ANIRUDH vs GAURAI GUPTA IAS
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
TH
DATED THIS THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO
CIVIL CONTEMPT PETITION NO. 200228 OF 2026
BETWEEN:
ANIRUDH S/O GOVINDRAO KUMTEKAR,
AGE:55 YEARS, OCC:BUSINESS & AGRICULTURE,
R/O: H NO 9-2-82, NEAR OLD POST OFFICE,
SHAH GUNJ, BIDAR-585401,
CELL NO.9448194482.
…COMPLAINANT
(BY SRI. GHATE KONDIBARAO, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
GAURAI GUPTA IAS,
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA THROUGH
ITS ADDL. CHIEF SECRETARY,
ROOM VIKASA NO.236, 2ND FLOOR,
SOUDHA, DR.B.R.AMBEDKAR STREET,
BENGALURU-560 001.
2. MR. SHASHIDHAR KURERA, IAS,
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
CORPORATE OFFICE, GESCOM,
KALABURAGI-585102.
Digitally signed
by
SHIVALEELA
D UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
3.
MR. CHANDRAKANTH PATIL,
THE DIRECTOR TECHNICAL,
CORPORATE OFFICE, GESCOM,
KALABURAGI-585102.
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
4. MR.MOUNESH PATTAR,
THE CHIEF ENGINEER ELECTRICITY
(OPERATIONS) CORPORATE OFFICE,
GESCOM, KALABURAGI-585102.
5. MR. RAMESH PATIL,
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (ELECTRICAL),
(O & M) ZONE, GESCOM BIDAR DIVISION,
DISTRICT: BIDAR-585401.
6. MR. SRI. VEERABHADRAPPA
THE SUPERINTENDENT (ELECTRICAL), (O & M)
ENGINEER CIRCLE, GESCOM BIDAR DIVISION,
DISTRICT BIDAR-585401.
…ACCUSED
7. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
THROUGH ITS CHIEF SECRETARY, III FLOOR,
VIDHANA SOUDHA, BENGALURU-560001.
…PROFORMA PARTY
(BY SRI. SUDARSHAN M, ADVOCATE FOR R2, R3, R5 & R6;
SMT.MAYA T.R, AGA FOR R7, R1 SERVED)
THIS CCC FILED U/SEC. 11 AND 12 OF THE CONTEMPT
OF COURT ACT, BY THE ADVOCATE FOR COMPLAINANT
PRAYING THAT THIS HONOURABLE COURT TO REGISTER THE
COMPLAINT AND ISSUE NOTICE CALLING UPON THE
RESPONDENTS NO.2 TO 6 WHY THEY SHOULD NOT BE DEALT
WITH UNDER THE CONTEMPT OF COURTS ACT 1971, HAVING
NOT COMPLAINT THE ORDER/DIRECTION PASSED BY THE
LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE OF THIS HONOURABLE COURT IN
WRIT PETITION NO.202086/2026 DATED 05.06.2026 VIDE
ANNEXURE-A AND ACCORDINGLY PUNISH THE RESPONDENTS
IN ACCORDANCE WITH LAW, TO MEET THE ENDS OF JUSTICE
AND EQUITY.
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO
ORAL ORDER
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI)
This contempt petition is filed under Sections 11 and 12
of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, for initiating a contempt
proceedings for disobeying the order dated 05.06.2026 passed
in WP No.202086/2026, wherein, the learned Single Judge has
disposed of the said writ petition directing the respondents
therein to address the grievances of the complainant and
consider his representation dated 19.05.2026 at Annexure-G
and H and pass appropriate orders in accordance with law
within a period of three months from the date of receipt of copy
of the order.
2. Despite directing the respondents, the respondents
did not obey the order passed by the learned Single Judge and
thus the respondents have willfully disobeyed the order passed
by the learned Single Judge. Hence, this contempt petition.
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
3. Today learned counsel appearing for the respondent
Nos.2, 3, 5 and 6 filed a compliance affidavit, which reads as
follows:
“2. I state that at the very outset, the deponent and the
other Accused officials, with utmost respect, submit that
they hold this Hon'ble Court in the highest esteem and
have never intended to disobey, much less wilfully, any
order of this Hon'ble Court. If any delay has occurred in
reporting compliance, the same is neither deliberate nor
intentional, but is due to the supervening circumstances
explained hereinbelow. The deponent tenders an
unconditional apology for any such delay.
THE ORDER OF THIS HON'BLE COURT
3. I state that the Complainant filed W.P. No.
202086/2026 seeking a writ of mandamus directing
Respondent Nos. 2 to 6 to consider his representations
dated 19.05.2026 (Annexures-G and H to the writ
petition) and to give connection to the grid from the
SRTPV generation system of his establishment to the
existing 11 kV line from RR No. KKL-35592, as per letter
No.BDR/EEE/AEE(O)/AE(T)/F-149/2025/26-10205-7
dated 24.11.2025. This Hon'ble Court, by order dated
05.06.2026, disposed of the writ petition at the stage of
preliminary hearing with the following direction in
paragraph 5:
"5. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances
and rival submissions, the respondents are hereby
directed to address the grievances of the petitioner
and consider his representations dated 19.05.2026
at Annexure-G and H and pass appropriate orders
in accordance with law, within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order."
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
The certified copy of the said order was received in the
office of the Respondents. A copy of the order is produced
herewith as Annexure-R1 .
4. I state that the direction of this Hon'ble Court was to
consider the representations and to pass appropriate
orders in accordance with law. This Hon'ble Court did not
direct the Respondents to grant any particular relief. It is
in this background that the deponent places on record the
following facts, which show that the grievance of the
Complainant was in fact addressed and that the
representations have been considered and disposed of.
THE INSTALLATION AND THE REGISTERED
CONSUMER
5. I state that as per the records of GESCOM, the
installation at Sy. No. 343, Kolhar (K) village stands
registered in the name of Smt. Meena W/o Govindrao
Kumtekar . The Complainant is her son. As stated by the
Complainant himself in his e-mail dated 08.06.2026, an
application for additional load and conversion from LT to
HT was made on 08.12.2025 and the fee of Rs. 250/- was
paid on 10.12.2025 vide Receipt No. 05131, with
reference to the order No. BDR/EEE/AEE(O)/AE(T)/F-
149/2025-26/10205-07.
6. I state that the registered consumer, Smt. Meena
Kumtekar, died on 21.12.2025 , as per the Death
Certificate (Form-6) bearing Registration No.
803060/T/D/2026/000085 dated 15.01.2026, issued on
17.01.2026 by the Registrar of Births and Deaths, Bidar
(CMC + OG). She is survived by her husband Sri
Govindrao Kumtekar and four children, viz., Sri Anirudh
Kumtekar (Complainant), Smt. Swati, Smt. Preeti
Jholgikar and Sri Upendra Kumtekar, as per the family
particulars furnished by the Complainant himself by e-
mail dated 09.07.2026. A copy of the Death Certificate is
produced as .
Annexure-R2
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
THE GRIEVANCE OF GRID CONNECTION WAS IN
FACT ADDRESSED ON 30.05.2026
7. I state that the HT power supply and the SRTPV grid
synchronisation sought by the Complainant were
processed and granted by GESCOM step by step, as
under:
(a) Estimate No. 442918/10.02.2026 was prepared and
power sanction for arranging power supply to a 360 KVA
HT installation in the name of Smt. Meena W/o Govindrao
Kumthekar, Cold Storage Constructed Building/Shed, Sy.
No. 343, Kolhar (K), under self-execution, was issued
vide letter No. BDR/EEE/ΑΕΕ(O)/ΑΕ(T)/F-186/2026-
27/447-49 dated 23.04.2026, at an estimated cost of Rs.
4,96,717/- (Annexure-R3).
(b) The Official No. GESCOM/BDR/EEE/AEEE(O)/AE-T/F-
186/2026-27/344-48 dated 24.04.2026 approved the
estimate. Supervision charges of Rs. 24,836/-, CGST of
Rs. 2,235/-, SGST of Rs. 2,235/- and D2 Security Deposit
of Rs. 7,00,646/-and Rs. 22,954/- were paid vide Receipt
Nos. 202600001180 to 202600001184, all dated
24.04.2026 ( Annexure-R4 ).
(c) The Work Completion Report No. dated
BDR/EEE/AEE(DWU)/AE-(DWU)/2026-27/635 27.04.2026
and letter No. BDR/EEE/AEE(DWU)/2026-27/694 dated
29.04.2026 (forwarding the file for testing and calibration
of the metering cubicle) were issued ( Annexure-R5 ).
(d) The Technical Audit & Quality Control Wing, GESCOM,
Bidar, inspected the materials vide Inspection Note No.
TA&QC/EEE/AEE(O)SEW-1160 dated 18.05.2026.
Electrical Inspectorate acknowledgments
No.ΕΙ000110964600 dated 15.05.2026 and No.
EI000110966632 dated 16.05.2026 were obtained
( Annexure-R6 ).
(e) Pre-commissioning and commissioning tests for
servicing the 360 kVA HT installation were conducted on
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
in letter No. recorded dated 18.05.2026, as
GESCOM/AEE/HTR/BDR/2026-27/188-195 19.05.2026 of
the AEE, HT Rating Sub-Division, Bidar. The installation
was serviced on 18.05.2026, and LT RR No. KKL-35592
was converted to HT RR No. KHT98, Tariff HT-2(a)
( Annexure-R7 ).
(f) A new connection application (Application ID 9299976
dated 25.05.2026) was registered online in the name of
"Meena W/o Govindrao Kumthekar" for 360 kW under
Tariff HT-2(a), and an intimation letter dated 29.05.2026
was issued by the AEE, Kamthana Sub-Division. SRTPV
Application Reg. No. 1000101820 dated 29.05.2026 was
also registered ( Annexure-R8 ).
(g) On 30.05.2026, the 360 kWp SRTPV system was
synchronised with the GESCOM grid at the 11,000 V level,
with Main and Check bi-directional ETV meters. This is
recorded in letter No. GESCOM/AEE/HTR/BDR/2026-
27/263-270 dated 30.05.2026 of the AEE, HT Rating Sub-
Division (referring to PPA Agreement dated 30.05.2026),
in the system-generated commissioning details of SRTPV
Application No. 1000101820, and in the Certificate
Synchronisation dated 30.05.2026 issued by the AEE,
O&M Sub-Division, Kamthana ( Annexure-R9 ).
8. I state that thus, the very relief prayed for in the
representations dated 19.05.2026, namely connecting the
Complainant's SRTPV generation system to the GESCOM
grid, was granted on 30.05.2026, even before the order
dated 05.06.2026 was passed. Since the writ petition was
disposed of at the preliminary hearing stage, these
developments could not be placed ATH before this
Hon'ble Court at the time.
SUBSEQUENT CONDUCT OF THE COMPLAINANT
9. I state that soon after the order, the Complainant
changed his stand. By e-mail dated 06.06.2026, he
requested GESCOM to reduce the load of the HT
connection of meter No. KHT98 from 360 kVA to 33 kVA
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
and to refund all the deposits and fees collected. By
another e-mail dated 08.06.2026, he again requested
reduction of the load from 360 kW to 33 KVA "without
any modification of any equipments etc. installed in the
HT yard". Copies of the e-mails are produced as
Annexure-R10 . These requests are entirely different
from, and inconsistent with, the grievance in the
representations dated 19.05.2026.
10. I state that the Complainant then caused a legal
notice dated 30.06.2026 to be issued through his counsel
Sri Jagdish V. Bhande, Advocate, Bidar, alleging
deficiency in service and claiming compensation of Rs.
25,00,000/-. The AEE, O&M Sub-Division, Kamthana,
replied on behalf of GESCOM vide letter No.
GESCOM/KMT/AEEE/SA/2026-27/819-22 dated
09.07.2026 ( Annexure-R11 ).
That reply recorded that:
(a) The May-2026 bill of Rs. 1,68,239/-, generated
by the Centralised Billing System from AMR data,
was re-verified and a revised bill of Rs. 52,839/-
was issued after correcting a system error. The
revised bill was paid, and supply to RR No. KHT98
was restored on 29.06.2026;
(b) The declared purpose of use at the time of
applying for the HT connection was "Cold Storage
Plant". The online application, however, described
the business "Information Technology Industries",
and the legal notice described the premises as an
"Educational Institution/College". The Complainant
has thus been taking inconsistent stands.
11. I state that by letter dated 03.07.2026, the
Complainant sought the RR docket/service file of RR No.
KHT98. By letter No. GESCOM/KMT/AEEE/SA/2026-
27/812-13 dated 09.07.2026, the AEE, Kamthana,
informed him that the installation stands in the name of
Smt. Meena W/o Govindrao Kamtekar and that, as per
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
the GESCOM Office Manual and data-privacy norms, the
service records cannot be furnished without written
authorisation from the registered consumer and approval
of the competent authority. In his reply e-mails of the
same date, the Complainant claimed to be the
"authorised signatory and legal heir" of the deceased
consumer. He also stated that his mother had died on
21.12.2025 and questioned how the HT connection was
serviced and the PPA entered into "in the name of
demised person". He furnished the family particulars
mentioned above. Copies are produced as Annexure-
R12 .
12. I state that the online application dated 25.05.2026
and the PPA dated 30.05.2026 were in the name of the
deceased consumer, Smt. Meena Kumtekar, although she
had died on 21.12.2025. The Complainant relies on a
Letter of Authorisation in Format-1A said to have been
executed by Smt. Meena Kumtekar in his favour for the
SRTPV net-metering programme ( Annexure-R13 ). Any
such authorisation, however, ceased to operate on the
death of the principal.
OBJECTION BY THE OTHER LEGAL HEIR AND THE
CONSEQUENT DISCONNECTION
13. I state that on 14.07.2026, Sri Govindrao Kumtekar
S/o Nanarao Kumtekar, Advocate, Bidar, the husband of
the deceased consumer and the father of the
Complainant, submitted a written objection to the
Executive Engineer, GESCOM, Bidar, with copies to the
Chief Engineer and the Managing Director, GESCOM. It
was received in the Division Office (Inward No. 654 dated
16.07.2026) and was also forwarded by the Legal
Section, Corporate Office, GESCOM, Kalaburagi, by e-mail
dated 24.07.2026 "for further necessary action". In the
objection he stated, inter alia, that:
a) The land in Sy. No. 343 measuring 3 acres was
owned and possessed by the late Smt. Meena
Kumtekar, who constructed the warehouse on it;
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
(b) After her death on 21.12.2025, whatever
agreement she had entered into with GESCOM for
sale of solar energy had become null, void and
unenforceable, and her successors had not entered
into any fresh agreement;
(c) Her successors are not interested in the
business, and the purchase of solar energy should
be stopped immediately until a fresh agreement is
executed.
Copies of the objection and the Legal Section e-mail
dated 24.07.2026 are produced as Annexure-R14 .
14. I state that in view of the objection of another Class-I
legal heir and the fact that the installation and the PPA
stood in the name of a deceased consumer, the power
(solar power) plant of RR No.KHT98 was disconnected on
27.07.2026 , as directed by the Division Office. This was
communicated through letter No. BDR/EEE/JPA/F-
149/2026-27/5111-12 dated 05.08.2026 and reported by
the AEE, Kamthana, vide letter No.
GESCOM/KMT/AEEE/SA/2026-27/1154-55 dated
10.08.2026, with a copy to the Superintending Engineer,
O&M Circle, Bidar ( Annexure-R15 ). The disconnection
related only to the SRTPV Installation and was a
precautionary measure taken in the face of a dispute
among the legal heirs. It was not intended to defeat the
order of this Hon'ble Court.
15. I state that thereafter, as directed by the General
Manager, Corporate Office, GESCOM, Kalaburagi, vide
letter No. 2026-27/41981 dated 10.08.2026, the AEE,
Kamthana, forwarded the change-of-name request file of
RR No. KHT98 (contract demand 360 KVA) to the Division
Office vide letter No. GESCOM/KMT/AEEE/SA/2026-
27/1135 dated 24.08.2026. That letter recorded that the
SRTPV Installation remained under disconnection and that
there is an ongoing legal dispute among the legal heirs
( Annexure-R16 ).
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
16. I state that the file was returned for rectification of
deficiencies and was resubmitted vide the AEE's letters
No. 2026-27/1419-20 dated 04.09.2026 and No. 2026-
27/1829 dated 08.10.2026, after the Division Office letter
No. 2026-27/6872 dated 29.09.2026. These letters
clarified that the disconnection was not connected with
the change of name, enclosed the arrears particulars, and
placed on record the pending legal notice and the
complaint filed by the Complainant before the District
Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Bidar, in C.C.
No. DC/529/CC/89/2026 (Anirudh S/o Govindrao
Kumtekar vs. AEE, GESCOM, Kamthana & Others), which
was listed for hearing on 07.09.2026. Copies of these
letters, with English translations, are produced as
Annexure-R17 .
CONSIDERATION OF THE REPRESENTATIONS AND
ORDER PASSED
17. I state that in compliance with the order of this
Hon'ble Court, the deponent has considered the
representations dated 19.05.2026 (Annexures-G and H),
together with the entire service file of RR No. KHT98, the
subsequent requests of the Complainant dated
06.06.2026 and 08.06.2026, the objection of Sri
Govindrao Kumtekar dated 14.07.2026, the reports of the
Sub-Division and the directions of the Corporate Office.
The deponent has passed a speaking order/endorsement
No. 7973-71 dated 31.10.2026, which was communicated
to the Complainant on 2/11/26 by [RPAD /hand delivery /
e-mail to [email protected]]. A copy of the
order and the proof of service are produced as
Annexure-R18 .
18. I state that by the said order, the Complainant has
been informed, in substance, that:
(a) His grievance of grid connection was redressed
by synchronising the 360 kWp SRTPV system with
the GESCOM grid at the 11 kV level on 30.05.2026;
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
(b) The SRTPV supply was later disconnected on
27.07.2026 only because of the objection raised by
another legal heir of the deceased registered
consumer and because the installation and the PPA
stand in the name of a deceased person;
(c) Reconnection of the SRTPV system, change of
name of RR No. KHT98 and his request for
reduction of load will be considered and processed
in accordance with the KERC Conditions of Supply
and the applicable KERC/GESCOM SRTPV
regulations and norms. This will be done on his
producing a legal heir/succession certificate, the
consent or no-objection of all the other legal heirs
(or an order or decree of a competent civil court
declaring his entitlement), executing a fresh
PPA/net-metering agreement in the name of the
new registered consumer, and clearing the dues, if
any;
(d) Once these requirements are fulfilled, the
installation will be reconnected and the PPA
continued without any further delay.
19. I state that with this, the representations dated
19.05.2026 have been considered and disposed of by an
appropriate order passed in accordance with law. The
order of this Hon'ble Court dated 05.06.2026 thus stands
complied with in letter and spirit.
REASONS FOR THE TIME TAKEN
20. I state that the deponent submits that the time taken
beyond three months was not wilful. It was caused by
supervening circumstances, largely attributable to the
Complainant and to the dispute within his family. These
are: (i) the Complainant's own changed requests for load
reduction and refund immediately after the order; (ii) his
legal notice dated 30.06.2026 and the consumer
complaint in C.C. No. DC/529/CC/89/2026 on the same
subject; (iii) the written objection dated 14.07.2026 of
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
his father, a Class-I legal heir of the deceased registered
consumer; and (iv) the need to obtain directions from the
Legal Section and the General Manager, Corporate Office,
and to process the change-of-name file through
rectification of deficiencies. The Accused officials, being
officers of a Government Company, had to act cautiously
so as not to prejudice the rights of any legal heir of the
deceased consumer.
21. I state that the dispute as to whether the
Complainant alone is entitled to continue the HT
installation and the SRTPV PPA standing in the name of
his deceased mother, against the objection of the other
legal heirs, is a civil dispute concerning succession.
GESCOM cannot adjudicate that dispute, and it is not
covered by the order under execution. Any grievance of
the Complainant regarding the order now passed on
merits is a fresh cause of action, for which he has
independent remedies in law. Such a grievance cannot be
the subject matter of contempt proceedings.
22. I state that once again tender an unconditional
apology for the delay, if any, in reporting compliance, and
undertakes that the Accused officials will abide by any
further direction that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased
to issue.
PRAYER
WHEREFORE, the I most respectfully pray that this
Hon'ble Court may be pleased to:
(a) Accept this affidavit as compliance of the order
dated 05.06.2026 passed in W.P. No.
202086/2026;
(b) Record compliance, and also " Unconditional
Apology " and thereby drop the contempt
proceedings and discharge the Accused; and
(c) Pass such other order(s) as this Hon'ble Court
deems fit in the facts and circumstances of the
case, in the interest of justice and equity.”
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:12156-DB
CCC No. 200228 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030107122026
4. From the perusal of the compliance affidavit, the
respondents have complied the order passed by the learned
Single Judge in WP No.202086/2026 and tendered
unconditional apology.
5. Compliance affidavit is taken on record.
6. The order of the learned Single Judge has been duly
complied and tendered unconditional apology. In view of the
same, nothing would survive for consideration in this contempt
petition.
7. Accordingly, contempt proceedings are dropped .
Notice issued to the respondents is discharged. Liberty is
reserved to the complainant to challenge the endorsement
issued by the respondents.
Sd/-
(ASHOK S. KINAGI)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO)
JUDGE
SDU
LIST NO.: 2 SL NO.: 8