THAKUR RANVEER SINGH vs STATE OF UTTARAKHAND

Court
Uttarakhand High Court

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB


HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL

THE HON’BLE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. MANOJ KUMAR TIWARI
AND
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE MR. SUBHASH UPADHYAY
November 17, 2026
Writ Petition (S/B) No.304 of 2025

Thakur Ranveer Singh ----Petitioner

Versus

State of Uttarakhand & Ors. ----Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:-
Mr. Shobhit Saharia, learned counsel for the petitioner
Mr. Rajeev Singh Bisht, learned Deputy A.G. with Mr. Puran Singh Bisht, learned Chief
Standing Counsel for the State of Uttarakhand/respondent nos.1, 2 and 3
Mr. Shashank Pandey and Mr. Akshay Pradhan, learned counsel for respondent nos.4
and 5
Mr. H.M. Bhatia, learned counsel for applicant in Intervention Application (IA
No.5/2026)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Court made the following:

JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Justice Sri Manoj Kumar Tiwari, A.C.J.)


1. By means of this writ petition, petitioner has sought
the following reliefs:-
“i. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari
quashing the order dated 30.06.2025 (Annexure No.1) as
well as DPC proceedings dated 12.06.2025 (Annexure
no.11).

ii. Issue a writ, order or directions in the nature of
mandamus commanding the respondents to undertake any
promotional exercise for the recruitment year 2024-25,
having cut-off date of 1.7.2024 (first day of recruitment
year) for determining the eligibility for being considered for
promotion, without applying Amendments in the Rules
1

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

brought into existence vide notification dated 26.05.2025,
which is prospective as per Rule 1(2) of the Amendment
itself, more pertinently from the cadre of substantively
appointed Joint Commissioner.

iii. Issue a writ, order or directions in the nature of
mandamus to consider the case of the petitioner for
promotion to the post of Additional Commissioner, which
was the next promotional post in existence after Joint
Commissioner, in the cadre of service, before coming into
effect of Amendment dated 26.05.2025, as the right to be
considered for promotion of the petitioner got crystallized,
prior to coming into effect of Amendment dated 26.05.2025.

iv. Pass any suitable order or direction of any nature which
this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the present
circumstance of the case.

v. Award the cost of the writ petition.

vi. Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari,
quashing the order dated 24.07.2025 passed by Secretary,
Finance, State of Uttarakhand, whereby the representation
of the petitioner has been rejected, annexed as Annexure
NO.A-24 to the Counter Affidavit filed by Respondent no.1.”

2. Petitioner has challenged promotion given to 05
persons who were serving as Joint Commissioner Grade-II in
State Tax Department, to the post of Joint Commissioner
Grade-I, vide order dated 30.06.2025. He contends that he
was eligible for promotion to the post of Joint Commissioner
Grade-I and that he was wrongly denied right to be
considered for promotion by the Departmental Promotion
2

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

Committee.

3. It is not in dispute that petitioner was appointed as
Assistant Commissioner, vide order dated 06.07.2005, and he
was promoted as Deputy Commissioner, vide order dated
26.04.2011. Lastly, he was promoted as Joint Commissioner,
Pay Matrix Level 12, vide order dated 04.01.2022.

4. The mode of recruitment and conditions of service
of Group ‘A’ and Group ‘B’ Officers serving in the Department
are governed by statutory Rules known as “Uttarakhand
Provincial Revenue Service (Tax) Rules, 2016”, which was
notified on 15.02.2016. As per Rule 5(d) of said Rules,
anyone who has completed 03 years service as Joint
Commissioner and total 20 years service on the first day of
year of recruitment, was eligible to be considered for
promotion to the post of Additional Commissioner. Thus,
Additional Commissioner was the promotional post available
to Joint Commissioner. The cadre of State Tax Department
was restructured, vide G.O. dated 28.06.2024, and 20 posts
of Joint Commissioner Grade-II in Level 12 (15 existing posts
and 05 additional posts) were created in addition to 06 new
posts of Joint Commissioner Grade-I in Level 13. The
applicable Service Rules were also amended, vide notification
3

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

dated 26.05.2025. After amendment in the Rules, a Deputy
Commissioner, upon completing 05 years of service as such
on the first day of year of recruitment, became eligible for
promotion as Joint Commissioner Grade-II. For promotion to
next higher post of Joint Commissioner Grade-I, a Joint
Commissioner Grade-II is required to complete qualifying
service of 03 years as such, on the first day of year of
recruitment and a total service of 15 years in the Assistant
Commissioner cadre.

5. As per amended Rules, a Joint Commissioner
Grade-I, upon completing 03 years of qualifying service as
such, on the first day of year of recruitment and a total
service of 20 years in the Assistant Commissioner cadre, is
eligible for promotion to the post of Additional Commissioner.
The criteria for promotion to the post of Additional
Commissioner is merit while criteria for promotion to other
two posts, mentioned earlier, is seniority subject to rejection
of unfit.

6. Petitioner contends that promotion exercise was
held in hot haste to deny right to be considered for promotion
to the petitioner. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that petitioner had made a representation to pre-pone the
4

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

date of his promotion to the post of Joint Commissioner to
11.05.2020 in place of 04.01.2022. The request made by
petitioner for preponing his promotion to the post of Joint
Commissioner was turned down by the State Government.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
amendment made in the Service Rules in 2025 is prospective
in nature, therefore, it cannot have an effect of taking away
the right, which accrued to the petitioner under the pre-
amended Rules. He submits that before amendment, there
was one single cadre of Joint Commissioner and petitioner
was promoted as Joint Commissioner on 04.01.2022, and in
the absence of any stipulation in the amendment Rules that
existing Joint Commissioners will be treated as Joint
Commissioner Grade-II, petitioner could not have been non-
suited for promotion to the post of Joint Commissioner Grade-
I.

7. The contention raised by learned counsel for the
petitioner is fallacious. The cadre of Officers, serving in State
Tax Department, was restructured vide Government Order
dated 28.06.2024 and the existing posts of Joint
Commissioner were merged in the post of Joint Commissioner
Grade-II. It is not in dispute that petitioner was promoted to
the post of Joint Commissioner in pay matrix level 12 in the
5

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

year 2022, and as per G.O. dated 28.06.2024, post of Joint
Commissioner Grade-II was also created in pay matrix Level
12. By the said G.O., 06 new posts of Joint Commissioner
Grade-I were created in pay matrix level 13. The Service
Rules were subsequently amended, vide notification dated
26.05.2025, which provided that persons serving as Joint
Commissioner Grade-II, who have completed 03 years of
qualifying service as such, on the first day of year of
recruitment, with a total 15 years of service in the cadre of
Assistant Commissioner, alone would be eligible for promotion
to the post of Joint Commissioner Grade-I. Thus, eligibility for
promotion as Joint Commissioner was to be seen with
reference to the first day of recruitment year 2024-25 i.e.
01.07.2024 and petitioner had not put in required 03 years’
service as Joint Commissioner Grade-II on the said date.

8. In the counter affidavit filed by Mr. Navneet Pande,
Additional Secretary, Finance Department, Government of
Uttarakhand, on behalf of respondent no.1, it is stated that
petitioner’s work and conduct were far from satisfactory;
Additional Commissioner, Trade Tax, Kumaun Region, had
expressed displeasure to him, vide order dated 03.05.2005;
petitioner’s three increments were ordered to be withheld
with cumulative effect, after enquiry, vide order dated
6

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

19.10.2015; warning was issued to him, vide order dated
27.06.2016 for negligence in discharge of official duties;
another warning was issued to petitioner, vide order dated
24.09.2023 and thereafter a charge-sheet was also issued to
him on 01.07.2025. It is further stated that letters dated
27.05.2025 issued by Commissioner, State Tax were received
by the State Government, wherein request was made for
filling vacancies on the post of Joint Commissioner Grade-I
(Level 13) and Joint Commissioner Grade-II (Level 12) for
selection year 2024-25; consequently State Government
initiated promotion exercise and convened DPC meeting for
29.05.2025; however, in the meantime, representation
submitted by petitioner was received and after disposal of
said representation, DPC meeting was reconvened for
12.06.2025, in which petitioner’s name could not be
considered as his name did not figure in the list of eligible
officers.

9. The contention that petitioner’s right to be
considered for promotion got crystallized before amendment
of the Rules, vide Notification dated 26.05.2025, is fallacious.
Before amendment, a Joint Commissioner would become
eligible for promotion to the next higher post of Additional
Commissioner only upon completion of 03 years of service in
7

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

the feeder post of Joint Commissioner, on the first day of the
relevant recruitment year.

10. Since petitioner was promoted to the post of Joint
Commissioner on 04.01.2022, therefore, he would become
eligible for promotion by completing required qualifying
service of 03 years as Joint Commissioner, only on
01.07.2025. Thus, petitioner did not complete the requisite
length of service needed for promotion to the next higher
post, on the date when amended Rules came into force. Even
otherwise also, Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State
of Himachal Pradesh and others vs. Raj Kumar and
others, reported as (2023) 3 SCC 773 , overruled the earlier
view that a vacancy which occurred prior to amendment in
the Rules would be governed by old Rules and summarized
the legal position as follows:-
“ 27 . The principle laid down in Roshan Lal Tandon case [Roshan Lal Tandon
v. Union of India, (1968) 1 SCR 185 : AIR 1967 SC 1889] is followed in a
number of decisions of this Court. [Union of India v. Arun Kumar Roy,
(1986) 1 SCC 675 : 1986 SCC (L&S) 199; A. Satyanarayana v. S.
Purushotham, (2008) 5 SCC 416 : (2008) 2 SCC (L&S) 279; Brij Mohan Lal
v. Union of India, (2012) 6 SCC 502 : (2012) 2 SCC (L&S) 177.] The
following are the propositions emanating from the principles laid down in
these precedents:
27.1 . Except as expressly provided in the Constitution, every person
employed in the civil service of the Union or the States holds office during
the pleasure of the President or the Governor (Article 310). Tenure at
pleasure is a constitutional policy for rendering services under the State for
public interest and for the public good, as explained in Tulsiram Patel
[Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel, (1985) 3 SCC 398 : 1985 SCC (L&S) 672]
8

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

.
27.2. The Union and the States are empowered to make laws and rules
under Articles 309, 310 and 311 to regulate the recruitment, conditions of
service, tenure and termination. The rights and obligations are no longer
determined by consent of the parties but by the legal relationship of rights
and duties imposed by statute or the rules. The services, thus, attain a
status.
27.3. The hallmark of status is in the legal rights and obligations imposed
by laws that may be framed and altered unilaterally by the Government
without the consent of the employee.
27.4. In view of the dominance of rules that govern the relationship
between the Government and its employee, all matters concerning
employment, conditions of service including termination are governed by
the rules. There are no rights outside the provision of the rules.
27.5. In a recruitment by the State, there is no right to be appointed but
only a right to be considered fairly. The process of recruitment will be
governed by the rules framed for the said purpose.
27.6. Conditions of service of a public servant, including matters of
promotion and seniority are governed by the extant rules. There are no
vested rights independent of the rules governing the service. [Khalid Rizvi
v. Union of India, 1993 Supp (3) SCC 575 : 1994 SCC (L&S) 84; Hardev
Singh v. Union of India, (2011) 10 SCC 121 : (2012) 1 SCC (L&S) 390]
27.7. With the enactment of laws and issuance of rules governing the
services, Governments are equally bound by the mandate of the rule. There
is no power or discretion outside the provision of the rules governing the
services and the actions of the State are subject to judicial review.
[Rajasthan Public Service Commission v. Chanan Ram, (1998) 4 SCC 202 :
1998 SCC (L&S) 1075]
28. In view of the above principles, flowing from the constitutional status of
a person in employment with the State, we have no hesitation in holding
that the observations in Rangaiah [Y.V. Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao,
(1983) 3 SCC 284 : 1983 SCC (L&S) 382] that posts which fell vacant prior
to the amendment of Rules would be governed by old Rules and not by new
Rules do not reflect the correct position of law. We have already explained
that the status of a government employee involves a relationship governed
exclusively by rules and that there are no rights outside these rules that
govern the services. Further, the Court in Rangaiah case [Y.V. Rangaiah v.
J. Sreenivasa Rao, (1983) 3 SCC 284 : 1983 SCC (L&S) 382] has not
justified its observation by locating such a right on any principle or on the
basis of the new Rules. [ In fact, the case of K. Ramulu v. S. Suryaprakash
Rao, (1997) 3 SCC 59 : 1997 SCC (L&S) 625 is exactly this where there
was a specific requirement in the new amended Rules to fill up the old
9

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

vacancies as per the new amended Rules. The repealed rules had a
provision for filling up the past vacancies as per the new Rules. Also, in P.
Ganeshwar Rao v. State of A.P., 1988 Supp SCC 740 : 1989 SCC (L&S) 123
the intendment was to fill the vacancies as per the old Rules.] As there are
a large number of judgments which followed Rangaiah [Y.V. Rangaiah v. J.
Sreenivasa Rao, (1983) 3 SCC 284 : 1983 SCC (L&S) 382] under the
assumption that an overarching principle has been laid down in Rangaiah
[Y.V. Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao, (1983) 3 SCC 284 : 1983 SCC (L&S)
382] , we have to necessarily examine the cases that followed Rangaiah
[Y.V. Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao, (1983) 3 SCC 284 : 1983 SCC (L&S)
382] . We will now examine how subsequent decisions understood, applied
or distinguished Rangaiah [Y.V. Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao, (1983) 3
SCC 284 : 1983 SCC (L&S) 382].”

11. Reportedly, petitioner in his representation made a
request to postpone the DPC meeting so that during the
interregnum, he may become eligible for promotion for the
next recruitment year i.e. 2025-26; however, his request was
not acceded to by the Competent Authority.

12. A government servant, who has not completed
requisite qualifying service on the date when DPC meeting is
scheduled, do not have a indefeasible right to have the DPC
meeting postponed to a later date, to enable him to complete
the required length of service on the feeder post. Thus, the
decision taken by the Competent Authority of not acceding to
petitioner’s request, cannot be faulted.

13. Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that
the amendment made in the Rules, vide Notification dated
26.05.2025, cannot be applied retrospectively; since
10

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

petitioner’s right to be considered for promotion to the post of
Additional Commissioner got crystallized much before the
amendment became effective, therefore, respondents be
directed to consider petitioner’s request for promotion as
Additional Commissioner.

14. As discussed earlier, even before amendment in
the Rules, a Joint Commissioner was eligible for promotion
as Additional Commissioner only upon completing 03 years
of qualifying service as such, on the first day of year of
recruitment. The promotion in question was made against
vacancies of recruitment year 2024-2025, therefore, first
day of the year of recruitment year would be 01.07.2024.
Since petitioner was promoted as Joint Commissioner in
pay matrix level-12 only on 04.01.2022, therefore, he had
not acquired eligibility for promotion as Additional
Commissioner on 01.07.2024 for want of qualifying service
of 03 years on the feeder post and he would have become
eligible for promotion only on 01.07.2025. Rules, however,
were amended much earlier on 26.05.2025. As held by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of H.P. vs.
Raj Kumar (supra) , the condition of service of a public
servant, including matters of promotion and seniority, are
11

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

governed by the Service Rules and there is no vested right
independent of the Rules governing the service. Para 26 of
the said judgment would be apposite in this regard, which
is extracted below:-
“26. It is in this background that the employment of a public servant is to
be understood. Though the relationship between the employee and the
State originates in contract, but by virtue of the constitutional constraint,
coupled with the legislative and executive rules governing the service, the
relation attains a unique position. Identifying such a relationship as being a
“status”, as against a contract, this Court in Roshan Lal Tandon v. Union of
India [Roshan Lal Tandon v. Union of India, (1968) 1 SCR 185 : AIR 1967
SC 1889] , explained what such a “status” constitutes. We have extracted
hereinbelow the exposition of the concept of “status” as explained by the
Constitution Bench for ready reference. In this case, the petitioner Roshan
Lal Tandon was appointed as Train-Examiner — Grade ‘D’. At the time when
he joined the service, the promotion to the next post in Grade ‘C’ was
governed by certain rules which later came to be amended. Questioning the
amendment, he contended that he had a right to be promoted to Grade ‘C’
when he joined the service and such a right could not have been altered by
way of a subsequent amendment. Rejecting this argument, this Court
explained the relationship of government employment as a “status” as
under : (AIR pp. 1894-95, paras 6-7)
“6. We pass on to consider the next contention of the petitioner that
there was a contractual right as regards the condition of service
applicable to the petitioner at the time he entered Grade ‘D’ and the
condition of service could not be altered to his disadvantage afterwards
by the notification issued by the Railway Board. It was said that the
order of the Railway Board dated 25-1-1958, Annexure ‘B’, laid down
that promotion to Grade ‘C’ from Grade ‘D’ was to be based on
seniority-cum-suitability and this condition of service was contractual
and could not be altered thereafter to the prejudice of the petitioner. In
our opinion, there is no warrant for this argument. It is true that the
origin of government service is contractual. There is an offer and
acceptance in every case. But once appointed to his post or office the
government servant acquires a status and his rights and obligations are
no longer determined by consent of both parties, but by statute or
statutory rules which may be framed and altered unilaterally by the
Government. In other words, the legal position of a government servant
is more one of status than of contract. The hallmark of status is
12

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

the attachment to a legal relationship of rights and duties
imposed by the public law and not by mere agreement of the
parties . The emolument of the government servant and his terms of
service are governed by statute or statutory rules which may be
unilaterally altered by the Government without the consent of the
employee. It is true that Article 311 imposes constitutional restrictions
upon the power of removal granted to the President and the Governor
under Article 310. But it is obvious that the relationship between the
Government and its servant is not like an ordinary contract of service
between a master and servant. The legal relationship is something
entirely different, something in the nature of status. It is much more
than a purely contractual relationship voluntarily entered into between
the parties. The duties of status are fixed by the law and in the
enforcement of these duties, society has an interest. …
7. We are therefore of the opinion that the petitioner has no
vested contractual right in regard to the terms of his service and
that the counsel for the petitioner has been unable to make good his
submission on this aspect of the case.”
(emphasis supplied)

15. Since the amendment made in the Rules became
effective on 26.05.2025, therefore, now a Joint Commissioner
Grade-II can only be promoted as Joint Commissioner Grade-
I and upon completing prescribed length of service on the
post of Joint Commissioner Grade-I, one can become eligible
for promotion to the next higher post of Additional
Commissioner. Thus, the contention that petitioner is entitled
for promotion to the post of Additional Commissioner, cannot
be accepted.

16. Having regard to the facts and circumstances, as
discussed above, we do not find any reason to interfere with
the promotion order dated 30.06.2025. Accordingly, the writ
13

UKHC010111552025

2026:UHC:10435-DB

petition fails and is hereby dismissed. Interim order dated
24.07.2025 is vacated.

17. No order as to costs.

_______________________________

MANOJ KUMAR TIWARI, A.C.J.




____________________________
SUBHASH UPADHYAY, J.
Dt: 17.11.2026
Rajni

14