Pushpa vs Dayawati
- Court
- Supreme Court
2026 INSC 603
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
(CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)
CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(Arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) No.__________ of 2026)
(Diary No. 26304 of 2019)
PUSHPA & ORS. … APPELLANT(S)
versus
DAYAWATI & ORS. … RESPONDENT(S)
J U D G M E N T
VIPUL M. PANCHOLI, J.
1. Delay condoned.
2. Leave granted.
3. The present appeal arises out of the impugned judgment and
order dated 16.04.2019 passed by the High Court of Delhi in
Civil Revision Petition No. 53 of 2018 preferred by respondent
No.1 (plaintiff), whereby the High Court, while exercising
Signature Not Verified
revisional jurisdiction, set aside the order dated 20.12.2017
Digitally signed by
MOHD IBRAHIM
Date: 2026.05.30
12:01:26 IST
Reason:
passed by the Additional District Judge-04, South-West
District, Dwarka Courts, New Delhi and proceeded to decree the
Page 1
suit for recovery of Rs.44,79,167/- with interest against
defendant No.3 (late father of the appellants), on the basis of
admission of receipt of Rs.3 crores in his Written Statement
dated 25.03.2010 in CS (OS) No. 2502 of 2009 before the High
Court.
4. The parties to the present proceedings are members of a Hindu
family. The family tree is as follows: Shis Ram (Defendant
No.1/Respondent No.2) and his wife Chameli (Defendant
No.2/Respondent No.3) had five children, namely, Dayawati
(Plaintiff/Respondent No.1), Daya Ram (Defendant No.3), Har
Prasad (Defendant No.4/Respondent No.4), Ramrati (Defendant
No.5/Respondent No.5), and Leelawati (Defendant
No.6/Respondent No.6). The present appellants, namely,
Pushpa (Appellant No.1), Saroj Kumari (Appellant No.2), and
Sudesh (Appellant No.3) are the daughters and legal heirs of
Defendant No.3.
5. The brief facts of the case as per the appellants are that in
August 2007, agricultural land admeasuring approximately 31
bighas 9 biswas, owned by the family, was sold by respondent
No.2 for a total sale consideration of Rs.15,31,25,000/-. The
entire amount was received by respondent No.2 in his personal
Page 2
account.
6. On 21.12.2009, respondent No.1 filed a suit bearing CS (OS)
No. 2502 of 2009 before the High Court seeking recovery of
Rs.45,00,000/- with interest, partition of family properties and
permanent injunction, jointly and severally, against her father,
mother, brothers and sisters. The case pleaded in the plaint was
that in pursuance of the ancestral agricultural land sold in
August 2007 for a consideration of approximately Rs.15 crores,
respondent No.1 was entitled to her share in the sale proceeds.
7. On 25.03.2010, defendant No.3 filed his written statement
stating that the suit was collusive and through a family
settlement, each had received Rs.3 crores out of the total sale
proceeds of Rs.15 crore.
8. The High Court passed a preliminary decree for partition on
17.08.2011 holding that the parties were entitled to equal
shares in the properties and sale proceeds and granting each
party a 1/7th share in the suit property.
9. On 15.03.2013, in FAO (OS) No. 560 of 2011 preferred by
defendant No.3, the Division Bench of the High Court modified
the preliminary decree for partition granting each party a 1/6th
Page 3
share in the suit property, since respondent No.6 relinquished
her share.
10. Thereafter, by order dated 03.09.2015, a final decree in respect
of immovable properties was passed, however, the question
relating to recovery of Rs.45,00,000/- with interest was kept
open. The High Court framed the following issues and the
matter was directed to proceed for evidence:
“(1) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recover a sum of Rs.45
lacs from defendants No.1 to 3 jointly/severally? (OPP)
(2) If issue No.(1) is decided in favour of the plaintiff, whether
she is entitled to interest on the amount awarded? If so, at what
rate and for what period? (OPP)
(3) Relief.”
11. On 16.10.2015, respondent No.1 filed an application under
Order XII Rule 6 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (for brevity “ the CPC ”) seeking recovery of
Rs.45,00,000/- through a decree on admission against
defendant No.3 alone on the basis of the averments made in the
written statement. It was stated that defendant No.3 admitted
that each party received an amount of Rs.3 crores in 2007 out
of sale proceeds of agricultural land of about Rs.15 crores from
respondent No.2 and vide the order dated 15.03.2013,
respondent No.1 has 1/6th share in the suit property
Page 4
(Rs.2,55,20,833/-) and in that case, defendant No.3 received
more than his share (Rs.44,79,167/-) and thus is liable to pay
an amount of Rs.45,00,000/- to respondent No.1.
12. Subsequently, the suit was transferred to the District Court as
the pecuniary jurisdiction of the High Court of Delhi was
increased.
13. The Additional District Judge, by order dated 20.12.2017,
dismissed the application under Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC
holding that the controversy required trial and that the issues
already framed could be adjudicated only upon appreciation of
evidence.
14. Aggrieved thereby, respondent No.1 filed a Civil Revision
Petition No. 53 of 2018 before the High Court.
15. Vide the impugned judgment and order dated 16.04.2019, the
High Court allowed the revision petition and decreed the suit
against defendant No.3 for recovery of Rs.44,79,167/- together
with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of filing of the suit.
16. Aggrieved by the impugned judgment and order, the appellants
(since defendant No.3 is deceased and now represented by his
legal representatives) have preferred the present appeal.
Page 5
17. Mr. Rakesh Kumar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellants, submitted that the High Court has exceeded its
limited revisional jurisdiction under Section 115 of the CPC. The
revisional jurisdiction cannot be exercised to reverse a finding
of fact rendered by the Trial Court that the suit involves triable
issue and there is no unequivocal admission which entitles
respondent No.1 a decree without trial. Reliance is placed on
1
Pandurang Dhondi Chougule v. Maruti Hari Jadhav , DLF
2
Housing & Construction Co. (P) Ltd. v. Sarup Singh , and
3
Sher Singh v. Jt. Director of Consolidation .
18. It is further submitted that there exists no clear, unambiguous
or unequivocal admission on the part of defendant No.3 which
would, in law, entitle respondent No.1 to a decree for recovery
of Rs.45,00,000/- against defendant No.3 and reliance is placed
4
on Vikrant Kapila v. Pankaja Panda .
19. It is contended that a joint reading of paragraphs 2, 12 and 13
of the plaint indicates that respondent No.2 received the entire
sale consideration of Rs.15,31,25,000/-, out of which a sum of
1
1965 SCC Online SC 83 (Para 10)
2
(1969) 3 SCC 807 (Para 5)
3
(1978) 3 SCC 172 (Paras 10-12)
4
(2024) 18 SCC 695 (Paras 29-40)
Page 6
Rs.3 crores, is alleged to have been given to defendant No.3. It
is an undisputed position that defendant No.3 did not receive
any amount directly from the purchaser of the suit property. It
is stated that the present suit is instituted with a motive to
harass defendant No.3, as any suit for recovery, if maintainable
at all, would lie only against respondent No.2.
20. It is further contended that there is nothing on record to
establish that respondent No.2 had distributed
Rs.12,31,25,000/- amongst the other respondents. The plaint
is silent as to why respondent No.1 has not claimed the
undistributed sale proceeds of Rs.12,31,25,000/- from
respondent No.2. Thus, whether respondent No.1 has any
enforceable claim against defendant No.3 raises serious
disputed questions of fact, which can only be adjudicated after
trial, including leading of evidence and hence the same
constitutes a triable issue.
21. It is stated that neither the pleadings nor any material on record
discloses that the amount claimed by respondent No.1 was ever
held by defendant No.3 in the capacity of a predecessor in
interest for the benefit of respondent No.1. In the absence of
such proof, it cannot be assumed that any money given by a
Page 7
father to his son was not from his own share and respondent
No.1 cannot claim, without any evidence, that such amount
legally belongs to her.
22. It is further stated that the present suit for recovery is not
maintainable against defendant No.3, as there exists no privity
of contract or any legal relationship between respondent No.1
and defendant No.3 giving rise to a cause of action for recovery
of money. In the absence of any direct transaction, obligation or
binding arrangement, no legal liability can be fastened upon
defendant No.3 by the claim of respondent No.1.
23. The High Court vide order dated 03.09.2015 took note of the
contention of respondent No.1 that defendant No.3 in his
written statement had admitted receipt of Rs.3 crores which
was in access particularly in light of the amount of
Rs.1,73,75,000/- received in 2007 from respondent No.2. It is
submitted that even assuming such receipt, the present suit for
recovery is not maintainable against defendant No.3 on the said
basis, as the said transaction originates from respondent No.2
and thus any claim, if at all, would lie only against respondent
No.2 and not against defendant No.3.
Page 8
24. Therefore, it is lastly submitted that the impugned judgment is
arbitrary and unsustainable in law and prayed that the
impugned judgment and order is liable to be set aside.
25. Mr. Anand Yadav, learned counsel appearing on behalf of
respondent No.1, supported the impugned judgment and
submitted that defendant No.3 in his own written statement
filed in CS (OS) No. 2502 of 2009 unequivocally admitted
receiving Rs.3 crores out of the sale proceeds of Rs.15 crores
which admission was reiterated in multiple proceedings. This
admission being clear and unambiguous squarely attracts the
provisions of Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC which empowers the
Court to pronounce judgment on the basis of admission.
26. It is further submitted that vide the order dated 15.03.2013,
each party is entitled to 1/6th share in the suit property
amounting to Rs.2,55,20,833/-. Since defendant No.3
admittedly received Rs.3 crores, he has received Rs.44,79,167/-
(approximately Rs.45,00,000/-) more than his lawful 1/6th
share. The said admission is clear, unambiguous and
unequivocal and entitles respondent No.1 to a decree under
Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC.
Page 9
27. It is contended that in Suit No. 414 of 2009 filed by defendant
No.3 himself in the District Court, Dwarka, he had claimed that
the suit property was sold with his consent and that he received
half share of the sale proceeds. The said inconsistency in his
own pleadings further reinforces the admission that he received
an excess amount.
28. It is further contended that the preliminary decree determining
the 1/6th share of each party has attained finality and cannot
be challenged or questioned at this stage and the appellants,
being legal representatives of defendant No.3, are bound by the
admission made in the written statement.
29. Therefore, it is lastly submitted that the impugned judgment
and order passed by the High Court is just, proper and legal
and does not require any interference by this Court and thus
the present appeal is liable to be dismissed.
30. Having heard learned counsel appearing on behalf of the parties
at length and having carefully perused the material on record,
the moot question which arises for consideration is whether the
averments made by defendant No.3 in the written statement
amount to a clear, unequivocal and unconditional admission so
Page 10
as to justify a decree for recovery under Order XII Rule 6 of the
CPC.
31. The controversy in the present case centres around the scope
and ambit of Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC and the nature of
admission required for passing a decree without trial. Order XII
Rule 6 of the CPC reads as under:
“ 6. Judgment on admissions.— (1) Where admissions of fact
have been made either in the pleading or otherwise; whether
orally or in writing, the Court may at any stage of the suit, either
on the application of any party or of its own motion and without
waiting for the determination of any other question-between the
parties, make such order or give such judgment as it may think
fit, having regard to such admissions.
(2) Whenever a judgment is pronounced under sub-rule (1) a
decree shall be drawn up in accordance with the judgment and
the decree shall bear the date on which the judgment was
pronounced. ”
32. The definition of “admission” under Sections 17 and 18 of the
Evidence Act, 1872, reads as under:
“ 17. Admission defined. ––An admission is a statement, oral
or documentary or contained in electronic form, which suggests
any inference as to any fact in issue or relevant fact, and which
is made by any of the persons, and under the circumstances,
hereinafter mentioned.
18. Admission by party to proceeding or his agent. ––
Statements made by a party to the proceeding, or by an agent
to any such party, whom the Court regards, under the
circumstances of the case, as expressly or impliedly authorised
by him to make them, are admissions. ”
Page 11
33. A plain reading of Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC indicates that the
provision confers a discretionary power upon the Court to
pronounce judgment on the basis of admission made either in
pleadings or otherwise however the exercise of such power is
conditioned upon the existence of a clear admission of fact. The
object of the provision is to enable a party to obtain speedy relief
where there is no substantial dispute requiring trial. At the
same time, the provision cannot be invoked in a manner so as
to deprive a party of adjudication where the controversy involves
disputed questions of fact requiring evidence.
34. The term “admission” has been defined under Sections 17 and
18 of the Evidence Act, 1872, an admission is a statement which
suggests any inference as to a fact in issue or relevant fact and
is made by a party to the proceeding or by a person authorised
by such party however every statement made by a party cannot
automatically result in a decree under Order XII Rule 6 of the
CPC. Thus, the admission must be categorical, unambiguous,
unconditional and unequivocal.
35. This Court in several decisions has consistently held that before
passing a decree on admission, the Court must be fully satisfied
that the admission relied upon leaves no room for controversy
Page 12
and if the alleged admission requires interpretation, inferential
reasoning or examination of surrounding circumstances, the
matter ought to proceed to trial and it is similarly well settled
that where substantial triable issues arise, the parties cannot
be denied the opportunity to lead evidence. Recently, this Court
in Vikrant Kapila v. Pankaja Panda (supra) reiterated the
principles under Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC, the relevant
paragraph reads as under:
“ 40. In Himani Alloys Ltd. v. Tata Steel Ltd. [Himani Alloys Ltd.
v. Tata Steel Ltd., (2011) 15 SCC 273 : (2014) 2 SCC (Civ) 376]
it is held that “Admissions” should be categorical and
intentional, as Order 12 Rule 6CPC allows discretion rather than
obligation. Admissions result in judgments without trial which
permanently deny any remedy to the defendant, by way of an
appeal on merits. Therefore, unless the admission is clear,
unambiguous, and unconditional, the discretion of the court is
not exercised to deny the valuable right of a defendant to contest
the claim. Hence, discretion should be used only where there is
a clear and unequivocal admission. The relevant paragraphs
read thus: (SCC pp. 276-77, para 11)
“11. It is true that a judgment can be given on an
“admission” contained in the minutes of a meeting. But the
admission should be categorical. It should be a conscious
and deliberate act of the party making it, showing an
intention to be bound by it. Order 12 Rule 6 being an
enabling provision, it is neither mandatory nor peremptory
but discretionary. The court, on examination of the facts
and circumstances, has to exercise its judicial discretion,
keeping in mind that a judgment on admission is a
judgment without trial which permanently denies any
remedy to the defendant, by way of an appeal on merits.
Therefore, unless the admission is clear, unambiguous
and unconditional, the discretion of the Court should not
be exercised to deny the valuable right of a defendant to
contest the claim. In short the discretion should be used
Page 13
only when there is a clear “admission” which can be acted
upon. There is no such admission in this case.”
(emphasis supplied) ”
36. Keeping the aforesaid principles in view, we may now examine
the facts of the present case.
37. The foundation of the claim of respondent No.1 rests upon the
statement made by defendant No.3 in the written statement
that, through a family settlement, he had received Rs.3 crores
out of the total sale proceeds of Rs.15 crores. According to
respondent No.1, since each party was ultimately held entitled
to 1/6th share in the suit property pursuant to the order dated
15.03.2013 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court, the
share of each party amounted to Rs.2,55,20,833/-. It is,
therefore, the case of respondent No.1 that defendant No.3 had
received an excess amount of Rs.44,79,167/- and was
consequently liable to refund the same. The said statement is
reproduced as under:
“ 2. That when the agricultural land of the family was sold in the
month of august 2007 the all members of the family i.e. Plaintiff
and defendants had entered into a family settlement whereby
Plaintiff and defendant No. 5 & 6 have agreed to not claim any
right in the ancestral property and Defendant 1 & 2 has agreed
to live with Defendant 4 and the answering Defendant was
given Rs. 3 Crore from the total sale proceed of Rs. 15 Crore and
1/2 share in Plot measuring 145 sq. Yards described in Para 6
(i) of the plaint; 100% share in plot measuring 178 sq. Yards
Page 14
described in Para 6(ii); 60x20 sq. feet area in Plot measuring 480
sq. yards as described in Para 6 (iii) of the Plaint and 1/2 share
in Khasra No. 65 as described in Para 7 of the Plaint. ”
38. A careful reading of the above reproduced averment makes it
clear that defendant No.3 had not admitted any liability towards
respondent No.1, whereas, the statement was made in the
context of a family settlement and distribution arrangement
amongst the family members, wherein respondent Nos. 5 and 6
had agreed not to claim any share in the suit property. The said
statement merely indicates that defendant No.3 had received
certain amounts and properties pursuant to such arrangement
and it nowhere records any admission that the amount so
received was in excess of his lawful entitlement or that he was
liable to refund any amount to respondent No.1.
39. While examining the question as to whether the aforesaid
statement constitutes an admission within the meaning of
Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC, it becomes necessary to read the
written statement as a whole. We have, therefore, carefully
examined the entirety of the written statement filed by
defendant No.3. In our considered opinion, the approach
adopted by the High Court in isolating a single portion of the
written statement and construing the same as an unequivocal
Page 15
admission of liability is legally unsustainable, as it is well
settled that pleadings cannot be read in a piecemeal manner
and must be construed holistically. A further perusal of the
written statement reveals that the claim of respondent No.1 was
specifically and categorically disputed by defendant No.3.
Defendant No.3 had also consistently asserted that the suit
itself was collusive in nature and that the parties had already
entered into a family settlement in the year 2007. In fact,
defendant No.3 specifically stated that he had received “only his
share” in paragraph 12 of the said settlement. Thus, the
reproduced statement relied upon by respondent No.1 was
neither unconditional nor unequivocal admission so as to
justify a decree on admission under Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC.
40. It is further required to be noted that the entire sale
consideration of Rs.15,31,25,000/- was admittedly received by
respondent No.2 in his personal account and thus the liability
sought to be fastened upon defendant No.3 is, therefore,
dependent upon several disputed factual assumptions, namely,
whether respondent No.2 had in fact distributed unequal
shares, whether the amount received by defendant No.3
represented money belonging to respondent No.1 and whether
Page 16
respondent No.1 retained any enforceable claim against
defendant No.3. However, there is no material on record to
conclusively establish that the amount received by defendant
No.3 was held by him for and on behalf of respondent No.1 or
in any fiduciary capacity and there is also no evidence to
indicate that the said amount was not received by defendant
No.3 towards his own share under the family arrangement.
Thus, the said questions necessarily require adjudication upon
evidence and cannot be conclusively determined merely on the
basis of pleadings.
41. It is pertinent to note that the plaint itself sought relief jointly
and severally against defendant Nos. 1 to 6 and no specific
pleading was raised that defendant No. 3 alone was exclusively
liable to satisfy the claim of the plaintiff/respondent No.1. Thus,
the very nature of the claim involved adjudication of inter se
rights and liabilities amongst the family members, which
constitutes a substantial triable issue and therefore, a decree
based on admission does not resolve the dispute.
42. In our view, a significant circumstance which completely weighs
against exercise of jurisdiction under Order XII Rule 6 of the
CPC is the order dated 03.09.2015 passed by the High Court
Page 17
itself whereby specific issues, as reproduced hereinabove, were
framed for trial, namely, whether respondent No.1 was entitled
to recover Rs.45,00,000/- from defendant Nos. 1 to 3 jointly and
severally and whether she was entitled to interest thereon.
Thereafter, the matter was directed to proceed for evidence. The
need for framing of the aforesaid issues demonstrates that the
Court itself found existence of disputed questions of fact
requiring adjudication after appreciation of evidence and thus
once the Court had concluded that triable issues existed and
directed parties to lead evidence, it was inappropriate to
subsequently invoke Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC and decree the
suit without trial.
43. The Additional District Judge, by order dated 20.12.2017, while
dismissing the application under Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC,
rightly observed that the controversy required adjudication after
trial and appreciation of evidence and the discretion exercised
by the Trial Court was in consonance with settled principles
governing Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC and did not suffer from
any perversity or jurisdictional infirmity.
44. However, the High Court, while exercising revisional jurisdiction
under Section 115 of the CPC, could not have substituted its
Page 18
own interpretation merely because another view was possible
as the scope of revisional jurisdiction is limited. This Court in
several decisions, namely, Pandurang Dhondi Chougule v.
Maruti Hari Jadhav (supra) , DLF Housing & Construction
Co. (P) Ltd. v. Sarup Singh (supra) and Sher Singh v. Joint
Director of Consolidation (supra) , held that the revisional
court cannot act as an appellate court and reassess findings of
fact or substitute conclusions unless jurisdictional error or
material irregularity is demonstrated. In the present case, the
High Court reassessed the factual matrix and proceeded to
substitute its own interpretation of the pleadings and such an
exercise travelled beyond the permissible limits of Section 115
of the CPC.
45. We are also unable to accept the contention raised on behalf of
respondent No.1 that inconsistent pleadings taken by
defendant No.3 in another suit conclusively establish liability,
because such inconsistencies may constitute material for cross-
examination and appreciation during trial, however, such
disputed factual circumstances of such nature cannot form the
sole basis for passing a decree under Order XII Rule 6 of the
CPC. It is a well settled law that a judgment on admission is an
Page 19
exception to the ordinary rule that civil disputes must be
adjudicated after parties are afforded full opportunity to lead
evidence because a decree under Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC
results in denial of a trial and thus the provision must be
applied with caution and only in cases where the admission is
absolutely clear, categorical and unconditional.
46. In the light of the aforesaid discussion, we are of the considered
opinion that the alleged admission relied upon by respondent
No.1 were neither categorical nor unequivocal so as to justify a
decree for recovery under Order XII Rule 6 of the CPC and the
controversy involved substantial disputed questions of fact
which necessarily required adjudication upon evidence.
47. Therefore, the High Court committed an error in interfering with
the order passed by the Additional District Judge and in
decreeing the suit against defendant No.3 solely on the basis of
alleged admission relied upon by respondent no.1.
48. For the said reasons, the present appeal is allowed. The
impugned judgment and order dated 16.04.2019 passed by the
High Court of Delhi in Civil Revision Petition No. 53 of 2018 is
set aside.
Page 20
49. The order dated 20.12.2017 passed by the Additional District
Judge-04, South-West District, Dwarka Courts, New Delhi, in
an application under Order XII Rule 6 read with Section 151 of
the CPC in CS No. 80 of 2016 is restored.
50. It is clarified that the observations made hereinabove are
confined solely to the adjudication of the issue arising in the
present appeal and shall not be construed as an expression on
the merits of the pending civil proceedings concerning the suit
property and recovery of money. The Trial Court shall
adjudicate the suit independently, uninfluenced by any
observations made in the present judgment and strictly in
accordance with law.
51. Pending applications, if any, shall stand disposed of.
………………………………J.
SANJAY KAROL
………………………………J.
VIPUL M. PANCHOLI
NEW DELHI
th
29 MAY, 2026
Page 21