Mangu Ram And Others vs St Of Pb.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH


CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M)
RESERVED ON : 27.08.2026
PRONOUNCED ON: 17.11.2026

FALKU AND ANR.
..... APPELLANTS
VERSUS
STATE OF PUNJAB
..... RESPONDENT

CRA-S-1977-SB-2004 (O&M)
RESERVED ON : 27.08.2026


MANGU RAM AND ANOTHER
..... APPELLANTS

VERSUS

STATE OF PUNJAB
..... RESPONDENT

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SURYA PARTAP SINGH


Argued by : Mr. PPS Tung, Advocate
for the appellants in both appeals.

Ms. Gagandeep Kaur, DAG, Punjab.

*

SURYA PARTAP SINGH , J .

These are two appeals, preferred by the appellants/convicts,
against the verdict of conviction. Since both the appeals have been filed
against the same judgment of conviction and order of sentence, both of them
are being disposed of by this common judgment.
2. By virtue of judgment of conviction dated 04.05.2004, the Court
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
of learned Special Court, (designated under Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act) , Mansa, hereinafter being referred to as ‘trial Court’ only, the
appellants have been convicted for the commission of offence punishable
under Section 15 of Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 ,
hereinafter being referred to as ‘NDPS Act’. As a consequence thereof, by
virtue of order of even date, i.e. dated 04.05.2004, on the point of quantum of
sentence, hereinafter being referred to as ‘impugned order’, following
sentences were awarded to the appellants:-

Sentence
Offence under
Section

Rigorous imprisonment for a period of ten years each
and to pay a fine of Rs.1,00,000/- each. In default thereof
to undergo further imprisonment (rigorous) for a period
of one year each.


15 of NDPS Act
3. In nut-shell, the facts emerging from record are that on
28.08.1999, one FIR, i.e. FIR No.102 of 1999 under-Section 15 of NDPS Act,
was lodged in Police Station Boha, at the instance of SI Baljit Singh. It was
reported by the above-named police officer that on that day, when he was
leading a team of police officials, deputed for patrolling duty, near village
Ladduwas, he deputed a picket on the unmetalled passage leading towards
village Ladduwas from the metalled road connecting village Saidewala to
Alampur Mandra. As per above-named police officer, at about 11:15 am, a
dark blue TATA Sumo bearing registration No.PB-31A-0187 was spotted,
which was approaching the barricade from Ladduwas side. It was further
reported by the above-named police officer that a signal was given to stop the
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
abovementioned vehicle, but its driver attempted to flee. As per above-named
police officer, the police party swung into action and therefore, the aforesaid
vehicle was successfully intercepted.
4 It was further reported by the above-named police officer that in
the above mentioned TATA Sumo there were five persons, the name of the
driver of the above mentioned vehicle was ‘Avtar Singh’, and names of other
occupants were ‘Falku’, ‘Mangu Ram’, ‘Rajinder Singh’ and ‘Joga Singh’.
According to above-named police officer, when search of the
abovementioned vehicle was carried out in the presence of ‘DSP Amarjit
Singh’, three bags, each containing 35 kg of poppy husk (totalling 105 Kg.),
were recovered.
5. It was further reported by the above-named police officer that
pursuant to recovery of abovementioned contraband, requisite formalities,
such as extracting samples, registration of FIR, and formal arrest of the
accused were completed and further investigation taken up. According to
prosecution, on completion of usual formalities of investigation, all the
above-named accused were sent to the Court to face trial.
6. To discharge its burden, of proving charges against the
appellants, the prosecution in the instant case had relied upon documentary as
well as oral evidence. The documents proved and marked with exhibits, by
the prosecution were:-
Ex.PA to
- Consent memos of ‘Falku’ ‘Mangu’,
‘Rajinder Singh’, ‘Avtar Singh’ and
‘Jagga Singh’, respectively
Ex.PF - Seizure memo of the recovered
PE
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
contraband
Ex.PG - Special Report under Section-57 of the
NDPS Act
Ex.PH to
- Option memo regarding search of TATA
Sumo, Jagga Singh, Mangu, Rajinder
Singh, Falku and Avtar Singh,
respectively
Ex.PM - The information-memo sent to the
police station (ruqqa)
Ex.PM/1 - Copy of First Information Report
Ex.PN - Rough site plan of the place of recovery
of contraband
Ex.PO to
Ex.PL
- Arrest memo of Falku, Mangu, Avtar
Singh, Jagga Singh and Rajinder Singh,
respectively
Ex.PT to
PS
- Memo of search of the persons of
Falku, Mangu, Avtar Singh, Jagga
Singh and Rajinder Singh, respectively
Ex.PY - Application filed by the police officer
before the Court for disposal of case

property
Ex.PZ - Inventory prepared by the Court of the
then learned Chief Judicial Magistrate
Mansa
Ex.PAA - Chemical Examination Report
Ex.P1 to
Ex.PX
- Seizure memo of gunny bag
Ex.P3
Ex.P4 - Registration certificate of TATA Sumo
bearing registration No.PB-31A-0187
owned by Sandeep Kumar
Ex.PW3/A - Affidavit of Constable Jagmail Singh

7. To provide support and corroboration to the above-mentioned
documentary evidence, as many as four witnesses were examined by the
prosecution. They were:-
PW-1 - DSP Amarjit Singh
-
PW-2 SI Baljit Singh
PW-3 - Constable Jagmel Singh Singh
PW-4 - HC Gurmail Singh
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M

8. Once the prosecution evidence was complete, the learned trial
Court completed all the formalities, enshrined under Section 313 CrPC.
Thereafter, opportunity to lead defence evidence was afforded to the
appellants. In their defence evidence, the appellants had examined one
witness only. He was :-
DW-1 - Khushal Chand

9 The appellants, in their defence, had relied upon documentary
evidence also. The document proved and marked with exhibits, by the
appellants, was:-
Ex.DA Statement of Amarjit Singh

10. When evidence of both the parties was over, the learned trial
Court gave opportunity to the learned public prosecutor and the learned
counsel for the appellants to address arguments. Thereafter, a judgment of
conviction of the appellants was pronounced. Accordingly, the appellants
were sentenced to undergo imprisonment, detailed, hereinbefore.
11. Heard.
12. It has been contended on behalf of appellants that the impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence passed by the learned trial
Court were perverse and unsustainable. According to learned counsel for the
appellants, merely on the basis of assumptions and presumption, the
unreliable and self-contradictory evidence adduced by the prosecution was
believed by the learned trial Court, and that the learned trial Court failed to
apply its judicial mind to the facts of the case. As per learned counsel for the
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
appellants merely, on the basis of conjectures and surmises the findings of
conviction of appellants, under Section 15 of NDPS Act, was recorded.
13. It has been further contended by learned counsel for the
appellants that the learned trial Court ignored this cardinal principle of
criminal jurisprudence that prosecution had to prove its case beyond the
shadow of all reasonable doubts. According to learned counsel for the
appellants, the evidence adduced by the prosecution was grossly inadequate
to draw an inference that all the essential ingredients, meant for the offence,
for which the appellants were convicted, had been established. In view of
above, the learned counsel for the appellants has contended that the case
against the appellants was not proved by the prosecution, upto the standard
prescribed under the law, but erroneously the learned trial Court returned the
finding of conviction.
14. While assailing the impugned judgment, it has been contended
by learned counsel for the appellants that instant case was a case, wherein all
the essential steps prescribed for the safeguard of interest of the appellants,
who have been prosecuted for a serious offence, were not followed by the
Investigating Officer. According to learned counsel for the appellants since
the appellants were prosecuted for an offence for which harsh punishment has
been prescribed under the law, the duty upon the Investigating Agency was
heavier to adhere to each and every instruction prescribed for safeguarding
the interest of the appellants. As per learned counsel for the appellants all
such instructions and statutory provisions were not followed by the
Investigating Officer. As per learned counsel for the appellant, the learned
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
trial Court ignored all such defects and returned the finding of conviction.
The learned counsel for the appellants has further contended that in view of
above, the abovesaid finding needs interference and indulgence of appellate
jurisdiction vested in this Court.
15. The learned counsel for the appellants has further contended that
in the present case another serious lapse on the part of the Investigating
Agency was that the samples were not sent to the Forensic Science
Laboratory immediately after the recovery, and that there was delay of 9 days
in sending samples to the Investigating Agency, which was fatal for the
prosecution case.
16. In the present case, one of the plea raised by learned counsel for
the appellants was that one independent witness, who was joined in the
proceedings, namely ‘Sukhdev Singh’, was withheld without any proper
reason. According to learned counsel for the appellants, in the absence of
examination of ‘Sukhdev Singh’, the entire prosecution case was resting upon
the depositions of official witnesses only. With regard to above, the learned
counsel for the appellants has contended that conviction solely on the basis of
official witnesses, was contrary to the settled principles of law. As per learned
counsel for the appellants, the testimonies of official witnesses alone were not
sufficient to prove recovery of contraband from the conscious possession of
the appellants.
17. It has also been contended by learned counsel for the appellants
that in the present case, Registration Certificate of the vehicle was proved by
the prosecution, as Ex.P4, and that as per Ex.P4, the owner of the TATA
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
Sumo No.PB31-A-0187 was ‘Sandeep Kumar’, who was not joined in the
investigation. According to learned counsel for the appellants, the failure to
examine registered owner of the above mentioned vehicle, rendered this
claim, of the prosecution, doubtful that ‘Avtar Singh’ was driving the
abovesaid TATA Sumo. The learned counsel for the appellants has contended
that it was the duty of the prosecution to rule-out abovesaid suspicion, but it
failed in its abovementioned endeavour.
18. In addition to above, the learned counsel for the appellants has
contended that instant case was a case, wherein the entire case developed by
the Investigating Officer was that there was a TATA Sumo, wherein
contraband was being transported, and that the appellants were travelling in
the abovementioned vehicle. According to learned counsel for the appellants
there was nothing on record to show that the above-named appellants were
having knowledge that contraband was being carried in the abovesaid vehicle
or that they were in conscious possession of the same. As per learned counsel
for the appellants, the conviction of appellants, merely, on the basis of
assumptions and presumptions that they were in conscious possession of the
contraband, was contrary to the settled norms of criminal jurisprudence.
19. During the course of his arguments, the learned counsel for the
appellants has contended that an error of judgment was committed by the
learned trial Court, while convicting the appellants and therefore, there is
need for indulgence and interference in the impugned judgment, by
exercising the appellate jurisdiction vested in this Court.
20. While controverting the arguments of learned counsel for the
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
appellants, it has been contended by learned counsel for the respondent/State
that all the essential ingredients meant for proving a charge for the
commission of offence under Section-15 of NDPS Act were duly proved by
the prosecution with the help of reliable evidence, and that the learned trial
Court rightly believed the same. As per learned counsel for the
respondent/State, there is no scope for indulgence or interference in the
findings of conviction, recorded by the learned trial Court. According to
learned counsel for the respondent/State, the present appeals, being devoid of
merits, deserve dismissal.
21 Qua this arguments of learned counsel for the appellants that the
independent witness, namely ‘Sukhdev Singh’, was not examined, it has been
contended by learned counsel for the respondent/State that when on the basis
of testimonies of official witnesses, all the essential ingredients meant for
proving the charge under Section-15 of NDPS Act stood proved, with the
help of prosecution, the non-examination of above-named witness could not
have any adverse impact on the prosecution case.
22. The record has been perused carefully.
23 In order to prove allegations against the appellants, as many as
four witnesses were examined by the prosecution. Amongst them, PW-1, PW-
2 and PW-4 were the material witnesses, being witness of recovery. However,
the role of remaining one witness, i.e. PW-3, was supportive in nature only.
All witnesses were the material witnesses, being witness of recovery.
24. The PW-1, when appeared in the witness-box, supported the
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
prosecution case by deposing the fact that on 28.08.1999, when he was
posted as DSP Sardulgarh, he received a wireless message from the Police
Station Sardulgarh. As per PW-1, on receipt of abovementioned information,
he rushed to the spot and reached there by 01:15 pm, where he found that a
TATA Sumo was parked obliquely. The PW-1 further deposed that one
independent witness, namely ‘Sukhdev Singh’, was also joined in the
investigation, and that the abovesaid TATA Sumo was intercepted by the
police party.
25. It was further deposed by the PW-1 that ‘Avtar Singh’ was
driving the abovementioned vehicle, whereas four persons, namely ‘Falku’,
‘Mangu Ram’, ‘Rajinder’ and ‘Joga Singh’, were travelling therein.
According to PW-1, when search of abovesaid vehicle was carried out, it was
found that in the abovementioned vehicle, 3 bags, each, containing poppy
husk were being recovered. The PW-1 also deposed that before carrying out
search, the ‘SI Baljit Singh’ had asked from the occupants of the TATA Sumo
as to whether they wanted their search to be conducted in the presence of
Magistrate or any Gazetted Officer, and that the abovementioned option was
exercised by the occupants of the truck and with regard to above, consent
memos Ex.PA to Ex.PE were prepared.
26. The PW-1 had offered himself for cross-examination. The
abovesaid right, i.e. right of cross-examination of PW-1, was duly exercised
by learned counsel for the appellants. However, despite sustained and probing
cross-examination, the PW-1 remained firm on the same stand.
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
27. Another material witness, examined by the prosecution, was SI
Baljit Singh. He was examined as PW-2. The PW-2 had testified that on
28.08.1999, when he was leading a team of police officials, deputed for
patrolling duty, near village Ladduwas, on the basis of suspicion one TATA
Sumo bearing registration No.PB-31-A-0187 was intercepted. The PW-2
further deposed that he shared the abovementioned information with his
superior officer, i.e. ‘DSP Amarjit Singh’, and thereafter, the abovenamed
DSP Sardulgarh came on the spot and search of the abovementioned vehicle
three gunny bags containing poppy husk were recovered. The story narrated
by the PW-2 was identical to the contents of FIR, vis-à-vis the deposition of
PW-1. Like PW-1, the PW-2, too, had deposed that one independent person,
namely ‘Sukhdev Singh’, was joined as independent witness during the
search of abovementioned vehicle.
28. The PW-2, too, was cross-examined at length by learned counsel
for the appellants, but nothing significant, which could have impeached the
credibility of his deposition, came out in his cross-examination. During his
cross-examination, the PW-2 deposed that he had sent wire-less message to
police station, requesting that some Gazetted Officer should be sent to the
spot. As per PW-2, after about 01:15 hours, ‘DSP Amarjit Singh’ arrived at
the spot, in whose presence search of the TATA Sumo bearing registration
No.PH-31A-0187, was conducted.
29. Another witness examined by the prosecution was ‘HC Gurmail
Singh’. He was examined as PW-4. The PW-4 had deposed that on
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
28.08.1999, while posted in Police Station Boha, he joined the police party
headed by SI Baljit Singh. The PW-4 further deposed that at about 11:00 am,
they spotted a Tata Sumo coming from Ladduwas side, being driven by a
clean-shaven person. In his deposition he had stated that despite being
signalled to stop, the driver attempted to run away, but the vehicle fell into a
minor canal, resulting in the breaking of its window and all the five
occupants, including the driver, namely Avtar Singh, were apprehended. The
PW-4 also deposed that the accused were individually asked whether they
wished to be searched in the presence of a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate,
and that they had opted for search in the presence of a Gazetted Officer. As
per PW-4, with regard to above option, the consent memos Ex.PH to Ex.PL
were prepared, and that a wireless message was sent to the police station.
According to PW-4, after some time, ‘DSP Amarjit Singh’ had arrived at the
spot along with his gunmen.
30 The PW-4, too, had offered himself for cross-examination. The
abovementioned right, i.e. right of cross-examination of PW-4, was duly
exercised by learned counsel for the appellants. However, despite sustained
and probing cross-examination, the PW-4 remained firm on the same stand.
31. Another witness, i.e. PW-3 Constable Jagmail Singh, was only a
formal witness, who had filed his affidavit as Ex.PW3/A, wherein he deposed
that the case property was collected by him in the police station and that he
delivered the same to the Forensic Science Laboratory. The above-named
witness was not cross-examined by learned counsel for the appellants.
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
32. I have given my due consideration to the facts and circumstances
of the case and the relevant law. It is pertinent to mention here that as per case
set-out by the prosecution, the contraband allegedly recovered from the
possession of appellants was not recovered during body search of the person
of the appellants.
33. As far as the above-discussed evidence, adduced by the
prosecution, was concerned, a careful perusal of the same would go to show
that as per story at the time of recovery of contraband, set-out by the
prosecution in addition to ‘DSP Amarjit Singh’, the Investigating Officer and
4-5 other police officials, one independent witness, namely ‘Sukhdev Singh’,
was also present. Amongst the abovementioned police officials, only three
persons, i.e. ‘DSP Amarjit Singh’, ‘SI Baljit Singh’ and ‘HC Gurmail Singh’
were examined by the prosecution. Since the abovementioned three witnesses
were official witnesses, their testimonies were supposed to be scrutinized
with utmost care and caution.
34. As far as the testimonies of PW-1, PW-2 and PW-4 were
concerned, a careful perusal of the same would go to show that by and large,
they were thoroughly consistent, but with regard to time, when message was
given to DSP Amarjit Singh and time of his arrival on the spot, there were
contradictions, such as the PW-1 and PW-2 deposed that information was
given to PW-1 ‘DSP Amarjit Singh’ at 12:00 noon, but as per PW-4 at 11:45
pm. Similarly with regard to time of arrival, the PW-1 and PW-2 testified that
the PW-1 arrived on the spot at about 01:00-01:15 pm, but as per PW-4, at
12:45 pm.
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
35. Although one may argue that the abovementioned contradictions
are not material, yet this fact cannot be ignored that being police officials, all
the three above-named witnesses were well-trained police officers, who were
duty bound to support the prosecution case. In such a scenario, the deposition
of ‘Sukhdev Singh’ would have been of utmost importance, because the
recovery of contraband had taken place in his presence. However, without
any proper justification, the above-named witness was not examined by the
prosecution. In my considered opinion, the failure of the prosecution to
examine ‘Sukhdev Singh’ as prosecution witness was fatal for the prosecution
case, with regard to its plea that contraband was recovered from the
conscious possession of appellants.
36. Instant case was not a case, wherein any independent witness
was not joined by the Investigating Officer at the time of trial. Things could
have been different in those cases, wherein an independent witness was not
joined at the time of recovery. In such type of cases, the adverse impact of
failure to join independent witness would be very small in comparison to
cases, wherein an independent witness was joined, but not examined during
the course of trial. With regard to abovementioned situation, the principles of
law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of ‘The
State of Himachal Pradesh V/s Kansara Mayur’ Criminal Appeal No.1515 of
2015, are relevant, wherein the story set-out by the prosecution with regard to
recovery of contraband was disbelieved by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in the absence of independent witness.
37. Similarly, in ‘Kamaljit Singh @Pappu V/s State of Punjab’
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
2020(14) SCC 9, the case of the prosecution was disbelieved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in view of the fact that the sole eye-witness was not
examined. The principles of law propounded in both the abovementioned
cases squarely cover the facts and circumstances of the present case.
38. In the present case, for the sake of arguments even if it would
have been assumed that the prosecution was successful in proving the
recovery of contraband from the possession of appellants even, then it was
the duty of the prosecution to show that the contraband recovered from the
possession of the appellants was poppy husk. For proving the
abovementioned component, it was the duty of the Investigating Officer to
prove that there was no chance of tampering of samples of contraband from
the spot of recovery, till its delivery to the Forensic Science Laboratory.
However, with regard to abovementioned component also, two serious lapses
were committed by the Investigating Officer:-
Firstly, that although it was projected by the prosecution and
deposed by all three prosecution witnesses, i.e. PW-1, PW-2 and PW-4 that
‘DSP Amarjit Singh’ (PW-1) was present on the spot at the time of recovery,
but as per deposition of PW-1, PW-2 and PW-4, the above-named DSP did
not put his seal on the samples. Thus, it was well within the hand of the
Investigating Officer, who had sealed the samples on the spot with his seal, to
change the samples by using his own seal; and
Secondly, that the police official, with whom samples were
deposited in the store-room ( Malkhana ) of the police station, was not
examined by the prosecution. The failure of the prosecution to examine
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
storeroom in-charge of the police station, was a serious lapse, because he
only could have deposed that samples were not tampered with in his custody.
39. The abovementioned lapses stood magnified in view of the fact
that the samples were delivered to the Forensic Science Laboratory after 9
days of its recovery. With regard to importance of link evidence, the
principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the
case of ‘Abdul Rajik V/s State of M.P.’ Criminal Appeal No.1561 of 2014,
are relevant, wherein in the absence of link evidence, the prosecution case
was held to be doubtful.
40. In addition to above, in the present case it was also relevant to
note that as per prosecution case, after use of seal, the same was handed over
to independent witness ‘Sukhdev Singh’, but neither the above-named
witness was examined, nor it was disclosed/proved on which date, the
abovementioned seal was returned by ‘Sukhdev Singh’ to Investigating
Officer. Since the samples were sent to Forensic Science Laboratory after 9
days, it was expected from the prosecution to prove that during the
abovementioned period of 9 days, the seal was not returned by ‘Sukhdev
Singh’ to the Investigating Officer. But any such evidence was not led by the
prosecution and therefore, this factor also breached the credibility of
prosecution case to the effect that there was no chance of tampering of
samples.
41. In addition to above, it is also relevant to mention here that in
the present case, there was no compliance of Section 42 of NDPS Act. With
regard to above, the five-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
in the case of ‘Karnail Singh V/s State of Haryana’ 2009(5) RCR (Criminal)
515, has ruled that the total non-compliance of Sections 42(1) and 42(2) of
NDPS Act is impermissible, i.e. where the officer does not record the
information at all and does not inform the official superior to him. In the
present case, the abovementioned compliance was not made.
42. It is relevant to note that as per deposition of PW-1, the option
given to the appellants before search was either by the PW-1 or some other
Gazetted Officer or by the Magistrate. However, the abovementioned
deposition of PW-1 was not in conformity with the record, wherein any
option by any other Gazetted Officer was not given to the appellants.
43. If the cumulative effect of all the abovementioned deficiencies
and lapses of the Investigating Agency would have been taken into
consideration co-jointly, it would lead to a firm conclusion that there was an
element of doubt with regard to stand of the prosecution qua the fact that any
contraband was found in conscious possession of the appellants. Thus, in my
considered opinion, the learned trial Court committed an error of judgment
when it ignored all the abovementioned factors prevailing in the present case
and recorded the fining of conviction of the appellants.
44. As a sequel to abovementioned observations, in my considered
opinion, there is scope for indulgence and interference in the impugned
judgment of conviction and order of sentence. Thus, it is hereby held that the
present appeals have got merits.
45. Therefore, finding merits in the present appeals, the same are
hereby allowed . The impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CRA-S-1591-SB-2004 (O&M
are hereby set aside and both the appellants are acquitted of the charges
framed against them.
46.

47. A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of connected
case.

(SURYA PARTAP SINGH)
JUDGE
17.11.2026
Gaurav Thakur



Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
GAURAV THAKUR
2026.11.18 13:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document