SRI. STEPHEN K.J. vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 17 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
®
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ
WRIT PETITION NO. 29656 OF 2024 (GM-FOR)
C/W
WRIT PETITION NO. 16251 OF 2023 (GM-FOR)
WRIT PETITION NO. 19980 OF 2023 (GM-FOR)
WRIT PETITION NO. 29690 OF 2025 (GM-FOR)
WRIT PETITION NO. 33767 OF 2025 (GM-FOR)
WRIT PETITION NO. 700 OF 2026 (GM-FOR)
IN WP NO.29656/2024
BETWEEN
M/S. SENTINEL ADVENTURES
SENTINEL ADVENTURES SRAT ROAD NORTHERN,
EXTENSION, AGANI GRAMA,
HANUBAALU HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN-573 165,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANGING PARTNER,
SRI. SATISH BABU,
REG UNDER INDIAN PARTNERSHIP ACT, 1932.
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. SAGAR V SHASTRI., ADVOCATE)
AND
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY CHIEF SECRETARY TO
GOVERNMENT,
RD
ROOM NO. 320, 3 FLOOR,
VIDHANA SOUDHA,
BENGALURU-560 001.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
2. THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA,
FOREST, ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY
DEPARTMENT,
TH
ROOM NO. 448, 4 FLOOR,
M.S. BUILDING,
BENGALURU-560 001.
3. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA,
FOREST, ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY
DEPARTMENT,
TH
ROOM NO. 442, 4 FLOOR,
M.S. BUILDING,
BENGALURU-560 001.
4. THE CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
HASSAN AND TUMKUR DIVISION,
HASSAN CIRCLE, ARANYA BHAVAN,
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE,
B.M. ROAD,
HASSAN-573 201.
5. THE DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
HASSAN CIRCLE, ARANYA BHAVAN,
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE,
B.M. ROAD,
HASSAN-573 201.
6. THE DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
(FOREST MOBILE SQUAD)
HASSAN CIRCLE, ARANYA BHAVAN,
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE,
B.M. ROAD,
HASSAN-573 201.
7. THE ASSISTANT CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS
SAKALESHPURA SUB DIVISION,
SAKALESHPURA,
HASSAN-573 134.
8. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA,
REVENUE DEPARTMENT,
M.S. BUILDING,
BENGALURU-560 001.
9. THE REGIONAL COMMISSIONER
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
MYSORE DIVISION REVENUE DEPARTMENT,
R.C. OFFICE, VINOBHA ROAD,
OPP KALA MANDIR,
MYSORE-570 005.
10.THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
HASSAN DISTRICT,
D.C. OFFICE,
B.M. ROAD,
HASSAN-573 201.
11.THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
SAKALESHPURA SUB DIVISION,
REVENUE DEPARTMENT,
A.C. OFFICE, B. M. ROAD,
SAKALESHPURA,
HASSAN-573 134.
12.THE TAHSILDAR
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
TALUK OFFICE, B.M. ROAD,
SAKALESHPURA,
HASSAN-573 134.
13.THE FOREST SETTLEMENT OFFICER
HASSAN CIRCLE,
ND
2 FLOOR, ARANYA BHAVAN,
DAIRY CIRCLE,
B.M. ROAD,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN-573 134.
…. RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. KIRAN V. RON., AAG)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI OR
ANY OTHER APPROPRIATE WRIT OR ORDER OR DIRECTION QUASHING THE
NOTICES DTD. 04.06.2024, 28.08.2024 AND 10.09.2024 BEARING NO.
A.VVA./HASSAN/ARANYA ADISOOCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 ISSUED BY THE
FOREST SETTLEMENT OFFICER / R-13 AS PER ANNX-G TO G2
RESPECTIVELY, AND NOTICES DTD. 20.09.2024 AND 18.10.2024 BEARING
NO. SAKAPU/UV/SAKAPU/AMO-08/2024-25 ISSUED BY THE ASSISTANT
CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS, HASSAN AND TUMKUR DIVISION, HASSAN/R-
4 AS PER ANNX-G3 AND G4 RESPECTIVELY. AND ETC.
IN WP NO.16251/2023
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
BETWEEN
1. SMT DAISY STEPHEN
W/O SRI STEPHEN K G
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS
R/A NO.68, ANCHANAHALLI
VILLAGE
HANBAL HOBLI
SAKLESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
2. SRI SUBHAS STEPHEN
S/O SRI STEPHEN K G
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
3. SRI SANTHOSH STEPHEN
S/O SRI STEPHEN K G
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
BOTH ARE R/A NO.906, C BLOCK
ARATT ARQUIZZA APARTMENT
GOLLAHALLI VILLAGE
ELECTRONIC CITY
PHASE-1
BENGALURU-560100
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. MANMOHAN P N., ADVOCATE)
AND
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REP BY CHIEF SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT
RD
ROOM NO.320, 3 FLOOR
VIDHANA SOUDHA
BENGALURU-560001
2. THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA
FOREST, ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY DEPARTMENT
TH
ROOM NO.448, 4 FLOOR
M S BUILDING
BENGALURU-560001
3. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA
FOREST, ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY DEPARTMENT
TH
ROOM NO.442, 4 FLOOR
M S BUILDING
BENGALURU-560001
4. THE CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
HASSAN CIRCLE, ARANYA BHAVAN
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE
B M ROAD
HASSAN-573201
5. THE DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
HASSAN DIVISION, ARANYA BHAWAN
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE
B M ROAD
HASSAN-573201
6. THE DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
(FOREST MOBILE SQUAD)
HASSAN DISTRICT, ARANYA BHAWAN
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE
B M ROAD
HASSAN-573201
7. THE ASSISTANT CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
SAKALESHPURA SUB DIVISION
SAKALESHPURA
HASSAN-573134
8. THE RANGE FOREST OFFICER
SAKALESHPURA RANGE
SAKALESHPURA
HASSAN-573134
9. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT
REVENUE DEPARTMENT
TH
ROOM NO.505, 5 FLOOR
M S BUILDING
BENGALURU-560001
10.THE REGIONAL COMMISSIONER
MYSORE DIVISION
REVENUE DEPARTMENT
R C OFFICE, VINOBHA ROAD
OPP KALA MANDIR
MYSORE-570005
11.THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
REVENUE DEPARTMENT
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
HASSAN DISTRICT
D C OFFICE
B M ROAD
HASAN-573201
12.THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
SAKALESHPURA SUB DIVISION
REVENUE DEPARTMENT
A C OFFICE, B M ROAD
SAKALESHPURA
HASSAN-573134
13.THE TAHSILDAR
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
TALUK OFFICE, B M ROAD
SAKLESHPURA
HASSAN-573134
…. RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. KIRAN V. RON., AAG)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT IN NATURE OF
CERTIORARI AND QUASH THE ORDER DTD 26.07.2022 PASSED BY THE
DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FOREST (FOREST MOBILE SQUAD), HASSAN
DISTRICT IN CASE NUMBER
YOLESUM/ASUMDAL/HASSAN/HOTUVARI/AMO.60/2022-23 VIDE
ANNEXURE-J AND ALSO THE NOTICE DTD 18.07.2023 ISSUED BY THE R8
I.E., RANGE FOREST OFFICER, SAKLESHPUR RANGE VIDE ANNEXURE-J1
AND ETC.
IN WP NO.19980/2023
BETWEEN
SRI. STEPHEN K.J.
S/O LATE K JOSEPH
AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS,
R/AT NO.68,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPUR TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. MANMOHAN P N., ADVOCATE)
AND
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
1 . THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
M S BUILDING
BENGALURU-560001
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY
2 . THE CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
HASSAN CIRCLE, ARYAN BHAVAN
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE,
B M ROAD
HASSAN-573201
3 . DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
(FOREST MOBILE SQUAD)
HASSAN DISTRICT ARANYA BHAVAN,
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE
B M ROAD
HASSAN-573201
4 . THE RANGE FOREST OFFICER
SAKLESHPUR SUB DIVISION
SAKLESHPUR HASSAN-573134
5 . THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
REVENUE DEPARTMENT,
HASSAN DISTRICT
D C OFFICE, B M ROAD
HASSAN-573201
DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
HASSAN DISTRICT
ARANYA BHAVAN,
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE
B M ROAD
HASSAN-573201
THE FOREST SETTLEMENT OFFICER
ST
1 FLOOR, ARANYA BHAVAN,
DAIRY CIRCLE, B.M. ROAD,
HASSAN-573201.
…. RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. KIRAN V. RON., AAG)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI AND
QUASH THE ORDER DATED 26.07.2022 BEARING NO.
RD
UASM/ASMDL/HASSAN/UTTUVARI/AM.60/2022-23 BY THE 3 RESPONDENT
(ANNEXURE-K) AND ETC.
6 .
7.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
IN WP NO.29690/2025
BETWEEN
1. MRS SABRINA FLORA BRITTO HOUGAARD
W/O MR. JESPER HOUGAARD,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, RESIDENT OF BRITNAM,
SL MATHIAS ROAD, 1 CROSS, HIGHLANDS,
MANGALURU 575002
2. MRS. CLARA D. MADAVATH @ CLARAMMA,
W/O SANTHOSH JOSEPH,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
RESIDENT OF GREEN HEIGHTS, FALNIR,
MANGALURU -575001
(REPRESENTED BY HER PA HOLDER,
ST
MRS SABRINA BRITTO HOUGAARD-1 PETITIONER)
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. A M VIJAY., ADVOCATE)
AND
1. STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF FOREST,
KARNATAKA GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
TH
7 FLOOR, M. S. BUILDING,
BENGALURU-560001
2. THE CONSERVATOR OF FOREST,
HASSAN DISTRICT, ARANYA BHAVAN,
NEAR DIARY CIRCLE, B.M ROAD,
HASSAN-573201
3. THE DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FOREST,
HASSAN DISTRICT, FOREST MOBILE SQUAD,
ARANYA BHAVAN, NEAR DIARY CIRCLE,
B.M ROAD, HASSAN-573201
4. THE ASSISTANT CONSERVATOR OF FOREST,
AND AUTHORISED OFFICER,
SAKLESHPUR SUB-DIVISION,
SAKLESHPUR-573134,
HASSAN DISTRICT
5. THE FOREST SETTLEMENT OFFICER,
ND
HASSAN AND TUMKUR DIVISION, 2 FLOOR,
ARANYA BHAVAN, DIARY CIRCLE,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
B.M ROAD, HASSAN-573201
6. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER,
HASSAN DISTRICT, HASSAN-573201
…. RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. KIRAN V. RON., AAG)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
QUASHING THE IMPUGNED PROCLAMATIONS ISSUED BY THE 5TH
RESPONDENT DATED 19/07/2023 VIDE ANNEXURE-A TO C INSOFAR AS THE
LANDS OWNED BY THE PETITIONERS ARE CONCERNED AND ETC.
IN WP NO.33767/2025
BETWEEN
1. MR.YOGESH H H
S/O LATE HOOVEGOWDA H M.,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
2. MR. VENKATESHA G E,
S/O LATE EEREGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS,
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
3. MR. RAJEGOWDA G E
S/O EEREGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS,
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT -573165.
4. MR. FRANSIS C C,
S/O CHUMMAR,
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
5. MR. JAYAKUMAR D K
S/O LATE KENCHAPPA D D,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
NADAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPUR TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT -573165.
6. MR. AMRUTHESHWARA H S
S/O LATE SHIVALINGAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
NADAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT -573165
7. MR. SANJAY H.M
S/O MANJUNATH H B,
AGED ABOUT 29 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
8. MR. KARTHIK KODANDARAMA,
S/O LATE GOWDA KODANDARAMA K S,
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS,
AGANI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
9. MR. PRACHETHA KODANDARAMA,
S/O LATE GOWDA KODANDARAMA K S,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
AGANI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
10.SMT. ASHA K T,
W/O LATE KODANDARAMA,
AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS,
AGANI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
11.MRS PARVATHAMMA K B
S/O LATE BAIRAPPA A G,
AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
AGANI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
12.MR BASAVARAJU D K
S/O LATE KENCHAPPA
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS
NADAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
13.MR HARIPRASAD C B
S/O BASAVEGOWDA H P
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
JAMBARADI/KYAMANAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
14.MR HARISH H A
S/O LATE APPALA GOWDA
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS
JAMBARADI/KYAMANAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
15.MR SUDEER A N
S/O LATE MOTEGOWDA
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
JAMBARADI/KYAMANAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
16.MRS YOGEESH M V
S/O LATE VASANTHAPPA M N
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
AGANI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
17.MR BELLIYAPPA P S
S/O LATE SUBBAYYA P K
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
KYAMANAHALLI VILLAGE,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
18.MR SUBASH STEPHEN
S/O STEPHEN K G
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS
ACHAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
19.MR SANTHOSH STEEPHEN
S/O STEPHEN K J
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
20.MR CHANDRA SHEKAR G M
S/O LATE MANJAPPAGOWDA
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS
NADAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
21.MR MANJUNATH B P
S/O LATE PUTTEGOWDA
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
ACHAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
22.SMT LALITHA
W/O MANJUNATH G D
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
NADAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573134
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
23.MR. KUMAR G T,
S/O THAMMANNA,
AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
24.MR. THAMMANNA G R,
S/O LATE RUKME GOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
25.RAKESHA K N
S/O NINGARAJU K T,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
26.MR. BALASUBRAMANYA H R,
S/O LATE RAJU H N,
AGE ABOUT 44 YEARS,
AGANI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
27.NARAYANA REDDY
S/O SUBRAMANYA REDDY D,
AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
AGNI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
28.MOHIYADDIN JUMA MASJID,
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORISED SIGNATORY
MR. NIJAMUDDEEN.
29.MRS. NIRMALA MANJUNATH,
W/O MANJUNATH,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS,
AGANI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT- 573134.
30.MR. JULE GOWDA,
S/O RUKMAYA GOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 76 YEARS,
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
31.MR. BALAKRISHNA
S/O RUKMEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
32.MR. HONNAPPA
S/O LATE ANNEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS,
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
33.SMT. HEMAVATHI,
S/O BHAIRAPPA R K,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
34.MR. INDRESHA,
S/O BHAIRAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
35.MR. UMESH R B,
S/O LATE BILIYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165.
36.MR. SURESH R B,
S/O LATE BILIYAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
37.SMT. KAMALA,
W/O SURESH R B,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
38.SMT. RADHA,
W/O LATE RANGASWAMY,
AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
39.MR. SANTHOSH K J,
S/O LATE JONI,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
40.SMT. LAKSHMI,
W/O LATE JONY,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165.
41.MR. BHASKAR K S,
S/O LATE SHANTHAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
42.MR. JOBY JOSE,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
S/O LATE PILIP,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT -573165.
43.MR. SAIDALVI P H,
S/O LATE HUSSAIN,
AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS,
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT -573165.
(SENIOR CITIZEN BENEFIT NOT CLAIMED)
44.SMT. HEMA
W/O RAJU AR
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
45.MR. NASIR BEG
S/O.AMEER BAIG
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBALU HOBLI,
SAKLESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573134
46.SMT. VANITHA S G
W/O LATE KRISHNA
AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI, SAKLESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165
47.MR. SANGAPPA A R,
S/O LATE RUDRE GOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
AGANI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165
48.DEVARAJ GN
S/O LATE NANJUNDAPPA G E
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
NADAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573134
49.RAJU A
S/O LATE ANAJANAPPA GOWDA
AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
50.MR SHANKARA
S/O SANTHU
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKLESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
51.MR ASHIRVADA K J
S/O JAGADISH K N
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
JAMBARADI VILLAGE HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
52.MR MANJUNATH B A
S/O APPASWAMY B R
AGED ABOUT 76 YEARS
AGANI VILLAGE HANBAL HOBLI
SAKLESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
53.MR ANIL MANJUNATH
S/O MANJUNATH B A
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
AGANI VILLAGE HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
54.MR SIDDARTH NAYAK
S/O SATISH NAYAK
AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
55.MR SATHISH BABU A
S/O AMRENDRA A P
AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
AGANI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
56.MR RAJU H T
S/O LATE TIMMEGOWDA
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
ACHANHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
57.MR BABU PHILIP
S/O PHILIP
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
58.MALI SURESH
S/O LATE SHANKARAPPA M N
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
59.MALI BHARATH
S/O MALI SURESH
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
60.MR RAJASHEKAR A S
S/O LATE SANNAPPAGOWDA A R
AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
AGANI VILLAGE, HANABAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
61.MR JAGADEESH A B
S/O LATE BYREGOWDA
AGE ABOUT 73 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE
HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
62.MR RAMESH B R
S/O RAMEGOWDA
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
AGE ABOUT 60 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTARICT 573165
63.MR PUTTEGOWDAS B R
S/O LATE RAMEGOWDA
AGE ABOUT 62 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANABAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 563135
64.MRS SHILPA T L
W/O GIRISH R
AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANABAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 576165
65.MR MANJUNATH H B
S/O LATE BILI GOWDA
AGE ABOUT 67 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANABAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 563165
66.MR PRAKASH M L
S/O LATE LINGAPPAGOWDA M K
AGE ABOUT 66 YARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHOPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
67.MRS MEGHANA D L
W/O NAVEEN M V
AGE ABOUT 50 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE
HANABAL HOBLI, SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
68.MRS SINDHU SHANOJ
W/O SANOJ KUMAR
AGE ABOUT 46 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
69.MR SUNDARESH B K
S/O LATE KENCHEGOWDA B S
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
AGE ABOUT 66 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
70.MR DINESH KUMAR B A
S/O LATE ANNEGOWDA B K
AGE ABOUT 79 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANABAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
71.MRS ANITHAMMA
W/O LATE ANNEGOWDA B K S
AGE ABOUT 79 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBALL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
72.MRS NAMITHA B A
W/O RATHNAKAR U R
AGE ABOUT 57 YEARS
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
73.MR. SHANKARE GOWDA B A,
S/O ANNEGOWDA B. K,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE , HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
74.MRS.NANDHA B A,
W/O PRAKASH T S,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
75.MR. RAGU H T,
S/O LATE THIMMEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI
SAKALESHPURA TALUK
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
76.MR. ADARSHA H K
S/O LATE KRISHNEGOWDA,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
77.MRS.SHUSHMA G B
D/O BASAVARAJU G D,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
NADAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT- 573134.
78.MRS.GOWRAMMA,
W/O HONNEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 80 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK, HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
79.SMT. SUSHEELA,
W/O LATE LOKESH,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
AGANI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
80.MR. ESHWARA GOWDA A B,
S/O LATE BYREGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK, HASSAN DISTRICT 573165.
81.MR. JAYANNA GOWDA,
S/O LATE RAMEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
82.MRS. SAVITRI B. R.
W/O BOBEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT 573165
83.MRS. GAYATRI H E,
W/O MANJUNATH H B,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
SAKLESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165.
84.MR. RAMACHANDRA AB
S/O LATE BETTEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKALESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573165.
85.SACHIN G.V
S/O VENKATESHA G E
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,
KADUMANE VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI, SAKLESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT – 573165
86.MR. JACOB,
S/O DEVARAJ,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
KADUMANE VILLAGE, HANBAL HOBLI,
SAKLESHPURA TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT- 573165.
87.MR. PRAKASH M C,
S/O LATE CHANDREGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
ACHANAHALLI VILLAGE,
HANBAL HOBLI, SAKLESHPUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT - 573165
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. VINAY N., ADVOCATE)
AND
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE,
M.S. BUILDING,
BENGALURU-560001
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY
2. DEPARTMENT OF KARNATAKA
FOREST, ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY,
TH
ROOM NO.442, 4 FLOOR, M.S BUILDING,
BENGALURU- 560001.
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
3. THE CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
HASSAN CIRCLE, ARANYA BHAVAN,
MILK DIARY CIRCLE, B.M.ROAD,
HASSAN-573201.
4. THE DEPUTY CONSERVATOR
OF FOREST HASSAN CIRCLE,
ARANYA BHAVAN, MILK DIARY CIRCLE,
B.M.ROAD, HASSAN- 573201.
5. THE ASSISTANT CONSERVATOR
OF FOREST SAKLESHPUR SUBDIVISION,
SAKLESHPUR, HASSAN- 573134.
6. RANGE FOREST OFFICER
SAKLESHPURA RANGE,
SAKLESHPUR, HASSAN-573134.
7. THE FOREST SETTLEMENT OFFICER,
HASSAN AND TUMKUR DIVISION,
ST
1 FLOOR, ARANYA BHAVANA,
DAIRY CIRCLE, B. M. ROAD,
HASSAN-573201.
8. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
REVENUE DEPARTMENT, HASSAN DISTRICT,
D.C. OFFICE, B. M. ROAD,
HASSAN-573201
9. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
SAKLESHPUR SUB-DIVISION,
REVENUE DEPARTMENT, A.C.OFFICE, B.M.ROAD,
SAKLESHPUR, HASSAN-573134
10.THE TAHSILDAR
SAKLESHPUR TALUK, TALUK OFFICE,
B.M.ROAD, SAKLESHPUR, HASSAN-573134.
11.THE REGIONAL COMMISSIONER
MYSORE DIVISION, REVENUE DEPARTMENT
R.C. OFFICE, VINOBHA ROAD,
OPP. KALA MANDIR, MYSORE-570005
…. RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. KIRAN V. RON., AAG FOR R1 TO R11)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF CERTIORARI AND
QUASH THE PROCLAMATIONS AND NOTICES ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENT
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
NO.7 BEARING NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-10/2023-24
DATED 19.07.2023 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE-A-2) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-10/2023-24 AND
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2023-24 DATED 19.07.2023
AND 30.06.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURES- B-3 AND B-4 ) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL- 10/2023-24 AND
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024- 25 DATED 19.07.2023
AND 30.06.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURES- C AND C-1 ) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED 26.06.2025
PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- D-1 ) BEARING NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED 26.06.2025 PRODUCED AT
(ANNEXURE- E-1 ) BEARING NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-
09/2024-25 DATED 26.06.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- F-2 ) BEARING
NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED
13.02.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- G-2 ) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 AND
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED 04.06.2024
AND 07.07.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- H-3 AND H-4 ) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-10/2023-24 AND
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2023-24 DATED 19.07.2023
AND 26.06.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURES- K-1 AND K-2 ) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL- 09/2024-25 DATED 07.07.2025
PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- M-2 ) BEARING NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 AND A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED 04.06.2024 AND 07.07.2025
PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURES- N-2 AND N-3 ) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL- 10/2023-24 DATED 09.11.2023
PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- P-1 ) BEARING NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
ADISUCHANE/GL-10/2023-24
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-10/2023-24 DATED
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYAA.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA DATED 09.11.2023
PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- Q-1 ) BEARING NO. 19.07.2023 PRODUCED AT
(ANNEXURE- R-1 ) BEARING NO. ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED
30.06.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- V-1 ) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-10/2023-24 AND
ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED 19.07.2023 AND 07.07.2025
PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURES- X-2 AND X-3 ) BEARING
NO.A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL- 09/2024-25 DATED
30.06.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- Z-1 ) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED 07.07.2025
PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- AA-3 ) BEARING NO. ADISUCHANE/GL-
09/2024-25 DATED AND A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
30.06.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- AB-2 ) BEARING
NO.A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED
04.06.2024 AND 30.06.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURES- AC-2 AND AC-3 )
BEARING NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED
30.06.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- AD-4 ) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED 26.06.2025
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- AE-1 )
BEARING A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA NO.ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-
25(ANNEXURE- AF-2 ) DATED 26.06.2025 PRODUCED AT ADISUCHANE/GL-
09/2024-25 DATED BEARING NO.A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA (ANNEXURE- AG-
1 ) BEARING NO.26.06.2025 PRODUCED ATADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-
25DATEDA.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYAA. VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
(ANNEXURE- AH-1 ) BEARING NO.26.06.2025 PRODUCED
ATADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED 26.06.2025 PRODUCED AT
(ANNEXURE- AJ-1 ) BEARING NO.A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYAADISUCHANE/GL-
09/2024-25
DATED 26.06.2025 PRODUCED AT (ANNEXURE- AK-2 ) BEARING NO.
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYAADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25
DATED 26.06.2025 PRODUCEDAT (ANNEXURE- AL-1 )
BEARING NO.A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25DATED 30.06.2025 PRODUCED AT
(ANNEXURE- AM-3 )
BEARING NO.A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYAADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25DATED
BEARING NO.07.07.2025 PRODUCED AT(ANNEXURE- AN-2 )
DATEDA.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYAADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25
30.06.2025 PRODUCED AT(ANNEXURE- AP-1 ) BEARING
NO.A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-10/2023-24DATED
19.07.2023 PRODUCED AT(ANNEXURE- AQ-1 ) BEARING
NO.A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/GL-10/2023-24 ADISUCHANE/GL-
09/2024-25 AND DATED 19.07.2023 AND 07.07.2025 PRODUCED AT
(ANNEXURE- AR-1 AND AR-2 ) BEARING NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
ADISUCHANE/GL- 10/2023-24 DATED 19.07.2023 PRODUCED AT
(ANNEXURE- AS- 1 ) BEARING NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024- 25 DATED 30.06.2025 PRODUCED AT
(ANNEXURE- AT-1 ) BEARING NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED 04.06.2024 PRODUCED AT
(ANNEXURE- AV-1 ) BEARING NO. A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
ADISUCHANE/GL-09/2024-25 DATED 07.07.2025 PRODUCED AT
(ANNEXURE- AW-2 ) AND CONSEQUENTLY QUASH ALL FURTHER
PROCEEDINGS PURSUANT THERETO AND ETC.
IN WP NO.700/2026
BETWEEN
SRI MANOHAR LAL PATEL
AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS
SON OF LATE RAMDEO PATEL
RIVER VIEW ESTATE
KADUMANE HANBAL HOBLI
SAKLESHPUR TALUK
HASSAN-573 134
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
ALSO AT
C-240, JAL VAYU VIHAR
KALYAN NAGAR
BENGALURU 560 043
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. BHUVANENDRA RAJU P., ADVOCATE)
AND
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
M.S. BUILDING
BENGALURU - 560 001
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY
2. DEPARTMENT OF KARNATAKA FOREST
ENVIRONMENT AND ECOLOGY
TH
ROOM NO 442, 4 FLOOR
M.S. BUILDING BENGALURU - 560 001
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
3. THE CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
HASSAN CIRCLE, ARANYA BHAVAN
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE,
B.M. ROAD HASSAN-573 201
4. THE DEPUTY CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
HASSAN CIRCLE, ARANYA BHAVAN
MILK DAIRY CIRCLE, B.M. ROAD
HASSAN-573 201
5. THE ASSISTANT CONSERVATOR OF FOREST
SAKLESHPUR SUB DIVISION
SAKLESHPUR
HASSAN-573 134
6. RANGE FOREST OFFICER
SAKLESHPUR RANGE
SAKLESHPUR
HASSAN-573 134
7. THE FOREST SETTLEMENT OFFICER
HASSAN AND TUMKUR DIVISION
ST
1 FLOOR, ARANYA BHAVAN
DAIRY CIRCLE, B.M. ROAD
HASSAN-573 201
8. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
REVENUE DEPARTMENT
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
HASSAN DISTRICT, D.C. OFFICE
B.M. ROAD HASSAN 573 201
9. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
SAKLESHPUR SUB DIVISION
REVENUE DEPARTMENT A.C. OFFICE,
B.M. ROAD SAKLESHPUR HASSAN-573 134
10.THE TAHSILDAR
SAKLESHPUR TALUK
TALUK OFFICE, B.M. ROAD
SAKLESHPUR
HASSAN-573 134
11.THE REGIONAL COMMISSIONER
MYSORE DIVISION
REVENUE DEPARTMENT
R.C. OFFICE, VINOBHA ROAD
OPP. KALA MANDIR
MYSORE 570 005
…. RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. KIRAN V. RON., AAG)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI QUASHING THE NOTICE DATED 30.06.2025 BEARING
NO.A.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA NOTIFICATION /GL-09/2024-25 ISSUED
BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT THE DEPUTY CONSERVATION OF FOREST
VIDE ANNEXURE-A AND ETC.
THESE WRIT PETITIONS COMING ON FOR ORDERS AND
HAVING BEEN RESERVED FOR ORDERS ON 27.04.2026, THIS DAY,
THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SURAJ GOVINDARAJ
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
CAV ORDER
1. WP No.29656 of 2024, the Petitioner is before this
court seeking the following reliefs:
1. Issue a writ of certiorari or any other appropriate writ or
order or direction quashing the notices dated 04.06.2024,
28.08.2024 and 10.09.2024 bearing No.A.
Vva:/Hassan/Aranya Adisoochane/GL-09/2024-25 issued by
The Forest Settlement Officer/ Respondent No.13, as per
ANNEXURE G to G2 respectively, and notices dated
20.09.2024 and 18.10.2024 bearing
No.Sakapu/UV/sakapu/Amo-08/2024-25 issued by the Asst
Conservator of Forests, Hassan and Tumkur division,
Hassan/Respondent No.7 ANNEXURE G3 & G4 respectively.
As per
2. Issue a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ or
order or direction, directing the Respondents not to
disturb/interfere with the possession of the Petitioner over
the land in question.
3. Issue any other appropriate writ, order or direction that
deems fit to grant in the circumstances of the case in the
interest of justice and equity.
2. WP No.16251 of 2023, the Petitioners are before this
court seeking the following reliefs:
1. Issue writ in the nature of certiorari and quash the order dated
26/07/2022 passed by the Deputy Conservator of Forest (Forest
Mobile Squad), Hassan District in case number
YOLESUM/ASUMDAL/HASSAN/HOTUVARI/AMO. 60/2022-23 vide
Annexure-J and also the notice dated 18/07/2023 issued by the
th
8 Respondent, i.e., Range Forest Officer, Sakleshpur range vide
Annexure- J-1;
2. And consequently, issue a writ in nature of mandamus and
direct the Respondents 1 to 8 to restore and not to further disturb
the possession of the resort called “Stone Valley Nature Resorts”
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
and also the dwelling house in the schedule land and all their
Belongings;
3. And grant such other order or direction as the case may be to
protect the interest of the Petitioners with respect to the schedule
lands owned by them, in the interest of justice and equity.
4. Issue a Writ declaring that the Notification dated 05.02.1920
published in Mysore Gazette February 12, 1920 No.R 8806-Ft43-
15-6 (Produced as Annexure “M”) has lapsed and has been
abandoned;
5. Issue a Writ of Certiorari and Quash the proclamation dated
09.11.2023 bearing No: A. VYA/Haasan/ ARANYA
ADHISUCHANE/JL-10/2023-24 issued by Respondent No.4
(produced as Annexure-“S”);
3. WP No.19980 of 2023, the Petitioner is before this
court seeking the following reliefs:
I. Issue a Writ of Certiorari and quash the order dated
26.07.2022 bearing No. UTTUVARI/AM.60/2022-23 by
rd
UASM/ASMDL/HASAN/the 3 Respondent (Annexure-K) and
II. Issue a Writ of Certiorari and quash the Notice dated
18.07.2023 bearing No.SAKAPU/VAA/UTTUVARI01 /2023-24
by Respondent No.4 (Annexure-L);
(ii)A. Issue a Writ declaring that the Notification dated
05.02.1920 published in Mysore Gazette February 12, 1920
No. R. 8806-Ft43-15-6 (Produced at Annexure-G) has
lapsed, abandoned and not having any legal effect.
(ii) B. Issue a Writ of Certiorari and quash the Proclamation
dated 09.11.2023 bearing No. A. VYA/HASSANA/ARANYA
ADHISUCHANE/GL-10/2023-24 issued by Respondent No.7
(Annexure-P).
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
III. Pass such orders as deemed fit in the facts and
circumstances of the case in the interest of justice and
equity.
4. WP No.29690 of 2025, the Petitioner is before this
court seeking the following reliefs:
a) Issue a Writ of Certiorari quashing the impugned
th
Proclamations issued by the 5 Respondent dated
19/07/2023 bearing No. AA.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA
ADISUCHANE/JL-10/2023-24 vide Annexure ‘A’ to ‘C’ insofar
as the lands owned by the Petitioners are concerned;
b) Issue a Writ of Certiorari quashing the notices dated
11/08/2025 & 26/08/2025 both in proceedings bearing Nos.
SAKAPU/VUU VE/SAKAPU/AAMO/-201/2021-22, issued by
th st
the 4 Respondent to the 1 Petitioner vide Annexure ‘D’ &
‘E’ and also the Enquiry Notice dated 30/06/2025 issued by
th nd
the 5 Respondent to the 2 Petitioner bearing No.
AA.VYA/HASSAN/ARANYA ADISUCHANE/JL-09/2024-25
VIDE ANNEXURE-F.
c) Issue a Writ of Mandamus directing the Respondents not
to proceed with the enquiry proceedings, initiate penal
action, etc. against the Petitioners in pursuance of the
Mysore Government Notification dated 05/02/1920 bearing
No. R. 8806-Ft-43-15-6-dated 5/2/1920 at Annexure-S and
consequently declare that the Mysore, Government
notification dated 05.02.1920 vide Annexure-S as not
binding on the land of the Petitioner. (Amended as per court
order dated 24.11.2025)
d) Grant such other relief or reliefs that this Hon’ble Court
deems fit in the interest of justice and equity.
5. WP No.33767 of 2025, the Petitioners are before this
court seeking the following reliefs:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:55, Bengaluru
Verified
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
i. Issue a Writ of Certiorari and quash the Proclamations and
Notices issued by the Respondent No.7 Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-10/2023-24 dated
19.07.2023 produced at (Annexure-A-2) by Petitioner No.1;
Bearing No. A. Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
10/2023-24 and A. Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 dated 19.07.2023 and 30.06.2025 produced at
(Annexures-“B-3 and B-4”) by Petitioner No.2; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-10/2023-24 and
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated
19.07.2023 and 30.06.2025 produced at (Annexures-“C and
C-1”) by Petitioner No.3; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated 26.06.2025 produced at
(Annexure-“D-1”) by Petitioner No.4; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated
26.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“E-1”)by Petitioner
No.5; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 dated 26.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“F-
2”)by Petitioner No.6; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated 13.02.2025 produced at
(Annexure-“G-2”) by Petitioner No.7; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 and
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated
04.06.2024 and 07.07.2025 produced at (Annexure-“H-3
and H-4”) by Petitioner No.8 to10; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-10/2023-24 and
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2023-24 dated
19.07.2023 and 26.06.2025 produced at (Annexures-“K-1
and K-2”) by Petitioner No.12; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated
07.07.2025 produced at (Annexure-“M-2”)by Petitioner
No.16; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 and A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 dated 04.06.2024 and 07.07.2025 produced at
(Annexures- “N-2 and N-3”) by Petitioner No.17; Bearing
No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-10/2023-24 dated
09.11.2023 produced at (Annexure-“P-1”) by Petitioner
No.18; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
10/2023-24 dated 09.11.2023 produced at (Annexure-“Q-
1”) by Petitioner No.19; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
Adisuchane/GL-10/2023-24 dated 19.07.2023 produced at
(Annexure-“R-1”)by Petitioner No.20; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated
30.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“V-1”)by Petitioner
No.23 and 24; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
Adisuchane/GL-10/2023-24 and A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated 19.07.2023 and
07.07.2025 produced at (Annexures-“X-2 and X-3”) by
Petitioner No.26; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated 30.06.2025 produced at
(Annexure-“Z-1”)by Petitioner No.28; Bearing No.
Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
07.07.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AA-3”)by Petitioner
No.29; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 dated 30.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AB-
2”)by Petitioner No.30; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/AranyaAdisuchane/GL-09/2024-25and
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated
04.06.2024 and 30.06.2025 produced at (Annexures-“AC-2
and AC-3”) by Petitioner No.31; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated
30.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AD-4”)by Petitioner No.
32; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 dated 26.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AE-
1”)by Petitioner No.34; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated 26.06.2025 produced at
(Annexure-“AF-2”) by Petitioner No.35; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated
26.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AG-1”)by Petitioner
No.36; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 dated 26.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AH-
1”)by A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Petitioner No.38; Bearing No.
dated Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 26.06.2025 produced at
(Annexure-“AJ-1”)by Petitioner No. 39 and 40; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated
26.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AK-2”)by Petitioner
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
No.41; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 dated 26.06.2025 produced at(Annexure-“AL-
1”)by A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Petitioner No.42; Bearing No.
Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated 30.06.2025 produced at
(Annexure-“AM-3”) by Petitioner No.43; Bearing No.
A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated
07.07.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AN-2”)by Petitioner
No.44; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 dated 30.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AP-
1”)by Petitioner No.45; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
19.07.2023 produced at (Annexure-“AQ-1”)by Petitioner
No.46; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
10/2023-24 and A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 dated 19.07.2023 and 07.07.2025 produced at
(Annexure-“AR-1 and AR-2”) by Petitioner No.47; Bearing
No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-10/2023-24 dated
19.07.2023 produced at (Annexure-“AS-1”)by Petitioner
No.48; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya Adisuchane/GL-
09/2024-25 dated 30.06.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AT-
1”)by Petitioner No.49; Bearing No. A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated 04.06.2024 produced at
Adisuchane/GL-10/2023-24 dated (Annexure-“AV-1”)by
Petitioner Bearing No.50; No.A.Vya/Hassan/Aranya
Adisuchane/GL-09/2024-25 dated 07.07.2025 produced at
(Annexure-“AW-2”) by Petitioner No.51 and consequently
quash all further proceedings pursuant thereto;
ii. Issue a Writ of Certiorari and quash the Notices issued by
the Respondent No.5: Bearing No.
SaKaPu/Uvi/SaKaPu/Ottuvari/A.Mo-164/2021-22 dated
04.07.2022 produced at (Annexure-“B-2”) by Petitioner
No.2; Bearing No. SaKaPu/Uvi/SaKaPu/A.Mo-165/2021-22
dated 12.08.2025 produced at (Annexure-“C-2”)by
Petitioner No.3; Bearing No. SaKaPu/Uvi/SakaPu/A.Mo-
09/2024-25 dated 06.11.2024 produced at (Annexure-“J-
2”) by Petitioner No.11; Bearing No.
SaKaPu/Uvi/SakaPu/A.Mo-136/2021-22 dated 11.08.2025
produced at (Annexure-“K-3”) by Petitioner No.12; Bearing
No. SaKaPu/Uvi/SakaPu/A.Mo-82/2022-23 and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
SaKaPu/Uvi/SakaPu/A.Mo-82/2022-23 dated 06.01.2025
and 02.05.2025 produced at (Annexures-“L-2 and L-3”)by
Petitioner No.13 to 15; Bearing No.
SaKaPu/Uvi/SakaPu/A.Mo-250/2021-22 dated 22.05.2024
produced at (Annexure-“S-2”)by Petitioner No.21; Bearing
No. SaKaPu/Uvi/SakaPu/A.Mo- 45/2021-22 dated
11.08.2025 produced at (Annexure-“T-2”) by Petitioner
No.22; Bearing No. SaKaPu/Uvi/SakaPu/A.Mo-247/2021-22
dated 08.09.2025 produced at (Annexure-“W-3”)by
Petitioner No.25; Bearing No. dated
SaKaPu/Uvi/SakaPu/Ottuvari/A.Mo-249/2021-22
08.03.2022 produced at (Annexure-“Y-2”) by Petitioner
no.27; Bearing No. SaKaPu/Uvi/SakaPu/Ottuvari/A.Mo-
92/2021-22 and SaKaPu/Uvi/SaKaPu/A.Mo-92/2021-22
dated 05.05.2022 and 29.08.2025 produced at (Annexure-
“AD-2 and AD-3”) by Petitioner No.32; Bearing No.
SaKaPu/Uvi/SaKaPu/A.Mo-255/2021-22 dated 14.07.2025
produced at (Annexure-“AM-4”)by Petitioner No.43; Bearing
No. SaKaPu/Uvi/SaKaPu/A.Mo-220/2021-22 dated
26.08.2025 produced at (Annexure-“AT-2”) by Petitioner
No.49.
iii. Issue a Writ declaring that the Notification dated
05.02.1920 published in Mysore Gazette February 12, 1920
No.R 8806-Ft43-15-6 (Produced as Annexure-“AAA-3”) has
lapsed/abandoned and consequently delete the name of
Forest Department from the revenue records in respect of
the properties of the Petitioners;
iv. And grant such other order or direction as the case may
be to protect the interest of the Petitioners in the interest of
justice and equity.
6. WP No.700 of 2026, the Petitioner is before this court
seeking the following reliefs:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
I. Issue a writ of certiorari quashing the notice dated
30.06.2025 bearing No. A.VYA/Hassan/Aranya
th
Notification/GL-09/2024-25 issued by the 4 Respondent The
Deputy Conservator of Forest vide Annexure-A;
II. Issue a writ of mandamus directing the Respondents not to
proceed with the enquiry proceedings, initiate penal action,
etc., against the Petitioner in pursuance of Mysore
Government Notification dated 05.02.1920 at Annexure-D;
III. Grant such other relief or reliefs as this Hon’ble Court deems
fit in the interest of justice and equity.
FACTS IN WP NO.16251/2023:
7. The Petitioners claim to be the absolute owners in
possession of the land bearing original Sy. No. 95,
subsequently re-surveyed as Sy. No. 92 and assigned
new Sy. No. 148, which has since been subdivided
into Sy. Nos. 148/1 and 148/2, measuring in all 5
acres and situated at Aachanahalli Village, Hanbal
Hobli, Sakleshpura Taluk, Hassan District.
8. Petitioners Nos. 1 and 2 claim to have purchased the
aforesaid property under a registered sale deed
dated 28.01.2016, executed by the legal heirs of Sri
Joseph Zakaria Vadakel. Following the said purchase,
the Petitioners claim to have developed the property
and established a resort under the name and style of
“Stone Valley Nature Resorts”.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
9. According to the Petitioners, the property originally
belonged to the Revenue Department of the State of
Karnataka and was auctioned by the Revenue
Department through the Amildar. It is their case that,
pursuant to an auction advertisement dated
30.08.1924, an auction in respect of Sy. No. 95 was
conducted on 20.09.1924, in which Sri Byregowda,
son of Sri Annegowda, emerged as the successful
bidder for a sum of Rs. 435/-. The Petitioners further
contend that Sri Byregowda paid the bid amount,
together with interest, aggregating to Rs. 475-12-6
(Rupees four hundred and seventy-five, annas twelve
and pies six only), on 09.11.1924.
10. The Petitioners further state that, subsequent to their
purchase, the property was partitioned under a
registered partition deed dated 02.06.2017.
Following the partition, phodi proceedings were
conducted, and the property was assigned the new
survey numbers, namely, Sy. Nos. 148/1 and 148/2.
According to the Petitioners, the resort and their
dwelling house are situated in Sy. No. 148/1,
whereas no construction has been put up in Sy. No.
148/2.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
11. The Petitioners contend that, pursuant to the sale
deed and the subsequent partition deed, the
necessary mutation entries were effected in their
names on 27.02.2018 and that their names have
been entered in the Record of Rights, Tenancy and
Crops (RTC) from the agricultural year 2023–2024
onwards.
12. The Petitioners further state that, by an order dated
12.06.2019, the property was converted from
agricultural to non-agricultural use for the purpose of
establishing a resort. In support of their claim, they
rely upon the conversion order, which, according to
them, refers to Sy. No. 148/1, measuring 3 acres and
4 guntas, inclusive of 4 guntas of A-Kharab land, and
records its conversion for non-agricultural purposes,
namely, the establishment of a resort.
13. The Petitioners further contend that, pursuant to the
conversion order, they obtained the requisite
permission from the Zilla Panchayat, Hassan, and
proceeded to construct the resort. They also rely
upon the registration of Stone Valley Nature Resorts
LLP, of which they are partners, under the Goods and
Services Tax regime, in support of their claim that
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the resort is being operated as a business
establishment.
14. The grievance of the Petitioners is that Respondents
Nos. 1 to 8 have been initiating proceedings and
registering cases against them without lawful
authority, on the premise that the petition schedule
property belongs to the Forest Department.
According to the Petitioners, the Forest Department
has issued notices and registered First Information
Reports alleging forest offences without duly
considering the documents issued by the Revenue
Department in respect of the property.
15. In this regard, the Petitioners refer to an order dated
26.07.2022 passed by Respondent No. 6, the Deputy
Conservator of Forests, Forest Mobile Squad, Hassan,
pursuant to a complaint lodged by Respondent No. 8,
the Range Forest Officer, Sakleshpura. By the said
order, the Petitioners were alleged to have
encroached upon forest land notified under Section 4
of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, vide
Notification No. R.8806/Ft.43-15-6 dated
05.02.1920. A further notice dated 18.07.2023 was
issued in furtherance of the said proceedings. The
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Petitioners state that similar notices were issued to
other owners of lands situated in the vicinity.
16. The Petitioners contend that the owners of the lands
in the said area submitted representations to the
Revenue Department, complaining that the Forest
Department was asserting rights over their lands in
disregard of the revenue records and seeking
protection against such action.
17. According to the Petitioners, the representations led
to two district-level coordination meetings being
convened at Sakleshpura under the chairmanship of
the Regional Commissioner, Mysuru Division,
attended by officials of both the Forest Department
and the Revenue Department of Hassan District, to
consider the disputes concerning lands situated in
the Moorkangudda area.
18. The Petitioners assert that, during the said
proceedings, it was concluded that the notification
issued under Section 4 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, had been cancelled by the then
Government of Mysore in the year 1924 itself, vide
Government Order No. IC 4239-Ft. 296-22-7 dated
11.01.1924, and that the cancellation had been duly
published in the Gazette.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
19. The Petitioners further rely upon an order dated
08.09.2022 passed by the Regional Commissioner,
Mysuru Division, whereby, according to them, it was
held that the cases initiated by the Forest
Department on the basis of the aforesaid cancelled
notification stood abated and directions were issued
to withdraw the notices issued against the
landowners on the same basis.
20. On the strength of the aforesaid order, the Petitioners
contend that the notification relied upon by the
Forest Department had ceased to operate nearly a
century ago and that the continued initiation of
proceedings against them, notwithstanding the
alleged cancellation of the notification and the
revenue records relied upon by them, amounts to
unlawful interference with their rights over the
petition schedule property.
21. The Petitioners further allege that, on 18.07.2023, at
about 8.00 a.m., approximately 45 officials of the
Forest Department, led by Respondent No. 8, the
Range Forest Officer, Sakleshpura, and allegedly
armed with firearms and lathis, entered the resort
premises and the Petitioners’ dwelling house without
prior notice. They contend that the officials seized
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 41 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
articles found in the premises without drawing a
mahazar and that valuables, including gold and silver
articles, were forcibly removed and have not been
returned to them.
22. Aggrieved by the alleged entry into their premises,
seizure of articles and interference with their
possession and enjoyment of the property, the
Petitioners caused a legal notice dated 21.07.2023 to
be issued to the Respondents, calling upon them to
restore possession of the resort and the dwelling
house and to return the movable articles allegedly
seized. The Petitioners state that the Respondents
have neither complied with the demands made in the
notice nor furnished any response thereto.
23. In these circumstances, alleging that the actions of
the Respondents are without lawful authority and
contrary to the records and proceedings relied upon
by them, the Petitioners have approached this Court
seeking the reliefs prayed for in the petition.
FACTS IN WP NO.19980/2023:
24. The Petitioner claims that he migrated to
Sakleshpura in search of employment and has been
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 42 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
engaged in plantation work since 1970. He states
that he constructed a house in Sy. No. 92, situated at
Hanubalu, Acchana Halli, Hassan District, and has
been cultivating an extent of 4 acres of land in the
said survey number. The Petitioner claims to have
submitted an application in Form No. 57, read with
Section 94 of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act,
seeking regularisation of his unauthorised occupation
of the aforesaid 4 acres of land. He further states
that he submitted a separate application under
Section 94C of the said Act seeking regularisation of
the house constructed by him, measuring
approximately 2,400 square feet.
25. The Petitioner contends that his name is entered in
the tax register maintained by the Devalakere Grama
Panchayat. He further relies upon a letter dated
10.02.2021 issued by the Grama Panchayat, which,
according to him, records that he has been residing
in the property since 2011. He states that electricity
has been supplied to the property pursuant to a No
Objection Certificate issued by the Grama Panchayat
and that he has been regularly paying the applicable
taxes in respect of the property. On this basis, the
Petitioner asserts that the land in Sy. No. 92 falls
within the jurisdiction of the Revenue Department.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 43 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
26. The Petitioner further states that his sons, who are
the Petitioners in W.P. No. 16251/2023, purchased
land bearing original Sy. No. 95, re-surveyed as Sy.
No. 92 and assigned new Sy. No. 148, presently
subdivided into Sy. Nos. 148/1 and 148/2, and
established a resort under the name and style of
“Stone Valley Nature Resorts”. He alleges that the
Forest Department has been subjecting both him and
his sons to undue harassment by asserting that the
lands occupied by them belong to the Forest
Department.
27. The Petitioner contends that the Moorkangudda block
comprises eight villages in the erstwhile Manjarabad
Taluk, presently falling within Sakleshpura Taluk, and
extends over a total area of 7,938 acres and 38
guntas. According to him, a notification dated
05.02.1920 was issued by the erstwhile Maharaja of
Mysore under Section 4 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, in respect of the said area. He
asserts that the aforesaid notification was
subsequently withdrawn by the Government of
Mysore vide Government Order dated 11.01.1924.
28. On the strength of the alleged withdrawal, the
Petitioner contends that the notification dated
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 44 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
05.02.1920 ceased to have effect and that the lands
in question continued to remain revenue lands. He
further asserts that, subsequent to the alleged
withdrawal, the Forest Department did not issue any
notification under the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963,
declaring the lands in question as forest lands or
undertake any forest settlement proceedings for
determining and settling the rights of persons in
occupation, including rights relating to occupation,
cultivation, grazing, water, collection of minor forest
produce, community rights and easementary rights.
Accordingly, the Petitioner maintains that the lands
continue to fall within the administrative control of
the Revenue Department.
29. The Petitioner claims to have been residing in the
property for over three decades and cultivating an
extent of 4 acres of land. However, Respondent No.
2, the Conservator of Forests, initiated proceedings
against him under Section 64A of the Karnataka
Forest Act, 1963, alleging unauthorised
encroachment upon forest land. By an order dated
26.07.2022, Respondent No. 2 held that the land in
question constituted forest land notified under the
notification dated 05.02.1920 and that the
Petitioner’s occupation thereof was unauthorised. The
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 45 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Petitioner states that, pursuant to the said
proceedings, his house was sealed and he was
evicted from the property on 18.07.2023.
30. Thereafter, on 09.11.2023, the Forest Settlement
Officer issued a proclamation notice under Section 5
of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, calling upon the
Petitioner to appear before the Forest Settlement
Officer on 04.12.2023 and produce documents in
support of his claim of ownership over the property.
The Petitioner states that he submitted the relevant
documents before the Forest Settlement Officer
pursuant to the said notice.
31. In the meanwhile, the Assistant Commissioner, by an
order dated 05.06.2025, rejected the Petitioner’s
application for regularisation of his occupation of the
land. Aggrieved by the said order, the Petitioner
preferred an appeal before the Deputy Commissioner,
which, according to him, is pending consideration.
32. The Petitioner further relies upon the proceedings of
the second district-level coordination meeting held on
08.09.2022 under the chairmanship of the Regional
Commissioner, Mysuru Division. According to the
Petitioner, at the said meeting, Respondent No. 3,
the Deputy Conservator of Forests, was directed to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 46 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
withdraw all forest offence cases initiated against
persons and farmers on the basis of the notification
issued under Section 4 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, dated 05.02.1920. The Petitioner
contends that Respondents Nos. 3 and 4 participated
in the said meeting and that the direction to
withdraw the cases was issued in their presence.
33. The Petitioner states that, in view of the aforesaid
proceedings, he was under the bona fide impression
that the notices and proceedings initiated by the
Forest Department on the basis of the notification
dated 05.02.1920 had been withdrawn. He
nevertheless alleges that the Forest Department
continued to assert its claim over the property and
proceeded against him notwithstanding the said
proceedings and the documents relied upon by him.
34. In these circumstances, contending that the action of
the Forest Department is without lawful authority,
that the notification relied upon by it had been
withdrawn in 1924 and that his long-standing
occupation and cultivation of the land have not been
duly considered, the Petitioner has approached this
Court seeking the reliefs prayed for in the writ
petition.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 47 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
FACTS IN WP NO.29656/2024
35. The Petitioner claims to be a registered partnership
firm engaged in the hospitality business. It is stated
that the Petitioner’s predecessors in title, namely, Sri
B.P. Yageshwar, Smt. M.B. Sarala, Sri A.Y. Nachiket
and Sri A.Y. Poorvika, were the owners of lands
bearing Sy. Nos. 102 and 198, measuring 5 acres
and 38 guntas and 5 acres and 23 guntas,
respectively, situated at Agani Grama, Kyamanahalli
Mandal Panchayat, Hanubala Hobli, Sakleshpura
Taluk, Hassan District.
36. The Petitioner states that it purchased the aforesaid
lands from the said owners under a registered sale
deed dated 19.01.2011. Subsequently, the Petitioner
obtained an order dated 13.06.2014 converting the
lands from agricultural to non-agricultural use for
commercial resort purposes. The Petitioner further
states that its application for establishing a resort
was approved by the Joint Director, Rural and Urban
Development, Mysuru. It also obtained a No
Objection Certificate from the Karnataka State
Pollution Control Board and approval of the layout
plan from the Panchayat Development Officer,
Moorkangudda, Sakleshpura Taluk.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 48 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
37. The Petitioner further claims that the property was
duly surveyed and an e-Khata was issued in its
name. Pursuant to the aforesaid approvals, the
Petitioner developed a resort on the property, which
is stated to be fully operational and to employ
approximately 30 persons.
38. The grievance of the Petitioner arises from notices
dated 04.06.2024, 28.08.2024 and 10.09.2024
issued by Respondent No. 13, the Forest Settlement
Officer (FSO), under the provisions of the Karnataka
Forest Act, 1963. By the said notices, the Petitioner
was informed that a preliminary notification dated
05.02.1920 had been issued in respect of the lands
in question, proposing to constitute the area as
forest land. Since the Petitioner’s lands were stated
to fall within the boundaries of the Moorkangudda
block, the Petitioner was called upon to appear
before the Forest Settlement Officer and produce the
relevant documents in support of its claims and
objections.
39. The Petitioner contends that, although a notification
dated 05.02.1920 was issued under Section 4 of the
Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, and published in the
Mysore Gazette on 12.02.1920, the proposal to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 49 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
constitute the Moorkangudda block as a State Forest
was subsequently dropped by the Government of the
erstwhile State of Mysore, vide Government Order
dated 11.01.1924. According to the Petitioner, by the
said order, the proposal to constitute the area as a
State Forest was abandoned and the Revenue
Department was directed to withdraw the acquisition
proceedings relating to the lands proposed to be
included within the Moorkangudda State Forest.
40. On the basis of the aforesaid Government Order, the
Petitioner asserts that the notification dated
05.02.1920 ceased to have effect and cannot be
relied upon by the Forest Department to assert
jurisdiction over the lands in question. Consequently,
the Petitioner contends that Respondent No. 13 had
no jurisdiction to issue the impugned notices calling
upon it to appear before the Forest Settlement
Officer and establish its rights over the property.
41. The Petitioner further states that, upon receipt of
similar notices from the Forest Department, the
owners of lands situated in the surrounding area
submitted representations to the Revenue
Department, alleging that the Forest Department was
asserting claims over their lands in disregard of the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 50 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
existing revenue records. According to the Petitioner,
the matter was thereafter considered at district-level
coordination meetings convened under the
chairmanship of the Regional Commissioner, Mysuru
Division.
42. The Petitioner contends that, upon consideration of
the matter, the Regional Commissioner concluded
that the notification issued under Section 4 of the
Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, had been cancelled
in the year 1924 itself. The Petitioner relies upon the
said proceedings to contend that the Forest
Department cannot continue to initiate proceedings
against landowners on the basis of the notification
dated 05.02.1920.
43. Despite the aforesaid Government Order and the
proceedings before the Regional Commissioner,
Respondent No. 13 is stated to have persisted with
the issuance of notices dated 04.06.2024,
28.08.2024 and 10.09.2024, calling upon the
Petitioner to appear before the Forest Settlement
Officer and produce documents in support of its
claims and objections concerning the petition
schedule property.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 51 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
44. Aggrieved by the issuance of the said notices, and
contending that the same are without jurisdiction in
view of the alleged withdrawal of the notification
dated 05.02.1920, the Petitioner has approached this
Court seeking the reliefs prayed for in the writ
petition.
FACTS IN WP NO.33767/2025 :
45. The present writ petition has been filed by 87
Petitioners, who claim to have a common cause of
action in respect of the subject matter of the
proceedings. Petitioners Nos. 1 to 29 claim to have
acquired their respective portions of land under
registered sale deeds, partition deeds, wills and other
instruments of transfer or devolution of title.
46. Petitioners Nos. 30 to 51 state that they were in
unauthorised occupation of portions of the land and
had submitted applications seeking regularisation of
such occupation. According to them, their
applications were allowed and their unauthorised
occupation was accordingly regularised by the
competent authority.
47. Petitioners Nos. 52 to 87 claim to be the owners of
their respective portions of land. The Petitioners have
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 52 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
approached this Court jointly, asserting a common
grievance in relation to the subject matter of the writ
petition and seeking the reliefs prayed for therein.
48. The claim of the Petitioners is tabulated hereunder
for ease of reference:
PETITIONER
NUMBER
SURVEY NUMBER
EXTENT LOCATION
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
2 acres 11
1 Sy.No.161/1
guntas
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Sy.No.176/3 and
2
Sy.No.176/6
22 guntas and 13
guntas
3 guntas and 10
3 Sy. No.76
guntas
Not explicitly
mentioned
6 acres 14
guntas, 2 acres
and 5 acres 22
guntas along with
18 guntas kharab
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Sy.No.89, 92/p
4
and 162
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Sy.No.88p,
Sy.No.197 (old
Sy.No.362)
6 acres and 2
acres 7 guntas
5
Nadahalli village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
6 Sy.No.197/paiki 10 acres
2 acres 22
guntas (including
15 guntas
kharab)
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
7 Sy.No.137
1 acre 23 guntas,
1 acre 23 guntas
and 2 acres 14
guntas
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Sy.No.216/p,
8, 9
216/p and 103
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Included with
10 Sy.No.103
Petitioners 8 & 9
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 53 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
11 Sy.No.197 2 acres 5 guntas
8 acres 10
guntas (for
Sy.No.197)
Nadahalli village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Sy.No.362,
12
Sy.No.197
Jambaradi
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
8 acres 13
13, 14, 15 Sy.No.14
guntas
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
9 Acres 29
16 Sy.No.186
Guntas
Kyamanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
17 Sy.No.142 (300) 7 acres 3 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
8 acres 36
18 Sy.No.153
guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
5 acres 36
19 Sy.No.157 /2
guntas
Nadahalli village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
20 Sy.No. 197 1 acre 26 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
2 acres 14
21 Sy.No.154
guntas
Nadahalli village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
22 Sy.No.197/p 3 acres
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
2 acres 30
23, 24 Sy.No.78
guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Sy.No. 91/2 and
25
91/3
26 guntas and 38
guntas
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
4 acres 10
26 Sy.No.104
guntas
Achanahalli
27 Sy.No.133 3 acres 4 guntas
village, Hanubalu
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 54 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Sy.No.164
28 2 acres
(Masjid)
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
6 acres 21
29 Sy.No.183
guntas
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Not Specified
(House
constructed)
30 Sy.No. 76
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Not Specified
(House
constructed)
31 Sy.No. 88
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Sy. No. 88 (old
32 2 guntas
No.76)
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
33, 34 Sy.No.45 1.12 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
35 Sy.No.92 24 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
36, 37 Sy.No.45 1.18 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
38 Sy.No.92 1.18 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
39, 40 Sy.No.92 1.18 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
41 Sy No.92 3 acres
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
42 Survey No. 39 02 guntas
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 55 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Sakleshpur Taluk
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
43 Sy.No.88 02 guntas
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
44 Sy. No. 103 1.12 Guntas
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
4 acres and 18
45 Sy. No. 88/1
guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
46 Sy.No.92 0.2 guntas
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
47 Sy.No.103 2 acres 9 guntas
Nadahalli village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
48 Sy.No.197 2 acres
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
49 Sy.No. 88 0.1 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
Not Specified
(House
constructed)
50 Sy.No.124
Jambaradi
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
51 Sy.No. 22 2 acres 5 guntas
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
52, 53 Sy.No.182 4 acres
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
4 acres 23
guntas and 13
guntas Kharab
54 Sy.No.161/2
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
1 acre 34 guntas
55 Sy.No.179
6 guntas Kharab
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
56 Sy. No.92 1 acre
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 56 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Sakleshpur Taluk
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
57 Sy.No.93 2 Acres
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
4 acres 22
guntas and 4
acres 20 guntas
Sy. No.142 and
58, 59
Sy.No.141
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
60 Sy.No.103 2 Acres
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
61 Sy.No.166 6 Acres
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
62 Sy.No.93 2 Acres
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
63 Sy.No.93 1 acre 20 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
2 acres 20
64 Sy.No.163
guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
2 acres 20
65 Sy.No.163
guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
66 Sy.No.98 4 Acres
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
67, 68 Sy.No.97 5 acres
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
7 acres 26
69 Sy.No.140
guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
70, 71, 72, 73, 2 Acres 10
Sy.No.134
74 guntas
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 57 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
75 Sy.No.92 1 Acre
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
76 Sy.No.136 1 Acre 2 guntas
Nadahalli village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
2 Acres 28
77 Sy.No.371
Guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
78 Sy.No.92 3 acres
Agani village,
Hanubalu Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
79 Sy.No.103 1.12 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
3 acres 22
80 Sy.No.174
guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
81, 82 Sy.No.92 2 acres
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
83 Sy.No.41 0.2 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
84 Sy.No.178 1 acre 31 guntas
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
85 Sy.No.176 12 guntas
Kadumane
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
86 Sy.No.76 2 guntas
Achanahalli
village, Hanubalu
Hobli,
Sakleshpur Taluk
87 Sy.No.92 4 acres
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 58 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
49. The Petitioners contend that, upon issuance of
notices by the Forest Settlement Officer (FSO), they
submitted representations to the Revenue
Department, raising objections to the assertion of
forest rights over the lands in question. They further
state that the issues concerning their lands were
considered at the district-level coordination meetings
held on 10.06.2022 and 08.09.2022 under the
chairmanship of the Regional Commissioner, Mysuru
Division. According to the Petitioners, the directions
issued by the Regional Commissioner in the said
proceedings are equally applicable to their cases. On
this basis, the Petitioners contend that the continued
issuance of proclamation notices under Section 5 of
the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, and the initiation or
continuation of proceedings under Section 64A(1) of
the said Act by the Forest Department are without
jurisdiction and contrary to the directions issued by
the Regional Commissioner. Aggrieved thereby, the
Petitioners have approached this Court seeking the
reliefs prayed for in the writ petition.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 59 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
FACTS IN WP NO.29690/2025:
50. Petitioner No. 1 claims to be the absolute owner in
possession and enjoyment of a coffee plantation
measuring 14 acres and 20 guntas, comprised in Sy.
Nos. 80, 177, 178, 179, 151/P and 133
(corresponding to old Sy. Nos. 88 and 88/P), situated
at Kadumane Village, Hanubalu Hobli, Sakleshpura
Taluk, Hassan District. Petitioner No. 1 states that
the said lands were acquired under four registered
sale deeds, three dated 30.08.2008 and the fourth
dated 06.07.2017.
51. Petitioner No. 2 claims to be the absolute owner in
possession and enjoyment of 7 acres of land,
inclusive of 10 guntas of kharab land, in Sy. No. 148
of the same village, having purchased the same
under a registered sale deed dated 22.11.2006.
52. The Petitioners state that, pursuant to their
respective purchases, the revenue records were
mutated in their names, and their names were
entered in the Record of Rights, Tenancy and Crops
(RTC). Petitioner No. 2 further states that a house
was constructed in the erstwhile Sy. No. 88/P, which
subsequently came within the Gramathana limits.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 60 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
53. The Petitioners contend that, during the period
between 1952 and 1961, the State Government
granted different extents of land in Sy. Nos. 88 and
88/P of Kadumane Village to various persons who
were in occupation of or cultivating the said lands, by
issuing saguvali chits. According to the Petitioners,
the lands forming part of their respective properties
were originally granted to Sri Hasan Koya, from
whom portions of the lands were purchased by them.
The remaining portions were acquired from
subsequent purchasers who had derived title from
other original grantees.
54. The Petitioners challenge the show-cause notices
issued during the year 2022 under Section 64(1) of
the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, alleging
contravention of Sections 24(g), 24(gg), 24(h),
73(d) and 104 of the said Act, as well as Section 2(a)
of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980. The notices
allege that the Petitioners have encroached upon
forest land situated in Sy. No. 76 of Kadumane
Village.
55. The Petitioners contend that the allegations are
devoid of any factual or legal basis, having regard to
their registered sale deeds, the revenue entries
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 61 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
standing in their names and the historical grants
evidenced by the saguvali chits.
56. The Petitioners further state that, pursuant to the
aforesaid proceedings, Respondent No. 5, the Forest
Settlement Officer (FSO), issued a proclamation
dated 19.07.2023 concerning the proposal to
constitute the Moorkangudda block as a Reserved
Forest, relying upon the notification dated
05.02.1920.
57. The Petitioners contend that the notification dated
05.02.1920, issued under Section 4 of the Mysore
Forest Regulation, 1900, had been withdrawn in its
entirety by a subsequent notification or Government
Order dated 11.01.1924. On that basis, they assert
that the earlier notification could not be relied upon
to initiate or continue forest settlement proceedings
in respect of the lands in question and that the
Forest Settlement Officer could not proceed on the
premise that the proposal to constitute the
Moorkangudda block as a Reserved Forest remained
operative.
58. In these circumstances, the Petitioners contend that
the show-cause notices issued under Section 64(1) of
the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, and the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 62 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
proclamation dated 19.07.2023 issued by the Forest
Settlement Officer are unsustainable in law.
Accordingly, they have approached this Court seeking
the reliefs prayed for in the writ petition.
FACTS IN WP NO.700/2026 :
59. The Petitioner claims to be the absolute owner in
possession and enjoyment of coffee plantation lands
measuring in all 52 acres and 5 guntas, comprised in
Sy. Nos. 142, 66, 65, 64, 76 and 113 of Kadumane
Village, Hanbal Hobli, Sakleshpura Taluk, Hassan
District; Sy. Nos. 61, 63, 136 and 135 of Mulehadlu
Kadumane Village, Hanbal Hobli, Sakleshpura Taluk,
Hassan District; and Sy. Nos. 422 and 423 of
Heggadde Village, Hanbal Hobli, Sakleshpura Taluk,
Hassan District. The Petitioner states that the
aforesaid lands were purchased under a registered
sale deed dated 24.06.1988 in the name of a
partnership firm styled “River View Estates”. The
Petitioner further claims that its name has been
entered in the Record of Rights, Tenancy and Crops
(RTC) in respect of the said lands and that coffee and
pepper are being cultivated thereon.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 63 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
60. The Petitioner states that a notice dated 30.06.2025
was issued to it under Section 7 of the Karnataka
Forest Act, 1963. According to the Petitioner, no
other notice has been served upon it, nor have any
proceedings been initiated against it under Section
64A(1) of the said Act.
61. The Petitioner further contends that, although
proclamation notices under Section 5 of the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, have been issued in
respect of lands belonging to other landowners and
plantation owners in the vicinity, no such
proclamation has been issued in respect of the lands
claimed by the Petitioner, nor has any such
proclamation been served upon it.
62. The Petitioner states that, in view of the proceedings
initiated by the Forest Department against other
landowners and plantation owners in the surrounding
area, it apprehends that similar proceedings may be
initiated in respect of its lands. Aggrieved by the
notice dated 30.06.2025 and apprehending further
action by the Forest Department against the lands in
its possession, the Petitioner has approached this
Court seeking the reliefs prayed for in the writ
petition.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 64 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
SUBMISSIONS OF THE LEARNED COUNSEL FOR
PETITIONERS:
63. Sri.Manmohan P N, learned counsel for the
Petitioner/s in WP No.16251/2023, WP
No.29656/2024 and WP No.19980/2023 submits
that:
63.1. The lands in question do not belong to the
Forest Department and continue to fall within
the jurisdiction and administrative control of the
Revenue Department. He submits that the
proposal to constitute the Moorkangudda block
as a State Forest, pursuant to the notification
dated 05.02.1920 issued under Section 4 of the
Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, was dropped
by the Government of Mysore vide Government
Order dated 11.01.1924. Consequently, the
notification ceased to have effect, and the
Forest Department cannot claim jurisdiction
over the Petitioners’ lands on the basis of the
said notification.
63.2. He further submits that the lands in question
were granted by the Revenue Department to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 65 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the predecessors-in-title of the Petitioners and
that such grants must be given their full legal
effect. In the absence of any challenge to the
grants made by the competent Revenue
authorities, the Forest Department cannot
disregard the grants and the consequential
revenue records and assert jurisdiction over the
lands in question.
63.3. Learned counsel reiterates that, the notification
dated 05.02.1920 having been withdrawn in
1924, the initiation of proceedings by the Forest
Settlement Officer (FSO) nearly a century later
is wholly without jurisdiction. In the alternative,
he submits that, even assuming that the
notification continues to subsist, the initiation of
proceedings after a lapse of approximately 100
years is beyond any reasonable period and is,
therefore, unsustainable in law. According to
him, the Forest Settlement Officer was required
to initiate and conclude the statutory
proceedings within a reasonable time, and a
delay of such magnitude cannot be justified.
63.4. He further contends that the Range Forest
Officer (RFO) has acted beyond the authority
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 66 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
conferred upon him and that the impugned
actions are illegal and actuated by mala fides.
63.5. Learned counsel submits that, even assuming
that the notification dated 05.02.1920
continues to remain in force, the Forest
Department could not have summarily evicted
the Petitioners without completing the statutory
procedure prescribed for constitution of a
Reserved Forest under the applicable forest
legislation. He contends that the mere
existence of a notification under Section 4 of
the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, does not,
by itself, authorise the Forest Department to
dispossess the Petitioners from the lands in
question.
63.6. He further submits that, unless the statutory
proceedings contemplated under the Mysore
Forest Regulation, 1900, had been completed
and a final notification under Section 17 thereof
had been issued, the Respondents could not
invoke Section 64A of the Karnataka Forest Act,
1963, to dispossess the Petitioners on the
premise that the lands had acquired the status
of forest land. He also contends that, upon
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 67 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
repeal of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900,
by the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, any action
by the Forest Department must be traceable to
the powers conferred under the latter
enactment and undertaken in accordance with
the procedure prescribed therein.
63.7. Learned counsel further submits that the
concept of a deemed forest cannot be invoked
as an independent legal basis to dispossess
persons who are in settled possession of land.
He contends that the Respondents cannot rely
upon a purported deeming fiction, without
establishing the legal status of the land and the
applicability of the relevant statutory
provisions, to justify the eviction of the
Petitioners.
63.8. With regard to the survey sketch relied upon by
the RFO, learned counsel submits that no
survey was conducted in the presence of the
Petitioners or after affording them an
opportunity to participate in the proceedings.
He contends that the sketch relied upon by the
Forest Department is based upon a unilateral
survey conducted by its officials in 2019 and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 68 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
that the Petitioners were neither associated
with the survey nor afforded an opportunity to
raise objections regarding the identification and
boundaries of the lands. On this basis, he
disputes the evidentiary value of the survey
sketch and contends that the Forest
Department cannot assert its claim over the
Petitioners’ lands solely on the strength of such
a unilateral exercise.
63.9. Learned counsel questions the competence of
the authority who initiated the proceedings and
passed the impugned orders. He submits that
the orders in question were passed by the
Deputy Conservator of Forests, Forest Mobile
Squad, Hassan, who, according to him, is not
the authority competent to exercise the powers
contemplated under Section 64A of the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963. He therefore
contends that the impugned proceedings are
vitiated for want of jurisdiction and are liable to
be set aside.
63.10. Section 64A is reproduced hereunder for ease
of reference:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 69 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
64A. Penalty for unauthorisedly taking
possession of land constituted as reserved
forest, 2[district forest, village forest, protected
forest and any other land under the control of
the Forest Department .—(1) Any person
unauthorisedly occupying any land in reserved forest,
2[district forest, village forest, protected forest and
any other land under the control of the Forest
Department may, without prejudice to any other
action that may be taken against him under any other
provision of this Act or any other law for the time
being in force, be summarily evicted, by a Forest
Officer not below the rank of an Assistant Conservator
of Forests and any crop including trees raised in the
land and any building or other construction erected
thereon shall, if not removed by him within such time
as the Forest Officer may fix, be liable to forfeiture:
Provided that before evicting a person under this sub-
section he shall be given a reasonable opportunity of
being heard.
(2) Any property forfeited under sub-section (1) shall
be disposed of in such manner as the Forest Officer
may direct and the cost of removal of any crop,
building or other work and of all works necessary to
restore the land to its original condition shall be
recoverable from the person evicted in the manner
provided in section 109.
(3) Any person aggrieved by an order of the Forest
Officer under sub-section (1) may, within such period
and in such manner as may be prescribed, appeal
against such order to the State Government or to such
officer as may be authorised by the State Government
in this behalf and the order of the Forest Officer shall,
subject to the decision in such appeal, be final.
63.11. By referring to Section 64A he submits that the
exercise of power of summary eviction under
the said provision is contingent upon the land in
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 70 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
question falling within one of the categories
specified therein, namely, reserved forest,
district forest, village forest, protected forest or
any other land under the control of the Forest
Department. He contends that, in the present
case, the lands in question neither constitute
reserved forest nor have been established to be
under the control of the Forest Department. On
the contrary, according to him, the lands
continue to fall within the jurisdiction and
control of the Revenue Department.
Consequently, the essential jurisdictional
requirement for invoking Section 64A of the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, is not satisfied.
63.12. Learned counsel further draws attention to the
express stipulation in sub-section (1) of Section
64A that the power of summary eviction may
be exercised only by a Forest Officer not below
the rank of an Assistant Conservator of Forests.
He submits that the authority which initiated
the impugned proceedings and passed the
orders in question lacks the requisite statutory
competence to exercise the said power. He
therefore contends that the impugned
proceedings are vitiated both for want of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 71 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
jurisdiction over the lands in question and for
non-compliance with the statutory requirement
concerning the rank and competence of the
officer authorised to order eviction.
63.13. Learned counsel submits that, although the
Deputy Conservator of Forests is a rank higher
than that of an Assistant Conservator of
Forests, the Deputy Conservator of Forests who
initiated the impugned action in the present
case is attached to the Mobile Squad and is not
the officer having territorial jurisdiction over the
lands in question. He contends that the officer’s
rank, by itself, does not establish his
competence to initiate the proceedings in
respect of the particular properties, and that
the jurisdiction of the officer concerned must
also be established.
63.14. Learned counsel further submits that, in some
cases, the lands were auctioned by the Revenue
Department and purchased by private
individuals, who subsequently obtained
conversion of the lands from agricultural to
non-agricultural use, including for commercial
resort purposes. According to him, the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 72 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
purchasers obtained the requisite licences and
registrations from the concerned departments
to carry on their businesses and invested
substantial amounts in the construction and
development of the resorts. He contends that
the concerned authorities have failed to take
into consideration the equities arising from
these transactions, the permissions and
licences granted, and the substantial
investments made by the Petitioners before
initiating the impugned proceedings.
63.15. As regards the proclamation, he refers to
Section 5 of the Act of 1963 which is
reproduced hereunder for his reference:
5. Proclamation by Forest Settlement Officer .—
When a notification has been issued under section 4,
the Forest Settlement Officer shall publish in Kannada
and in any other regional language of the area, at the
headquarters of each taluk in which any portion of the
land comprised in such notification is situate and in
every town and village in the neighbourhood of such
land a proclamation,—
(a) specifying, as nearly as possible, the situation and
limits of the proposed forest;
(b) setting forth the substance of the provisions of
section 6;
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 73 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
(c) explaining the consequences which, as hereinafter
provided, will ensue on such forest being constituted a
reserved forest; and
(d) fixing a period of not less than three months from
the date of publishing such proclamation, and
requiring every person claiming any right or making
any claim referred to or mentioned in section 4, either
to present to such officer within such period a written
notice specifying or to appear before him within such
period and state the nature of such right or claim (if
any) and in either case to produce all documents in
support thereof.
The Forest Settlement Officer shall also serve a notice
to the same effect on every known or reputed owner
or occupier of any land included in or adjoining the
land proposed to be constituted a reserved forest or
on his recognised agent or manager. Such notice may
be sent by registered post to persons residing beyond
the limits of the district in which such land is situate.
63.16. By referring to Section 5, he submits that
Section 5 prescribes the procedure to be
followed upon issuance of a notification under
Section 4 of the said Act. The provision requires
publication of a proclamation in Kannada and
any other regional language of the area,
specifying the situation and limits of the
proposed forest, setting forth the substance of
Section 6, explaining the consequences of
constitution of the forest as a reserved forest,
and calling upon persons claiming any right or
interest in the land to submit their claims within
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 74 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the prescribed period. Section 5 further
requires the Forest Settlement Officer to serve
a notice to the same effect on every known or
reputed owner or occupier of land included in or
adjoining the land proposed to be constituted
as a reserved forest, or on such person’s
recognised agent or manager.
63.17. Placing reliance on Section 5 of the Karnataka
Forest Act, 1963, learned counsel submits that
individual notice to every known or reputed
owner or occupier of the land in question, or to
such person’s recognised agent or manager, is a
mandatory procedural requirement. He
contends that, in the present case, no such
notice was served on the Petitioners
subsequent to the issuance of the notification
under Section 4, much less was the procedure
prescribed under Section 5 complied with.
Accordingly, he submits that the proceedings
are vitiated by non-compliance with the
statutory requirements governing the
settlement of rights in the proposed reserved
forest.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 75 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
63.18. Learned counsel submits that several rights in
favour of the Petitioners came to be created
after 1920 and, more particularly, after the
cancellation of the notification in 1924. In the
circumstances, he contends that reliance on the
notification issued in 1920 is misplaced. He
further submits that, if the Respondents intend
to constitute the lands in question as a
reserved forest, they must recommence the
proceedings de novo under the Karnataka
Forest Act, 1963, by following the procedure
prescribed therein from the inception.
63.19. Learned counsel contends that, in the absence
of such fresh proceedings, all actions taken
pursuant to the notification of 1920, which has
been cancelled in 1924, are non est in law and
are not binding on the Petitioners. He further
submits that, once the notification issued under
the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, ceased to
be in force, a proclamation under Section 5 of
the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, could not have
been issued without a valid notification under
Section 4 of the said Act. Accordingly, he
argues that the impugned actions of the
Respondents are contrary to the applicable
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 76 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
statutory provisions and are liable to be set
aside.
63.20. He refers to Section 4 of the Regulations of
1900 which is reproduced hereunder for ease of
reference:
Notification by Government
4. Whenever it is proposed to constitute any land a State
Forest, the Government shall publish a notification in the
official Gazette-
(a) specifying as nearly as possible the situation and
limits of such land;
(b) declaring that it is proposed to constitute such land a
State Forest; and
(c) appointing an officer (hereinafter called “the Forest
Settlement Officer”) to inquire into and determine the
existence, nature and extent of any rights claimed by, or
alleged to exist in favour of any person in or over any
land comprised within such limits, or to any forest
produce of such land, and to deal with the same as
provided in this chapter.
The officer appointed under clause (c) of this section shall
ordinarily be a person other than a Forest Officer; but a
Forest Officer may be appointed by the Government to
assist the Forest Settlement Officer in the inquiry
prescribed by this chapter.
63.21. Learned counsel refers to Section 4 of the
Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, which provides
for the issuance of a notification in the Official
Gazette whenever it is proposed to constitute
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 77 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
any land as a State Forest. The provision
requires the notification to specify, as nearly as
possible, the situation and limits of the land
proposed to be constituted as a State Forest,
declare such proposal, and appoint a Forest
Settlement Officer to inquire into and determine
the existence, nature and extent of the rights
claimed by, or alleged to exist in favour of, any
person in or over the land or in respect of the
forest produce thereof.
63.22. Placing reliance on Section 4 of the Mysore
Forest Regulation, 1900, learned counsel
submits that the provision contemplates the
publication of a proposal to constitute land as a
State Forest and is not pari materia with
Section 4 of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963.
Drawing a comparison between the two
provisions, he contends that, while Section 4 of
the Regulation contemplates a proposal to
constitute land as a State Forest, Section 4 of
the Act of 1963 provides for the initiation of
proceedings for constituting land as a reserved
forest under the statutory framework of the
said Act. He submits that, in the absence of
proceedings initiated under Section 4 of the Act
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 78 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
of 1963, the Respondents could not have
resorted to Section 5 thereof after the lapse of
nearly a century by relying upon the cancelled
notification issued in 1920.
63.23. Learned counsel further contends that, even
assuming that the proposal contained in the
notification issued in 1920 continued to subsist,
it remained only a proposal to constitute the
land as a State Forest and could not, by itself,
be treated as a decision to constitute the land
as a reserved forest under the Act of 1963.
According to him, the statutory scheme under
the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, differs
from that under the Karnataka Forest Act,
1963, and the two cannot be treated as
interchangeable for the purpose of initiating or
continuing proceedings for constitution of a
reserved forest.
63.24. Referring to the procedure contemplated under
the Regulation, learned counsel submits that,
upon publication of a notification under Section
4, the Forest Settlement Officer was required to
publish a proclamation in the prescribed
manner, specifying, as nearly as possible, the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 79 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
situation and limits of the proposed forest,
setting forth the substance of the relevant
provisions concerning claims to rights,
explaining the consequences of the proposed
constitution of the land as a State Forest, and
fixing a period of not less than three months for
persons claiming rights or interests in the land
to submit their claims or appear before the
Forest Settlement Officer and produce
supporting documents. He contends that the
statutory process under the Regulation was
distinct from that prescribed under the Act of
1963 and that the Respondents could not rely
upon the former notification to dispense with
the initiation and compliance of proceedings
under the latter enactment.
63.25. Learned counsel submits that the time limit
prescribed under the Mysore Forest Regulation,
1900, underscores the importance of adhering
to the statutory timeline and completing the
prescribed process within a reasonable period.
Upon publication of the notification, the Forest
Settlement Officer was required to issue a
proclamation calling upon persons claiming
rights or interests in the land to submit their
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 80 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
claims or objections within the prescribed
period of not less than three months from the
date of publication of the proclamation.
63.26. He contends that no such proclamation was
issued by the Forest Settlement Officer under
the relevant provisions of the Regulation
following the notification issued in 1920.
Consequently, even assuming that the
notification of 1920 continued to remain in
force, notwithstanding its cancellation in 1924,
the Respondents could not seek to rely upon it
after the lapse of nearly a century without
having undertaken the consequential statutory
proceedings within a reasonable period.
According to learned counsel, the prolonged
inaction and failure to follow the prescribed
procedure have rendered the reliance placed on
the notification untenable.
63.27. Learned counsel further refers to Section 7 of
the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, which is
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 81 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
7. Enquiry by Forest Settlement Officer
The Forest Settlement Officer shall take down in
writing all statements made under Section 5(d), and
shall, at some convenient place, enquire into all
claims duly preferred under that section, and into
the existence and extent of any rights mentioned in
Section 4(c) and not claimed under Section 5(d), so
far as the same may be ascertainable from the
records of Government and the evidence of any
persons likely to be acquainted with the same.
The Forest Settlement Officer shall, at the same
time, consider and record any allegation which
the Forest Officer, if any, appointed to assist him
may make to any such claim or any information
which he may afford with regard to the existence
and extent of any such right.
63.28. By referring to Section 7 he submits that the
Forest Settlement Officer was required to
record in writing the statements made pursuant
to the preceding provisions and conduct an
inquiry into the claims received. He contends
that no such inquiry was conducted and no
steps were taken by the Forest Settlement
Officer to complete the statutory process
contemplated under the Regulation.
63.29. Learned counsel further relies on Section 11 of
the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, which is
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
11. Order on claims to rights of way or pasture
or to forest produce or water. — In the case of a
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 82 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
claim to rights of way or pasture or to forest
produce or water, the Forest Settlement Officer
shall pass an order specifying the particulars of such
claim and admitting or rejecting the same in whole
or in part.
63.30. By referring to Section 11 he submits that the
Forest Settlement Officer was required, in
respect of every claim received, to pass an
order specifying the particulars of the claim and
admitting or rejecting it, either wholly or in
part. He contends that no such orders were
passed and that the claims of persons asserting
rights over the lands were never adjudicated in
accordance with the statutory procedure.
63.31. On this basis, he submits that the proceedings
initiated by reference to the notification of 1920
cannot be sustained in the absence of
compliance with the mandatory steps
prescribed under the Regulation.
63.32. He relies on Section 12 of the Regulation of
1900, which reads as under:-
12. Record to be made where claim is
admitted.
If the Forest Settlement Officer admits in whole or in part
any claim under Section 11, he shall record the extent to
which the claim is so admitted, specifying-
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 83 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
(a) in the case of rights of way, by whom they may be
enjoyed, the width of way, and whether for cart traffic or
for men and cattle only, and the conditions, if any,
attached to the right;
(b) in the case of pasturage, the number and de-scription
of cattle which the claimant is from time to time entitled
to graze in the forest, the season during which such
pasturage is permitted, and any conditions attached to
the right;
(c) in the case of forest produce, the quantity of timber
or other forest produce which the claimant is entitled to
take or receive, whether the benefit of such timber or
other forest produce may be leased, sold or bartered,
and such other particulars as may be necessary in order
to define the nature, incidents and extent of the right;
and
(d) in the case of water, by whom and for what purposes
the water may be utilized, and any conditions attached to
its use.
63.33. Learned counsel, placing reliance on Section 12
of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, submits
that the provision prescribes the particulars to
be recorded by the Forest Settlement Officer
upon admitting, either wholly or in part, a claim
preferred under Section 11. The Forest
Settlement Officer is required to specify the
extent to which the claim is admitted and
record the particulars relevant to the nature
and incidents of the right recognised. These
include, as applicable, the persons entitled to
exercise a right of way, the width and nature of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 84 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the way and the conditions attached thereto;
the number and description of cattle permitted
to be grazed, the relevant season and the
conditions governing pasturage; the quantity of
timber or other forest produce which the
claimant is entitled to take or receive and the
incidents of that right; and the persons entitled
to utilise water, the purposes for which it may
be used and the conditions governing such use.
63.34. He further submits that the statutory
requirement is not satisfied by a general or
unspecified recognition of a claim. The extent of
the admission and the particulars of the right
recognised must be specifically recorded by the
Forest Settlement Officer. According to learned
counsel, no such determination was made and
no record specifying the extent and particulars
of any admitted claim was prepared. He
therefore contends that the failure to comply
with Section 12 constitutes a further instance of
non-compliance with the procedure prescribed
under the Regulation.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 85 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
63.35. He refers to Section 13 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
13. Exercise of admitted rights
Record to be made where claim is admitted .—If the
Forest Settlement Officer admits in whole or in part any
claim under section 12, he shall record the extent to
which the claim is so admitted, specifying as far as may
be practicable,—
(a) the name, father’s name, residence, and occupation
of the person claiming the right;
(b) the designation, position and area of all fields or
groups of fields (if any) and the designation and position
of all buildings (if any) in respect of which the exercise of
such rights is claimed;
(c) in the case of rights of way, by whom they may be
enjoyed, the width of the way, and whether for vehicular
traffic or for men and cattle only, and the conditions, if
any, attached to the right;
(d) in the case of pasturage, the number and description
of cattle which the claimant is from time to time entitled
to graze in the forest, the season during which such
pasturage is permitted, and any conditions attached to
the rights;
(e) in the case of forest produce, the quantity of timber
or other forest produce which the claimant is entitled to
take or receive, whether the benefit of such timber or
other forest produce may be leased, sold or bartered and
such other particulars as may be necessary in order to
define the nature, incidents and extent of the right;
(f) in the case of water, by whom and for what purposes
the water may be utilised, and any condition attached to
its use.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 86 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
63.36. By referring to Section 13, his submission is
that the provision further requires the Forest
Settlement Officer, upon admitting a claim,
either wholly or in part, to record the extent of
such admission and, as far as practicable,
specify the particulars of the claimant, the fields
or groups of fields and buildings in respect of
which the rights are claimed, and the details
necessary to identify and define the nature and
extent of the rights admitted. These particulars
include the persons entitled to exercise rights of
way, the width and nature of the way and the
conditions governing its use; the number and
description of cattle permitted to graze, the
relevant season and the conditions attached to
pasturage; the quantity and nature of forest
produce which may be taken or received and
the incidents of that right; and the persons
entitled to utilise water, the purposes for which
it may be used and the conditions governing its
use.
63.37. Learned counsel further submits that Section 13
is intended to ensure that the rights admitted
by the Forest Settlement Officer are specifically
identified and recorded with sufficient
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 87 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
particulars to facilitate their exercise in
accordance with the terms of the settlement.
He contends that, in the present case, no such
record specifying the claimants, the lands or
buildings concerned, or the nature and extent
of the rights admitted was prepared. According
to him, the absence of such particulars
demonstrates that the claims were not
adjudicated, and the exercise of any admitted
rights was not provided for in the manner
contemplated by the Regulation. He therefore
submits that the failure to comply with Section
13 constitutes a further instance of non-
compliance with the statutory procedure.
63.38. He relies on Section 14, of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
14. Commutation of rights
In case the Forest Settlement Officer finds it
impossible, having due regard to the maintenance
of the proposed State Forest, to make such
settlement under Section 13 as shall secure the
continued exercise of the said rights to the
admitted extent, he shall, subject to such rules as
the Government may from time to time prescribe in
this behalf, he may commute such rights, either by
the payment of a sum of money in lieu thereof, or,
with the consent of the claimant, by the grant of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 88 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
land, or in suh other manner as such officer thinks
fit.
63.39. By relying on Section 14, his submission is that
Section 14 requires the Forest Settlement
Officer, after recording the rights admitted, to
pass appropriate orders to ensure their
continued exercise, having due regard to the
maintenance of the proposed reserved forest.
For this purpose, the provision empowers the
Forest Settlement Officer to provide an
alternative and reasonably convenient right of
way; set apart another forest tract of sufficient
extent and in a reasonably convenient locality
for the exercise of rights of pasturage or the
collection of forest produce; alter the limits of
the proposed reserved forest to exclude the
relevant tract or demarcate an enclosure within
which the rules governing reserved forests
would not apply; or permit the continued
exercise of the admitted rights, subject to
prescribed conditions and restrictions designed
to prevent their abuse.
63.40. Referring to Section 14 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, learned counsel further
submits that, where the Forest Settlement
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 89 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Officer is unable to make an order ensuring the
continued exercise of the admitted rights, the
Regulation provides for the commutation of
such rights by payment of a sum of money in
lieu thereof or, with the consent of the claimant,
by the grant of land or through such other
arrangement as may be permissible under the
applicable provision. He contends that,
consequently, if the rights of the Petitioners
were admitted but could not be continued in
their existing form, the Forest Settlement
Officer was required to consider their
commutation in accordance with law, including
by monetary compensation or the grant of
alternative land, as applicable. Learned counsel
submits that no such determination or
arrangement was made following the
notification issued in 1920. He therefore
contends that the failure to provide for the
continued exercise of the admitted rights or to
deal with their commutation in accordance with
the statutory scheme constitutes a further
ground for challenging the impugned
proceedings.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 90 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
63.41. He relies on Section 15, of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
15. Appeal from order passed under Sections
10, 11, 12, 13 or 14.
Any person who has made a claim under this
chapter or any Forest Officer or other person
generally or specially empowered by the
Government in this behalf, may, within three
months from the date of the order passed on such
claim by the Forest Settlement Officer under Section
10, 11, 12, 13 or 14, prefer an appeal from such
order to the officer of the Revenue Department, of
rank not lower than that of a Deputy Commissioner,
as the Government may, by notification in the
official Gazette, appoint by name, or as holding an
office, to hear appeals from such ...
63.42. Section 15 provides for payment of
compensation where the Forest Settlement
Officer, having due regard to the maintenance
of the reserved forest, finds it impossible to
make a settlement under Section 14 that would
ensure the continued exercise of the admitted
rights to the extent recognised. In such
circumstances, the Forest Settlement Officer is
required to direct the State Government to pay
compensation, determined on the basis of the
value of the rights as on the date of the
notification issued under Section 4, in
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 91 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
accordance with the applicable provisions of the
Land Acquisition Act, 1894.
63.43. He relies on Section 16, of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
16. Appeal under Section 15
Every appeal under the last foregoing section shall
be made by petition in writing, and may be
delivered to the Forest Settlement Officer, who shall
forward it without delay to the appellate authority.
Every such appeal shall be heard and determined in
the manner prescribed for the time being for the
disposal of appeals in matters relating to land
revenue and the order passed on the appeal shall be
final, subject only to revision by the Government.
63.44. Learned counsel further submits that Section 16
of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, provides
for an appeal by a claimant aggrieved by an
order passed under Sections 10 to 14 of the
Regulation to an officer of the Revenue
Department not below the rank of a Deputy
Commissioner, as prescribed by the
Government by notification. He contends that,
in the present case, no orders were passed
under Sections 10, 11, 12, 13 or 14 of the
Regulation. Consequently, no occasion arose for
the claimants or landowners to invoke the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 92 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
appellate remedy against any such order.
According to learned counsel, the absence of
orders determining the claims and rights in
accordance with the statutory scheme further
demonstrates that the proceedings
contemplated under the Regulation were not
completed.
63.45. He relies on Section 17, of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
17. Notification declaring forest State forest .—(1)
When the following events have occurred, viz:—
(a) the period fixed under Section 5 for preferring claims
has elapsed, and all claims, (if any) made within such
period have been disposed of by the Forest Settlement
Officer; and
(b) if such claims have been made, the period limited by
section 15 for appealing from the orders passed on such
claims has elapsed and all appeals (if any) presented
within such period have been disposed of by the
appellate authority; and
(c) all proceedings prescribed by Sections 10 and 13
have been taken and all lands and buildings (if any) to be
included in the proposed State Forest, which the Forest
Settlement Officer has under section 10 elected to
acquire under the Land Acquisition Regulation, 1894,
have become vested in Government under section 16 of
that Regulation,
(d) the Government may publish a notification in the
official Gazette specifying the limits of the forest which is
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 93 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
intended to constitute a State Forest and declaring the
same to be a State forest from a date fixed by such
notification, subject to the exercise of rights (if any)
specified at foot of the said notification.
(2) From the date so fixed, such forest shall be deemed
to be a “State Forest”.
63.46. By relying on Section 17, he submits that it
prescribes the conditions precedent for issuance
of a final notification declaring a forest to be a
reserved forest. The provision contemplates
that the period prescribed for preferring claims
under Section 5 must have expired and all
claims made under that section or Section 9
must have been disposed of by the Forest
Settlement Officer; the period prescribed for
preferring appeals against orders passed on
such claims must have expired and all appeals
presented within that period must have been
disposed of; and the proceedings contemplated
under Sections 10 and 13 must have been
completed, including the acquisition of any
lands or buildings required to be acquired under
the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.
63.47. Upon fulfilment of these conditions, the State
Government is required to publish a notification
specifying the limits of the forest and declaring
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 94 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
it to be a reserved forest with effect from the
date specified therein, subject to any rights
expressly recognised in the notification. Under
sub-section (2), the forest is deemed to be a
reserved forest from the date so specified.
63.48. Referring to Section 17 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, learned counsel submits that
a final notification declaring the land to be a
reserved forest could be issued only upon
completion of the statutory proceedings
contemplated under the Regulation, including
the adjudication of claims by the Forest
Settlement Officer and the disposal of any
appeals arising therefrom. He contends that, in
the present case, the proceedings contemplated
under Sections 5 to 14 of the Regulation were
not completed, no final notification under
Section 17 was issued, and the lands have
continued in the possession of the individual
owners. Accordingly, he submits that the lands
were never finally constituted as a reserved
forest under the Mysore Forest Regulation,
1900.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 95 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
63.49. Learned counsel further places reliance on the
report dated 11.10.2022 prepared by the
Assistant Commissioner, Sakleshpur Sub-
Division, Hassan District, and submits that the
report also refers to the withdrawal of the
notification issued in 1920. He contends that
this material lends support to the Petitioners’
case that the notification relied upon by the
Respondents had been withdrawn and that no
subsequent proceedings culminating in a final
notification under Section 17 were undertaken
to constitute the lands as a reserved forest.
63.50. He relies on the judgment of Co-ordinate Bench
of this Court in the case of M/s.Bharat Parikh
and Co vs. The State of Karnataka and
others [W.P. 22514/2018 dated 18.6.2019],
more particularly paragraphs 5 to 7, which are
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
5. We have carefully considered the submissions. The
impugned order/ communication proceeds on the
assumption that the subject land has been declared as a
reserved forest only because of the notification issued
under Section 4 of the Karnataka Forest Act. The only
ground for invoking the said Act of 1980 is the issuance
of notification under sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the
Karnataka Forest Act.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 96 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
6. We have perused the provisions of Chapter II of the
Karnataka Forest Act. For constituting any land as
reserved forest, the notification under sub-section
(1) of Section 4 of the Karnataka Forest Act is only
a first step which is required to be taken before the
State Government decides to constitute a land as a
reserved forest. Thereafter, elaborate process will
be followed as provided in various provisions of
Chapter II and the land is declared as a reserved
forest only after a notification under Section 17 of
the Karnataka Forest Act is issued. Only on this
narrow ground, the impugned communication will have
to set aside.
7. The issue whether subject land falls within the wider
definition of ‘forest’ as held by the Apex Court and
whether Section 2 of the said Act of 1980 is applicable
are the issues which need not be gone into in this writ
petition inasmuch as the impugned order proceeds only
on one ground namely, the publication of the notification
under sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the Karnataka
Forest Act. The issue whether the subject land is a
forest land within the meaning of said Act of 1980
is always open and we have made no adjudication
on the said question. Hence, subject to what is
observed above, a case is made out for quashing of
impugned notice.
63.51. By relying on M/s.Bharat Parikh and Co , he
submits that the issuance of a notification
under Section 4(1) of the Karnataka Forest Act,
1963, is only the first step in the process of
constituting land as a reserved forest and that
the statutory procedure prescribed under
Chapter II of the Act must thereafter be
followed. The Court further observed that land
can be declared a reserved forest only upon
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 97 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
issuance of a notification under Section 17 of
the Act. On that basis, the impugned
communication in that case was set aside, while
leaving open the question whether the land in
question fell within the wider definition of
‘forest’ and whether the provisions of the Forest
(Conservation) Act, 1980, were applicable.
63.52. Placing reliance on M/s.Bharat Parikh and
Co , learned counsel submits that the issuance
of a notification under Section 4, by itself, does
not culminate in the constitution of land as a
reserved forest. The statutory process
prescribed under the Karnataka Forest Act,
1963, must be completed, culminating in the
issuance of a final notification under Section 17.
He contends that, in the present case, no such
final notification has been issued and that the
Respondents cannot treat the notification of
1920, issued under the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, as sufficient, by itself, to
establish that the lands in question were
constituted as reserved forest. He therefore
submits that, in the absence of a final
notification and completion of the prescribed
statutory process, the impugned proceedings
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 98 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
are liable to be set aside, in view of the
principle laid down by the Co-ordinate Bench in
M/s. Bharat Parikh and Co .
63.53. He relies on the judgment of Co-ordinate Bench
of this Court in the case of Emerald Haven
Estates Ltd., vs. State of Karnataka and
others [WP No.41187/2016 dated 16.3.2017],
more particularly Paras 7 to 13, which are
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
7.In order to appreciate the submission advanced by
Mr.S.Vijayshankar, we need to consider certain provisions
of the Karnataka Forest Act.
Sub-section (6) of Section 2 of the said Act defines the
expression “Forest Officer” as under:-
“Forest Officer means any person appointed by or under
the orders of the State Government to be the Principal
Chief Conservator, Additional Principal Chief Conservator,
Chief Conservator, Additional Chief Conservator,
Conservator, Deputy Conservator, Assistant Conservator,
Forest Ranger, Forester, Forest Guard or Forest Watcher,
or to discharge any function of Forest Officer under this
Act or any rule or order made thereunder to be done by a
Forest Officer.”
8. Sub section (14) of Section 2 of the said Act,
defines “Reserved Forest” as any land settled and
notified as such in accordance with the provisions
of Chapter II of the said Act.
9. The clause (c) of sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the
said Act provides for appointment of Forest Settlement
Officer to inquire into and determine the existence,
nature and extent of any rights claimed by or alleged to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 99 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
exist in favour of any person in or over any land
comprised within such limits or in or over any forest
produce, and to deal with the same as provided in the
Chapter II of the said Act.
10. He is a different person from a Forest Officer. It
was expressly provided under sub-section (2) of
Section 4 of the said Act that an officer appointed
as Forest Settlement Officer shall be a person not
holding any forest office except that of a Forest
Settlement Officer. However, the State Government
may appoint a Forest Officer to represent it in the
inquiry under Chapter II by the Forest Settlement
Officer.
11. We find that Respondent No.2 is a Forest
Officer within the meaning of sub-section (6) of
Section 2 of the said Act and, therefore, is not
competent to inquire into and determine the
existence, nature and extent of the right, title and
interest claimed by the writ Petitioner, inasmuch as
it may be determined by a Forest Settlement
Officer appointed under clause (c) of sub-section
(1) of Section 4 of the said Act.
12. We find from the order dated October 21, 2016, that
the proceeding was initiated for the purpose of
ascertaining the rights of the writ Petitioner, proceeding
on the assumption that the property has been a reserved
forest. The initiation of the proceeding and the
inquiry by the Respondent No.2, who has been a
Forest Officer, is without jurisdiction. Thus, the
entire initiative by the Respondent No.2 is void ab initio.
13. We, thus, quash the notice at Annexure-B to the writ
petition dated December 16, 2015 and all subsequent
proceedings in pursuance thereof.
63.54. By relying on Emerald Haven Estates Ltd , he
submits that the Court considered the
definitions of ‘Forest Officer’ and ‘reserved
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 100 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
forest’ under Section 2 of the Karnataka Forest
Act, 1963, and the statutory scheme under
Section 4 governing the appointment and
functions of the Forest Settlement Officer. The
Court held that a Forest Settlement Officer is
distinct from a Forest Officer and is entrusted
with the statutory responsibility of inquiring into
and determining the existence, nature and
extent of rights claimed in respect of land
proposed to be constituted as a reserved forest.
It further held that a Forest Officer could not
assume the jurisdiction of the Forest Settlement
Officer to inquire into and determine the rights,
title and interest claimed by the Petitioner
therein, particularly where the proceedings
proceeded on the assumption that the property
was already a reserved forest. Accordingly, the
Court held that the proceedings initiated by the
Forest Officer were without jurisdiction and
quashed the notice and all consequential
proceedings.
63.55. Learned counsel submits that the statutory
functions of a Forest Settlement Officer cannot
be exercised by a Forest Officer in the absence
of the authority specifically conferred under the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 101 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963. He contends that,
in the present case, the Respondents have
initiated proceedings concerning the Petitioners’
rights over the lands in question without
establishing that the lands were duly
constituted as a reserved forest in accordance
with the statutory procedure. He further
submits that the authorities cannot proceed on
the assumption that the lands are reserved
forest and, on that basis, undertake an inquiry
into or determine the Petitioners’ rights without
following the procedure prescribed under the
Act and acting through the competent statutory
authority. On this basis, he contends that the
impugned proceedings are without jurisdiction
and are liable to be quashed in the light of the
principle laid down in Emerald Haven Estates
Ltd .
63.56. He relies on the judgment of Division Bench of
this Court in the case of V.Sampangi
Ramaiah v. The Director/Commissioner,
Department of Mines and Geology and
others [2012 SCC OnLine Kar 8879], more
particularly Paras 10 to 21, which are
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 102 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
10. The object of the Act is to consolidate the law
relating to forest produce in the State of Karnataka. Sub-
section (14) of Section 2 defines “Reserved Forest” to
mean any land settled and notified as such, in
accordance with the produce of Chapter II of the Act.
Section 3 empowers the State Government to constitute
any land which is the property of the Government or over
which the Government has proprietary rights, as a
reserved forest. For that purpose, a notification has to be
issued under Section 4 of the Act declaring that it has
been decided to constitute such land as a reserved forest
specifying as nearly as possible, the situation and the
limits of such land. An Officer called Forest Settlement
Officer has to be appointed to enquire into and determine
the existence, nature and extent of any rights claimed by
or alleged to exist in favour of any person in or over any
land comprised within such limits or in or over any forest
produce. Such an Officer shall not be a Forest Officer.
11. The notification issued under Section 4 of the Act can
be termed as a preliminary notification. The same has to
be published by the Forest Settlement Officer under
Section 5 and also a copy of the notice has to be served
on every known or owner or occupier of any land
included in or adjoining the land proposed to be
constituted a reserved forest or on his recognized agent
or manager. On the issuance of a notification under
Section 4, no right can be acquired in or over the land
comprised in the notification, except by succession or
under a grant or contract in writing made or entered into
by or on behalf of the Government and between issuance
of the preliminary notification and issuance of the Final
Notification. Also no Civil Court can entertain any suit for
the establishment of any right on any land included in the
notification issued under Section 4.
12. Under clause (d) of Section 5 of the Act, under which
a proclamation is made by the Forest Settlement Officer
a minimum period of three months from the date of
publishing the proclamation is given to any person
claiming, any right or making any claim referred to under
Section 4 by producing all documents in support thereof.
If such a claim is made, the Forest Settlement Officer
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 103 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
shall enquire into the claim by looking into the records by
the Government and the evidence of any person
acquainted with the same and also hear the concerned
Forest Officer as regards any objections under Section 7.
13. Section 8 grants certain powers to the Forest
Settlement Officer for the purpose of conducting the
enquiry. If no claim is made within the period fixed under
Section 5 before the Forest Officer, any rights in that
regard shall be extinguished unless before the final
notification under Section 17 is published, the person
claiming them satisfies the Forest Settlement Officer that
he had sufficient cause for not preferring such a claim
within the period fixed under Section 5 in which case the
Forest Settlement Officer would have to proceed to
dispose of the claim.
14. Section 10 deals with the manner in which claims
relating to shifting cultivation would have to be dealt
with. Section 11 enables the Forest Settlement Officer to
acquire land over which a right is claimed in case such
land is not excluded from the limits of the reserved forest
or no agreement with the owner for the surrender of his
rights is arrived at. In the event of an acquisition, the
provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 would apply
and the Forest Settlement Officer would act as a Deputy
Commissioner. With regard to the right of way to
pasturage or other forest produce or water, the Forest
Settlement Officer has to consider any such claims and
pass an order under Section 12 read with Sections 13
and 14. If no settlement under Section 14 is arrived at,
then compensation has to be determined on the basis of
the value of the right claimed on the date of the
preliminary notification in accordance with the provisions
of the Act, insofar as such provisions are applicable under
Section 15 of the Act.
15. Section 16 provides for an appeal against an order
passed under Sections 11. 12, 14 or 15. The statutory
period for filing of an appeal is three months from the
date of the order made by the Forest Settlement Officer.
Section 17 states that when the period fixed under
Section 5 for preferring a claim has lapsed and all claims
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 104 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
have been disposed of under Section 9 and the period of
limitation for filing an appeal under Section 16 has lapsed
and appeals if any filed have been disposed of and all
proceedings under Sections 11 and 14 have been taken,
the State Government shall publish a final notification
specifying clearly the boundary marks to constitute a
reserved forest and declare the same to be a reserved
forest from the date fixed by a notification subject to the
exercise of rights if any specified in such a notification.
From the date so fixed, such forest shall be deemed to be
a reserved forest. Before the date fixed in the notification
under Section 18. The same shall be published in the
Official Gazette and at the Taluk Headquarters in which
the forest is situated and in the neighbourhood as a
proclamation is published under Section 5.
16. Under Section 19, the State Government has the
power to revise any arrangement made under Section 14
by modifying any order made under the said section and
substitute the same by awarding compensation under
Section 15. But the same has to be done within five years
from the publication of any notification under Section 17.
17. On a reading of the aforesaid provision, it becomes
clear that though no specific date has been fixed for the
issuance of a declaration under Section 17 of the Act,
nevertheless, after the issuance of the preliminary
notification, only a minimum period of three months is
granted to every person to make a claim. Also, the
provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 would have
to be read into Section 11 of the Act incase, a necessity
to acquire the land arises.
18. It is needless to observe that in many provisions of
the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, specified time frames
have been mandated from the declaration of the
preliminary and final notification as well as for passing of
an award. No doubt, an elaborate procedure has been
contemplated between the issuance of a preliminary
notification and the issuance of a final notification under
the Act encompassing the making of claims with regard
to the notified areas proposed to be declared to be
reserved forest and also settlement of the said claims,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 105 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, are also
contemplated and orders passed under Sections 11, 12,
14 and 15 are also subject to appeal. However, we find
that there is no specified period mentioned under the Act
within which, the notification declaring the reserved
forest has to be made once the preliminary notification
has been issued.
19. When specific period has been fixed, for making a
claim and also by filing an appeal by any persons, a
corresponding time frame for the adjudication of the
claims and for issuance of a declaration ought to have
been made. The absence of any specific time frame
for the issuance of a declaration under Section 17
would imply that such a declaration must be made
within a reasonable time. What is the reasonable time
in the absence of any specific time frame mentioned in a
statutory provision would vary from Act to Act and
depending upon the object and scope of the Act. In the
instant case, having regard to the object and scope
of the Act in question, we are of the view that a
period of three years would be the reasonable
period within which, a declaration under Section 17
of the Act ought to be made, excluding the period
when steps are taken under the Land Acquisition
Act, 1894, as well as appellate proceedings, if any.
This period obviously would exclude any stay orders
granted by any Court of Law. But in the instant case, the
State is unable to point out any steps initiated after the
order passed by the Forest Settlement Officer, excluding
366.63 acres, which according to the Petitioner also
includes the area of the subject quarry. This aspect is
communicated to the Petitioner in the year 2007,
whereas in 2004 itself the quarry lease was granted to
the Petitioner.
20. In this context, reliance could be placed on the fact
that originally in the matter of issuance of preliminary
notification and a declaration under the provisions of the
Land Acquisition Act, 1894, there was no time limit fixed
for making an award. Subsequently, in the year 1984, an
amendment was brought in the form of insertion to
Section 11-A of the Land Acquisition Act. In fact, in the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 106 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
case of Ram Chand v. Union of India, (1994) 1 SCC 44,
which is a decision on a dispute arising prior to the
insertion of Section 4 to the Land Acquisition Act, the
Supreme Court has held that compensation has to be
paid within a reasonable time, even in the absence of any
time limit prescribed under the Act and the reasonable
time was stated to be about two years in the said case.
21. In the instant case, though the preliminary
notification is issued on 3-6-1991, the final notification is
yet to be issued. In fact, several adjournments were
given in the matter so as to enable the Respondent-
Authorities to take a decision with regard to issuance of a
declaration under Section 17 of the Act, even then, no
steps have been taken to issue such a declaration.
Therefore, we find that the State Government has
by not taking steps for over two decades after the
issuance of the preliminary notification, abandoned
its intention to notify Sy. No. 601/A1 as a Reserved
Forest. This becomes all the more clear by the fact
that subsequent to the issuance of the preliminary
notification in the year 1991 and quarrying lease
has also been granted to the Petitioner and
possibly to the other similarly placed persons in the
year 2004. Therefore, the impugned order at Annexure-
A is without authority of law.
63.57. By relying on V. Sampangi Ramaiah , he
submits that the Division Bench of this Court
examined the statutory scheme under Chapter
II of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, and
observed that a notification under Section 4 is
only a preliminary notification initiating the
process of constituting land as a reserved
forest. The Court noted that the statutory
scheme contemplates an elaborate procedure
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 107 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
involving publication of a proclamation,
submission and adjudication of claims by the
Forest Settlement Officer, consideration of the
rights claimed, and disposal of appeals,
wherever preferred, before a final notification
can be issued under Section 17 of the Act.
63.58. Learned counsel submits that, although the Act
does not prescribe an express time limit for
issuance of the final notification under Section
17, such notification must be issued within a
reasonable period. He draws particular
attention to the observation of the Co-ordinate
Bench in paragraph 19 that, having regard to
the object and scheme of the Act, a period of
three years would constitute a reasonable
period for issuance of the final notification,
excluding the time taken in acquisition
proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act,
1894, appellate proceedings and any period
covered by an order of stay granted by a
competent court.
63.59. Learned counsel further submits that, in V.
Sampangi Ramaiah , the Division Bench of
this Court held that the State’s failure to take
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 108 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
steps towards issuance of a final notification for
over two decades, coupled with the subsequent
grant of a quarrying lease, indicated that the
State had abandoned its intention to constitute
the land in question as a reserved forest. The
impugned order was accordingly held to be
without authority of law.
63.60. Applying the principle laid down in the aforesaid
decision to the facts of the present case,
learned counsel contends that the notification
relied upon by the Respondents dates back to
1920 and that no final notification under
Section 17 has been issued even after the lapse
of nearly a century. He submits that the
Respondents have failed to demonstrate that
the statutory proceedings were completed or
that any legally sustainable steps were taken
within a reasonable period to constitute the
lands in question as a reserved forest. He
further contends that the prolonged inaction of
the authorities, together with the subsequent
dealings with the lands and the rights asserted
by the Petitioners, supports their case that the
intention to constitute the lands as a reserved
forest was not pursued to completion.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 109 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Accordingly, he submits that the impugned
proceedings, founded on the preliminary
notification of 1920 in the absence of a final
notification, are unsustainable in law.
63.61. He relies on the judgment of Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Joint Collector Ranga
Reddy District and another vs. D. Narsing
Rao and others [(2015) 3 SCC 695], more
particularly Paras 25 to 31, which are
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
25. The legal position is fairly well settled by a
long line of decisions of this Court which have laid
down that even when there is no period of
limitation prescribed for the exercise of any power,
revisional or otherwise, such power must be
exercised within a reasonable period. This is so even
in cases where allegations of fraud have necessitated the
exercise of any corrective power. We may briefly refer to
some of the decisions only to bring home the point that
the absence of a stipulated period of limitation makes
little or no difference insofar as the exercise of the power
is concerned which ought to be permissible only when
the power is invoked within a reasonable period.
26. In one of the earlier decisions of this Court in S.B.
Gurbaksh Singh v. Union of India, this Court held that
exercise of suo motu power of revision must also be
within a reasonable time and that any unreasonable
delay in the exercise may affect the validity. But what
would constitute reasonable time would depend upon the
facts of each case.
27. To the same effect is the decision of this Court in
Ibrahimpatnam Taluk Vyavasaya Coolie Sangham v. K.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 110 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Suresh Reddy wherein this Court held that even in cases
of fraud the revisional power must be exercised within a
reasonable period and that several factors need to be
kept in mind while deciding whether relief should be
denied only on the ground of delay. The Court said :
(SCC p. 677, para 9)
“9. … In cases of fraud, this power could be exercised
within a reasonable time from the date of detection or
discovery of fraud. While exercising such power,
several factors need to be kept in mind such as
effect on the rights of the third parties over the
immovable property due to passage of
considerable time, change of hands by subsequent
bona fide transfers, the orders attaining finality
under the provisions of other Acts (such as the
Land Ceiling Act).”
28. To the same effect is the view taken by this Court in
Sulochana Chandrakant Galande v. Pune Municipal
Transport wherein this Court reiterated the legal position
and held that the power to revise orders and proceedings
cannot be exercised arbitrarily and interminably. This
Court observed : (SCC p. 476, para 28)
“28. The legislature in its wisdom did not fix a time-limit
for exercising the revisional power nor inserted the
words ‘at any time’ in Section 34 of the 1976 Act. It does
not mean that the legislature intended to leave the
orders passed under the Act open to variation for an
indefinite period inasmuch as it would have the effect of
rendering title of the holders/allottee(s) permanently
precarious and in a state of perpetual uncertainty. In
case it is assumed that the legislature has conferred an
everlasting and interminable power in point of time, the
title over the declared surplus land, in the hands of the
State/allottee, would forever remain virtually insecure.
The Court has to construe the statutory provision in a
way which makes the provisions workable, advancing the
purpose and object of enactment of the statute.”
29. In State of H.P. v. Rajkumar Brijender Singh [(2004)
10 SCC 585] this Court held that in the absence of any
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 111 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
special circumstances a delay of 15 years in suo motu
exercise of revisional power was impermissible as the
delay was unduly long and unexplained. This Court
observed : (SCC pp. 588-89, para 6)
“6. We are now left with the second question which was
raised by the Respondents before the High Court,
namely, the delayed exercise of the power under sub-
section (3) of Section 20. As indicated above, the
Financial Commissioner exercised the power after 15
years of the order of the Collector. It is true that sub-
section (3) provides that such a power may be exercised
at any time but this expression does not mean there
would be no time-limit or it is in infinity. All that is meant
is that such powers should be exercised within a
reasonable time. No fixed period of limitation may be
laid but unreasonable delay in exercise of the power
would tend to undo the things which have attained
finality. It depends on the facts and circumstances of
each case as to what is the reasonable time within which
the power of suo motu action could be exercised. For
example, in this case, as the appeal had been withdrawn
but the Financial Commissioner had taken up the matter
in exercise of his suo motu power, it could well be open
for the State to submit that the facts and circumstances
were such that it would be within reasonable time but as
we have already noted that the order of the Collector
which has been interfered with was passed in January
1976 and the appeal preferred by the State was also
withdrawn sometime in March 1976. The learned counsel
for the appellant was not able to point out such other
special facts and circumstances by reason of which it
could be said that exercise of suo motu power after 15
years of the order interfered with was within a
reasonable time. That being the position in our view, the
order of the Financial Commissioner stands vitiated
having been passed after a long lapse of 15 years of the
order which has been interfered with. Therefore, while
holding that the Financial Commissioner would have
power to proceed suo motu in a suitable case even
though an appeal preferred before the lower appellate
authority is withdrawn, may be, by the State. Thus, the
view taken by the High Court is not sustainable. But the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 112 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
order of the Financial Commissioner suffers from the vice
of the exercise of the power after unreasonable lapse of
time and such delayed action on his part nullifies the
order passed by him in exercise of power under sub-
section (3) of Section 20.”
30. We may also refer to the decision of this Court in
Dehri Rohtas Light Railway Co. Ltd. v. District
Board, Bhojpur wherein the Court explained the
legal position as under : (SCC pp. 602-03, para 13)
“13. The rule which says that the Court may not enquire
into belated and stale claim is not a rule of law but a rule
of practice based on sound and proper exercise of
discretion. Each case must depend upon its own facts. It
will all depend on what the breach of the fundamental
right and the remedy claimed are and how delay arose.
The principle on which the relief to the party on the
grounds of laches or delay is denied is that the rights
which have accrued to others by reason of the delay in
filing the petition should not be allowed to be disturbed
unless there is a reasonable explanation for the delay.
The real test to determine delay in such cases is
that the Petitioner should come to the writ court
before a parallel right is created and that the lapse
of time is not attributable to any laches or
negligence. The test is not as to physical running of
time. Where the circumstances justifying the conduct
exist, the illegality which is manifest cannot be sustained
on the sole ground of laches. The decision in Tilokchand
case [Tilokchand Motichand v. H.B. Munshi, (1969) 1
SCC 110] relied on is distinguishable on the facts of the
present case. The levy if based on the net profits of the
railway undertaking was beyond the authority and the
illegal nature of the same has been questioned though
belatedly in the pending proceedings after the
pronouncement of the High Court in the matter relating
to the subsequent years. That being the case, the claim
of the appellant cannot be turned down on the sole
ground of delay. We are of the opinion that the High
Court was wrong in dismissing the writ petition in limine
and refusing to grant the relief sought for. We however
agree that the suit has been rightly dismissed.”
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 113 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
31. To sum up, delayed exercise of revisional
jurisdiction is frowned upon because if actions or
transactions were to remain forever open to
challenge, it will mean avoidable and endless
uncertainty in human affairs, which is not the
policy of law. Because, even when there is no
period of limitation prescribed for exercise of such
powers, the intervening delay, may have led to
creation of third-party rights, that cannot be
trampled by a belated exercise of a discretionary
power especially when no cogent explanation for
the delay is in sight. Rule of law it is said must run
closely with the rule of life. Even in cases where the
orders sought to be revised are fraudulent, the exercise
of power must be within a reasonable period of the
discovery of fraud. Simply describing an act or
transaction to be fraudulent will not extend the time for
its correction to infinity; for otherwise the exercise of
revisional power would itself be tantamount to a fraud
upon the statute that vests such power in an authority.
63.62. By relying on Joint Collector Ranga Reddy
District , he submits that even where the
statute does not prescribe a specific period of
limitation for the exercise of a statutory power,
such power must nevertheless be exercised
within a reasonable period. He contends that
the absence of an express limitation period
does not confer an indefinite or perpetual
authority to initiate proceedings, particularly
where the passage of time has resulted in the
creation of third-party rights, changes in the
nature and use of the property, or the
attainment of finality by transactions and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 114 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
orders. He further submits that the
determination of what constitutes a reasonable
period must depend upon the facts and
circumstances of each case, including the
nature of the power exercised, the extent of the
delay, the explanation for such delay and the
consequences of disturbing rights that have
accrued in the intervening period.
63.63. Applying these principles to the facts of the
present case, learned counsel contends that the
Respondents cannot rely upon the preliminary
notification dated 05.02.1920 to initiate
proceedings after the lapse of several decades,
without demonstrating that the statutory
process for constitution of the lands as a
reserved forest was completed or that the
prolonged inaction is legally justified. He
submits that the absence of a final notification
under Section 17 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, coupled with the subsequent
dealings with the lands and the rights claimed
by the Petitioners, renders the belated action of
the Respondents unsustainable. Accordingly, he
contends that the impugned proceedings are
vitiated by unreasonable delay and are contrary
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 115 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
to the principles laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Joint Collector, Ranga
Reddy District.
63.64. He relies on the judgment of Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Union of India and
another vs. Citi Bank [(2022) 19 SCC 188],
more particularly Para 19, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
19. It is a settled proposition of law that when the
proceedings are required to be initiated within a
particular period provided under the statute, the same
are required to be initiated within the said period.
However, where no such period has been provided
in the statute, the authorities are required to
initiate the said proceeding within a reasonable
period. No doubt that what would be a reasonable
period would depend upon the facts and
circumstances of each case.
63.65. By relying on Citi Bank , he submits that where
the statute does not prescribe a specific period
for initiating or completing proceedings, the
authorities are nevertheless required to act
within a reasonable period, having regard to
the facts and circumstances of the case. He
contends that the absence of an express
statutory time limit cannot be construed as
conferring an unfettered power upon the
authorities to initiate proceedings at any point
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 116 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
of time, irrespective of the length of the delay
and its consequences. Applying this principle to
the present case, learned counsel submits that
the Respondents’ reliance on the preliminary
notification dated 05.02.1920, in the absence of
a final notification under Section 17 of the
Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, even after the
lapse of several decades, warrants scrutiny on
the touchstone of reasonableness. He further
submits that the prolonged inaction of the
authorities, considered alongside the
subsequent dealings with the lands and the
rights asserted by the Petitioners, renders the
belated proceedings unsustainable in law.
63.66. He relies on the judgment of Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of M.Karunanidhi vs. Union
of India and another [(1979) 3 SCC 431],
more particularly Para 35, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
35. On a careful consideration, therefore, of the
authorities referred to above, the following propositions
emerge:
1. That in order to decide the question of
repugnancy it must be shown that the two
enactments contain inconsistent and irreconcilable
provisions, so that they cannot stand together or
operate in the same field.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 117 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
2. That there can be no repeal by implication
unless the inconsistency appears on the face of
the two statutes.
3. That where the two statutes occupy a particular
field, but there is room or possibility of both the
statutes operating in the same field without coming
into collision with each other, no repugnancy results.
4. That where there is no inconsistency but a statute
occupying the same field seeks to create distinct and
separate offences, no question of repugnancy arises
and both the statutes continue to operate in the
same field.
63.67. By relying on M.Karunanidhi , he submits that
in determining whether two statutory
enactments can operate in the same field, the
test is whether their provisions are inconsistent
and irreconcilable, such that both cannot
operate simultaneously. He contends that the
mere fact that two enactments deal with the
same subject matter does not, by itself, give
rise to repugnancy or result in the implied
repeal of one enactment by the other. Applying
these principles to the present case, learned
counsel submits that the statutory framework
governing the lands in question must be
examined to determine whether the relevant
provisions of the Mysore Forest Regulation,
1900, and the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, can
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 118 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
operate consistently, or whether any actual
inconsistency exists between them. He further
contends that the Respondents cannot rely
merely on the existence of the later enactment
to overcome the legal consequences arising
from the failure to complete the proceedings
contemplated under the earlier Regulation,
particularly in the absence of a final notification
under Section 17 thereof.
63.68. He relies on the judgment of Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Union of India and
others vs. Rajeev Bansal (and other
appeals) [2024 SCC Online SC 2693], more
particularly Paras 42 and 43, which are
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
42. Another principle of interpretation is that when two
laws are inconsistent or repugnant, the later legislation is
interpreted as having impliedly repealed the earlier
legislation. The principle underlying implied repeal is
that there is no need for the later enactment to
state in express words that the earlier enactment
has been repealed if the legislative intent to
supersede the earlier law is manifested through the
provisions of the later enactment. (State of Orissa v.
M.A. Tulloch and Co. In Municipal Corporation of Delhi v.
Shiv Shanker, this court culled out the following
principles applicable to the implied repeal of legislation:
(a) A subsequent legislation may not be too readily
presumed to effectuate a repeal of existing
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 119 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
statutory laws in the absence of express or at least
unambiguous indication to that effect;
(b) Courts must lean against implying a repeal unless the
two provisions are so plainly repugnant to each other
that they cannot stand together and it is not possible on
any reasonable hypothesis to give effect to both at the
same time;
(c) It is necessary to closely scrutinise and consider the
true meaning and effect of both the earlier and the later
statute; and
(d) If the objects of the two statutory provisions are
different and the language of each statute is restricted to
its objects or subject, then they are generally intended to
rule in parallel lines without meeting and there would be
no real conflict.
43. The principle on which the rule of implied repeal rests
is that if the subject-matter of a later legislation is
identical to that of an earlier legislation so that they both
cannot stand together, then the earlier legislation is
impliedly repealed by the later legislation. (Zaverbhai
Amaidas v. State of Bombay) The courts have to
determine whether the Legislature intended the two sets
of provisions to be applied simultaneously. (Ratan Lal
Adukia v. Union of India) The presumption against
implied repeal is based on the theory that the Legislature
knows the existing laws and does not intend to create
any confusion by retaining two conflicting provisions or
statutes. (Pradeep S. Wodeyar v. State of Karnataka) The
test to be applied for the construction of implied repeal is
whether the new or subsequent law is inconsistent with
or repugnant to the old law. The inconsistency or
repugnancy should clearly and manifestly reveal an
intention to repeal the existing laws. (Municipal Council
Palai v. T.J. Joseph) The inconsistency or repugnancy
must be such that the two statutes cannot be reconciled
on reasonable construction or hypothesis. To determine
whether a later statute repeals by implication of an
earlier statute, it is necessary to examine the scope and
object of the two enactments by comparison of their
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 120 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
provisions. (State of M.P. v. Kedia Leather and Liquor
Ltd. ) Implied repeal should be avoided, if possible,
where both the statutes can stand together. (Harshad S.
Mehta v. State of Maharashtra )
63.69. By relying on Rajeev Bansal , he submits that
a subsequent enactment cannot be presumed
to have impliedly repealed an earlier enactment
merely because both deal with the same
subject matter. Such repeal can be inferred only
where the provisions of the two enactments are
so inconsistent or repugnant that they cannot
be reconciled or given effect to simultaneously,
and the legislative intention to supersede the
earlier law is clearly manifested. He contends
that, in determining whether an implied repeal
has occurred, the scope, object and effect of
both enactments must be examined, and where
they can reasonably operate alongside each
other, the presumption must be against implied
repeal.
63.70. Applying these principles to the present case,
learned counsel submits that the provisions of
the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, and the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, must be examined
to ascertain whether the later enactment
expressly or by necessary implication displaced
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 121 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the earlier statutory framework and what
consequences follow in respect of proceedings
initiated under the earlier Regulation. He
contends that the Respondents cannot merely
rely upon the subsequent enactment to
disregard the statutory procedure contemplated
under the earlier Regulation, particularly the
requirement of a final notification under Section
17, without establishing the legal basis on
which the lands in question are claimed to have
acquired the status of reserved forest.
Accordingly, he submits that the impugned
proceedings must be tested against the
applicable statutory provisions and the
principles governing implied repeal laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
63.71. He relies on the judgment of Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of M/s.Godrej Sara Lee
Ltd., vs. The Excise and Taxation Officer-
cum-Assessing Authority & Ors., [(2025) 11
SCC 808] more particularly paragraphs 4 and 6,
which are reproduced hereunder for ease of
reference:
27. Before answering the questions, we feel the
urge to say a few words on the exercise of writ
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 122 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
powers conferred by Article 226 of the Constitution
having come across certain orders passed by the
High Courts holding writ petitions as “not
maintainable” merely because the alternative
remedy provided by the relevant statutes has not
been pursued by the parties desirous of invocation
of the writ jurisdiction. The power to issue
prerogative writs under Article 226 is plenary in
nature. Any limitation on the exercise of such power
must be traceable in the Constitution itself.
Profitable reference in this regard may be made to
Article 329 and ordainments of other similarly
worded articles in the Constitution. Article 226 does
not, in terms, impose any limitation or restraint on
the exercise of power to issue writs. While it is true
that exercise of writ powers despite availability of a
remedy under the very statute which has been
invoked and has given rise to the action impugned
in the writ petition ought not to be made in a
routine manner, yet, the mere fact that the
Petitioner before the High Court, in a given case,
has not pursued the alternative remedy available to
him/it cannot mechanically be construed as a
ground for its dismissal. It is axiomatic that the
High Courts (bearing in mind the facts of each
particular case) have a discretion whether to
entertain a writ petition or not. One of the self-
imposed restrictions on the exercise of power
under Article 226 that has evolved through
judicial precedents is that the High Courts
should normally not entertain a writ petition,
where an effective and efficacious alternative
remedy is available. At the same time, it must be
remembered that mere availability of an alternative
remedy of appeal or revision, which the party
invoking the jurisdiction of the High Court under
Article 226 has not pursued, would not oust the
jurisdiction of the High Court and render a writ
petition “not maintainable”. In a long line of
decisions, this Court has made it clear that
availability of an alternative remedy does not
operate as an absolute bar to the
“maintainability” of a writ petition and that
the rule, which requires a party to pursue the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 123 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
alternative remedy provided by a statute, is a
rule of policy, convenience and discretion
rather than a rule of law. Though elementary,
it needs to be restated that “entertainability”
and “maintainability” of a writ petition are
distinct concepts. The fine but real distinction
between the two ought not to be lost sight of. The
objection as to “maintainability” goes to the root of
the matter and if such objection were found to be of
substance, the courts would be rendered incapable
of even receiving the lis for adjudication. On the
other hand, the question of “entertainability” is
entirely within the realm of discretion of the High
Courts, writ remedy being discretionary. A writ
petition despite being maintainable may not be
entertained by a High Court for very many
reasons or relief could even be refused to the
Petitioner, despite setting up a sound legal
point, if grant of the claimed relief would not
further public interest. Hence, dismissal of a writ
petition by a High Court on the ground that the
Petitioner has not availed the alternative remedy
without, however, examining whether an
exceptional case has been made out for such
entertainment would not be proper.
……..
6. At the end of the last century, this Court in
paragraph 15 of its decision reported in (1998) 8
SCC 1 (Whirlpool Corporation vs. Registrar of Trade
Marks, Mumbai and Others) carved out the
exceptions on the existence whereof a Writ Court
would be justified in entertaining a writ petition
despite the party approaching it not having availed
the alternative remedy provided by the statute. The
same read as under:
(i) where the writ petition seeks enforcement of any
of the fundamental rights;
(ii) where there is violation of principles of natural
justice;
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 124 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
(iii) where the order or the proceedings are
wholly without jurisdiction; or
(iv) where the vires of an Act is challenged.
63.72. By relying on M/s. Godrej Sara Lee Ltd , he
submits that the availability of an alternative
statutory remedy does not constitute an
absolute bar to the maintainability of a writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India. He submits that the rule requiring a party
to ordinarily avail itself of an alternative remedy
is a rule of judicial policy, convenience and
discretion, and not an inflexible rule of law. He
further submits that the maintainability of a
writ petition must be distinguished from its
entertainability, as a writ petition that is
maintainable may nevertheless not be
entertained in the exercise of the discretionary
jurisdiction of the High Court
63.73. The learned counsel further submits that, as
recognised by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the
High Court may exercise its writ jurisdiction
notwithstanding the availability of an
alternative remedy in exceptional
circumstances, including where the impugned
proceedings are wholly without jurisdiction or
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 125 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
where the principles of natural justice have
been violated. In the present case, he contends
that the Petitioners have raised substantial
questions concerning the jurisdiction of the
authorities to initiate the impugned proceedings
and the legality of the action taken against their
respective properties. Accordingly, he submits
that the Petitioners’ challenge ought not to be
rejected merely on the ground that an
alternative statutory remedy is available,
without examining the nature of the
jurisdictional objections raised and whether the
circumstances warrant the exercise of writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India.
63.74. He relies on the judgment of Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Radha Krishan
Industries vs. State of Himachal Pradesh
and other [(2021) 6 SCC 771 ], more
particularly Para 27, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
27. The principles of law which emerge are that:
27.1. The power under Article 226 of the Constitution to
issue writs can be exercised not only for the enforcement
of fundamental rights, but for any other purpose as well.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:56, Bengaluru
Verified
- 126 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
27.2. The High Court has the discretion not to entertain
a writ petition. One of the restrictions placed on the
power of the High Court is where an effective alternate
remedy is available to the aggrieved person.
27.3. Exceptions to the rule of alternate remedy
arise where : (a) the writ petition has been filed for
the enforcement of a fundamental right protected
by Part III of the Constitution; (b) there has been a
violation of the principles of natural justice; (c) the
order or proceedings are wholly without
jurisdiction; or (d) the vires of a legislation is
challenged.
27.4. An alternate remedy by itself does not divest the
High Court of its powers under Article 226 of the
Constitution in an appropriate case though ordinarily, a
writ petition should not be entertained when an
efficacious alternate remedy is provided by law.
27.5. When a right is created by a statute, which
itself prescribes the remedy or procedure for
enforcing the right or liability, resort must be had
to that particular statutory remedy before invoking
the discretionary remedy under Article 226 of the
Constitution. This rule of exhaustion of statutory
remedies is a rule of policy, convenience and discretion.
27.6. In cases where there are disputed questions
of fact, the High Court may decide to decline
jurisdiction in a writ petition. However, if the High
Court is objectively of the view that the nature of the
controversy requires the exercise of its writ jurisdiction,
such a view would not readily be interfered with.
63.75. By relying on Radha Krishan Industries , he
submits that the existence of an alternative
statutory remedy does not, by itself, bar the
exercise of the jurisdiction of this Hon’ble Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 127 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
He contends that the rule requiring exhaustion
of alternative remedies is a rule of discretion
and not an absolute prohibition against
entertaining a writ petition. He further submits
that the recognised exceptions to this rule
include cases involving violation of the
principles of natural justice and proceedings
initiated wholly without jurisdiction.
63.76. Applying these principles to the present case,
learned counsel contends that the impugned
proceedings are amenable to judicial review
under Article 226 of the Constitution, as the
Petitioners challenge the jurisdiction of the
authorities to initiate proceedings in respect of
the lands in question and allege non-
compliance with the mandatory statutory
procedure. He submits that, in the absence of a
final notification under Section 17 of the Mysore
Forest Regulation, 1900, and having regard to
the alleged failure to follow the prescribed
procedure under the applicable forest law, the
Petitioners’ challenge falls within the recognised
exceptions to the rule of alternative remedy.
Accordingly, he submits that the writ petitions
are maintainable and may be entertained
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 128 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
notwithstanding the availability of any
alternative statutory remedy.
63.77. By relying on all the above, his submission is
that the writ petition is required to be allowed.
64. Sri. A.M. Vijay, learned counsel appearing for the
Petitioner in W.P. No. 29690/2025, adopts the
submissions made by Sri. Manmohan P.N., learned
counsel appearing for the other Petitioners. He
makes the following additional submissions:
64.1. The resort in question was developed by the
Petitioners in W.P. No. 16251/2023. He submits
that the Respondent authorities entered the
Petitioner’s property and forcibly evicted the
Petitioners, an action which, according to him,
cannot be countenanced either in law or on
facts. He contends that such action violates the
Petitioners’ constitutional right to property
guaranteed under Article 300A of the
Constitution of India.
64.2. Learned counsel submits that a notification
which has been withdrawn or has otherwise
ceased to operate cannot be revived in the
absence of statutory authority. Neither the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 129 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, nor the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, contemplates the
revival of such a notification, particularly after
the lapse of nearly a century. He submits that
the entire area is now inhabited and developed,
with several landowners having established
resorts and undertaken other developmental
and agricultural activities. When the State
Government had chosen not to proceed with
the notification in 1924, at a time when the
population in the area was comparatively
smaller, the question of reviving the notification
after such a prolonged period, in the changed
circumstances, does not arise.
64.3. He further submits that, even assuming that
such revival is legally permissible, it would
cause serious prejudice to the landowners, who
have invested substantial amounts in
constructing houses, developing resorts,
establishing amenities and undertaking
agricultural activities. In view of the significant
changes that have occurred in the intervening
period, learned counsel contends that the
Forest Department was required to undertake a
thorough assessment of the likely impact of the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 130 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
proposed action on the local population before
proceeding to issue a proclamation under
Section 5 of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963.
64.4. In this regard, learned counsel draws a
distinction between Section 4 of the Mysore
Forest Regulation, 1900, and Section 4 of the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963. He submits that,
while the former contemplated the existence of
a proposal to constitute land as a State Forest,
the latter requires the State Government to
take a decision in that regard. According to
him, the use of the expression “decide” in
Section 4 of the 1963 Act necessitates a proper
decision-making process, involving
consideration of all relevant aspects, including
the nature of the land, the rights and interests
of the existing owners and occupants, and the
adverse consequences that the proposed action
may have on the local population. He contends
that the issuance of a proclamation under
Section 5 of the 1963 Act, without a proper
decision having been taken under Section 4,
demonstrates non-application of mind, is
indicative of mala fides and violates the
principles of natural justice.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 131 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
64.5. Learned counsel further submits that the State
Government itself had granted lands in
Kadumane Village to various occupants from
the year 1952 onwards, some by way of grants
without payment of consideration and others at
an upset price. He contends that these grants
constitute subsequent governmental conduct
consistent with the withdrawal of the
notification in 1924. The Respondents,
therefore, ought to have considered the grants
and the rights flowing therefrom before
mechanically issuing the proclamation under
Section 5 of the 1963 Act.
64.6. He refers to Section 133 of the Karnataka Land
Revenue Act, 1963, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
133. Presumption regarding entries in the
records .—An entry in the Record of Rights and a
certified entry in the Register of Mutations [or in the
patta book] shall be presumed to be true until the
contrary is proved or a new entry is lawfully
substituted therefore.
64.7. By relying on Section 133 learned counsel
submits that the entries in the revenue records
carry a statutory presumption as to their
genuineness and correctness. He points out
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 132 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
that the revenue records relating to the lands in
question have, in many cases for several
decades, stood in the names of the respective
landowners and not in the name of the State
Government or the Forest Department. He
further submits that the relevant revenue
records do not contain entries indicating any
right of the Government over the lands in
question. The lands have also been assessed to
land revenue and other applicable taxes, which
have been paid by the respective owners. These
circumstances, according to learned counsel,
support the Petitioners’ claim to the lands and
ought to have been considered by the
Respondents before initiating the impugned
proceedings.
64.8. Learned counsel additionally submits that,
following the grants and subsequent
transactions, several phodi and durasthi
proceedings have been undertaken in respect of
the lands, resulting in changes to the survey
numbers and the subdivision of the original
extents. He contends that the proclamation
issued by the FSO is unsustainable because it
refers to survey numbers that no longer
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 133 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
correspond to the existing survey particulars of
the lands in question.
64.9. He further submits that the Respondents’
allegation that the Petitioners are encroachers
is itself disputed, as the Petitioners assert
independent rights over their respective
properties on the basis of documentary
evidence, including grant certificates, registered
sale deeds, partition deeds and other title
documents. According to learned counsel, the
notices issued by the FSO under Section 5 of
the 1963 Act are incapable of eliciting an
effective response because the descriptions
therein do not correspond to the existing
survey particulars and boundaries of the lands.
He submits that multiple rights have accrued in
respect of the lands over the intervening
decades and that, before issuing notices, the
FSO was required to ascertain the identity and
extent of each parcel, its boundaries, the
persons claiming ownership or occupation, and
the nature of their respective rights, even
assuming that the notification of 1920
continued to subsist.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 134 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
64.10. Learned counsel contends that, in the absence
of clear particulars identifying the lands claimed
by the Respondents, including their extent and
boundaries, the landowners and occupants are
unable to ascertain the precise subject matter
of the proceedings or submit effective
objections and claims. He submits that the
Petitioners have not been served with notices
containing sufficient particulars to enable them
to respond meaningfully. On these grounds,
learned counsel submits that the impugned
proceedings are unsustainable and that the writ
petition is liable to be allowed by granting the
reliefs sought therein.
65. Sri. Kiran Ron, learned Additional Advocate General
appearing for the Respondents, opposes the writ
petitions and submits that:
65.1. The lands claimed by the Petitioners form part
of the Moorkangudda Block, which was notified
for constitution as a State Forest under
Notification No. R.8806-FT.43-15-6 dated
05.02.1920, issued under Section 4 of the
Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 135 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.2. He submits that the notification covered a total
extent of 7,938 acres and 38 guntas, equivalent
to approximately 12.4 square miles, situated in
Manjerabad Taluk and comprising lands in
Achanahalli, Agini, Kyamanahalli, Nadahalli and
Kadumane villages, as well as Jambardi,
Manjanahalli Estate and Kadumane Estate.
65.3. According to him, the notification relating to the
said extent continues to form the basis of the
Forest Department’s claim over the lands in
question and was not cancelled by the
subsequent notification dated 11.01.1924, as
alleged by the Petitioners.
W.P. NO. 16251/2023
65.4. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the lands claimed by the Petitioners in W.P.
No. 16251/2023 form part of an extent of 36
acres and 22 guntas in Sy. No. 92 of
Achanahalli Village, which was auctioned by the
Revenue Department notwithstanding the
earlier notification dated 05.02.1920. He
submits that an extent of 536 acres 22 guntas
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 136 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
in Achanahalli Village was subsequently
mutated in the name of the Forest Department
on 05.08.2013, vide M.R. No. H3/13-14.
According to him, the absence of corresponding
revenue entries in the name of the Forest
Department in respect of the remaining extent
does not extinguish or otherwise affect the legal
consequences flowing from the notification
issued under Section 4 of the 1900 Regulation.
65.5. He further submits that the auction of land in
Sy. No. 92 of Achanahalli Village was conducted
by the Revenue Department through the
Amildar in favour of Byregowda at a public
auction held by the jurisdictional Tahsildar on
20.09.1924. The said auction, according to the
learned Additional Advocate General, took place
despite the prior notification dated 05.02.1920,
solely because the necessary revenue entries
had not been carried out in the name of the
Forest Department following publication of the
notification in the Official Gazette. He contends
that an omission to make corresponding entries
in the revenue records cannot, by itself, nullify
the notification or confer upon the Revenue
Department the authority to deal with the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 137 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
notified lands in a manner inconsistent with
their alleged forest status.
65.6. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that, if the lands had already been
brought within the ambit of the forest
notification, the Revenue Department could not
have treated them as ordinary revenue lands
and proceeded to auction them without first
ascertaining their legal status. He contends that
the legality of the auction must be examined in
the context of the subsisting notification and
the statutory restrictions governing the use and
disposal of forest land. In this regard, he relies
upon Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation)
Act, 1980 (hereinafter referred to as the
‘Conservation Act’), which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
2. Restriction on the dereservation of forests
or use of forest land for non-forest purpose .—
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other
law for the time being in force in a State, no State
Government or other authority shall make, except
with the prior approval of the Central Government,
any order directing—
(i) that any reserved forest (within the meaning of
the expression “reserved forest” in any law for the
time being in force in that State) or any portion
thereof, shall cease to be reserved;
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 138 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
(ii) that any forest land or any portion thereof may
be used for any non-forest purpose.
[(iii) that any forest land or any portion thereof may
be assigned by way of lease or otherwise to any
private person or to any authority, corporation,
agency or any other organization 2 [subject to such
terms and conditions, as the Central government
may, by order specify];
(iv) that any forest land or any portion thereof may
be cleared of trees which have grown naturally in
that land or portion, for the purpose of using it for
reafforestation.] [Explanation.— For the purposes of
this section “non-forest purpose” means the
breaking up or clearing of any forest land or portion
thereof for—
(a) the cultivation of tea, coffee, spices, rubber,
palms, oil-bearing plants, horticultural crops or
medicinal plants;
(b) 4 [but does not include any work relating to or
ancillary to conservation, development and
management of forest and wildlife, such as-
(i) silvicultural operations including regeneration
operations;
(ii) establishment of check-posts and infrastructure
for the front line forest staff;
(iii) establishment and maintenance of fire lines;
(iv) wireless communication;
(v) construction of fencing, boundary marks or
pillars, bridges and culverts, check dams,
waterholes, trenches and pipelines;
(vi) establishment of zoo and safaris referred to in
the Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972, owned by the
Government or any authority, in forest areas other
than protected areas;
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 139 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
(vii) eco-tourism facilities included in the Forest
Working Plan or Wildlife Management Plan or Tiger
Conservation Plan or Working Schedme of that
area; and
(viii) any other like purposes, which the Central
Government may, by order, specify.”;]
[(2) The Central Government may, by order, specify
the terms and conditions subject to which any
survey, such as, reconnaissance, prospecting,
investigation or exploration including seismic
survey, shall not be treated as non-forest purpose.]
65.7. By referring to Section 2, he submits that, once
land is legally recognised as forest land within
the meaning of the applicable law, its diversion
for a non-forest purpose requires prior approval
of the Central Government, wherever the
provision applies. According to him, no such
approval was obtained before the auction of the
extent of 36 acres and 22 guntas and,
consequently, the auction could not have
lawfully been conducted on the assumption that
the land was available for disposal by the
Revenue Department.
65.8. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the subsequent mutation of 500 acres in
favour of the Forest Department does not mean
that only the said extent was covered by the
notification dated 05.02.1920. He contends that
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 140 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the notification and the extent of land covered
thereby must be construed with reference to
the notification itself and the relevant survey
particulars, rather than merely on the basis of
the entries subsequently made in the revenue
records.
65.9. He submits that, although the final notification
relied upon by the Respondents pertains to an
extent of 500 acres, the remaining extent of 36
acres and 22 guntas forms part of Sy. No. 92 of
Achanahalli Village and is claimed by the Forest
Department as part of the lands notified in
1920. According to him, the absence of a
mutation entry in respect of the latter extent
cannot, by itself, be treated as proof that the
land was excluded from the forest notification
or that the Petitioners acquired an indefeasible
right over it through the auction conducted by
the Revenue Department.
65.10. He further submits that revenue entries are
maintained primarily for fiscal and
administrative purposes and that the existence
or absence of a particular mutation entry
cannot, without examining the underlying
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 141 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
notification, title documents and relevant
survey records, conclusively determine the legal
status of the land. On that basis, he contends
that the Petitioners cannot rely solely upon the
absence of entries in the name of the Forest
Department to defeat the Respondents’ claim.
He submits that the material question is
whether the subject lands fall within the area
covered by the notification and the subsequent
statutory proceedings, and that the Petitioners’
claims must be examined in that context.
65.11. Without prejudice to the aforesaid submissions,
learned Additional Advocate General advances
an alternative contention with regard to the
extent of land claimed by the Petitioners in W.P.
No. 16251/2023. He submits that, even
assuming that the auction conducted by the
Revenue Department was valid and that the
Petitioners derived a lawful right thereunder,
such right could extend only to 5 acres and
could not be enlarged to cover the entire extent
of 14 acres and 36 guntas over which the resort
has been developed.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 142 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.12. He contends that the Petitioners, under the
guise of asserting ownership over 5 acres, have
extended their possession and construction
activities to an additional extent of 9 acres and
36 guntas belonging to the Forest Department.
According to him, the Petitioners cannot claim
any right over the additional extent merely
because the resort has been developed as a
single establishment across the entire property.
He submits that the extent of any legally
acquired right must be determined by reference
to the relevant grant, auction records, title
documents and survey particulars, and that the
Petitioners cannot use the development
undertaken over the larger area to enlarge the
extent of land lawfully acquired by them.
65.13. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that proceedings were initiated under Section
64A of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, before
the Deputy Conservator of Forests, on the basis
of a complaint received from the Range Forest
Officer, Sakleshpura. He states that, pursuant
to the said proceedings, an order dated
26.07.2022 was passed directing the Assistant
Conservator of Forests, Sakleshpura, to evict
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 143 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the Petitioners from the portion alleged to have
been encroached upon, measuring 14 acres and
36 guntas.
65.14. He further submits that, even if the extent of 5
acres claimed by the Petitioners were excluded
from the area alleged to have been encroached
upon, the remaining extent of 9 acres and 36
guntas would continue to be in unauthorised
occupation. According to him, the Petitioners
would have no legal basis to retain possession
of that portion, much less to maintain the
structures and commercial activities established
thereon. He accordingly contends that, at the
minimum, the structures standing on the extent
of 9 acres and 36 guntas are liable to be
removed, subject to the applicable statutory
procedure and the determination of the rights
asserted by the Petitioners.
65.15. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the Respondents have been unable to
proceed with the proposed action on account of
the interim orders passed by this Court. He
contends that the dispute regarding the extent
of the Petitioners’ alleged entitlement must be
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 144 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
kept distinct from the question whether the
remaining extent is under unauthorised
occupation, and that the Petitioners cannot
claim protection over the entire property merely
by asserting a limited right over 5 acres.
65.16. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the interim protection initially granted by
this Court was confined to an extent of 5 acres.
Subsequently, the Petitioners approached this
Court seeking stay of the proceedings initiated
under Section 64A of the Karnataka Forest Act,
1963, and an order granting such relief came to
be passed on 10.08.2023. He contends that the
subsequent order has prevented the
Respondents from proceeding with the
statutory action initiated against the Petitioners
in respect of the alleged encroachment.
65.17. He further alleges that, notwithstanding their
alleged unauthorised occupation of forest land,
the Petitioners have threatened the Forest
Department officials with various legal
proceedings, including contempt proceedings.
According to him, the resort had earlier been
seized by the authorities; however, the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 145 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Respondents were subsequently compelled to
unseize the entire resort and restore it to the
Petitioners, with the result that the Petitioners
have continued to remain in possession and to
carry on activities over the land claimed by the
Forest Department.
65.18. Learned Additional Advocate General contends
that the Petitioners have not fairly disclosed the
distinction between the extent of 5 acres
claimed by them and the additional extent of 9
acres and 36 guntas alleged to be under
encroachment. He submits that, by relying
upon the interim orders passed in the writ
proceedings, the Petitioners have continued in
possession, occupation and enjoyment of the
entire extent of 14 acres and 36 guntas,
although, even according to their alternative
claim, their entitlement could extend only to 5
acres.
65.19. He reiterates that this submission is without
prejudice to the Respondents’ primary
contention that the entire extent, including the
5 acres claimed by the Petitioners, forms part
of the forest land. He therefore submits that
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 146 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the interim orders ought not to be construed as
conferring any substantive right upon the
Petitioners over the disputed property or as
preventing the Respondents from asserting
their rights in accordance with law. According to
him, the Petitioners’ claim to interim protection
must be considered in the light of the extent of
land actually covered by their title documents
and the nature of the proceedings initiated by
the Forest Department.
65.20. With regard to the Government Order or
notification dated 11.01.1924, learned
Additional Advocate General specifically denies
the Petitioners’ contention that the notification
dated 05.02.1920, bearing No. R.8806-FT.43-
15-6, was cancelled or withdrawn. He submits
that the notification dated 11.01.1924 related
to a separate notification issued on 05.02.1920
under No. R.8808-FT.43-15-7, concerning other
lands proposed to be constituted as part of the
Moorkangudda State Forest. According to him,
it was the latter notification that was dropped
by the Government Order dated 11.01.1924,
and not the notification bearing No. R.8806-
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 147 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
FT.43-15-6, which is relied upon by the
Respondents in the present proceedings.
65.21. He contends that the Petitioners have
proceeded on an erroneous assumption that,
because both notifications were issued on
05.02.1920 and related to the Moorkangudda
area, the Government Order dated 11.01.1924
must necessarily have cancelled the notification
concerning the subject lands. Learned
Additional Advocate General submits that the
notification numbers are distinct and that the
legal effect of the Government Order must be
determined by examining the particular
notification to which it refers, and the extent of
land covered thereby. He argues that the
similarity in the date and general description of
the lands cannot justify treating the two
notifications as one and the same instrument.
65.22. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the notification dated 11.01.1924
dropped only an extent of 68 acres and 33
guntas and did not withdraw the entire proposal
concerning the Moorkangudda Block, which
comprises 7,938.38 acres, equivalent to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 148 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
approximately 12.4 square miles. He contends
that the Petitioners’ assertion that the
constitution of the entire Moorkangudda Forest
was abandoned is therefore contrary to the
terms and scope of the Government Order
relied upon by them.
65.23. He submits that the notification dated
05.02.1920 bearing No. R.8806-FT.43-15-6
continued to remain operative and that the
subsequent proceedings must be examined on
that basis. According to him, the Petitioners
cannot derive a right to treat the entire area as
having been released from the proposed forest
merely by relying upon an order which,
according to the Respondents, relates to a
different notification and a limited extent of
land.
65.24. Learned Additional Advocate General further
alleges that the Petitioners have sought to
utilise the alleged withdrawal of the notification
to justify private development over lands
claimed by the Forest Department,
notwithstanding the statutory restrictions
governing such lands. He submits that the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 149 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
development of the resort and other activities
undertaken by the Petitioners cannot, by
themselves, establish that the lands were
lawfully released from the forest notification or
that the Respondents have lost the right to
proceed in accordance with the applicable law.
65.25. With regard to the alleged decision or direction
said to have been issued at a meeting of the
District-Level Committee chaired by the
Regional Commissioner, learned Additional
Advocate General denies that any direction was
issued to drop the proceedings initiated against
the Petitioners. He submits that Annexure-L
produced by the Petitioners consists of
representations made by villagers requesting
that the cases registered or proceedings
initiated against them be dropped. According to
him, the mere submission or consideration of
such representations does not establish that the
competent Government authority has taken a
decision accepting the request.
65.26. He further submits that no order has been
passed by the State Government directing the
dropping of the proceedings against the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 150 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Petitioners. He contends that, where the law
requires a decision by the competent authority,
the same must be evidenced by an appropriate
order issued in accordance with law and cannot
be inferred merely from an oral statement or an
alleged understanding said to have emerged
during a committee meeting. He also
specifically denies that the Regional
Commissioner issued any direction to drop the
proceedings and submits that the Petitioners
have not established the existence of any such
direction.
65.27. Learned Additional Advocate General
accordingly contends that Annexure-L does not
support the Petitioners’ assertion that the
proceedings against them had been ordered to
be dropped. He submits that, in the absence of
an authenticated decision by the competent
authority, the Respondents were entitled to
continue the proceedings in accordance with
the applicable statutory provisions, subject to
the orders passed by this Court.
65.28. He further submits that the Petitioners’
application seeking amendment of the writ
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 151 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
petition to challenge the notification dated
05.02.1920 is a circumstance that, according to
the Respondents, supports their contention that
the notification had not been cancelled by the
Government Order dated 11.01.1924. He
argues that the Petitioners’ decision to
specifically challenge the original notification
indicates that they themselves recognise the
need to question its continuing legal effect,
rather than merely rely upon the alleged
withdrawal in 1924.
65.29. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the notification dated 05.02.1920 bearing
No. R.8806-FT.43-15-6 continued to remain in
force and that, in furtherance of the statutory
process, the Forest Settlement Officer issued a
proclamation dated 09.11.2023 under Section 5
of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963. He points
out that the said proclamation has also been
challenged by the Petitioners in the present
proceedings. According to him, the challenge to
the proclamation cannot be sustained merely
on the basis of the Petitioners’ interpretation of
the Government Order dated 11.01.1924,
particularly when, according to the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 152 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Respondents, that order related to a different
notification and a limited extent of land.
65.30. On these grounds, learned Additional Advocate
General submits that the notification dated
05.02.1920 was not cancelled in respect of the
lands in question, that the Petitioners have
failed to establish a lawful right over the entire
extent occupied by them, and that the
Respondents were justified in initiating
proceedings to protect the lands claimed by the
Forest Department. He accordingly seeks
dismissal of the writ petitions.
65.31. He relies on Section 4 of the Mysuru Forest Act,
1900, which is reproduced hereunder for ease
of reference:
4. Notification by Government
Whenever it is proposed to constitute any land a State
Forest, the Government shall publish a notification in the
Official Gazette—
(a) specifying as nearly as possible the situation and
limits of such land;
(b) declaring that it is proposed to constitute such land a
State Forest; and
(c) appointing an officer (hereinafter called “the Forest
Settlement Officer”) to inquire into and determine the
existence, nature and extent of any rights claimed by, or
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 153 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
alleged to exist in favour of, any person in or over any
land comprised within such limits, or to any forest
produce of such land, and to deal with the same as
provided in this chapter.
The officer appointed under clause (c) of this section shall
ordinarily be a person other than a Forest Officer; but a
Forest Officer may be appointed by the Government to
assist the Forest Settlement Officer in the enquiry
prescribed by this chapter.
65.32. His submission is that the publication of a
notification under Section 4 is the initial step in
the statutory process of constituting land as a
State Forest and is intended to be followed by
further proceedings in accordance with the
provisions of the Mysore Forest Regulation,
1900. He contends that, upon publication of
such notification, the Forest Settlement Officer
is required to inquire into and determine the
existence, nature and extent of the rights
claimed by, or alleged to exist in favour of,
persons in or over the notified lands or in
respect of forest produce thereof. He submits
that the statutory scheme contemplates the
identification and adjudication of such rights,
together with the consequential steps
prescribed under the Regulation, before the
process of constituting the land as a State
Forest can be completed. Accordingly, he
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 154 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
contends that the legal effect of the notification
dated 05.02.1920 and the subsequent
proceedings must be examined with reference
to the statutory scheme as a whole and not
merely on the basis of the absence of mutation
entries in the revenue records.
65.33. Learned Additional Advocate General reiterates
that the Petitioners have taken inconsistent
stands. On the one hand, they contend that the
notification dated 05.02.1920 was cancelled or
withdrawn; on the other, they challenge the
very same notification. He submits that the
auction conducted by the Revenue Department
admittedly took place subsequent to the
issuance of the notification under Section 4 of
the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900. According
to him, the inconsistency in the Petitioners’
submissions is evident from their initial
contention that their predecessor acquired the
property through the auction after the alleged
cancellation or withdrawal of the notification
dated 05.02.1920.
65.34. It was only when it was pointed out that the
notification had neither been cancelled nor
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 155 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
withdrawn that the Petitioners proceeded to
challenge the notification itself. He therefore
contends that their earlier plea, that the
purchase was made after the cancellation or
withdrawal of the notification, is unsustainable.
He further submits that the notification dated
05.02.1920 continued to remain in force as on
20.09.1924 and that Section 6 of the Mysore
Forest Regulation, 1900, expressly precludes
the acquisition of rights over land notified under
Section 4.
65.35. He relies upon Section 6 of the Mysuru Forest
Act, 1900 is reproduced hereunder for ease of
reference:
6. Bar of accrual of forest rights
(1) During the interval between the publication of such
proclamation and the date fixed by the notification
declaring the forest to be a State Forest as hereinafter
provided, no right shall be acquired in or over the land
comprised in such notification, except by succession, or
under a grant or contract in writing made or entered into
by, or on behalf of, the Government or some person in
whom such right, or power to create such right, was
vested when the proclamation was published; and, on
such land, no new house shall be built or plantation
formed, no fresh clearings for cultivation or for any other
purpose shall be made, and no trees shall be cut for the
purpose of trade or manufacture except as hereinafter
provided. No right of occupancy shall, without the
previous sanction of the Government, be granted in
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 156 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
respect of such land, and every right of occupancy
granted without such sanction shall be null and void.
(2) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to prohibit
any act done under the written permission of the Forest
Settlement Officer.
(3) No Civil Court shall, between the dates of publication
of the notification under section 4 and of the final
notification to be issued under section 17, entertain any
suit to establish any right in or over any land or to the
forest produce of any land included in the notification
under section 4.
65.36. Relying on Section 6 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, learned Additional Advocate
General submits that, during the period
between the publication of the proclamation
and the issuance of the final notification
declaring the land to be a State Forest, the
acquisition of rights over the notified land is
barred, except in the circumstances expressly
provided under the provision. He contends that
the statutory restriction assumes significance in
examining the Petitioners’ claim that rights over
the subject land were subsequently acquired
through grants, transfers or other transactions.
He further relies on Section 6(3), which bars
civil courts from entertaining suits for the
establishment of rights over the notified land or
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 157 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
its forest produce during the period specified
therein.
65.37. Learned Additional Advocate General
accordingly submits that the claims of the
Petitioners must be examined in the light of the
statutory restrictions imposed by Section 6,
including the exceptions expressly recognised
therein, and the legal effect of the notification
dated 05.02.1920, which, according to him,
continued to remain in force.
65.38. His submission is that the entire prayer which
has been sought for after the amendment is
contradictory and diametrically opposite to the
prayers which had been sought for when the
writ petition was filed originally. His contention
is that both these prayers actually cancel each
other out.
65.39. He submits that now that it has been
established that the cancellation or withdrawal
was regards another notification though dated
05.02.1920, the notification in respect of
Moorkangudda State Forest dated 05.02.1920
subject matter of the writ petition continues to
be in operation. He invokes the doctrine of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 158 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
public trust and submits that the State
Authorities are custodians of forest land. There
is a deemed trust which has been created
requiring the State to protect the interest not
only of the present generation but also of the
future generation thereby making it a custodian
of intra-generational equity and it is discharge
of this obligation that the Government including
the Forest Department is discharging.
65.40. He relies upon the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in M.C. Mehta v. Kamal Nath ,
[(1997) 1 SCC 388], which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
"Public Trust Doctrine was founded on the ideas that
certain common properties such as rivers, sea-shore,
forests and the air were held by the Government in
trusteeship for the free and unimpeded use of the
general public. These natural resources have a great
importance to the people as a whole that it would wholly
unjustified to make them subject to private ownership.
These resources being a gift of nature, should be made
freely available to everyone irrespective of the status in
life. The doctrine enjoins upon the Government to
protect the resources for the enjoyment of the
general public rather than to permit their use for
private ownership or commercial purposes.”
65.41. By relying on M.C Mehta , he submits that the
State, as a trustee of natural resources, bears a
public duty to protect and preserve forests and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 159 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
other ecologically significant resources for the
benefit of the public, including future
generations. He contends that this duty
requires the State authorities to prevent the
unauthorised appropriation, degradation or
exploitation of forest lands and to ensure that
natural resources are not dealt with solely in
furtherance of private or commercial interests
at the expense of the public good. He submits
that the action taken by the State to protect
the subject land must be considered in the light
of this obligation. According to him, the
doctrine of public trust reinforces the State’s
responsibility to preserve the land and its
ecological value.
65.42. He relies upon the decision of the Hon'ble Apex
Court in the case of Narinder Singh and Ors.
v. Divesh Bhutani [2022 SCC OnLine SC 899],
more particularly Para 41 thereof, which is
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
41. If a land is shown as a forest in government
records, it will be governed by Section 2. A
government record is a record maintained by its various
departments. A government record is always made after
following a certain process. Only the entries made
after following due process can be a part of any
government record. Government records will include
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 160 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
land or revenue records, being statutory documents. For
the same reason, it will also include the record of the
Forest Department. After all, the Forest Department is
the custodian of forests. It is this department of the State
which is under an obligation to protect the forests for
upholding the constitutional mandate. Further, it is this
department which identifies the forest lands and
maintains a record. Therefore, the record maintained by
the Forest Department of forest lands after duly
identifying the forest lands will necessarily be a
government record.
65.43. By relying on Narinder Singh , his submission
is that the Forest Department, being the
custodian of forests, is under a constitutional
obligation to protect forest lands. He contends
that the Forest Department is entrusted with
the identification of forest lands and the
maintenance of records pertaining thereto.
Accordingly, records maintained by the Forest
Department following due identification of
forest lands constitute Government records
and, in his submission, are entitled to due
evidentiary consideration, including
presumptive value, while determining the
nature and status of the subject land.
65.44. He relies upon the judgment of the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of State of Karnataka
vs. I.S.Nirvane Gowda & ors., [(2007) 15
SCC 744], more particularly Para 4 thereof,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 161 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
which is reproduced hereunder for ease of
reference:
4. The trial court as well as the first appellate court,
based on the evidence, recorded findings that the lands
in question were the part of reserved forest. We do not
find any good ground or a valid reason for rejection of
Ext. D-1 by the High Court. When the lands were
included in reserve forest, the entries in the
revenue records were of no consequence and
further, mere saguvali chits did not confer any title
on the suit lands. This apart, the Revenue
Authorities were not competent to deal with the
property which was the part of the reserved forest.
The first appellate court was right in affirming the
judgment and decree of the trial court. We find it difficult
to sustain the impugned judgment and decree as far as
these Respondents — I.S. Nirwane Gowda and B.
Govindaraj in these two appeals are concerned. In this
view these appeals are entitled to succeed. Accordingly,
they are allowed. The impugned judgment and decree
passed by the High Court, so far as these Respondents,
namely, I.S. Nirwane Gowda and B. Govindaraj are
concerned, are set aside and the judgment and decree
passed by the first appellate court affirming the judgment
and decree of the trial court dismissing the suits are
restored. No costs.
65.45. By relying on I.S.Nirvane Gowda he submits
that once land has been duly constituted as
reserved forest, entries in the revenue records
do not, by themselves, confer title or override
its status as reserved forest. He further
contends that the mere issuance of saguvali
chits does not confer title to land forming part
of a reserved forest and that the Revenue
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 162 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Authorities lack competence to deal with such
land. On this basis, he submits that the revenue
entries and grants relied upon by the
Petitioners cannot be considered in isolation,
but must be examined in the context of the
legal status of the subject land and the
statutory framework governing reserved
forests.
W.P. NO. 19980/2023
65.46. Insofar as W.P. No. 19980/2023 is concerned,
learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the contentions advanced on behalf of the
Respondents in W.P. No. 16251/2023 would, to
a substantial extent, apply equally to the
present writ petition. He further points out that
the Petitioner in W.P. No. 19980/2023 is the
husband of the first Petitioner and the father of
the other Petitioner in W.P. No. 16251/2023 and
submits that the issues arising in the two
petitions are, therefore, closely interconnected.
He reiterates that the Petitioner has advanced
an incorrect claim regarding the alleged
withdrawal or cancellation of the notification
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 163 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
dated 05.02.1920 relating to the Moorkangudda
State Forest.
65.47. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the notification dated 11.01.1924, upon
which reliance is placed in support of the
alleged withdrawal or cancellation, was issued
under sub-section (1) of Section 48 of the
Mysore Land Acquisition Regulation, 1894, in
relation to the proposed acquisition of certain
lands by the Government. According to him, the
said notification concerned the withdrawal of
acquisition proceedings in respect of 68 acres
and 33 guntas of land and had no bearing on
the notification dated 05.02.1920 issued under
Section 4 of the Mysore Forest Regulation,
1900, in respect of the Moorkangudda State
Forest, comprising an extent of 7,938 acres and
38 guntas. He contends that the two
notifications relate to distinct statutory
proceedings and that the withdrawal of the
proposed acquisition of a specified extent of
land under the land acquisition legislation
cannot be construed as having the effect of
withdrawing or cancelling the notification issued
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 164 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
in relation to the constitution of the State
Forest.
65.48. He therefore submits that the Petitioner's
reliance on the notification dated 11.01.1924 to
contend that the notification dated 05.02.1920
ceased to operate is misconceived. According to
him, unless the notification relating to the
Moorkangudda State Forest was itself
withdrawn or otherwise rendered inoperative in
accordance with law, the notification issued
under Section 4 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, would continue to have the
legal effect attributable to it under the
applicable statutory provisions. He accordingly
maintains that the Petitioner's claim must be
examined on the basis of the distinction
between the proceedings under the Mysore
Land Acquisition Regulation, 1894, and those
initiated under the Mysore Forest Regulation,
1900.
65.49. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the Petitioner has himself asserted
that he is in unauthorised occupation of the
land situated in Survey No. 92 of Achanahalli
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 165 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Village. He contends that this assertion
assumes significance in determining the nature
of the Petitioner's claim over the subject land.
According to him, the Petitioner's own case is
not founded on an established title or a
recognised right of occupation, but on an
occupation which he subsequently sought to
have regularised by approaching the Revenue
Authorities. He submits that, in the absence of
an independently established legal right over
the subject land, the Petitioner cannot rely
merely on his continued occupation thereof to
resist the action initiated by the Forest
Department.
65.50. He further contends that the Petitioner's
assertion of unauthorised occupation, when
considered alongside his subsequent
applications seeking regularisation, undermines
his claim that he possesses an existing and
enforceable right over the subject land. On this
basis, he submits that the Petitioner cannot
claim a right against the Forest Department
merely by reason of his occupation, particularly
when the land is claimed by the State to form
part of the Moorkangudda State Forest. He
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 166 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
maintains that the legal status of the land and
the Petitioner's entitlement, if any, to occupy it
must be determined with reference to the
applicable statutory provisions and the relevant
records.
65.51. In this context, learned Additional Advocate
General submits that the proceedings initiated
against the Petitioner under Section 64A of the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, are proper and
justified. He contends that the Petitioner,
having failed to establish a lawful entitlement to
occupy the subject land, cannot resist
proceedings for removal of unauthorised
occupation merely on the basis of his
possession or the pendency of his earlier
requests for regularisation. According to him,
the action taken by the Forest Department is
intended to protect the land claimed to be
under its control and to prevent continued
occupation without lawful authority.
65.52. He accordingly submits that the proceedings
under Section 64A must be considered in the
light of the Petitioner's asserted unauthorised
occupation, the alleged forest status of the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 167 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
subject land and the statutory powers conferred
on the competent Forest Officer. He maintains
that the initiation of such proceedings cannot
be faulted merely because the Petitioner has
been in occupation of the land for a
considerable period, particularly when no order
regularising such occupation has been passed in
his favour.
65.53. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the Petitioner approached the
Revenue Authorities only after several decades
of occupation, seeking regularisation of the
structures and cultivation on the subject land.
He refers to the application dated 02.09.2021,
stated to have been filed under Section 94C of
the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964, seeking
regularisation of a house measuring
approximately 2,400 square feet constructed on
the subject land. He submits that the said
application was rejected by the Tahsildar,
Sakleshpur, by order dated 01.07.2024. He
contends that the rejection of the application
demonstrates that the Petitioner has not
obtained regularisation of the house through
the statutory process invoked by him and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 168 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
cannot, on that basis, assert a right to continue
in occupation.
65.54. He also refers to the application dated
15.09.2022, filed under Section 94A of the
Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964, seeking
regularisation of unauthorised cultivation over
an extent of four acres in Survey No. 92 of
Achanahalli Village. Learned Additional
Advocate General submits that the said
application was rejected by the Deputy
Commissioner, Hassan, by order dated
07.08.2024. He contends that the Petitioner
has, therefore, failed to secure regularisation
either of the house constructed on the land or
of the cultivation carried on therein. According
to him, the Petitioner cannot rely upon the
mere filing of applications for regularisation as
conferring any right or legitimate expectation of
continued occupation, particularly when the
competent Revenue Authorities have rejected
the applications.
65.55. Learned Additional Advocate General
accordingly submits that the Petitioner's claim
to continue in occupation is not supported by
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 169 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
any order granting regularisation under
Sections 94A or 94C of the Karnataka Land
Revenue Act, 1964. He contends that the
Petitioner's own case, as reflected in the
applications submitted to the Revenue
Authorities, is that he sought regularisation of
an existing unauthorised occupation, and that
such requests have been rejected. In these
circumstances, he submits that the Petitioner
cannot claim to have acquired a lawful right to
occupy the subject land merely by reason of the
passage of time or the construction of a house
and cultivation thereon.
65.56. He therefore contends that the Petitioner has
not established a legally enforceable right which
would entitle him to the reliefs sought in the
writ petition. He submits that the rejection of
the regularisation applications, read with the
Petitioner's assertion of unauthorised
occupation and the State's claim that the land
forms part of the Moorkangudda State Forest,
supports the action initiated by the Forest
Department under Section 64A of the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963. On these grounds,
he seeks dismissal of the writ petition.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 170 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.57. He relies on the judgment of this Court in the
case of B.R.Ganapathi Singh vs. State of
Karnataka [2020 SCC Online Kar 3074], more
particularly Para 64 thereof, which is
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
64. Having regard to the definition of forest enunciated
by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, it must be held that all
statutorily recognized forest, whether designated as
reserved forest, protected or otherwise, must be held to
come within the scope of the expression “Forest”. In the
instant case, the land in question was decided to be
constituted as reserved forest under S. 4 of the Act.
Merely because a final declaration under S. 17 of
the Act has not been issued in the instant case, it
cannot be held that subject land is not forest land.
As already noted, when once the land is decided to
be constituted as reserved forest under S. 4 of the
Act, it continues to be forest land until the
procedure contemplated for exclusion of any
portion of the said land from being declared as
reserved forest is completed by adjudication of the
claims. If no claim is made in respect of the land
constituted as reserved forest under S. 4 of the Act, it
fructifies as reserved forest. The object of issuance of
Notification under S. 17 of the Act is to restate the
boundaries of the reserved forest after excluding the
lands constituted as reserved forest on adjudication of
the claims under the Act. Thus, if there are no claims
which are adjudicated, then the land intended to be
constituted as reserved forest is declared as reserved
forest.
65.58. By relying on B.R.Ganapathi Singh , he
submits that the absence of a final notification
under Section 17 of the Karnataka Forest Act,
1963, does not, by itself, necessarily establish
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 171 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
that land covered by a notification under
Section 4 is not forest land. He contends that,
once the statutory process for constituting land
as reserved forest has been initiated under
Section 4, the land continues to retain its
character as forest land unless and until the
claims and objections are dealt with in
accordance with the applicable statutory
procedure and the land is excluded, where
warranted, from the proposed reserved forest.
He further submits that, where no claims are
made or where the statutory process does not
result in the exclusion of any portion of the
notified land, the absence of a final notification
cannot, in itself, be treated as determinative of
the land’s status. On this basis, he contends
that the legal effect of the notification dated
05.02.1920 relating to the Moorkangudda State
Forest must be considered in the light of the
principles enunciated in B.R. Ganapathi
Singh , together with the relevant statutory
provisions and the subsequent proceedings
concerning the subject land.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 172 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
W.P. NO. 29656/2024
65.59. Insofar as W.P. No. 29656/2024 is concerned,
learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the proceedings relating to the constitution
of the Moorkangudda State Forest have
progressed in accordance with the statutory
scheme contemplated under the Karnataka
Forest Act, 1963. He submits that the
Government, by Government Order No. FEE
258AASE 2022, Bengaluru, dated 19.12.2022,
appointed a Forest Settlement Officer to
conclude the proceedings in accordance with
the provisions of the said Act. The officer so
appointed is arrayed as Respondent No. 13 in
the present writ petition. Pursuant to the said
appointment, Respondent No. 13 issued a
proclamation under Section 5 of the Karnataka
Forest Act, 1963, on 19.07.2023, calling upon
persons claiming any right or interest in or over
the lands comprised within the notified limits to
submit their respective claims in accordance
with law.
65.60. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that, pursuant to the proclamation
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 173 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
issued under Section 5 of the Act, several
persons came forward and submitted their
claims before Respondent No. 13. The Forest
Settlement Officer thereafter undertook an
inquiry under Section 7 of the Karnataka Forest
Act, 1963, and proceeded to consider the
claims in accordance with the statutory
procedure. Upon consideration of the claims
and the material placed before him, Respondent
No. 13 passed orders under Section 14 of the
Act. According to learned Additional Advocate
General, the proceedings before the Forest
Settlement Officer were thus not merely at an
interlocutory stage but had culminated in an
order determining the claims put forward by the
persons concerned in relation to the notified
lands.
65.61. On the basis of the aforesaid statutory
proceedings, learned Additional Advocate
General raises a preliminary objection to the
maintainability of the writ petition. He submits
that, once the Forest Settlement Officer has
considered the claims and passed an order
under Section 14 of the Karnataka Forest Act,
1963, the aggrieved claimant is required to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 174 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
pursue the statutory remedy of appeal provided
under Section 16 of the Act. He contends that
the appellate remedy is specifically intended to
enable a person aggrieved by the determination
of the Forest Settlement Officer to question the
decision before the competent appellate forum,
namely, the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal.
According to him, the Petitioner cannot
disregard the remedy expressly provided by the
legislature and directly invoke the writ
jurisdiction of this Court to challenge the
determination made by the Forest Settlement
Officer.
65.62. He further submits that the statutory appellate
forum is competent to examine the legality and
correctness of the order passed by Respondent
No. 13, including the determination of the
claims and the treatment of the documentary
material relied upon by the Petitioner.
Therefore, according to learned Additional
Advocate General, the Petitioner ought to have
availed himself of the remedy under Section 16
of the Act, rather than seeking adjudication of
the disputed claims in the present writ
proceedings. He accordingly contends that the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 175 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
writ petition is liable to be rejected on the
ground that an efficacious alternative statutory
remedy is available to the Petitioner.
65.63. Learned Additional Advocate General draws
attention to the order dated 24.10.2025 passed
by Respondent No. 13 and submits that the
Petitioner’s claim was considered by the Forest
Settlement Officer and was neither wholly
accepted nor wholly rejected. He points out that
Respondent No. 13 recognised the Petitioner’s
rights in respect of an extent of 5 acres and 38
guntas in old Survey No. 167, corresponding to
new Survey No. 102 of Agni Village, while
rejecting the claim in respect of a further extent
of 11 acres and 18 guntas in Agni Village. He
submits that the order thus reflects an
adjudication of the Petitioner’s claim to the
extent considered by the Forest Settlement
Officer and distinguishes between the extent in
respect of which rights were recognised and the
extent in respect of which the claim was not
accepted.
65.64. According to learned Additional Advocate
General, if the Petitioner is aggrieved by the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 176 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
rejection of his claim to the extent of 11 acres
and 18 guntas, the appropriate course is to
challenge that part of the order by filing an
appeal under Section 16 of the Karnataka
Forest Act, 1963, before the Karnataka
Appellate Tribunal. He submits that the
Petitioner cannot seek to have the disputed
claim reconsidered in writ proceedings without
first pursuing the statutory remedy available
against the order of the Forest Settlement
Officer. He accordingly reiterates that the
objection concerning the availability of an
alternative remedy applies with particular force
to the challenge against the rejection of the
Petitioner’s claim.
65.65. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the Petitioner did not place before
Respondent No. 13 documentary material
sufficient to establish his ownership over the
lands claimed by him. He identifies the
properties in question as an extent of 5 acres
and 38 guntas in Survey No. 102 and an extent
of 5 acres and 23 guntas in Survey No. 198 of
Agni Village, within Kamanahalli Mandala
Panchayat, Sakleshpur Taluk, Hassan District.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 177 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
According to him, a person asserting a right or
interest in land included within the notified
limits is required to substantiate the claim by
producing the relevant title documents and
other supporting material before the Forest
Settlement Officer. He contends that the
Petitioner failed to establish a clear and legally
sustainable basis for the title claimed over the
disputed extents.
65.66. He further submits that the Petitioner’s claim to
ownership must be examined not merely on the
basis of possession or isolated revenue entries,
but with reference to the documents evidencing
the origin and devolution of title. According to
him, the Petitioner did not establish the source
from which his alleged predecessor derived
title, the nature of the right held by such
predecessor, or the manner in which the right
was transferred to the Petitioner. He therefore
contends that, in the absence of a satisfactorily
established chain of title, the Petitioner cannot
claim that the order passed by the Forest
Settlement Officer is liable to be interfered with
in the exercise of the writ jurisdiction of this
Court.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 178 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.67. Learned Additional Advocate General also
emphasises that the Petitioner claims to have
purchased the subject properties on
19.01.2011, nearly nine decades after the
notification dated 05.02.1920 was issued under
Section 4 of the Mysore Forest Regulation,
1900. He submits that the purchase relied upon
by the Petitioner is subsequent to the issuance
of the notification and that the Petitioner cannot
disregard the legal consequences, if any,
flowing from that notification merely because
the purchase was effected at a later point of
time. According to him, the date of purchase is
a material circumstance in examining the
Petitioner’s claim, particularly in view of the
State’s contention that the lands in question fall
within the boundaries of the area notified for
constitution as the Moorkangudda State Forest.
65.68. He further submits that the Petitioner acquired
the property long after the issuance of the
notification and must, therefore, establish that
the person from whom he purchased the land
possessed a transferable right capable of being
conveyed to him. Learned Additional Advocate
General contends that a subsequent
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 179 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
conveyance cannot, by itself, establish a better
title in the purchaser than that possessed by
the transferor. He accordingly submits that the
Petitioner was required to demonstrate not only
the execution of the purchase transaction dated
19.01.2011, but also the subsisting title of the
transferor and the legal entitlement to convey
the land, having regard to the prior forest
notification and the statutory proceedings
undertaken thereafter.
65.69. Learned Additional Advocate General
specifically submits that, out of the lands
claimed by the Petitioner, an extent of 5 acres
and 23 guntas in Survey No. 198 of Agni Village
falls within the boundaries covered by the
notification dated 05.02.1920. He contends that
the location of the said extent within the
notified boundary is a material circumstance
that cannot be overlooked while examining the
Petitioner’s claim of ownership. According to
him, the Petitioner’s purchase in 2011 does not,
without further proof, establish that the land
was available for valid transfer or that the
transferor possessed a right capable of being
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 180 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
conveyed, particularly if the land was subject to
a subsisting statutory forest notification.
65.70. He further submits that the Petitioner has not
produced a satisfactory account of the title
history of the property tracing the rights from
the original holder through the successive
transfers, if any, up to the purchase relied upon
by him. In his submission, the absence of a
clear chain of title assumes particular
significance where the State asserts that the
land falls within an area notified for constitution
as a State Forest. He therefore contends that
the Petitioner cannot establish an enforceable
right merely by relying upon the purchase
transaction without first demonstrating the title
of the transferor and the legal status of the
land at the time of the transfer.
65.71. Learned Additional Advocate General
accordingly submits that the Petitioner’s
challenge to the order dated 24.10.2025 is
liable to be considered in the light of the
statutory proceedings conducted by Respondent
No. 13, the determination made under Section
14 of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, and the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 181 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
appellate remedy available under Section 16 of
the Act. He reiterates that the Petitioner has
failed to establish a clear chain of title to the
disputed lands and that a substantial portion of
the property claimed by him, namely, 5 acres
and 23 guntas in Survey No. 198 of Agni
Village, is stated to fall within the boundaries
covered by the notification dated 05.02.1920.
He submits that the subsequent purchase dated
19.01.2011 cannot, in itself, displace the legal
consequences of the earlier notification, if it
remained operative and applicable to the land
in question.
65.72. On these grounds, learned Additional Advocate
General contends that the Petitioner has not
made out a case for interference in the exercise
of the writ jurisdiction of this Court and that the
Petitioner ought to be relegated to the statutory
appellate remedy available under Section 16 of
the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, in respect of
the order passed by Respondent No. 13.
65.73. He further relies upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Prabhagiya Van
Adhikari Awadh Van Prabhag v. Arun
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 182 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Kumar Bhardwaj , [(2021) 18 SCC 104], more
particularly paragraphs 24 and 28, which are
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
24. Mr. Khan further raised an argument that the
final notification under Section 20 of the Forest Act
has not been published. A reading of Section 20 of
the Forest Act does not show that for a reserved
forest, there is a requirement of publication of
notification but no time limit is prescribed for
publication of such notification under Section 20.
Therefore, even if notification under Section
20 of the Forest Act has not been issued, by
virtue of Section 5 of the Forest Act, there is a
prohibition against acquisition of any right
over the land comprised in such notification
except by way of a contract executed in
writing by or on behalf of the Government.
Since no such written contract was executed by or
on behalf of the State or on behalf of the person in
whom such right was vested, therefore, the Gaon
Sabha was not competent to grant lease in favour of
the appellant.
xxx
28. The High Court had referred to the objections
filed by the lessees under the Consolidation Act and
also objections by the Forest Department. It was
held by the High Court that since no objections were
filed by the Forest Department earlier, therefore,
the objections would be barred by Section 49 of the
Consolidation Act. We find that such finding
recorded by the High Court is clearly erroneous.
The land vests in the Forest Department by
virtue of notification published under a
statute. It was the lessee who had to assert
the title on the forest land by virtue of an
agreement in writing by a competent authority
but no such agreement in writing has been
produced. Therefore, the lessee would not be
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 183 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
entitled to any right only on the basis of an
entry in the revenue record.
65.74. By relying on Arun Kumar Bhardwaj , Learned
Additional Advocate General submits that in
paragraph 24, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
observed that, notwithstanding the absence of
a final notification under Section 20 of the
applicable Forest Act, the prohibition under
Section 5 against acquisition of rights over land
comprised in the preliminary notification
continued to operate, except where such rights
were acquired under a written contract
executed by or on behalf of the Government or
a person competent to create such rights. The
Court consequently held that the Gaon Sabha
was not competent to grant the lease in
question in the absence of such a written
contract.
65.75. In paragraph 28, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
further held that the lessee could not claim
rights over the forest land merely on the basis
of an entry in the revenue records, particularly
when no written agreement executed by a
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 184 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
competent authority had been produced to
establish the claimed title.
65.76. Placing reliance on the aforesaid judgment, the
learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the absence of a final notification under
the applicable forest legislation does not, by
itself, render every subsequent grant or
transaction concerning land covered by a
preliminary forest notification legally valid. He
contends that the legal effect of any grant,
lease or other transaction relied upon by the
Petitioners must be examined with reference to
the applicable statutory restrictions and the
competence of the authority purporting to
create the right. He further submits that
revenue entries, by themselves, cannot confer
title where the claimed right is not supported
by a legally valid grant or other instrument
recognised by law.
65.77. Accordingly, he contends that the Petitioners
cannot rely solely upon revenue entries or
subsequent transactions to establish an
enforceable right over the lands in question
without demonstrating that the rights asserted
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 185 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
by them were lawfully created and are
consistent with the applicable forest legislation.
65.78. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the Petitioners have failed to explain the
source of title of their respective predecessors-
in-interest or to establish how the latter
acquired rights over the subject lands. He
further submits that the Petitioners appeared
before the Forest Settlement Officer and
produced documents in support of their
respective claims, thereby participating in and
submitting to the statutory proceedings before
the said authority. According to him, it is only
after the Forest Settlement Officer passed
orders adverse to their interests that the
Petitioners approached this Court by filing the
present writ petitions. He also contends that
the Petitioners have suppressed the material
fact of their participation in the proceedings
before the Forest Settlement Officer and have,
therefore, not placed the complete factual
background before this Court.
65.79. Learned Additional Advocate General reiterates
that, upon issuance of a notification under
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 186 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Section 4 of the Mysore Forest Regulation,
1900, the land comprised within the notified
limits is intended to be constituted as a State
Forest and must be dealt with in accordance
with the statutory scheme governing such
constitution. He submits that the subsequent
proceedings, including the inquiry into the
claims and rights asserted by interested
persons, are steps contemplated by the
Regulation, culminating in the issuance of the
final notification under Section 17.
65.80. Relying on Section 6 of the Regulation, he
contends that, during the prescribed period, no
new rights may be acquired over the notified
land except in the circumstances expressly
recognised by the provision. On this basis, he
submits that the Petitioners cannot claim rights
over the subject lands merely by relying upon
subsequent transactions or entries in the
revenue records, without establishing that such
rights were lawfully acquired and are
recognised under the applicable statutory
framework.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 187 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.81. He accordingly submits that the proceedings
initiated under Section 64A of the Karnataka
Forest Act, 1963, are in accordance with law.
According to him, the Petitioners are required
to participate in those proceedings, produce all
relevant documents in support of their claims
and permit the competent authority to consider
the material and pass appropriate orders in
accordance with law. He contends that the
Petitioners cannot circumvent the statutory
process by approaching this Court prematurely,
particularly when the relevant questions
concerning their claims and the status of the
land are required to be examined by the
competent authorities under the applicable
legislation.
W.P. No. 33767/2025
65.82. Insofar as W.P. No. 33767/2025 is concerned,
learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the writ petition has been filed by 87
Petitioners, of whom 86 appeared before the
Forest Settlement Officer and submitted their
objections and claims in respect of the lands
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 188 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
asserted by them. He submits that, pursuant to
their participation, the Forest Settlement Officer
conducted the inquiry and prepared a report,
which was forwarded to the concerned
authorities for further action in accordance with
law.
65.83. He further submits that the claims of certain
Petitioners have been admitted, either wholly or
in part, in the course of the proceedings before
the Forest Settlement Officer. In particular, the
claims of Petitioners Nos. 13, 14 and 15 in
respect of lands in Survey No. 14 of Jambaradi
Village, Petitioner No. 25 in respect of Survey
No. 91/3 of Achanahalli Village, and Petitioner
No. 26 in respect of Survey No. 104 of Agni
Village have been admitted to the extent of an
aggregate area of 14.07 acres, which,
according to him, falls within the extent of 68
acres and 33 guntas proposed to be acquired
by the State Government. He also refers to the
claim of Petitioner No. 50 in respect of 0.10
acres in Survey No. 124 of Achanahalli Village,
which, according to him, falls outside the
boundary covered by the notification dated
05.02.1920.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 189 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.84. Learned Additional Advocate General makes a
specific submission that the State will not
proceed against the lands to the extent of the
claims admitted by the Forest Settlement
Officer in respect of Petitioners Nos. 13, 14, 15,
25, 26 and 50. He submits that, to the extent
their claims have been recognised, those
Petitioners need not apprehend further
proceedings by the State in respect of the
admitted extents. However, insofar as the
claims of the Petitioners have been rejected or
have not been accepted in their entirety, he
contends that the appropriate remedy is to
challenge the adverse determination in an
appeal under Section 16 of the Karnataka
Forest Act, 1963, before the Karnataka
Appellate Tribunal. He submits that the
Petitioners, having participated in the
proceedings before the Forest Settlement
Officer, cannot bypass the statutory appellate
mechanism and seek a reconsideration of the
disputed claims directly in these writ
proceedings.
65.85. Learned Additional Advocate General further
refers to Notification No. R.8806-Ft.43-15-6,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 190 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
issued under Section 4 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, in respect of the
Moorkangudda Block, comprising an extent of
7,938 acres and 38 guntas. He submits that, as
on the date of issuance of the said notification,
all the lands comprised within the notified
extent, except 68 acres and 33 guntas, were
already at the disposal of the State
Government. According to him, it was only the
remaining extent of 68 acres and 33 guntas
that was required to be acquired by the State
Government. He contends that the distinction
between the total extent covered by the forest
notification and the smaller extent proposed to
be acquired is material to understanding the
effect of the subsequent Government order
dated 11.01.1924.
65.86. In this regard, learned Additional Advocate
General submits that the Petitioners are seeking
to create confusion by relying upon the
withdrawal made in 1924 without distinguishing
between the relevant notifications. He contends
that the Government order dated 11.01.1924
related to Notification No. R.8808-Ft.43-15-7
and not to Notification No. R.8806-Ft.43-15-6,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 191 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
which pertains to the Moorkangudda Block and
is the subject matter of the present
controversy. According to him, Notification No.
R.8806-Ft.43-15-6 has never been withdrawn
or cancelled and continues to remain in force.
He therefore submits that the Petitioners
cannot rely upon the withdrawal of a different
notification to contend that the notification
dated 05.02.1920 concerning the
Moorkangudda Block has ceased to operate.
65.87. Learned Additional Advocate General also
disputes the Petitioners’ contention that the
Mysore Forest Act, 1900, and the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, are distinct enactments
having separate legal identities relevant to the
present controversy. He submits that the
Petitioners are attempting to introduce an
untenable distinction between the two
descriptions of the legislation. According to him,
whether referred to as the Mysore Forest Act,
1900, or the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900,
the statutory scheme relied upon by the State
is the same and provides that, following the
issuance of a preliminary notification under
Section 4, claims and rights over the notified
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 192 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
land are to be dealt with in accordance with the
prescribed procedure, subject to the restrictions
contained in Section 6. He contends that the
Petitioners cannot avoid the legal consequences
of the notification by relying upon the
nomenclature of the enactment under which it
was issued, his further submission is that the
nomenclature has been used interchangeably,
both of them are one and the same is his
submission.
65.88. He further submits that the restriction under
Section 6 operates during the period
contemplated by the provision, pending
completion of the statutory process culminating
in the final notification under Section 17.
According to him, the Petitioners’ contention
that rights could freely accrue over the notified
lands during the intervening period is contrary
to the statutory scheme. He therefore submits
that any claim founded on subsequent grants,
transfers or other transactions must be
examined in the light of Section 6, including the
exceptions expressly provided therein, and
cannot be accepted merely because the
transaction is reflected in revenue records.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 193 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.89. With regard to the repeal of the Mysore Forest
legislation of 1900, learned Additional Advocate
General submits that the Karnataka Forest Act,
1963, repealed the earlier enactment but
preserved the legal effect of actions validly
taken thereunder. He contends that the repeal
did not, by itself, extinguish the notification
dated 05.02.1920, which had been issued
under the earlier legislation. According to him,
the notification and the proceedings validly
undertaken pursuant thereto continue to have
legal effect, subject to the applicable repeal-
and-savings provisions and any subsequent
lawful action affecting them. On this basis, he
submits that the notification relating to the
Moorkangudda Block cannot be treated as
having lapsed merely because the earlier forest
legislation was repealed.
65.90. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the Petitioners have not placed on
record any material demonstrating that the
State Government had granted the subject
lands to them or to their respective
predecessors-in-interest. He contends that the
Petitioners have failed to establish the source of
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 194 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
their alleged title and have not produced
documents tracing the origin and devolution of
title through the successive holders of the
properties. According to him, the mere
assertion of ownership, possession or reliance
upon revenue entries is insufficient to establish
a lawful entitlement to the lands, particularly
where the State disputes the Petitioners’ claims
and asserts that the lands fall within the area
covered by the forest notification.
65.91. He draws attention to the Record of Rights,
Tenancy and Crops (RTCs) and submits that, in
respect of more than 6,400 acres of land, the
name of the Forest Department is recorded in
Column Nos. 9 or 11. According to him, these
entries are material evidence of the association
of the lands with the Forest Department and
support the State’s contention that the lands
were not at the disposal of the Revenue
Department for grant or disposal as ordinary
revenue lands. He submits that the relevant
revenue records must be considered along with
the forest notification, the records maintained
by the Forest Department and the statutory
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 195 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
proceedings undertaken in respect of the
notified area.
65.92. Learned Additional Advocate General further
contends that the Revenue Department did not
have administrative control over the lands
which were under the control of the Forest
Department and, consequently, could not
validly grant or dispose of such lands without
the requisite authority under law. He submits
that, even if any grant, auction or other
transaction is shown to have been effected by
the Revenue Department, the validity and legal
effect of such transaction must be examined
with reference to the status of the land at the
relevant time and the authority of the
department purporting to deal with it.
According to him, a transaction effected by an
authority lacking the requisite competence
cannot, merely by reason of its entry in the
revenue records or the subsequent possession
of the grantee or purchaser, establish an
indefeasible right against the State.
65.93. He further submits that, in several instances,
the Revenue Department has granted,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 196 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
auctioned or otherwise dealt with lands claimed
by the Forest Department without obtaining the
latter’s concurrence and in disregard of the
statutory restrictions applicable to forest lands.
According to him, such transactions cannot be
treated as conclusive proof of title merely
because they were undertaken by a
Government department. He contends that the
respective powers and responsibilities of the
Revenue and Forest Departments must be
determined with reference to the governing
statutes and the legal status of the lands
concerned, rather than solely by reference to
the fact that a grant or auction was conducted
by the Revenue Department.
65.94. Learned Additional Advocate General also refers
to the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, which
came into force on 25.10.1980, and submits
that even after its commencement, forest lands
continued in certain instances to be granted or
diverted by the Revenue Department without
obtaining the prior approval of the Central
Government contemplated under Section 2 of
the said Act. He contends that such action,
where it involved the diversion of forest land for
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 197 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
a non-forest purpose and attracted Section 2,
could not lawfully be undertaken without
compliance with the statutory requirement. He
therefore submits that transactions involving
the grant, assignment or diversion of land
claimed to be forest land must be scrutinised in
the light of the applicable forest legislation and
cannot be presumed valid merely because they
were effected through the Revenue
Department.
65.95. Finally, learned Additional Advocate General
reiterates that the Forest Settlement Officer has
completed the inquiry and submitted a report in
which the claims of certain Petitioners have
been admitted, either wholly or in part. He
submits that the Petitioners participated in the
statutory proceedings, produced documents
and had an opportunity to substantiate their
claims before the competent authority.
According to him, they cannot now disregard
the outcome of those proceedings and seek to
challenge the process itself before this Court
merely because the determination is adverse to
their interests. He maintains that the
Petitioners whose claims have been rejected or
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 198 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
only partially admitted must pursue the
statutory appellate remedy under Section 16 of
the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, before the
Karnataka Appellate Tribunal. On these
grounds, he seeks rejection of the Petitioners’
challenge to the proceedings and reiterates that
the State is entitled to take such further action
as is permissible under the applicable law.
65.96. He refers to the Forest Conservation Act, 1980
more particularly Section 2 thereof, he submits
that forest land cannot be diverted for a non-
forest purpose, assigned by way of lease or
otherwise, or dereserved without the prior
approval of the Central Government, wherever
such approval is statutorily required. He
contends that the lands in question have
consistently been treated as forest land and
that, in the absence of material establishing
otherwise, the contrary contention cannot be
accepted.
65.97. As regards the ecological significance of the
subject lands, learned counsel submits that
Moorkangudda forms part of the Western
Ghats, a region of exceptional ecological
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 199 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
importance, characterised by rich biodiversity,
high levels of endemism and a variety of
sensitive forest and grassland ecosystems. He
relies upon the recognition of the Western
Ghats as one of the world’s eight biodiversity
hotspots and submits that the region contains
some of the finest examples of non-equatorial
tropical evergreen forests and is home to a
substantial number of globally threatened
species of flora and fauna. In this regard, he
refers to the identification of at least 325
globally threatened species in the Western
Ghats, including plants, mammals, birds,
amphibians, reptiles and fish. He further
submits that the ecological importance of the
region is not confined to its biodiversity but
extends to the regulation of the monsoon, the
maintenance of catchment areas and the
sustenance of water systems upon which a
large population depends.
65.98. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the presence of wildlife in the Western
Ghats, including tigers, elephants, leopards,
gaurs and sloth bears, as well as other species
such as the leopard cat, mouse deer, Indian
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 200 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
porcupine, barking deer, peacock and jungle
fowl, underscores the need to preserve the
ecological integrity of the region. He also refers
to species such as the Nilgiri marten, brown
palm civet, Indian brown mongoose and lion-
tailed macaque, which are associated with the
biodiversity of the Western Ghats. Relying upon
camera-trap exercises and other observations
said to have been undertaken in the area, he
submits that the Moorkangudda landscape
provides habitat for wildlife and that its
protection is necessary to preserve the
ecological balance of the region. He contends
that the species-specific claims, including the
presence of particular species in Moorkangudda
and their respective statutory classifications.
65.99. Learned Additional Advocate General places
particular emphasis on the shola forests and
grasslands of Moorkangudda. He submits that
these ecosystems perform an important
hydrological function by intercepting and
absorbing rainfall, facilitating infiltration and
releasing water gradually into streams and
rivers. According to him, the grasslands
function as natural catchment areas and help
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 201 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
regulate runoff and sustain stream flows
beyond the monsoon season. He contends that
their ecological value cannot be assessed
merely by reference to their outward
appearance, since an area that appears to be
open grassland may nevertheless perform an
indispensable function within a forest and
catchment ecosystem. He therefore submits
that the protection of Moorkangudda must take
account of the interdependence of its shola
forests, grasslands, soil, water resources and
wildlife.
65.100. He further submits that the ecological
consequences of degradation would not be
confined to the immediate locality. According to
him, encroachment, unauthorised occupation,
construction and commercial activities,
including the operation of resorts, could alter
the natural characteristics of the area, impair
its water-retention capacity and adversely
affect the streams originating therein. He
contends that the Forest Department is
consequently required to act proactively to
prevent unauthorised occupation and protect
the area from activities that may compromise
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:57, Bengaluru
Verified
- 202 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
its ecological integrity. Learned counsel submits
that the protection of the subject lands must be
considered in the context of the larger
environmental interests involved and not
merely as a dispute concerning the competing
claims of individual occupants and the State.
65.101. In support of the hydrological significance of
the area, learned counsel refers to streams said
to originate in the Moorkangudda forest,
including Bennehalla and Chettinahalla, which,
according to him, join the Yagachi River and
thereafter the Hemavathi River, ultimately
forming part of the east-flowing Cauvery river
system, which drains into the Bay of Bengal. He
also refers to the Yettinahole stream, which he
submits originates in the Western Ghats and
forms part of the west-flowing river system that
ultimately drains into the Arabian Sea. On this
basis, he contends that the forest and grassland
ecosystems of Moorkangudda are connected
with the broader hydrological systems of the
region and that their degradation may have
consequences extending beyond the immediate
area.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 203 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.102. Learned Additional Advocate General further
refers to the Yettinahole Integrated Drinking
Water Project, undertaken by the Government
of Karnataka to address drinking-water
requirements in drought-prone parts of the
State by diverting water from west-flowing
streams originating in the Western Ghats. He
submits that the project involves a substantial
public investment and is intended to benefit
several districts, towns and villages by
providing drinking water and facilitating the
filling of irrigation tanks for groundwater
recharge. He refers to the project’s proposed
coverage of 6,657 villages and 38 towns, the
intended filling of 527 tanks, and the estimated
population of approximately 75 lakh
beneficiaries. He also refers to the revised
project cost of approximately ₹23,000 crore.
These particulars are relied upon to
demonstrate the public importance of
protecting the source catchments and
associated ecosystems.
65.103. Learned Additional Advocate General contends
that, if the shola forests and grasslands of
Moorkangudda are degraded, the consequences
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 204 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
may extend to the availability and regulation of
water in the region and may prejudice the
drinking-water interests of the population
intended to be served by the project. He
submits that the protection of these lands is
therefore not merely a matter of conserving
flora and fauna, but also concerns the
preservation of ecological services, catchment
functions and water security for southern
Karnataka. He accordingly urges that the
potential environmental consequences of
encroachment and unauthorised commercial
activity must be considered while examining the
legality of the proceedings initiated by the
Forest Department.
65.104. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the shola forests and grasslands of
Moorkangudda constitute a distinct and
ecologically sensitive ecosystem forming part of
the Western Ghats. He submits that the
ecological significance of the area cannot be
assessed merely by examining whether the land
is covered by dense tree growth or whether it
outwardly resembles a conventional forest. The
shola forests and the adjoining grasslands
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 205 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
function as an integrated ecological unit, each
performing a complementary role in the
conservation of biodiversity, the regulation of
water flows and the maintenance of the
regional environment. He contends that the
grasslands are not wastelands or ecologically
insignificant open areas, but form an integral
part of the natural landscape and contribute
substantially to its ecological stability.
65.105. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the shola forests and grasslands
perform an important hydrological function by
intercepting rainfall, facilitating the infiltration
of water into the soil and regulating the release
of water into streams and rivers. The
grasslands, in particular, are said to function as
natural catchment areas by absorbing and
retaining rainfall and moderating surface runoff.
According to him, these characteristics enable
the ecosystem to sustain stream flows beyond
the monsoon season and contribute to the
replenishment of water resources. He therefore
submits that the ecological value of
Moorkangudda extends beyond the immediate
forest area and encompasses the maintenance
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 206 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
of the catchments and water systems
associated with the Western Ghats.
65.106. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the shola forests and grasslands of
Moorkangudda must be viewed as an
interconnected ecological system, the
degradation of which could have consequences
extending well beyond the immediate area. He
contends that encroachment, unauthorised
occupation, construction and commercial
activities, including the establishment and
operation of resorts, may disturb the natural
vegetation, alter soil characteristics, impair
water infiltration and affect the ecological
functions of the catchment. Such activities,
according to him, may consequently affect the
habitat of wildlife and the capacity of the
landscape to regulate water flows. He submits
that the protection of the area is therefore
necessary not only for the conservation of flora
and fauna but also for safeguarding the
ecological services upon which surrounding
communities depend.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 207 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.107. In this regard, learned Additional Advocate
General refers to the streams originating in and
around the Western Ghats, including those said
to form part of the Yagachi–Hemavathi–Cauvery
river system and the west-flowing river system
associated with the Netravati. He further refers
to the Yettinahole drinking-water project, which
is intended to address the water requirements
of drought-prone districts of Karnataka. He
submits that the ecological integrity of the
source catchments is material to the long-term
sustainability of water resources and that
damage to the shola forests and grasslands of
Moorkangudda may adversely affect the
hydrological functions of the region. He
accordingly contends that the potential
consequences of degradation must be
considered in the context of the larger public
interest in the conservation of water resources
and the protection of the environment.
65.108. Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the ecological importance of shola forests
and grasslands also warrants a precautionary
approach to activities that may cause
irreversible environmental damage. He
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 208 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
contends that the absence of dense tree cover
in a particular portion of the landscape cannot,
by itself, be treated as proof that the land is
ecologically insignificant or incapable of forming
part of a forest ecosystem. According to him,
the character and function of the land must be
assessed having regard to its vegetation,
ecological associations, catchment functions
and relationship with the surrounding forest
landscape. He therefore submits that any
proposal to permit construction, commercial
exploitation or other activities in the subject
area must be examined with due regard to the
potential impact on the shola ecosystem and
the public interest in its preservation.
65.109. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the State, as custodian of natural
resources held for the benefit of the public, is
under an obligation to protect ecologically
sensitive areas from degradation and
unauthorised exploitation. He relies upon the
public trust doctrine and the principles
governing environmental protection to contend
that natural ecosystems cannot be permitted to
deteriorate merely because portions of the land
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 209 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
have been occupied, developed or used for
commercial purposes. He submits that the
Forest Department’s efforts to protect
Moorkangudda must therefore be considered in
the light of the ecological functions performed
by the shola forests and grasslands and the
wider public interest in conserving the natural
environment.
65.110. Learned Additional Advocate General finally
submits that the ecological significance of
Moorkangudda reinforces the need to preserve
the area and to prevent further degradation
pending determination of the competing claims.
He contends that the protection of the shola
forests and grasslands is a matter of long-term
environmental security and that the
consequences of irreversible ecological damage
may extend to biodiversity, catchment stability
and the availability of water resources. He
accordingly urges that the claims of individual
occupants and the legality of the activities
undertaken in the subject lands be examined in
a manner that gives due consideration to the
ecological sensitivity of the area and the State’s
obligation to protect the environment.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 210 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.111. Turning to the statutory framework, learned
counsel submits that the preliminary
notification dated 05.02.1920 was issued under
Section 4 of the Mysore Forest Regulation,
1900, declaring the Government’s proposal to
constitute the notified area as a State Forest
and initiating the statutory process for the
ascertainment and settlement of rights claimed
in respect of the area. He contends that the
Regulation does not prescribe an express outer
time limit within which the final notification
under Section 17 must be published. On that
basis, he argues that the absence of a final
notification, merely because a considerable
period has elapsed since the preliminary
notification, should not automatically result in
the extinguishment of the State’s authority to
protect the notified lands.
65.112. He further submits that the preliminary
notification was not a mere declaration of an
intention without legal consequences. According
to him, the notification attracted the statutory
restrictions applicable to the notified area,
including restrictions upon the acquisition of
rights after its publication, subject to the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 211 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
exceptions recognised by law. He therefore
contends that the legal effect of the notification
must be examined in accordance with the
applicable provisions of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, and cannot be determined
solely by reference to the subsequent entries
made in revenue records, grants or other
dealings with the land. He submits that the
absence of a final notification under Section 17
does not, by itself, answer every question
concerning the subsistence of the preliminary
notification or the consequences flowing from it.
65.113. Learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that neither the Petitioners nor their
predecessors challenged the preliminary
notification dated 05.02.1920 for several
decades and that the present challenge has
been raised only after the Forest Settlement
Officer was appointed and proceedings were
initiated in respect of the subject lands. He
contends that the prolonged failure to question
the notification, coupled with the subsequent
challenge at the stage of the statutory
settlement proceedings, attracts the principles
of delay, laches and acquiescence. According to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 212 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
him, the Petitioners cannot permit the statutory
process to remain unchallenged for decades
and then seek to defeat the proceedings merely
by questioning the preliminary notification at a
belated stage.
65.114. He therefore submits that the challenge to the
notification and the consequential proceedings
is liable to be rejected on the grounds of delay,
laches and acquiescence. He further contends
that, having regard to the ecological
significance of the area and the public interest
in preserving its forest and catchment
functions, the passage of time should not, in
itself, be treated as sufficient to defeat the
State’s lawful efforts to protect the subject
lands. He accordingly urges that the Petitioners’
objections be examined in the light of the
statutory scheme, the legal effect of the
notification dated 05.02.1920, the nature of the
rights claimed by the Petitioners and the public
interest in the preservation of the area.
65.115. He also relies upon the judgment of this Court
in Girish H.E. v. State of Karnataka, [2013
SCC OnLine Kar 10537], more particularly
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 213 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
paragraphs 8, 10-17, and 19 to thereof, which
are reproduced hereunder for ease of
reference:
8. Any action taken by the authorities prior to the
issuance of the impugned notification is irrelevant
for the purpose of the case. The notification dated
22-6-1991 states that an extent of 422.32 hectares
in Uchangi Durga Village, Davangere District, is
notified as reserved forest. The said notification has
appointed the Range Forest Officer as the Forest
Settlement Officer. Once any land is notified to
constitute as a reserved forest, various steps are
contemplated under the Act before a declaration
can be issued under Section 17 of the Act declaring
that the land is reserved forest. The relevant
provisions of the Act in this regard are extracted
below for felicity of reference:
“2. Definitions. —In this Act, unless the context
otherwise requires.—
(14) “Reserved Forest” means any land
settled and notified as such in accordance
with the provisions of Chapter II of this Act;
3. Powers to constitute reserved forests .— The
State Government may constitute any land which is
the property of the Government or over which the
Government has proprietary rights, or to the whole,
or any part of the forest produce of which the
Government is entitled, a reserved forest in the
manner hereinafter provided.
4. Notification by Government. —(1) Whenever it
has been decided to constitute any land a reserved
forest the State Government shall issue a
notification.—
(a) declaring that it has been decided to constitute
such land a reserved forest;
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 214 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
(b) specifying, as nearly as possible, the situation
and limits of such land; and
(c) appointing an officer (hereinafter called the
“Forest Settlement Officer”) to inquire into and
determine the existence, nature and extent of any
rights claimed by or alleged to exist in favour of any
person in or over any land comprised within such
limits or in or over any forest produce, and to deal
with the same as provided in this Chapter.
Explanation. —For the purpose of clause (b) it shall
be sufficient to describe the limits of the forest-by
roads, rivers, bridges, or other well-known or
readily intelligible boundaries.
(2) The officer appointed under clause (c) of sub-
section (1) shall, be a person not holding any forest
office except that of Forest Settlement Officer; but
a Forest Officer may be appointed by the State
Government to represent it in the inquiry under this
Chapter by the Forest Settlement Officer.
5. Proclamation by Forest Settlement Officer.
—When a notification has been issued under
Section 4, the Forest Settlement Officer shall
publish in Kannada and in any other regional
language of the area, at the Headquarters of” each
taluk in which any portion of the land comprised in
such notification is situate and in every town and
village in the neighbourhood of such land a
proclamation.—
(a) specifying, as nearly as possible, the situation
and limits of the proposed forest;
(b) setting forth the substance of the provisions of
Section 6;
(c) explaining the consequences which, as
hereinafter provided, will ensue on such forest
being constituted a reserved forest; and
(d) fixing a period of not less than three months
from the date of publishing such proclamation, and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 215 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
requiring every person claiming any right or making
any claim referred to or mentioned in Section 4,
either to present to such officer within such period
a written notice specifying or to appear before him
within such period and state the nature of such
right or claim (if any) and in either case to produce
all documents in support thereof.
The Forest Settlement Officer shall also serve a
notice to the same effect on every known or
reputed owner or occupier of any land included in
or adjoining the land proposed” to be constituted a
reserved forest or on his recognised agent or
manager. Such notice may be sent by registered
post to persons residing beyond the limits of the
district in which such land is situate.
6. Bar of accrual of forest rights. —(1) After the
issue of a notification under Section 4, no right shall
be acquired in or over the land comprised in such
notification, except by succession or under a grant
or contract in writing made or entered into by or on
behalf of the Government or some person in whom
such right, or power to create such right, was
vested when the notification was issued; and on
such land no new house shall be built or plantation
formed, no fresh clearings for cultivation or for any
other purpose shall be made and no trees shall be
cut for the purpose of trade or manufacture except
as hereinafter provided. No patta or right of
occupancy shall without the previous sanction of
the State Government be granted, in respect of
such land, and every patta or right of occupancy
granted without such sanction shall be null and
void.
(2) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to
prohibit any act done under the written permission
of the Forest Settlement Officer.
(3) No Civil Court shall, between the dates of
publication of the notification under Section 4 and
of the final notification to be issued under Section
17 entertain any suit to establish any right in or
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 216 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
over any land or to the forest produce of any land
included in the notification under Section 4.
7. Inquiry by Forest Settlement Officer. — The
Forest Settlement Officer shall take down in writing
all statements made under clause (d) of Section 5
and shall, at some convenient place, inquire into all
claims duly preferred under that section and into
the existence and extent of any rights mentioned in
Section 4 and not claimed under Section 5 so far as
the same may be ascertainable from the records of
the Government and the evidence of any person
likely to be acquainted with the same.
The Forest Settlement Officer shall at the same
time, consider and record any objection which the
Forest Officer, if any, appointed under sub-section
(2) of Section 4 may make to any such claim or any
information which he may afford with regard to the
existence and extent of any such right.
8. Powers of Forest Settlement Officer. — For
the purpose of such inquiry, the Forest Settlement
Officer may exercise the following powers, that is to
say.—
(i) power to enter, by himself or any officer
authorised by him for the purpose, upon any land,
and to survey, demarcate and make a map of the
same; and
(ii) the powers of a Civil Court in the trial of suits.
9. Extinction of rights — Rights in respect of
which no claim has been preferred under Section 5,
and of the existence of which no knowledge has
been acquired by inquiry under Section 7, shall be
extinguished unless, before the final notification
under Section 17 is published, the person claiming
them satisfies the Forest Settlement Officer that he
had sufficient cause for not preferring such claim
within the period fixed under Section 5 in which
case the Forest Settlement Officer shall proceed to
dispose of the claim as hereinafter provided.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 217 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
xxx
17. Notification declaring forest a reserved forest.—
(1) When the following events have occurred,
namely.—
(a) the period fixed under Section 5 for preferring
claims has elapsed, and all claims, if any, made
under that section or Section 9 have been disposed
of by the Forest Settlement Officer;
(b) if any such claims have been made, the period
limited by Section 16 for appealing from the orders
passed on such claims has elapsed and all appeals
(if any) presented within such period have been
disposed of; and
(c) all proceedings prescribed by Sections 11 and
14 have been taken and all lands and buildings (if
any) to be included in the proposed reserved forest,
which the Forest Settlement Officer has under
Section 11 elected to acquire under the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894, have become vested in the
Government under Section 16 of that Act,
the State Government shall publish a notification
specifying clearly according to the boundary marks
erected or otherwise, the limits of the forest which
is intended to constitute a reserved forest and
declaring the same to be a reserved forest from the
date fixed by such notification, subject to the
exercise of rights (if any) specified in such
notification.
(2) From the date so fixed, such forest shall be
deemed to be a reserved forest”.
10. The notification issued under Section 4 of the
Act may be termed as a Preliminary Notification.
The same has to be published by the Forest
Settlement Officer under Section 5 as a
proclamation and also a copy of the notice has to
be served on every known owner or occupier of any
land included in or adjoining the land proposed to
be constituted a reserved forest or on his
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 218 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
recognized agent or manager. On the issuance of a
notification under Section 4, no right can be
acquired in or over the land comprised in the
notification, except by succession or under a grant
or contract in writing made or entered into by or on
behalf of the Government. Also no Civil Court can
entertain any suit for the establishment of any right
on any land included in the notification issued under
Section 4.
11. Under clause (d) of Section 5 of the Act, under
which a proclamation is made by the Forest
Settlement Officer a period of three months from
the date of publishing the proclamation is given to
any person claiming any right or making any claim
referred to under Section 4 by producing all
documents in support thereof. If such a claim is
made, the Forest Settlement Officer has to enquire
into the claim by looking into the records of the
Government and the evidence of any person
acquainted with the same and also hear the
concerned Forest Officer as regards any objections
under Section 7.
12. Section 8 grants certain powers to the Forest
Settlement Officer for the purpose of conducting an
enquiry. If no claim is made within the period fixed
under Section 5 before the Forest Officer, any
rights in that regard shall be extinguished unless
before the final notification under Section 17 is
published, the person claiming them satisfies the
Forest Settlement Officer that he had sufficient
cause for not preferring such a claim within the
period fixed under Section 5 in which case the
Forest Settlement Officer would have to proceed to
dispose of the claim.
13. Section 10 deals with the manner in which
claims relating to shifting cultivation would have to
be dealt with. Section 11 enables the Forest
Settlement Officer to acquire land over which a
right is claimed in case such land is not excluded
from the limits of the reserved forest or no
agreement with the owner for the surrender of his
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 219 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
rights is arrived at. In the event of an acquisition,
the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
would apply and the Forest Settlement Officer
would act as a Deputy Commissioner. With regard
to the right of way to pasturage or other forest
produce or water, the Forest Settlement Officer has
to consider any such claims and pass an order
under Section 12 read with Sections 13 and 14. If
no settlement under Section 14 is arrived at, then
compensation has to be determined on the basis of
the value of the right claimed on the date of the
preliminary notification in accordance with the
provisions of the Act, insofar as such provisions are
applicable under Section 15 of the Act.
14. Section 16 provides for an appeal against an
order passed under Section 11, 12, 14 or 15. The
statutory period for filing of an appeal is three
months from the date of the order made by the
Forest Settlement Officer. Section 17 states that
when the period fixed under Section 5 for preferring
a claim has lapsed and all claims have been
disposed of under Section 9 and the period of
limitation for filing an appeal under Section 16 has
lapsed and appeals if any filed have been disposed
of and all proceedings under Sections 11 and 14
have been taken, the State Government shall
publish a final notification specifying clearly the
boundary marks of the reserved forest and declare
the same to be a reserved forest from the date
fixed by a notification subject to the exercise of
rights if any specified in such a notification. From
the date so fixed, such forest shall be deemed to be
a reserved forest. Before the date fixed in the
notification under Section 18, the same shall be
published in the Official Gazette and at the Taluk
Headquarters in which the forest is situated and in
the neighbourhood as a proclamation is published
under Section 5.
15. On a reading of the aforesaid provisions, it
becomes clear that though no specific date has
been fixed for the issuance of a declaration under
Section 17 of the Act, nevertheless, after the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 220 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
issuance of the preliminary notification, a period of
three months is granted to every person to make a
claim. Also, the provisions of the Land Acquisition
Act, 1894 would have to be read into Section 11 of
the Act in case, a necessity to acquire the land
arises.
16. It is observed that in many provisions of the
Land Acquisition Act, 1894, specified time-frames
have been mandated-from the date of publication
of the preliminary and final notification as well as
for passing of an award. No doubt, an elaborate
procedure has been contemplated between the
issuance of a preliminary notification and the
issuance of a declaration or final notification under
the Act under consideration encompassing the
making of claims with regard to the notified areas
proposed to be declared to be reserved forest and
also settlement of the said claims, but the
provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, are
also contemplated and orders passed under
Sections 11, 12, 14 and 15 are also subject to
appeal. However, there is no specified period
mentioned under the Act within which, the
notification declaring the reserved forest has to be
issued under Section 17 of the Act, once the
preliminary notification has been issued.
17. Before answering the contention raised by the
Petitioners that in the absence of any declaration
under Section 17 of the Act, the lands notified
under Section 4 of the Act cannot become forest
lands and therefore, FC clearance is not required, it
would be necessary to first set at rest, the rival
contentions raised on the basis of the decision of
the Division Bench of this Court in V. Sampangi
Ramaiah's case to which one of us (Mrs. B.V.
Nagarathna, J.) was a member. Briefly stated, the
facts of that case were that the Petitioner therein
was granted quarrying lease in respect of 12.30
acres of land in Sy. No. 601/A1 in Kollegal Taluk.
Notice dated 8-7-2005 was issued to the Petitioner
therein calling upon him to stop all quarrying
operations. The same was assailed in W.P. No.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 221 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
17941 of 2005, which was allowed by this Court by
order dated 16-8-2007 and the impugned notice
was quashed. As preliminary notification dated 3-6-
1991 had been issued under Section 4(1) of the
Act, and the Assistant Commissioner of Kollegal
Station was appointed as Forest Settlement Officer
by the State Government to enquire into the
existence of any rights or claims of persons under
the Act pursuant to Section 4 notification, a
communication dated 18-1-2007 was issued to the
Petitioner therein. In the meeting held on 20-1-
2007 under the Chairmanship of the Forest
Settlement Officer-cum-Assistant Commissioner, it
was decided to exclude 366.63 acres of land and
the balance 617.71 acres was to be constituted as
reserved forest out of a total extent of 984.34 acres
in Sy. No. 601/A1. When the matter stood thus,
another notice dated 17-10-2008 was issued to the
Petitioner therein asking him to stop all quarrying
operations and not to transport the quarried
material till further orders. That notice was assailed
in W.P. No. 13708 of 2008 and by order dated 25-
6-2009, the writ petition was allowed and the
notice was quashed reserving liberty to the Joint
Director, Department of Mines and Geology, Mysore
Zone to hold a detailed enquiry with regard to the
nature of the land and to pass orders in accordance
with law. During the pendency of that writ petition,
the lease period had come to an end and an
application for renewal had been filed by the
Petitioner therein seeking renewal of 10 acres of
land out of 12.30 acres of land granted originally.
By an endorsement dated 8-1-2010, the Petitioner
therein was informed by an endorsement that the
land sought by him for renewal of the lease was
notified as a reserved forest. Assailing that
endorsement a revision petition was filed, which
was dismissed and thereafter, the writ petition was
filed. In the order passed in the writ petition,
paragraphs 19 to 23 are extracted for immediate
reference:
“19. When specific period has been fixed, for
making a claim and also by filing an appeal by any
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 222 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
persons, a corresponding time-frame for the
adjudication of the claims and for issuance of a
declaration ought to have been made. The
absence of any specific time frame for the
issuance of a declaration under Section 17
would imply that such a declaration must be
made within a reasonable time. What is the
reasonable time in the absence of any specific time
frame mentioned in a statutory provision would
vary from Act to Act and depending upon the object
and scope of the Act. In the instant case, having
regard to the object and scope of the Act in
question, we are of the view that a period of
three years would be the reasonable period
within which, a declaration under Section 17
of the Act ought to be made, excluding the
period when steps are taken under the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894, as well as appellate
proceedings, if any. This period obviously would
exclude any stay orders granted by any Court of
Law. But in the instant case, the State is unable to
point out any steps initiated after the order passed
by the Forest Settlement Officer, excluding 366.63
acres, which according to the Petitioner also
includes the area of the subject quarry. This aspect
is communicated to the Petitioner in the year 2007,
whereas in 2004 itself the quarry lease was granted
to the Petitioners.
20. In this context, reliance could be placed on the
fact that originally in the matter of issuance of
preliminary notification and a declaration under the
provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, there
was no time limit fixed for making an award.
Subsequently, in the year 1984, an amendment
was brought in the form of insertion to Section 11-
A of the Land Acquisition Act. In fact, in the case of
Ram Chand v. Union of India, (1994) 1 SCC 44,
which is a decision on a dispute arising prior to the
insertion of Section 4 to the Land Acquisition Act,
the Supreme Court has held that compensation has
to be paid within a reasonable time, even in the
absence of any time limit prescribed under the Act
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 223 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
and the reasonable time was stated to be about two
years in the said case.
21. In the instant case, though the preliminary
notification is issued on 3-6-1991, the final
notification is yet to be issued. In fact, several
adjournments were given in the matter so as to
enable the Respondent-authorities to take a
decision with regard to issuance of a declaration
under Section 17 of the Act, even then, no steps
have been taken to issue such a declaration.
Therefore, we find that the State Government
has by not taking steps for over two decades
after the issuance of the preliminary
notification, abandoned its intention to notify
Sy. No. 601/A1 as a Reserved Forest. This
becomes all the more clear by the fact that
subsequent to the issuance of the preliminary
notification in the year 1991 and quarrying
lease has also been granted to the Petitioner
and possibly to the other similarly placed
persons in the year 2004. Therefore, the
impugned order at Annexure-A is without authority
of law.
22. The preliminary notification dated 3-6-1991 is
also quashed insofar as Sy. No. 601/A1 is
concerned, though in our view, the entire
preliminary notification is inchoate. Annexures-A
and B are also quashed. The Respondent-
Authorities are directed to consider the Petitioner's
application for renewal of the quarrying lease for a
further period of ten years, excluding the period of
lease when the Petitioner was prevented from
carrying on the quarrying activities during the
subsistence of the Quarrying Deed No. 105 since
the year 2004.
23. The writ petition is accordingly, allowed. The
renewal of the lease to be effected within a period
of 30 days from the date of receipt of certified copy
of this order. Parties to bear their respective costs”.
19. Having considered the implication of the
decision in V. Sampangi Ramaiah's case, this case
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 224 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
would have to be decided on its facts. If the
provisions of the Act are applied to the facts
of the case, what emerges is that when a
notification is issued under Section 4
declaring the decision to constitute any land
as Reserved Forest, by virtue of Section 6 of
the Act, no contract can be entered into in
respect of that land on behalf of the
Government with any person except with the
previous sanction of the State Government
and no right can be acquired in or around or
over the land comprised in the notification
except by succession or under the grant or
contract in writing made or entered into by or
on behalf of the Government or some person
in whom such right or power to create such
right, was vested when the notification was
issued. No doubt, under Section 6, the State
can enter into a contract with any person in
respect of the lands notified under Section 4
provided the provisions of that section are
fully complied with. Therefore, in that sense the
Petitioners may be partly right in contending that
despite issuance of notification under Section 4 of
the Act State had the power to grant the mining
leases in favour of the Petitioners. But the matter
does not rest here.
65.116. By relying on Girish H.E. , the Learned
Additional Advocate General submits that the
issuance of a preliminary notification under
Section 4 of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963,
initiates the statutory process for constitution of
a reserved forest, which requires further
proceedings in accordance with the provisions
of the Act, culminating in a final notification
under Section 17. He relies on the observations
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 225 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
in paragraphs 8 and 10 to 17 of the said
judgment, which explain the statutory
procedure governing the notification,
publication of proclamation, submission and
inquiry into claims, settlement of rights and
issuance of the final notification.
65.117. The learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that, upon issuance of a notification
under Section 4, the consequences prescribed
under Section 6 of the Act ensue, including
restrictions on the acquisition of rights over the
notified land, subject to the exceptions provided
therein. He contends that the legal effect of
subsequent grants, contracts or other purported
creation of rights must, therefore, be examined
in the light of Section 6 and the circumstances
in which such rights are claimed to have arisen.
65.118. He also relies on the discussion in Girish H.E .
concerning the decision in V. Sampangi
Ramaiah , particularly the principle that,
although the Act does not prescribe a specific
period for issuance of the final notification
under Section 17, the statutory process must
be completed within a reasonable time. He
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 226 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
submits, however, that the question of
reasonable time and the legal consequences of
delay must be determined having regard to the
facts and circumstances of the present case,
including the steps taken by the authorities, the
nature of the land and the rights claimed by the
Petitioners.
65.119. Relying further on paragraph 19 of Girish H.E . ,
the learned Additional Advocate General
submits that the effect of a preliminary
notification under Section 4, and the validity of
any subsequent grant or contract relating to the
notified land, must be assessed by applying the
relevant provisions of the Act to the facts of the
case. He contends that the Petitioners cannot
rely merely on the existence of subsequent
grants or other transactions to defeat the
statutory consequences of the notification,
without establishing that the rights asserted by
them were lawfully created and are legally
enforceable.
65.120. He relies on B.R. Ganapathi Singh v. State of
Karnataka [2020 SCC OnLine Kar 3074] more
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 227 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
particularly Paras 46 and 64 thereof, which are
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
46. Further, in the aforesaid context, we do not think
that there can be any distinction with regard to a piece of
land which has been decided to be constituted as
reserved forest under S. 4(1) of the Act and land being
deemed to be reserved forest under S. 17 of the Act
which is like a final notification. The reason being, once
the land is constituted as reserved forest under S. 4(1) of
the Act, it is by issuance of a Notification then the claims
would have to be made and it is only on the
consideration of the claims that an application for
exclusion of the land constituted as reserved forest under
S. 4(1) of the Act could be ordered. Merely because the
procedure contemplated under the Act subsequent to the
issuance of a Notification under S. 4 of the Act is not yet
completed or no Notification has been issued under S.
17(1) of the Act, in our view, would not make any
difference, as the object and purpose of reserving any
land is to treat the said land as being constituted a
reserved forest. If such a land or any portion thereof is
excluded on adjudication of claims, it would not find a
place in Notification issued under S. 17 of the Act. In
such a case, it would no longer be constituted as
reserved forest. But, till that procedure is not
completed by the Forest Settlement Officer, it
remains to be constituted as reserved forest.
64. Having regard to the definition of forest enunciated
by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, it must be held that all
statutorily recognized forest, whether designated as
reserved forest, protected or otherwise, must be held to
come within the scope of the expression “Forest”. In the
instant case, the land in question was decided to be
constituted as reserved forest under S. 4 of the Act.
Merely because a final declaration under S. 17 of
the Act has not been issued in the instant case, it
cannot be held that subject land is not forest land.
As already noted, when once the land is decided to
be constituted as reserved forest under S. 4 of the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 228 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Act, it continues to be forest land until the
procedure contemplated for exclusion of any
portion of the said land from being declared as
reserved forest is completed by adjudication of the
claims. If no claim is made in respect of the land
constituted as reserved forest under S. 4 of the Act, it
fructifies as reserved forest. The object of issuance of
Notification under S. 17 of the Act is to restate the
boundaries of the reserved forest after excluding the
lands constituted as reserved forest on adjudication of
the claims under the Act. Thus, if there are no claims
which are adjudicated, then the land intended to be
constituted as reserved forest is declared as reserved
forest.
65.121. By relying on B. R. Ganapathi , the learned
Additional Advocate General submits that the
issuance of a notification under Section 4 of the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, declaring the
intention to constitute an area as a reserved
forest, has legal consequences even before the
issuance of the final notification under Section
17. He contends that the mere absence of a
final notification does not, by itself, establish
that the notified land has ceased to be forest
land, as the statutory process initiated by the
preliminary notification remains to be
completed through the ascertainment and
adjudication of claims by the Forest Settlement
Officer. He submits that, until the statutory
process is completed and any exclusion is
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 229 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
effected in accordance with law, the absence of
a final notification cannot be relied upon, by
itself, to defeat the State’s claim to protect the
notified area.
65.122. The learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that, as explained in B.R. Ganapathi
Singh , the final notification under Section 17
serves to declare the boundaries of the
reserved forest after taking into consideration
the claims adjudicated during the settlement
proceedings. He contends that, where no claims
are made or where the adjudication of claims
does not result in the exclusion of any portion
of the notified area, the absence of a final
notification cannot, by itself, lead to the
conclusion that the land is not forest land. On
this basis, he opposes the Petitioners’
contention that the non-issuance of a final
notification under Section 17 necessarily
deprives the State of the authority to protect
the subject lands.
65.123. Applying the aforesaid reasoning to the facts of
the present case, the learned Additional
Advocate General submits that the preliminary
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 230 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
notification dated 05.02.1920, issued under
Section 4 of the Mysore Forest Regulation,
1900, must be considered in the light of its
terms and legal effect. He contends that the
absence of a final notification should not, by
itself, be treated as extinguishing the legal
consequences of the preliminary notification or
as conferring an unrestricted right upon private
parties to occupy, develop or commercially
exploit the notified lands. He accordingly
submits that the Petitioners’ claims must be
examined with reference to the notification
history, the statutory process for settlement of
rights and the applicable provisions governing
the protection of forest lands.
65.124. The learned Additional Advocate General further
relies upon paragraph 64 of B.R. Ganapathi
Singh to submit that statutorily recognised
forests fall within the expression “forest”,
irrespective of whether they are classified as
reserved forests, protected forests or
otherwise. He contends that the character of
the subject lands cannot be determined merely
by reference to the presence or absence of
dense tree cover or to subsequent descriptions
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 231 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
in revenue records. According to him, the
absence of a final notification under Section 17
cannot, in itself, conclusively establish that the
subject lands fall outside the scope of forest
protection.
65.125. He therefore submits that the preliminary
notification dated 05.02.1920, the subsequent
proceedings, the claims made before the Forest
Settlement Officer and the effect of the
applicable repealing and saving provisions must
be considered together. On these grounds, he
opposes the writ petitions and seeks rejection
of the Petitioners’ contention that the subject
lands are not forest lands merely because a
final notification under Section 17 was not
issued.
65.126. The learned Additional Advocate General,
appearing on behalf of the State and opposing
the writ petitions, relies upon the Circular dated
20.08.2004 issued by the Ministry of
Environment and Forests, referring to the order
dated 13.11.2000 passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Centre for Environmental
Law, WWF-India v. Union of India [2000
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 232 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
SCC OnLine SC 119]. He submits that the said
order emphasises that no dereservation of
forests, sanctuaries or national parks shall be
undertaken without following the prescribed
procedure.
65.127. The learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the Ministry of Environment and
Forests has clarified that a proposal for deletion
of an area covered by a notification under
Section 4 of the applicable forest legislation can
be processed by the Central Government only
after the concerned State Government or Union
Territory administration obtains the requisite
permission of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. He
contends that, in view of the aforesaid
directions and the procedure followed pursuant
thereto, several States and Union Territories
have approached the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
relation to proposals for deletion of such areas,
which have been referred for consideration by
the Central Empowered Committee (CEC). He
submits that the procedure prescribed for
seeking such deletion must be followed in the
present case as well, and that the Petitioners
cannot circumvent the prescribed process by
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 233 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
seeking to occupy or assert rights over the
subject lands without establishing their
entitlement in accordance with law.
65.128. The learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the revenue records relating to the
subject lands disclose their forest character and
that such entries put the Petitioners on notice
of the Forest Department’s claim. He contends
that the Petitioners, having purchased the lands
despite the entries in the revenue records and
the subsisting claim of the Forest Department,
cannot claim equities merely on the basis of
such purchases or the investments made
thereafter. He accordingly submits that the
Petitioners cannot seek protection of their
alleged rights on equitable considerations while
disregarding the statutory framework and the
procedure applicable to the deletion or
dereservation of forest land.
65.129. He relies on Narinder Singh v. Divesh
Bhutani [2022 SCC OnLine SC 899], more
particularly para 49 thereof, which is
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 234 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
49. Most of the well-known dictionaries are more or less
consistent when it comes to the meaning of the word
“forest”. The erstwhile Nagpur High Court in Laxman
Ichharam v. Divl. Forest Officer made an attempt to
define “forests” by referring to dictionary meaning of the
word “forest” in the Oxford English Dictionary. Para 13 of
the said decision reads thus : (SCC OnLine MP)
“13. The term “forest” has not been defined anywhere in
the Forest Act. In the absence of such a definition
the word “forest” must be taken in its ordinary
dictionary sense. The Shorter Oxford English
Dictionary, Vol. I, gives the following meaning to it:
‘1. An extensive tract of land covered with trees and
undergrowth, sometimes intermingled with pasture….
2. Law. A woodland district, usually belonging to the
king, set apart for hunting wild beasts and game, etc.….
3. A wild uncultivated waste.’ ”
65.130. By relying on Narinder Singh , the learned
Additional Advocate General submits that, in
the absence of an exhaustive statutory
definition of the expression “forest”, the
expression must be understood in its ordinary
dictionary sense, having regard to the context
in which it is used. He relies upon the meaning
of the expression referred to in Narinder
Singh , which includes an extensive tract of
land covered with trees and undergrowth,
sometimes intermingled with pasture, a
woodland district, and a wild, uncultivated tract
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 235 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
of land. He contends that the character of a
forest cannot be determined solely by
examining whether the land is densely covered
with trees, as the expression is capable of
encompassing land comprising both tree-
covered areas and interspersed pasture or
grassland.
65.131. Applying the aforesaid principle to the present
case, the learned Additional Advocate General
submits that the shola forests and grasslands of
Moorkangudda must be considered as part of
the larger ecological landscape and that the
presence of open grasslands or the absence of
dense tree cover in certain portions does not,
by itself, exclude such lands from being treated
as forest. He further contends that the nature
and character of the subject lands must be
assessed in the light of the relevant forest
records, the notification dated 05.02.1920 and
the ecological characteristics of the area, rather
than merely by reference to the present
physical appearance of individual parcels.
65.132. The learned Additional Advocate General
accordingly submits that the Petitioners cannot
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 236 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
contend that the subject lands fall outside the
scope of forest protection merely because some
portions comprise grasslands or are not covered
by dense tree growth. He urges that the
expression “forest” be construed in its proper
statutory and factual context and that the
Petitioners’ challenge be rejected insofar as it
rests solely upon the absence of dense tree
cover.
65.133. He relies on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of UOI v. Kirloskar
Pneumatic Co. Ltd. , [(1996) 4 SCC 453],
particularly paragraph 10, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
10. According to these sub-sections, a claim for
refund or an order of refund can be made only in
accordance with the provisions of Section 27 which
inter alia includes the period of limitation mentioned
therein. Mr Hidayatullah submitted that the period
of limitation prescribed by Section 27 does not apply
either to a suit filed by the importer or to a writ
petition filed by him and that in such cases the
period of limitation would be three years. The
learned counsel refers to certain decisions of this
Court to that effect. We shall assume for the
purposes of this appeal that it is so, notwithstanding
the fact that the said question is now pending
before a larger Constitution Bench of nine Judges
along with the issue relating to unjust enrichment.
Yet the question is whether it is permissible for the
High Court to direct the authorities under the Act to
act contrary to the aforesaid statutory provision. We
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 237 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
do not think it is, even while acting under Article
226 of the Constitution. The power conferred by
Articles 226/227 is designed to effectuate the
law, to enforce the rule of law and to ensure
that the several authorities and organs of the
State act in accordance with law. It cannot be
invoked for directing the authorities to act
contrary to law. In particular, the Customs
authorities, who are the creatures of the Customs
Act, cannot be directed to ignore or act contrary to
Section 27, whether before or after amendment.
Maybe the High Court or a civil court is not bound
by the said provisions but the authorities under the
Act are. Nor can there be any question of the High
Court clothing the authorities with its power under
Article 226 or the power of a civil court. No such
delegation or conferment can ever be conceived. We
are, therefore, of the opinion that the direction
contained in clause (3) of the impugned order is
unsustainable in law. When we expressed this view
during the hearing Mr Hidayatullah requested that in
such a case the matter be remitted to the High
Court and the High Court be left free to dispose of
the writ petition according to law.
65.134. By relying on Kirloskar Pneumatic , the
Learned Additional Advocate General submits
that Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the
jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India is intended to effectuate
the law, enforce the rule of law and ensure that
State authorities act in accordance with law.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court further observed
that such jurisdiction cannot be invoked to
direct statutory authorities to act contrary to
the provisions of the governing enactment.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 238 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.135. The learned Additional Advocate General
submits that the jurisdiction of this Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot
be exercised to compel statutory authorities to
act contrary to the applicable law or to
disregard the statutory restrictions governing
their powers. He contends that, where the
Forest Department authorities are acting in
discharge of their statutory duties under the
applicable forest legislation, this Court ought
not to issue directions that would require them
to act in derogation of the governing statutory
provisions. He further submits that the
Petitioners cannot seek relief that would have
the effect of restraining the competent
authorities from enforcing the law, merely by
relying upon revenue entries, grants or other
transactions, without establishing that the
rights asserted by them are legally sustainable
under the applicable law.
65.136. He relies on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Jit Ram Shiv Kumar v.
State of Haryana [(1981) 1 SCC 11]
[Paragraph 51], which is reproduced hereunder
for ease of reference:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 239 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
51. On a consideration of the decisions of this Court
it is clear that there can be no promissory estoppel
against the exercise of legislative power of the
State. So also, the doctrine cannot be invoked for
preventing the Government from acting in
discharge of its duty under the law. The
Government would not be bound by the act of its
officers and agents who act beyond the scope of
their authority and a person dealing with the agent
of the Government must be held to have notice of
the limitations of his authority. the Court can enforce
compliance by a public authority of the obligation laid on
him if he arbitrarily or on his mere whim ignores the
promises made by him on behalf of the Government. It
would be open to the authority to plead and prove that
there were special considerations which necessitated his
not being able to comply with his obligations in public
interest.
65.137. By relying on Jit Ram Shiv Kumar , the
learned Additional Advocate General submits
that the doctrine of promissory estoppel cannot
be invoked to prevent the State from exercising
its legislative powers or discharging its
statutory duties. He contends that the State
cannot be bound by acts or assurances given by
its officers or agents beyond the scope of their
authority and that persons dealing with such
officers are required to take note of the
limitations on their authority. He further
submits that an obligation allegedly arising
from a representation made on behalf of the
Government cannot be enforced where doing so
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 240 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
would prevent the competent authority from
acting in accordance with law.
65.138. Applying the aforesaid principle to the present
case, the learned Additional Advocate General
contends that any grants, permissions, revenue
entries or other acts of the Revenue
Department relied upon by the Petitioners
cannot, by themselves, preclude the Forest
Department or the State from discharging its
statutory obligations to protect forest lands, if
such acts were contrary to the applicable law or
were undertaken by authorities lacking the
requisite competence. He submits that the
Petitioners cannot claim an enforceable
equitable right merely on the basis of acts or
representations of public authorities, without
establishing that those authorities were legally
competent to grant the rights asserted.
65.139. The learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the doctrine of promissory
estoppel cannot be employed to compel the
State to perpetuate an illegality or to refrain
from taking action required by law in the public
interest. He therefore contends that the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 241 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Petitioners cannot resist the proceedings
initiated by the Forest Department solely on the
ground that they or their predecessors acquired
the lands, obtained revenue entries or made
investments in reliance upon acts of the
Government, particularly if the underlying
transactions are shown to be inconsistent with
the governing forest legislation. On this basis,
he seeks rejection of the Petitioners’ claims
founded upon promissory estoppel or equitable
considerations.
65.140. He relies on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of Manish Goel v. Rohini
Goel [(2010) 4 SCC 393], Paragraph 14, which
is reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
14. Generally, no court has competence to issue a
direction contrary to law nor can the court direct an
authority to act in contravention of the statutory
provisions. The courts are meant to enforce the rule of
law and not to pass the orders or directions which are
contrary to what has been injected by law. (Vide State of
Punjab v. Renuka Singla, State of U.P. v. Harish Chandra
, Union of India v. Kirloskar Pneumatic Co. Ltd.,
University of Allahabad v. Dr. Anand Prakash Mishra and
Karnataka SRTC v. Ashrafulla Khan)
65.141. By relying on Manish Goel , the learned
Additional Advocate General submits that a
Court cannot issue directions contrary to law or
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 242 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
compel a statutory authority to act in
contravention of the governing statutory
provisions. He contends that the jurisdiction of
a constitutional Court must be exercised to
uphold the rule of law and cannot be invoked to
secure an outcome that is impermissible under
the applicable legislation.
65.142. Applying the aforesaid principle to the present
case, the learned Additional Advocate General
submits that the Petitioners cannot seek
directions from this Court that would prevent
the competent authorities from discharging
their statutory obligations under the applicable
forest laws. He contends that, if the subject
lands are governed by the relevant forest
legislation and the proceedings initiated by the
Forest Department are otherwise in accordance
with law, the Petitioners cannot obtain relief
that would effectively require the authorities to
disregard the statutory framework or permit
acts prohibited thereunder.
65.143. He further submits that any grants,
permissions, revenue entries or other dealings
relied upon by the Petitioners cannot, merely by
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 243 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
their existence, entitle them to relief contrary to
the governing law. According to him, the
legality and effect of such instruments must be
determined in accordance with the applicable
statutory provisions, and the Court cannot
direct the State or its authorities to recognise
or perpetuate rights that are legally
unsustainable. On this basis, the learned
Additional Advocate General opposes the reliefs
sought in the writ petitions and submits that
the petitions cannot be allowed to the extent
that the reliefs claimed would require the
authorities to act contrary to law.
65.144. He relies on the judgment of the Hon’ble High
Court of Kerala in the case of CIT v. Punalur
Paper Mills , [(1988) 170 ITR 37], Paragraphs
5 and 6 which are reproduced hereunder for
ease of reference:
5. We see no force in this plea. The Board of
Revenue is competent to issue circulars under
section 119 of the Income-tax Act. The circulars
so issued have got the force of law. All officers
of the Department are bound by the said
circulars. The benevolent circulars issued by the
Board are in the nature of administrative relief.
They really “supplant” the law. The circular can
afford administrative relief even beyond the relevant
terms of the statute. It can deviate from the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 244 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
provisions of the Act. The courts have held that
such circulars are binding on the officers of the
Department. It is not open to the Department to
contend, even in cases where the circular goes
beyond the terms of the section, that the circular
has no legal effect or should not be given effect to.
The circulars would go to the assistance of the
assessees. It is settled law that the circulars cannot
impose any burden on the taxpayer. But, by the
issue of a circular, the rigour of the law can be
relaxed by giving administrative relief. Apart from
the fact that such circulars are binding on the
officers of the Department, even if the circulars are
relied on for the first time in the High Court during
the course of hearing, the assessee will be entitled
to the benefit afforded by the circular. The court is
bound to take note of the circular. These
propositions are well settled by a series of decisions
of the Supreme Court as well as of High Courts
(Vide Navnit Lal C. Javeri v. K.K. Sen, AAC [1965]
56 ITR 198 at p. 203 (SC), Ellerman Lines Ltd. v.
CIT [1971] 82 ITR 913 (SC), Tala Iron & Steel Co.
Ltd. v. N.C. Upadhyaya [1974] 96 ITR 1 (Bom), F.C.
Agarwal v. CIT [1976] 102 ITR 408 (Gauhati),
Navnitlal Ambalal v. CIT [1976] 105 ITR 735 (Bom),
CWT v. Gammon India P. Ltd. [1981] 130 ITR 471
(Bom) and Addl. CIT v. Mrs. Avtar Mohan Singh
[1982] 136 ITR 645 (Delhi)). This court has also
taken the same view in a series of decisions. They
are: Rajarajeswari Weaving Mills v. ITO [1978] 113
ITR 405, CIT v. B. Al. Edward, India Sea Foods
[1979] 119 ITR 334 [FB] and CIT v. T.S.
Venkiteswaran [1979] 120 ITR 675. It is too late in
the day for the Revenue to contend that the circular
issued by the Board of Revenue is only an
administrative direction or that it will not bind the
Department or that it shall not be given effect to,
since it goes beyond or deviates from the terms of
the statute. As stated, the circular “supplants “ the
law and not “ supplements “ the law.
6. In the light of the above position in law, we are
satisfied that the Appellate Tribunal was justified in
giving effect to the Circular dated
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 245 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
65.145. By relying on Punalur Paper Mills the Learned
Additional Advocate General submits that
administrative circulars issued by a competent
statutory authority, within the scope of its
powers, have binding effect upon the officers of
the concerned Department. He further contends
that, in the present case, the relevant circulars
and administrative instructions relied upon by
the State must be considered in the context of
their legal authority and applicability to the
forest lands in question.
65.146. He relies on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the case of RBI v. Peerless [(1987) 1
SCC 424], Paragraph 33, which is reproduced
hereunder for ease of reference:
33. Interpretation must depend on the text and the
context. They are the bases of interpretation. One may
well say if the text is the texture, context is what gives
the colour. Neither can be ignored. Both are important.
That interpretation is best which makes the textual
interpretation match the contextual. A statute is best
interpreted when we know why it was enacted. With this
knowledge, the statute must be read, first as a whole and
then section by section, clause by clause, phrase by
phrase and word by word. If a statute is looked at, in the
context of its enactment, with the glasses of the statute-
maker, provided by such context, its scheme, the
sections, clauses, phrases and words may take colour
and appear different than when the statute is looked at
without the glasses provided by the context. With these
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 246 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
glasses we must look at the Act as a whole and discover
what each section, each clause, each phrase and each
word is meant and designed to say as to fit into the
scheme of the entire Act. No part of a statute and no
word of a statute can be construed in isolation.
Statutes have to be construed so that every word has a
place and everything is in its place. It is by looking at the
definition as a whole in the setting of the entire Act and
by reference to what preceded the enactment and the
reasonsfor it that the Court construed the expression
“Prize Chit” in Srinivasa [(1980) 4 SCC 507 : (1981) 1
SCR 801 : 51 Com Cas 464] and we find no reason to
depart from the Court’s construction.
65.147. By relying on Peerless , the learned Additional
Advocate General submits that the provisions of
the applicable forest legislation must be
interpreted having regard to the text, context,
object and scheme of the enactment as a
whole. He contends that the relevant provisions
cannot be read in isolation or construed solely
on the basis of the meaning attributed to an
individual expression, without considering their
relationship with the other provisions and the
legislative purpose. Accordingly, the legal effect
of the notification dated 05.02.1920 and the
subsequent Government Order dated
11.01.1924 must, according to him, be
determined by examining the relevant
instruments in their proper statutory and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 247 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
historical context and in the light of the scheme
of the applicable forest legislation.
65.148. On the basis of all the above arguments and
contentions, learned Additional Advocate
General submits that the petition is required to
be dismissed.
66. Heard Sri.Manmohan P.N., learned counsel for the
Petitioner/s in WP No.16251/2023, WP
No.29656/2024, WP No.33767/2025 in WP
No.700/2026 and WP No.19980/2023, Sri.A.M.Vijay,
learned counsel for the Petitioner/s in WP
No.29690/2025, and Sri.Kiran Ron, learned
Additional Advocate General for the Respondents and
perused papers.
67. The points that would arise for consideration are as
under:
(i) Whether the notification dated
05.02.1920, bearing No. R.8806-Ft.43-15-
6, issued under Section 4 of the Mysore
Forest Regulation, 1900, continues to
remain operative, and whether the
Government Order dated 11.01.1924 had
the effect of withdrawing or cancelling the
said notification or related to a distinct
notification and a limited extent of land?
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 248 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
(ii) What is the legal effect of the absence of a
final notification under Section 17 of the
Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, and
whether the absence of such notification
precludes the State from asserting the
forest status of the notified lands or taking
action under the applicable forest
legislation?
(iii) Whether the repeal of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, by the Karnataka Forest
Act, 1963, affects the validity or continued
operation of the notification dated
05.02.1920 and the proceedings initiated
pursuant thereto, having regard to the
applicable repeal-and-savings provisions?
(iv) Whether the prolonged lapse of time
between the preliminary notification and
the subsequent proceedings renders the
proceedings legally unsustainable on the
grounds of unreasonable delay,
abandonment of the proposal to constitute
the lands as reserved forest, or creation of
third-party rights in the intervening
period?
(v) Whether the grants, saguvali chits,
registered instruments, revenue entries,
conversion orders, licences and other
permissions relied upon by the Petitioners
confer legally enforceable rights over the
lands in question, having regard to the
applicable forest legislation and the
competence of the authorities who issued
them?
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 249 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
(vi) Whether the Petitioners have established
that their respective properties fall within
the boundaries of the land covered by the
notification dated 05.02.1920, having
regard to the survey particulars, extent,
boundaries and other relevant records?
(vii) Whether the Petitioners are entitled to
invoke the jurisdiction of this Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India
notwithstanding the availability of
alternative statutory remedies, having
regard to the nature of the impugned
action and the grounds urged in the
respective writ petitions?
(viii) Proceedings under Section 64A: In the
writ petitions challenging proceedings
under Section 64A of the Karnataka Forest
Act, 1963, whether the provision was
legally applicable to the respective petition
schedule properties; whether the
proceedings were initiated by competent
authorities; and whether the prescribed
procedure, including the requirement of a
reasonable opportunity of hearing, was
complied with?
(ix) Proceedings before the Forest Settlement
Officer: In the writ petitions challenging
proceedings before the Forest Settlement
Officer, whether the appointment of the
Officer, publication of the proclamation,
service of notices, inquiry into claims and
objections, and determination of rights
were in accordance with the applicable
statutory provisions?
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 250 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
(x) Orders under Section 14 and remedy under
Section 16: In the writ petitions
challenging orders passed by the Forest
Settlement Officer under Section 14 of the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, whether the
Petitioners have an effective statutory
appeal under Section 16 before the
Karnataka Appellate Tribunal and, if so,
whether the circumstances of the
respective cases nevertheless warrant
interference under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India?
(xi) Proceedings of the Regional
Commissioner: In the writ petitions relying
upon the proceedings dated 08.09.2022 of
the Regional Commissioner, Mysuru
Division, whether those proceedings
possess any binding legal effect upon the
State Government or the Forest
Department and whether they affect the
validity or continuation of the forest
proceedings?
(xii) Individual rights and relief: Whether, in
the facts and circumstances of each writ
petition, the Petitioners have established a
legally enforceable right warranting the
relief sought, including any challenge to
eviction, sealing of premises, seizure of
articles or other consequential action?
(xiii) What order?
68. This court answers the above points as follows:
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 251 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
69. Answer to Point No. (i): Whether the
notification dated 05.02.1920, bearing No.
R.8806-Ft.43-15-6, issued under Section 4 of
the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, continues
to remain operative, and whether the
Government Order dated 11.01.1924 had the
effect of withdrawing or cancelling the said
notification or related to a distinct notification
and a limited extent of land?
69.1. Learned counsel for the Petitioners submits that
the proposal to constitute the Moorkangudda
Block as a State Forest, notified on 05.02.1920,
was dropped by the Government of Mysore by
its order dated 11.01.1924. The notification,
therefore, ceased to operate from that date,
and the Forest Department cannot claim
jurisdiction over the Petitioners’ lands on its
basis. He further submits that rights in favour
of the Petitioners were created after the 1920
notification and after the Government’s decision
in 1924; that proceedings founded on the 1920
notification are non est in law; and that, if the
State intends to constitute the lands a reserved
forest, it must initiate fresh proceedings under
the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963. He also relies
on the report dated 11.10.2022 of the Assistant
Commissioner, Sakleshpur Sub-Division, and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 252 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the proceedings of the coordination meetings
held under the Regional Commissioner.
69.2. Sri A.M. Vijay submits that a notification once
withdrawn or rendered inoperative cannot be
revived in the absence of statutory authority.
Neither the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, nor
the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, provides for
such revival, particularly after nearly a century
during which the area has become inhabited
and developed. He also relies on the grant of
lands by the State in Kadumane Village from
1952 onwards as conduct consistent with the
Government’s decision of 1924.
69.3. On this basis, the Petitioners in W.P. Nos.
16251/2023, 19980/2023 and 33767/2025
seek a declaration that the 1920 notification
has lapsed or been abandoned. The Petitioner
in W.P. No. 29690/2025 seeks, pursuant to the
amendment allowed on 24.11.2025, a
declaration that the notification is not binding
on its land.
69.4. The learned Additional Advocate General
submits that the Petitioners’ lands fall within
the Moorkangudda Block, stated to comprise
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 253 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
7,938 acres 38 guntas, and that the notification
dated 05.02.1920 continues to form the basis
of the Forest Department’s claim. He denies
that the notification was cancelled or
withdrawn. According to him, the Government
Order dated 11.01.1924 concerned a separate
notification dated 05.02.1920, bearing No.
R.8808-Ft.43-15-7, issued under the Land
Acquisition Regulation, 1894. It withdrew
acquisition only in respect of 68 acres 33
guntas and did not affect the notification issued
under Section 4 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900. He submits that, when the
1920 notification was issued, all lands within
the notified extent, except 68 acres 33 guntas,
were already at the disposal of the State
Government, and only that extent required
acquisition. Unless the Section 4 notification
was itself withdrawn or rendered inoperative in
accordance with law, he submits, it continues to
have effect.
69.5. The learned Additional Advocate General further
submits that the Petitioners have taken
inconsistent positions. According to him, they
initially pleaded that the notification had been
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 254 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
cancelled and sought to challenge it only after
that assertion was disputed; the prayers
subsequently introduced by amendment are,
therefore, inconsistent with the original prayers.
He submits that the Revenue Department
auctioned land in Achanahalli Village on
20.09.1924 only because the revenue records
had not been updated to reflect the Forest
Department’s claim, and that such omission
does not invalidate the notification. He relies on
RBI v. Peerless [(1987) 1 SCC 424],
paragraph 33, to contend that the 1920
notification and the Government Order dated
11.01.1924 must be construed in their
statutory and historical context.
69.6. The issue turns on the Government records and
the legal effect of the orders recorded therein.
Both sides accept that the notification dated
05.02.1920 was published, that the
Government passed an order on 11.01.1924,
and that a notification of that date was
published in the Gazette. The dispute concerns
the decision taken by the Government in 1924.
That question must be answered from the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 255 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
contemporaneous documents relied upon by the
parties.
69.7. The relevant provisions of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, are Sections 4 and 17.
Section 4 provides:
4. Whenever it is proposed to constitute any
land a State Forest, the Government shall
publish a notification in the official Gazette—
(a) specifying as nearly as possible the situation and
limits of such land; (b) declaring that it is proposed
to constitute such land a State Forest; and (c)
appointing an officer (hereinafter called ‘the Forest
Settlement Officer’) to inquire into and determine
the existence, nature and extent of any rights
claimed by, or alleged to exist in favour of any
person in or over any land comprised within such
limits, or to any forest produce of such land, and to
deal with the same as provided in this chapter.
69.8. Section 4 provides for publication of a proposal
to constitute land a State Forest and for inquiry
into the rights claimed in respect of that land.
The notification issued under that provision
does not, by itself, constitute the land a State
Forest. That status is conferred by the
notification contemplated under Section 17.
After the claims and appeals have been
disposed of, the proceedings required by the
Regulation have been completed and the lands
to be acquired have vested in the Government,
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 256 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Section 17 provides for publication of a
notification specifying the limits of the forest
and declaring it to be a State Forest from a
date fixed therein. Under Section 17(2), the
forest is deemed to be a State Forest from that
date.
69.9. The Government is not bound to complete the
process merely because it has issued a
notification under Section 4. It may decide not
to proceed with the proposal. The notification
under Section 4 initiates the statutory process;
it does not compel the Government to carry
that process to its conclusion.
69.10. The notification No. R.8806-Ft.43-15-6, dated
05.02.1920, published on 12.02.1920, declares
that it is proposed to constitute the lands
described in its Schedule as a State Forest. The
Schedule identifies the Moorkangudda Block in
Manjarabad Taluk, comprising Achanahalli,
Agini, Kyamanahalli, Nadahalli, Kadumane,
Jambardi, Manjanahalli Estate and Kadumane
Estate, with an extent of about 7,938 acres 38
guntas. It also appoints the Forest Settlement
Officer and the appellate authority.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 257 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
69.11. The separate notification dated 05.02.1920,
bearing No. R.8808-Ft.43-15-7, was issued
under Section 6 of the Mysore Land Acquisition
Regulation, VII of 1894, in respect of private
holdings aggregating 68 acres and 33 guntas,
required for the reservation of the
Moorkangudda Forest Block. It was published in
the Mysore Gazette dated 12.02.1920. It was
distinct from the preliminary notification dated
05.02.1920, bearing No. R.8806-Ft.43-15-6,
issued under Section 4 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, XI of 1900. The former initiated
acquisition of the specified private holdings; it
did not itself propose to constitute the entire
Moorkangudda Block as a State Forest.
69.12. The file of the General and Revenue Secretariat,
File No. 296 of 1922, certified copies of which
are on record, discloses the subsequent course
of events. By letter No. 712, received on
29.04.1923, the Conservator of Forests wrote:
“Adverting to G.O. No.R.8803-5/Ft.43-15-5
dated the 5th February 1920, sanctioning the
reservation of the Moorkangudda Forest Block
in the Manjerabad Taluk and the issue of the
notification under Section 4 of the Forest
Regulation, I have the honour to state that
during my recent tour in the Hassan District, I
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 258 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
had an occasion to inspect the area in
compliance with the protest petitions received
by me. The area proposed for reservation
comprises of treeless, grassy plains, without
any vegetation whatever. As it is not worth
while conserving the block to the detriment of
the villagers concerned, I am of opinion that
further proceedings in the matter may be
dropped and the notification issued under
Section 4 of the Forest Regulation treated as
cancelled.”
69.13. The Secretariat thereafter sought information
as to whether any land had been acquired and
compensation paid, whether the area had been
demarcated, and whether the Forest Settlement
Officer had taken any action. The District Forest
Officer, Hassan, reported that twelve miles of
preliminary demarcation line had been cut and
that “no compensation was paid as no lands
were acquired”. The Secretariat then recorded
that “the reservation should be cancelled”.
69.14. By a further letter No.595 dated 17.12.1923,
the Conservator forwarded the settlement
records and reiterated that the area comprised
treeless grassy plains and that the proposal
could be dropped.
69.15. The Government took its decision on
11.01.1924. The cover sheet of the Secretariat
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 259 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
file bears the subject “Cancelling the
reservation of the Murkangudda State Forest in
the Hassan District”. The direction was
addressed to the Conservator of Forests, the
Revenue Commissioner and the Deputy
Commissioner of Hassan, and stated that “the
proposal to constitute the area into a State
Forest may be dropped”.
69.16. The Proceedings in File No. 296-22 (Serial No.
6) list two matters. The first is:
“Govt. Notfn. No. R8806-Ft.43-15-6 dt.
05.02.1920 declaring the proposal to
constitute certain lands in the Manjarabad
Taluk into a State Forest under the name the
Moorkangudda Block”.
69.17. The second, Notification No. R.8808-Ft.43-15-7
dated 05.02.1920, issued under the Mysore
Land Acquisition Regulation in respect of private
lands required for the constitution of the Block,
is the order authorising acquisition of lands for
that purpose. After setting out the
Conservator’s letters, the Proceedings record
the following order:
“Order — IC 4236.8. Govt. agree with the
Conservator and direct that the proposal to
constitute the area into a State Forest be
dropped. 2. A notification will be published in
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 260 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the gazette withdrawing from the acquisition
of the properties referred to above.”
69.18. The digest of Government orders for the second
week of January 1924 records the decision as
item 271, I.C. 4236.8-Ft.296-22-6, dated
11.01.1924 under the heading “Moorkangudda
Forest Block”:
“Directs that the proposal to constitute certain
lands in the Manjarabad Taluk into a State
Forest under the name of — be dropped”.
69.19. Item 272 records the consequential order
withdrawing, under Section 48(1) of the Land
Acquisition Regulation, the properties declared
for acquisition under Notification No. R.8808-
Ft.43-15-7. That order was published in the
Mysore Gazette dated 17.01.1924 as
Notification No. I.C. 4239-Ft.296-22-7 dated
11.01.1924. It reads:
“Under Section 48 (1) of the Mysore Land
Acquisition Regulation, VII of 1894, the
Government of His Highness the Maharaja of
Mysore are pleased to withdraw from the
acquisition of the properties declared for
acquisition in their Notification No. R. 8808—
Ft. 43-15-7, dated 5th February 1920, as
required for the constitution of the
Moorkangudda State Forest in the Hassan
District.”
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 261 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
69.20. The typed copy of the Government proceedings
recording Entry 272 refers to the Mysore Land
Acquisition Regulation, VII of 1891. However,
the separate acquisition notification No.
R.8808-Ft.43-15-7 dated 05.02.1920 identifies
the applicable Regulation as VII of 1894. The
Gazette notification dated 11.01.1924,
published on 17.01.1924 to withdraw that
acquisition, also refers to the Mysore Land
Acquisition Regulation, VII of 1894. The
discrepancy in the reference to the Regulation
in the typed copy of Entry 272 is noted. The
statutory references in the two Gazette
notifications are reproduced as they appear in
those documents.
69.21. For clarity, the records disclose two distinct
notifications dated 05.02.1920 and two
separate Government actions dated
11.01.1924. Notification No. R.8806-Ft.43-15-6
was the preliminary notification issued under
Section 4 of the Mysore Forest Regulation, XI of
1900, proposing to constitute the
Moorkangudda Block, measuring approximately
7,938 acres and 38 guntas, as a State Forest.
Notification No. R.8808-Ft.43-15-7 was a
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 262 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
separate notification issued under Section 6 of
the Mysore Land Acquisition Regulation, VII of
1894, for acquisition of 68 acres and 33 guntas
of private lands required for that purpose. On
11.01.1924, Entry 271, bearing No. I.C.
4236.8-Ft.296-22-6, recorded the
Government's decision to drop the proposal to
constitute the Moorkangudda Block as a State
Forest. Entry 272, bearing No. I.C. 4239-
Ft.296-22-7, recorded the consequential
withdrawal, under Section 48(1) of the Land
Acquisition Regulation of the acquisition of the
68 acres and 33 guntas. The latter notification
was published in the Mysore Gazette dated
17.01.1924. Thus, Entry 271 concerns the
Section 4 proposal for the entire Moorkangudda
Block, whereas Entry 272 concerns only the
separate acquisition proceedings relating to 68
acres and 33 guntas.
69.22. These documents resolve the first part of the
dispute. On 11.01.1924, the Government made
two distinct decisions, recorded separately as
IC 4236.8 and IC 4239. By the first, it dropped
the proposal to constitute the Moorkangudda
Block a State Forest. By the second, it withdrew
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:58, Bengaluru
Verified
- 263 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the acquisition of the 68 acres 33 guntas
required for that purpose.
69.23. The withdrawal of acquisition was consequential
upon the decision to abandon the proposal to
constitute the forest. The acquisition
notification itself states that the properties were
required for the constitution of the
Moorkangudda State Forest. Once the
Government decided not to constitute the
forest, the acquisition for that purpose was no
longer required. Paragraph 2 of the order
expressly provides that a notification
withdrawing the acquisition “will be published”.
It follows the decision recorded in paragraph 1;
it does not replace or limit that decision.
69.24. The learned Additional Advocate General
submits that the Government Order concerned
only the separate acquisition notification No.
R.8808-Ft.43-15-7 and the limited extent of 68
acres 33 guntas. That submission reads the
consequential withdrawal of acquisition in
isolation and fails to account for the principal
decision recorded as item 271 (IC 4236.8). It
cannot be accepted for the following reasons.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 264 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
69.24.1. The order expressly directs that “the
proposal to constitute the area into a
State Forest be dropped”. Section 4 of
the Regulation provides for publication of
precisely such a proposal. The only
notification proposing to constitute the
Moorkangudda Block a State Forest was
the notification dated 05.02.1920,
bearing No. R.8806-Ft.43-15-6. A
notification under the Land Acquisition
Regulation declares that land is required
for a public purpose; it does not propose
to constitute a forest. No other
instrument answers the description used
in the Government order.
69.24.2. The Government’s own record confirms
this distinction. The Proceedings list the
1920 notification under the Forest
Regulation as the first matter and the
acquisition notification as the second.
The order then deals with “the proposal
to constitute the area” in paragraph 1
and “the properties referred to above” in
paragraph 2. The two paragraphs
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 265 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
correspond to the two matters listed in
the Proceedings.
69.24.3. The Government accepted the
Conservator’s recommendation that the
area comprised treeless grassy plains
and that conserving the Block would be
to the detriment of the villagers. That
reason concerned the Block as a whole,
not merely the 68 acres 33 guntas of
private holdings. The Conservator had
recommended that further proceedings
be dropped and that the Section 4
notification be “treated as cancelled”.
The Secretariat recorded that “the
reservation should be cancelled”, and the
file itself was titled “Cancelling the
reservation”. The decision cannot
reasonably be read as applying only to
the limited extent proposed for
acquisition.
69.24.4. The learned Additional Advocate
General’s own submission supports this
conclusion. He states that, when the
1920 notification was issued, all lands
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 266 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
within the Block, except 68 acres 33
guntas, were already at the disposal of
the State Government, and that only the
latter extent required acquisition. Thus,
68 acres 33 guntas was the extent
sought to be acquired, not the extent
covered by the proposal to constitute a
State Forest. The proposal covered the
entire Block. When the Government
dropped “the proposal”, it dropped the
proposal for the entire Block. The limited
extent relied upon by the Respondents
pertains to the consequential withdrawal
of acquisition, not to the principal
decision.
69.24.5. If the Government had intended to deal
only with acquisition, there would have
been no reason to direct that the
proposal to constitute the area a State
Forest be dropped, to communicate that
decision to the Conservator of Forests,
the Revenue Commissioner and the
Deputy Commissioner, or to record it in
the digest under the heading
“Moorkangudda Forest Block”.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 267 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
69.25. The learned Additional Advocate General also
relies on RBI v. Peerless [(1987) 1 SCC 424],
paragraph 33, to submit that the 1920
notification and the 1924 order must be read in
their statutory and historical context. The
principle that text must be read in context, and
that no part of a statute or word may be
construed in isolation, is sound. The same
discipline applies when construing a
Government order. Here, the text, context and
purpose of the order establish that the proposal
to constitute the entire Block a State Forest was
dropped.
69.26. The next question is whether the Government’s
decision was effective in the absence of a
separate notification under the Regulation
withdrawing the Section 4 notification. It was.
69.27. The Regulation prescribes no particular form for
the Government to abandon a proposal notified
under Section 4. Nor has any party identified a
provision requiring a further notification for that
purpose. Section 17 confers a power on the
Government to issue a final notification; it does
not compel the Government to complete the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 268 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
process once a proposal has been notified. A
decision not to proceed with the proposal,
therefore, did not require a notification in the
form prescribed for constituting a State Forest.
69.28. The Government recorded its decision in the
Secretariat file and communicated it to the
officers responsible for carrying the process
forward. It also published the notification
required to withdraw the acquisition. The order
was a decision of the Government, made and
recorded in the manner reflected in its official
proceedings. The absence of a separate
notification withdrawing the Section 4
notification does not nullify that decision.
69.29. The Government’s subsequent conduct is
consistent with the decision of 1924. The
Respondents have produced no proclamation,
inquiry or final notification concerning the Block
after January 1924 before 2022.
69.30. The Revenue Department auctioned land in
Achanahalli Village on 20.09.1924, eight
months after the Government’s decision. The
Petitioners state that the Government granted
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 269 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
lands in Kadumane Village from 1952 onwards,
and that assertion has not been controverted.
69.31. No notification concerning the Block under the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, which came into
force on 01.06.1969, has been shown.
According to the learned Additional Advocate
General, a Forest Settlement Officer was
appointed by Government Order dated
19.12.2022, nearly ninety-nine years after the
order of 11.01.1924.
69.32. The suggestion that the auction in 1924 was
held only because the revenue records had not
been updated to reflect the Forest Department’s
claim is unsupported by any document before
this Court. It also fails to explain why the
Government had itself directed, eight months
earlier, that the proposal to constitute the Block
a State Forest be dropped.
69.33. Some petitions describe the cancellation of the
Section 4 proposal as having been made by
"Government Order No. I.C. 4239-Ft.296-22-
7". That description conflates the two entries.
The decision to drop the proposal to constitute
the Moorkangudda Block as a State Forest is
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 270 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
recorded in Entry 271, bearing No. I.C. 4236.8-
Ft.296-22-6, dated 11.01.1924. Entry 272,
bearing No. I.C. 4239-Ft.296-22-7, dated
11.01.1924, concerns the consequential
withdrawal under Section 48(1) of the
acquisition initiated by Notification No. R.8808-
Ft.43-15-7. The withdrawal was published in
the Mysore Gazette dated 17.01.1924.
69.34. The 1920 notification remains part of the
historical record. What ceased to exist was the
proposal under that notification as a live
proposal to constitute the Block a State Forest.
69.35. The contention that the Petitioners have taken
inconsistent positions is without merit. Their
case is that the notification ceased to operate in
1924. A prayer seeking a declaration that the
notification has lapsed or been abandoned is
consistent with that case. It seeks a declaration
of the legal position asserted by the Petitioners
and does not contradict the prayer for quashing
the impugned proceedings. The Respondents
have not demonstrated any prejudice arising
from the amendment.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 271 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
69.36. This Court answers Point No. (i) by holding that
the notification dated 05.02.1920, bearing No.
R.8806-Ft.43-15-6, does not remain operative
as a proposal to constitute the Moorkangudda
Block a State Forest. By the Government
decision recorded in Entry 271, bearing No. I.C.
4236.8-Ft.296-22-6, dated 11.01.1924, the
Government dropped the proposal for the entire
Block. The decision was not confined to the 68
acres and 33 guntas covered by the separate
acquisition notification. Entry 272, bearing No.
I.C. 4239-Ft.296-22-7, dated 11.01.1924, and
published in the Mysore Gazette dated
17.01.1924, records the consequential
withdrawal of acquisition under Notification No.
R.8808-Ft.43-15-7. The Respondents' contrary
contention is rejected.
70. Answer to Point No. (ii): What is the legal
effect of the absence of a final notification
under Section 17 of the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900, and whether the absence of
such notification precludes the State from
asserting the forest status of the notified lands
or taking action under the applicable forest
legislation?
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 272 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
70.1. Sri Manmohan P.N., learned counsel for the
Petitioners, submits that, even assuming that
the notification dated 05.02.1920 had remained
in force, it could not, by itself, authorise the
Forest Department to dispossess the
Petitioners. Unless the proceedings under the
Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900 were completed
and a final notification under Section 17 was
issued, the Respondents could not treat the
lands as a reserved forest or invoke Section
64A of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963 on that
basis. He submits that the expression “deemed
forest” cannot furnish an independent ground
for dispossession and that the Respondents
must first establish the legal status of the
lands.
70.2. Sri Manmohan P.N. further submits that Section
17 of the Regulation prescribes the stages
which must be completed before a final
notification can be issued. The period for
preferring claims must have expired and the
claims must have been disposed of; the period
for preferring appeals must have expired and all
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 273 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
appeals must have been decided; and the
proceedings prescribed by the Regulation,
including the acquisition of lands and buildings
selected for that purpose, must have been
completed. None of these stages was
completed in respect of Moorkangudda Block.
No final notification under Section 17 was
issued. The lands were therefore never
constituted a State Forest under the Regulation.
He also relies on the report of the Assistant
Commissioner dated 11.10.2022 in support of
the Petitioners’ case.
70.3. Sri Manmohan P.N. relies on M/s. Bharat
Parikh & Co. v. State of Karnataka [W.P. No.
22514/2018], decided on 18.06.2019,
particularly paragraphs 5 to 7. A Coordinate
Bench held that a notification under Section
4(1) of the 1963 Act is only the first step in the
process of constituting a reserved forest and
that the land acquires that status only upon
publication of a notification under Section 17.
The Bench expressly left open the question
whether the land constituted forest in the wider
sense under the Forest (Conservation) Act,
1980.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 274 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
70.4. Sri A.M. Vijay, learned counsel for the
Petitioners in W.P. No. 29690/2025, adopts the
submissions of Sri Manmohan P.N. on this point.
70.5. Sri Kiran Ron, learned Additional Advocate
General, does not contend that a final
notification under Section 17 of the Regulation
was issued in respect of Moorkangudda Block.
His submission is that the notification dated
05.02.1920 was not a mere expression of
intention. It attracted statutory restrictions on
the acquisition of rights in the notified area,
and its legal effect must be examined under the
Regulation rather than determined solely by
reference to subsequent revenue entries, grants
and transactions. He submits that the
Regulation prescribes no outer time limit for
publication of the final notification and that the
absence of such notification does not, by itself,
determine the legal consequences of the
preliminary notification.
70.6. Sri Kiran Ron relies on B.R. Ganapathi Singh
v. State of Karnataka [2020 SCC OnLine Kar
3074], particularly paragraphs 46 and 64. He
submits that land covered by a subsisting
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 275 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
notification under Section 4 continues to be
subject to the statutory process until the claims
are adjudicated and the land, where
appropriate, is excluded from the proposed
forest. He further relies on Prabhagiya Van
Adhikari Awadh Van Prabhag v. Arun
Kumar Bhardwaj [(2021) 18 SCC 104],
particularly paragraphs 24 and 28, and Girish
H.E. v. State of Karnataka [2013 SCC OnLine
Kar 10537], particularly paragraphs 8, 10 to 17
and 19. According to him, these decisions
establish that the absence of a final notification
does not, by itself, extinguish the statutory
restrictions attached to a preliminary
notification.
70.7. Sri Kiran Ron also relies on Narinder Singh v.
Divesh Bhutani [2022 SCC OnLine SC 899],
particularly paragraphs 41 and 49. He submits
that, in the absence of a statutory definition,
the expression “forest” bears its ordinary
dictionary meaning and that land recorded as
forest in Government records attracts Section 2
of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980. On that
basis, he contends that the shola forests and
grasslands of Moorkangudda constitute forest
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 276 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
notwithstanding the absence of dense tree
cover in some parts. He also relies on Section 2
of the 1980 Act, the circular issued by the
Ministry of Environment and Forests dated
20.08.2004, and the order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 13.11.2000 in Centre for
Environmental Law, WWF-India v. Union of
India [2000 SCC OnLine SC 119], to submit
that an area covered by a notification under
Section 4 cannot be deleted without the
permission of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. He
further relies on State of Karnataka v. I.S.
Nirvane Gowda [(2007) 15 SCC 744],
particularly paragraph 4, to contend that
revenue entries and saguvali chits confer no
title over land forming part of a reserved forest.
70.8. This point raises two distinct questions. The
first is whether the absence of a final
notification under Section 17 prevented
Moorkangudda Block from acquiring the status
of a State Forest or reserved forest. The second
is whether, notwithstanding the absence of such
notification, the State can rely on the
preliminary notification dated 05.02.1920 to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 277 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
assert forest status or initiate proceedings
against the Petitioners.
70.9. Section 17 of the Regulation prescribes the
stages which must precede publication of the
final notification. The period fixed under Section
5 for preferring claims must have expired and
the claims must have been disposed of by the
Forest Settlement Officer. Where claims have
been made, the period for preferring appeals
under Section 15 must have expired and the
appeals must have been disposed of. The
proceedings prescribed by Sections 10 and 13
must also have been completed, including the
vesting in the Government of lands and
buildings which the Forest Settlement Officer
elected to acquire under the Land Acquisition
Regulation, 1894.
70.10. Upon completion of those stages, Section
17(1)(d) provides that the Government may
publish a notification specifying the limits of the
forest and declaring it to be a State Forest from
the date fixed in that notification. Section 17(2)
provides that, from that date, the forest shall
be deemed to be a State Forest. The final
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 278 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
notification is thus the statutory instrument by
which the proposed forest acquires the status of
a State Forest under the Regulation.
70.11. No notification under Section 17 has been
identified or produced in respect of
Moorkangudda Block. The Respondents do not
dispute its absence. The lands were therefore
never constituted a State Forest under the
Regulation.
70.12. The same conclusion follows under the 1963
Act. Section 2(14) defines a “Reserved Forest”
as land settled and notified as such in
accordance with Chapter II of that Act. Section
23(1) recognises as reserved forests under the
1963 Act forests which had already been
notified as State Forests under the Mysore
Forest Regulations, 1900, before the 1963 Act
came into force. It does not confer the status of
a reserved forest on land which was merely the
subject of a preliminary notification under
Section 4 of the Regulation and was never
declared a State Forest under Section 17. Since
Moorkangudda Block was never constituted a
State Forest, Section 23 does not apply to it.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 279 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Section 23 is reproduced hereunder for ease of
reference:
23. Reserved forests constituted previous to
passing of this Act.— (1) Any forest which has
been notified as a State Forest under the Mysore
Forest Act, 1900, or as a reserved forest under the
Indian Forest Act, 1927, the Madras Forest Act,
1882, or the Hyderabad Forest Act, 1355F, prior to
the date on which this Act comes into force, shall be
a reserved forest under this Act:
Provided that if the rights of private persons to or
over any land or forest produce in such forest shall
not have been inquired into, settled and recorded in
a manner which the State Government deems
sufficient, the same shall be inquired into, settled
and recorded in the manner provided by this Act;
and until such inquiry, settlement and record have
been completed, the operation of this section shall
not abridge, or affect such rights.
(2) All questions decided, orders issued and records
prepared in connection with the constitution of such
forest as a State Forest or reserved forest shall be
deemed to have been decided, issued and prepared
under this Act, and the provisions of this Act
relating to reserved forests shall apply to forests to
which the provisions of sub-section (1) are
applicable.
70.13. The decision in M/s. Bharat Parikh & Co.
supports this distinction. The Coordinate Bench
held that a notification under Section 4(1) of
the 1963 Act is “only a first step which is
required to be taken before the State
Government decides to constitute a land as a
reserved forest” and that the land is declared a
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 280 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
reserved forest only after publication of a
notification under Section 17. Though that
decision concerned the 1963 Act, the distinction
between the preliminary notification and the
final declaration applies equally to the scheme
of the Regulation. Section 4 initiates the
process; Section 17 completes it and confers
the status of a State Forest. The Coordinate
Bench also expressly left open the question
whether the land constituted forest land within
the meaning of the 1980 Act. This Court adopts
the same distinction.
70.14. The absence of a final notification, however,
does not by itself answer the second question.
A preliminary notification may attract statutory
consequences before the land acquires the final
status of a State Forest or reserved forest. The
nature, commencement and duration of those
consequences must be determined from the
applicable statutory provisions. They cannot be
equated with the legal status conferred by a
final notification under Section 17.
70.15. Section 6 of the Regulation is material. Section
6(1) prohibits the acquisition of rights in or over
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 281 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the notified land, subject to the exceptions
specified in that provision. It also restricts the
construction of new houses, formation of
plantations, fresh clearings and cutting of trees
for trade or manufacture. It further prohibits
the grant of a right of occupancy without the
previous sanction of the Government. The
prohibition under Section 6(1), however,
operates during the interval between
publication of the proclamation contemplated
by Section 5 and the date fixed by the
notification declaring the forest to be a State
Forest. It does not commence merely upon
publication of the notification under Section 4.
Section 6(2) preserves acts done with the
written permission of the Forest Settlement
Officer.
70.16. It follows that the prohibition under Section
6(1) cannot be applied to every transaction
entered into after the notification dated
05.02.1920 merely on the basis of that
notification. The statutory trigger prescribed by
Section 6(1) must first be established.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 282 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
70.17. Section 6(3) deals with a different matter. It
bars a Civil Court, during the period between
publication of the notification under Section 4
and the final notification under Section 17, from
entertaining a suit to establish a right in or over
the notified land or its forest produce. It does
not prohibit the acquisition of rights in the same
terms as Section 6(1), nor does it confer on the
Forest Department a power of eviction. It is a
procedural bar ancillary to the statutory process
for constituting a State Forest. Once the
Government formally dropped that proposal,
the provision could not continue to operate as
though the process remained pending. It
cannot be used to preserve indefinitely the
consequences of a proposal which the
Government itself had abandoned.
70.18. In Prabhagiya Van Adhikari Awadh Van
Prabhag v. Arun Kumar Bhardwaj , the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that, even in the
absence of a final notification, a statutory bar
on the acquisition of rights could continue to
operate after publication of a preliminary
notification. The decision must be read in the
context of the statutory provision considered by
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 283 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the Supreme Court. It concerned Section 5 of
the Indian Forest Act, 1927, as substituted by
the Uttar Pradesh Act 23 of 1965. That
substituted provision expressly prohibited the
acquisition of rights in land after publication of
a notification under Section 4, subject to the
exceptions specified in it.
70.19. The decision establishes that a preliminary
notification may attract an express statutory
bar on the acquisition of rights. It does not
permit the Court to disregard the wording of
the corresponding provision in the Regulation.
Section 6(1) of the Regulation ties the
prohibition on the acquisition of rights to
publication of the proclamation under Section 5.
The statutory trigger under the Regulation is
therefore different from the one considered in
Arun Kumar Bhardwaj . The decision cannot
be applied without regard to that distinction.
Further, the statutory restrictions recognised in
that decision presuppose a subsisting
notification. It does not hold that those
restrictions continue after the Government has
withdrawn the proposal on which they depend.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 284 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
70.20. In B.R. Ganapathi Singh , a co-ordinate bench
of this Court considered a notification issued
under Section 4(1) of the 1963 Act. The co-
ordinate bench held that, notwithstanding the
absence of a final notification under Section 17,
land covered by a subsisting Section 4(1)
notification continued to be forest land for the
purposes of the 1980 Act until the claims were
adjudicated and the boundaries of the proposed
forest were settled. The decision recognises
that the absence of a final notification does not,
by itself, remove the consequences of a
preliminary notification which remains in force.
70.21. That proposition does not assist the
Respondents in the present case. The decision
concerned a subsisting notification under
Section 4(1) of the 1963 Act. This Court has
already held under point (i) that the
Government Order dated 11.01.1924 (IC
4236.8) dropped the proposal contained in the
notification dated 05.02.1920 for the entire
Moorkangudda Block. Notification IC 4239 was
the consequential withdrawal of the acquisition
proceedings relating to 68 acres 33 guntas. The
notification of 1920 did not remain in force as a
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 285 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
live proposal after 11.01.1924. B.R. Ganapathi
Singh does not hold that the consequences of a
preliminary notification survive the
Government’s withdrawal of the proposal itself.
70.22. Girish H.E. also concerns the statutory process
under the 1963 Act. The observations in
paragraph 19 recognise the restrictions which
follow a notification under Section 4 of that Act,
including the restrictions under Section 6.
Those observations apply where the notification
under Section 4 remains in force. They do not
concern a proposal under the Regulation which
the Government subsequently withdrew. The
decision therefore does not establish that the
restrictions under the 1963 Act can be founded
on a notification which had ceased to operate
before the 1963 Act came into force.
70.23. These decisions lay down principles which
operate in their respective statutory settings.
M/s. Bharat Parikh & Co. explains that a
preliminary notification does not, by itself,
confer the final status of a reserved forest. B.R.
Ganapathi Singh recognises that a subsisting
notification under Section 4(1) of the 1963 Act
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 286 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
may have consequences under the 1980 Act
even before publication of the final notification.
Arun Kumar Bhardwaj applies an express
statutory bar contained in the Uttar Pradesh
amendment to the Indian Forest Act, 1927.
Girish H.E. concerns the restrictions under the
1963 Act. None of these decisions holds that
statutory restrictions continue after the
Government has withdrawn the proposal on
which they rest. There is no conflict between
these authorities.
70.24. The Petitioners’ submission concerning “deemed
forest” requires a further distinction. Section
17(2) of the Regulation deems land to be a
State Forest from the date fixed in the final
notification. That provision was never attracted
in respect of Moorkangudda Block. The lands
were therefore never deemed to be a State
Forest under the Regulation.
70.25. That conclusion does not determine whether
any parcel is forest land under the 1980 Act or
under another applicable provision of law. The
expression “forest land” under the 1980 Act is
not confined to land formally declared a
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 287 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
reserved forest. The question whether any
parcel falls within that wider meaning must be
examined independently.
70.26. In Narinder Singh v. Divesh Bhutani , the
Hon’ble Supreme Court considered the meaning
of “forest” for the purposes of Section 2 of the
1980 Act. It held that, in the absence of a
statutory definition, the word “forest” bears its
ordinary dictionary meaning. It also recognised
that land shown as forest in Government
records attracts Section 2 of the 1980 Act,
provided the relevant entries were made after
due process. This Court applies those
principles.
70.27. Those principles do not, however, create a
power of summary eviction under Section 64A
of the 1963 Act or confer jurisdiction on a
Forest Settlement Officer under Section 5 and
the succeeding provisions of that Act. The
exercise of those powers must satisfy the
conditions prescribed by the 1963 Act. The
existence of forest land under the 1980 Act and
the availability of a particular statutory power
under the 1963 Act are separate questions.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 288 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
70.28. Whether a particular parcel is forest in the
ordinary dictionary sense or is recorded as
forest in a Government record prepared after
due process, is a question of fact. It requires
examination of the nature of the parcel, the
relevant records, the manner in which those
records came into existence, and the identity
and boundaries of the land. Sri Kiran Ron
submits that the character of the area must be
assessed with reference to the forest records,
the notification and its ecological features,
rather than solely by reference to the present
physical appearance of individual parcels.
70.29. The general reference to forest entries in
Government records does not establish that
each Petitioner's property is forest land. The
relevant records must be identified, their
provenance and legal basis examined, and the
entries matched to the particular parcels
claimed by the Petitioners. The present record
does not permit a parcel-wise finding on
whether any land in Moorkangudda Block is
forest in the ordinary dictionary sense. Nor
does the description of the area in the 1924
documents as treeless grassy plains conclude
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 289 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
that question. The ordinary meaning of forest
may include extensive tracts in which pasture
and woodland occur together. The character of
each parcel must therefore be determined on
the relevant evidence and under the applicable
law.
70.30. I.S. Nirvane Gowda concerned land which had
been included in a reserved forest. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that revenue entries were
of no consequence in relation to such land and
that the Revenue Authorities could not deal
with it. The decision applies where the legal
status of the land as a reserved forest has first
been established. It does not establish that land
which was never constituted a reserved forest
under the applicable statute must be treated as
one.
70.31. Sri Kiran Ron also relies on the circular dated
20.08.2004 and the order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 13.11.2000 in Centre for
Environmental Law, WWF-India v. Union of
India . He submits that an area covered by a
notification under Section 4 cannot be deleted
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 290 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
without the permission of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court.
70.32. That procedure has no application to the finding
under point (i). The Government Order dated
11.01.1924 dropped the proposal to constitute
the entire Moorkangudda Block as a State
Forest. Recognising the effect of that order is
not an act of deletion or dereservation of an
area from a subsisting forest notification. This
judgment does not direct the deletion of any
area from a notification which remains in force,
nor does it authorise non-forest use of land
which is otherwise established to be forest land.
If any parcel in Moorkangudda Block is forest
land within the meaning of the 1980 Act, the
restrictions imposed by that Act continue to
apply.
70.33. Sri Kiran Ron also relies on CIT v. Punalur
Paper Mills [(1988) 170 ITR 37], particularly
paragraphs 5 and 6, for the proposition that
circulars issued by a competent authority within
its statutory powers bind the officers of the
department. The Hon’ble Kerala High Court
recognised the binding effect of circulars issued
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 291 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
by the competent authority under the Income-
tax Act. The principle is accepted. It does not
advance the Respondents’ case. A departmental
circular may regulate the manner in which
officers exercise an existing power. It cannot
create a statutory notification, revive a proposal
already withdrawn, or confer jurisdiction which
the statute does not provide. The circular dated
20.08.2004 cannot, therefore, revive the
proposal withdrawn in 1924.
70.34. The legal position follows from the statutory
scheme and the finding under point (i). The
absence of a final notification under Section 17
means that Moorkangudda Block was never
constituted a State Forest under the Regulation.
It did not acquire the status of a reserved forest
under Section 2(14) of the 1963 Act, nor does
it fall within Section 23 of that Act as a forest
previously notified as a State Forest.
70.35. A preliminary notification may attract statutory
restrictions before the final notification is
issued. The restrictions under Section 6 of the
Regulation, however, operate in accordance
with the conditions and time periods specified
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 292 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
in that provision. They cannot be detached from
the statutory process and continued after the
Government has withdrawn the proposal. The
Government Order dated 11.01.1924 (IC
4236.8) dropped the proposal to constitute the
entire Block as a State Forest. Notification IC
4239 was consequential and withdrew the
acquisition proceedings relating to 68 acres 33
guntas. The Respondents cannot rely on the
1920 notification as a continuing source of
restrictions or as the basis for proceedings
against the Petitioners.
70.36. The repeal-and-savings provision in Section 117
of the 1963 Act cannot revive a notification or
proposal which the Government had withdrawn
before the 1963 Act came into force. The
finding under point (i), that the proposal had
been dropped in 1924, governs that
consideration.
70.37. These findings do not determine whether any
particular parcel is forest land under the 1980
Act or falls within another category recognised
by the 1963 Act. The State may establish such
status on an independent legal and factual
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 293 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
basis and take action authorised by the
applicable law. The existence of forest land
under the 1980 Act does not, by itself, confer
jurisdiction to invoke Section 64A or to conduct
proceedings before a Forest Settlement Officer.
Each statutory power must be exercised only
after establishing the conditions which confer it.
Since the proposal under the 1920 notification
was withdrawn, the State cannot use that
notification as a substitute for a fresh decision
under Section 4(1) of the 1963 Act if it seeks to
constitute the lands as a reserved forest.
70.38. This Court therefore answers Point No. (ii) by
holding that no final notification under Section
17 of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, was
issued in respect of Moorkangudda Block. The
lands were never constituted a State Forest
under the Regulation and did not acquire the
status of a reserved forest under Section 2(14)
of the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, or under
Section 23 of that Act.
70.39. The absence of a final notification does not, by
itself, extinguish statutory restrictions attached
to a subsisting preliminary notification. In the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 294 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
present case, however, the Government Order
dated 11.01.1924 (IC 4236.8) dropped the
proposal contained in the notification dated
05.02.1920 for the entire Moorkangudda Block.
Notification IC 4239 was consequential and
related to the withdrawal of acquisition
proceedings for 68 acres 33 guntas. The
Respondents cannot rely on the withdrawn
proposal as a continuing basis to assert that the
lands constitute a State Forest or reserved
forest, or to initiate proceedings against the
Petitioners.
71. Answer to Point No. (iii): Whether the repeal of
the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900, by the
Karnataka Forest Act, 1963, affects the validity
or continued operation of the notification dated
05.02.1920 and the proceedings initiated
pursuant thereto, having regard to the
applicable repeal-and-savings provisions?
71.1. Sri Manmohan P.N., learned counsel for the
Petitioners, submits that, after the repeal of the
Regulation by the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963,
every action of the Forest Department must
derive its authority from the 1963 Act and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 295 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
comply with the procedure prescribed therein.
He submits that a notification under Section 4
of the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900 is
fundamentally different from a notification
under Section 4(1) of the 1963 Act. The former
announces a proposal to constitute land as a
State Forest, whereas the latter declares that
the State Government has decided to constitute
land as a reserved forest. The subsequent
proceedings, including the appointment of the
Forest Settlement Officer, publication of the
proclamation and inquiry into claims, must
therefore satisfy the requirements of the 1963
Act. Even if the notification dated 05.02.1920
had survived, it remained a proposal under the
Regulation and could not, by itself, be treated
as a decision under Section 4(1) of the 1963
Act. A proclamation under Section 5 of the
1963 Act could not be issued without a
notification satisfying Section 4(1).
71.2. Sri A.M. Vijay, learned counsel for the
Petitioners in W.P. No. 29690/2025, advances
the same distinction between a proposal under
the Regulation and a decision under the 1963
Act. He submits that the issue of a
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 296 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
proclamation without a proper decision under
Section 4(1) of the 1963 Act demonstrates non-
application of mind.
71.3. Sri Manmohan P.N. relies on M. Karunanidhi
v. Union of India [(1979) 3 SCC 431],
particularly paragraph 35, and Union of India
v. Rajeev Bansal [2024 SCC OnLine SC 2693],
particularly paragraphs 42 and 43. He submits
that repeal by implication is not readily
inferred. It arises only where the provisions of
the two enactments are so inconsistent that
they cannot operate together. The scope, object
and scheme of both enactments must be
examined before such a conclusion is reached.
On that basis, he contends that the
Respondents cannot rely on the 1963 Act to
dispense with the statutory process under the
Regulation or avoid the requirement of a final
notification under Section 17. They must
establish the legal basis on which the lands
acquired the status of a reserved forest.
71.4. Sri Kiran Ron, learned Additional Advocate
General, submits that Section 117 of the 1963
Act expressly repealed the earlier forest
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 297 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
enactment but preserved the legal effect of
actions validly taken under it. According to him,
the repeal did not extinguish the notification
dated 05.02.1920 or the proceedings validly
undertaken pursuant to it. Those actions
continued to have effect under the savings
provision until superseded by action taken
under the 1963 Act. The notification cannot be
treated as having lapsed merely because the
earlier enactment was repealed.
71.5. Sri Kiran Ron further submits that the
description of the old enactment as the Mysore
Forest Act, 1900 or the Mysore Forest
Regulation, 1900 makes no difference to the
present controversy. The statutory scheme
contemplated a preliminary notification under
Section 4, followed by adjudication of claims
and determination of rights, subject to the
restrictions under Section 6. He submits that
the repeal-and-savings provision must be read
together with the preliminary notification and
the proceedings undertaken pursuant to it.
71.6. The question is whether the repeal of the
Regulation by the 1963 Act affected the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 298 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
notification dated 05.02.1920 and the
proceedings initiated under it. The question
must be answered in light of the finding under
point (i) that the Government dropped the
proposal to constitute Moorkangudda Block as a
State Forest by its order dated 11.01.1924.
Point (ii) has further held that the lands were
never constituted a State Forest under the
Regulation and that the Respondents cannot
rely on the withdrawn notification as a
continuing basis for proceedings against the
Petitioners.
71.7. The Respondents nevertheless rely on Section
117 of the 1963 Act to contend that the
notification and the proceedings pursuant to it
were preserved. The effect of that provision
must therefore be examined. Section 117 is
reproduced hereunder for ease of reference:
117. Repeal and savings. —The Indian Forest Act,
1927 (Central Act XVI of 1927), as in force in the 1
[Belgaum Area]1 , the Indian Forest Act, 1927
(Central Act XVI of 1927), as in force in the Coorg
District, the Hyderabad Forest Act, 1355 Fasli
(Hyderabad Act II of 1355 Fasli), as in force in the 1
[Gulbarga Area]1 , the Madras Forest Act, 1882
(Madras Act V of 1882), as in force in the 1
[Mangalore and Kollegal Area]1 , the Mysore Forest
Act, 1900 (Mysore Act X of 1900), as in force in the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 299 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Mysore Area, and the 1 [Karnataka]1 Preservation
of Private Forests Act, 1962 (1 [Karnataka]1 Act No.
19 of 1962), are hereby repealed:
Provided that the repeal shall not affect,—
(a) the previous operation of any law so repealed or
anything duly done or suffered thereunder, or
(b) any right, privilege, obligation or liability
acquired, accrued or incurred under any law so
repealed, or
(c) any penalty, forfeiture or punishment incurred in
respect of any offence committed against any law so
repealed, or
(d) any investigation, legal proceeding or remedy in
respect of any such right, privilege, obligation,
liability, penalty, forfeiture or punishment as
aforesaid; and any such investigation, legal
proceeding or remedy, may be instituted, continued
or enforced, and any such penalty, forfeiture or
punishment may be imposed as if this Act had not
been passed:
Provided further that, subject to the preceding
proviso, anything done or any action taken
(including any appointment or delegation made,
notification, order, instruction or direction issued,
rule, regulation, form, or scheme framed, certificate
obtained, permit or licence granted or registration
effected) under any such law shall be deemed to
have been done or taken under the corresponding
provision of this Act and shall continue to be in force
accordingly, unless and until superseded by
anything done or any action taken under this Act.
71.8. Section 117 of the 1963 Act is the repeal-and-
savings provision. It expressly repeals, among
other enactments, the Mysore Forest
Regulations, 1900, as in force in the Mysore
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 300 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Area. The first proviso preserves the previous
operation of the repealed law, anything duly
done or suffered under it, rights, privileges,
obligations and liabilities acquired, accrued or
incurred under it, and investigations, legal
proceedings and remedies relating to those
matters. It further provides that such
investigations, proceedings and remedies may
be instituted, continued or enforced as if the
1963 Act had not been passed.
71.9. The second proviso reads:
“Provided further that, subject to the preceding
proviso, anything done or any action taken
(including any appointment or delegation made,
notification, order, instruction or direction issued,
rule, regulation, form, or scheme framed, certificate
obtained, permit or licence granted or registration
effected) under any such law shall be deemed to
have been done or taken under the corresponding
provision of this Act and shall continue to be in force
accordingly, unless and until superseded by
anything done or any action taken under this Act.”
71.10. The two provisos serve distinct purposes. The
first preserves the past operation of the
repealed law and the rights, obligations,
liabilities and proceedings which accrued under
it. The second gives continuity under the
corresponding provisions of the new Act to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 301 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
actions and instruments taken or issued under
the repealed law. Neither proviso can be read in
isolation from the other or beyond the terms
used by the Legislature.
71.11. Section 117 does not extinguish what was
validly done under the repealed enactment. It
preserves the legal consequences which had
accrued under that enactment. It also continues
actions and instruments which remained in
force when the 1963 Act came into operation,
by treating them as actions taken under the
corresponding provisions of the new Act. The
words “shall continue to be in force accordingly”
are decisive. They preserve continuity; they do
not revive an action which had already ceased
to operate before the new Act commenced.
71.12. The notification dated 05.02.1920 must be
examined on that basis. The 1963 Act came
into force on 01.06.1969. The proposal
contained in the 1920 notification had been
dropped by the Government order dated
11.01.1924. The notification was therefore not
a subsisting proposal when Section 117 came
into operation. The second proviso cannot
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 302 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
revive it. This conclusion follows from the text
of Section 117 and the finding already reached
under point (i). The position may be stated as
under:
71.12.1. The repeal was express. Section 117
specifically names the Mysore Forest Act,
1900, as in force in the Mysore Area,
among the enactments repealed by the
1963 Act. The principles governing
implied repeal, on which the Petitioners
rely, do not determine the present issue.
In M. Karunanidhi , the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that repeal by
implication cannot be inferred unless the
inconsistency between the enactments is
apparent and irreconcilable. In Union of
India v. Rajeev Bansal , the Hon’ble
Supreme Court reiterated that a later
enactment is not readily presumed to
repeal an earlier law in the absence of an
express or unambiguous intention and
that implied repeal must be avoided
where both enactments can operate
together. Those principles are well
settled. They have no application to the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 303 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
question whether the Legislature
expressly repealed the earlier forest law.
Section 117 answers that question in
clear terms. The issue here is the extent
of the savings made by that section.
71.12.2. The difference in nomenclature between
the Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900 and
the Mysore Forest Act, 1900 does not, by
itself, decide the issue. The notification
dated 05.02.1920 is described as having
been issued under Section 4 of the
Mysore Forest Regulation, 1900. Section
117 refers to the Mysore Forest Act,
1900, as in force in the Mysore Area.
The parties have proceeded on the basis
that the provision in Section 117 relates
to the earlier Mysore forest law
governing the notification in question.
For the purpose of deciding the present
point, the Court proceeds on that
common position. The second proviso to
Section 117 does not revive the
notification dated 05.02.1920. The
notification was duly published under the
old law. Its past operation is therefore
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 304 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
not erased by repeal. But the
Government subsequently dropped the
proposal to constitute Moorkangudda
Block as a State Forest by its order
dated 11.01.1924. As held under point
(i), that order brought the proposal to an
end. The notification was not in force on
01.06.1969, when the 1963 Act
commenced.
71.12.3. The expression “shall continue to be in
force accordingly” in the second proviso
presupposes that the action or
instrument was still in force when the
new Act came into operation. It does not
authorise the revival of an action which
had ceased to operate under the
repealed law. To hold otherwise would
convert a provision for continuity into a
power of revival. Section 117 contains
no such power. The general submission
of Sri Kiran Ron that actions validly
taken under the repealed enactment are
preserved is correct. It does not assist
the Respondents because the proposal
had already been withdrawn in 1924.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 305 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
71.12.4. The first proviso must be considered
separately. It preserves the previous
operation of the repealed law, anything
duly done or suffered under it, rights,
privileges, obligations and liabilities
which accrued under it, and
investigations, proceedings and remedies
relating to them. It is therefore not
correct to say that the first proviso has
no application merely because the
notification was withdrawn before the
1963 Act commenced. Any right or
liability validly accrued under the
Regulation during its operation remains
governed by the first proviso, subject to
proof of its existence and legal character.
71.13. That saving, however, does not establish that a
proceeding under the Regulation remained
pending on 01.06.1969. The steps taken
between 1920 and 1923, preceded the
Government’s decision to drop the proposal. No
subsequent proceeding under the Regulation
has been identified. Nor have the Respondents
identified any investigation or legal proceeding
pending on 01.06.1969 which was later
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 306 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
continued under the first proviso. The
proceedings commenced in 2022 and thereafter
were initiated under the 1963 Act, including
proceedings under Section 5 and the
succeeding provisions of Chapter II and action
under Section 64A. They were not a
continuation of any pending proceeding under
the Regulation. Their validity must therefore
rest on a notification under Section 4(1) of the
1963 Act or on a notification lawfully saved and
deemed to have been issued under the
corresponding provision by the second proviso
to Section 117. The withdrawn notification of
1920 provides neither.
71.14. The Petitioners also contend that a notification
under Section 4 of the Regulation, which merely
announced a proposal to constitute land as a
State Forest, cannot be treated as a notification
under Section 4(1) of the 1963 Act, which
requires a decision to constitute land as a
reserved forest. The distinction is apparent
from the language of the two provisions.
Section 4 of the Regulation applies when it is
proposed to constitute land as a State Forest
and requires the notification to declare that
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 307 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
proposal. Section 4(1) of the 1963 Act applies
when the State Government has decided to
constitute land as a reserved forest and
requires the notification to declare that
decision. Section 4(2) of the 1963 Act further
requires the Forest Settlement Officer to be a
person who does not hold any forest office
other than that of Forest Settlement Officer.
The Regulation, by contrast, states that the
officer shall ordinarily be a person other than a
Forest Officer.
71.15. The second proviso to Section 117 refers to a
“corresponding provision”, not an identical
provision. Whether a notification announcing a
proposal under the Regulation could, in a case
where it remained in force on the
commencement of the 1963 Act, be treated as
a notification under the corresponding provision
of that Act is a question which does not arise
for decision here. The notification dated
05.02.1920 had already ceased to operate in
1924.
71.16. It is sufficient to hold that Section 5 of the 1963
Act permits the Forest Settlement Officer to
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 308 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
publish a proclamation only when a notification
has been issued under Section 4 of that Act.
The Respondents have not established that a
notification under Section 4(1) of the 1963 Act
was issued in respect of Moorkangudda Block
before the proceedings commenced in 2022.
Nor can the withdrawn notification of 1920 be
treated as a notification continuing under
Section 117.
71.17. Sri Manmohan P.N.’s submission that the repeal
did not dispense with the need to complete the
statutory process is correct to the extent that
the State could not treat a preliminary proposal
as a final declaration of a State Forest or
reserved forest. The repeal itself did not
invalidate the notification dated 05.02.1920 or
erase its past operation. The proposal ceased to
operate because the Government dropped it by
its order dated 11.01.1924. The legal
consequence follows from that order, not from
the subsequent repeal of the Regulation.
71.18. The Respondents’ reliance on the savings
provision and the Petitioners’ reliance on the
distinction between the two enactments must
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 309 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
therefore be considered in light of the same
conclusion. Section 117 preserves the past
operation of the repealed law and any rights,
obligations, liabilities and proceedings which
accrued under it. Its second proviso continues
actions and instruments which remained in
force when the 1963 Act commenced. It does
not revive the notification dated 05.02.1920,
which the Government had withdrawn in 1924.
Nor does it authorise the commencement of
fresh proceedings under the 1963 Act on the
strength of that withdrawn notification.
71.19. The State remains entitled to exercise the
powers conferred by Sections 3 and 4(1) of the
1963 Act if it seeks to constitute land as a
reserved forest. It must do so by taking a
decision under Section 4(1), issuing the
prescribed notification and following the
procedure in Chapter II. This finding does not
preclude the State from establishing that any
identified parcel constitutes forest land under
the 1980 Act or under another applicable
provision of law. That issue remains governed
by point (ii).
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 310 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
71.20. This Court answers Point No. (iii) by holding
that Section 117 of the Karnataka Forest Act,
1963, expressly repealed the earlier Mysore
forest law. The repeal did not, by itself,
extinguish the notification dated 05.02.1920 or
erase its past operation. The first proviso to
Section 117 preserves the previous operation of
the repealed law and any rights, obligations,
liabilities, investigations, proceedings and
remedies validly accrued under it. The second
proviso continues actions and instruments
which remained in force when the 1963 Act
commenced, by deeming them to have been
taken under the corresponding provisions of
that Act.
71.21. The proposal contained in the notification dated
05.02.1920 had, however, been dropped by the
Government order dated 11.01.1924. It was
not in force on 01.06.1969, when the 1963 Act
came into operation. Section 117 neither saves
it as a continuing notification nor deems it to
have been issued under Section 4(1) of the
1963 Act. The proceedings commenced under
the 1963 Act on the strength of the withdrawn
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 311 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
notification are not supported by the savings
provision.
72. Answer to Point No. (iv): Whether the
prolonged lapse of time between the
preliminary notification and the subsequent
proceedings renders the proceedings legally
unsustainable on the grounds of unreasonable
delay, abandonment of the proposal to
constitute the lands as reserved forest, or
creation of third-party rights in the intervening
period?
72.1. Sri Manmohan P.N., learned counsel for the
Petitioners, submits in the alternative that,
even if the notification dated 05.02.1920 had
remained in force, the State was required to
initiate and complete the statutory proceedings
within a reasonable time. A delay of nearly a
century, without any satisfactory explanation, is
unreasonable and cannot sustain proceedings
commenced in 2022. The Regulation prescribes
a minimum period of three months for persons
to submit their claims after publication of the
proclamation under Section 5. Yet, no
proclamation or subsequent proceedings under
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 312 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the Regulation followed the notification of 1920.
The prolonged inaction and failure to follow the
statutory procedure render the Respondents’
present reliance on the notification untenable.
72.2. Sri Manmohan P.N. relies on V. Sampangi
Ramaiah v. Director/Commissioner,
Department of Mines and Geology [2012
SCC OnLine Kar 8879], particularly paragraphs
10 to 21. He submits that, although the 1963
Act prescribes no period for publication of the
final notification under Section 17, the power
must be exercised within a reasonable time. In
paragraph 19, the Hon’ble Division bench of this
Court held that three years was a reasonable
period on the facts of that case, excluding the
time taken in acquisition proceedings, appeals
and court-ordered stays. In paragraph 21, the
Court held that the State had abandoned its
intention to constitute the land as a reserved
forest after taking no steps for over two
decades, particularly when a quarrying lease
had been granted in the meantime.
72.3. Sri Manmohan P.N. also relies on Joint
Collector, Ranga Reddy District v. D.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 313 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Narsing Rao [(2015) 3 SCC 695], particularly
paragraphs 25 to 31, for the principle that a
statutory power must be exercised within a
reasonable period even where the statute
prescribes no limitation. The length of the
delay, the explanation for it, the creation of
third-party rights, changes in the nature and
use of the property, and the need for finality in
transactions are relevant considerations. He
further relies on Union of India v. Citi Bank
[(2022) 19 SCC 188], particularly paragraph
19, for the proposition that, where the statute
prescribes no period, the authority must initiate
proceedings within a reasonable time having
regard to the facts and circumstances of the
case.
72.4. Sri A.M. Vijay, learned counsel for the
Petitioners in W.P. No. 29690/2025, submits
that when the Government decided not to
proceed with the proposal in 1924, the area
was sparsely populated. It is now inhabited and
developed, with agricultural activity, residential
structures and resorts. The owners have made
substantial investments in the lands. Acting
upon the notification after nearly a century
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 314 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
would cause grave prejudice to them. He
further submits that, before issuing a
proclamation under Section 5 of the 1963 Act,
the Forest Department ought to have assessed
the effect of the proposed action on the local
population. He also relies on the grants made
by the State in Kadumane Village between 1952
and 1961 as conduct consistent with the
Government having abandoned the proposal in
1924.
72.5. Sri Kiran Ron, learned Additional Advocate
General, submits that the Regulation prescribes
no outer time limit for publication of the final
notification under Section 17. The passage of
time cannot, by itself, extinguish the State’s
authority to protect lands covered by a forest
notification. He accepts that the statutory
process must be pursued within a reasonable
time but submits that what constitutes a
reasonable period depends on the
circumstances of each case, including the steps
taken by the authorities, the nature of the land
and the rights asserted by the Petitioners. He
further submits that the Respondents were
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 315 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
unable to proceed because of interim orders
passed by this Court.
72.6. Sri Kiran Ron further submits that the
Petitioners and their predecessors did not
question the notification for several decades
and approached this Court only after the Forest
Settlement Officer was appointed and
proceedings commenced. Their challenge is
therefore barred by delay, laches and
acquiescence. He submits that the ecological
importance of the area and its role in
maintaining forest and catchment functions are
matters of public interest which must be
considered while assessing the State’s action.
The passage of time should not defeat the
State’s lawful duty to protect the lands. He also
relies on the revenue records to contend that
the forest character of the lands was reflected
in Government records and that the Petitioners
acquired their properties with notice of those
entries and of the Forest Department’s claim.
According to him, the Petitioners cannot rely on
their purchases or subsequent investments to
claim equities against the State.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 316 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
72.7. Sri Kiran Ron relies on M.C. Mehta v. Kamal
Nath [(1997) 1 SCC 388], in support of the
public trust doctrine. The principle, as explained
in the judgment, is that forests and other
natural resources are held by the Government
in trust for the public and that the doctrine
“enjoins upon the Government to protect the
resources for the enjoyment of the general
public rather than to permit their use for private
ownership or commercial purposes”. He submits
that the State, as trustee, must prevent
unauthorised appropriation, degradation and
exploitation of forest land. He accepts that this
obligation must be discharged within the
applicable statutory framework.
72.8. In support of the ecological importance of
Moorkangudda, Sri Kiran Ron refers to its
location in the Western Ghats, its biodiversity,
shola forests and grasslands, the streams
originating in the area, their connection with
the Cauvery and west-flowing river systems,
and the Yettinahole Integrated Drinking Water
Project. He also refers to the risk of ecological
damage from unauthorised occupation,
construction and commercial activity. He
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 317 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
accepts that claims concerning particular
species, and the course and hydrological
connectivity of the streams, must be
established through wildlife records and
scientific and hydrological material.
72.9. This point concerns three matters:
unreasonable delay, abandonment of the
proposal, and the creation of third-party rights
in the intervening period.
72.10. The finding under point (i) is that the
Government dropped the proposal contained in
the notification dated 05.02.1920 by its order
dated 11.01.1924. Points (ii) and (iii) hold that
the lands were never constituted a State Forest
under the Regulation and that the withdrawn
notification was not saved or revived by Section
117 of the 1963 Act. The Respondents
therefore cannot rely on the 1920 notification
as a continuing source of authority.
72.11. The question of delay and abandonment must
nevertheless be examined independently. In the
alternative, even if the notification had survived
the Government order of 11.01.1924, the State
could not leave the statutory process
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 318 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
unattended for nearly a century and then act on
the preliminary notification as though the
proceedings had remained pending throughout.
The effect of third-party rights is considered
separately.
72.12. The governing principle is settled. The absence
of a prescribed period of limitation does not
confer an unlimited power to act at any time. In
Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District , the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that “such power
must be exercised within a reasonable period”.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court also warned
against “endless uncertainty in human affairs”
and held that third-party rights created during
a prolonged and unexplained delay cannot be
defeated by a belated exercise of statutory
power. The reasonableness of the period
depends on the nature of the power, the
circumstances in which it is exercised and the
consequences of disturbing rights and
transactions which have attained finality.
72.13. In Union of India v. Citi Bank , the Hon’ble
Supreme Court reiterated in paragraph 19 that,
“where no such period has been provided in the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 17:59, Bengaluru
Verified
- 319 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Statute, the authorities are required to initiate
the said proceeding within a reasonable period”.
What constitutes a reasonable period depends
on the facts and circumstances of the case.
72.14. This Hon’ble Division bench of this Court
applied the same principle to proceedings for
constitution of a reserved forest in V.
Sampangi Ramaiah . In paragraph 19, the
Hon’ble Division bench of this Court held that
the absence of a specific time limit for
publication of the notification under Section 17
of the 1963 Act required the final notification to
be issued within a reasonable time. Having
regard to the statutory scheme and the
circumstances of that case, the Hon’ble Division
bench considered three years to be a
reasonable period, excluding the time taken in
acquisition proceedings, appeals and court-
ordered stays. In paragraph 21, it held that the
State had abandoned its intention to constitute
the land as a reserved forest after taking no
steps for over two decades, particularly when a
quarrying lease had been granted in the
meantime.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 320 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
72.15. The three-year period fixed in Sampangi
Ramaiah is not a statutory period of limitation
applicable to every forest notification. It was
the reasonable period determined on the facts
of that case. The controlling principle is that
statutory proceedings must be pursued within a
reasonable time. That principle applies to the
present controversy as well. The Regulation
prescribes no outer time limit for completion of
the process under Section 17. That omission
does not authorise the State to leave a proposal
pending indefinitely.
72.16. The chronology is decisive. The notification
dated 05.02.1920 was published in the Mysore
Gazette on 12.02.1920. The Settlement Officer
submitted a report on 25.09.1922. The
Conservator of Forests reported against
constitution of the proposed forest in April
1923. The Government thereafter passed its
order dated 11.01.1924, the effect of which has
been determined under point (i).
72.17. Even on the Respondents’ case that the
notification dated 05.02.1920 remained in
force, the record discloses no further statutory
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 321 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
settlement proceedings for nearly a century. No
proclamation under Section 5 of the Regulation,
service of notices on the affected owners or
occupiers, completed inquiry into claims,
adjudication of rights, final demarcation or
notification under Section 17 has been
established for the period after the initial steps
in 1920 to 1923. The next material step was
the Government Order No. FW258AASC 2022
dated 19.12.2022 appointing the Forest
Settlement Officer to proceed with the matter.
The proclamation under Section 5 of the 1963
Act followed on 19.07.2023.
72.18. Thus, the State took no demonstrated step to
carry the statutory settlement process to
completion for nearly a century. The
Respondents have furnished no satisfactory
explanation for that prolonged inaction. The
interim orders passed by this Court do not
explain the delay. The order dated 10.08.2023,
on which the learned Additional Advocate
General relies, stayed proceedings under
Section 64A in W.P. No. 16251/2023. It was
passed after the appointment of the Forest
Settlement Officer in December 2022 and after
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 322 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
the proclamation of July 2023. It cannot explain
or justify the absence of proceedings between
1924 and 2022.
72.19. Sri Kiran Ron submits that the reasonableness
of the period must be assessed by considering
the steps taken by the authorities, the nature of
the lands and the rights claimed by the
Petitioners. Those considerations have been
examined. The steps taken between 1920 and
1923 did not lead to completion of the statutory
process. No subsequent settlement proceedings
have been shown until the appointment of the
Forest Settlement Officer in December 2022.
The State cannot explain a delay of nearly a
century by referring to steps taken at the
commencement of the process and then relying
on interim orders passed only in 2023.
72.20. The learned Additional Advocate General also
relies on the public interest in protecting the
area. The ecological and public interest
considerations are relevant to the State’s
decision to protect forests and other natural
resources. They do not displace the
requirement that statutory powers be exercised
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 323 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
within a reasonable time and in accordance
with law. Public interest cannot convert an
abandoned proposal into a perpetual source of
authority. The decision in Sampangi Ramaiah
itself concerned the proposed constitution of a
reserved forest. Despite the public interest in
forest protection, the Division Bench of this
Court held that the State’s prolonged inaction,
considered with the subsequent grant of a
quarrying lease, established abandonment.
72.21. The question of abandonment must be
considered in light of the State’s conduct. The
primary finding under point (i) is that the
Government expressly dropped the proposal on
11.01.1924. This is not a case in which
abandonment is inferred solely from the
passage of time. The Government’s own order
brought the proposal to an end.
72.22. Even if that finding is set aside and the
Respondents’ interpretation of the 1924 order is
accepted, the subsequent conduct of the
Government remains relevant. The Revenue
Department auctioned land in Sy. No. 92 of
Achanahalli Village in September 1924. The
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 324 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Petitioners in W.P. No. 29690/2025 rely on
grants made by the State in Kadumane Village
between 1952 and 1961. The Respondents
themselves acknowledge that the Revenue
Department granted, auctioned or otherwise
dealt with lands in the area. These transactions
do not, by themselves, establish title or
determine whether the Revenue Department
was competent to deal with the lands.
72.23. Sri Kiran Ron submits that the Revenue
Department had no administrative control over
lands under the Forest Department and that the
auction and grants cannot bind the Forest
Department. He also points to the absence of
entries in the revenue records showing the
Forest Department’s name. These submissions
concern the authority of the Revenue
Department and the legal effect of its
transactions. They do not explain why the
statutory process under the Regulation was not
pursued for nearly a century.
72.24. The Respondents also rely on the mutation of
500 acres in Achanahalli Village in favour of the
Forest Department on 05.08.2013 and on
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 325 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
revenue records which, according to them,
show the Forest Department’s name in respect
of more than 6,400 acres. Those entries
evidence a later assertion of the Forest
Department’s claim over the lands covered by
the entries. They do not establish that the
statutory settlement process under the
Regulation was continued or completed. A
mutation or an entry in the Record of Rights is
not a substitute for the proclamation, inquiry,
adjudication and final notification prescribed by
the forest legislation. The Government Order
appointing the Forest Settlement Officer in
2022 is likewise a later step; it does not
retrospectively cure the prolonged failure to
pursue the statutory process within a
reasonable time.
72.25. The conclusion is therefore twofold. First, as
held under point (i), the Government expressly
dropped the proposal to constitute
Moorkangudda Block as a State Forest on
11.01.1924. Secondly, even if the notification
dated 05.02.1920 had survived that order, the
State’s failure to pursue the statutory process
for nearly a century, without any satisfactory
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 326 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
explanation, renders its belated reliance on the
notification legally unsustainable. The inaction,
viewed with the subsequent dealings with the
lands by Government authorities, establishes
abandonment of the proposal. A preliminary
notification cannot be kept in abeyance for an
indefinite period and acted upon after nearly a
century as though the statutory process had
remained alive. If the State now seeks to
constitute any land as a reserved forest, it must
proceed under the 1963 Act on the basis of a
fresh decision and the procedure prescribed
therein.
72.26. The objection that the Petitioners are
themselves guilty of delay, laches and
acquiescence is not sustainable. The Petitioners
do not challenge the validity of the notification
as it stood when issued in 1920. Their case is
that the Government withdrew the proposal in
1924 and that the Respondents cannot act upon
it after the lapse of nearly a century. The
immediate cause of action arose when the
Respondents began relying on the notification
to initiate proceedings, issue notices and take
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 327 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
coercive action between 2022 and 2025. The
petitions were filed in response to those steps.
72.27. The principle discussed in paragraph 30 of
Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District , with
reference to Dehri Rohtas Light Railway Co.
Ltd. v. District Board, Bhojpur , requires the
Court to consider whether the Petitioner
approached the Court before a parallel right
was created and whether the delay is
attributable to the Petitioner’s own negligence
or inaction. The Petitioners approached this
Court after the Respondents began acting upon
the 1920 notification. The long period during
which the State itself took no statutory step
cannot be attributed to the Petitioners. Their
challenge to the present reliance on the
notification is not barred by laches.
72.28. The effect of the Petitioners’ participation in
proceedings before the Forest Settlement
Officer, and whether any individual Petitioner is
precluded from raising a particular objection by
reason of such participation, is considered
under point (vii).
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 328 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
72.29. The third aspect concerns third-party rights.
The Petitioners rely on grants, sale deeds,
revenue entries, houses, agricultural activity,
resorts, licences and substantial investments
made over the years. Sri Kiran Ron disputes the
equities claimed by the Petitioners and submits
that they acquired their properties with notice
of the Forest Department’s claim and the
relevant revenue entries.
72.30. The creation of third-party rights and changes
in the nature and use of property are relevant
to the application of the rule of reasonable
time. Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District
recognises that transactions which have
attained finality and rights created in favour of
third parties cannot be unsettled by an
unexplained and belated exercise of statutory
power. Those considerations assume
significance in the present case.
72.31. This Court does not, under this point,
adjudicate the title or the enforceability of the
rights claimed by any individual Petitioner or
purchaser. Whether a particular grant, auction,
sale deed, revenue entry or other instrument
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 329 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
confers a legally enforceable right must be
determined on its own terms and under the
applicable law. The question whether a
purchaser acquired property with notice of the
Forest Department’s claim is also a matter to be
examined on the relevant evidence. Those
questions are considered under point (v). The
existence and extent of individual properties
within the notified boundaries are considered
under point (vi).
72.32. The finding on delay and abandonment does
not rest on the equities of any individual
purchaser. The State’s own order of 1924 and
its prolonged failure to pursue the statutory
process provide the basis for the conclusion.
The intervening transactions, changes in land
use and investments reinforce the prejudice
that would result from permitting the State to
act upon the proposal after such an
extraordinary lapse of time.
72.33. The public trust doctrine is an established
principle of law. In M.C. Mehta v. Kamal
Nath , the Hon’ble Supreme Court recognised
that the Government holds forests, rivers and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 330 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
other natural resources in trust for the public
and must protect them for public enjoyment.
The doctrine imposes a duty on the State; it
does not confer a statutory power which the
Legislature has withheld or permit the State to
act without authority of law.
72.34. Article 300A of the Constitution of India
provides:
“No person shall be deprived of his property save by
authority of law.”
72.35. The public trust doctrine and Article 300A must
operate together. The State must protect
natural resources, but it must do so by
exercising powers conferred by law and in
accordance with the procedure prescribed by
law. The duty to protect forests cannot justify
proceedings founded on a notification which
had been withdrawn or on a statutory proposal
left unattended for nearly a century. Equally,
this judgment does not release any land which
is otherwise established to be forest land from
the protection of the applicable law. The State
remains under a duty to protect such land
through lawful measures.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 331 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
72.36. This Court has considered the ecological
submissions advanced by Sri Kiran Ron. The
location of Moorkangudda in the Western Ghats,
the presence of shola forests and grasslands,
the biodiversity of the area and the role of its
streams and catchments are matters of public
importance. The learned Additional Advocate
General has himself accepted that species-
specific claims and the hydrological connections
of the streams must be assessed on wildlife
records and scientific material.
72.37. This Court makes no finding on the ecological
character of any particular parcel or on the
asserted hydrological connection with the
Yettinahole Integrated Drinking Water Project.
72.38. The ecological importance of the area does not
alter the legal conclusion on delay. It requires
the State to act promptly and lawfully to
protect any land established to be forest land.
It does not authorise the State to proceed on a
withdrawn or abandoned proposal.
72.39. The State remains free to take action under the
applicable forest legislation, including by
initiating proceedings under Section 4(1) of the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 332 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
1963 Act where the statutory conditions are
satisfied. Nothing in this judgment protects any
construction, clearing, felling or commercial
activity which is otherwise unlawful.
72.40. This Court answers Point No. (iv) by holding
that the Government dropped the proposal
contained in the notification dated 05.02.1920
to constitute Moorkangudda Block as a State
Forest by its order dated 11.01.1924. This is
the primary ground on which the Respondents
cannot rely upon that notification as a
continuing basis for proceedings against the
Petitioners.
72.41. In the alternative, even if the notification had
survived the Government order, the State’s
failure to pursue the statutory process for
nearly a century, without any satisfactory
explanation, constitutes unreasonable delay
and establishes abandonment of the proposal.
The subsequent appointment of the Forest
Settlement Officer and commencement of
proceedings in 2022 and 2023 do not cure that
delay. The State cannot act upon the 1920
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 333 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
notification after leaving the statutory process
unattended for such an extraordinary period.
72.42. The objections of delay, laches and
acquiescence raised against the Petitioners are
rejected. The State remains at liberty to take
fresh action in accordance with the 1963 Act
and other applicable law, upon satisfying the
statutory requirements.
73. Answer to Point No. (v): Whether the grants,
saguvali chits, registered instruments, revenue
entries, conversion orders, licences and other
permissions relied upon by the Petitioners
confer legally enforceable rights over the lands
in question, having regard to the applicable
forest legislation and the competence of the
authorities who issued them?
73.1. Sri Manmohan P.N., learned counsel for the
Petitioners, submits that the lands were granted
by the Revenue Department to the Petitioners’
predecessors-in-title. Those grants have not
been set aside by the competent authorities,
and the Forest Department cannot disregard
them or the revenue records maintained on
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 334 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
their basis. In some cases, the lands were
auctioned by the Revenue Department and
purchased by private individuals. The
purchasers thereafter obtained conversion of
the lands for non-agricultural purposes,
including the establishment of resorts, secured
the necessary licences and registrations, and
made substantial investments. Learned counsel
submits that the authorities failed to consider
these transactions, the rights arising from them
and the consequences of disturbing long-
standing possession before initiating the
impugned proceedings. He further submits that
several rights in favour of the Petitioners arose
after the notification of 1920 and, in particular,
after the Government withdrew the proposal in
1924.
73.2. Sri A.M. Vijay, learned counsel for the
Petitioners in W.P. No. 29690/2025, submits
that the State itself granted lands in Kadumane
Village between 1952 and 1961, some free of
cost and others at an upset price. The
Respondents ought to have considered those
grants and the rights flowing from them before
issuing the proclamation.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 335 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
73.3. Sri A.M. Vijay relies on Section 133 of the
Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964 (hereinafter,
“the KLR Act”), which provides:
“ 133. Presumption regarding entries in the
records.— An entry in the Record of Rights and a
certified entry in the Register of Mutations [or in the
patta book] shall be presumed to be true until the
contrary is proved or a new entry is lawfully
substituted therefor.”
73.4. He submits that this presumption applies to the
entries which have stood in the Petitioners’
names for several decades, in which no right of
the Government or the Forest Department is
recorded. The lands have also been assessed to
land revenue and taxes have been paid by the
Petitioners and their predecessors. He further
submits that phodi and durasthi proceedings
resulted in changes to the survey numbers and
that the Petitioners rely on grant certificates,
registered sale deeds and partition deeds as the
source of their respective rights.
73.5. Sri Kiran Ron, learned Additional Advocate
General, submits that, in W.P. No. 16251/2023,
the Petitioners claim land forming part of an
extent auctioned by the Revenue Department
notwithstanding the notification dated
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 336 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
05.02.1920. He points out that 536 acres 22
guntas in Achanahalli Village were subsequently
mutated in favour of the Forest Department on
05.08.2013. The absence of corresponding
entries in respect of the remaining extent, he
submits, does not extinguish the legal
consequences of the forest notification.
73.6. Sri Kiran Ron contends that the Revenue
Department could not treat land covered by the
forest notification as ordinary revenue land
without first ascertaining its legal status. He
relies on Section 2 of the Forest (Conservation)
Act, 1980, which restricts the use of forest land
for non-forest purposes and its assignment to
private persons without the prior approval of
the Central Government. He further submits
that revenue entries are maintained primarily
for fiscal and administrative purposes and
cannot conclusively determine the legal status
of land.
73.7. In the alternative, and without prejudice to
these submissions, Sri Kiran Ron submits that,
even if the auction is held to be valid, the right
derived from it extends to five acres only and
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 337 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
not to the entire extent of 14 acres 36 guntas
over which the resort has been developed.
73.8. For all the petitions, Sri Kiran Ron relies on
Section 6 of the Regulation and Section 6 of the
1963 Act. He submits that, after publication of
the notification under Section 4, rights cannot
be acquired in the notified lands except in the
manner permitted by the applicable provision.
Claims based on subsequent grants and
transfers must therefore be examined in the
light of those restrictions and cannot be
accepted merely because they are reflected in
revenue records.
73.9. He further contends that the Revenue
Department had no administrative control over
lands under the control of the Forest
Department and was not competent to grant or
otherwise dispose of them. A transaction by an
authority lacking competence does not create
an indefeasible right against the State merely
because it is followed by possession or reflected
in revenue records. In several instances,
according to him, the Revenue Department
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 338 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
dealt with lands claimed by the Forest
Department without obtaining its concurrence.
73.10. Sri Kiran Ron also relies on the entries showing
the Forest Department’s name in Columns 9 or
11 of the Records of Rights, Tenancy and Crops
(RTCs) relating to more than 6,400 acres. He
submits that the Petitioners have not
established the source of their title or traced
the chain of devolution through successive
holders. A purchaser cannot acquire a better
title than that held by the transferor. The State,
he submits, is not bound by grants, permissions
or revenue entries which are contrary to law or
made by authorities lacking competence. The
Petitioners cannot claim an enforceable right or
equity merely from acts of public authorities
which were beyond their powers.
73.11. Sri Kiran Ron relies on State of Karnataka v.
I.S. Nirvane Gowda [(2007) 15 SCC 744],
particularly paragraph 4, to submit that, once
land is included in a reserved forest, revenue
entries are of no consequence, saguvali chits do
not confer title, and the Revenue Authorities
are not competent to deal with such land.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 339 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
73.12. He also relies on Prabhagiya Van Adhikari
Awadh Van Prabhag v. Arun Kumar
Bhardwaj [(2021) 18 SCC 104], particularly
paragraphs 24 and 28, to submit that, while a
preliminary notification remains in force, rights
cannot be acquired except through a written
contract made by or on behalf of the
Government, and a lessee cannot claim rights
merely on the basis of a revenue entry without
a written agreement executed by a competent
authority.
73.13. Sri Kiran Ron further relies on Girish H.E. v.
State of Karnataka [2013 SCC OnLine Kar
10537], particularly paragraph 19, concerning
the effect of Section 6 of the 1963 Act on
grants made after publication of a notification
under Section 4. He also relies on Jit Ram Shiv
Kumar v. State of Haryana [(1981) 1 SCC
11], particularly paragraph 51, for the
proposition that there can be no promissory
estoppel against the exercise of legislative
power or against the Government discharging
its statutory duties. The Government, he
submits, is not bound by acts of officers who
acted beyond the scope of their authority.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 340 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
73.14. Lastly, he relies on Section 2 of the 1980 Act
and contends that certain diversions and grants
made after its commencement were effected
without the prior approval of the Central
Government.
73.15. This point does not require the Court to declare
the title of any Petitioner. The title to each
property depends on the documents relied
upon, the authority of the person who made the
original grant, the extent of the land granted
and the subsequent chain of transactions.
Those matters cannot be finally determined in
these writ petitions on the basis of affidavits,
particularly when the documents and the rights
of persons who are not parties may also be
involved.
73.16. The question for determination is whether the
forest legislation or any want of competence
established on the present record renders the
documents relied upon by the Petitioners legally
ineffective. The answer requires examination of
the statutory restrictions, the decisions relied
upon by the Respondents, and the legal effect
of each category of document.
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 341 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
73.17. The Respondents rely on Section 6(1) of the
Regulation to contend that no rights could be
acquired in the notified area after publication of
the notification under Section 4. The relevant
portion of Section 6(1), reads:
“(1) During the interval between the publication of
such proclamation and the date fixed by the
notification declaring the forest to be a State Forest
as hereinafter provided, no right shall be acquired in
or over the land comprised in such notification,
except by succession, or under a grant or contract
in writing made or entered into by, or on behalf of,
the Government or some person in whom such
right, or power to create such right, was vested
when the proclamation was published; … No right of
occupancy shall, without the previous sanction of
the Government, be granted in respect of such land,
and every right of occupancy granted without such
sanction shall be null and void.”
73.18. The language of Section 6(1) is clear. The
prohibition on the acquisition of rights does not
commence merely upon publication of the
notification under Section 4. It operates during
the interval between publication of the
proclamation under Section 5 and the date
fixed by the final notification declaring the
forest to be a State Forest. The provision also
recognises exceptions for acquisition of rights
by succession and under a written grant or
contract made by or on behalf of the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 342 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Government, or by a person vested with the
power to create such rights when the
proclamation was published. A right of
occupancy, however, cannot be granted without
the previous sanction of the Government.
73.19. The Respondents have not produced a
proclamation under Section 5 of the Regulation
in respect of Moorkangudda Block. The burden
of establishing the statutory bar rests on the
Respondents, who rely upon it to defeat the
rights claimed by the Petitioners. In the
absence of proof of the event which attracts
Section 6(1), that provision cannot be invoked
to invalidate the grants and transactions relied
upon by the Petitioners.
73.20. There is a further and decisive consideration.
The Government withdrew the proposal to
constitute Moorkangudda Block as a State
Forest by its order dated 11.01.1924. As held
under point (i), the proposal did not remain
alive thereafter. The statutory process initiated
by the proposal thus came to an end. The
restrictions attached to that process cannot be
treated as continuing indefinitely after the
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 343 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Government itself had abandoned it. The
auction in Achanahalli Village took place in
September 1924, after the Government order
of 11.01.1924. The grants relied upon in
Kadumane Village were made between 1952
and 1961. Neither category of transaction is
rendered invalid by Section 6(1) of the
Regulation on the basis of the withdrawn
proposal.
73.21. Section 6(1) of the 1963 Act provides that,
after publication of a notification under Section
4, no right shall be acquired in or over the land
comprised in such notification, except by
succession or under a grant or contract in
writing made by or on behalf of the
Government or a person vested with the power
to create such right. The provision also requires
the previous sanction of the State Government
for the grant of a right of occupancy.
73.22. The restriction under the 1963 Act therefore
depends upon the issue of a notification under
Section 4 of that Act. No such notification has
been issued in respect of Moorkangudda Block.
Nor was the notification dated 05.02.1920
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 344 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
carried into the 1963 Act by Section 117, as
held under point (iii). Section 6 of the 1963 Act
is consequently not attracted to the Petitioners’
lands on the basis of the 1920 notification.
73.23. The decision in Girish H.E ., particularly
paragraph 19, concerns rights in land covered
by a notification under Section 4 of the 1963
Act. It recognises the restrictions imposed by
Section 6 and also the exceptions which that
provision permits. It does not support the
application of Section 6 to lands which are not
covered by a subsisting notification under that
Act.
73.24. The Respondents’ reliance on I.S. Nirvane
Gowda must be considered in its factual and
legal context. In that case, the trial court and
the first appellate court had, on the evidence,
found that the lands formed part of a reserved
forest. The Hon’ble Supreme Court held:
“When the lands were included in reserve forest, the
entries in the revenue records were of no
consequence and further, mere saguvali chits did
not confer any title on the suit lands. This apart, the
Revenue Authorities were not competent to deal
with the property which was the part of the
reserved forest.”
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 345 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
73.25. The principle laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court is that once land is duly established to
form part of a reserved forest, revenue entries
and saguvali chits cannot override that status,
and the Revenue Authorities cannot deal with
the land contrary to the forest legislation.
73.26. The decision does not apply to the present case
in the manner suggested by the Respondents.
Under point (ii), this Court has held that
Moorkangudda Block was never constituted a
State Forest under the Regulation and did not
acquire the status of a reserved forest under
the 1963 Act. The Respondents cannot
therefore invoke I.S. Nirvane Gowda on the
assumption that the Petitioners’ lands form part
of a reserved forest. Whether any parcel is
forest land on an independent basis, including
under the 1980 Act, remains open.
73.27. The Respondents’ further submission that the
Revenue Department lacked competence to
deal with the lands presupposes that the
relevant lands were under the control of the
Forest Department or had otherwise been
placed beyond the authority of the Revenue
Digitally Signed By:
SURAJ GOVINDA RAJ
17/11/2026, 18:00, Bengaluru
Verified
- 346 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63685
WP No. 29656 of 2024
C/W WP No. 16251 of 2023
WP No. 19980 of 2023
AND 3 OTHERS
CNR: KAHC010629462024
Department under a subsisting statutory
provision. The withdrawn notification of 1920
does not establish that proposition. The Forest
Department’s revenue entries must be
examined on their own evidentiary basis, as
considered below. The competence of the
authority which issued any particular grant
must also be assessed with reference to the
relevant grant, the extent and identity of the
land, and the law in force on the date of the
grant.
73.28. In Prabhagiya Van Adhikari Awadh Van
Prabhag v. Arun Kumar Bhardwaj , the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held in paragraph 24
that, even in the absence of a final notification,
“by virtue of Section 5 of the Forest Act, there