Deepak Kumar vs North Delhi Municipal Corporation
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1
OA No. 469/2020
Item No. 30 (C-3)
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI
OA No. 469/2020
MA No. 587/2020
RD
This the 03 Day of November, 2026
Hon’ble Ms. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J)
Hon’ble Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member (A)
1. Deepak Kumar, EE (Civil), Group 'A',
Aged About 51 years,
S/o Sh. Gurbachan Singh
R/o 41, Vrindavan Apartments,
I.P. Extension, New Delhi
2. Ramesh Kumar, EE (Civil), Group 'A',
Aged About 50 years,
S/o Sh. Pitru Mal
R/o B- 5/76, Sector-4, Rohini, Delhi
3. Kuldeep Singh, EE (Civil), Group 'A',
Aged About 51 years,
S/o Sh. Inder Singh Maan
R/o C-57, Prem Kutir Apartments,
Sec-9, Rohini, Delhi
.…Applicants
(By Advocate : Mr. Nishant Rajnama with Mr. M.K. Bhardwaj)
VERSUS
1) North Delhi Municipal Corporation
through its Commissioner
Dr.SPM Civic Centre
JLN Marg, New Delhi-110002
2) South Delhi Municipal Corporation
through its Commissioner
Dr.SPM Civic Centre
JLN Marg, New Delhi-110002
3) East Delhi Municipal Corporation
through its Commissioner
Patparganj Industrial Area
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:02+05'30'
2
OA No. 469/2020
Item No. 30 (C-3)
Delhi-110092
4) Union Public Service Commission
through Secretary
Dholpur House, Shahjahan Road
New Delhi
5) Govt. of NCT
through Director Local Bodies
Players Building, I.T.O. Delhi
6) Director Personnel, North DMC
Dr.SPM Civic Centre
JLN Marg, New Delhi-110002
7) Sh. Pramod Kumar Raja
S/o Sh. J.N Raja
Newly promoted adhoc SE (civil) working as
Executive Engineer, M-II/Karol Bagh Zone, North
MCD, Delhi.
through Commissioner, North DMC
8) Sh. Mahesh Singh Nimesh
S/o Sh. Attar Singh
Newly promoted adhoc SE (civil)- SE to E-in-C,
Civic Centre, North MCD, New Delhi.
through Commissioner, North DMC
9) Sh. Ravi Prakash
S/o Sh. Chattar Pal
Newly promoted adhoc SE (civil)- SW (DEMS)
Civic Centre, North MCD, New Delhi.
through Commissioner, North DMC
10) Sh. Shyam Lal Bairwa
S/o Sh. Mewa Ram Bairwa
Newly promoted adhoc SE (civil)- working as
Executive Engineer (Project)/Civil Lines Zone,
North MCD, Delhi.
through Commissioner, North DMC
11) Sh. Jagpal Singh
S/o Sh. Jugti Ram
Ex. Engineer (Bldg)/City & SP Zone, North MCD,
Delhi.
through Commissioner, North DMC
12) Sh. K. Kanan
S/O Sh. Krishan Sami
Executive Engineer, looking after charge of SE
(Project)/NGZ, South MCD, Delhi.
through Commissioner, South DMC
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:02+05'30'
3
OA No. 469/2020
Item No. 30 (C-3)
13) Sh. Rajendra Prasad Meena
S/O Sh. Har Lal Meena
Ex. Engineer (Bldg)-I/West Zone
South MCD, Delhi.
through Commissioner, South DMC
14) Sh. Surender Singh
S/o Sh. Than Singh
Working as Executive Engineer (Project)-I/Shah
North Zone, East MCD, Delhi
through Commissioner, East DMC
15) Sh. Pukhraj Meena
S/o Sh. Prithvi Lal Meena
Newly promoted adhoc SE (civil)- working as EE
(M)-I/Shah South Zone, East MCD, Delhi.
through Commissioner, East DMC
.... RESPONDENTS
[By Advocate : Ms. Anupama Bansal, Mr. R.V. Sinha with Ms. Shriya
Sharma and Mr. Harsh Verma]
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:02+05'30'
4
OA No. 469/2020
Item No. 30 (C-3)
ORDER (ORAL)
Hon’ble Ms. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J)
The instant OA has been filed by the applicants, who, at
the time of filing of the OA, were working as Executive
Engineers on ad-hoc basis. The grievance of the applicants is
primarily with regard to the alleged improper calculation of
vacancies by the respondents while considering the cases of
Assistant Engineers for promotion to the post of Executive
Engineer. They have also challenged the manner in which the
seniority list was prepared. Further, they have alleged that the
benefit of reservation in promotion was illegally extended to
candidates belonging to the SC/ST categories. Accordingly,
the present OA was filed on 13.02.2020, seeking the following
reliefs:
(i) To quash and set aside the impugned order dated 09.01.2020
and direct the respondents to fill up 55 vacancies of EE (civil)
against 2008-09 by holding review DPC.
(ii) To quash and set aside the decision of DPC dated 26.12.2016,
promotion order dated 12.01.2017 and direct the respondents to fill
up 55 vacancies of EE (Civil) instead of 32 against panel year 2008-
09 by holding review DPC strictly on the basis of seniority and
without applying rule of reservation.
(iii) To direct the respondents to consider the applicants for
promotion to the post of EE (Civil) against the vacancy year 2008-09
by holding review DPC of impugned DPC held in December 2016
and distributing total vacancies of EE (civil) for the said year 2008-
09 as per DOP&T instructions.
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:02+05'30'
5
OA No. 469/2020
Item No. 30 (C-3)
(iv) To declare the action of respondents in not taking into account all
the vacancies became available on account of promotion and
retirement in the higher grades as illegal and issue appropriate
directions to take into consideration all the aforesaid vacancies for
promotion to the post of EE (C) by holding review DPC of the original
DPC held on 26.12.2016 and issue consequential promotion order
on the basis of yearwise panel and issue final seniority list of EE
(Civil).
(v) To allow the OA with cost.
(vi) Pass any other orders that this Hon'ble Tribunal' may deem fit in
the facts and circumstances of the case.
2. Upon issuance of notice, the respondents entered
appearance and filed their replies, contesting the claims raised
in the OA.
3. When the matter is taken up today for final hearing,
learned counsel for the applicants submits that the applicants
had submitted representations before the respondents, raising
objections with regard to the incorrect calculation of
vacancies. The said representations were rejected vide order
dated 09.01.2020, which is also the subject matter of
challenge in the present OA.
4. We have had the occasion to peruse the aforesaid order,
which provides details of the vacancies for each of the relevant
years, including the period prior to the trifurcation of the MCD
as well as the period thereafter.
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:02+05'30'
6
OA No. 469/2020
Item No. 30 (C-3)
5. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submits
that following the unification of the three erstwhile municipal
corporations in May 2022, a comprehensive exercise for proper
cadre management in the Engineering Department was
undertaken, which is still underway. In the course of the said
exercise, the vacancy position was recalculated, seniority lists
were appropriately prepared and, in certain cases, review
DPCs were also convened. She further submits that the
seniority list of Assistant Engineers was thereafter published
and promotions were made on the basis thereof.
6. Learned counsel for the respondents further submits
that, as on date, the MCD is in the process of finalizing
promotions from the post of Superintending Engineer to that
of Chief Engineer, for which the matter is presently pending
consideration before the UPSC. She submits that the seniority
lists up to the level of Superintending Engineer have already
been finalized.
7. Learned counsel for the applicants, on the other hand,
submits that the applicants are now working as Executive
Engineers. He, however, fairly acknowledges that the issue
raised in the present OA primarily pertains to the calculation
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:02+05'30'
7
OA No. 469/2020
Item No. 30 (C-3)
of vacancies in the cadre of Executive Engineers for the period
prior to the unification of the MCD.
8. Since the unification has taken place in the meantime
and a comprehensive exercise of cadre restructuring and
management has subsequently been undertaken, much water
has flown since the filing of the present OA. The OA has
neither been amended nor updated to take into account the
subsequent developments.
9. In view of the aforesaid developments, we are of the
considered opinion that adjudication of the issues raised in
the present OA, which primarily pertain to the pre-unification
period, would now be merely an academic exercise,
particularly in view of the subsequent reorganization and
cadre-management exercise undertaken by the respondents.
10. Accordingly, the present OA has been rendered
infructuous and is disposed of as such. Pending MAs, if any,
also stand disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.
(Dr. Sumeet Jerath) (Harvinder Kaur Oberoi)
Member (A) Member (J)
/nk/
NISHA KUMARI 2026.11.19 17:19:02+05'30'