MALEKA BIBI vs UNION OF INDIA & ORS
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
1
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Biswaroop Chowdhury
F.M.A. 2332 of 2016
Maleka Bibi
VERSUS
Union of India
For the appellant:
Mr. Pradip Kumar Roy, Sr. Adv.
Ms. Soumita Chakraborty, Adv.
Ms. Shruti Mitra, Adv.
Mr. Soumak Bera, Adv.
For the respondent:
Last Heard on: October 08, 2026
Judgment on: November 17, 2026
Biswaroop Chowdhury, J:
The appellant before this Court was an applicant in a case under Section
124A of the Motor Vehicles Act 1988 and is aggrieved by the Judgment and
Award dated 29-06-2015 passed by Learned Railway Claim Tribunal Kolkata
Bench in OS(IIu)/Kol/2008/C124.
The case of the appellant/applicant before the Learned Tribunal may be
summed up thus:-
2
On 17-07-2003 while moving in a local Train from Howrah to Uluberia
the deceased was dashed with a post and sustained injury on his head and he
was brought by public to Uluberia station. Thereafter he was admitted to
Hospital and died on 17-07-03 at 2.20 p.m. The accident took place near
Uluberia Station.
The respondent Railway Authority contested the case by filing written
statement. ISSUES were framed and evidence was adduced. Learned Trial
Judge upon considering the evidence and upon hearing the Learned Advocates
was pleased to dismiss the claim case by observing as follows:-
‘It is the fact that the natural corollary of the decision in the cited acted
by the Learned Counsel for the applicant and various other judgments of
similar nature is that once it is established that the person was injured or died
on account of an untoward incident on Railways, a presumption can be
convincingly drawn concerning his bona fide as a passenger. But in the instant
case the applicant could not establish that the deceased fell down from a
running train. Therefore we are unable to draw a parallel view with the case
cited by the applicant and presume that the victim was a bona fide passenger,
in absence of any proof submitted by the applicant. Hence it is held that the
bona fide of the deceased as a passenger has not been established and as such
this issue is also decided against the applicant.
Issue Nos. 4 and 5.
3
Since the above two issues are inter-related they are being taken up
together for analysis.
In view of the findings made under Issue No. 3 and 2 above as the
applicant fails to establish her case she is not entitled to get any compensation
or any other relief as prayed for. Thus the claim application is liable to be
dismissed.
Hence ORDERED that the claim Application is dismissed on contest with
no order as to costs.’
The applicant being aggrieved by the Judgment and Award passed by the
Learned Trial Judge has come up with the instant appeal.
Heard Learned Advocate for the appellant and Learned Advocate for the
respondent. Perused the evidence adduced and materials on record.
Mr. Roy Learned Advocate for the appellant submits that the learned
Tribunal erred in dismissing the claim of the appellant solely on the ground
that no railway ticket was recovered from the possession of the deceased.
Learned Advocate further submits that the Hon’ble Tribunal erred in law
by failing to apply the well established legal principle that the mere absence of
a railway ticket from the possession of a deceased or injured passenger does
not by itself disprove their status as a bona-fide passenger. It is a matter of
judicial recognition that in the aftermath of a railway accident tickets can be
lost displaced or even amidst the ensuing chaos.
4
Learned Advocate also submits that multiple official reports including the
Police Report Inquest Report and Post Mortem Report categorically establish
that the deceased met with railway accident.
It is submitted by the Learned Advocate that the accident was a direct
consequence of severe overcrowding in the train as per evidence of AW-2
maternal uncle of the victim who testified during cross examination that the
train was dangerously congested particularly between Fuleswar and Uluberia.
It is further submitted that it is evident there was neither self-inflicted
harm nor any act of criminal negligence on the part of the deceased.
It is also submitted that the Railway Authorities themselves have not
disputed the fact that the train was severely overcrowded at the time of the
incident. In their submission they have implicitly acknowledged the issue of
excessive congestion in local trains which is a widespread and well documented
problem.
Learned Advocate relies upon the following Judicial decisions:-
Union of India VS Rina Devi
Reported in MANU/SC/0522/2018.
Sukumar Mondal VS Union of India General Manager South Eastern
Railway.
FMA-104 of 2021.
5
Kamukayi and others VS Union of India
Civil Appeal No. 3799 of 2023.
(Supreme Court of India)
Fatima Khatun VS Union of India
FMA-81 of 2025.
Anamika Halder and ors VS Union of India.
FMA-1152 of 2025.
Sukhabhai Nanjibhai, Makwana VS Union of India.
Mr. Bera Llearned Advocate for the respondent submits that the time at
which accident took place was morning and there was no crowd thus the fall of
the victim from the train was self inflicted injury. Learned Advocate submits
that considering the facts of the case Learned Tribunal did not commit any
error.
Before proceeding to decide the matter in issue it is necessary to consider
the evidence adduced by the claimants regarding fall from the train.
The appellant/applicant in the instant case has examined 2. Witnesses.
AW.-1 Maleka Bibi is the appellant herself AW-1 specifically stated about the
date of journey of her son from Salar Station in Murshidabad District to
Uluberia for doing job as contract labour in brick field at Uluberia. In cross-
6
examination she stated that she heard from Helu SK that her son was leaning
outside the doors of the compartment and he was struck by an electric post.
A.W.-2 Helu Sk. in cross-examination has stated that on the date of
incident they were going to Uluberia from Salar Station for doing some work
there. They came out from the house at about 5 p.m. on that date. They came
to Howrah by Gaya passenger and from where they got local Uluberia bound
train. He further stated that in between Fuleswar and Uluberia after striking
against one signal post the victim fell down from the train which was very
much overcrowded. The name of the victim was Insun Sk. He also stated that
14/16 persons were standing in between himself and the victim stated that at
the said time he was looking outside of the said train. Later he came to know
that it was Insun Sk. is corroborated from Surathal Report, and Post Mortem
Report. Thus the death of the victim due to fall from the train is established.
As the Learned Tribunal dismissed the claim of the appellant/applicant
on the ground that the applicant failed to prove that the victim was a bona-fide
passenger as no Railway ticket was filed by claimants it is necessary to
consider as to whether a non-recovery of Railway ticket from possession of
victim can be fatal and ground of rejection of claim.
In the case of Union of India VS Rina Devi (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme
Court observed as follows:-
‘17.4 We thus hold that mere presence of a body on the Railway premises
will not be conclusive to hold that injured or deceased was a bona-fide
7
passenger for which claim for compensation could be maintained. However
mere absence of ticket with such injured or deceased will not negative the
claim that he was a bona-fide passenger. Initial burden will be on the claimant
which can be discharged by filing an affidavit of the relevant facts and burden
will then shift on the Railways and the issue can be decided on the facts shown
or the attending circumstances. This will have to be dealt with from case tocase
on the basis of facts found. The legal position in this regard will stand
explained accordingly.’
In the case of Anamika Halder (Pal) and ors. VS Union of India (supra) it
was observed as follows:-
‘In many cases of Railway untoward incident where ticket could not be
recovered from victim reliance can be placed on oral evidence. Normally a
person does not dare to travel without ticket for the fear of being caught and
punished. Moreover when a passenger has to face Travelling Ticket Examiner
or ticket collector he is bound to produce the ticket but when the person is
dead he should not be charged with the allegation that he was travelling
without ticket as he will not be in a position to defend himself. A person
usually keeps his ticket either in money pursue or shirt pocket or pant pocket
or inside shirt pocket. Merely because ticket is not found a dead person cannot
be said to be a ticketless traveller.
In the event there is a reasonable doubt the benefit of doubt should go in
favour of the victims family.’
8
In the case of Anima Sarkar (Dolui) VS Union of India FMA-1169 of 2021
(supra) it was observed as follows:-
‘10. The respondent authorities could not have expected the complainant
to prove the nature and circumstances leading to the death of the victim. Both
the parties are to rely on the final report furnished by the investigating
authority. The complainant was not present either on the train or at the spot of
accident, to have vividly narrated the cause of accident, the presence as
absence of the valid ticket. The police report categorically mentioned ‘no foul
play’ to have been detected to obliterate the possibility of a self inflicted injury.
The investigating report the post mortem report and the final police report in
unequivocal terms endorsed the accident to have occurred while the victim had
been the passenger of the train. The absence of ticket under otherwise proven
case will not deter the complainant from legitimate claim in view of the
judgments cited above.’
Thus upon considering the facts of the case and the Judicial decisions
relied upon this court is of the view that the appellant/applicant has been able
to establish that the death of the victim is an untoward incident under Section
124A of the Railways Act.
Hence the applicant/appellant is entitled to the compensation as prayed
for.
Hence this FMA 2332/2016 stands allowed. The Judgment and Award
dated 29-06-2015 passed by Learned Railway Claims Tribunal Kolkata Bench
9
in Claim Application being O.S. (IIu)/Kol/2008/0124 is set aside. The
applicant/appellant is entitled to compensation of Rs. 400,000/- alongwith
interest @6% per annum from the date of filing claim case till today or Rs.
800,000/- (Rupees eight lac) whichever is higher. The respondent shall deposit
the compensation amount whichever is higher before the Registrar General
High Court at Calcutta. Such deposit shall be made within 8 weeks from the
date of communication of this order.
The appellant/applicant will be entitled to withdraw the compensation
upon compliance of necessary formalities.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, should be
made available to the parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)