MRS. VINEETHA SURESH BABU vs DR. ROSE MARY WILSON
- Court
- Kerala High Court
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:1:-
2026:KER:86708
‘CR’
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SOUMEN SEN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SYAM KUMAR V.M.
TH
THURSDAY, THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026 / 21ST KARTHIKA, 1948
COML.A NO. 4 OF 2026
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 20.08.2026 IN IA 1/2026 IN CS
NO.1 OF 2026 OF ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT, THRISSUR
APPELLANT/RESPONDENTS 1 AND 2/DFENDANTS 1 AND 2
1 MRS. VINEETHA SURESH BABU
AGED 44 YEARS, SPOUSE OF SURESH BABU
2/236C MULAMKUNNATHUKAVU, TRICHUR CIRCLE, M.G. KAVU
P.O, THRISSUR, KERALA, PIN - 680581
2 M/S AMEYA SWEETS
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER MS. VINEETHA SURESH BABU,
M.G. KAVU, MULAMKUNNATHUKAVU, THRISSUR, KERALA, PIN
- 680581
BY ADVS.
SHRI.K.RADHAKRISHNAN NAIR
SRI.SAJEN THAMPAN
SMT. JINU SAMYUKTHA PADMAKUMAR
SMT.AYOONA P. M.
SHRI.ATHIL JAMAL
SMT.ASHMY LAL G.
SMT.SARIKA KRISHNA A.
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:2:-
2026:KER:86708
RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS AND 3RD RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFFS AND 3RD
DEFENDANT
1 DR. ROSE MARY WILSON
AGED 63 YEARS
TRADING AS M/S. K. P. PATHROSE VAIDYAN'S
KANDAMKULATHY VAIDYASALA, RESIDING AT KANDAMKULATHY
HOUSE, KUZHUR P O, MALA, THRISSUR, AND HAVING
BUSINESS OFFICE AT KUZHUR P.O. MALA, KAKKULISSERI
VILLAGE, CHALAKUDI TALUK, MALA POLICE STATION,
THRISSUR DISTRICT, KERALA., PIN - 680734
2 M/S K.P. PATHROSE VAIDYAN'S KANDAMKULATHY VAIDYASALA
PVT. LTD.,
THRISSUR, KERALA, DOOR NO: 2/664, KUZHUR P.O,
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR MR. PATROUS WILSON,
PIN - 680734
3 M/S. LA FAIR STITCHING
NSS SHOPPING COMPLEX, KAITHARAM SCHOOL PADI, NORTH
PARAVUR, ERNAKULAM, REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER,
PIN - 683519
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.ABRAHAM CHERIAN
SMT.NIMMY K. JOSEPH
SHRI.JOE JOSEPH
SHRI.JAISON S. ROZARIO
SHRI.ARAVIND VARGHESE
SMT.POOJA JOSE
SHRI.V.VARUN
SMT.HARITHA MOHAN
SHRI.AMAL JOHN SABU
THIS COMMERCIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
12.11.2026, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:3:-
2026:KER:86708
J U D G M E N T
th
(Dated this the 12 day of November, 2026)
Soumen Sen, C.J.
The suit has been filed by the plaintiffs praying, inter
alia , for a permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the
defendants from using the trade mark ELADI, ELADI THRILL
and/or device mark given in Schedule B of the plaint or any
other trade mark similar to the device marks of the plaintiffs
given in Schedule A of the plaint, in relation to chewable
tablet/candy and thereby infringing the trade mark
registration and copyright of the plaintiff No.1 and passing off
their chewable tablet/candy as and for that of the plaintiffs.
2. In the suit, an interlocutory application was filed in
which, the impugned order was passed.
3. The learned Additional District Judge, after hearing
the parties, was satisfied that a case has been made out for
restraining the said defendants from using the said device
mark as well as the trade name, has passed an interim order
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:4:-
2026:KER:86708
and disposed of the application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 of
CPC by restraining the defendants from passing off or
infringing the registered trade mark of the respondents/
plaintiffs ‘ELADI’; and from using the names ‘ELADI’ and
‘ELADI THRILL’ or using any other trade name and a trade
mark as part of it, identical or deceptively similar to it, till the
disposal of the suit.
4. This order is under challenge.
5. A brief summary of facts and circumstances leading
to the filing of the suit are stated hereinafter.
6. Plaintiff No.1 is an ayurvedic doctor by profession
and also carrying on business related to manufacture and
sale of ayurvedic medicinal preparations under the name and
style “M/s. K.P. Pathrose Vaidyan's Kandamkulathy
Vaidyasala” (in short, ‘Vaidyasala’) since 1989. Plaintiff No.2
is a private limited company incorporated by plaintiff No.1
and her husband Mr. K.P. Wilson in the year 1995. The said
company manages and runs ayurvedic hospital as well as
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:5:-
2026:KER:86708
treatment centres and is also engaged in the manufacture
and sale of ayurvedic medicinal preparations. Defendant No.1
is, inter alia , engaged in the business of manufacture and
sale of chewable tablet/candy under the trademark
ELADI/ELADI THRILL and a device mark closely similar to
that of the plaintiffs. Defendant No.2 is a business entity
managed by defendant No.1.
7. The Vaidyasala earned substantial reputation and
goodwill for its authentic ayurvedic formulation derived from
the family's traditional palm-leaf manuscripts. Due to the old
age and ill health of K.P. Pathorse Vaidyan, the activity of the
Vaidyasala gradually slowed down. Thereafter, in order to
revive the business and to preserve the legacy built by the
late K.P. Pathorse Vaidyan, plaintiff No.1, the daughter-in-
law and a qualified ayurvedic physician, combined her
professional knowledge and skill with the family's traditional
formulations and established the business in the year 1989
as a sole proprietorship and carried on business under the
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:6:-
2026:KER:86708
name and style of K.P. Pathrose Vaidyan's Kandamkulathy
Vaidyasala.
8. The ayurvedic medicinal preparations of the
plaintiffs are being sold in India and exported to various
foreign countries like UAE, Australia, New Zealand, Kuwait
and Russia. The plaintiffs over the past three decades have
been conducting various activities connected with research,
pursuant to which they either develop and/or manufacture
the ayurvedic medicinal preparations which they market,
export and/or sell. The niche of the plaintiffs lies in their
research and development activities besides the consistency
in manufacturing, marketing and/or selling quality products
of the said ayurvedic medicinal preparations.
9. Plaintiff No.1 is the proprietor of well-known
trademarks in relation to ayurvedic medicinal preparations
developed, manufactured and sold by the plaintiffs. Plaintiff
No.2 is a company promoted by plaintiff No.1 and the said
plaintiff manufactures and sells various ayurvedic medicines
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:7:-
2026:KER:86708
under the trademarks of which plaintiff No.1 is the proprietor
th
with due permission of plaintiff No.1 with effect from 16
November, 2023.
10. ELADI chewable tablet/candy as well as lehyam for
cough and cold, was originally introduced by K.P.Pathrose,
the father-in-law of plaintiff No.1, in the year 1983 and
revived in the year 1989. The ELADI chewable tablet and
lehyam sold by the plaintiffs under the trademark ‘ELADI’
have been continuous and extensive for the past 37 years
and have become entrenched in the mind of the public. The
said products are of high quality and standard and have been
duly certified since the time of their launch. The ELADI
chewable tablet/candy of the respondents/plaintiffs is a
proprietary medicine as defined under Section 3(h) of the
Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940, being a unique formulation
developed by the respondents/plaintiffs and licensed by the
Drug Controller and comprises of Kurumulaku, Chukku
Thippalli Sugar, Liquid Glucose, Jeerakam, Thaleesapatram,
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:8:-
2026:KER:86708
Elakka, Nagappoovu, Perum Jeerakam, Omam, Iratty
Madhuram. That the ELADI chewable table/candy of the
plaintiffs are marketed and sold through more than 430
authorised distributors spread across all districts of Kerala
and extending to major cities in Tamil Nadu, Karnataka,
Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Maharashtra, Gujarat, Madhya
Pradesh, and the National Capital Region. Through an
extensive and well-organized network, the plaintiffs' ELADI
chewable tablet/candy for cough and cold are made available
in virtually every medical store, department stores, pharmacy
as well as supermarket in South India and are exported to
international markets thereby establishing a strong and
growing global presence. The ELADI chewable tablet/candy of
the plaintiffs are so widely distributed that it is difficult to
find any pharmacy, departmental store or supermarket in
Kerala that does not display or sell the plaintiffs ELADI
chewable tablet/candy. The plaintiffs' chewable tablet/candy
under the trade mark ELADI for cough and cold is also sold
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:9:-
2026:KER:86708
through plaintiff No.2’s website www.kandamkulathy.com
and through various e-commerce platforms namely
www.flipkart.com/, https://www.amazon.in/, https://www.
apollopharmacy.in/, etc. For these reasons, the ELADI
chewable tablet/candy of the plaintiffs has become a
household name and enjoys enduring consumer trust
and goodwill.
11. The plaintiffs are also using a unique trade dress
for the ELADI chewable tablet/candy with a color
combination of yellow, green and red and a unique
representation of the word “ELADI”.
12. The trade dress is an original artistic work as
defined under Section 2(C) of the Copyright Act, 1957,
designed by Mr. K.P. Wilson at the instance of plaintiff No.1.
Plaintiff No.1 is the owner of the copyright subsisting in the
above artistic work and has the exclusive right to use or
reproduce the features thereof in any material form.
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:10:-
2026:KER:86708
13. The device mark with the word “ELADI” was
th st
registered on 20 May, 2014 with user date as 1 January
th
1989 and the word mark “ELADI” on 24 January, 2014 with
st
user date 1 January, 1989, both in Class 5. The sales figure
of “ELADI” chewable tablet/candy of the plaintiffs for the
financial years 2002-2003 to 2025-2026 till December would
be ₹ 66,70,61,308/-. The advertisement and promotion
expenses incurred by the plaintiffs for its promotion for the
aforesaid period would be 29,96,44,552/-. By reason of long ₹
extensive, exclusive and continuous use of the mark “ELADI”
in respect of its products coupled with widespread
voluminous sales, promotional activities and long presence,
the chewable tablets/candy of the plaintiffs under the said
marks have acquired enviable goodwill and impeccable trade
reputation among the public and trade. The chewable
tablets/candy for cough and cold under the said marks have
thus attained widespread recognition across the country and
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:11:-
2026:KER:86708
have come to be exclusively identified and associated with
the plaintiffs among the public and trade circles.
14. Defendant No.1 filed an application for the
trademark “ELADI THRILL” in relation to medicated candy in
Class 5 which was refused by the Registrar of Trademarks
under Sections 9 and 11 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 and
the Registrar of Trademarks has also cited trademark of
plaintiff No.1 in the examination report. Thereafter,
defendant No.1 filed an application and obtained registration
for the trademark “ELADI THRILL” in Class 30 under the
th
Trademark No.2981494 with effect from 9 June, 2015
st
claiming user since 1 April, 2008 in relation to candy which
th
in substance remains medicinal candy. Accordingly, on 27
March, 2026, the plaintiffs filed an application for
rectification before the Registrar of Trademarks under
Section 57 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 and the said
application is pending. The trademark “ELADI THRILL” and
its device mark “ELADI THRILL Candy” are deceptively
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:12:-
2026:KER:86708
similar to that of the plaintiffs. The word “THRILL” is written
inconspicuously, rendering the dominant and audible prefix
“ELADI” in a writing identical to that of the plaintiffs.
15. The appellants/defendants are also using the trade
dress which is exclusively associated with the respondents/
plaintiffs, thereby infringing the copyright subsisting in the
artistic level of the plaintiffs. The manufacture and sale of
chewable tablets/candy by the defendants using trademark
and trade dress identical and/or similar to that of the
plaintiffs is causing confusion to the public.
16. The defendants adopted the impugned marks with
ulterior motives to divert and encash upon the hard-earned
reputation and goodwill garnered by the plaintiffs in and
around the said marks over the past four decades. The
identity of ingredients and the identical purpose of treating
cough and cold establish a clear trade connection between
the goods of the plaintiffs and the defendants, which makes
confusion and deception among the public inevitable.
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:13:-
2026:KER:86708
st
17. The 1 defendant in its counter affidavit has taken
the following defence:
i) The defendants have never sold its candies with a
trademark ELADI. The defendants are engaged in the
business of manufacturing and marketing chewable candies
and its registered proprietor of the trademark “ELADI
THRILL”, registered at the Trademarks Registry, Chennai
th st
with effect from 9 June, 2015 claiming user thereof since 1
April, 2008. The chewable candies of the appellants is sold
with the registered trademark “ELADI THRILL” only. The
second plaintiff who has been incorporated only in the year
1995 and has obtained permission, if any, only from 16
November, 2023 to use the trademark of the first plaintiff
and, therefore, cannot depose to or assert facts which are not
within his personal knowledge.
ii) The first plaintiff is a non-user of the registered
trademark and the second plaintiff has been manufacturing
ayurvedic medicine using the trademark of the first plaintiff.
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:14:-
2026:KER:86708
Thus, the second plaintiff has no right to claim any right
arising from the same.
iii) The limitation which was imposed by the Registry
at the time of granting registration for the mark
"KANDAMKULATHY ELADI LEHYAM" bearing application
number 728927, where it was specifically recorded that the
registration of the descriptive expressions "ELADI" and
"LEHYAM" was subject to association with Application No.
593035 and that no exclusive rights be claimed or granted in
respect of the other matters appearing on the label. This
limitation was deliberately suppressed both before the
Registry as well as the Trial Court.
st
iv) The medicinal tablet of the 1 plaintiff is registered
in Class 5, whereas the product of the defendants which is a
candy is registered in Class 30.
v) Numerous products bearing the name "ELADI",
including but not limited to Eladi Gutika, Eladi Bati, Eladi
Keram, Eladi Oil, Eladi Tailam, Eladi Kera Tailam, Eladi
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:15:-
2026:KER:86708
Choornam, Eladi Churnam, Eladi Cream, Asana Eladi Oil,
Dinesa Eladi Coconut Oil, Eladi Coconut Oil Balm and
various other ayurvedic preparations are manufactured and
marketed by different entities across India in addition, "Eladi
Plus" is a registered trademark in Class 5 of which trademark
remains unchallenged by the plaintiffs till date.
vi) There exists no similarity whatsoever between the
appellants’ word mark ‘ELADI THRILL’ and the plaintiffs’
device mark.
vii) The products of the appellants are confectionery
goods, namely chewable candies and bear no resemblance in
nature, character, purpose, composition or trade channels to
the alleged medical products of the respondents/plaintiffs.
The first plaintiff possesses only a registered trademark in
accordance with the provisions of the Trade Marks Act, 1999,
which has been subject to non use by the first plaintiff. The
plaintiffs’ attempt to extend such rights by claiming copyright
protection over a trade dress and packaging does not satisfy
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:16:-
2026:KER:86708
the requirements of an artistic work within the meaning of
Section 2(c) of the Copyright Act, 1957.
viii) The trademarks of the first plaintiff are subject
matter of pending rectification proceedings, namely TM
Application No.14332640 pertaining to the word mark ELADI
and TM Application No.14332701 pertaining to the mark
Kandamkulathy ELADI Chewable tablet. The said
rectification proceedings have been initiated, inter alia, on the
ground that the word “ELADI” is Publici Juris and common to
the trade, particularly, in the field of Ayurveda. The word
“ELADI” is devoid of any inherent distinctiveness and is
descriptive of the nature, composition and characteristics of
the medicinal and pharmaceutical goods in respect of which
the marks are registered.
18. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellants has assailed the said judgment primarily on two
grounds. Firstly, plaintiff No.2 being a permitted user is not
entitled to sue for infringement under Section 53 of the Trade
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:17:-
2026:KER:86708
Marks Act, 1999 and secondly, the word mark “ELADI” is
common to the trade, descriptive and could not have been
registered. The learned counsel has also submitted that
plaintiff No.1 has discontinued her business and the same is
presently being carried on by plaintiff No.2. Plaintiff No.2 is
using the said mark recently in 2023 and being a permitted
user, plaintiff No.2 could not have been maintained a suit as
a co-plaintiff in a suit for infringement of the mark ELADI of
which plaintiff No.1 has claimed to be the registered owner.
Moreover, the goods and products of the appellants are sold
under the trademark ELADI THRILL in a different class of
business. The said mark is distinctive in character. The
products sold under the said trademark are different from
the products sold under the registered trademark of the
plaintiff No.1.
19. We have heard the learned counsel for the
appellants and the respondents, and perused the materials
on record.
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:18:-
2026:KER:86708
20. In any event, plaintiff No. 2 is a closely held family
business of the Wilson family and, for all practical purposes,
the business of plaintiff No.2 is that of plaintiff No.1 and/or
the Wilson family.
21. The function of a trademark is to identify the
source of manufacture of goods and distinguish the goods of
one person from another. As was said by UPJOHN, J., “A
man infringes the mark of another if he seizes upon some
essential feature of the plaintiff's mark. That essential feature
may be ascertained by the eye or by the ear in this sense,
that goods bearing that mark may be likely to become known
by a certain name……” (emphasis supplied). Furthermore,
evidence is admissible to establish what is or has become an
essential feature, but evidence is not essential if the Court
feels satisfied on inspection in coming to the conclusion that
some particular feature is a distinguishing feature of the
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:19:-
2026:KER:86708
Mark allegedly infringed. (See Cluett Peabody & Co. Inc. v.
1
McIntyre Hogg Marsh and Co. Ltd . )
22. Trademark is an indication of origin. In the market,
the chief value of the trademark is its power to stimulate
sales. In law, the fundamental theory upon which the
interest in the trademark is protected is that a trademark
identifies the goods coming from a particular source, and
that an infringing designation tends to divert customer from
that source by falsely representing that other goods come
from it. (See Ellora Industries v. Banarsi Das Goela and
2
Others ) .
23. Section 2(m) of the Act gives an inclusive definition
of “mark”. “Mark” includes amongst others “word”. Section
2(h) defines “deceptively similar”. It states that a mark shall
be deemed to be deceptively similar to another mark if it so
nearly resembles that the other mark as to be likely to
1 1958 RPC 335 at 351
2 AIR 1980 Del 254
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:20:-
2026:KER:86708
deceive or cause confusion. Under Section 29, a registered
trademark is infringed, if -
(a) the mark is identical and is used in respect of similar
goods or services; or
(b) the mark is similar to the registered trade mark and
there is an identical or similarity of the goods or services
covered by the trade mark; or
(c) the trade mark is identical and is used in relation to
identical goods or services;
2 4. On the first impression, it is obvious that there is
every likelihood of deception or confusion by the user of the
mark of the appellants.
25. It is now well-settled that the Court while
considering likelihood of deception or confusion must make
allowance for imperfect recollection. Until the removal of the
trademark from the Register, there is presumption about the
validity of the trademark. Deception can be caused even
without the word as prefix or suffix. Every word can be a
trademark. It is often said that an ordinary purchaser is not
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:21:-
2026:KER:86708
gifted with the powers of observation of a Sherlock Holmes.
The question of deception or confusion has to be approached
from the point of view of an unwary purchaser. The marks
must be looked at from the first impression of a person of
average intelligence and imperfect recollection and must be
compared as a whole, microscopic examination being
impermissible. The statute does not require actual deception
or confusion to found an action based on infringement. [See
The Hearst Corporation v. Dalal Street Communications
3 4
Ltd. , Wockhardt Ltd. v. Aristo Pharmaceuticals Ltd.
and ITC Ltd. v. Whole Leaf Tobacco Venture Pvt. Ltd. and
5
Others ]
26. In Hindustan Embroidery Mills Pvt. Ltd. v. K.
6
Ravindra & Co . , it was held as follows:
“It is not the practice to consider the validity of the
registration of a trade mark on motion for
interlocutory injunction taken out by the persons
3 Cal LT 1995 (2) HC 346
4 1999 PTC (19) 210
5 AIR 2019 Calcutta 215
6 1974 (76) Bom LR 146
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:22:-
2026:KER:86708
who has got the mark registered in his name. While
a mark remains on the register (even wrongly), it is
not desirable that others should imitate it.”
(emphasis supplied)
27. Similar is the observation in Walter Bushnell Pvt.
7
Ltd. v. Miracle Life Sciences and Another .
28. The appellants have contended that an application
for rectification is pending . In Walter Bushnell Pvt. Ltd.
(supra), it has been further held that unless the trademark
challenged by the defendant is cancelled or rectified it is not
the practice to infringe the same in an action for infringement
of the trademark.
29. In Gold Star Co. Ltd. v. Gold Star Industries and
8
Others , it was held that “what would happen to the
rectification proceedings nobody can predict. As of today,
prima facie evidence establishes plaintiff's exclusive rights
regarding the trade mark… Plaintiff cannot be deprived the
fruit of registered trade mark nor can the defendant be
7 2014 (59) PTC 339 (Del)
8 1995 PTR 78
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:23:-
2026:KER:86708
allowed to use the trade mark of the plaintiff for passing off
its goods… If the defendants are allowed to use the trade
mark of the plaintiff it would adversely affect the business of
the plaintiff, internationally as well as in India”.
30. Similar was the view expressed by the Delhi High
Court in the case of M/s. Avis International Ltd. v. Avi
9
Footwear Industries and Another . The dicta laid down in
the aforesaid decisions have been considered and followed in
ITC Limited v. Green India Rice Millers and Exporters
10
Private Limited and Others .
31. The registration of the device mark “ELADI”, with
the word “ELADI” prominently displayed in the said label
mark, has clearly established, at this stage, that the plaintiffs
have an undoubted right to use the device mark or the label
mark prominently displaying the word “ELADI”, which is
identifiable with the plaintiffs and their products. The
9 AIR 1991 Del. 22
10 2017 SCC OnLine Cal 5859: AIR 2019 Cal 3
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:24:-
2026:KER:86708
plaintiff No.1 having established that the said word is being
used in relation to its products extensively since 1989, is
entitled to protect its intellectual property rights in relation to
the said word “ELADI” which had acquired a considerable
goodwill in the market as would be evident from the
documents disclosed in the petition. Once the plaintiffs have
prima facie been able to establish that the said word is
closely associated with and identifiable with their products,
and that an unwary purchaser with imperfect recollection
would consider the said mark “ELADI” to be that of the
plaintiffs, they are entitled to an order of injunction, unless
the appellants/defendants are able to establish and offer a
plausible ground or reason for adopting the said mark
“ELADI” at a much subsequent point of time, as the law
would not allow an infringer to thrive on the goodwill of
the plaintiffs. In fact, the appellants have failed to explain
the adoption of the word “ELADI” in relation to its products.
The word “ELADI” is much prominent and conspicuous in its
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:25:-
2026:KER:86708
products as opposed to other words used as a label mark or
word mark.
32. In Laxmikant V. Patel v. Chetanbhai Shah and
11
Another , the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as
follows:
“10. A person may sell his goods or deliver his
services such as in case of a profession under a trading
name or style. With the lapse of time such business or
services associated with a person acquire a reputation or
goodwill which becomes a property which is protected by
courts. A competitor initiating sale of goods or services in
the same name or by imitating that name results in injury
to the business of one who has the property in that name.
The law does not permit anyone to carry on his business
in such a way as would persuade the customers or clients
in believing that the goods or services belonging to
someone else are his or are associated therewith. It does
not matter whether the latter person does so fraudulently
or otherwise. The reasons are two. Firstly, honesty and
fair play are, and ought to be, the basic policies in the
world of business. Secondly, when a person adopts or
intends to adopt a name in connection with his business
or services which already belongs to someone else it
11 (2002) 3 SCC 65
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:26:-
2026:KER:86708
results in confusion and has propensity of diverting the
customers and clients of someone else to himself and
thereby resulting in injury.”
(emphasis supplied)
33. This dicta was followed in Ramdev Food Products
12
(P) Ltd. v. Arvindbhai Rambhai Patel & Ors.
34. A trademark is infringed if the essential features of
the registered mark of an owner have been copied. A mark is
said to be infringed by another trader if, even without using
the whole of it, the latter uses one or more of its “essential
features”. If a word forming part of a mark has come in trade
to be used to identify the goods of the owner of the mark, it is
an infringement of the mark itself to use that word as the
mark or part of the mark of another trader, for confusion is
likely to result. (See Balsara Hygiene Products Ltd. v.
13
Arun Chowdhury and Another ).
12
(2006) 8 SCC 726: AIR 2006 SC 3304
13 2005 (30) PTC 272 (Cal)
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:27:-
2026:KER:86708
35. It is no answer to a charge of infringement – as
contrasted with a passing off action – that the defendant's
mark, whilst including the plaintiff's mark, includes other
marks too. Still less is it an answer that by something
outside that actual mark, the defendant has distinguished
his goods from those of the plaintiff by adding his own name
( Kerly's Law of Trade Mark and Trade Names , Para
14.22).
36. However, in the instant case, it cannot be said that
the respondent is able to establish any such distinguishing
feature which would distinguish its goods from that of the
plaintiffs. The trademark is the whole thing. When a word
mark or a label mark or a get up is considered, the court
would be required to consider the totality of the situation –
the mark as a whole with due regard to the background
provided by any other marks shown to be in use.
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:28:-
2026:KER:86708
37. The Trade Mark law does not permit and protect a
person who is trying to take the benefit of someone else's
reputation with references to goods which may not be similar
when it is established that the said mark has acquired some
reputation. The appellants are competitors and trade rivals.
38. Even if we accept that the mark “ELADI” is a label
mark, the word “ELADI” is an essential feature of the label
which is covered by the registration. The distinctive feature of
the label mark is the prominent display and predominant
presence of the word “ELADI”. The word “ELADI” has been
independently registered in favour of plaintiff No.1. When the
word itself forms the essential feature of the mark, it can be a
basis for an infringement action and more so when it deals
with similar goods.
39. It has long been accepted that, if a word forming
part of a mark has come in trade to use to identify the goods
of the owner of the mark, it is an infringement of the mark
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:29:-
2026:KER:86708
itself to use that word as the mark or part of the mark of
another trader, for confusion is likely to result. It is sufficient
to refer to the words of Lord Cranworth L.C., in Seixo v.
14
Provezende ‘If the goods of a manufacturer have, from the
mark or device he has used, become known in the market by
a particular name, I think that the adoption by a rival trader
of any mark which will cause his goods to bear the same
name in the market, may be as much a violation of the rights
of that rival as the actual copy of his device’.
(emphasis supplied)
40. In Kaviraj Pandit Durga Dutt Sharma v.
15
Navaratna Pharmaceutical Laboratories , while
discussing the distinction between an action for passing off
and action for infringement of trademark, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held as under:
14 (1866 LR 1 Ch. 192)
15 AIR 1965 Supreme Court 980
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:30:-
2026:KER:86708
“28.......In an action for infringement, the plaintiff must,
no doubt, make out that the use of the defendant's mark
is likely to deceive, but where the similarity between the
plaintiff's and the defendant's mark is so close either
visually, phonetically or otherwise and the court reaches
the conclusion that there is in imitation, no further
evidence is required to establish that the plaintiff's
rights are violated. Expressed in another way, if the
essential features of the trade mark of the plaintiff have
been adopted by the defendant, the fact that the get-up,
packing and other writing or marks on the goods or on
the packets in which he offers his goods for sale show
marked differences, or indicate clearly a trade origin
different from that of the registered proprietor of the
mark would be immaterial; whereas in the case of
passing off, the defendant may escape liability if he can
show that the added matter is sufficient to distinguish
his goods from those of the plaintiff.”
41. The likelihood of confusion or deception in such
cases is not disproved by placing the two marks side by side
and demonstrating how small is the chance of error in any
customer who places his order for goods with both the marks
clearly before him, for orders are not placed, or are often not
placed, under such conditions. It is more useful to observe
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:31:-
2026:KER:86708
that in most persons the eye is not an accurate recorder of
visual detail, and that marks are remembered rather by
general impressions or by some significant detail than by any
photographic recollection of the whole.
42. A trademark need not be registered to be protected,
in fact, passing off rights are superior to the rights conferred
by registration. In this regard, reference may be made to
16
S. Syed Mohideen v. P. Sulochana Bai , wherein it is
stated at paragraphs 31 to 32 as follows:
“31.1 Traditionally, passing off in common law is considered to
be a right for protection of goodwill in the business against
misrepresentation caused in the course of trade and for
prevention of resultant damage on account of the said
misrepresentation. The three ingredients of passing off are
goodwill, misrepresentation and damage. These ingredients are
considered to be classical trinity under the law of passing off
as per the speech of Lord Oliver laid down in Reckitt & Colman
Products Ltd. v. Borden Inc. [Reckitt & Colman Products Ltd. v.
Borden Inc., (1990) 1 WLR 491 : (1990) 1 All ER 873 (HL)]
which is more popularly known as “Jif Lemon” case wherein
Lord Oliver reduced the five guidelines laid out by Lord Diplock
in Erven Warnink Besloten Vennootschap v. J. Townend &
16 (2016) 2 SCC 683: (2016) 2 SCC (Civ) 201: 2015 SCC OnLine SC 1084
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:32:-
2026:KER:86708
Sons (Hull) Ltd. [Erven Warnink Besloten Vennootschap v. J.
Townend & Sons (Hull) Ltd., 1979 AC 731 at p. 742 : (1979) 3
WLR 68 : (1979) 2 All ER 927 (HL)] (“the Advocaat case”) to
three elements : (1) goodwill owned by a trader, (2)
misrepresentation, and (3) damage to goodwill. Thus, the
passing off action is essentially an action in deceit where the
common law rule is that no person is entitled to carry on his or
her business on pretext that the said business is of that of
another. This Court has given its imprimatur to the above
principle in Laxmikant V. Patel v. Chetanbhai Shah [Laxmikant
V. Patel v. Chetanbhai Shah , (2002) 3 SCC 65 ]
31.2. The applicability of the said principle can be seen as to
which proprietor has generated the goodwill by way of use of
the mark/name in the business. The use of the mark/carrying
on business under the name confers the rights in favour of the
person and generates goodwill in the market. Accordingly, the
latter user of the mark/name or in the business cannot
misrepresent his business as that of business of the prior right
holder. That is the reason why essentially the prior user is
considered to be superior than that of any other rights.
Consequently, the examination of rights in common law which
are based on goodwill, misrepresentation and damage are
independent to that of registered rights. The mere fact that both
prior user and subsequent user are registered proprietors are
irrelevant for the purposes of examining who generated the
goodwill first in the market and whether the latter user is
causing misrepresentation in the course of trade and damaging
the goodwill and reputation of the prior right holder/former
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:33:-
2026:KER:86708
user. That is the additional reasoning that the statutory rights
must pave the way for common law rights of passing off.
32….it is also recognised principle in common law jurisdiction
that passing off right is broader remedy than that of
infringement. This is due to the reason that the passing off
doctrine operates on the general principle that no person is
entitled to represent his or her business as business of other
person. The said action in deceit is maintainable for diverse
reasons other than that of registered rights which are allocated
rights under the Act. The authorities of other common law
jurisdictions like England more specifically Kerly's Law of
th
Trade Marks and Trade Names, 14 Edn., Thomson, Sweet &
Maxwell South Asian Edition recognises the principle that
where trade mark action fails, passing off action may still
succeed on the same evidence. This has been explained by the
learned author by observing the following:
“ 15-033. A claimant may fail to make out a case of
infringement of a trade mark for various reasons and
may yet show that by imitating the mark claimed as
a trade mark, or otherwise, the defendant has done
what is calculated to pass off his goods as those of
the claimant. A claim in ‘passing off’ has generally
been added as a second string to actions for
infringement, and has on occasion succeeded where
the claim for infringement has failed.”’
(emphasis supplied)
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:34:-
2026:KER:86708
43. The aforesaid enunciation of law is a clear answer
to the objection raised as regards plaintiff No.2 as co-plaintiff
under Section 53 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999. The
argument that plaintiff No.2 is a permitted user is also not
borne out from the record at this stage. The averments made
in the plaints are considered to be true and correct.
Moreover, the commonality of interest and the relationship
between plaintiff No.1 and plaintiff No.2, which appears to be
closely held company in which plaintiff No.1 is one of the
shareholders are factors to be taken into consideration. The
same has been dealt with in the impugned order in
paragraph No.9 which is as under:
“9). The above petition is supported by an affidavit
nd
sworn by the Director of the 2 plaintiff company
M/s. K.P Pathrose Vaidyan's Kandamkulathy
Vaidyasala Pvt. Ltd. that this company established in
the year 1989 and doing business of chewable tablet
st
in the name 'ELADI'. The 1 plaintiff is an Ayurvedic
Doctor and the daughter of late K.P Pathrose
st
Vaidyan. The 1 plaintiff is the wife of the Director of
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:35:-
2026:KER:86708
nd
the 2 plaintiff. Nothing legally preventing these both
plaintiffs together seeking an injunction against the
respondents 1 & 2 to restrain the usage of the trade-
name 'ELADI/ELADI THRILL, therefore, this petition
is maintainable. ”
44. It is not being contended that plaintiff No.2 could
not have independently filed a suit for passing off. However,
for the reasons we have already recorded, the plaintiffs have
been able to demonstrate infringement of the mark in
question. In the alternative, the imitation of the mark by the
appellants being, prima facie , established by reason of the
clear enunciation of law by Kerly on Trade Marks and
Trade Names and approved in S. Syed Mohideen (supra),
the impugned interim order should be sustained.
45. Insofar as the infringement and/or passing off
action is concerned, the learned Additional District Judge
has referred to Sections 34 and 27(2) of the Trade Marks Act,
1999 to extend the benefit of an order of injunction in favour
of the plaintiffs. It is a trite principle of law that once the
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:36:-
2026:KER:86708
plaintiffs are able to establish their prior use of the mark,
such prior use will prevail even over a subsequently
registered trade mark containing the same word or device
and the registered proprietor of the said mark would not be
entitled to an order of injunction against a person who had
acquired interests in the said mark by reason of its prior long
use. In the instant case, the plaintiffs, both by reason of prior
use and subsequent registration, have been able to establish
the paramount right and used the mark “ELADI” in respect of
its products. Insofar as the argument that the said word is
common to the trade, is also not acceptable because a word
which may be common, may, by reason of its long and
extensive use, become identifiable with the proprietor of the
said mark and acquire a secondary meaning.
46. In the label mark, the word “ELADI” is prominent
and conspicuous. The word “ELADI” as a word mark has
also been registered with user since January 1989. In view
of long, continuous and extensive use of the mark in their
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:37:-
2026:KER:86708
products, the public is likely to associate the word with the
goods and services of the plaintiffs. It is by reason of such
long use, it has earned reputation and goodwill and acquired
a secondary meaning, thereby acquiring a distinctiveness.
The appellants have disclosed their turnover and expenses
incurred for advertisement for the last 23 years. Admittedly,
the mark “ELADI” of the plaintiffs was in use much prior to
adoption of the mark “ELADI” by the appellants.
47. It is equally well settled that if a mark, by reason of
its exclusive, continuous and extensive use, becomes
distinctive, and such mark is applied to a class of goods
which the proprietor of the mark does not deal with,
consumers may always wonder as to whether the proprietor
of the trademark has launched a new product. This is a
matter of confusion and deception.
48. The much belated adoption and registration of the
mark, may be in a different class, by the appellants, with the
word “ELADI” being conspicuous all over, shall fall foul of the
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:38:-
2026:KER:86708
aforesaid legal principles, as the appellants cannot rough ride
over the goodwill acquired over a period of time and make
quick money by unjust enrichment. In Kaviraj Pandit
Durga Dutt Sharma (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court
recognised that l ength of user will be a material factor for the
mark to become distinctive. [See paragraph 16 of Kaviraj
Pandit Durga Dutt Sharma (supra)]. The proof of acquired
distinctiveness can overcome the objection that a mark is
descriptive.
49. Moreover, the plaintiffs have also become the
registered proprietors of the said mark with user since
January 1989. A registered trade mark proprietor is not
expected to sue every infringer to save him. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in National Bell Co. and Another v. Metal
17
Goods MFG. Co. (P) Ltd. and Another has held that a
proprietor of a trade mark need not take action against
infringement which do not cause prejudice to its
17
(1970) 3 SCC 665: AIR 1971 SC 898
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:39:-
2026:KER:86708
distinctiveness. In Express Bottlers Services Private Ltd.
18
v. Pepsico Inc. & Others , it has been held as follows:
“….To establish the plea of common use, the use
by other persons should be shown to be substantial. In
the present case, there is no evidence regarding the
extent of the trade carried on by the alleged infringers or
their respective position in the trade. If the proprietor of
the mark is expected to pursue each and every
insignificant infringer to save his mark, the business will
come to a standstill. Because there may be occasion
when the malicious persons, just to harass the proprietor
may use his mark by way of pinpricks…. The mere use
of the name is irrelevant because a registered proprietor
is not expected to go on filing suits or proceedings
against infringers who are of no consequence… Mere
delay in taking action against the infringers is not
sufficient to hold that the registered proprietor has lost
the mark intentionally unless it is positively proved that
delay was due to intentional abandonment of the right
over the registered mark. This Court is inclined to accept
the submissions of the respondent No. 1 on this point…
The respondent No. 1 did not lose its mark by not
proceeding against insignificant infringers…”
(emphasis supplied)
18 1989 PTC 14; 1988 SCC OnLine Cal 62
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:40:-
2026:KER:86708
50. As far as the argument of the appellants that the
word “ELADI” is common to the trade and that variants of
“ELADI” are available in the market, we find that the
appellants have not been able to prima facie prove that the
said ‘infringers’ had significant business turnover or they
posed a threat to plaintiffs’ distinctiveness.
51. In fact, in Dr. Reddy Laboratories Limited v.
19
Reddy Pharmaceuticals Limited , a learned Single Judge
of the Delhi High Court has held as under:
“…the owners of trade marks or copy rights are not
expected to run after every infringer and thereby
remain involved in litigation at the cost of their
business time. If the impugned infringement is too
trivial or insignificant and is not capable of harming
their business interests, they may overlook and
ignore petty violations till they assume alarming
proportions. If a road side Dhaba puts up a board of
“Taj Hotel”, the owners of Taj Group are not expected
to swing into action and raise objections forthwith.
They can wait till the time the user of their name
19 (2004) 29 PTC 435
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:41:-
2026:KER:86708
starts harming their business interest and starts
misleading and confusing their customers.”
52. In fact, we are of the view that the respondents/
plaintiffs are not expected to “sue all small type infringers
who may not be affecting respondents/plaintiffs business”
20
[See Pankaj Goel v. Dabur India Ltd . ] The aforesaid
judgments are also considered in Pankaj Goel (supra).
53. In an action on the trademark, that is to say, in an
infringement action, an injunction would issue as soon as it
is proved that the defendant is improperly using the
plaintiff's mark. (See Ruston & Hornsby Ltd. v. Zamindara
21
Engineering Company Ltd . )
54. When the plaintiffs have been able to establish that
there has been wrongful and deceptive use of the said mark
and the defendants having failed to offer any plausible
explanation for the adoption of the said mark at a much
subsequent period of time and the plaintiffs having
20 (2008) 38 PTC 49 (DB)
21 AIR 1970 SC 1649
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:42:-
2026:KER:86708
established goodwill, misrepresentation and damage, the
classical trinity, the interim order passed by the learned
Additional District Judge does not call for any interference.
55. The duty of the Appellate Court in considering an
appeal from an interim order was considered in Super
Smelters Limited & Ors. v. SRMB Srijan Private
22
Limited . It was held as under:
“42. It is well-settled that an appellate court would be
extremely slow and cautious to interfere with the
discretionary jurisdiction of the trial court with regard
to the granting of an ad-interim order. The appeal
court will not substitute its discretion unless the trial
court has exercised jurisdiction arbitrarily,
capriciously, perversely or in ignorance of settled
principles of law regulating the grant or refusal of an
ad-interim order of injunction. As observed in Cello
Plast v. L.A. Opala R.G. Ltd. (2018 SCC OnLine Cal
2475) at paragraph 4:
“It is only when an ad interim order is passed
completely without reasons or appears to be
bad to the meanest mind in the sense that it
22 2020 (81) PTC 101 [Cal] [DB] : 2019 SCC OnLine Cal 4888
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:43:-
2026:KER:86708
is outlandish, that an Appellate Court should
interfere in an intra-Court appeal”
56. On the facts narrated above, the view taken by the
learned Additional District Judge is a possible and
reasonable view, and we are not inclined to interfere with the
exercise of such discretion.
57. The appeal fails and accordingly dismissed.
Sd/-
Soumen Sen,
Chief Justice
Sd/-
Syam Kumar V.M.,
Judge
ds/SSK/ms/krj
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:44:-
2026:KER:86708
APPENDIX OF COML.A NO. 4 OF 2026
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure A1 TRUE COPY OF THE I.A. NO.:1 OF 2026 IN THE
FILES OF C.S.NO.: 1 OF 2026 BEFORE THE III
ADDL. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
THRISSUR DATED 02.04.2026
Annexure A2 TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER IN I.A. NO.:1 OF
2026 IN THE FILES OF C.S.NO.: 1 OF 2026
BEFORE THE III ADDL. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS
JUDGE, THRISSUR DATED 05.06.2026
Annexure A3 TRUE COPY OF THE DISCLAIMER ISSUED BY THE
TRADEMARK REGISTRY DATED 18.08.2006 IN
APPLICATION NUMBER 728927
Annexure A4 TRUE COPY OF THE REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE
WORD MARK 'ELADI' OF THE 1ST RESPONDENT
WITH REFERENCE NO. 1949529 DATED
24.01.2014
Annexure A5 TRUE COPY OF THE REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE
OF 'KANDAMKULATHY ELADI CHEWABLE TABLET'
OF THE 1ST RESPONDENT WITH REFERENCE NO.
1640400 DATED 20.05.2014
Annexure A6 TRUE COPY OF THE REGISTRATION CERTIFICATE
OF 'ELADI THRILL' OF THE 1ST APPELLANT
WITH REFERENCE NO. 2081524 DATED
09.06.2015
ANNEXURE A28 Indo-Pharma Pharmaceutical Works Ltd. vs.
Citadel Fine Pharmaceuticals Ltd. -
MANU/TN/1178/1998
ANNEXURE A7 M/s Kandamkulathi Ayurveda Vaidyasala (P)
Ltd. vs. Regional Director and others -
WP(C) No.:31973 of 2017
ANNEXURE A8 Ultratech Cement Limited and Anr. vs.
Dalmia Cement Bharat Limited - NOTICE OF
MOTION (L) NO. 141 OF 2014 IN SUIT NO. 42
OF 2014
ANNEXURE A10 Pernod Ricard India Private Limited vs.
Karanveer Singh Chhabra - 2025 ICO 1983
ANNEXURE A11 Nandhini Deluxe vs. Karnataka Co-Operative
Milk Producers Federation Limited - 2018
ICO 1272
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:45:-
2026:KER:86708
ANNEXURE A12 Nestle India Limited vs. Mood Hospitality
Private Limited - 2010 ICO 2185
ANNEXURE A13 S.B.L. Ltd. vs. The Himalaya Drug Co. -
FAO (OS)301 of 1996
ANNEXURE A14 Shoban Salim Thakur vs. Chaitanya Arora
and others - COMMERCIAL SUIT (L) NO. 18197
OF 2025 WITH LEAVE PETITION (L) NO.18257
OF 2025
ANNEXURE A15 Registrar of Trade Marks vs. Ashok Chandra
Rakhit Limited - 1955 ICO 88
ANNEXURE A17 Lupin Limited vs. Johnson and Johnson -
2014 ICO 3467
ANNEXURE A20 Uniply Industries Limited vs. Unicorn
Plywood Private Limited - 2001 ICO 319
ANNEXURE A22 Wander Limited and Another vs. Antox India
Private Limited - 1990 ICO 369
ANNEXURE A23 Schering Corporation and Others. vs. Alkem
Laboratories Ltd. - 2008 SCC OnLine Del
760
ANNEXURE A24 Reckitt and Colman of India Limited vs.
Medicross Pharmaceuticals Private Limited
- LNIND 1992 BOM 252
ANNEXURE A25 Aristo Pharmaceuticals Limited vs.
Wockhardt Limited - 1999 ICO 805
ANNEXURE A26 Apex Laboratories Ltd. vs. Zuventus Health
Care Ltd. - 2006 SCC OnLine Mad 1238
ANNEXURE A19 J.R. Kapoor vs. Micronix India - Appeal
(civil) 2253 of 1994
ANNEXURE A18 F. Hoffmann La Roche and Company Limited
vs. Geoffrey Manners and Company Private
Limited - 1969 ICO 395
ANNEXURE A9 Sana Herbals Private Limited vs. Mohsin
Dehlvi and Another - FAO (COMM) 77/2025
ANNEXURE A21 Regency Sanitary Ware Pvt. Ltd. Vs.
Madhusudan Industries Ltd. -
MANU/GJ/1186/2001
ANNEXURE A16 Cadila Health Care Limited vs. Cadila
Pharmaceuticals Limited - 2001 ICO 237
ANNEXURE A27 Acme Pharmaceuticals vs. Torrent
Pharmaceuticals Ltd. - 2010 SCC OnLine Guj
69
CNR: KLHC010760812026
Coml.A. No.4 of 2026
-:46:-
2026:KER:86708
RESPONDENT ANNEXURES
Annexure B1 Wander Ltd. v. Antox India (P) Ltd.,
Annexure B2 Pernod Ricard India Pvt. Ltd. v. Karanveer
Singh Chhabra
Annexure B3 Gujarat Bottling Co. Ltd. v. Coca Cola Co.
Annexure B4 Kaviraj Pandit Durga Dutt Sharma v.
Navaratna Pharmaceutical Laboratories
Annexure B5 Amritdhara Pharmacy v. Satya Deo Gupta
Annexure B6 Corn Products Refining Co. v. Shangrila
Food Products Ltd.,
Annexure B7 Cadila Health Care Ltd. v. Cadila
Pharmaceuticals Ltd.,
Annexure B8 FDC Limited Vs. Docsuggest Healthcare
Services Pvt. Ltd. and Ors.
Annexure B9 Renaissance Hotel Holdings Inc. v. B.
Vijaya Sai
Annexure B10 Rana Steels Vs. Ran India Steels Pvt. Ltd.
Annexure B11 Rajeev K.P. v. Unais K.K.,
Annexure B12 Khadi and Village Industries Commission v.
Khadi Design Council of India
Annexure B13 Pankaj Goel v. Dabur India Ltd.,
Annexure B14 Godfrey Phillips India Ltd. v. Girnar Food
and Beverages (P) Ltd.,
Annexure B15 Heinz Italia v. Dabur India Ltd.,
Annexure B16 Automatic Electric Ltd. v. R.K. Dhawan
Annexure B17 S. Syed Mohideen v. P. Sulochana Bai
Annexure B18 Laxmikant V. Patel v. Chetanbhai Shah
Annexure B19 Wockhardt Ltd. v. Torrent Pharmaceuticals
Ltd.,
Annexure B20 Midas Hygiene Industries (P) Ltd. v.
Sudhir Bhatia
Annexure B21 Taste Box v. JSF Holdings Pvt. Ltd.,
Annexure B22 ITC Limited Vs. Whole Leaf Tobacco Venture
Pvt. Ltd. and Ors
Annexure B23 Sanjay Soya Pvt. Ltd. v. Narayani Trading
Co.,
Annexure B24 Arun Krishnan M. v. Cure and Care
Therapeutics,