Anokhey And Others vs State of U.P.

Court
Allahabad High Court

Reserved on 06.08.2026
Delivered on 17.11.2026
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 2923 of 1985
Anokhey And Others
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P.
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Amrita Rai Mishra (A.C.), P.N.Mishra,
Rajesh Kumar Verma
Counsel for Respondent(s) : A.G.A.
Court No. - 43
HON'BLE SIDDHARTH, J.
HON'BLE VINAI KUMAR DWIVEDI, J.
(Delivered by Hon'ble Siddharth, J.)
1. Heard Ms. Amrita Rai Mishra, learned Amicus Curiae appearing for
appellants; Shri Udai Prakash Srivastava, learned A.G.A. for the State and
perused the trial court record and judgment and order passed by the trial
court.
2. This criminal appeal has been preferred by learned counsel for the
appellants against the judgment and order dated 18.10.1985 passed by
Additional Sessions Judge, Bareilly, in Sessions Trial No. 448 of 1983,
convicting and sentencing the appellants, namely, Anokhey, Ved Ram and
Gendan, for life imprisonment under Section 302/34 IPC.
2A. During the pendency of this criminal appeal, the appellants, Anokhey
and Ved Ram, have died and appeal has been dismissed as abated qua them.
Only appellant no.3, Gendan, is alive and his counsel has been heard with
regard his role. Appellant, Gendan, is son of appellant no.1, Anokhey, who
has already died.
3. The prosecution case, in short, is that on 2.6.83 at about 8:00 p.m. in the
night deceased, Mangli, was at his tube well situated in his field in village
Dharampur within the circle of P.S.Aonla, District Bareilly. Ramveer s/o
the deceased was looking after his chilli field at a distance of 12 paces from

CRLA No. 2923 of 1985
2
the tubewell. Ompal of their village was also present in his field which was
also adjacent to the chilli field of the complainant Ramveer. Accused,
Anokhey, Ved Ram and Gendan came there together at the tubewell where
deceased Mangli was there. Accused, Anokhey and Gendan had guns in
their hands and accused Ved Ram had a Lathi. The accused asked Mangli for
water to drink and on this deceased drew water from the well and served to
the accused. Thereafter accused, Anokhey and Gendan each fired shots with
their guns at Mangli as a result of which Mangli got injured and sustained
fire injuries on his left hand and left abdomen. Accused Ved Ram gave a
lathi blow which hit on the right hand of Mangli. Seeing all this,
complainant Ramveer and Ompal rebuked the accused and also raised an
alarm and thereafter all the three accused ran away towards their village
Harharpur. There was an old enmity with accused as accused wanted to
purchase the land from Puna Brahauri of village Sigoi, P.S. Kunwar Gaon
but they could not purchase for want of money. The deceased had purchased
the land from Puna Brahauri and on account of this accused bore enmity and
on account of said enmity they fired shots at Mangli with an intention to kill
him. The complainant and Ompal both saw and identified all the three
accused in the light of torch.
4. After the said incident the complainant Ramveer took his father in a truck
to the police station Aonla where he lodged the report of the incident. The
injured was sent from police station to Primary Health Centre Aonla for
medical examination.
5. Dr. C.P. Shinghal was posted as Medical Officer at P.H.C. Aonla on
3.6.83. On 3.6.83 he examined the injuries of Mangli at about 12.10 Α.Μ.
and found the following injuries on his person,
i. One fire arm lacerated wound 7 cm x 6 cm-x muscle deep on the back side
of left upper arm. Margins of the Wound irregular. Bleeding present,
margins are black.
ii. Multiple fire arm lacerated Wound about 20 in an area of 11. cm x 5 cm
on the outer aspect and middle part of left chest. Size of each wound is 0.25
cm x 0.25 cm. x muscle deep. Margins irregular. Bleeding present. Surgical
emphysien present.
iii Lacerated wound 3 cm x 0.5 cm x muscle deep on the web between right
index finger and right thumb. Margins of the wound irregular. Bleeding

CRLA No. 2923 of 1985
3
present.
6. All the above injuries were kept under observation and were fresh at the
time of medical examination. Injuries no.1 and 2 were caused by some fire
arm and no.3 was caused by some blunt object. Dr. Shinghal proved the
injury report. This is Ex.Ka-4. He stated that all the above injuries of injured
Mangli could have been caused on 2.6.83 at 8 in the night. In his opinion
injury no.3 could be caused by a Lathi.
7. Injured was medically advised to be shifted to Bareilly Civil Hospital for
medical treatment and so he was taken from there to Bareilly Civil Hospital
but deceased succumbed to his injuries on the way at Chaupula. The
information about the death of Mangli was given at P.S.Kotwali by Satya
Deo Gupta. Satya Deo Gupta was posted as constable at P.S.Aonla on
2.6.83. The injured was sent to Primary Health Centre, Aonla for medical
examination through this constable. One blood stained Banian was taken by
this constable in his possession at P.H.C.Aonla. He prepared a Fard
regarding the same. This is Ex.Ka-2. He started from P.H.C. Aonla on the
next day and reached Civil Hospital, Bareilly, at 8.40 A.M. but Mangli had
died before he could be given any treatment by the doctor. Hence this
constable went to P.S.Kotwali where he lodged the report about the death of
Mangli.
8. Sri Rajendar Pal was posted as S.I. at P.S.Kotwali on 3.6.83.He was
present at Civil Hospital, Bareilly where he was given the copy of report by
constable Satya Deo Gupta. The information which was given by Satya Deo
Gupta about the death of Mangli at P.S.Kotwali, was entered in G.D. at
report no. 19 on 3.6.83 at 8.45 A.M. by clerk constable Room Singh. The
copy of G.D. is Ex.Ka-14. Constable Beerbal took Jild panchayatnama and
memo and copy of report to Civil Hospital regarding which an entry in G.D.
at report No. 21 on 3.6.83 at 9.45 A.M. was made by clerk constable Dular
Singh. The copy of G.D. is Ex.Ka-15.
9. On 3.6.83 at 10 in the morning Sri Rajendar Pal Singh S.I. prepared the
inquest report of the dead body of Mangli at Civil Hospital, Bareilly. This is
Ex.Ka-16. The dead body of Mangli in a sealed cover was sent for post
mortem to mortuary through constables Satya Deo and Paras Nath. He also
prepared Namoona Mohr Ex.Ka-17, photo lash Ex.Ka-18, chalan lash
Ex.Ka-19, Chithi to R.I. Ex.Ka-20 and Chithi to C.M.O. Ex.Ka-21. All these

CRLA No. 2923 of 1985
4
papers, were also handed over to the constable, who took the dead body of
deceased for post mortem.
10. Dr. J.N.Bhargava Was posted as Medical Officer at District Hospital,
Bareilly on 3.6.83. On 3.6.83 at 2.30 P.M. he conducted the post mortem of
the dead body of deceased Mangli.
11. The deceased was of average built and rigor mortis was present and there
was no decomposition of both limbs and digested food was coming out from
mouth and nose. The following ante-mortem injuries were found on the
person of the deceased.
i.Gun shot wound of entry 3 cm x 2 cm x muscle deep (lacerated wound) on
back of left upper arm 1 cm above elbow joint. Blackening present around
the wound.
ii. Gun shot wound 2 cm x 1½ cm x muscle deep on the back of left upper
arm. 5 cm apart just above injury no.1. Blackening present. Margins
inverted.
iii. Exit lacerated wound 4 cm x 3 cm in the inner aspect of left upper arm 9
cm above elbow joint. Margins everted.
iv. Gun shot Wound of exit 1 cm x 1 cm outer side of left upper arm 5 cm
below injury no.3. Margins everted.
v. Gun shot wound of entry 1 cm x 1 cm inner aspect of left upper arm 7 cm
below axillary pit. Margin inverted.
vi. Multiple gun shot wounds of entry in an area of 7 cm x 5 cm left side of
chest 13 cm below axila. Margin inverted. average size .5 cm x .5 cm to .25
cm x .25 cm spin muscle chest cavity deep.
vii. Lacerated wound 2 cm x .5 cm x muscle deep. Web span of thumb and
index finger(right).
12. On internal examination left 8th rib fractured under injury and plura
lacerated, (left) blood fluid present about 1 litre, 2 shots recovered, left lung
lacerated lower lobe 2 shots recovered were seen and found. Semi digested
food about 100 gm was present in belly. The duration of death was about 1/2
day.

CRLA No. 2923 of 1985
5
13. The death was caused due to shock and haemorrhage due to ante-mortem
injuries. In the opinion of Dr. Bhargava all injures which were found ante-
mortem were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. In his
opinion all ante-mortem injuries except injury no. 7 were caused by some
fire arm and injury no. 7 was caused by some blunt object including Lathi. In
his opinion death of deceased could be caused on 3.6.83 at 2.30 in the night.
He proved the post mortem report which is Ex.Ka-3. Four pellets which
were recovered from the dead body of deceased were sealed in a bundle and
were given to the constables who had taken the dead body for post mortem.
One Dhoti which was recovered from the dead body of Mangli was also
sealed and given to the said constables. The Dhoti is Ex. 1.
14. Constable, Satya Deo Gupta, was given the post mortem report and
sealed bundles by Dr. Bhargava after post mortem which he had lodged at
the police station. After giving information about the death of Mangli by this
constable Satya Deo Gupta, the case was converted from 307 I.P.C. to 302
I.P.C.
15. Sri Bhagwan Singh was posted as S.I. at police station Aonla on 2.6.83.
The case was registered at P.S.Aonla in his presence by clerk constable
Netra Pal Singh. He proved the chick F.I.R. Ex.Ka-1. An entry in G.D. at
report 59 at 23.15 on 2.6.83 was also made by the same constable. The copy
of G.D. is Ex.Ka-5. Initially the case was registered under section 307 I.P.C.
16. The investigation of the case was entrusted to the said S.I. Sri Bhagwan
Singh. He took the statement of clerk constable Netra Pal Singh,
complainant Ram Veer and also injured Mangli on 2.6.83 at the police
station. He proved the statement of deceased Mangli which was recorded by
him under section 161 Cr.P.C. in case diary. The copy of the said statement
is Ex.Ka-6. On 3.6.83 at 12.06 in the night he took the statement of Ompal at
the police station. Thereafter he along with two constables reached the
village of accused on 3.6.83 and made search of accused at their houses like
but accused were not available. Thereafter he went to the place village of the
complainant on the same day i.e. on 3.6.83 where he reached at 9.15 in the
morning. There he made enquiry from persons and recorded their statements
in case diary. Thereafter he reached the place of incident at 12 noon and
prepared the site plan on the pointing out of the complainant. He proved the
site plan which is marked Ex.Ka-7. Thereafter he seized the simple and
blood stained earth from the place of incident and prepared a recovery memo

CRLA No. 2923 of 1985
6
regarding to it. This is Ex.Ka-8. The blood stained and simple earth were
kept in two separate containers and were sealed. The blood stained and
simple earth are marked Ex.Ka1 and 2. Thereafter he also sealed the bucket
and rope with the help of which deceased had served water to the accused
and he also prepared a Supardiginama which was witnessed by the
witnesses. This is Ex.Ka-9. Thereafter he inspected the torch of the
complainant and after examination he gave it in the Supardigi of the
complainant and also prepared a Supardiginama which is Ex.Ka-1.
Thereafter again he made search of accused in their village but accused were
not found. On 3.6.83 he made arrest of accused Ved Ram at 5.30 in between
Harharpur and Dharampur on the information of the informant and took his
statement at the place of his arrest and thereafter he returned to police station
with accused Ved Ram and lodged him in the lock up and an entry in G.D. at
report No. 28 on 3.6.83 at 18.46 was made. The case property was lodged in
the Malkhana. On 3.6.83 at 19.30 constable Satya Deo Gupta reached police
station Aonla from Civil Hospital, Bareilly. He stated that constable Satya
Deo Gupta lodged the medical report of Mangli which was done at P.H.C.
Aonla and also a Fard which was prepared regarding the blood stained
Banian of deceased, which had marks of pellets and also the sealed bundle of
blood stained Banian. This constable also lodged the post mortem report and
other sealed packets regarding pellets and Dhoti which were given by the
doctor after post mortem to this constable. An entry in G.D. at report no. 29
at 19.30 on 3.6.83 regarding lodging of the said case property by constable
Satya Deo Gupta was made by head Moharrir Bishambhar Dayal. I.O.
proved the copy of G.D. which is Ex.Ka-11. I.O. again went to the village of
accused on 5.6.83 and made their search but accused were not found.
Thereafter again he went to the village of complainant. I.O. stated that he
enquired about the sale deed from the Complainant and other witnesses
which was the cause of murder but he was told that the same would be filed
later on. He stated that he took the statement of Sia Ram regarding the sale
deed. He also examined the torch of Ompal and thereafter gave it in the
Supardigi of Ompal. He also prepared the Supardiginama regarding the torch
of Ompal which is Ex.Ka -12.
17. On 9.6.83 he asked the complainant and Sia Ram to show the sale deed
but they told that they could not get it yet and would present it on getting.
Accused Anokhey and Gendan had surrendered in court on 6.6.83 so he took
their statements in Jail. On 9.6.83. he got the post mortem report, inquest

CRLA No. 2923 of 1985
7
report and other papers, at the police station and he copied them in case
diary. On 13.6.83 he sent the case property through constable SatyavDeo
Gupta for the report of Chemical analysis. On 14.6.83 he went to Civil
Hospital, Bareilly and enquired about the doctor who had conducted the post
mortem. Thereafter he went to police station Kotwali, Bareilly and took the
statements of the witnesses of inquest report. On 20.6.83 he took the
statements of other witnesses of inquest report in village of the complainant.
On 21.6.83 Ram Chandar the son of the deceased Mangli gave him the photo
stat copy of original sale deed which he found correct after comparision with
the original and thereafter he returned the said photo stat of the sale deed, to
the said Ram Chandar. On 24.6.83 he took the statement of Puno from
whom the sale deed was allegedly received. On the same day i.e. on 24.6.83
he after completing the investigation submitted the charge sheet against all
the three accused. This is Ex.Ka-13. There is also the statement of the I.O.
that after getting information from Satya Deo Gupta, constable, about the
death of the Deceased the case was converted from 307 I.P.C. to section 302
I.P.C. and an entry in G.D. at report No.29 regarding the same was also
made, the copy of which is Ex.Ka-11.
18. All the three accused were committed to the court of Sessions as stated
above. They have been charged under section 302 read with section 34 I.P.C.
They did not plead guilty and claimed to be tried.
19. The prosecution in support of its case examined all 7 witnesses out of
whom first two witnesses, namely, Ram Veer P.W.1 and Ompal, P.W.2, are
the witnesses of fact, and rest are formal witnesses.
20. The complainant, Ram Veer, PW-1, is the son and of the deceased and is
also the informant who lodged the report at the police station about the
incident. He stated the prosecution case in detail.
21. The witness, Ompal, P.W.2, is also the witness of fact. He has also stated
about the prosecution case in detail.
22. Dr. C.P. Shinghal, P.W.4, examined the injuries of deceased and proved
his report Ex.Ka-4.
23. Dr. J.N. Bhargava, P.W.3, conducted the post mortem on the dead body
of the deceased and proved the post mortem report.
24. Constable, Satya Deo Gupta, took the injured from police station Aonla

CRLA No. 2923 of 1985
8
to P.H.C. Aonla for medical examination and later on took the deceased to
Bareilly for his treatment and after the death of the deceased he gave
information at the police station Kotwali and he also took the dead body of
deceased to mortuary and after the post mortem brought the sealed bundles
and post mortem report to the police station.
25. S.I. Sri Rajendar Pal Singh prepared the inquest report of the dead body
of deceased and he also prepared the necessary papers. Sri Bhagwan Singh is
the I.O. of the case.
26. The accused persons were examined under section 313 Cr.P.C. they
denied the charge and stated their false implication in the case on account of
enmity. The accused Gendan Lal has pleaded that some dispute over water
had taken place with Ompal. He further pleaded that witnesses examined in
the case belong to one family.
27. Accused, Anokhey, has pleaded that he was at his house. He further
pleaded that they (accused) had purchased the field adjacent to the tube well
of deceased Mangli on account of which witnesses have become inimical to
them. He also pleaded that witnesses examined in the case belong to one
family.
28. The accused, Ved Ram, has pleaded that he was not at the place of
incident and denied the charge and further stated that they had purchased the
field adjacent to the tubewell of deceased which complainant Ram Veer also
wanted and on account of this, they have been falsely implicated in the case.
29. The accused have not led any evidence either oral or documentary in
their defence.
30. After hearing the rival submissions, we find that the motive for the crime
set up by the prosecution is that the deceased had purchased a land from a
lady of the village, which the accused wanted to purchase and hence they
committed the murder of the deceased, Mangali. In their statements recorded
under Section 313 Cr.P.C., the accused claimed that they had purchased the
land adjacent to that of the deceased and not vice versa. It is true that two
prosecution witnesses of fact, PW-1 and PW-2, are family members of the
deceased. Learned counsel for the appellant has assailed their testimony on
this ground.
31. It is well settled that merely because the witnesses are closely related to

CRLA No. 2923 of 1985
9
the deceased, they cannot be said to be interested witnesses and their
evidence cannot be discarded on this ground. The Court has to consider their
testimonies with greater care and circumspection, as held by the Apex Court
in the case of
Gangadhar Behera and others Vs. State of Orrisa, (2002) 8
SCC 381 and Raju @ Balchandran and others Vs. State of Tamil Nadu
. We are not inclined to disbelieve the testimonies of
(2012) 12 SCC 701
PW-1 and PW-2 since we do not find any vital contradictions in their
testimonies and they have given a detailed account of the incident.
32. The non-recovery of the weapon has been argued to be a fact fatal to the
prosecution case. However, this argument cannot be accepted in view of the
judgment of the Apex Court in the case of State of Rajasthan v. Arjun
. It is settled law that where the
Singh and Others , (2011) 9 SCC 115
prosecution case is proved by oral evidence corroborated by medical
evidence, the mere non-recovery of the weapon cannot be fatal to the
prosecution case.
33. In this case, before his death, the deceased had given a statement to the
Investigating Officer, which was recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. We
have gone through the dying declaration of the deceased, wherein he
assigned the role of having firearms to the appellant, Gendan and his father,
Anokhey, while the deceased, Ved Ram, was assigned the role of causing
injuries to the deceased by lathi.The deceased had sustained seven ante-
mortem injuries, as detailed hereinabove in paragraph No. 11. The only fatal
injury was injury No. 6, in the form of simple gunshot entry wound on the
left side of the chest, measuring 7 cm × 5 cm. The injury had penetrated the
chest cavity and as per the doctor's opinion, it caused fracture of the
underlying eighth rib and laceration of the pleura on the left side. The other
six injuries were on the left arm of deceased, while one injury was on the
right thumb and index finger in the form of lacerations, which may have
been caused by a lathi, as attributed to the accused, Ved Ram.
34. From the dying declaration of the deceased, it is not clear as to who
caused the fatal firearm injury to the deceased on his chest. The other five
injuries on the left hand are all gunshot wounds, comprising of four entry
wounds and two exit wounds and appear to have been caused by pellets. It is
not clear whether the firing was made from one firearm or two firearms or
whether the fatal injury was caused to the deceased by appellant No. 1,
Anokhey, or appellant No. 3, Gendan. Appellant No.3, Gendan, is the son of

CRLA No. 2923 of 1985
10
appellant No. 1, Anokhey.
35. The Apex Court, in the case of State of Gujarat v. Jayrajbhai
Puniabhai Varu AIR 2016 SC 3218 (PARA 10 & 11) , has laid down that,
"courts have to be extremely careful while dealing with a dying declaration
as the maker thereof is not available for the cross-examination which poses a
great difficulty to the accused person. The Court has to examine a dying
declaration scrupulously with a microscopic eye to find out whether the
dying declaration is voluntary, truthful, made in a conscious state of mind
and without being influenced by the relatives present or by the investigating
agency who may be interested in the success of investigation or which may
be negligent while recording the dying declaration. The Court has to weigh
all the attendant circumstances and come to the independent finding whether
the dying declaration was properly recorded and whether it was voluntary
and truthful. Once the court is convinced that the dying declaration is so
recorded, it may be acted upon and can be made a basis of conviction. The
courts must bear in mind that each criminal trial is an individual aspect. It
may differ from the other trials in some or the other respect, and therefore a
mechanical approach to the law of dying declaration has to be shunned. A
mechanical approach in relying upon a dying declaration just because it is
there, is extremely dangerous."
36. The only surviving appellant, Gendan, was aged about 20 years on
30.09.1985 and is now above 61 years of age. The motive for the crime was
attributed to his father, Anokhey. PW-1 stated in his deposition that accused,
Anokhey, wanted to purchase the land from Puna Brahauri of village Sigoi,
but he did not have the means to purchase the land and Mangali purchased
the same, which was not liked by Anokhey. Therefore, Anokhey had a
grudge against the deceased. The surviving appellant, Gendan, has been
implicated and convicted because he is the son of Anokhey.
37. However, if the dying declaration of the deceased is read with the ante-
mortem injuries of the deceased, it becomes clear that gunshot entry wounds
were caused to him from the back of left upper arm, inner aspect of left
upper arm and outer aspect of left upper arm, when the multiple gunshot
entry wounds were caused in an area measuring 7 cm × 5 cm on the left side
of his chest, 13 cm below the axilla. Therefore, the assignment of firearms to
appellant No. 1, Anokhey and appellant No. 3, Gendan, by the deceased in
his dying declaration appears to be justified. The injury on the chest of the

CRLA No. 2923 of 1985
11
deceased was caused from the front while the injuries on his left arm were
caused from both behind and the front. It is also possible that the pellets
from the chest injury may have caused wounds on the outer side of the
deceased's left upper arm. However, one person could not have caused fatal
injuries to the deceased from both the front and the back. Therefore, the
involvement of two accused persons appears probable. In his dying
declaration, the deceased assigned the role of causing gunshot injuries to
appellant No. 1, Anokhey, and appellant No. 3, Gendan, son of Anokhey.
Appellant No. 3 has been convicted and sentenced with the aid of Section 34
of the IPC since he shared common intention with his father in the
commission of the alleged crime. He was a youth at that time and his
participation in the alleged offence along with his father cannot be ruled out.
38. Therefore, we are inclined to uphold the conviction of the appellant no.3,
Gendan, as recorded by the trial court and affirm the findings recorded by
the learned trial court qua him. The conviction and sentence of appellant No.
3, Gendan, by trial court is upheld. He is on bail. His bail bonds are
cancelled and sureties are discharged. He is directed to surrender forthwith
and undergo the remaining sentence. In case of failure, it shall be open for
the C.J.M. concerned to take all coercive measures to secure presence of the
appellant no.3 for sending him to jail.
39. The above-noted criminal appeal is
dismissed.
40. The Office is directed to send back the trial court record and
communicate this judgment to the trial court within two weeks.
41. Ms. Amrita Rai Mishra, learned Amicus Curiae appearing for the
appellant in this case, is entitled to professional fees of Rs. 15,000/- (Rupees
fifteen thousand only), which shall be paid to her within one month of the
submission of the bill.


(Vinai Kumar Dwivedi,J.) (Siddharth,J.)
November 17, 2026
Ruchi Agrahari
Digitally signed by :-
RUCHI AGRAHARI
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad