- were also
awarded. The claim of the wife for maintenance was rejected,
holding that she was residing separately without sufficient
cause.

42. Aggrieved by the rejection of her maintenance claim
and the quantum of maintenance awarded to the minor
children, the wife, along with the children, has preferred RPFC
No.240/2023 under Section 19(4) of the Family Courts Act,
challenging the order dated 06.03.2023.

(xii) GROUNDS:
43. It is contended that the Family Court failed to
properly appreciate the documentary evidence regarding the
respondent's income and his capacity to maintain the
petitioners. It is asserted that, apart from his KSRTC salary, he
was earning rental income of Rs.4,000/- per month and
agricultural income of more than Rs.1,00,000/- per annum
from the agricultural land at Mikkere Village.

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

44. The petitioners also contend that the Court
overlooked the complaints lodged before the Women Police
Station, Mysuru, including the complaint dated 24.11.2021,
pursuant to which Crime No.112/2021 was registered for the
alleged offences under Sections 498-A and 504 of IPC and
Section 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, and which, according to
them, was pending before the VII Additional Civil Judge and
JMFC, Mysuru. They further contend that the respondent
instituted M.C. No.636/2022 for restitution of conjugal rights
only to avoid his liability to pay maintenance. It is also urged
that the wife has no independent income or accommodation
and is dependent upon her aged parents.

45. The petitioners accordingly seek enhancement of
maintenance to Rs.20,000/- per month for the wife and
Rs.15,000/- each for the minor children, from the date of the
petition, apart from Rs.50,000/- towards litigation expenses
and the entire educational expenses of the children. The
revision petition was presented on 03.10.2023, with an
application seeking condonation of 121 days' delay, which was
condoned by order dated 14.03.2025.

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

(xiii) REASONS AND ANALYSIS:
46. On consideration of the material, the rejection of
the wife's claim cannot be viewed in isolation from the
circumstances in which the parties separated. The Family Court
has not rejected her claim merely because the husband had
instituted proceedings for restitution of conjugal rights. It has
examined the period of cohabitation, the complaint dated
02.09.2021, the evidence relating to the alleged cruelty and the
admissions made by PW.1. The parties continued to live
together at Mysuru from 2008 till 2020-21.

47. The allegation that the wife was subjected to
continuous cruelty throughout this period was not supported by
any specific contemporaneous complaint or independent
evidence. The subsequent registration of Crime No.112/2021
on 24.11.2021, on the basis of allegations under Sections 498-
A and 504 of IPC and Section 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, is
a matter to be dealt with in those proceedings. Mere
registration of a criminal case, which is stated to be pending,
cannot by itself establish that the respondent had driven the
wife out or that she was justified in refusing to reside with him.

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

48. There is also substance in the Family Court's
reliance upon the admissions of PW.1. Though the wife alleged
that the respondent had completely neglected the children and
had not borne their educational expenses, she admitted in
cross-examination that the respondent himself had been
meeting those expenses. She further admitted that he supplied
grocery articles in accordance with the list prepared by her.
These admissions have a direct bearing on the allegation of
total neglect.

49. Her evidence regarding the conditions imposed for
returning to the matrimonial home, when read with the
evidence in M.C.No.636/2022, also indicates that the
separation was accompanied by disputes relating to the
mortgaged house, the proposed separate accommodation and
the monetary and property arrangements. The Family Court
was entitled to examine these circumstances while deciding
whether the wife had sufficient reason to live separately.

50. As regards the financial capacity of the respondent,
the Family Court has considered the salary slip and the other
materials placed before it. Though the gross salary was

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

Rs.41,484/-, the net salary shown was Rs.19,804/- after
deductions. The alleged rental income and agricultural income
were not established by satisfactory evidence. Even so, the
Family Court did not absolve the respondent of his
responsibility towards the minor children.

51. It directed payment of Rs.5,000/- per month to
each child, from the date of the petition, till attainment of
majority, and also directed him to bear their entire educational
expenses from the academic year 2021-22, apart from
litigation expenses of Rs.3,000/-. In the circumstances, the
challenge to the quantum cannot be considered merely on the
basis of the gross salary or unsubstantiated income figures
pleaded by the petitioners.

52. The statutory entitlement of the wife under Section
125 Cr.P.C. must be considered along with the restriction
contained in sub-section (4), where a wife, without sufficient
reason, refuses to live with her husband. On the evidence in
the present case, the Family Court has recorded a finding that
the wife failed to establish a justifiable reason for residing
separately.

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

53. There is no sufficient ground to displace that finding
in revision. At the same time, the maintenance granted to the
minor children is an independent matter and has rightly been
preserved. The fact that the matrimonial relationship between
the parties has become strained cannot be a reason to deprive
the children of their legitimate maintenance or educational
requirements. The Family Court has taken care to protect those
interests.

54. Having regard to the evidence of PW.1 and RW.1,
the admissions elicited in cross-examination, the documents
marked as Exs.P1 to P20 and Exs.R1 to R17, and the findings
recorded by the Family Court, no perversity or material error
warranting interference under Section 19(4) of the Family
Courts Act is made out.

55. The revision petition, insofar as it seeks
maintenance for the wife and enhancement of the amounts
already awarded to the children, does not merit acceptance.

56. Accordingly, RPFC No.240/2023 is liable to be
dismissed, leaving the order granting maintenance and
educational expenses to the minor children undisturbed.

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:56525-DB
MFA No. 6880 of 2023
C/W RPFC No. 240 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010521892023

57. For the foregoing reasons, we pass the following;
ORDER
M.F.A.No.6880/2023 and R.P.F.C.No.240/2023 are
dismissed.

Consequently, the judgment and decree dated
06.03.2023 passed in M.C.No.636/2022 by the II Additional
Principal Judge, Family Court, Mysuru and the order dated
06.03.2023 passed in Crl.Misc.No.593/2021 by the II Additional
Principal Judge, Family Court, Mysuru, stand undisturbed.

No order as to costs.

Sd/-
(D K SINGH)
JUDGE


Sd/-
(H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
JUDGE

KNM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 13