SRI. B K NAGESH GOWDA vs B R NAGARAJ

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019



IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU


TH
DATED THIS THE 30 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR

REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 800 OF 2019 (DEC/INJ)

BETWEEN:

SRI. B.K. NAGESH GOWDA
S/O LATE SRI. B. KALLE GOWDA
AGED ABOUT 76 YEARS
EX-MILITARY AND AGRICULTURIST
R/AT. BIDARAHALLI VILLAGE AND POST
MUDIGERE TALUK
CHIKKAMAGALURU – 577 101.






…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. A MADHUSUDHANA RAO, ADVOCATE)

AND:


B.R. NAGARAJ
DEAD BY HIS LRS

1. SMT. RATHNAMMA
W/O LATE B.R. NAGARAJ
S/O LATE B.K. RAMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.

2. SRI .B.N. SUDHEER
S/O LATE B.R. NAGARAJ
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS.

BOTH ARE R/AT
BIDARAHALLI VILLAGE AND POST
MUDIGERE TALUK
CHIKKAMAGALURU – 577 101.

…RESPONDENTS
(VIDE ORDER DATED: 21.06.2022
NOTICE TO R-1 & R-2 IS H/S)

THIS RSA IS FILED U/S.100 OF CPC AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND
DECREE DATED 02.01.2019 PASSED IN RA.NO.77/2018 ON THE FILE OF




Digitally
signed by
VANDANA S
Location:
High Court of
Karnataka

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


THE II ADDL.DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, CHIKKAMAGALURU
DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND FILED AGAINST THE ORDER DATED
02.08.2018 PASSED IN C.MISC.NO.01/2017 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR
CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, MUDIGERE DISMISSING THE PETITION FILED
UNDER ORDER 20 RULE 12 AND 18 R/W SEC.151 OF CPC FOR
DECLARATION,POSSESSION AND MESNE PROFITS.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR

ORAL JUDGMENT
The appellant was the petitioner in C.Mis.No.1/2017 filed by
him under Order XX Rules 12 and 18 CPC before the Senior Civil
Judge and JMFC, Mudigere (for short “the Trial Court”) seeking
recovery of mesne profits and for other reliefs. In the said
proceedings, the respondents remained ex-parte and did not
contest the said proceedings which culminated in the impugned
judgment and decree dated 02.08.2018, whereby the said
C.Mis.No.1/2017 was dismissed by the Trial Court. Aggrieved by
the said Judgment and Decree, the appellant preferred an appeal
in R.A.No.77/2018 before the II Additional District and Sessions
Judge, Chikkamagaluru (For short “the First Appellate Court”),
which came to be dismissed as not maintainable by the First
Appellate Court. Aggrieved by the impugned judgment and decree

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


of the Trial Court and First Appellate Court, the appellant is before
this Court by way of the present appeal which was admitted on
30.10.2026 to consider the following substantial questions of law:
"1) Whether the Trial Court was justified in dismissing the
petition in C.Mis.No.1/2017 filed by the appellant without
considering the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court
in the case of Nemichand Tavanappa Kudachi v.
Jinnappa Mahadev Kudachi - ILR 1974 Karnataka 661 ?
2) Whether the First Appellate Court was justified in dismissing
the appeal in R.A. No.77/2018 filed by the appellant as not
maintainable without appreciating the provisions contained
in Order XX Rule 12(2) CPC?"
2. Heard learned counsel for the appellant and perused
the material on record.
3. The respondent having been served with notice, has
chosen to remain unrepresented and not contested the appeal.
4. A perusal of the material on record will indicate that it
is an undisputed fact that the appellant instituted a suit in
O.S.No.130/2006 against the respondent for declaration of title,
possession and mesne profits in relation to the suit schedule
immovable property. The said suit having been contested by the

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


respondent-defendant, the Trial Court proceeded to pass the
judgment and decree dated 10.12.2010 decreeing the suit of the
appellant-plaintiff against the respondent-defendant by holding as
under:
“
The plaintiff has filed this suit against the defendants
for declaration in respect of "A" schedule property, for
possession of "B" schedule property from the defendants,
for enquiry into past and future mesne profits and also for
the costs of the suit.
2. Brief facts of the case as stated in the plaint is
that:
The plaintiff is the absolute owner of "A" schedule
property acquired the same under partition deed dated 1-5-
1972. Since then he was in possession and enjoyment of
the same by growing coffee. Though the defendant has no
right, interest whatsoever over the plaint schedule property,
but he has encroached an extent of 0.06 guntas in the first
week of May 2004 when he was away from the suit
schedule property due to his ill-health. The encroached
portion is described as "B" schedule in the plaint. After
coming to know the said encroachment, when the plaintiff
has questioned the act of the defendants, but the defendant
has denied and claimed as it is belonging to him. The
defendant has stated that after survey is conducted and if
the land is found belonging to the plaintiff, then he will give
back the possession. Accordingly, in the month of March

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


2005 the plaintiff has got surveyed the suit schedule
property and requested the defendant to vacate and hand
over the "B" schedule property. Inspite of several
panchayath held in the village, the defendant has not
handed over the possession of "B" schedule property.
Hence, without any alternative, he was forced to file the suit
for the above said reliefs.
3. In response to the summons issued by this Court,
the defendant appeared before this Court through his
counsel and filed his written statement. Wherein, he has
generally denied the fact that the plaintiff is the absolute
owner in possession of "A" schedule property having
acquired the same under partition deed dated 1-5-1972. He
has also denied that he has encroached "B" schedule
property in the month of May 2004 by illegally and he had
promised to vacate the same after survey. He has also
denied that, inspite of several requests and demands and
also panchayath held, he has not keep up his promise and
delivered the possession. He has further contended that, he
is in possession of the property on the western side of the
plaintiff's property which fell to his share under registered
partition deed dated 5-2-1988. Since then, he is in
possession and enjoyment of the same. He has been
enjoying "B" schedule property openly, continuously and
uninterruptedly as to the knowledge of the plaintiff and his
predecessors in title for over 35 to 45 years as owner and
hence, he has perfected his title by way of adverse
possession of "B" schedule property. The plaintiff cannot
claim any right over "B" schedule property as he or his

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


predecessors in title were never in possession and
enjoyment of "B" schedule property. He has planted robosta
coffee plants, silver oak and jungle wood shade trees in "B"
schedule property and his predecessors in title have been
harvesting the coffee crop in the "B" schedule property,
even prior to 1970. There is a live fence bifurcating "A" &
"B" schedule properties. This suit is barred by limitation.
There is no cause of action to file this suit. The Court fee
paid is insufficient. Hence, this suit is liable to be dismissed
with exemplary costs.

4. In view of the above rival pleadings the following
issues have been framed:
1. Does plaintiff proves that he is the absolute
owner of the "A" schedule property?
2. Whether the plaintiff proves that the defendant
has encroached the "B" schedule property?
3. Whether the defendant proves that, he has
perfected his title over "B" schedule property
by way of adverse possession having
enjoyment of the same openly continuously,
uninterruptedly to the knowledge of the
plaintiff and his predecessor in title for over 35
to 45 years?
4. Whether the suit is barred by limitation?
5. What decree of order?

6. In order to prove his claim the plaintiff got
examined himself as PW.1 and he has produced 10
documents and got marked as Ex.P.1 to 10. On the other

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


hand, the defendant got examined himself as DW.1 and he
has also produced 16 documents and got marked as Ex.D.1
to 16. In this suit, at the instance of the plaintiffs a taluk
surveyor has been appointed as Court commissioner. After
his local investigation, he has submitted his report and
sketch. The said Court commissioner has been summoned
and got examined before this Court as CW.1 and the report
and sketch of the commissioner have been got marked as
Ex.C.1 to 4.

7. I have heard the arguments of both side and I
have perused the records.

8. On appreciation of pleadings, oral and
documentary evidence and also contentions raised by both
the parties, my findings on the above Issues are:
Issue NO.1: In the affirmative;
ISSUE NO.1: In the affirmative
Issue NO.2: In affirmative;
Issue NO.4: In the negative;
Issue NO.3: In the negative;
Issue NO.5: As per final order,
for the following:
REASONS
9. In order to prove his claim, the plaintiff during the
course of his evidence, has filed an affidavit in the form of
chief-examination as PW.1. In his affidavit he has reiterated
all the averments made in the course of plaint. In support of
his oral evidence he has produced the certified copy of the
registered partition deed dated 1-5-1972, RTC extract,

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


mutation register extract, Record of Right, Index of land,
revenue sketch, haddu bastu sketch, copy of the notice and
got marked as Ex.P.1 to 10.

10. On the other hand, in order to dis-prove the claim
of the plaintiff and to prove his defence the defendant during
the course of his evidence, he has filed an affidavit in the
form of chief-examination as DW.1. In his affidavit he has
reiterated all the defence as taken in his written statement.
In support of his oral evidence, he has produced the RTC
extract, mutation register extract, photographs alongwith
certified copy of the partition deed, copy of the plaint,
endorsement and acknowledgment issued by the PSI of
Mudigere police and got marked as Ex.D.1 to 17.

11. The learned counsel for the plaintiff during the
course of his arguments, has submitted that, the defendant
admits that he is in possession of "B" schedule property,
and he is claiming adverse possession. But, the defendant
has denied the ownership of the plaintiff. When such being
the case, the question of acquiring title by way of adverse
possession in respect of "B" schedule property, does not
arises. The defendant has also not produced any single
document to prove his possession over "B" schedule
property since 30 to 40 years. On the other hand, the Court
commissioner has clearly identified the encroachment made
by the defendant in the "A" schedule property. When the
defendant has not proved the adverse possession, his
possession become illegal. The plaintiff has produced the
registered partition deed and subsequent revenue records

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


and proved the fact that the entire "A" schedule property is
belonging to him. Hence, the oral evidence of PW.1 is
corroborated with these documentary evidence and
succeeded to prove his title and also encroachment of "B"
schedule property made by the defendant. Hence, the
plaintiff is entitled for the relief of declaration and also
possession of "B" schedule property.

12. The learned counsel for the defendant has
vehemently argued that though the plaintiff has specifically
stated that, in the first week of May 2004 the defendant has
encroached "B" schedule property, but absolutely there is
no evidence before this Court to substantiate his claim. On
the other hand, PW.1. during the course of his cross-
examination he has admitted that since from the date of the
partition he is in possession and enjoyment of the property,
then the question of alleged encroachment made by the
defendant, particularly in the month of May 2004 does not
arises. Moreover, if the defendant really encroached the
property of the plaintiff, then why he encroached only 0.06
guntas. He would have encroached entire property of the
plaintiff. Even as per the commissioner report, the coffee
plants existing in the "B" schedule property are aged more
than 20 - 30 years. There is a fence in between "A" & "B"
schedule properties since several years. Since several
years the defendant is in possession and enjoyment of "B"
schedule property. Hence, the defendant has perfected his
title by way of adverse possession. Hence, the plaintiff is

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


not entitled for any relief as prayed for in the suit. Hence, he
requests to dismiss the suit with costs.

13. In view of these rival submissions made by both
the parties, on perusal of the entire materials on record,
which clearly indicates that the plaintiff is claiming land
bearing sy.No.58/7A to an extent of 1 acre 23 guntas as the
same was acquired under registered partition deed dated 1-
5-1972. The defendant in his written statement has disputed
the title and also possession of entire "A" schedule property.
Hence, it is for the plaintiff to prove that he is the absolute
owner in possession of entire "A" schedule property,
acquired the same under registered partition deed as
alleged by him.

14. In order to prove this issue, in support of his oral
evidence, the plaintiff has produced the certified copy of the
registered partition deed dated 1-5-1972 and subsequent
revenue documents. Ex.P.1 is the certified copy of the
partition deed discloses that this suit schedule property was
allotted to the share of the plaintiff alongwith other
properties. Based on these registered documents, the name
of the plaintiff got mutated as per Ex.P.4 mutation register
extract. Subsequently, the name of the plaintiff is reflected
in RTC. Ex.P.2 RTC extract for the year 2003-04 discloses
the name of the plaintiff in respect of entire "A" schedule
property. Moreover, Ex.P.5 Record of Right, Ex.P.6 Index of
land are also discloses the absolute right of predecessor of
the plaintiff and subsequently during partition, the suit
schedule property allotted to the share of the plaintiff.

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


Ex.P.7 revenue sketch, Ex.P.8 haddu bastu sketch are also
locate "A" schedule property. Hence, all these documents
clearly establish the fact that, the plaintiff has acquired valid
title and possession of "A" schedule property and he was in
possession and enjoyment of the same.

15. Though the defendant has generally disputed the
title and possession of the entire "A" schedule property by
the plaintiff, but during the course of his evidence he is not
claiming any title over this suit schedule Sy No.58. He has
also produced partition deed and subsequent revenue
documents as per Ex.D.1, 2 and 9. As per these
documents, the defendant is the owner in possession of
land bearing Sy.No.56/p7 measuring 0.32 guntas. The
plaintiff is also not claiming this land which is adjacent to the
suit schedule property. Hence, in respect of title of "A"
schedule property is concerned, the oral evidence of PW.1
is corroborated with these documentary evidence and
succeeded to prove that the plaintiff has acquired "A"
schedule property through his family partition and he was in
possession and enjoyment of the same. Moreover, in this
suit the major dispute is about encroachment of "B"
schedule property. Admittedly, the defendant is in
possession of "B" schedule property. Whether the
defendant has encroached "B" schedule property in the
month of May 2004 or earlier, it is to be decided while
discussing on issue No.2. But, in respect of title of entire "A"
schedule property including this "B" schedule property is
concerned, the defendant has not specifically disputed the

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


same. Moreover, the plaintiff has also produced the
registered partition deed and subsequent revenue
documents and succeeded to prove that, he is the absolute
owner in possession of "A" schedule property. In view of the
above reasons, I answer issue No.1 in affirmative.

ISSUE NO.2 & 3
16. Since these two issues are inter-linked with each
other, I proceed to discuss together to avoid repetition of
facts.
17. In respect of encroachment is concerned, there is
no dispute that the defendant is in possession of "B"
schedule property, which is part and parcel of "A" schedule
property, which is belonging to the plaintiff. Though the
defendant is claiming possession over this particular
property since 35 to 45 years, but he is not claiming title,
which is acquired under any title deeds. But, he is also
claiming adverse possession. Hence, in this suit, the major
dispute is, as to when the defendant has encroached the
property in question. Because, according to the plaintiff,
particularly in the month of May 2004 the defendant has
encroached. But, the defendant has specifically denied the
same and contended that he has been in possession and
enjoyment of the same since more than 35 to 45 years.
Hence, it is for the plaintiff to prove that, in the month of
May 2004 the defendant has encroached the "B" schedule
property. If the plaintiff discharge his initial burden, then the
burden shift on the defendant to show that he has been in

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


possession and enjoyment of "B" schedule property since
more than 35 to 45 years.

18. In order to prove these issues, no doubt that,
during the course of his chief-examination, the plaintiff has
deposed to the same facts as stated in his plaint. But, he
has not produced any documentary evidence. Though he
has specifically deposed that when he came to know the
encroachment he had questioned the defendant. The
defendant had promised to give back possession, if it is
found that the said land belonging to the plaintiff, after the
survey is conducted. But, there is no material to show that
immediately after encroachment, particularly in the year
2004 itself, the plaintiff has questioned the defendant. Even
he has not lodged any complaint to the police. Even in
support of his oral evidence, he has not examined any of
the neighbouring land owners. Though he has stated that,
due to his ill-health he was away from the suit schedule
property, but he has not produced any medical certificates
to show that, during particular period he was suffering from
ill-health. Accordingly, he was hospitalised. Hence, except
his self explanatory oral evidence, absolutely there is no
cogent evidence to prove that the defendant has
encroached this "B" schedule property, particularly in the
first week of May 2004.

19. On the other hand, according to the defendant,
he has been in possession and enjoyment over the "B"
schedule property since more than 35 to 45 years. But,
there is no specific pleading as to how he came to be in

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


possession of this "B" schedule property, which is belonging
to the plaintiff. There is no whisper as to whether he has
encroached the property at particular time or whether
somebody had put him in possession of the said property.
Even there is no explanation on what capacity, he is in
possession. Moreover, though the defendant is claiming
possession since more than 35 to 45 years, but he has not
produced any single document to prove his physical
possession since such long time. Hence, the defendant has
also not produced any documentary evidence to prove that
he has been in possession and enjoyment over this "B"
schedule property since more than 35 to 45 years as
claimed in the suit.

20. However, the learned counsel for the defendant
has mainly relied upon photos and also commissioner
report and his evidence to show the age of the coffee plants
and trees existing in the lands of the defendant and plaintiff,
which are similar as to the effect that, since several years
the defendant is in possession. Admittedly, in both the
properties, both of them have planted coffee plants. PW.1
during the course of his cross-examination, he has admitted
that the coffee plants existing in the land of the defendant is
aged about 20 - 30 years. CW.1, who is the Court
commissioner, during the course of his cross-examination,
he has specifically admitted that, there is a live fence and a
trench existing between "A" & "B" schedule properties.
Beyond the said fence, towards the property of the
defendant, the coffee garden is existing at little upper level.

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


There is barbed wire fence, which is embedded in the stem
of the trees existing in the fence. These pieces of evidence
of commissioner clearly indicates that, "A" & "B" schedule
properties are bifurcated by a trench and also a fence. The
said fence is existing since more than 20 years. The trees
existing in the fence since aged more than 25 years, barbed
wire embedded in the trunk. These plants and trees indicate
that, the defendant has been in possession and enjoyment
of "B" schedule property since more than 20 years. If really
the defendant has encroached this particular portion in the
first week of May 2004, definitely this live fence would not
been existing. These spot circumstances clearly indicates
that, the defendant has been in possession and enjoyment
over the "B" schedule property since more than 20 or 25
years. Though the defendant has not produced any material
to show that he has been in possession since more than 35
to 45 years, but as per the evidence of the commissioner
and admission made by the plaintiff, which clearly indicates
that the defendant has been in possession and enjoyment
over the "B" schedule property since more than 20 or 25
years.
21. In respect of claim of adverse possession is
concerned, according to the defendant since he has been in
possession and enjoyment over "B" schedule property since
more than 35 to 45 years, he has perfected his title by
adverse possession. But, as I have already observed that,
absolutely there is no specific pleadings or oral evidence as
to how and particularly when he has entered into the
possession over the "B" schedule property. Whether he has

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


encroached or he is put in possession over this property.
Even there is no pleadings or evidence, when his
possession has become hostile to the interest of true owner.

22. Moreover, as rightly pointed out by the learned
counsel for the plaintiff, first of all, the defendant is not
admitting the ownership of the plaintiff. When he is not
admitting, the plaintiff is the true owner, he cannot claim
adverse possession. Though he has succeeded to prove
that since 20 to 25 years he has been in possession over
this "B" schedule property, but there is no pleadings or
evidence to show that his possession is open, to the
knowledge of the plaintiff. Though he is claiming possession
since several years, but admittedly he has not paid tax to
the concerned authority. He has not made any attempts to
get the revenue entries in his name. He has not produced
any single document to show that he has been enjoying the
property adverse to the interest of true owner. Even
according to the plaintiff, in the year 2005 when he got
surveyed "A" schedule property, he came to know the exact
encroachment made by the defendant. Till then he was not
aware about particular extent of encroachment made by the
defendant. The defendant has also not produced any
material before this Court to show that the plaintiff was fully
aware about his encroachment and possession over this
particular portion.

23. It is necessary to note here that, in one stretch,
the defendant is claiming that, since he has been in
possession, since several years, he has become absolute

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


owner of the ‘B’ suit schedule property. In another stretch
he is claiming adverse possession. Hence, the defendant
himself is not sure on which capacity he is in possession of
"B" schedule property. No doubt that, the defendant can
take alternative plea of adverse possession. But, there must
be specific pleadings to the effect that, from particular date
or period his possession has become hostile to the interest
of true owner. But, in this case, as I have already observed
that, absolutely there is no pleadings from which particular
date or period his possession has become adverse to the
interest of the true owner. Hence, the defendant has not
produced any material before this Court to prove any of the
ingredients of principle of adverse possession. It is well
settled principle of law that, mere possession for long time
does not convert permissive possession into adverse
possession, unless it is proved that person in possession
asserted an adverse title to the property to the knowledge of
the true owner for a period of 12 years or more. Hence, the
defendant has utterly failed to prove that he has perfected
his title by way of adverse possession over the "B" schedule
property.

24. On the other hand, though the plaintiff failed to
prove that the defendant has encroached "B" schedule
property in the first week of May 2004 itself, but he has
succeeded to prove that the possession of the defendant is
illegal and unlawful. When the defendant has failed to prove
that he has perfected his title by way of adverse possession
over "B" schedule property, his possession become un-

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


lawful possession. Hence, he is bound to deliver the same
to the true owner. In view of the above reasons, I answer
issue No.2 in affirmative and issue No.3 in negative.

ISSUE NO.4:
25. The defendant has taken another defence that
this suit is barred by limitation. According to the defendant,
the plaintiff and his predecessors were never in possession
of "B" schedule property, immediately 12 years before filing
this suit. Hence, this suit is barred by limitation. But, all the
documents including partition deed and revenue records
discloses the name of the plaintiff in respect of entire "A"
schedule property. Though the defendant has succeeded to
prove that since 20 to 25 years he has been in possession,
but, he has failed to prove that his possession is within the
knowledge of the plaintiff. On the other hand, the plaintiff
has specifically deposed that in the month of March 2005
when he got surveyed this "A" schedule property, he came
to know that the defendant has encroached the particular
extent i.e., 0.06 guntas of land. Therefore, from the date of
the knowledge, this suit is filed within three years, for
possession. Though the plaintiff has failed to prove that, in
the first week of May 2004 the defendant has encroached
this "B" schedule property, but this encroachment came to
the knowledge of the plaintiff in the year 2004.
Subsequently, in the year 2005, the plaintiff came to know,
the particular portion has been encroached. Accordingly,
from the date of the knowledge, this suit is in time. Hence,
the defendant has failed to prove that this suit is barred by

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


limitation. In view of the above reasons, I answer this issue
in negative.

ISSUE NO.5:
26. When the plaintiff has succeeded to prove that he
is the absolute owner of "A" schedule property and the
defendant has encroached "B" schedule property and the
possession of the defendant is illegal and unlawful, the
plaintiff is entitled for the relief of declaration and also
possession of "B" schedule property.

27. When the plaintiff proves that the possession of
the "B" schedule property is wrongful possession, the
plaintiff is also entitled for current and future mesne profits.
But, he is not entitled for past mesne profits. However,
enquiry is to be conducted in a separate proceedings in
order to ascertain the current and future mesne profits.
Hence, the plaintiff is entitled for relief of declaration,
possession and mesne profits from the date of the suit till
the date of delivery of possession of "B" schedule property
to the plaintiff. Hence, I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
The suit of the plaintiff is hereby partly decreed
with costs. It is hereby declared that the plaintiff is the
absolute owner of "A" schedule property. The
defendant is directed to quit and deliver the possession
of "B" schedule property in favour of the plaintiff,
within three months, from the date of this judgment and
decree. Otherwise, the plaintiff can take possession
through this Court, in accordance with law. The plaintiff

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


is entitled for current and future mesne profits from the
date of the suit till get the possession of "B" schedule
property.
Draw the decree accordingly.”

5. The aforesaid judgment and decree had attained
finality and become conclusive and clearly binding upon the
respondent, whose appeal in R.A.No.21/2010 was dismissed by
the First Appellate Court on 09.10.2014 and no further appeal was
preferred by the respondent-defendant. Under these
circumstances, having regard to the decree passed by the Trial
Court in O.S.No.130/2006 holding that the appellant-plaintiff is
entitled to mesne profits and directing the respondent-defendant to
pay mesne profits in favour of the appellant-plaintiff, the appellant
instituted the instant proceedings in C.Mis.No.1/2017 invoking
Order XX Rules 12 and 18 CPC. According to the appellant, the
appellant took possession of the suit schedule property from the
respondent in terms of the decree passed in OS No.130/2006 on
26.03.2017 in Execution No.29/2015. Under these circumstances,
it was contended that having regard to the decree for mesne profits
passed in favour of the appellant-plaintiff, who would be entitled to

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


mesne profits from the date of the suit which was instituted on
35.05.2006 till the appellant took possession of the suit schedule
property from the respondent i.e., on 26.03.2017, the appellant
contended that the respondent would be liable to pay mesne profits
to the appellant in a total sum of Rs.6,22,600/- and since the
respondent did not do so, the aforesaid C.Mis.No.1/2017 was
instituted by the appellant against the respondent. In the said
C.Mis.No.1/2017, the respondent remained ex-parte and did not
contest the proceedings and the Trial Court framed the following
points for consideration:
"1) Whether the petitioner proves that from the 'B' schedule
property respondents have an income of Rs.56,600/- per
year?
2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for mesne profits?
3) What Order?"
6. After hearing the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
petitioner examined himself as PW-1 and documentary evidence at
Exs.P-1 to P-6 were marked, but the respondent-defendant who
did not file statement of objections to the miscellaneous petition did

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


not cross-examine PW-1 nor adduced any defence evidence in the
said proceedings.
7. Before the Trial Court, it was specifically contended by
the petitioner that in the light of the judgment of the Division Bench
in the case of Nemichand Tavanappa Kudachi v. Jinnappa
Mahadev Kudachi - ILR 1974 Karnataka 661 , it was necessary to
appoint a Court Commissioner to determine mesne profits, despite
which the Trial Court proceeded to dismiss the petition filed by the
petitioner. Aggrieved by the said Judgment and Decree of the Trial
Court dismissing C.Mis.No.1/2017, the appellant filed an appeal in
R.A.No.77/2018, in which the Registry of the First Appellate Court
raised objection regarding maintainability of the appeal on the
ground that the order of the Trial Court was arising out of
C.Mis.No.1/2017 and not a regular original suit and as such, the
appeal was not maintainable. The appellant contended before the
First Appellate Court that in the light of the provisions contained in
Order XX Rule 12 (2) and (3) CPC, the Judgment and Decree
passed in C.Mis.No.1/2017 was maintainable by way of an appeal
and as such, the office objection deserves to be overruled.
However, the First Appellate Court proceeded to pass the

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


impugned judgment and decree dismissing the appeal as not
maintainable, aggrieved by which the appellant is before this Court
by way of the present appeal which was admitted to consider the
aforesaid substantial questions of law.
8. Though the respondent was served, he remained
unrepresented and has not chosen to contest the appeal.
Re. Substantial Questions of law No.1 and 2:
9. A perusal of the material on record will indicate that the
Trial Court came to the conclusion that the appellant-plaintiff is not
entitled to mesne profits as sought for by him in the proceedings. In
this context, it is relevant to state that despite referring to the
judgment of the Division Bench in Nemichand's case supra , the
Trial Court clearly committed an error in not appointing a Court
Commissioner to determine the mesne profits payable by the
respondent to the appellant, which had been awarded in favour of
the appellant by the Trial Court vide judgment and decree dated
10.12.2010 in O.S.130/2006 and confirmed by the First Appellate
Court vide judgment and decree dated 09.10.2014 in

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


R.A.No.21/2011, which have attained finality and become
conclusive and binding upon the respondent.
10. In this regard, in the case of Nemichand Tavanappa
Kudachi v. Jinnappa Mahadev Kudachi - ILR 1974 Karnataka
661 , the Division Bench of this Court held as under:
“ 1. This is an appeal by the plaintiff against the final
decree passed in Special Suit No. 79/51 on the file of the
Civil Judge, Belgaum. The plaintiff brought the suit against
the defendants for partition and separate possession of his
one-half share in the suit properties. The suit was instituted
on 15th August, 1951 and decreed by the trial Court on 30th
November, 1953. The matter came up in appeal before this
Court which affirmed the decree of the trial Court on 28th
October, 1960. According to the preliminary decree in the
suit the plaintiff was declared as being entitled to a one-half
share in the suit properties and also for mesne profits from
defendants 1, 2 and 7 from date of suit. The mesne profits
were directed to he ascertained on an application under
Order 20 Rule 12 C.P.C.
2. It is necessary to observe that in a partition suit the
proper direction to give is to direct the co-owners in
possession to render an account of the profits they have
received. However, we are not concerned in this appeal with
the correctness of the nature of direction given.
3. After disposal of the appeal by this Court, the
plaintiff applied before the Court below for ascertainment of

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


mesne profits from 15th August, 1951 to 30th October, 1962.
According to the plaintiff-appellant for the aforesaid period of
accounting which is about 11 years, his share of mesne
profits is about Rs. 63,000. The learned Civil Judge
determined the mesne profits payable for the said period as
only Rs. 5,003.14 ps. and accordingly passed a final decree
for the said amount. Aggrieved by the said decree, the
plaintiff has preferred this appeal.
4. The suit properties consist of agricultural lands
comprising of lands on which Paddy Ragi, Hurali, Chillies,
Potato etc. are grown, besides mango-groves and grass-
lands. Some of the lands were in the khas possession of
defendants 1, 2 and 7 while the rest were leased to tenants.
Defendants 1, 2 and 7 did not produce any accounts
maintained by them in regard to the income from the suit
properties. Oral evidence was adduced by the parties
regarding the income. Yield notifications and notifications
regarding the market-rates of agricultural commodities were
also produced and on the basis of the said evidence the Civil
Judge determined the mesne profits.
5. We have persued the order of the Court below
which is highly unsatisfactory. The Court below ought to
have appointed a Commissioner to take an account of the
mesne profits as the matter is not so simple. It involves the
taking of accounts in respect of a number of lands exceeding
in extent, over 100 acres. The period of accounting is nearly
12 years. Where there is a preliminary decree for taking of
accounts of income which the parties in possession are liable
to account or pay as mesne profits what the Court ought to

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


do is to appoint a Commissioner to take an account of the
profits for the period of accounting. It should give clear
directions with regard to the mode in which the accounting
has to be taken or vouched. The accounting may be on the
basis of actual realisation or on the basis of what the
accounting party might have realised as a prudent manager,
i.e., on the basis of mesne profits.
6. In the instant case, the direction in the preliminary
decree is to pay mesne profits. Therefore, the direction to the
Commissioner should be to taken on account of the profits
on the basis which defendants 1, 2 and 7 as prudent
managers might have realised during the period of
accounting.
7. The absence of such an accounting by a
Commissioner appointed in the case for that purpose has
placed both sides as also the Court at a disadvantage.
Before the Commissioner the parties have to lead evidence.
After the Commissioner files his report, the Court should give
opportunity to the parties to file their objections. The
Commissioner has to make a further report with reference to
those objections raised by the parties. Thus the controversy
between the parties will be narrowed down. When there is a
proper and full report made by the Commissioner, it will be
sufficient for the Court to decide the points in controversy.
This is the normal practice that is followed by Courts in suits
for partition or suits for accounting where one party is made
liable to account for the profits.
8. As already stated, the failure to follow this normal
practice by the Court below in the instant case has in our

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


opinion, vitiated the entire proceedings as it is extremely
difficult for this Court sitting in appeal to determine as to what
is the mesne profits to which the plaintiff is entitled to get
from defendants 1, 2 and 7. The learned counsel for the
parties are also agreeable for our setting aside the decree of
the Court below and remanding the matter with a direction to
appoint a Commissioner as indicated in this order.
9. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed; the final decree
passed by the Court below is set aside and the matter is
remanded to the Court below for a fresh disposal in the light
of the observations made in this order.
The appellant is entitled to the refund of court-fee paid
on the memorandum of appeal. Costs of the appeal will be
costs in the cause.”

11. As can be seen from the aforesaid judgment, when the
Division Bench of this Court has held that in the event it is not
possible to determine the mesne profits payable to a party,
pursuant to a decree of a Civil Court, especially in relation to
agricultural lands, it would be necessary/essential to appoint a
Commissioner to determine the mesne profits.
12. In the instant case, the Trial Court despite having
referred to the aforesaid Judgment, clearly fell in error in dismissing
the petition filed by the appellant without appreciating that the

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


pleadings and evidence of the appellant had been unchallenged,
uncontroverted and unimpeached before the Trial Court by the
respondents, who had remained ex-parte and not contested the
proceedings nor cross-examined PW-1 or adduced any defence
evidence. Under these circumstances the impugned judgment and
decree passed by the Trial Court being contrary to the facts and
law, the same deserves to be set aside.
13. Before the First Appellate Court, the Registry of the
First Appellate Court raised objections regarding maintainability of
the appeal on the ground that the proceedings before the Trial
Court was not a original suit and no decree was passed by the Trial
Court in this regard.
14. In this context, it would be profitable to extract the
definition of decree under Section 2(2) CPC and Order XX Rule XII
Order XX Rule 12(1) (b-a), (c) and (2) of CPC:
" Section 2(2) : "decree" means the formal expression of an
adjudication which, so far as regards the Court expressing it,
conclusively determines the rights of the parties with regard
to all or any of the matters in controversy in the suit and may
be either preliminary or final. It shall be deemed to include

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


the rejection of a plaint and the determination of any question
within Section 144, but shall not include -
(a) any adjudication from which an appeal lies as an appeal
from an order, or
(b) any order of dismissal for default."
" Order XX Rule 12 CPC: Decree for possession and
mesne profits. - (1) Where a suit is for the recovery of
possession of immovable property and for rent or mesne
profits, the Court may pass a decree:
(a) xxxx
(b)xxxx
(ba) For the mesne profits or directing an inquiry as to such
mesne profits;
(c) directing an inquiry as to rent or mesne profits from the
institution of the suit until, -
(i) the delivery of possession to the decree-holder,
(ii) the relinquishment of possession by the judgment-
debtor with notice to the decree-holder through the
Court, or
(iii) the expiration of three years from the date of the
decree, whichever event first occurs.

- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


(2) Where an inquiry is directed under clause (b) or clause
(c), a final decree in respect of the rent or mesne profits shall
be passed in accordance with the result of such inquiry.”
15. As can be seen from the aforesaid provision, while
passing a decree for recovery of possession of immovable property
and for rent or mesne profits, the Trial Court / the Civil Court would
be entitled to pass a decree for mesne profits or directing an
enquiry as to such mesne profits in terms of Order XX Rule 12 (ba)
of CPC. So also, the Trial Court would be entitled to direct an
enquiry as to rent or mesne profits from the date of institution of the
suit until delivery of possession to the decree holder. In the instant
case, the material on record discloses that as stated supra, the
Trial Court in O.S.No.130/2006 passed a judgment and decree in
favour of the appellant-plaintiff directing grant of mesne profits,
i.e.,current and future mesne profits from the date of the suit till the
appellant gets possession of the suit schedule property from the
respondent-defendant. As stated earlier, said suit was instituted on
35.05.2006 and the said appellant took possession of the suit
schedule property from the respondent on 26.03.2017 after a
period of 11 years. It is for this period that the appellant

- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


approached the Trial Court in C.Mis.No.1/2017 for recovery of
mesne profits from the respondent.
16. A perusal of Order XX Rule 12(2) CPC will clearly
indicate that the said provision contemplates that once an enquiry
is directed under clause (b) or clause (c), a final decree in respect
of the rent or mesne profits shall be passed in accordance with the
result of such inquiry. In the present case, in pursuance of the
aforesaid decree passed in OS No.130/2006, the appellant having
instituted proceedings in C.Mis.No.1/2017 by invoking Order XX
Rule 12 and 18 CPC, the final order passed by the Trial Court in
C.Mis.No.1/2017 is clearly in the nature of a final decree and was
clearly in the nature of a final decree in terms of Order XX Rule
12(2) CPC and consequently, since the rights of the parties were
finally adjudicated by the Trial Court by rejecting the claim of the
appellant for mesne profits, an appeal under Section 96 CPC would
be maintainable before the First Appellate Court and failure to
appreciate this has resulted in an erroneous conclusion. Under
these circumstances, I am of the considered opinion that the First
Appellate Court fell in error in dismissing the appeal as not

- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


maintainable, warranting interference by this Court in the present
appeal.
The substantial questions of law are accordingly answered in
favour of the appellant.
17. The next question that arises for consideration is the
procedure to be followed by this Court after setting aside the
judgment and decree of the Trial Court and the First Appellate
Court. As stated supra, the Trial Court committed an error in not
appointing a Court Commissioner for the purpose of adjudication
of the mesne profits payable in favour of the appellant and the First
Appellate Court also fell in error in dismissing the appeal as not
maintainable. In view of the findings recorded by this Court herein
before that the impugned judgment and decree of the Trial Court
dismissing the petition and the impugned judgment and decree of
the First Appellate Court dismissing the appeal as not maintainable
being set aside, I deem it just and appropriate to remit the matter
back to the Trial Court for reconsideration of the matter afresh and
in accordance with law, especially when that the respondents had
remained ex-parte and did not contest the proceedings before the

- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60611
RSA No. 800 of 2019


CNR: KAHC010113822019


Trial Court, First Appellate court as well as before this Court and by
issuing certain directions in this regard.
18. In the result, I pass the following:
ORDER
i. The appeal is allowed .
ii. The impugned order dated 02.08.208 passed in
C.Mis.No.1/2017 by the Senior Civil Judge and JMFC, Mudigere
and the impugned order dated 02.01.2019 passed in
R.A.No.77/2018 by the II Addl. District and Sessions Judge,
Chikkamagaluru are hereby set aside.
iii. The matter is remitted back to the Trial Court for
reconsideration of the matter afresh, in accordance with law and
bearing in mind the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in
the case of Nemichand Tavanappa Kudachi v. Jinnappa
Mahadev Kudachi - ILR 1974 Karnataka 661.
iv. The appellant shall appear before the Trial Court on
07.12.2026, without awaiting further notice.

Sd/-
(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
BMC: List No.: 1 Sl No.: 43