BHUPATI MAJHI AND ORS. vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Arjun Ray Mukherjee
WPA/ 24114/2025
BHUPATI MAJHI AND ORS.
VS
STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.
For the petitioners : Ms. Kaberi Ghosh (Dey)
For the State : Mr. Dibasish Basu, Ld. AGP
Mrs. Sneha Dutta,
Mr. Purnendu Das
th
Heard on : 20 November, 2026
th
Judgment on : 20 November, 2026
th
Uploaded on : 20 November, 2026
Arjun Ray Mukherjee, J.
1. The petitioners are aggrieved by the order dated 04.09.2025 passed by the
District Magistrate, Bankura and also the Appellate Authority under the West
Bengal Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Identification) Rules, 1995
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the said Rules, 1995’) framed under the West Bengal
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Identification) Act, 1994.
2. By the impugned order dated 04.09.2025, the District Magistrate, Bankura and
the Appellate Authority (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Appellate Authority’)
rejected the appeal preferred by the petitioners and upheld the order dated
2
10.12.2024, passed by the Sub-Divisional Officer, Khatra whereby the Scheduled
Tribes Certificates of the petitioners had been cancelled.
3. The case of the petitioners set forth in the writ petition are as follows.
4. According to the petitioners, they belonged to Scheduled Tribes Community,
namely, ‘the Santal’.
5. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Khatra, Bankura on the basis of the application
submitted by the petitioner no. 1, issued Castes/Tribe Certificate dated
24.06.2022 whereby he certified that the petitioner no. 1 belonged to the Santal
Tribe which was recognized as Scheduled Tribes under the Constitution
(Scheduled Castes) Order, 1950 and the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order,
1950 as amended by the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Lists
(Modification) Order, 1956 and the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Order
(Amendment) Act, 1976. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Khatra, issued identical
Castes /Tribe Certificate to the other petitioners on 30.11.2022.
6. The petitioners received notices from the Sub-Divisional Officer, Khatra, whereby
they were directed to appear before him with all necessary documents along-with
their Caste Certificates in original for hearing in connection with a proceeding
initiated under Rule 3 of the said Rules, 1995.
7. The petitioners duly participated in the said hearing.
8. By an order dated 10.12.2024, the Sub-Divisional Officer, Khatra, having
considered the submissions of the petitioners and the materials on record,
cancelled the Scheduled Tribe Certificates of the petitioners in terms of Rule 5 of
the said Rules, 1995.
9. The relevant portion of the order dated 10.12.2024 is set out herein below—
3
“ Whereas, several discrepancies were found between the
statements provided during the field enquiry and the hearing.
Bhupati Majhi made inconsistent claims regarding his
community's social structure, language proficiency, religious
practices, and rituals. Initially, he described the social hierarchy
as consisting of Majhi Baba. Jag Majhi, Godel Paranik and
Naike, which contradicted the information provided by him
during the field enquiry.
Additionally, his son, Manindra Majhi, claimed to know the
Santhali language but failed to communicate effectively when
tested by a fellow community member. Both individuals gave
conflicting accounts of the deities they worship. For instance,
during the field enquiry, Bhupati Majhi mentioned their deities as
Goram, Baghuit, Karam and Shitala, whereas during the
hearing, be cited Marang Burru, Jaher Ayo, and Goram.
Furthermore, he was unable to identify the Santhali deity
associated with the Mamore ritual and incorrectly stated that
More-Ko is the god of air, while in fact, More-Ko is the god of fire.
These inconsistencies indicate a possible attempt to misrepresent
the cultural and religious practices of the Santhali community,
potentially to gain undue benefits under reservation policies.
And
Whereas, based on the above findings and a thorough review of
the enquiry report submitted by the DM & DC, Khatra, and the
Inspector, BCW & TD, Raipur Development Block, dated
06.09.2024, I am of the opinion that the ST Certificate bearing
No. WB1303ST2022021436, dated 24.06.2022, issued to Bhupati
Majhi, son of Late Bhabataran Majhi, residing at Village:
Chapabani, PO: Taptadamdi. PS: Raipur, District: Bankura, was
mistakenly issued during the Duare Sarkar period. Furthermore,
the then SDO, Khaira, should have exercised more caution before
approving the same.
Order
It is hereby ordered that the ST Certificate bearing No.
WB1303ST2022021435, dated 24.06.2022, issued to Bhupati
Majhi, son of Late Bhabataran Majhi, residing at Village:
Chapabani, PO: Taptadamdi, PS: Raipur, District: Bankura,
stands cancelled under Section 5 of the West Bengal Scheduled
Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Identification) Rules, 1995. ”
10. Being aggrieved by the order dated 10.12.2024, the petitioners filed a writ
petition, being WPA 5368 of 2025.A Co-Ordinate Bench of this Court, having
found that the order impugned was an appealable one, dismissed the writ petition
4
with liberty to the petitioners to approach the competent Appellate Forum in
accordance with law.
11. Pursuant to the order dated 22.07.2025, the petitioners preferred an appeal
under Rule 7G of the said Rules, 1995 before the Appellate Authority. The
Appellate Authority afforded an opportunity of hearing to the petitioners and
passed the impugned order dated 04.9.2025, as referred to hereinabove. The
relevant portions of the order dated 04.09.2025 are set out hereinbelow—
“ Heard the appellants. They have claimed that they belong to
Scheduled Tribe community, Santal sub-caste and Mandi gotra.
When enquired about their family treeline, several discrepancies have
been noted in the statements of the appellants. When Bhupati Majhi,
S/O- Late Bhabataran Majhi, has been asked about his grandfather's
name, he has mentioned Jayram Majhi (instead of Jayram Santal as
per his family treeline). He has also mentioned that Haru Santal was
the father of Babulal Santal (Instead of brother as per his family
treeline).
Bhupati Majhi, S/O- Late Bhabataran Majhi, has produced an EPIC
of Bhabataran Majhi, S/O- Jayram, where the surname of Jayram
was neither Majhi nor Santal (as per his family treeline) but
remained unmentioned.
The appellants have not been able to produce any documents of
ancestors that may have claimed their sub-caste as Santal.
Bhupati Majhi, S/O- Late Bhabataran Majhi, has been enquired
about the deities worshipped by the family. He has mentioned Joher
Babo which contradicted the deities mentioned by him in the hearing
dated 10.12.2024 before the Sub-Divisional Officer, Khatra.
When Mukul Majhi, S/O- Manindra Majhi, has been enquired about
the house deities of the family, he has mentioned Bindo Chanda after
a lot of thought. When he has been asked to describe the deity, he has
been unable and remained silent.
When Mukul Majhi, S/O- Manindra Majhi, has been asked the name
of his maternal uncle, he has mentioned Biswanath Hembram/
Hansda/ Majhi, expressing hesitation in mentioning the surname.
Deputy Magistrate & Deputy Collector, Khatra sub-division, has
mentioned that the appellants were unable to communicate in Santali
language or write In Olchiki script during his field enquiry. The claim
has not been refuted by any of the appellants.
Hence, as per the findings of the hearing and available case records,
alongwith documents produced by the appellants, the said appeal
5
before the undersigned to review the orders dated 10.12.2024 of the
Sub-Divisional Officer, Khatra, regarding cancellation of their
Scheduled Tribe Certificates is hereby rejected and disposed of. ”
12. Ms. Kaberi Ghosh (Dey), learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits
that, Rule 3(3) of the said Rules, 1995, mandates that the Certificate Issuing
Authority shall issue a notice to the holder of the certificate to show-cause within
fifteen days or within such period as the authority may deem fit indicating why
the certificate issued in favour of certificate-holders shall not be cancelled,
impounded or revoked on the ground stated in the notice.
13. Ms. Ghosh (Dey), learned counsel, submits that no such show cause notice was
issued to the petitioners by the Certificate Issuing Authority and consequently all
steps taken by the said authority are liable to be set aside as the same violated the
statutory provisions of Rule 3(3) of the said Rule, 1995.
14. She further refers to a Records of Rights at pages 14 to 20 of the writ petition and
she draws my attention to page 17 of the writ petition, which is a Record of
Rights. It shows that one Joyram Majhi, father of Haru Majhi was recorded as
‘Santal.’ She refers to page 21 of the writ petition which is a deed executed on
01.05.1950 by one Babulal Majhi, whose tribe was recorded as ‘Santal’.
15. She further refers to a chart indicating the family lineage of the petitioners
certified by the Raipur Gram Panchayat authority. From the said document she
submits that Joyram Santal and Haru Santal was the grandfather and great
grandfather of the petitioner no. 1 respectively. The petitioner no. 2 is the son of
the petitioner no. 1. The petitioner no. 3 and 4 are the grandson and
granddaughter of the petitioner no. 1 respectively. Relying on the aforesaid
documents vis-à-vis the Record of Rights and the Deed executed on 01.05.1950,
6
she submits that all these documents are contemporaneous and very old records
where-from it can be ascertained that the ancestors of the petitioners belonged to
Santal tribe.
16. She, in support of her contentions, also places reliance on a judgment reported in
2012 (1) SCC, 113 (Anand Vs. Committee for Security and Verification of Tribe
Claims and Others) delivered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
17. Per contra , Mr. Purnendu Das, learned counsel appearing for the State
respondents refers to a mass petition dated 28.08.2024, signed by fifty-three
persons and also a representation dated 21.08.2024, whereby the Block
Development Officer, Raipur, Bankura and the Sub-Divisional Officer, Khatra,
Bankura were requested to cancel the Castes Certificates of the petitioners as
according to them the petitioners do not belong to ‘Santal’ tribe and those
certificates were obtained fraudulently.
18. He further refers to a notice dated 28.11.2024, issued by the Sub-Divisional
Officer, Khatra, whereby the petitioners were directed to appear before him on
10.12.2024.
19. He submits that the Sub-Divisional Officer, Khatra considered the issue on
27.08.2024, 06.09.2024 and 27.11.2024 and thereafter, having considered the
statements made by the petitioners and the relevant documents, cancelled the
Caste Certificates of the petitioners.
20. He submits that those Caste Certificates were obtained during a Scheme initiated
by the Government of West Bengal namely, “Duare Sarkar Prokalpo” sometime in
2021-20222 and during that period the petitioners obtained these Caste
Certificates.
7
21. He also submits that the Appellate Authority duly considered all aspects of the
matter and rightly rejected the claim of the petitioners.
22. Lastly, he submits that there was no illegality or procedural infirmity in the
decision-making process adopted by the respondents.
23. Heard the parties.
24. It appears from the records of the writ petition that the respondent authority
without issuing a show-cause notice, as prescribed under Rule 3(3) of the said
Rules, 1995 proceeded to determine the caste status of the petitioners and arrived
at a finding that the petitioners do not belong to Santal sub-caste and therefore
do not fall under the Scheduled Tribe community. On the basis of such finding,
the respondents cancelled the certificates issued in favour of the petitioners.
25. Rule 3(3) is a statutory rule which prescribes that before taking any coercive step
against a person holding a caste certificate, a show-cause notice is required to be
issued. It is well-settled that “… where a power is given to do a certain thing in a
certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all. Other methods of
performance are necessarily forbidden.”
26. However, in the instant case, such violation will not help the petitioners much in
overcoming the other impediments as it appears from the impugned order dated
th
4 September, 2025, passed by the Appellate Authority.
th
27. The petitioners, being aggrieved by the order dated 10 December, 2024, passed
by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, moved the writ petition, referred to
hereinabove and this Court dismissed the writ petition with a liberty to the
petitioners to prefer an appeal before the Appellate Authority.
8
28. From the memorandum of appeal annexed to this writ petition, it does not appear
that the petitioners had taken this point of violation of Rule 3(3) of the said Rules,
1995. Therefore, having failed to raise the said issue before the Appellate
Authority, the petitioners cannot now be permitted to raise the same in the
present proceeding.
29. A show-cause notice is a pre-condition to the initiation of proceedings or inquiry
against a certificate holder. The purpose of issuing such notice is to afford an
opportunity to the certificate holder before initiation of the proceeding and also
to take a decision by the authority as to whether at all a proceeding is required to
be initiated against the certificate-holder or not.
30. In the instant case, the petitioners were afforded an opportunity to substantiate
their cases and no allegations of procedural infirmity have been alleged by the
petitioners against the respondents. Moreover, no prejudice has been caused to
the petitioners for non-issuance of the show-cause notice as the petitioners were
subsequently afforded adequate opportunity to substantiate their respective cases
by the respondents.
31. The scope of judicial review in respect of administrative or quasi-judicial
decisions is limited. It is now well settled that the duty of the court is to confine
itself to the question of legality and its concern should be: whether a decision-
making authority exceeded its powers, or committed an error of law, or breach of
the rules of natural justice, or reached a decision which no reasonable person
would have reached or, abused its powers, or whether the decision suffers from
perversity.
9
32. In Anand vs. Committee for Scrutiny and Verification (supra) the Caste Scrutiny
Committee failed to consider a school leaving certificate of the appellant’s
grandfather issued in the year 1929. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, while
considering the said issue, held the following:
“(i) While dealing with documentary evidence, greater
reliance may be placed on pre-
Independence documents because they furnish a higher
degree of probative value to the declaration of status of a caste,
as compared to post-Independence documents. In case the
applicant is the first generation ever to attend school, the
availability of any documentary evidence becomes difficult, but
that ipso facto does not call for the rejection of his claim. In fact
the mere fact that he is the first generation ever to attend school,
some benefit of doubt in favour of the applicant may be given.
Needless to add that in the event of a doubt on the credibility of
a document, its veracity has to be tested on the basis of oral
evidence, for which an opportunity has to be afforded to the
applicant;
20. Having examined the present case on the
touchstone of the aforesaid broad parameters, we are of
the opinion that the claim of the appellant has not been
examined properly. We feel that the documentary
evidence produced by the appellant in support of his
claim had been lightly brushed aside by the Vigilance
Officer as also by the Caste Scrutiny Committee. Insofar
as the High Court is concerned, it has rejected the claim
solely on the basis of the affinity test. It is pertinent to
note that some of these documents date back to the pre-
Independence era, issued to appellant's grandfather and
thus, hold great probative value as there can be no
reason for suppression of facts to claim a non-existent
benefit to the 'Halbi' Scheduled Tribe at that point of
time. From the documents produced by the appellant, it
appears that his near paternal relatives had been
regarded as belonging to the "Halbi' Scheduled Tribe.
The Vigilance Officer's report does not indicate that the
documents produced by the appellant in support of his
claim are false. It merely refers to the comments made by
the Head Master with reference to the school records of
appellant's father's maternal brother and his aunt, which
had been alleged to be tampered with, to change the
entry from Koshti Halba to Halba and nothing more.
Neither the Head Master was examined, nor any further
10
enquiry was conducted to verify the veracity of Head
Master's statement. It is of some importance to note at
this juncture that in similar cases, involving appellant's
first cousin and his paternal uncle, the High Court, while
observing non-application of mind by the Caste Scrutiny
Committee, had decided a similar claim in their favour.
We are convinced that the documentary evidence
produced by the appellant was not examined and
appreciated in its proper perspective and the High Court
laid undue stress on the affinity test. Thus, the decision of
the Caste Scrutiny Committee to cancel and confiscate the
caste certificate as well as the decision of the High Court,
affirming the said decision is untenable. We are,
therefore, of the opinion that the claim of the appellant
deserves to be re-examined by the Caste Scrutiny
Committee. For the view we have taken on facts in hand,
we deem it unnecessary to refer to the decisions cited at
the bar.”
33. In the instant case, the petitioners referred to some old Records of
st
Rights and a deed executed on 1 May, 1950. It appears from the said
records that the tribe of Joyram Majhi, son of Haru Majhi, was Santhal.
Although the identity card issued by the Election Commission of India
in favour of the petitioner does not indicate the surname of the father of
the petitioner no. 1, namely, Bhabataran Majhi, who is the father of the
st
petitioner no. 1, but it appears from the documents executed on 1 May,
1950 and those old Records of Rights, that the tribe of Joyram Majhi
was recorded as Santal.
34. Whether the person, namely Joyram Majhi, recorded in the Record of
Rights, which is at page 17 of the writ petition, and Joyram, the father of
Bhabataran Majhi, as appearing from the identity card issued by the
Election Commission of India, are the same and identical person or not
11
is a disputed question of fact which cannot be decided in a writ
proceeding.
35. However, these facts have not been considered by the Appellate
Authority. Neither the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Khatra in the order
th
dated 10 December, 2024, nor the Appellate Authority in his order
th
dated 4 September, 2025, considered the aforesaid issues. These
records are vital pieces of evidence. Therefore, before coming to the
conclusion that the petitioners do not belong to the Santhal tribe, the
respondents should consider the old documents.
36. Having considered the rival submissions and the materials on record, I
find that there is a very limited scope, as indicated above, to interfere
th
with the impugned order dated 4 September, 2025. Since valuable
rights of the petitioners would be infringed if the aforesaid issue is not
considered in accordance with law, I think it would be proper to relegate
the matter to the Appellate Authority for a fresh consideration.
Accordingly, the impugned order dated 04.09.2025 is set aside.
37. The Appellate Authority is directed to consider the records referred to
hereinabove or any other records in order to ascertain whether Joyram,
as mentioned in the identity card issued by the Election Commission of
India, and Joyram Majhi, as recorded in the Record of Rights and the
st
deed executed on 1 May, 1950, were the same and identical person or
not, and further whether Joyram Majhi, as recorded in the Record of
Rights at page 17 of the writ petition, was the ancestor of the petitioners
or not.
12
38. On the aforesaid limited issue, the matter is remanded to the Appellate
Authority for reconsideration. The Appellate Authority shall decide the
aforesaid issue after affording an opportunity of hearing to the
petitioners within a period of six weeks from the date of communication
of this order and shall pass a reasoned order strictly in accordance with
law within two weeks from the date of hearing.
39. The petitioners are at liberty to produce any other records before the
Appellate Authority. The Appellate Authority is also at liberty to call for
the original records of the aforesaid Record of Rights and deeds or any
other records in order to ascertain the claim of the petitioners.
40. The Appellate Authority is directed to pass a reasoned order strictly in
accordance with law.
41. With the above observation, this writ petition stands disposed of. There
will be no order as to costs.
42. Parties shall act on the server copy of this order.
43.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be
made available to the parties upon compliance with necessary
formalities.
(Arjun Ray Mukherjee, J.)