Ashwini Mahesh Oza vs The State Of Maharashtra And Ors
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM010578192026
1 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO.6137 OF 2026
Ashwini Mahesh Oza .... Petitioner
versus
The State of Maharashtra & Ors. .... Respondents
…....
•
Mr. Tanoj Joshi a/w Ms. Shivani Gautam a/w Mr. Sumit Pal,
Advocate for Petitioner.
•
Mr. D. K. Singh, Advocate for Intervenor(for informant).
•
Ms. M. M. Deshmukh, APP for the State/Respondent.
CORAM : SARANG V. KOTWAL &
RANJITSINHA RAJA BHONSALE, JJ.
th
DATE : 18 NOVEMBER, 2026
JUDGMENT : (PER : SARANG V. KOTWAL, J.)
1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith with consent of
the parties.
2. The Petition is filed with a grievance that the
Petitioner's continued detention in connection with CR No.491
MANUSHREE
NESARIKAR
of 2026 registered at Achole Police Station is illegal. The main
Digitally signed by
MANUSHREE
NESARIKAR
Date: 2026.11.20
15:41:15 +0530
contention is that the Petitioner was produced after more than
Nesarikar
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
2 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
24 hours from her arrest. Therefore, there is violation of Article
22(2) of the Constitution and Section 58 of the BNSS..
3. Heard Mr. Tanoj Joshi, learned Counsel for the
Petitioner, Mr. D. K. Singh, learned counsel for the Intervenor
and Ms. M. M. Deshmukh, learned APP for the State.
4. The FIR, i.e. CR No.491 of 2026, dated 04/10/2026,
under Sections 318(4), 316(2), 335, 336(2), 336(3), 338 and
3(5) of the BNS, was lodged by one Uday Pratap Chandrabhan
Singh. The gist of the FIR is that, between 26/02/2024 and
05/05/2026, the Petitioner and one Mohammad Naseem
Hashmi, in collusion with each other, sold Flat No.A/1004, Nero
Building, Bandra East, to the informant, though it was already
sold to another person. The flat was sold to the informant for a
price of Rs.2 crores. Out of the said amount, Rs.88,39,500/- was
taken from the informant. Possession was not given. The
informant took out search report and found that the said flat
was already sold to Amruta Saxena and Rohit Mistry. The
informant demanded back his amount. Thereafter, the Petitioner
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
3 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
and the co-accused returned only Rs.5 lakhs and caused a loss of
Rs.83,39,500/- to the informant. On these allegations the FIR
was lodged.
5. The grievance of the Petitioner is that, in this
connection, she was taken into custody from her house at
Kanjurmarg at 1:05 PM on 03/11/2026. She was produced
before the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Vasai, on 04/11/2026
at 3:05 PM. Hence, she was produced beyond the statutory
period of 24 hours and, therefore, she is entitled to be released
from this illegal detention.
6. During the course of arguments, the learned counsel
also raised a ground that the Petitioner was not produced before
the nearest Magistrate from where she was arrested, though this
particular point was not specifically taken in the Petition. Since
the allegations are about illegal detention, we are not restricting
our consideration to the strict rules of pleadings.
7. The learned APP opposed this Petition. She submitted
that the Petitioner was formally arrested at 10:17 PM on
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
4 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
03/11/2026. She was produced before the learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Vasai at 1:30 PM on 04/11/2026. At that
time, the learned Magistrate was busy in recording statements of
witnesses under Section 183 of the BNSS. He finally took up the
Petitioner's matter for remand at 3:05 PM on 04/11/2026. This
time was within the period of 24 hours from the arrest and,
therefore, there is no substance in the submissions of the learned
counsel for the Petitioner.
8. She further submitted that, since the Petitioner was
formally arrested at Achole Police Station at 10:17 PM on
03/11/2026, the nearest Magistrate was the JMFC, Vasai, and,
therefore, the police authorities have complied with the
requirement of producing the Petitioner before the nearest
Magistrate as well.
9. The learned APP further submitted that the Petitioner
has a long history of offences against her. She invited our
attention to paragraph 15 of the affidavit-in-reply, which lists the
offences against the Petitioner. They are as follows:
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
5 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
Sr. Police Station C.R.No. Sections
1. Vile Parle Police Station 700/2024 IPC Sections 419,
420, 465, 467, 468,
471
2. Ratnagiri Police Station 122/2024 IPC Sections 316(2),
318(4)
3. Vimantal Police Station 243/2024 IPC Sections 420,
406
4. Nigdi Police Station 52/2022 IPC Sections 420,
406, 34
5. Shivajinagar Police 557/2020 IPC Section 306
Station
6. Hupari Police Station 963/2024 IPC Sections 420,
406
She, therefore, submitted that no relief be granted to
the Petitioner.
10. We have considered these submissions.
11. The timeline of the Petitioner's arrest is mentioned in
paragraph 7 of the affidavit-in-reply filed by the investigating
agency. The timeline shows that, at 4:13 PM on 03/11/2026, the
police team traced the Petitioner to her residence at Kanjurmarg.
She was taken to Kanjurmarg Police Station, being the
jurisdictional police station. After completing the formalities, the
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
6 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
police team left Kanjurmarg Police Station. GD Entry No.039
was recorded at 4:13 PM, documenting that the Petitioner was
found at her home and was being taken to Achole Police Station.
The said fact was also informed to the son of the Petitioner.
It is the case of the Petitioner that she was picked up
from her house at about 1:00 PM on 03/11/2026. The Petitioner
has annexed some photographs showing the timing. Those
photographs are at pages 35, 36 and 37 of the Petition.
12. The learned APP seriously disputed the timings in the
photographs. The learned APP submitted that upto 5:00 PM, she
was able to talk with her son telephonically and, therefore, the
Petitioner's liberty was not curtailed. Therefore, according to the
learned APP, the Petitioner was not arrested till she was put
under formal arrest at 10:17 PM at Achole Police Station.
13. The further timeline shows that the Petitioner was
taken from Kanjurmarg Police Station to Achole Police Station
for further procedural compliance and investigation. They
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
7 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
reached Achole Police Station at 5:21 PM on 03/11/2026.
Sunset was to take place at 6:04 PM. The time was short for
completing rest of the formalities, and, therefore, the Petitioner
was produced along with the report before the learned Judicial
Magistrate First Class, Vasai, seeking permission to arrest a lady
accused after sunset, as mandated by law.
14. She was produced before the learned JMFC, Vasai, at
7:00 PM on 03/11/2026, who granted permission to arrest the
Petitioner. Thereafter, she was formally arrested at 10:17 PM on
03/11/2026 after complying with the requirements of Sections
47 and 48 of the BNSS. She was then taken before the learned
JMFC, Vasai, at 1:30 PM on 04/11/2026. The remand
application was taken up at 3:05 PM on 04/11/2026. The
learned Magistrate rejected the Petitioner's prayer for bail and
also the contention that she was produced beyond 24 hours
from her arrest. This was the timeline of her arrest.
15. As far as the production of the Petitioner before the
learned Magistrate within 24 hours of her arrest is concerned, it
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
8 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
is the first issue raised before us. According to the learned
counsel, the Petitioner was arrested at 1:00 PM on 03/11/2026.
The timeline shows that she was, in fact, produced before the
learned JMFC, Vasai, at 7:00 PM on 03/11/2026. Though, by
that time, she was not formally shown as arrested, and though
permission was sought from the Magistrate to arrest her after
sunset, she was produced before the JMFC, Vasai, at 7:00 PM
after being taken from Kanjurmarg to Achole. At that time itself
the Magistrate could have authorised her further custody u/s
187 of BNSS r/w section 58 of BNSS. Though she was not
shown formally arrested at 4:13 PM, on 03/11/2026, her liberty
was definitely curtailed at 4:13 PM at Kanjurmarg Police Station.
From that police station, the Petitioner did not go to Achole
Police Station voluntarily on her own, but was taken by the
police.
16. However, the matter does not rest there. The
requirements of law, under Article 22(2) of the Constitution and
Section 58 of the BNSS, are important in this context. They are
as follows:
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
9 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
“22. Protection against arrest and detention in certain cases
(1) …..
(2) Every person who is arrested and detained in custody
shall be produced before the nearest magistrate within a
period of twenty-four hours of such arrest excluding the
time necessary for the journey from the place of arrest to
the court of the magistrate and no such person shall be
detained in custody beyond the said period without the
authority of a magistrate.
Section 58 in Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023
58. Person arrested not to be detained more than twenty-four
hours.
No police officer shall detain in custody a person
arrested without warrant for a longer period than under
all the circumstances of the case is reasonable, and such
period shall not, in the absence of a special order of a
Magistrate under section 187, exceed twenty-four hours
exclusive of the time necessary for the journey from the
place of arrest to the Magistrate's Court, whether having
jurisdiction or not.”
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
10 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
17. The requirement is that the arrested accused is
required to be produced before the ‘nearest Magistrate’
(Emphasis supplied.)
18. In this case, the affidavit-in-reply of the investigating
agency itself shows that, from her residence at Kanjurmarg, the
Petitioner was taken to Kanjurmarg Police Station. There, a
General Diary entry was made at 4:13 PM on 03/11/2026 and
then she was taken to Achole Police Station.
19. Thus, it is clear that she was taken from her residence
to Kanjurmarg Police Station. At that time, her liberty was
curtailed, but she was not produced before the nearest
Magistrate at Kanjurmarg. Instead, she was taken to Achole, and
the jurisdictional Magistrate was the JMFC, Vasai. This does not
satisfy the requirement of production before the nearest
Magistrate, as is held by a Judgment of this Court at
Aurangabad Bench in the case of Vachhalabai W/o Bharat
Shinde, Vs. State of Maharashtra, as reported in 2019 SCC
OnLine Bom 2937 . The term ‘nearest Magistrate’ and the
requirement to produce the accused before the ‘nearest
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
11 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
Magistrate’ is explained in this Judgment in paragraph 26, 55
and 56 as follows :
“26. The aforesaid reasons given to have the Article in the
present form show that no scope is left to police to keep
arrested person in their custody for the purpose of
investigation for more than 24 hours excluding the time
required for taking the accused from the place of arrest to
the Court of Magistrate. Only to ensure such observance,
mandate, the term "nearest magistrate" is used and
specific period is also given. The period of 24 hours is
given in relation to the term "nearest magistrate" and it
cannot be read separate from this term. Further, as per the
aforesaid reasoning given, "nearest magistrate" cannot be
presumed as the Magistrate having jurisdiction over the
crime, in which the accused is arrested. Further, right to
inform the Magistrate of the charge under which that man
is arrested given in this Article shows that it was intention
to see that the Magistrate within whose territorial
jurisdiction the man is arrested is expected to be informed
about such arrest and such Magistrate is expected to
exercise the power, which can be like bail, remand etc.
No other interpretation of the aforesaid obligation, to
inform to the Magistrate about the arrest mentioned by
Dr. Ambedkar is possible. In view of this object behind
using the term "nearest" the subsequent reference of terms
like "Court of Magistrate" and "Magistrate" in Article
22(2) can have the same object. So, the subsequent terms
used as "Court of Magistrate" and "Magistrate" means
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
12 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
that "nearest magistrate" mentioned in the Article. If the
purpose behind Article 22(2) of Constituent Assembly is
kept in mind, only the aforesaid meaning can be given to
the term "nearest magistrate".
55. The provision of Section 167(2-A) of Cr.P.C. already
quoted shows that no excuse is available to the police
officer arresting the accused like nearest Judicial
Magistrate was not available. In that case also, as per this
provision, the accused needs to be transmitted to the
nearest Executive Magistrate on whom powers are
conferred of Judicial Magistrate. In that case also, some
record is required to be prepared by the police officer
under this Section. This provision shows that no scope is
left to police to say that they could have produced such
arrested accused before the concerned Magistrate, the
Magistrate having jurisdiction over the offence within 24
hours from the time of arrest and so, the accused was
taken before the concerned Magistrate. In view of the
aforesaid provisions, the interpretation suggested for the
Respondents by the learned APP is not at all acceptable.
56. The aforesaid provisions are safeguards for protection of
fundamental rights mentioned in Article 21 of the
Constitution of India. They need to be strictly followed by
the officers effecting arrest. If there is a material to infer
that there was actual arrest, but after the arrest the
accused was not taken before the nearest Magistrate and
he was taken far away from that place for production
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
13 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
before the concerned Magistrate, the moment the accused
is taken out of the jurisdiction of nearest Magistrate, his
detention becomes unauthorized and illegal. Such
detention will not become legal only because
subsequently the accused is produced before the
Magistrate having jurisdiction to try or inquire into the
offence within 24 hours of the actual arrest. Here only it
needs to be mentioned that the contention of police that
formal arrest was made after taking the accused to the
local jurisdiction of the concerned Magistrate and the
period needs to be counted from that time and the case
needs to be considered from that angle cannot be
accepted. There are other provisions in Cr.P.C. like
issuing notice or summons for making inquiry and by that
process calling a person to the police station is possible. If
that procedure is not followed and accused is picked up
from a place over which the police station has no
jurisdiction and he is taken to the place over which the
police has jurisdiction, inference become easy that the
accused was taken away from the first place only by
illegally detaining him. If such interpretation is not made
then the aforesaid provisions mentioned like Section 41-
B, 41-C and all subsequent provisions will become otiose
and that will be against all the provisions made to
safeguard the fundamental rights of such person.”
20. Thus, from the record, it is clear that, after taking the
Petitioner into custody and curtailing her liberty, she was not
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
14 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
produced before the nearest Magistrate. This is violative of
Article 22(2) and Section 58 of the BNSS. On this ground, she
deserves relief in this case.
21. Though we are inclined to allow this Petition, we must
also add that the Petitioner has a long history of antecedents,
and in some of the cases, she is still shown as absconding.
Therefore, this particular order in this Petition shall not come in
the way of the investigating agencies in those offences to take
steps to arrest the Petitioner in accordance with law, if found
necessary.
22. Even in this particular case, even after her release, the
investigating agency investigating CR No.491 of 2026 registered
at Achole Police Station can re-arrest the Petitioner after
following due process of law, if found necessary.
23. Hence, the following order :
O R D E R
(i) The Petitioner shall be released in connection
with CR No.491 of 2026 registered at Achole
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
15 / 15 04-WP-6137-26.odt
Police Station on her furnishing a P.R. bond in
the sum of Rs.50,000/- with one or two sureties
in the like amount.
(ii) The Petitioner shall attend the said police station
every alternate Saturday between 3:00 PM and
5:00 PM till the filing of the charge-sheet.
(iii) The Petitioner shall not tamper with the
evidence or the witnesses.
(iv) The investigating agency shall be at liberty to re-
arrest her after following due procedure of law
in connection with CR No.491 of 2026 registered
at Achole Police Station, if her re-arrest is
necessary.
(v) The Petition is disposed of.
(vi) Rule is made absolute in the aforesaid terms.
(RANJITSINHA RAJA BHONSALE, J.) (SARANG V. KOTWAL, J.)
Uploaded on - 20/11/2026 Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 15:52:58
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)