Iffco Tokio General Insurance Co Ltd vs Sher Singh And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH AT CHANDIGARH AT CHANDIGARH AT CHANDIGARH
Reserved on : 01.10.2026 Reserved on : 01.10.2026 Reserved on : 01.10.2026 Reserved on : 01.10.2026
Pronounced on : Pronounced on : 12.11.2026 Pronounced on : Pronounced on : 12.11.2026 12.11.2026 12.11.2026
Uploaded on : Uploaded on : 17.11.2026 Uploaded on : Uploaded on :
(I) (I) (I) (I) FAO FAO-9209 FAO FAO 9209 9209-2014 (O&M) 9209 2014 (O&M) 2014 (O&M) 2014 (O&M)
Lakhmiri Devi
…Appellant
Versus
Rajender Singh and another ...Respondents
(II) (II) (II) (II) FAO FAO-1831 FAO FAO 1831 1831-2012 (O&M) 1831 2012 (O&M) 2012 (O&M) 2012 (O&M)
with XOBJ with XOBJ-202 with XOBJ with XOBJ 202 202-CII 202 CII CII-2014 CII 2014 2014 2014
Iffco Tokio General Insurance Company Ltd.
…Appellant
Versus
Sher Singh and others ...Respondents
CORAM: CORAM: HON’BLE M CORAM: CORAM: HON’BLE M HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN HON’BLE M JUSTICE HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN JUSTICE HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN JUSTICE HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN
Present: Mr. Vikas Kumar, Advocate,
for the claimant-appellant in FAO-9209-2014
and for respondent Nos.1 to 3-Cross-objectors,
in FAO-1831-2012.
Mr. Abhimanyu Batra, Advocate,
for the Insurance Company-appellant in FAO-1831-2012
and for respondent No.2 in FAO-9209-2014.
None for the owner-respondent No.1 in FAO-9209-2014
and respondent No.4 in FAO-1831, despite service.
HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN, J. HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN , J.
HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN , J. , J.
CM CM-25588 CM CM 25588 25588-CII 25588 CII CII-2014 CII 2014 2014 in FAO 2014 in FAO in FAO-9209 in FAO 9209 9209-2014 9209 2014 2014 2014
Prayer in the application is for condonation of 945 days’
delay in filing the appeal.
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
1
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
Notice of the application was issued to the non-
applicant/respondents way back on 21.04.2015, however, despite due
service, no reply has been filed on their behalf.
In view of the above and for the reasons mentioned in the
application, same is allowed as prayed for.
Consequently, delay of 945 days in filing the appeal is
condoned.
Main case(s) Main case(s) Main case(s) Main case(s)
1. The aforesaid appeals and the cross-objections have been
filed impugning a common Award dated 14.12.2011, passed by the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Palwal (hereinafter referred to as ‘the
Tribunal’), as such, these are being decided by this common order.
2. Relevant facts in brief are claimant-Lakhmiri Devi (FAO-
9209-2014) filed claim petition under Section 163-A of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, ‘the Act’), claiming compensation
regarding the death of his son-Manoj Kumar, in a motor vehicle
accident against the owner-Rajender Singh and the insurer of the
motorcycle bearing registration No.HR-99CJ-Temp-8415 (for short,
‘the motorcycle’); whereas, claimant/cross-objectors Sher Singh and
others (FAO-1831-2012) filed a separate claim petition regarding the
death of Arun Kumar in the same accident, involving the aforesaid
motorcycle.
2.1 Both the claim petitions were filed under Section 163-A of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, ‘the Act’), alleging therein
that on 22.11.2010 at about 6.00 p.m., Manoj Kumar and Arun Kumar
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
2
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
(both since deceased) were travelling on the motorcycle, which is
owned by their cousin-Rajender Singh. When they reached near
Village Mitrol, they were hit by an unknown vehicle, which was being
driven by its driver in a rash and negligent manner. At that time, the
motorcycle was being driven by Arun Kumar, whereas Manoj Kumar
was riding pillion. After the accident, Highway Ambulance picked up
both the injured for being taken to General Hospital, Palwal, however,
both of them died on account of the injuries suffered by them in the
said accident. FIR No.465 dated 23.11.2010, under Sections 279, 304-
A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, was registered at Police Station, City
Palwal. The claim petitions were filed against the owner and insurer of
the motorcycle being driven by the deceased at the time of the accident.
2.2 Respondent No.1-owner of the motorcycle admitted the
death of the deceased in the accident in question; the ownership of the
motorcycle was also admitted; and it was alleged that the vehicle is
insured with respondent No.2-Insurance Company.
2.3 The Insurance Company took the plea that the insured has
violated the terms & conditions of the insurance policy by giving the
vehicle to a third person; the accident was denied, however, it was
admitted that the motorcycle was insured with the Insurance Company.
2.4 The claim petition filed by Lakhmiri Devi was allowed by
the Tribunal and a sum of Rs.3,10,000 was awarded as compensation
regarding the death of Manoj Kumar, who was the pillion-rider on the
motorcycle while holding that the petition filed under Section 163-A of
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
3
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
the Act was maintainable by the legal heirs of the deceased, who was
riding pillion.
2.5 The claim petition filed on behalf of Sher Singh and other
was allowed, however, compensation was awarded only to the tune of
Rs.1,00,000/- while holding that since Arun Kumar was driving the
motorcycle at the time of the accident, as such he stepped into the shoes
of the registered owner and is only entitled to Rs.1,00,000/- under the
contract as per the terms of the policy.
2.6 Feeling aggrieved by the Award of compensation of
Rs.1,00,000/- regarding the death of Arun Kumar, the Insurance
Company has filed FAO No.1831-2012; whereas the claimants Sher
Singh and others have filed Cross Objections No.202-CII-2014,
seeking enhancement of compensation.
2.7 The claimant-appellant, Lakhmiri Devi has filed FAO-
9209-2014 for enhancement of compensation awarded by the Tribunal
regarding the death of Manoj Kumar.
(I) (I) (I) (I) FAO FAO-9209 FAO FAO 9209 9209-2014 (compensation regarding death of pillion 9209 2014 (compensation regarding death of pillion 2014 (compensation regarding death of pillion- 2014 (compensation regarding death of pillion
rider, Manoj Kumar rider, Manoj Kumar). rider, Manoj Kumar rider, Manoj Kumar
3. Learned counsel for the claimant-appellant contends that
proper compensation has not been awarded by the Tribunal.
4. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent-Insurance
Company contends that the compensation has been rightly awarded by
the Tribunal and there is no scope for enhancement.
5. I have considered the aforesaid submissions.
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
4
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
6. The Tribunal has assessed the income of the deceased as
Rs.3,000/- per month; and as per the postmortem report, the age has
been considered as 25 years. Consequently, the multiplier of 17 was
applied. While deducting 50% towards personal expenses, the Tribunal
has calculated the compensation as under:-
i) Monthly notional income of Manoj Kumar
Rs.3,000/-
at the time of his death
ii) Annual income comes to Rs.3,000 x 12
iii) Out of this amount, 50% amount is to be
Rs.18,000/-
deducted from the annual income of the
deceased being bachelor as per ratio of law
laid down in Sarla Verma Versus Delhi Sarla Verma Versus Delhi Sarla Verma Versus Delhi Sarla Verma Versus Delhi
Transport Corporation 2009 (3) RCR Transport Corporation 2009 (3) RCR Transport Corporation 2009 (3) RCR Transport Corporation 2009 (3) RCR
(Civil) 77 (Civil) 77. (Civil) 77 (Civil) 77
iv) For the purpose of compensation to the
Rs.18,000/-
legal heirs
v) Multiplier is to be adopted in accordance
‘17’
with age of deceased who was aged about
25 years at the time of his death in the
accident as per postmortem report Ex. P-7
vi) Compensation comes to Rs.18000x17
=Rs.3,06,000/-
vii Expenditure incurred on transportation and
Rs.4,000/-
cremation of deceased Manoj Kumar
Total amount of compensation comes to Rs.3,10,000/-
7. As per the Second Schedule under Section
163-A of the Act, there is no error in calculation of compensation as
Rs.3,06,000/- assessed by the Tribunal; however, the compensation
awarded towards funeral expenses and transportation needs to be
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
5
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
enhanced. In view of the Second Schedule under Section 163-A of the
Act, the appellant is entitled to compensation of a sum of Rs.2,500/-
regarding loss of estate and Rs.2,000/- for funeral expenses. The
petitioner being mother, is also entitled to compensation on account of
loss of consortium (parental) of Rs.5,000/- provided under the Schedule
and in terms of the law laid down by Hon’ble the Apex Court in
Magma General Insurance Company Limited Magma General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Nanu Ram alias Magma General Insurance Company Limited Magma General Insurance Company Limited s. Nanu Ram alias s. Nanu Ram alias s. Nanu Ram alias
Chuhru Ram and Others, (2018) 18 SCC 13 Chuhru Ram and Others, (2018) 18 SCC 13, Chuhru Ram and Others, (2018) 18 SCC 13 Chuhru Ram and Others, (2018) 18 SCC 13 wherein, it has been held
that the parents are also entitled to compensation towards ‘loss of
consortium’. As such, the total compensation is calculated as
Rs.3,06,000 + Rs.9,500/- = Rs.3,15,500/-.
8. With the modification in the impugned award to the extent
indicated above, the appeal (FAO FAO FAO-9209 FAO 9209 9209-2014 9209 2014 2014) is partly allowed. 2014
9. The enhanced amount of compensation, along with
interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of filing the appeal,
till its realization, shall be paid to the claimants in terms of the decision
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Parminder Singh vs. Hon Parminder Singh vs. Honey Goyal & Parminder Singh vs. Hon Parminder Singh vs. Hon ey Goyal & ey Goyal & ey Goyal &
Ors., 2025 INSC 361 Ors., 2025 INSC 361. Ors., 2025 INSC 361 Ors., 2025 INSC 361
10. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of
accordingly.
(II) (II) (II) (II) FAO FAO-1831 FAO FAO 1831 1831-201 1831 201 2012 & XOBJ 201 2 & XOBJ 2 & XOBJ-202 2 & XOBJ 202 202-CII 202 CII CII-2014 CII 2014 2014 (compensation 2014 (compensation (compensation (compensation
regarding death of regarding death of driver regarding death of regarding death of driver driver, , , , Arun driver Arun Arun Kumar Arun Kumar Kumar). Kumar
11. Learned counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company
contends that the findings of the Tribunal are erroneous; on one hand,
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
6
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
the Tribunal has observed that Arun Kumar was cousin of Rajender
Singh-respondent (owner of the motorcycle) and the deceased had
stepped into the shows of the owner; as such petition under Section
163-A of the Act is not maintainable, but on the other hand, the
Tribunal has awarded compensation amounting to Rs.1,00,000/- to the
claimants. It is well settled that under Section 163-A of the Act, the
owner of the vehicle and the person who steps into the shoes of the
owner, cannot claim compensation.
12. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent Nos.1 to
3/claimant-cross-objectors seeks enhancement of compensation and
contends that the driver cannot be treated as borrower of the vehicle in
the absence of any evidence and claim under Section 163-A is
maintainable for compensation by legal heirs. Reliance has been
placed on Manju Devi Vs. Rajesh Kumar, 2023 Law Finder (P&H) Manju Devi Vs. Rajesh Kumar, 2023 Law Finder (P&H) Manju Devi Vs. Rajesh Kumar, 2023 Law Finder (P&H) Manju Devi Vs. Rajesh Kumar, 2023 Law Finder (P&H)
11384 11384. 11384 11384
13. I have considered the aforesaid submissions.
14. The Tribunal has observed that Arun Kumar had stepped
into the shoes of the registered owner and as per the contract, i.e.
Insurance Policy (Ex.P-3), the Insurance Company is liable to pay the
owner a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- due to the death of Arun Kumar, who had
stepped into the shoes of the owner. The relevant findings of the
Tribunal are as under:-
“16. Now the next question comes that what is the liability of
respondent no.2 qua the petitioners of Petition (RBT) No. 238 of
2011 titled Sher Singh etc. Versus Rejender Singh etc. on account of
ATUL SETHI
death of Arun Kumar who stepped into the shoes of registered
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
7
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
owner. For this purpose, it is necessary to examine the contents of
the policy Ex.P-3. As per the policy, the respondent no. 2 was liable
to pay owner upto extent of Rs. 1 lac in case of death under a
contract. In case titled Oriental Insurance Company Lim Oriental Insurance Company Lim Oriental Insurance Company Limited Versus Oriental Insurance Company Lim ited Versus ited Versus ited Versus
Rajni Devi and others 2008 (4) RCR (Civil) 905, Rajni Devi and others 2008 (4) RCR (Civil) 905, it was held by the Rajni Devi and others 2008 (4) RCR (Civil) 905, Rajni Devi and others 2008 (4) RCR (Civil) 905,
Hon’ble Supreme Court that under section 163-A of the Motor
Vehicles Act, the owner of the vehicle as a person cannot be both, a
claimant as also a recipient. For the said purpose, the only terms of
the contract of insurance could be taken recourse to. Relying upon
this authority, out Hon’ble High Court in case titled ICICI Lombard ICICI Lombard ICICI Lombard ICICI Lombard
General Insurance Company Limited Versus Jagdish (P&H) held General Insurance Company Limited Versus Jagdish (P&H) General Insurance Company Limited Versus Jagdish (P&H) General Insurance Company Limited Versus Jagdish (P&H)
that under the Motor Vehicles Act, the owner of the vehicle cannot
claim compensation for himself but the Hon’ble Supreme Court
further held that the parties would be governed by the terms of their
policy.
17. In view of the above ratio of law, the legal heirs of Arun
Kumar who was driving the motor-cycle bearing temporary
registration No.HR-99CJ-8115, chassis No.MBLHAIOAHAGK
15793 and Engine No.HAIOEDAGK 11137 and now permanent
number No. HR-50B-6398, are entitled to receive the compensation
from the respondent no. 2 to the tune of Rs.1 lac under a contract.”
15. The findings of the Tribunal require no interference since
as per the insurance policy (Ex.P-3), there is a contract for payment of
Rs.1,00,000/- in case of death of the owner.
16. A controversy similar to the present one has been dealt
with by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Ram Khiladi & Anr. Vs. The Ram Khiladi & Anr. Vs. The Ram Khiladi & Anr. Vs. The Ram Khiladi & Anr. Vs. The
United India Insurance Company & Anr., (2020) 2 SCC 550. United India Insurance Company & Anr., (2020) 2 SCC 550 United India Insurance Company & Anr., (2020) 2 SCC 550 United India Insurance Company & Anr., (2020) 2 SCC 550 In the
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
8
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
said case, the legal representatives of the deceased filed a claim petition
under Section 163-A of the Act against the owner and insurer of the
motorcycle on which he was travelling. Neither the driver, nor the
owner/insurer of the other vehicle, which was involved in the accident,
was made a party. The Hon’ble Apex Court held that a claim under
Section 163-A of the Act for use of the vehicle is not maintainable
since the deceased stepped into the shoes of the owner, however, at the
same time, as per the contract of insurance, the Insurance Company
shall be liable to pay compensation to a third-party and not to the owner
and in that case, on the basis of contract of insurance, it was held that
the legal representatives are entitled to compensation to the extent of
Rs.1,00,000/-. The relevant observations of the Hon’ble Apex Court
are as under:-
“5.4 An identical question came to be considered by this Court in
the case of Ningamma (supra). In that case, the deceased was
driving a motorcycle which was borrowed from its real owner and
met with an accident by dashing against a bullock cart i.e. without
involving any other vehicle. The claim petition was filed under
Section 163A of the Act by the legal representatives of the deceased
against the real owner of the motorcycle which was being driven by
the deceased. To that, this Court has observed and held that since
the deceased has stepped into the shoes of the owner of the vehicle,
Section 163A of the Act cannot apply wherein the owner of the
vehicle himself is involved. Consequently, it was held that the legal
representatives of the deceased could not have claimed the
compensation under Section 163A of the Act. Therefore, as such, in
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
9
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
the present case, the claimants could have even claimed
the compensation and/or filed the claim petition under Section 163A
of the Act against the driver, owner and insurance company of the
offending vehicle i.e. motorcycle bearing registration No. RJ-29-
2M-9223, being a third party with respect to the offending vehicle.
However, no claim under Section 163A was filed against the driver,
owner and/or insurance company of the motorcycle bearing
registration No. RJ-29-2M-9223. It is an admitted position that the
claim under Section 163A of the Act was only against the owner and
the insurance company of the motorcycle bearing registration No.
RJ-02-SA-7811 which was borrowed by the deceased from the
opponentowner Bhagwan Sahay. Therefore, applying the law laid
down by this Court in the case of Ningamma (supra), and as the
deceased has stepped into the shoes of the owner of the vehicle
bearing registration No. RJ-02-SA-7811, as rightly held by the High
Court, the claim petition under Section 163A of the Act against the
owner and insurance company of the vehicle bearing registration
No. RJ-02-SA-7811shall not be maintainable.
5.5 It is true that, in a claim under Section 163A of the Act, there is
no need for the claimants to plead or establish the negligence and/or
that the death in respect of which the claim petition is sought to be
established was due to wrongful act, neglect or default of the owner
of the vehicle concerned. It is also true that the claim petition under
Section 163A of the Act is based on the principle of no fault
liability. However, at the same time, the deceased has to be a third
party and cannot maintain a claim under Section 163A of the Act
against the owner/insurer of the vehicle which is borrowed by him
as he will be in the shoes of the owner and he cannot maintain a
claim under Section 163A of the Act against the owner and insurer
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
10
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
of the vehicle bearing registration No. RJ-02-SA-7811. In the
present case, the parties are governed by the contract of insurance
and under the contract of insurance the liability of the insurance
company would be qua third party only. In the present case, as
observed hereinabove, the deceased cannot be said to be a third
party with respect to the insured vehicle bearing registration No. RJ-
02-SA-7811. There cannot be any dispute that the liability of the
insurance company would be as per the terms and conditions of the
contract of insurance. As held by this Court in the case of Dhanraj
(supra), an insurance policy covers the liability incurred by the
insured in respect of death of or bodily injury to any person
(including an owner of the goods or his authorized representative)
carried in the vehicle or damage to any property of a third party
caused by or arising out of the use of the vehicle. In the said
decision, it is further held by this Court that Section 147 does not
require an insurance company to assume risk for death or bodily
injury to the owner of the vehicle.
5.6 In view of the above and for the reasons stated above, in the
present case, as the claim under Section 163A of the Act was made
only against the owner and insurance company of the vehicle which
was being driven by the deceased himself as borrower of the vehicle
from the owner of the vehicle and he would be in the shoes of the
owner, the High Court has rightly observed and held that such a
claim was not maintainable and the claimants ought to have joined
and/or ought to have made the claim under Section 163A of the Act
against the driver, owner and/or the insurance company of the
offending vehicle i.e. RJ-29-2M-9223 being a third party to the said
vehicle.
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
11
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
5.7 Now, so far as the reliance placed upon by the
learned Advocate for the claimants on the decision of this Court in
the case of Naveen Kumar (supra), on considering the issue involved
in that decision, we are of the opinion that the said decision shall not
be applicable to the facts of the case on hand and/or the same shall
not be of any assistance to the claimants. In that case, the issue was
as to who could be said to be the registered owner of the vehicle and
the liability of the owner who sold the vehicle, but his name
continued to be as the owner with the registering authority. To that,
it was held that the person in whose name the motor vehicle stands
registered is the owner of the vehicle for the purpose of the Act.
5.8 However, at the same time, even as per the contract
of insurance, in case of personal accident the ownerdriver is entitled
to a sum of Rs.1 lakh. Therefore, the deceased, as observed
hereinabove, who would be in the shoes of the owner shall be
entitled to a sum of Rs.1 lakh, even as per the contract
of insurance. However, it is the case on behalf of the
original claimants that there is an amendment to the 2nd Schedule
and a fixed amount of Rs.5 lakh has been specified in case of death
and therefore the claimants shall be entitled to Rs.5 lakh. The same
cannot be accepted. In the present case, the accident took place in
the year 2006 and even the Judgment and Award was passed by the
learned Tribunal in the year 2009, and the impugned Judgment and
Order has been passed by the High Court in 10.05.2018, i.e. much
prior to the amendment in the 2nd Schedule. In the facts and
circumstance of the present case, the claimants shall not be entitled
to the benefit of the amendment to the 2nd Schedule. At the same
time, as observed hereinabove, the claimants shall be entitled to Rs.1
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
12
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
lakh as per the terms of the contract of insurance, the driver being in
the shoes of the owner of the vehicle.
5.9 Now, so far as the submission made on behalf of the claimants
that in a claim under Section 163A of the Act mere use of the
vehicle is enough and despite the compensation claimed by the heirs
of the owner of the motorcycle which was involved in the accident
resulting in his death, the claim under Section 163A of the Act
would be maintainable is concerned, in view of the decision of this
Court in Rajni Devi (supra), the aforesaid cannot be accepted. In
Rajni Devi (supra), it has been specifically observed and held that
the provisions of Section 163A of the Act cannot be said to have any
application with regard to an accident wherein the owner of the
motor vehicle himself is involved. After considering the decisions
of this Court in the cases of Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. V. Jhuma
Saha (2007) 9 SCC 263; Dhanraj (supra); National Insurance Co.
Ltd. V. Laxmi Narain Dhut (2007) 3 SCC 700 and Premkumari v.
Prahlad Dev (2008) 3 SCC 193, it is ultimately concluded by this
Court that the liability under Section 163A of the Act is on the
owner of the vehicle as a person cannot be both, a claimant as also a
recipient and, therefore, the heirs of the owner could not have
maintained the claim in terms of Section 163A of the Act. It is
further observed that, for the said purpose, only the terms of the
contract of insurance could be taken recourse to. In the recent
decision of this Court in the case of Ashalata Bhowmik (supra), it
is specifically held by this Court that the parties shall be governed
by the terms and conditions of the contract of insurance. Therefore,
as per the contract of insurance, the insurance company shall be
liable to pay the compensation to a third party and not to the
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
13
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
owner, except to the extent of Rs.1 lakh as observed
hereinabove.”
(Emphasis supplied)
17. The Tribunal has not passed the Award under Section 163-
A of the Act, which has been rightly done in view of the facts &
circumstances of this case and the ratio of the aforesaid decision in
Ramkhiladi (supra) Ramkhiladi (supra). Ramkhiladi (supra) Ramkhiladi (supra)
18. The Tribunal has awarded compensation on the basis of
Personal Accident cover for owner & driver of the contract as per
insurance policy in question. Learned counsel for the Insurance
Company could not dispute that as per the terms and conditions of the
policy, the insurer is liable to pay compensation for bodily injury/death
sustained by the Owner-Driver of the vehicle caused due to the use of
the vehicle insured or whilst mounting into/dismounting from or
traveling in the insured vehicle as a co-driver. The claimant, while
driving the motorcycle, had stepped into the shoes of the owner, as
such, he would be covered under the term – ‘owner-driver’ for all
intents and purposes, including for grant of compensation under the
personal accident cover as has been held by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Ramkhiladi (supra) Ramkhiladi (supra) Ramkhiladi (supra) Ramkhiladi (supra) . As such, the case of the claimant cannot be
rejected merely only on the ground that the policy does not cover the
unnamed driver. Hence, the argument raised on behalf of the Insurance
Company has no merits.
19. The decision relied upon by learned counsel for the
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23 Insurance Company in Manju Devi (supra) Manju Devi (supra) Manju Devi (supra) Manju Devi (supra) is distinguishable on facts
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
14
FAO-9209-2014 (O&M) with
FAO-1831-2012 with XOBJ-202-CII-2014 (O&M)
as in the said case, it was noticed that the Insurance Company has only
taken a plea in the written statement that the vehicle was being used as
commercial vehicle, i.e. on hire & reward basis and there were no
pleadings that the deceased was a borrower.
20. In view of the above, the appeal filed on behalf of the
Insurance Company (FAO FAO FAO-1831 FAO 1831 1831-201 1831 201 2012) 201 2) 2) is liable to be dismissed. 2)
21. In view of the facts and circumstances of this case and the
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Ramkhiladi (supra) Ramkhiladi (supra) Ramkhiladi (supra) Ramkhiladi (supra) , the
claimant-cross-objectors are not entitled to grant of any compensation
under Section 163-A of the Act, as such, the cross-objections
(XOBJ (XOBJ-202 (XOBJ (XOBJ 202 202-CII 202 CII CII-2014) CII 2014) 2014) are also liable to be dismissed. 2014)
22. Ordered accordingly.
23. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
12.11.2026 12.11.2026 12.11.2026 12.11.2026 [HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN] [HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN] [HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN] [HARPREET KAUR JEEWAN]
Atul Sethi Atul Sethi
Atul Sethi Atul Sethi JUDGE JUDGE JUDGE JUDGE
Whether speaking / reasoned : Yes No
Whether Reportable : Yes No
ATUL SETHI
2026.11.17 16:23
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
15