Mandeep Singh vs State Of Punjab And Another

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CRM-M-17962-2026 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CRM-M-17962-2026
Mandeep Singh . . . Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of Punjab and another . . . Respondent(s)
12.11.2026
1. Date when Order / Judgment was reserved
17.11.2026
2. Date of Decision / pronouncement of Order /
Judgment
17.11.2026
3. Date of uploading Order / Judgment
FULL
4. Whether operative part or full Order /
Judgment is pronounced
NOT APPLICABLE
5. Delay, if any, in pronouncing of full Order /
Judgment, and reasons thereof
YES/NO
6. Whether Speaking/Reasoned
YES/NO
7. Whether Reportable
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY VASHISTH
Present: Mr. Sunil Chadha, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Raghav Chadha, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. Manjinder Singh Bhullar, DAG, Punjab.

SANJAY VASHISTH, J. (Oral)
1. Petitioner-Mandeep Singh has filed the instant petition under
Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS),
seeking quashing of FIR No.15 dated 01.11.2022, registered under Sections
7 and 7-A of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and Section 120-B
IPC, at Police Station Economic Offences Wing, Punjab Vigilance Bureau,
RASHMI
2026.11.17 19:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-17962-2026 2
Ludhiana along with all consequential proceedings arising therefrom,
including order dated 16.12.2025 (Annexure P-4) and challan dated
17.029.2025, whereby charges were framed against him by the trial Court.
2. Complainant-Daljit Singh got the aforesaid FIR registered,
alleging therein that
“his mother, Sukhwinder Kaur, owned a plot measuring 54
square yards and that he intended to raise construction thereon
to start a business. On making an inquiry from the Manager of
Bank of Baroda, Cheema Chowk Branch, he was informed that,
for obtaining a bank loan, 30 years' revenue record pertaining
to the plot, along with an inspection report from the Patwari,
was required to initiate the loan process.
Complainant thereafter approached Mandeep
Singh, Patwari, who advised him to meet his karinda, Gurpreet
Singh Soni, who would get his work done. A few days earlier,
when the complainant had met Gurpreet Singh Soni (Karinda)
at the Patwar Khana, he was informed that an amount of
Rs.7,000/- would be required for obtaining 30 years' revenue
record and the inspection report. Accordingly, an amount of
Rs.1,000/- was paid to Gurpreet Singh Soni, upon which the
complainant was assured that his work would be done.
When the complainant subsequently spoke to
Patwari-Mandeep Singh over the telephone, the latter informed
him that the fard was with him and that he had already signed
it. He further asked the complainant to collect the same from
Gurpreet Singh Soni on his asking. The complainant got the
said conversation recorded in a CD and produced the same
before the police for necessary inquiry. He also handed over ten
Indian currency notes of Rs.500/- denomination each, bearing
Sr. Nos. (1) GWN634264, (2) 0TQ952646, (3) 5SV813411, (4)
RASHMI
2026.11.17 19:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-17962-2026 3
6RN663209, (5) 0MH665620, (6) 2VN267366, (7) 4NB335052,
(8) 6KA102644, (9) 2FF489088 and (10) 7EH273752, totalling
Rs.5,000/-, for taking necessary legal action.”
3. Thereafter, impugned FIR was registered and trap was also laid
leading to the arrest of the accused.
Hence, petitioner has approached this Court seeking quashing
of the FIR and all consequential proceedings arising therefrom, including
challan dated 17.09.2025(P-3) and order dated 16.12.2025(P-4), whereby
charges were framed against him.
4. Mr. Sunil Chadha, learned Senior Advocate, argues that never
there was any demand by the petitioner for payment of an illegal
gratification, either at the time when an amount of Rs.7,000/- was allegedly
demanded by the karinda or at any subsequent stage.
Further submits that, at the time of conducting the raid/trap, the
amount in question was received by co-accused-Gurpreet Singh @ Soni and
it was recovered only from his possession. Neither there is any allegation of
demand; nor the acceptance of bribe by the petitioner, nor any amount was
recovered from his possession or at his instance.
Also argues that there is no call recording reflecting any
demand of bribe by petitioner from the complainant. Thus, in the absence of
any such evidence and the requisite ingredients constituting an offence under
the Act, petitioner could not have been charge-sheeted.
5. Mr. Sunil Chadha, learned Senior Advocate, further argues that
complainant himself, in his complaint, which subsequently formed the basis
RASHMI
2026.11.17 19:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-17962-2026 4
of the impugned FIR (Annexure P-1), disclosed that he was working in the
Court Complex and that he is not an Advocate, but is engaged in private
work in the Court Complex, which also includes procuring the revenue
records from the Tehsil Office. With this background, there was absolutely
no reason for the complainant to approach the petitioner for obtaining the
revenue record and the inspection report, pertaining to the plot owned by his
mother, much less by offering any illegal gratification.
Further argues that complainant himself was arrayed as an
accused in FIR No.2 dated 10.05.2017, registered at Police Station,
Economic Offences Wing, Punjab Vigilance Bureau, Ludhiana, under
Sections 7, 8 and 13(2) of the Act. In the said case, complainant stands
convicted vide judgment dated 07.12.2023 (Annexure P-6), passed by
learned Special Judge, Ludhiana, for offences under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d)
of the Act, punishable under Section 13(2) thereof. He was sentenced to
undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of five years and also to pay
fine amount of Rs.10,000/-. Aggrieved with the judgment dated 07.12.2023,
respondent No.2/complainant preferred an appeal, i.e. CRA-S-622-2024,
before this Court and the appeal was admitted vide order dated 16.02.2024,
though, for the time being substantive sentence imposed upon respondent
No.2/complainant was suspended vide order dated 04.03.2024.
6. By referring the judgment dated 07.12.2023, whereby
complainant-Daljit Singh @ Sonu was convicted in a corruption case,
learned Senior Counsel submits that allegations levelled in the present case
are of similar nature, whereas complainant himself had earlier faced
RASHMI
2026.11.17 19:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-17962-2026 5
prosecution and was found guilty in respect of similar allegations. In the said
case, his co-convict, Jasminder Singh, Patwari, had allegedly informed the
complainant therein that, for getting a mutation sanctioned, 30 years' old
revenue record was required and thus had demanded a bribe of Rs.10,000/-
for doing the said job.
Therefore, learned Senior Counsel submits that allegations
levelled in the present case are far away from the truth and appear to be an
attempt by the complainant to introduce the allegations almost verbatim and
of similar nature, which he himself had already faced in the proceedings,
arising out of FIR No.2 dated 10.05.2017, registered under Sections 7, 8 and
13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act at Police Station, Economic
Offences Wing, Punjab Vigilance Bureau, Ludhiana.
Further submits that, apart from the prayer for quashing of the
FIR, even order, framing the charges is non-speaking, as not even a single
part of the investigation report submitted under Section 173 Cr.P.C. has been
discussed therein. Accordingly, prays for allowing the present petition.
7. On the other hand, Mr. Manjinder Singh Bhullar, DAG, Punjab,
submits that sufficient material was collected during investigation. Further
submits that the fact that petitioner reposed so much faith in a private
person/karinda, having no official connection with the work in question, and
in lieu of getting the work done allowing him to demand illegal gratification,
cannot be taken so lightly at this stage to absolve the petitioner of the
allegations, which are of serious nature. There is no explanation from
petitioner as to why he suggested the complainant to approach Gurpreet
RASHMI
2026.11.17 19:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-17962-2026 6
Singh Soni (Karinda), who, upon meeting complainant, allegedly demanded
the bribe amount. Further submits that, the mere fact that complainant
himself stands convicted by learned Special Judge, Ludhiana, in another
corruption case cannot be treated as a ground to presume that the present
prosecution has been launched on similar lines. The factual position would
become clear only after conclusion of a full-fledged trial in accordance with
the procedure prescribed under BNSS, 2023. Therefore, this is not an
appropriate stage either to allow the present petition or to discharge
petitioner.
8. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and also perused
the record.
9. Before proceeding with the trial, at the stage of framing of the
charges trial Court, is expected to examine the entire investigation report for
considering the total prosecution evidence collected during investigation, to
ascertain whether the material on record, even if it raises a strong suspicion
against the accused, is sufficient to proceed further by framing charges and
calling upon the prosecution to lead its evidence. Considered view of this
Court is that there are various aspects requiring consideration for forming a
prima facie opinion at this stage, without expressing any final opinion on the
merits of the case. Some of these aspects are as follows:-
i) Whether, upon receipt of the complaint and during the
course of inquiry/investigation, the Punjab Vigilance Bureau
was aware or not about the fact that complainant-Daljit Singh,
who also worked as a karinda, had himself been arrayed as
RASHMI
2026.11.17 19:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-17962-2026 7
accused in case FIR No.2 dated 10.05.2017 (supra), registered
at the same police station in a corruption case, and that,
subsequent to registration of the present FIR, he was convicted
on 07.12.2023 (Annexure P-6) by the Court of Dr. Ajit Attri,
learned Special Judge, Ludhiana?
ii) Whether, in the aforesaid case, complainant herein, was
found guilty of demanding an amount of Rs.10,000/- for
arranging 30 years' old revenue record for sanctioning of
mutation?
iii) Is there any evidence on record to show that, at any point of
time or during any meeting with complainant, petitioner himself
expressed his willingness to accept or demanded any bribe
amount, or that any such amount was recovered from his
possession?
iv) Is there any call record establishing conversations between
petitioner and complainant or, between petitioner and his co-
accused, Gurpreet Singh Soni, reflecting any intention or
agreement to demand or accept the illegal gratification?
10. As per the FIR, even before its registration, eve “ fard” had
already been signed by the petitioner, and this fact was even communicated
to the complainant himself, when he telephoned the petitioner. Moreover, by
that time, complainant had paid only an amount of Rs.1,000/- to co-accused-
Gurpreet Singh Soni (Karinda). Thus, the fard had already been signed even
before payment of the remaining amount of Rs.6,000/-. Despite this, the
RASHMI
2026.11.17 19:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-17962-2026 8
complaint was lodged against the accused persons, and recovery of the bribe
amount was also effected only from co-accused-Gurpreet Singh Soni.
However, petitioner was found sitting beside the co-accused, which,
according to the prosecution, constitutes a strong circumstance raising
suspicion against him.
Further, Transcript No.1 pertains to the mobile conversation
between complainant and co-accused-Gurpreet Singh Soni, recorded on
01.11.2022 at about 10:43:35 hours, whereas Transcripts No.2 and 3 pertain
to conversations between petitioner and complainant-Daljit Singh (Annexure
P-7). Whether these conversations reflect any common intention or
conspiracy between petitioner and his co-accused is also required to be
examined with the background that as per the FSL report, the voices in the
telephonic conversations were found matching.
11. Though this may not be an appropriate stage to quash the FIR
on the assumption that no offence is made out against the petitioner but the
order framing charges appears to be cryptic and non-speaking, as the
material collected during investigation and the relevant circumstances have
not been adequately considered.
Therefore, in the considered view of this Court, the
impugned order of charge and Charge-sheet, deserves to be set aside.
Order accordingly.
12. Let the entire investigation report be thoroughly examined
afresh by the trial Court. Thereafter, all the issues raised by petitioner, along
with, other relevant material available on record, shall be duly considered,
RASHMI
2026.11.17 19:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRM-M-17962-2026 9
and a fresh order shall be passed as to whether or not, the allegations and
evidence collected during investigation are sufficient to proceed further for
trial, qua the petitioner by framing charges.
With the aforesaid directions, present petition stands partly
allowed .
13. Disposed of.
(SANJAY VASHISTH)
JUDGE
17.11. 2026
Rashmi
RASHMI
2026.11.17 19:39
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document