M.C. NINGARAJU vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 05 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE E.S.INDIRESH
WRIT PETITION NO.1983 OF 2025 (KLR-RES)
BETWEEN:
M.C. NINGARAJU
SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRS.
1. SRI. CHANDRASHEKAR
S/O LATE NINGARAJU,
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS.
2. SRI. VIJAY KUMAR M.N.
S/O LATE NINGARAJU,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS.
3. SMT. VIDYA
D/O LATE NINGARAJU,
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS.
ALL ARE R/AT H. MYLANAHALLI VILLAGE,
DUDDA HOBLI,
HASSAN TALUK-573118.
…PETITIONERS
Digitally signed
by CHAYA S A
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
(BY SRI. VIJAYA KUMAR K., ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
M.S.BUILDING,
DR. B.R. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
BENGALURU-560001
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY.
2. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
HASSAN DISTRICT,
HASSAN -573201.
3. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
HASSAN SUB-DIVISION,
HASSAN,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573201.
4. SRI. M.K. MANJEGOWDA
S/O KRISHNEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
R/AT MYLANAHALLI VILLAGE,
DUDDA HOBLI,
HASSAN TALUK-573118.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. SHARADA H.V., AGA FOR R1 TO R3;
SRI. K.R. NAGARAJA, ADVOCATE FOR R4)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO SET
ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 09/01/2025 PASSED BY THE
RESPONDENT NO.2 IN RP NO.14/2024-25 (ANNX-A) AND
ORDER DATED 09/01/2025 PASSED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.2
IN RP NO.14/2024-25 (ANNX-B) BY ALLOWING THIS WRIT
PETITION.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
IN 'B' GROUP, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS
UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE E.S.INDIRESH
ORAL ORDER
1. In this Writ Petition, petitioners are assailing the order
dated 09.01.2025 as per Annexures-A and B, passed by the
respondent No.2.
2. Sri. Vijaya Kumar K., learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners, submitted that land bearing Sy.No.12/P1
measuring 1 acre 30 guntas guntas of H. Mylanahalli Village
was granted in favour of father of the petitioners – Ningaraju as
per Official Memorandum dated 28.05.1980 and saguvali chit is
produced at Annexure-C and D respectively and thereafter
mutation has been effected. However, respondent No.4, at the
instance of villagers of H. Mylanahalli Village, filed an
application to the competent authority and accordingly, the
impugned orders have been passed and therefore, sought for
interference of the Court.
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
3. It is also contended by the learned counsel appearing for
the petitioners by referring to the order dated 12.01.2022 in
case No.L.N.D.77/2017-18(Annexure-H) and the order dated
26.09.2023 in case No.R.A.(HSN)03/2022-23(Annexure-L),
wherein the respondent-authorities have dismissed the appeal
preferred by respondent No.4 and confirmed the grant made in
favour of the petitioners and further referred to the proceedings
in O.S.No.351/2017 (Annexure-J) before the Civil Court,
wherein the competent Civil Court has declared that father of
the petitioners has been declared as owner of the suit property
which came to be confirmed by the First Appellate Court in
R.A.No.51/2020 (Annexure-K), and contended that,
respondent-authorities have no authority under law to review
their own orders and accordingly, sought for interference of the
Court.
4. Per contra, Sri. K.R. Nagaraja, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent No.4, submitted that as fraud has been
committed by the petitioners herein at the time of claiming
grant order, and same has been considered by respondent-
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
authorities, and therefore, sought to justify the impugned
order.
5. Smt. Sharada H.V., learned Additional Government
Advocate, appearing for respondent Nos.1 to 3, sought to
justify the impugned order.
6. In the light of the submissions made by the learned
counsel for the parties, on careful consideration of the order
dated 12.01.2022 (Annexure-H), wherein respondent No.3,
after verifying the entire material on record including
the grant made in favour of father of the petitioners, has
rejected the claim made by respondent No.4 herein. The said
order was confirmed by respondent No.2 vide order dated
26.09.2023 (Annexure-L). Thereafter, respondent No.2 has
reviewed its own order by passing the impugned order at
Annexures-A and B.
7. It is well settled principle in law, that the revenue
authorities have no power to review its own order and the said
aspect of the matter was considered by this Court in
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
W.P.No.20882/2016 disposed of on 15.06.2016. Para Nos.4 to
18 therein read as follows:
“ 4. Nextly he relies on the Apex Courts judgment in
the case of PATEL NARSHI THAKERSHI AND OTHERS
vs. SHRI PRADYUMANSINGHJI ARJUNSIGHJI
reported in 1971 (3) SCC 844 The relevant portion
of para 4 read by him is as follows: .
“……. It is well settled that the power to
review is not an inherent power. It must be
conferred by law either specifically or by
necessary implication. No provision in the Act
was brought to notice from which it could be
gathered that the Government had power to
review its own order. If the Government had
no power to review its own order, it is obvious
that its delegate could not have reviewed its
order….”
5. He submits that the review is only a creation of
statute and that therefore if the reviewing power is
not expressly granted, the question of exercising the
review jurisdiction would 5 not arise at all. Drawing
support from the case of DR.(SMT.) KUNTESH
GUPTA vs. MANAGEMENT OF HINDUKANYA
MAHAVIDYALAYA, SITAPUR (U.P.) AND OTHERS
reported in (1987) 4 SCC525 wherein it is held that
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
a quasi-judicial authority cannot review its own
order unless the power of review is expressly
conferred on it by the statute under which it derives
its jurisdiction.
6. He relies on the Apex Courts judgment in the
case of KAPRA MAZDOOR EKTA UNION vs. BIRLA
COTTON SPINNING AND WEAVING MILLS LTD. AND
ANOTHER reported in (2005) 13 SCC 777 to
advance the submission that the power of review is
not an inherent power and that therefore it cannot
be exercised invoking Section 25 of the KLR Act. He
submits that review of the final order, dated
19.12.2015 is not traceable to any provision in the
KLR Act. He read out paras 31 and 33 from the Apex
Courts decision in the case of SUNITA JAIN vs.
PAWAN KUMAR JAIN AND OTHERS reported in
(2008) 2 SCC 705:
“ 31. The section makes it clear that a court
cannot alter or review its judgment or final
order after it is signed except to correct
clerical or 6 arithmetical error. The scheme of
the Code, in our judgment, is clear that as a
general rule, as soon as the judgment is
pronounced or order is made by a court, it
becomes functus officio (ceases to have
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
control over the case) and has no power to
review, override, alter or interfere with it.
………....
33. It is also well settled that power of
review is not an inherent power and must be
conferred on a court by a specific or express
provision to that effect (Vide Patel Narshi
Thakershi vs. Pradyumansinghji Arjunsinghji).
No power of review has been conferred by the
Code of a criminal court and it cannot review
an order passed or judgment pronounced.”
7. Nextly, he brings to my notice, the Apex Courts
judgment in the case KALABHARATI ADVERTISING
vs. HEMANT VIMALNATH NARICHANIA AND OTHERS
reported in (2010) 9 SCC 437 and submits that
unless the statues/ rules so permit, the review
application is not maintainable in case of
judicial/quasi-judicial orders. If an order in review is
passed without the statute conferring an express
power of review, it is ultra vires, illegal and without
jurisdiction. It is further held in the said decision
that the application for review under the garb of
clarification / modification / correction is not
permissible.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
8. Learned counsel read out Para 17 from the Apex
Courts decision in the case of BINABHAI BHATE vs.
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND OTHERS reported
in (2011) 13 SCC 32:
“ 17. So far the power of review is concerned,
the High Court does not have the power of
review as such power of review has to be
specifically provided for in the Act. A power of
review against an order passed is a creature
of the statute and since no such power of
review is provided for under the provisions of
the Act, the High Court was justified in
holding that there could be no review to the
order passed. So far the review and
modifications of the development plan or
adjoining plan as provided in Sections 23 and
23-A of the Act are concerned, the said
provisions are not applicable in the present
case for the State Government has not made
any modification in the development plan,
and therefore, the contentions appearing for
the appellant are held to be without any
merit. Besides, the said power is exclusively
vested with the State Government and in
appropriate case, the State Government is
empowered to exercise such power as and
when 8 deemed proper. This is not a case
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
where the State Government thought it fit to
invoke such power.”
9. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that the Assistant Commissioner has endorsed on
the fourth respondents representation, dated
06.01.2016 (wrongly mentioned as 06.01.2015 in
Annexure-E) as put up recall. He submits that the
Assistant Commissioner cannot recall his order,
dated 19.12.2015 unilaterally and without issuing
notice to the petitioner. He submits that there is yet
another irregularity in the proceedings. Though the
respondent No.4 was granted interim stay on
06.01.2016 itself, the petitioner was put on notice
belatedly only on 14.03.2016.
10. Sri D.Ashwathnarayana, the learned counsel for
the respondent No.4 submits that the Assistant
Commissioner acts as a Revenue Court under
Section 24 of the KLR Act. He submits that under
Section 25 of the KLR Act, the Assistant
Commissioner can exercise the inherent powers of
the Revenue Courts. It is by exercising the inherent
power conferred by Section 25 of the KLR Act that
the Assistant Commissioner has entertained the
review application. He submits that the error 9
apparent on the face of the record calling for review
is that the petitioners appeal was taken up for final
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
disposal on merits without passing any order on his
delay condonation application.
11. Sri Ashwathnarayana relies on the Apex Courts
judgment in the case of SUNITADEVI SINGHANIA
HOSPITAL TRUST AND ANOTHER vs. UNION OF
INDIA AND ANOTHER reported in (2008) 16 SCC365
wherein it is held that the Administrative Tribunals
have the inherent power to recall their own orders
passed in violation of the principles of natural
justice. He has also relied on this Courts decision in
the case of SANGANAGOUDA vs. TAHSILDAR,
SHORAPUR, GULBARGA DISTRICT reported in
(2005) 1 KLJ 357 and SMT. A.E.DAKSHAYANAMMA
vs. KARANTAKA APPELLATE TRIBUNAL AND OTHERS
reported in AIR 1995 KAR 341 for advancing the
submission that the Revenue Courts can exercise
inherent powers invoking Section 25 of the KLR Act.
The very purpose of conferring the inherent powers
on the statutory authorities is to prevent the abuse
of process.
12. The learned counsel submits that the
endorsement on the petitioners letter at Annexure-E
is not indicative of recalling 10 the order dated
19.12.2015 as such; the endorsement is only for
putting up the recalling application. He submits that
giving such endorsement falls within the executive
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
authority of the Assistant Commissioner, when he
has to do something on the spot. The learned
counsel submits that it is incorrect on the part of the
petitioners side to state that the Assistant
Commissioner has acted only on the representation.
As a matter of fact, the review application is filed on
06.01.2016 and that based on the same, a letter is
written for the stay of the order, dated 19.12.2015.
13. Sri A.G.Shivanna, the learned Additional
Advocate General submits that there seems to be an
error apparent on the face of the record. Although
there is a delay of seventeen years in filing the
appeal, the Assistant Commissioner has disposed of
the main matter by allowing the appeal without
passing any order on the delay condonation
application. It is this aspect of the matter which has
warranted the entertaining of the recalling
application from the respondent No.4. He has relied
on this Courts order dated 08.10.2015 passed in WP
No.41243/2015 and the case of K.R.LAKSHMAN vs.
STATE OF KARNATAKA AND OTHERS reported in
1995 (5) KLJ 137 to advance the submission that
the review jurisdiction is conferred to the Revenue
Court to do justice and to prevent injustice.
14. The submissions of the learned counsel have
received my thoughtful consideration. The question
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
that falls for my consideration is whether the
Assistant Commissioner is justified in entertaining
the application filed by the respondent No.4 for
recalling the order, dated 19.12.2015. There is no
provision in the Land Revenue Act or the Rules
framed thereunder for reviewing the order passed
on merit. Once the Assistant Commissioner passes
the order under Section 136(2) of the said Act, he
becomes functus-Officio.
15. The entertaining of the application for recall is
sought to be justified with reference to Section 25 of
the Act. I find it hard to give acceptability to the
same as the Apex Court itself in the case of KAPRA
MAZDOOR AND KALABHARATI (SUPRA) has held in
no uncertain terms that the power of review is not
an inherent power.
16. Though the word used in the fourth respondents
application is recall, the perusal of its supporting
affidavit shows 12 that it is in the nature of the
review. Even assuming that the Assistant
Commissioner is conferred with the power to recall
his order, it is confined only to the circumstances
such as preponement of the case without notice to
the parties or where the matter is decided without
service of notice on the parties. But it cannot be
extended to the situations where the matter is
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
decided on merit. Even if the Assistant
Commissioner has wrongfully decided the appeal, he
cannot re-open the case. As held by the Apex Court
judgment in the case of MAKKAD PLASTIC
AGENCIES (SUPRA), under the garb of seeking
clarification/modification/rectification the re-opening
of the case cannot be sought. It is trite that the
review can only be a creature of statute. It may not
be out of the context to mention that the criminal
courts cannot and do not review their orders as
Criminal Procedure Code has not conferred the
review power upon them. Thus, viewed from any
angle, the Assistant Commissioners order to re-open
the case is unsupportable and unsustainable.
17. Let me examine this case assuming that the
review power is indeed available to the Assistant
Commissioner. As 13 held by the Apex Court in the
case of DR. SUBRAMANYA SWAMY VS. STATE OF
TAMIL NADU AND OTHERS reported in (2014) 5 SCC
75 even an erroneous decision cannot be a ground
for the Court to undertake review as the first and
foremost requirement of entertaining a review
petition is that the review of the order which is
sought, suffers from any error apparent on the face
of the order. In the case of K.R.LAKSHMAN (SUPRA)
relied upon by the learned Additional Advocate
General, it is held that the review jurisdiction can be
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
exercised to remove an error, not every kind of
error but only an error apparent on the face of the
record. Review jurisdiction is not exercisable to
rectify the order passed on merit.
18. It is also helpful to refer to the Apex Courts
judgment in the case of HARINAGAR SUGAR MILLS
LTD. AND ANOTHER VS. STATE OF BIHAR AND
OTHERS reported in (2006) 1 SCC 509 wherein, it is
held that though the review may have been
maintainable but a party cannot be allowed to
reagitate the points which had already been decided
by the Court. It is extremely helpful to refer to what
the Apex Court has to say in the case of HARIDAS
DAS VS. USHA RANI BANIK reported in AIR 2006
SC1634 The review provisions, 14 if any, do not
postulate the rehearing of the case because the
party has not highlighted all the aspects of the case
and could perhaps have argued more forcefully
and/or cited binding precedents to the Court and
thereby enjoyed a favourable verdict.”
8. The aforementioned aspect was also considered by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of FAIME MAKERS PVT. LTD.
Vs. DISTRICT DEPUTY REGISTRAR, CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES
(3), MUMBAI AND OTHERS reported in (2025) 5 SCC 772,
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that quasi judicial
authorities are also bound by principles of res judicata to
prevent re-litigation on the same issue and therefore, following
the declaration of law made by this Court as well as the Hon'ble
Supreme Court, as the grant made in favour of father of the
petitioners has already been confirmed by respondent No.3 in
the order dated 12.01.2022 (Annexure-H) which came to be
confirmed by respondent No.2 in the order dated 26.09.2023
(Annexure-L), I am of the view that respondent No.2 has no
jurisdiction to review its own order. Be that as it may, the
father of the petitioners had filed O.S.No.351/2017 before the
Prl. Civil Judge and JMFC, Hassan, against respondent No.4 and
others seeking relief of declaration and injunction which came
to be declared in favour of father of the petitioners vide
Judgment and Decree dated 12.03.2020 (Annexure-J) which
came to be confirmed by the First Appellate Court in
R.A.No.51/2020 dated 12.01.2023 (Annexure-K).
9. On careful consideration of the finding recorded by both
the Courts below in the aforementioned suit as well as the First
Appeal, the grant made in favour of father of the petitioners
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:61751
WP No. 1983 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010053672025
has been confirmed based on the documentary evidence. In
that view of the matter, I pass the following:
ORDER
(i) The Writ Petition is allowed.
(ii) The order dated 09.01.2025 (Annexure-A) and the
order dated 09.01.2025 (Annexure-B) passed by respondent
No.2 are hereby quashed.
(iii) It is made clear that the revenue authority,
particularly respondent No.2 herein has passed two orders on
the very same day and such action on the part of respondent
No.2 is deprecated.
SD/-
(E.S.INDIRESH)
JUDGE
sac
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 63