Arun Fotedar vs Dr. Jatinder Fotedar And Another
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
262 CR-1952-2025 (O&M)
Date of decision: 13.11.2026
Arun Fotedar
....Petitioner
Vs.
Jitender Fotedar and another
....Respondents
CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER
Present: Mr. Raghav Kapoor, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Mr. Sandeep Vermani, Advocate
for respondents.
*
HARSH BUNGER J. (Oral)
1. The present civil revision petition has been filed, under Article
227 of the Constitution of India , seeking setting aside of the order dated
03.02.2025 passed by the learned Trial Court, whereby an application filed
by the petitioner under Order 11 Rule 12 CPC seeking production and
discovery of documents by respondent No. 1 herein, has been dismissed.
2. Briefly, the present petitioner (Arun Fotedar) filed a suit for
mandatory injunction and recovery of mesne profits against the respondents
herein. The aforesaid suit was filed by the petitioner on the plea that he and
the present respondents are real brothers, and that the suit was primarily
against the present respondent No. 1 (Dr. Jitender Fotedar).
2.1 Petitioner pleaded that he along with the respondents herein, are
co-owners in the built-up immovable property constructed on Plot
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -2-
No. C-2/72-73 situated at Lord Krishna Enclave, Sushant Lok, Phase-I,
Gurugram. Petitioner stated that the plot of respondent No. 1 – Jitender
Fotedar, bearing No. C-2/71-B measuring 416 square yards was adjacent to
the above-referred property i.e. Plot No. C-2/72-73.
2.2 It is the pleaded case of the petitioner that he as well as the
respondents have been living in the built-up property on Plot No. C-2/72-73,
however, they were having their separate kitchens. It is stated that the
petitioner and respondent No. 2 are the co-owners of the said property
i.e. Plot No. C-2/72-73, and respondent No. 1- Jitender Fotedar has no title
or legal interest in the same, and even the property tax for the said property
was being paid by the petitioner himself. It is further the case of the
petitioner that there was an oral settlement / oral understanding between the
parties and their parents that 1/2 of the said property i.e. C-2/72-73, shall go
to the petitioner and the other one-half share will go to respondent No. 2,
and that the respondent No. 1 - Jitender Fotedar would reside in the said
property as a licensee and that he will shift to his independent house to be
constructed on the adjoining Plot No. C-2/71-B.
2.3 It is stated by the petitioner that respondent No. 1 - Jitender
Fotedar had been assuring his father and him that he will construct his house
and shift therein, but he only needs time. Petitioner maintains that there was
an understanding that after vacation of the first floor by respondent
No. 1 - Jitender Fotedar, the petitioner and his family will shift to the first
floor. It is stated that the father of the parties unfortunately expired on
28.09.2017, thereafter, also the petitioner continued to maintain good
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -3-
relationship with the respondents, however, respondent No. 1 - Jitender
Fotedar started picking up fights with his sisters and their children. The
sister is stated to have asked respondent No. 1 - Jitender Fotedar, to vacate
the suit premises i.e. Plot No. C-2/72-73, and look for some alternative
accommodation so that the petitioner and respondent No. 2 can live
comfortably and peacefully.
2.4 It is the categoric case of the petitioner that in last week of
December 2020, when the petitioner and his family had gone to Jammu, then
respondent No. 2 submitted a false affidavit to the Dakshin Haryana Bijli
Vitran Nigam (DHBVN) claiming that he is the sole owner of the property
No. C-2/72-73 and that he has no objection in case a separate electricity
connection is sanctioned in favour of respondent No. 1 - Jitender Fotedar. It
is stated that the electricity connection was obtained without the knowledge
of the petitioner when he was not in town.
2..5 It is stated that thereafter COVID-19 came when their mother
got ill and developed post-COVID complications. It is alleged that at that
time respondent No. 1 took possession of his father's room. It is further
alleged that on 31.05.2021, when the petitioner's mother had called her
eldest daughter Mrs. Girja Dhar, and while Mrs. Girja was with her mother,
she was assaulted by the respondents herein, whereupon the petitioner asked
respondent No. 1 - Jitender Fotedar to vacate the premises which he was
occupying as a permissive licensee.
2.6 Petitioner is further stated to have got served a legal notice
dated 11.06.2021 upon respondent No. 1 to vacate the premises, however, on
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -4-
the contrary, respondent No. 1 sent his reply dated 20.06.2021 through his
counsel denying that he was a licensee and stated that the suit property was
the sole ownership of his brother, and that their father and three sons
constituted a Joint Undivided Family, therefore, his possession is not illegal.
3. In the backdrop of the aforementioned facts and circumstances,
the petitioner filed the suit seeking decree of mandatory injunction against
respondent No. 1 - Jitender Fotedar to vacate and hand over peaceful and
vacant possession of the first floor of the suit property, and further prayer
was made for grant of mesne profits.
4. Upon notice being issued in the suit, respondent No. 1 - Jitender
Fotedar filed his written statement opposing the claim of the plaintiffs, and
in his preliminary submissions, he has taken the following stand:-
“2. That the correct fact with regard to the property bearing
Plot No. C-2/72 and 73 Lord Krishna Enclave, Sushant
Lok-I are that the defendant No.1 had sold a plot at
Ghaziabad in the year 1999 for a sum of Rs. 12,00,000
and had taken a loan from HDFC Bank for a sum of
Rs.8,00,000 and this loan account was joint account of
the answering defendant and his mother Mrs.Rattan
Fotedar and as a matter of record EMI of Rs.9207 with
effect from 1.8.2000 to June, 2003 from the accounts of
the answering defendant in Bank of Baroda and ICICI
Bank to the tune of Rupees around Rs.2 lacs and ninety
two thousand respectively and apart from the same and
the said loan was settled with the Bank at a later stage
thus the total amount invested by the answering
defendant in the construction of house of about
Rs.14,39,029 and all the amounts are paid by cheque
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -5-
and apart from this a sum of Rs.4,00,000 was paid in
cash by the answering defendant to various construction
worker for which appropriate details will be shared at
the time of leading evidence.
3. That further the correct facts with regard to the
litigations between the parties are that the answering
defendant prior to making investment in the construction
of the house at Plot No.C-2/72-73 in the year 1999 out
of his own funds had purchased property bearing no.
C-2/71-B measuring Approx.416 sq.yards situated at
Lord Krishna Enclave Sushant Lok Phase 1 Gurugram
and since other family members found the locality
peaceful and good for inhabitation hence out of joint
funds plot no. C/2-73 admeasuring approx.416sq.yards
was purchased in the name of Mrs. Rattan Rani who
later on executed a gift deed in the name of youngest son
Sanjay Fotedar i.e. defendant no.2 and thereafter plot
no. C-2/72 measuring 416 square yards was also gifted
in the name of defendant no.2 [Sanjay] by M.L.Bajaj.
4. That as such the Defendant No. 2 became the owner of
plots bearing C2/72-C2/73 Sushant Lok Phase 1
Gurugram measuring 832.416 square yards but in the
year 2002 to 2004 at the time of constructing the
property here in after referred as suit property as single
unit residential property the funds were arranged by the
answering defendant(As mentioned above) and his
father as the plaintiff and defendant no.2 were not in the
capacity to arrange and invest the funds so the title of
the plot remained in the name of the Defendant no. 2 but
since the funds to raise construction were arranged by
answering defendant, the answering defendant also
became entitled to the share in the property after
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -6-
construction of basement, ground floor, first floor and
second floor the defendant no. 2 started residing at
ground floor whereas first floor and second floor is in
the share of answering defendant and he is residing at
the first floor from day of its construction.
5. That the Late Sh. M.L. Fotedar/ father of the plaintiff as
well as the defendants wished and desired that his sons
reside jointly in the said property during his lifetime and
in order to fulfill the desires of departed soul the
plaintiff was given right to reside on the second floor of
the suit property however out of joint funds a residential
flat in Vishantika Apartments at Dwarka was acquired
in the name of plaintiff apart from huge industrial plot
of land at Manesar and commercial property at Qutab
plaza phase 1 in the name of his wife.
6. That as such the answering defendant No.1 who had
purchased a property bearing no. C-2/71 Shushant Lok
Phase1 Gurugram out of his own funds invested his
hard earned money in the construction of basements,
ground floor, first floor and second floor at plot
bearing.no. C-2/72 and 73 Shushant lok phase1
Gurugram which is in the name of Sanjay Fotedar and
Flat at Dwarka was purchased in the name of Arun
Fotedar out of joint funds of the family.
7. That other properties as mentioned above has been
purchased out of joint funds and proceeds of all the
properties have been made during the life of Late Sh.
M.L. Fotedar however as per the conveniences and
requirements of the same at the relevant times the titles
of properties remained in the name of different members
of the family as 250 sq yards plot in Dwarka, 600 sq
yards plot of green land in Shushant lok as well as
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -7-
agricultural land of two acres in village Daboda
Farookhnagar as well as mutual funds and bank
accounts are in the name of mother whereas apart from
the other ancestral properties office space at Qutab
plaza and flat in Dwarka are in the name of plaintiff
while the Manesar land is in the name of a company
owned by the family and likewise the property C-2/72
and 73 is in the name of defendant No. 2 on which the
construction has been carried out by the funds of
answering defendant with an understanding that either
the defendant no.2 would execute transfer deed in
respect of first and second floor of suit property or when
the answering defendant No,1 would raise his own
house at property solely owned by him then the expenses
shall be dully compensated by the family.
8. That the attitude of plaintiff right from beginning has
been quite hostile against defendant no. 2 and even
father of answering defendant had been entrusting the
answering defendant No. 1 with the responsibility to
take care of youngest brother[defendant no.2] as Arun
[plaintiff] would never hesitate in causing harm and for
this reason the answering defendant No. 1 never insisted
the defendant no.2 to execute transfer deed in his favour
and thought of getting it done only after plaintiff shifts to
his flat in Dwarka but after the death of Late Sh. M L
Fatedar the family members kept on deliberating to
partition the joint properties and answering defendant
No. 1 kept on asking the plaintiff to shift to Dwarka and
required the defendant no.2 to execute transfer deed in
his favour but they kept on delaying on one pretext or
other.
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -8-
9. That the plaintiff when required by all the family
members to disclose about all the joint properties sent a
mail to the answering defendant No.1 on dated
01.06.2020 wherein it was disclosed that the plaintiff
has got a transferred deed executed by defendant No.2
in respect of the share of property of C 2/72 & 73
Sushant Lok Phase 1 and when the defendant No. 2 was
confronted that he had no right as the construction of
above said property was carried out by the funds from
the answering defendant No.1 and transfer deed was
instead bound to be executed in favour of plaintiff it was
assured by the defendant no. 2 to get the said deed
cancelled as the same has been fraudulently obtained by
the defendant no.2 and in order to resolve the dispute a
family settlement was proposed and was drafted by the
husband of Mrs.Rashmi Shali and as such an another
mail was sent by the husband of Mrs. Rashmi to the
plaintiff on 10.06.2020 regarding settlement of the
above said properties. Copies of mails dated 01.06.2020
and 10.06.2020 are annexed as Annexure D -1 (Colly)
10. That on 31.05.2021 plaintiff tried to trespass in the
portion of the answering defendant and a dispute arose
between the parties subsequent to which a complaint
was lodged by the defendant No.2 against plaintiff and
his sister on 31.05.2021 and there after the plaintiff
through his/her counsel sent a legal notice dated
11.06.2021 to the answering defendant No.1 which was
replied vide letter dated 20.06.2021.
11. That the mother of the plaintiff being unwell was got
treated by answering defendant No.1 under provocation
from plaintiff even wrote letters and sent legal notices to
the answering defendant No.1 and defendant No. 2
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -9-
admitting the fact that the defendant No. 2 has been
looking after the bank accounts of mother of plaintiff
and defendants for last more than two decades and the
mother is also suffering from Alzheimers Diseases and
there is every apprehension that any of the parties may
misuse her present medical condition concerning
moveable and immoveable properties which may add
fuel to fire in the dispute and hence the present. Copy of
the mails, complaint, legal notice and reply to the legal
notice are annexed as ANNEXURE - D-2(Colly)
12. That the answering defendant No.1 and defendant no. 2
are co-owners of the above said suit property and their
father during his lifetime while staying jointly at the first
floor with the answering defendant No.1 had told him
that the plaintiff has always been harassing and
torturing the defendant No.2 and the answering
defendant being elder member of the family should take
care of Sanjay Fotedar i.e. defendant No. 2
13. That as apprehended by his father the plaintiff took the
originals of all the properties owned jointly by the
family and did not disclose about the properties and
further creation of the transfer deed without any
consideration itself proves that the said document is
prepared by fraud means and since the defendant no.2
had no right to execute it the same is liable to cancelled
and hence the answering defendant preferred a separate
suit for cancellation of the said transfer deed dated
22.07.2014, the existence of which was revealed to the
answering defendant on 1.6.2020 and the said suit
bearing No.CS No.2127/2021 is also pending
adjudication before this Hon'ble Court.”
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -10-
5. It transpires that during the pendency of the suit before the
learned Trial Court, the petitioner filed an application under Order 11 Rule
12 read with Section 151 CPC for discovery of documents, seeking
production of the following documents:-
“a. Statement of bank accounts where the Defendant No.1
has purportedly deposited the alleged amount of
Rs.12,00,000/- and thereafter spend the said amount by
way of cheques on the construction of house on plot No.
C2/72-73 Lord Krishna Enclave Sushant Lok-1
Gurugram.
b. Statement of account of HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank
from August 2000 to June 2003 showing the payment of
alleged amounts towards the payment of loan
installments.
c. All documents pertaining to the sanction of loan and the
settlement thereof by the Defendant No.1.
d. All receipts of the contractors/dealers/workers to whom
payments have been allegedly made by the Defendant
No.1 either in cash or by way of cheques.
e. All counterfoils of cheques purported to have been issued
by Defendant No.1 for the purpose of raising
construction.
f. Income Tax returns filed by the Defendant No.1 for the
period 2004 to 2004 during which construction of the
house as claimed by Defendant No.1 along with any
rebate claimed by the Defendant No.1 on payment of
home loan or any capital gain tax exemption.
g. All such other documents in his power and possession to
which reference has been made in his reply dated
4.10.2021 regarding construction of the house on suit
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -11-
property and documents regarding the source of
spending of so-called joint funds.”
5.1 The aforesaid application filed by the petitioner under Order 11
Rule 12 CPC was opposed by respondent No. 1 by filing his reply.
6. The learned Trial Court, upon consideration of the aforesaid
application, dismissed the same vide impugned order dated 03.02.2025
(Annexure P-1).
7. In the aforementioned circumstances, the present civil revision
petition has been filed before this Court.
10. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
paperbook with their able assistance.
11. The aforementioned facts are not disputed before this Court.
12. Here it would be apposite to refer to Rule 12 and Rule 14 of
Order 11 of Civil Procedure Code, which reads thus:-
“12. Application for discovery of documents. - Any party may,
without filing any affidavit, apply to the Court for an order
directing any other party to any suit to make discovery on oath
of the documents which are or have been in his possession or
power, relating to any matter in question therein. On the
hearing of such application the Court may either refuse or
adjourn the same, if satisfied that such discovery is not
necessary, or not necessary at that stage of the suit, or make
such order, either generally or limited to certain classes of
documents, as may, in its discretion be thought fit :
Provided that discovery shall not be ordered when and so far as
the Court shall be of opinion that it is not necessary either for
disposing fairly of the suit or for saving costs.
XXX XXX XXX
14. Production of documents. - It shall be lawful for the Court,
at any time during the pendency of any suit, to order the
production by any party thereto, upon oath of such of the
documents in his possession or power, relating to any matter in
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -12-
question in such suit, as the Court shall think right; and the
Court may deal with such documents, when produced, in such
manner as shall appear just.”
12.1 A perusal of aforesaid Rules reveal that thereunder discretion
has been given to the Court for directing discovery of documents or their
production. The Court may refuse the prayer if satisfied that discovery or
production is either not necessary or not necessary at that stage of the suit.
The provisions are not mandatory in nature and it is for the Court to decide
in each particular case when the power under the aforesaid rules ought to be
exercised.
13. Hon'ble Apex Court in case “Basanagouda v. Dr. S.B.
Amarkhed”, (1992)2 SCC 612 , observed as under :-
"7. The Court, therefore, is clearly empowered and it shall be
lawful for it to order the production, by any party to the suit,
such documents in his possession or power relate to any matter
in question in the suit provided the Court shall think right that
the production of the documents are necessary to decide the
matter in question. The Court also has been given power to deal
with the documents when produced in such manner as shall
appear just. Therefore, the power to order production of
documents is coupled with discretion to examine the
expediency, justness and the relevancy of the documents to the
matter in question…”
13.1 From the observations as recorded by the Apex Court in the
aforesaid judgment it could well be observed that a different procedure has
been provided for production of documents under Order 11 Rule 12 and 14
of Civil Procedure Code. Irrespective of the fact that the party could step
over Rule 14 Order 11 Civil Procedure Code without invoking the Rule 12
of the said order, yet the Court will have to advert to the relevant
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -13-
consideration of expediency, justness and relevancy of the documents by
recording its satisfaction with regard thereto before deciding to summon the
document in possession of the parties.
14. In AIR 1972 Supreme Court 2379, M.L. Sethi v. R.P. Kapur ,
Order 11, Rule 12 came up for interpretation. It was held that generally
speaking, a party is entitled to inspection of all documents which do not
themselves constitute exclusively the other party's evidence of his case or
title. If a party wants inspection of documents in the possession of the
opposite party, he cannot inspect them unless the other party produces them.
The party wanting inspection must therefore call upon the opposite party to
produce the documents. And how can a party do this unless he knows what
documents are in the possession or power of the opposite party? In other
words, unless the party seeking discovery knows what are the documents in
the possession or custody of the opposite party which would throw light
upon the question in controversy, how is it possible for him to ask for
discovery of specific documents? It was further held that every document
which will throw any light on the case is a document relating to a matter in
dispute in the proceedings, though it might not be admissible in evidence. In
other words, a document might be inadmissible in evidence, yet it may
contain information which may either directly or indirectly enable the party
seeking discovery either to advance his case or damage the adversary's case
or which may lead to a trial or enquiry which may have either of these two
consequences.
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -14-
15. It was also observed by this Court in case “Ahuja Distributor
and Anr. v. Sarup Tanneries Limited and Anr.”, (2008) 151 PLR 484 , that
an application under Order 11 Rule 14 is independent of Order 11 Rule 12
and that the court has enough discretion and it may even suo moto call for
such documents which it may consider relevant for the matter in issue.
16. Now coming to the case in hand, evidently, an application filed
under Order 11 Rule 12 CPC filed by the petitioner has been dismissed by
the learned Trial Court vide the impugned order dated 03.02.2025
(Annexure P-1) by observing as under:-
“7. When the nature of suit is seen, it is found that the core
controversy in the present suit revolves around title of plaintiff
in the suit property and alleged illegal occupation of defendant
no. 2 and when the relief claimed in the application is seen in
relation to the controversy, it is found that the discovery of
documents sought to be made by plaintiff are not necessary for
disposing fairly of the suit. Relevancy of the documents
mentioned in the application in order to prove his case by
plaintiff is not disclosed. It is not the prayer of applicant that
the title of ownership is in possession of defendant no. 1 which
is to be discovered. Relevancy of documents, as mentioned in
the application, to the controversy involved has not been
explained. It is primarily the responsibility of plaintiff to prove
his case which would involve proof of title of ownership and
termination of licence of defendant no. 1. Application under
order 11 rule 12 cannot be used as a means to gather evidence
for justification of claim of the applicant. Present application
appears to be an attempt to gather irrelevant information as a
fishing expedition. Relevancy of the documents sought to be
discovered has not been explained by the applicant. I find no
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh
CR-1952-2025 (O&M) -15-
merit in the application at this stage and hence the application
being devoid of merits stands dismissed.”
16.1 When the impugned order is seen in the light of the legal
positions indicated above, no fault can be found with the same.
17. Before this Court as well, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner has failed to demonstrate the relevancy of the documents sought to
be produced by the petitioner from respondent No. 1 - Jitender Fotedar to the
controversy involved in the suit. The learned Trial Court has rightly
observed that the application under Order 11 Rule 12 CPC cannot be used as
a means to gather evidence for justification of the claim of the
petitioner/plaintiff and that the application filed by the petitioner appears to
be an attempt to make a fishing inquiry. It has also not been shown as to how
the impugned order is either illegal or perverse.
18. Considering the totality of circumstances, I see no merit in the
present civil revision petition and the same is accordingly, dismissed .
19. All the pending application(s), if any, shall also stand closed.
(HARSH BUNGER)
13.11.2026 JUDGE
Ankit
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
ANKIT
2026.11.20 16:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh