Kulwant Singh vs State Of Punjab
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
123
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M)
Kulwant Singh . . . Appellant(s)
Versus
State of Punjab . . . Respondent(s)
1. Date when the judgment was reserved 16.10.2026
2. Date when the judgment is pronounced 17.11.2026
3. Date when the judgment is uploaded on the
website
17.11.2026
4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or whether the full judgment is
pronounced
Full
5. The delay, if any, of the pronouncement of full
judgment, and reasons thereof.
Not applicable.
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY VASHISTH
PRESENT: Mr. Karnail Singh Ahi, Advocate
for the Appellant(s).
Mr. Manjinder S. Bhullar, DAG, Punjab.
SANJAY VASHISTH , J.
1. Appellant – Kulwant Singh, aged about 56 years (age
mentioned in the impugned judgment), then posted as Sub-Division Officer
(S.D.O.) in the Irrigation Department, in the State of Punjab, has fild present
appeal by challenging the judgment of conviction and order of sentence
dated 31.07.2014, passed by the Court of learned Special Judge, Sri Muktsar
Sahib (Ld. trial Court) in the proceedings of FIR No.12, dated 02.12.2008,
registered under Section 13(1)(e) r/w Section 13(2) of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988, lodged at Police Station Vigilance Bureau, Ferozepur,
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 2 -
was convicted and sentenced as under: -
Under Section Sentence (R.I.) Fine (in Rs.) In Default
Section 13(2) of
04 years Rs.10,000/- R.I. for 03
P.C. Act
months
2. At the outset, before proceeding further, only for reference
purpose, Section 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (for brevity,
‘P.C. Act’) mentioned under CHAPTER – III “OFFENCES AND
PENALTIES” , is reproduced here-under
“ 13. Criminal misconduct by a public servant. - [(1) A public
servant is said to commit the offence of criminal misconduct,-
(a) if he dishonestly or fraudulently misappropriates or
otherwise converts for his own use any property entrusted
to him or any property under his control as a public
servant or allows any other person so to do; or
(b) if he intentionally enriches himself illicitly during the
period of his office.
Explanation 1. - A person shall be presumed to have
intentionally enriched himself illicitly if he or any person
on his behalf, is in possession of or has, at any time
during the period of his office, been in possession of
pecuniary resources or property disproportionate to his
known sources of income which the public servant cannot
satisfactorily account for.
Explanation 2. - The expression "known sources of
income" means income received from any lawful
sources.] [Substituted by Act No. 16 of 2018, dated
26.7.2018.]
(2) Any public servant who commits criminal misconduct
shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which shall
be not less than one year but which may extend to seven years
and shall also be liable to fine. ”
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 3 -
3. Facts leading to the appellant’s prosecution and as discussed in
the impugned judgment, reads as under:-
“ One inquiry bearing NO. against that 2 one
vigilance dated 23.1.2007 Kulwant Singh J.E. of Canal
department, Muktsar was registered in of regard to
disproportionate assets due to more expenses than his known
sources income for the check period pertaining to 1.4.2000 to
31.3.2006. It has been alleged that during the above said check
period, accused was having total tune of income to the whereas
his Rs. 12,83,139/-, expenses was Rs. 15,42,432/-. Due to these
circumstances, accused has spent more than Rs. 2,59,293/-
being a public servant and he has collected assets by misusing
hisofficial position being J.E. of the canal department.
As such, accused has allegedly committed offence
under sections 13(1)(e) read with Section 13 (2) of Prevention
of Corruption Act.
After preliminary investigation, case was got
registered and investigation was handed over to D.S.P. of Sri
Muktsar Harbhajan Singh Pannu Sahib. During investigation,
accused was arrested and documents pertaining to the check
period i.e. 1.4.2000 to 31.3.2006 were collected and it has been
found that accused has also constructed one Kothi and also
constructed other shops, where he has spent Rs. 3,48,193.66 Ps
and Rs. 1,47,137.66 PS, AS per assessment report technical
team. of from Apart this, accused has also purchased land in
the name of his son for a sum 2,07,600/- and one car for Rs. of
Rs. 60,000/-.”
Thus, being a public servant spending the amount of
Rs.2,59,293/-, beyond his sources of income, by appellant herein was
challaned by the Agency after obtaining sanction from the authority
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 4 -
concerned.
4. Vide order dated 14.02.2013, learned trial Court, read out the
allegation and thereupon, charge-sheeted the appelalnt for committing
offences under Section 13(1)(e) r/w Section 13(2) of the PC Act, relevant
part of it is as under:-
“ That you Kulwant Singh during the period
01.04.2000 to 31.03.2006 was a public servant and during that
period your total income was Rs.1283139/- and your expenses
were Rs.1542432/- and you couldn’t satisfactorily account for
Rs.259293/-, of your pecuniary sources and you thereby
committed an offence punishable under sections 13(1)(e) of
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 read with section 13(2) of
Prevention of Corruption Act.
And I hereby direct that you will be tried by this
Court on the said charge. ”
5. Prosecution examined total 10 witnesses, i.e.;
th
(i) PW-1 – Suresh Kumar Sharma, XEN , deposed that on 30
May 2007, he was posted as SDO in the Vigilance Bureau,
Technical Team-II, and inspected the appellant’s (Kulwant
Singh) house. He proved the assessment report as Ex.PW1/A
prepared by him, and also the assessment report pertaining to
the shop(s) as Ex.PW1/B. Besides, he also proved on record
the site plan pertaining to the house and shop(s) as Ex.PW1/C
& EX.PW1/D, respectively.
(ii) PW-2 HC Chana Masih , took ruqa Ex.PW2/A for registration
of the case to the Police Station, Vigilance Bureau, Ferozepur.
(iii) PW-3 Ashok Kumar, Clerk, in the District Transport
Officer, Faridkot , proved registration of car bearing
registration No.PB30B/4138,and attested copy of the RC record
as Ex.PW3/A.
JAWALA RAM (iv) PW-4 Tript Kaur w/o late Sh. Karnail Singh , deposed that in
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 5 -
the year 1999, she purchased one Zen car bearing registration
No. PB30B/4138 and later on in the year 2011 same was sold to
Kamaljit Singh s/o Kulwant Singh, JE (appellant herein) for
Rs.60000/-.
(v) PW-5 Kaur Singh, Registration Clerk, Ofice of Naib
Tehsildar, Doda , brought the original record pertaining to
Wasika No.884, dated 09.06.2004 and Wasika No.586,
dated20.05.2005, from Tehsildar Gidderbaha, proved the copies
of both the Wasika Nos. 884 and 586, as Ex.PW5/A and
Ex.PW5/B, respectively.
(vi) PW-6 Anil Kumar Sharma, Accounts Officer, Abohar Canal
Division, Abohar , brought the record pertaining to the salary
and the arrears drawn by Kulwant Singh, J.E. (appellant herein)
from 01.04.2000 to 31.03.2006, proved the attested copies of
salary bill as Ex.PW6/A (in 82 leaves) and the report as
Ex.PW6/B (in two leaves) prepared by him on the basis of that
record.
(vii) PW-7 Harchand Singh, Superintendent, Punjab Civil
Secretariat, Irrigation-III Branch, Chandigarh , he proved
the signatures Ex.PW7/A, of Mr. KBS Sidhu, Principal
Secretary, Irrigation Department, Punjab, Chandigarh, in
respect of sanction to launch prosecution against the appellant –
Kulwant Singh.
However, in cross examination said witness admitted that
at the first instance sanction was denied by Chief Engineer,
Drainage, who was competent authority to launch the sanction
and that he himself had no personal knowledge of the facts of
the present case or the documents placed on the file at the time
of getting sanction second time.
(viii) PW-8 DSP Harbhajan Singh Pannu , deposed that on
02.12.2008, he was posted as DSP, Vigilance Bureau, Muktsar
and after registration of the case, he investigated the same.
Also proved the recording of statements of the witnesses, on
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 6 -
10.12.2008, arrest of the accused – Kulwant Singh and from his
personal search one gold ring was recovered, which was taken
into police possession vide memo Ex.PW8/A. Besides, on
conducting search of residential house of the accused, nothing
incriminating was recovered and, in this regard, memo
Ex.PW8/B was prepared and got signed by the parties
concerned, as per procedure. Besides, he also prepared memo
of income and expenditure as Ex.PW8/C.
During cross-examination, said witness admitted that he
could not see the document, on the basis of which, value of
house was assessed, and the ownership of the accused was
confirmed. Value of the house and shops were assessed by PW
Suresh Kumar, who was the member of the technical team, as
requested by the police. Also admitted that there is nothing
mentioned regarding the ownership of the house and shops in
question in the statement u/s 161 Cr.PC. of said witness Suresh
Kumar. He also admitted that no demarcation report of the
house and shops in question was taken from the revenue
authority or even confirmed its khasra numbers.
(ix) PW-9 Ashok Kumar, Retd. Superintendent-II, Irrigation
Department , proved the relevant pages of the service book of
the appellant as Ex.PW9/A (in two leaves), besides, proving
other documents.
(x) PW-10 Sukhdev Singh , deposed that on 02.12.2008, while he
was posted as SP, Vigilance Bureau, Ferozepur, had written
ruqa Ex.PW2/A and got registered FIR Ex.PW2/B under the
signatures of MHC, Rajpal, who made his endorsement
Ex.PW2/C on the said ruqa. He also recorded statement of HC
Chana Masih u/s 161 Cr.PC and handed-over further
investigation to DSP Harbhajan Singh, Vigilance bureau
Muktsar.
Besides, all the aforesaid; statement of Ashwani Kumar Senior
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 7 -
Assistant, Canal Division, Abohar, was also recorded, regarding the bringing
of photocopies of the posting order of the accused.
Thereafter, learned APP for the State closed the prosecution
evidence on 28.01.2014.
6. Statement of accused – Kulwant Singh (appellant herein) under
Section 313 Cr.PC. was recorded on 04.02.2014, wherein, he took a specific
stand to the last question by recording as under:-
“ Que Have you anything else to say in your defence?
Ans. I am innocent. I have been falsely implicated in
this case. The investigation agency has wrongly counted by
income and expenses mentioned in this case. I am not the
owner of Kothi, shops shown in Ex.PW1/C and due to this
reason IO of this case did not collect the documents regarding
ownership of the said property. The house mentioned in the
case was constructed by my father and he was inherited this
property from his father Nand Singh. My father executed a Will
of the house in question in favour of my son Kamaljeet. Th
eland purchased in the name of my son by my father and he has
paid the sale consideration of the same from his agriculture
income and he appeared as purchaser in Ex.PW5/B. The car
mentioned in the list of property was also purchased by my
father in the name of my son. The police got recorded on some
blank papers from me regarding construction under pressure
during inquiry. Technical team also did not inspect the spot.”
7. On the other hand, accused (appellant herein) in his defense
also examined total six witnesses, such as;
(i) DW-1 Sukhmander Singh , Senior Assistant, Canal Lining
Division, Sri Muktsar Sahib;
(ii) DW-2 Gurmeet Kaur , Senior Assistant, Canal Lining Division,
JAWALA RAM Abohar;
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 8 -
(iii) DW-3 Surjit Singh s/o Hakam Singh , Agriculturist, r/o Village
Mannianwali, Tehsil Gidderbaha;
(iv) DW-4 Hardev Singh s/o Bakhshish Singh , agriculturist and
co-villager of the accused, r/o Vilage Mannianwala, Tehsil
Gidderbaha. He sold 3 Kanal of land for Rs.60,000, to
Kamaljeet Singh on 06.09.2004, situated in village
Mannianwala and that sale consideration was paid to him by
Raghbir Singh in the presence of DW Surjit Singh, who later
joined even at the time of execution of the sale-deed in favour
of Kamaljeet Singh. Sale-deed was proved as Ex.PW5/B.
DW-4 Joginder Singh, Revenue Patwari , Halqa Muktsar-
II;who proved the mutation entries entered in the name of
Harbans Singh s/o Raghbir Singh and Kamaljit Singh s/o
Kulwant Singh s/o Raghbir Singh on the basis of registered Will
executed by Raghbir Singh on 02.07.2008. Mutation was
sanctioned on 21.10.2010 and same is Ex.DW4/B.
(v) DW-5 Ved Parkash s/o Des Raj , Cloth Merchants, Gidderbaha
r/o Guru Nanak Nagar, Gidderbaha, who owns the land in
Village Mannianwala, and sold 10 Kanals of land on
09.05.2005, to Harbans Singh s/o Raghbir Singh and Kamaljit
Singh s/o Kulwant Singh s/o Raghbir Singh, for total sale
consideration of Rs.2,64,000/- vide sale-deed Ex.PW5/A.
(vi) DW-6 Manjit Singh s/o Uttam Singh , Mason, r/o Street No.3,
Guru Teg Bahdar Nagar, Bathinda Road, Sri Muktsar Sahib,
who proved that about 21 years back, he started the construction
of Kothi of Raghbir Singh in his field at Muktsar, and
construction was done by him as Mason in three stages. Also
proved that labour charges were paid to him by Raghbir Singh,
after purchasing the other construction material, such as, bricks
& cement etc. He also proved that Raghbir Singh was having
two sons, namely, Harbans Singh and Kulwant Singh
(accused/appellant herein).
JAWALA RAM Thereupon, on 08.05.2014, counsel for the accused before trial
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 9 -
Court, tendered in evidence certified copy of Jamabandi for the year 2000-
2001 as Ex.D1, copy of Jamabandi for the year 2010-2011 as Ex.D2,
certified copy of Mutation No.24255 as Ex.D3 and copy of order daed
15.12.2010 of Collector Muktsar as ExD4 and photocopy of order of AC-1
as Mark ‘A’ and the documents, such as, Jamabandi for the year 2000.
Again, on 03.07.2014, he tendered into defence evidence
certified copy of order dated 28.10.2010 as Ex.D5 and closed his defence
evidence.
8. On the basis of aforesaid evidence, trial Court concluded that
charges are proved and thereupon convicted and sentenced the appellant..
9. ARGUMENTS IN APPEAL:-
A) Learned counsel for the appellant argued that neither any
complaint was moved by any person, alleging therein the involvement of the
appellant in any corrupt practices during his past service carrier by that time,
nor requirement of Section 19 of the PC Act, was met with, by the
prosecution, as the sanction remained unproved on record.
At the first instance, sanction was denied by the Chief Engineer,
Drainage, however, it was obtained subsequently by re-submitting it before
the Principal Secretary, Irrigation Department, Punjab, Chandigarh, which in
fact is ‘no sanction’ in the eyes of law.
Order of sanction is not reviewable; therefore, it cannot be even
treated as the ‘genuinely granted sanction’ to launch prosecution against the
appellant.
It is also argued by learned counsel that the Principal Secretary,
who reviewed the earlier order and then granted the sanction for prosecution
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 10 -
of the appellant, himself did not come present in the witness-box to prove
his sanction order and if the statement including the cross-examination of
PW-7 Harchand Singh, Superintendent, is gone into, it is clear that the order
of granting sanction remains unproved.
B) To make assessment of the properties belonging to the ‘public
servant’ no guiding rules, guidelines or even approved formulas brought on
record. Therefore, report prepared by PW1 – Suresh Kumar Sharma (XEN),
who himself was in the Vigilance Bureau, Technical Team-II, and also
inspected the appellant’s house, has no basis of it’s preparation in
accordance with any law. Moreover, it is prepared unilaterally and without
any prescribed procedure.
No authority in favour of PW1-Suresh Kumar Sharma, to
prepare the assessment report of appellant’s property is proved on record;
nor there is any other evidence in that regard.
Thus, assessment report in itself is nothing, but a waste paper
and cannot be made basis for holding the appellant guilty.
C) Learned counsel further argued that none of the properties, i.e.,
house, shops or car in question, is found to be registered in the name of the
appellant. There is no material on record or connecting evidence collected
during the investigation nor it is available on record to establish that from
the income of the appellant, shops or it’s underneath land or house or its
underneath land or even the Zen Car, were purchased by the appellant by
making the payment from his own pocket or the bank account. Thus, basis
of framing of charges and then to launch the prosecution is completely
illusionary/imaginary idea without there being any substance or connecting
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 11 -
evidence on record.
D) Counsel also argued that the land of the house and the shops
was mutated in the name of the appellant’s brother and appellant’s son by
appellant’s father – Raghbir Singh, through a registered Will dated
02.07.2008. Investigating Officer failed in collecting any documentary
evidence that the property was purchased by the son of the appellant, or if
so, how it can fall in the share of the appellant. Even Investigating Officer
did not collect the said piece of evidence from the record.
E) Though the difference in the amount for disputed period is only
Rs.2,59,293/-, which is not very high, and even if the expenses of Kothi and
the shops are excluded, 1/3rd share of alleged expenses would be much less
to the income. Moreover, in the absence of spending of any amount on the
purchase of land or car coupled with the statements made by the defence
evidence, nothing is left in the case of prosecution.
F) It is also argued that as per law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court and the High Court(s), variation of 10% is to be taken into account to
the difference of actually known sources of income and the amount spent by
the employee concern. Thus, there being no substance in the allegation,
learned counsel prayed for acquittal of the appellant by setting aside of the
impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 31.07.2014.
10. On the other hand, learned State counsel vehemently opposed
the submissions and argued that charges are well proved, as assessment
report was prepared by the technical team consisting of the then SDO in
Vigilance Bureau, in regard to the properties and expenses of appellant.
Further argued that the assessment report is a proved document
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 12 -
on record and same was even confirmed with the statements of the other
supporting witnesses produced by the prosecution. Registration of the car
having been proved on record, clearly establishes the connectivity of the
appellant with the said car. No evidence is led by the appellant that the
expenses were not incurred by him for construction of the house and the
shops and also the car. There is no denial that Kamaljit Singh is related as
son of the appellant, or that he had nothing to do with the properties in the
names of other family members.
Thus, as per law of presumption under Section 19 of the PC
Act, it was upon the accused to prove the allegations to be false; because
burden was upon the appellant to disprove the allegations to the extent of
falsehood in it, instead of trying to take help of any benefit of doubt.
Thus, there being ample evidence on record and the findings
recorded in the impugned judgment of conviction, learned State counsel
prayed for dismissal of instant appeal.
11. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
relevant material available on record.
FINDINGS:-
12. SANCTION ORDER NOT AS PER LAW
For deciding the issue of Sanction; statement of PW-7 Harchand
Singh, Supdt., Punjab Civil Secretariat, Irrigation-III Branch, Chandigarh,
would be material as in examination-in-chief, he proved the signature as
Ex.PW7/A of Mr. KBS Sidhu, Principal Secretary, Irrigation Department,
Punjab, Chandigarh, who granted sanction to launch prosecution against the
appellant.
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 13 -
In cross-examination, he admitted in clear terms that earlier
sanction for launching prosecution was denied by the Chief Engineer,
Drainage, who in fact, was the competent authority to launch sanction. He
also admitted that he had no personal knowledge of the facts of the case, and
also admitted that no new document was even placed on record/file as to
why sanction was granted second time by another authority. For reference,
the complete ‘on oath’ statement of said witness, i.e., PW-7 Harchand Singh,
Superintendent, reads as under:-
“xx xxx xx xxx
On 10.01.2013 I was posted on the above said seat and with
the files concerning Junior Engineers. I received the file against
accused Kulwant Singh, Junior Engineer for according sanction to
launch prosecution in my office. I put up the file with Principal
Secretary, Irrigation Department, Punjab Govt. Chandigarh. After
going through the documents attached with the file sanction to
launch prosecution was given by KBS Sidhu, Principal Secretary,
Irrigation Department. Punjab Chandigarh, I identify his signatures
on Ex.PW7/A being well conversant with the same as I usually seen
him writing and signing the documents. My statement was recorded
by the police.
XXXXmn by Shri NS Mehal. Advocate counsel for accused.
1 presented the file before the Principal Secretary, Irrigation
Department but I'do not know who typed the same. Usually, as like
the sanctions are typed by the Steno. It is is correct that as per
Ex.PW7/A firstly sanction was denied to launch the prosecution to
the accused by the Chief Engineer, Drainage, who was competent to
launch the sanction. I have no personal knowledge of the facts of the
present case. I cannot tell whether new documents were placed on
the file at the time of getting the sanction second time. It is wrong to
suggest that I am deposing falsely being an official witness.
Sd/-
RO&AC (SS Dhaliwal)
JSC/16-09-2013 ”
There is a strong doubt over the sanction granted by the Principal
Secretary, Irrigation Department Punjab, Chandigarh, that too at second
occasion.
Once the competent authority for granting sanction to launch
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 14 -
prosecution had denied to grant sanction, basis of getting it reviewed by
another authority was ver much needed to be brought on record. Even,
another question, which arises is that, in the absence of any rule of law,
could executive itself review its own order to make it favorable to them to
launch prosecution against its employee under the P.C. Act.
On reading of the order of granting sanction in second
turn, it was the principal Secretary Irrigation Department, as there was
direction “to grant sanction” by the Senior Superintendent of
Police/Superintendent of Police (Kaptan Superintendent). There was no
such stage that non-granting of sanction was firstly brought to the notice of
Court and thereupon direction was issued to review it through some higher
authority.
From the sanction order it also does not come out that there is
any discussion regarding the factual allegations against the appellant as to
whether the assessment of the properties done by PW1-Suresh Kumar
Sharma is correct as per law. Thus, no sanctity can be given to such a
sanction order to meet out the statutory requirement under Section 19 of P.C.
Act.
13. While examining the sanction order from another angel also,
this Court noticed that it was PW7 Harchand Singh, who appeared to prove
the sanction order but was not aware of the facts of the case. In a way
appellant was not in a position to cross-examine the said witness on the facts
recorded in the sanction order, thus, there was no opportunity with the
accused to challenge the finding recorded by the sanctioning authority
through the cross examination of the said witness.
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 15 -
Merly identifying the signature of principal secretary would not
serve the purpose in law, because, such practice precludes of subjecting the
sanction granting authority to cross-examine by actually aggrieved person
i.e. accused in the criminal case.
Thus, in view of the aforementioned sanction order is defective
and not as per law, rather is an unproved document on record.
NO EVIDENCE, AS TO HOW AND ON WHAT BASIS ASSESSMENT
OF THE PROPERTIES WAS DONE:-
14. Prosecution did not prove any guidelines/approved
formula/rules on the basis of which unilaterally assessment report was
prepared by PW1 Suresh Kumar Sharma (XEN at relevant time posted as
SDO Vigilance Bureau, Technical -II). In the absence of any settled
provision, such a vague “mathematical calculation” cannot be made basis to
call upon any public servant to face prosecution charges under the punitive
law of Corruption. Even there is no evidence to prove that, at what time
exactly the construction was done and what were the construction rates at
that particular time. Even no clarification is found to be sought from the
appellant, as to who raised construction of house and shop over the land and
the construction material was purchased from whom. In such situation
preparing an assessment report only on asking of the investigation team
won’t be suffice to conclude that in the six years period, the expenses made
by the appellant that too of Rs.2,59,000/- (tentative) is more than the known
sources.
There cannot be any doubt that, whenever assessment of any
JAWALA RAM property’s rate is done by an individual without following any
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 16 -
procedure/regulation/rules/guidelines, always there would be difference in
the assessment.
15. Prime basis for convicting the appellant seems to be the
assessment reports, i.e., Ex.PW1/A and Ex.PW1/B (regarding house and
shops) and in this regard, statement “on oath” of PW-1 Suresh Kumar
Sharma (XEN), needs to be gone into thoroughly. For reference, same reads
as under:-
“ xx xxx xx xxx
That on 30.05.2007, I was posted as SDO in Vig.
Bureau, Technical team II. On that day. I alongwith Sn. Jarnail
Singh, SI and accused Kulwant Singh JE present in the court went to
inspect the house and shops situated at Sri Muktsar Sahib as given
in site plan and I did the assessment of the residence of Kulwant
Singh in his presence. He has spent Rs.56580/- on the foundations in
the year, 1993 and in the year, 1997, he spent Rs.1,09092/-. Then he
spent Rs.5,75960/- in the year, 2003 and in the year, 2005, he spent
Rs.368965/- for the construction work. After that in the year, 2006,
he spent Rs.99656/- on that. In totality, he spent Rs.12,10253/- on his
residential house and besides that I also assessed the amount used
on shops. In the year, 2004, he spent Rs.441413/- for construction of
shops. I prepared assessment report Ex. PW 1/A (two leaves) and
assessment report regarding shop Ex. PW 1/B also having one leave
and site plan of his residence is Ex. PW 1/C and site plan of shops
Ex. PW 1/D. Both the assessment reports were prepared by me and
bear my signatures and site plans bears the signatures of Kulwant
Singh accused present in the Court and also bear my signatures. My
statement was recorded.
Xxxxxxmmmnnnn.... cross-examination of the witness is deferred as
counsel for the accused has gone to Amritsar to attend the Bhog
ceremonies of the father-in-law of Sh.Rakesh Kumar Sharma, Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Sri Muktsar Sahib.
Sd/-
RO&AC .(S.S.Dhaliwal),
Judge Special Court,
Sri Muktsar Sahib.
18.03.2013”
Again subjected to the cross-examination on 24.04.2013.
“Xxxxxxmmmnnnn.... by the defence counsel, Sh.N.S.Mahal
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 17 -
Advocate
I did not verify the ownership of land under this house.
It is correct that at the time of inspection conducted by me, me,
father of the accused was present there. It is wrong to suggest that
father of the accused stated to me and other team members that this
house is in his name as owner and same has been constructed by
him(his father) with his funds. It is correct that house in question is
situated at very outer of the city and there are few house and it is an
isolated place. The house was not totally in furnished condition. I
did not estimate the aging of the construction. Volunteered I
estimated the house for the purpose of aging as stated by the I.O.
and the accused on the back of the site plan Ex. PW 1/C signed by
the accused. I did not measure the depth and width of the foundation.
It is correct that there are difference between the government rate
and private contractor rates. It is correct that 1 have prepared the
assessment reports Ex. PW 1/A and Ex. PW 1/B as per Government
rates. It is correct that if a person while construction uses his own
labour and other sources like vehicle for carrying the material etc.,
then it will cost lesser than the government rates. It one man use his
own wood etc. then the costs will also lesser than the assessed
amount. I had prepared some rough notes while preparing this
report and inspection but the same has not been handed over to the
police. I destroyed the same being my personal notes. It is correct
that costs of electricity fitting are varying according the quality of
the material. It is correct that we did not mention in our report Ex.
PW 1/A and Ex. PW 1/B regarding the quality of the electricity
material. It is correct that rates of bricks also vary according to
quality. It is correct that we did not mention in our reports regarding
the quality of bricks. It is correct that to construct the house rates
are varying to quality- wise. It is correct that I did not mention the
quality of material used in the construction of the buildings in our
reports. It is wrong to suggest that I have prepared a false
assessment reports as per the instructions of the Vig. Department. It
is also wrong to suggest that I have deposed falsely. It is also wrong
to suggest that value of the buildings in question is less than
assessed by me.”
16. While going through the statement of aforementioned witness,
it is noticed that he clearly admitted in the opening line of his cross-
examination that he did not verify the ownership of land underneath the
house . Also admitted that the house in question is situated on the outskirts
of the city and very few houses are there in that area, it being an isolated
place. House was not even in completely furnished condition. Age of the
house was also not estimated by him. Also admitted the difference in the
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 18 -
Government rates and private contractor rates and that, assessment report
was prepared on the basis of Government rates.
Also there are the admissions that :-
“ If one wishes to get the construction done through his
own labour and with the use of the other sources like vehicle for
carrying material etc. attaches importance in the assessment of
expenses.”
Said admission is to be read with the statement of mason-Manjit
Singh (DW6), who stated that construction of the house was started by him
in the year 1993.
Witness also admitted that the report in question was prepared
by him with the help of some rough notes, but were never handed-over to the
police during investigation, nor were produced before the Court, as same had
already been destroyed by the witness himself.
Regarding the varying rates of bricks as per its quality also,
there is admission by witness PW8- Retd. DSP – Harbhajan Singh Pannu
(PW-8), who during cross examination clearly stated that he could not see
any document, which may prove the value on the basis of which, value of
the house could be assessed and the ownership of the appellant could also be
confirmed. He also admitted that the value of the house and the shops were
assessed by technical witness – Suresh Kumar Sharma (PW-1) as per the
request of the police.
17. As per the documents given by the police to the witness –
Suresh Kumar Sharma; admittedly nothing was found mentioned regarding
the ownership of the house and shops in question. Anyway, it was even not
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 19 -
so stated by the witness – Suresh Kumar, while recording the statement
under Section 161 Cr.P.C.
During cross-examination, DSP – Harbhajan Singh Pannu (PW-
8) also admitted that as per sale-deed PW7/B, it was Raghbir Singh, who
had appeared for himself as purchaser and also on behalf of his co-purchaser
Kamaljit Singh s/o Kulwant Singh (appellant).
There is an admission that the land earlier belonged to the father
of the appellant, and it was transferred by him (their father) only in the name
of two, including the son of the appellant. Not only this, as per admission
made by DSP – Harchnad Singh Pannu (PW-8), no demarcation of the
house and the shops in question was taken from the revenue authorities or
the khasra numbers of the land where construction of shop and house was
raised.
18. This Court is unable to convince itself as to on what basis
prosecution agency had assumed that the constructed portion is built up by
the appellant by spending the amount from his own pocket to develop the
underneath land like his own Benami property. It is also not clear that in the
absence of proving of the construction of the house and the shops; in a
particular portion of the land of some khasra number and how the allegations
could be proved, when the land in question is owned by the other co-sharers
also. Even khasra numbers of the underneath land was not proved on record.
In the absence of any evidence regarding the identifying of the khasra
numbers and the demarcation of the area in favour of the appellant or his
son/brother, the charges are held to be only based upon hypothesis,
illusionary and on imaginations. Rather it seems that prosecution initiated
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 20 -
its proceedings only by creating a document of expenses to the tune of
Rs.2,59,293/-, which is in excess of the known source of income and that too
during the period of six years.
19. I have examined the provisions of Section 20 of the P.C. Act
also, which reads as under:-
“ 20. Presumption where public servant accepts any undue
advantage .- Where, in any trial of an offence punishable under
section 7 or under section 11, it is proved that a public servant
accused of an offence has accepted or obtained or attempted to
obtain for himself, or for any other person, any undue
advantage from any person, it shall be presumed, unless the
contrary is proved, that he accepted or obtained or attempted to
obtain that undue advantage, as a motive or reward under
section 7 for performing or to cause performance of a public
duty improperly or dishonestly either by himself or by another
public servant or, as the case may be, any undue advantage
without consideration or for a consideration which he knows to
be inadequate under section 11.] [Inserted by Act No. 16 of
2018, dated 26.7.2018.”
From bare reading of above provision, it is clear that law of
presumption is available to the prosecution only in respect of the offences,
where accused is facing the charges under Sections 7 or 11 of the P.C. Act.
In the case in hand, appellant is facing charge under Section 13(1)(e) read
with Section 13(2) of the P.C. Act; therefore, no presumption under Section
20 of the P.C. Act can be drawn against appellant in respect of aforesaid
charge. Accordingly, argument of learned State counsel that burden was
upon the appellant to disprove the allegations is wholly misconceived.
20. After going through the record having been discussed here-
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-3296-SB-2014 (O&M) - 21 -
above, this Court is fully convinced with the appellant, that there was never
any substantial evidence available on record to prove the allegations
against the appellant . Therefore, by allowing the appeal, appellant is
acquitted and discharged from the charges.
21. Appeal stands allowed in above terms .
Pending misc. application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
(SANJAY VASHISTH)
JUDGE
November 17, 2026
J.Ram
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether Reportable: Yes/No
JAWALA RAM
2026.11.17 19:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document