P.GOPINATH vs V.MURUGARAJ

Court
Madras High Court

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
DATED: 18.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE P. MURUGAN
CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
CNR:{HCMD010496752023}
1. P.Gopinath,
S/o K.K.Palanisamy,
No.4/157, Ayyanar Nagar,
Aathumadu,
Vedasnthur Taluk,
Dindigul District.
2. K.K.Palanisamy
S/o Karuppana Gounder,
No.4/157, Ayyanar Nagar,
Aathumadu,
Vedasnthur Taluk,
Dindigul District. .. Appellants
Vs.
V.Murugaraj
S/o Velusamy,
No.3764/1, Palaiyakottai,
Sullerumbu Post,
Vedasanthur Taluk,
Dindigul Distict. .. Respondents
PRAYER: Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed under section 30 of
Employee’s Compensation Act, to set aside the impugned order
passed in E.C.No.80 of 2018 dated 27.02.2023 on the file of the
Commissioner, Employee’s Compensation Tribunal, Dindigul.
For Appellants :Mr. C.Nihil Nandha
for Mr. D.Kirubakaran
For Respondent :Mr.S.Sankar
__________
Page  1  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
J U D G M E N T
The respondent in E.C.No.80 of 2018 on the file of the
Commissioner, Employee’s Compensation Tribunal, Dindigul,
challenges the order dated 27.02.2023 passed in that case, where the
claim petition filed by the respondent herein was allowed in part,
fastening the liability on the appellants to pay compensation of
Rs.6,51,984/- together with interest at 12% per annum, in addition to
medical expenses amounting to Rs.8,72,666/-, to a total sum of
Rs.15,24,650/-.
2. The litigative status of the parties are referred to as it
stood before the Tribunal that the appellants are the respondents and
the respondent is the petitioner / claimant.
3 (a). The respondent, who is the injured, filed the claim
petition before the Commissioner of Employee’s Compensation,
Dindigul (hereinafter referred as ‘Tribunal’) stating that the first
respondent in the claim petition is the owner of the land in survey
No.77, in S.C.No.30 of Navaluthu village, in which the second
respondent, who is the father of the first respondent, maintaining the
said property, in which as the request made by the respondents, the
claimant had been working in the said land with well for sludge and
__________
Page  2  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
silt removal ( ) work for the past one month. The
fpzW J}h;thUjy;
injured was paid Rs.15,000/- as monthly wages with daily patta of
Rs.150/-, during the working days.
3 (b). On 23.08.2018, while he was working with the
respondents’ land with well at about 06.00 pm, when the injured was
attending the motor pipe setting work, the side wall of the well
scrubbing and fallen down on the injured and out of which, the
injured sustained injuries on his head, neck, chest, left thigh and all
over body and there was heavy bone fracture. Immediately, he was
taken to Kumaran Hospital, Oddanchathiram, in which first aid was
given and thereafter, he was recommended to the Vellammal
Hospital, Madurai and there he was admitted on 24.08.2018 till
27.08.2018 as inpatient. Thereafter, once again he has taken
treatment at City Hospital, Dindigul, for some time and thereafter,
he is taking treatment in the said hospital as out patient.
3 (c). For the said accident, a case in Crime No.77 of 2018
under sections 228 and 338 of I.P.C was filed at Idayakottai police
station. Out of the said accident, the injured sustained bone fracture
on his neck, chest, left thigh and thereby he could not able to attend
his work and any employment. The said accident was happened
__________
Page  3  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
when the injured was working under the respondents with the
supervision, even then the respondents did not send any notice under
section 10 of the Employee’s Compensation Act, 1923 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘1923 Act’) to the Commissioner under the 1923 Act.
Though the claimant made a request to the employers to pay
compensation with medical expenses, but, there is no reply.
Thereby, the claimant filed a compensation petition before the
Commissioner under the 1923 Act, for claim of Rs.15,00,000/- as
compensation.
4 (a). Brief counter of the respondents before the Tribunal is
as that the land and well mentioned in the claim petition belongs to
the first respondent. The other allegations are denied. The second
respondent is the father of the first respondent and the second
respondent has no right over the subject property. The alleged
accident is denied. At no point of time the respondents engaged the
service of the petitioner as workman. The first respondent was
working in a private company at Coimbatore. The second respondent
is residing 10 Kms away from the subject land and well, at
Vedasandur, Ayyanar Nagar. The respondents 1 and 2 did not
present at the accident place.
__________
Page  4  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
4 (b). It is true that the respondents engaged the service of
Nachimuthu and his younger brother Dharmar @ Dharmaraj, for
sludge and slit removal of the well belonging to the first respondent.
They brought the claimant for the said work. There is no direct
employer and employee relationship between the claimant and the
respondents. The respondents did not know the claimant. The
respondents are not necessary parties. Nachimuthu and Dharmar @
Dharmaraj, are necessary parties in which they have not been added
as parties to the case. Therefore, the claim petition is liable to be
dismissed. The claimant has no educational qualification or technical
qualification to attend the motor pipe work. The claim petition is
filed only to get compensation from the respondents.
4 (c). The claimant worked under Nachimuthu and Dharmar
@ Dharmaraj, to carry out sludge and slit removal work, which was
entrusted to the said Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj. The
claimant attended the said work as they requested and having done
the work at 04.30 p.m. and left the place. Thereafter, no work was
engaged from the claimant. The real truth is that the claimant came
__________
Page  5  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
to the well around 06.00 p.m. only to steal motor pump set and he
voluntarily went down to the well and at that time the scrubbing of
the well wall taken place, thereby the claimant sustained injury.
4 (d). Having the claimant decided to steal the motor pump
set and sustained injury during that course, on humanitarian ground
the respondents did not file any police complaint for the welfare of
the injured. If at all the compensation is to be paid, the said
Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj, are liable to pay.
Therefore, the claim petition is to be dismissed.
5. During the enquiry, the injured claimant examined as
P.W.1, and through him Exh.P1 to Exh.P11 have been marked. Then
the medical expert opinion with regard to disability of the injured
was marked as Court document in Exh.C1 through Court witness
C.W.1 - Mr. Sivakumar from City Hospital, Dindigul. On behalf of
the first respondent, the first respondent was examined as R.W.1 and
through him Exh. R1 to Exh.R3 were marked. On behalf of the
second respondent, the second respondent was examined as RW2
and through him Exh. R1 / R.W.2 was marked. After taking into
consideration of the facts, evidence, the tribunal came to the
conclusion that the injured worked under the direction of the second
__________
Page  6  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
respondent in the land and well of the first respondent. Thereby there
is an employer and employee relationship between the respondents
and the claimant, and the accident was taken place during the course
of employment, and thereby the compensation with medical
expenses as ordered is indicated in paragraph No.1 of this judgment.
Against the said judgment, both the appellants filed this appeal.
6. Heard both sides. Perused the records. Considered the
submissions raised by both sides.
7. The appeal was admitted on 11.07.2023 on the following
four substantial questions of law:
I. Whether the Tribunal is right in fixing the liability upon the
appellants to pay the compensation in the absence of any substantial
evidence?
II. Whether the Tribunal shall award compensation in the case
where there is no employer-employee relationship exist?
III. Whether the Tribunal is right in awarding the
compensation, despite the claim is in violation of section 12 of the
Employee’s Compensation Act 1923?
IV. Is the Tribunal is correct in awarding the compensation,
even in the absence of the necessary parties to the claim and whether
__________
Page  7  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
the petition filed by the respondent is maintainable without adding
the necessary parties?
8. The learned counsel for the appellants / respondents
submitted that there is no contract of employment between the
claimant and the respondents. There is no employer and employee
relationship between the parties to the case. Though the respondents
engaged the service of Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj, for
cleaning the well and sludge and silt removal, and thus those
persons, who to have brought the claimant, for daily wages. On the
fateful day of 23.08.2018, when the sludge and silt removal work
was over between 09.00 a.m. and 04.30 / 05.00 p.m., the wages for
that day was disbursed around 04.30 to 05.00 p.m.
9. It was further submitted that the injured left the place and
thereafter around 06.00 p.m. came to the well and went down to the
well for the purpose of stealing the motor and pump set. At that time
the side wall of the well was being scrubbed and thereby the alleged
accident was happened. Having the injured was not working under
the respondents, the respondents are not liable to pay compensation,
and if at all anything is to be paid, only by Nachimuthu and Dharmar
@ Dharmaraj, in which they engaged the service of the claimant, is
__________
Page  8  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
liable to pay compensation. All these aspects have not been taken for
consideration. Therefore, this appeal is filed.
10. The said learned counsel further submitted that, though
the injured had allegedly attempted to commit theft of the motor
pump set and sustained injuries in the course of such an attempt, no
police complaint was lodged, taking into consideration the welfare,
life and future of the injured. On the above grounds, the learned
counsel submitted that the appeal is liable to be allowed.
11. The learned counsel appearing for the injured / claimant
submitted that it is not in dispute that the injured was engaged in
sludge and silt removal work in the well situated in the land
belonging to the first respondent, which was maintained,
administered and cultivated by the second respondent, who is none
other than the father of the first respondent. It is a common practice
in agricultural activities that, whenever a well is required to be
cleaned by removing sludge and silt, the owner of the property
would engage workers for the said purpose.
12. He further submitted that though the respondents had
engaged the services of the claimant and others for such work, it is
also a matter of common practice that the workers engaged in sludge
__________
Page  9  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
and silt removal would, as part of their incidental work, to switch on
the motor pump set then and there to pump out the water from the
well and attend to the necessary operational requirements of the
motor pump set, including the adjustment, setting, resetting and
removal of the foot valve, whenever required. Such activities are
ordinarily incidental to and form part of the work undertaken by the
workers engaged in cleaning agricultural wells. Therefore, the
performance of such ancillary duties cannot be treated as an act
unconnected with or beyond the scope of their routine work in the
agricultural field.
13. Though the work relating to the removal of sludge and
silt had been completed at around 05.00 p.m. on 23.08.2018, the
respondents directed the claimant to go down to the well to check
the availability of the motor pump, pipe and foot valve for pouring
water the next day. At that time, the side wall of the well suddenly
crumbled, thereby causing injuries to the claimant. Since the
claimant was working under the employment of the respondents, the
contention of the respondents that they had not engaged the claimant
cannot be accepted. Therefore, the Tribunal has rightly awarded
compensation. Hence, the appeal is liable to be dismissed.
__________
Page  10  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
14. As the substantial questions of law reveals that there is no
challenge about the quantum of compensation awarded and the
disability sustained by the claimant, which is 85%, and the monthly
wages, age factors, etc. It is the contention of the respondents before
the Tribunal that there is no employer and employee relationship and
the award is against under section 12 of the 1923 Act and there is an
absence of necessary parties.
15. The evidence adduced by the parties before the Tribunal
is considered. The claimant has deposed as P.W.1 in accordance
with the facts stated in the claim petition. He has incurred medical
expenses of Rs.8,72,666/-. Initially, he received first-aid treatment at
Kumaran Hospital, Oddanchatram, on 23.08.2018. Thereafter, he
underwent treatment as an inpatient at Velammal Hospital, Madurai,
from 24.08.2018 to 27.08.2018 and at City Hospital, Dindigul, from
28.08.2018 to 10.12.2018, followed by outpatient treatment. In
respect of the accident, an FIR in Crime No.77 of 2018 was
registered by the claimant’s wife under sections 228 and 338 of the
IPC against the second respondent.
16. The said FIR was marked as Exh.P1. The discharge
summary relating to the claimant was marked as Exh.P2. The
__________
Page  11  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
discharge summary issued by City Hospital was marked as Exh.P3,
and the admission and treatment certificate issued by City Hospital
was marked as Exh.P4. The medical expense bills issued by City
Hospital were marked as Exh.P5 and Exh.P6. The medical expense
bill issued by Velammal Hospital was marked as Exh.P10, and the
bill issued by City Hospital was marked as Exh.P11. Exh.P7 is the
patta relating to the subject land, standing in the name of the first
respondent. The remaining documents are the family card and ration
card of the claimant.
17. On perusal of the cross-examination of the claimant,
examined as P.W.1, it is revealed that he is a coolie and is not well
educated. He was engaged in the work of sludge and silt removal
under the respondents. Though two other persons, namely,
Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj, had also worked along
with the claimant, they were not impleaded as parties. However, the
respondents had engaged the services of the claimant. C.W.1, the
Court witness, spoken about the medical records.
18. The second respondent was examined as R.W.1 and
narrated his counter facts in his R.W.1 chief examination before the
Tribunal. On perusal of his cross-examination conducted by the
__________
Page  12  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
claimant, R.W.1 stated that the accident was informed to him by
Dharmar @ Dharmaraj. The said Dharmar @ Dharmaraj had been
engaged to clean the well by removing sludge and silt, for which
there was no written contract. He further admitted that they might
have engaged the services of the claimant. The subject land,
comprised in Survey No. 77, situated at Navaluthu Village, is owned
by his son, the first respondent. Since his son was working at
Coimbatore, the second respondent was administering the said
property. After the accident, R.W.1 visited the injured claimant
twice at the hospital.
19. The complaint given by the claimant's wife in Crime No.
77 of 2018 is not disputed. The second respondent has been shown
as an accused, and the charge sheet has been taken on file in STC
No. 121 of 2020. The second respondent has not taken any steps to
challenge the criminal proceedings by filing a quash petition or
otherwise.
20. It is the case of the respondents that four workmen would
have been engaged for the removal of sludge and silt, and the
claimant could also have been one among them. However, this is
merely a hypothetical answer. Though the stand of the respondents
__________
Page  13  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
is that the injured Murugaraj came to the subject well for the purpose
of stealing the motor pump set, RW1 has admitted that no F.I.R. was
registered in this regard.
21. It is also admitted by R.W.1 that when the well cleaning
work, that is silt and slit removal, taken place, the foot valve of the
motor is to be cleaned and then only the water could be taken from
the well to the field, for which only the injured came in the evening
hours for cleaning the motor pump set and foot valve. Though
denied by RW1, RW1 admitted that he has paid the wages to
Dharmar @ Dharmaraj and Nachimuthu, who will disburse the same
to the workman. Though the said Dharmar @ Dharmaraj and
Nachimuthu worked with the claimant and they have engaged the
service of the claimant as contended by the respondents, the
respondents could not take any steps to implead those persons as
parties to the case.
22. The first respondent examined as R.W.2, in which he
stated that on the accident date he was not at the accident place and
was working at Coimbatore. Thereby he produced gas bill, identity
card to show that he was at Coimbatore. He admitted that the subject
land in Survey No.77 belongs to him, and the second respondent,
__________
Page  14  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
who is his father, taking care of the said land, maintaining and
administering the land. The answer to most of the questions is not
known. There is no contract for sludge undislit removal is admitted
by R.W.2. The other questions have been denied by him.
23. Though the respondents engaged the workmen's service
for sludge and silt removal work, and the work was entrusted to
Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj, in which as per the
evidence of R.W.1, minimum four persons worked in the said work
for one month, wherein the Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj,
the claimant Murugaraj and one Mr. Gopal worked for the said
purpose. It is the stand of the respondents that on the fateful day of
23.08.2018, the wages on that day was disbursed to Nachimuthu,
and the said Nachimuthu disbursed each workman wages and left the
place. Thereafter, the said Murugaraj injured came to the subject
land and well and step into the well for the purpose of stealing the
pump set, for which no police complaint given.
24. It is the contention of the respondents in the counter that
the first respondent was working in Coimbatore and the second
respondent was staying 10 Kms away from the subject land and well
at Vedasandur. He was not there at the subject land on 23.08.2018
__________
Page  15  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
when the injured Murugaraj attended motor pump set cleaning and
refitting. Though the stand taken by the respondents that the injured
had come to the well at around 06.00 p.m after the sludge and silt
work was over about 04:30 to 05.00 p.m for the purpose of stealing
the motor pump set. Non-filing of the police complaint by the
respondents makes a great doubt about their contentions.
25. It is quite common for sludge and silt removal work
workmen engaged and in such activities to adjust the motor pipeline
and clean the foot valve of the motor pipe in order to facilitate the
pumping of water from the well to the agricultural field. Though the
work on the day was over around 05.00 p.m., thereafter the
respondents could have engaged the service of injured for the said
cleaning and refitting the motor pipe and foot valve, and at that time
the well wall scrubbing where the injured sustained various injuries.
26. Having there is no written contract between the
respondents and the said Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj to
fasten their liability on them, and the respondents did not take any
steps to bring those two persons as respondents and further failed to
file police complaint about the intention to steal the motor pump set
it is proved that the respondents not only engaged the service of the
__________
Page  16  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
injured for well cleaning, for sludge and silt removal, and also
engaged the said Murugaraj's service or work for cleaning the motor
pipe foot valve. Therefore, there was an employer and employee
relationship between the injured Murugaraj and the respondents.
However, the Tribunal has held that the first respondent being the
land owner, which is not disputed and also admitted by both the
respondents, there is an employer and employee relationship
between the first respondent and the claimant. This Court after
re-appreciation of evidence had reached the same conclusion that the
land owner utilised the services of the injured, therefore, there was
an employer and employee relationship between the claimant and
the first respondent.
27. The respondents contended that the award is violation of
section 12 of the 1923, Act. Section 12 of the said Act says that
when a principal employer engaged service of the contractor for the
execution of the whole or any part of work, sustained injury or death
taken place, the principal is liable to pay employee execution of the
work. Sub-section (1) of section 12 of the 1923 Act is extracted
below for better clarity:
__________
Page  17  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
“12. Contracting.- (1) Where any person
(hereinafter in this section referred to as the
principal) in the course of or for the purposes of his
trade or business contracts with any other person
(hereinafter in this section referred to as the
contractor) for the execution by or under the
contractor of the whole or any part of any work
which is ordinarily part of the trade or business of
the principal, the principal shall be liable to pay to
any employee employed in the execution of the
work any compensation which he would have been
liable to pay if that employee had been immediately
employed by him; and where compensation is
claimed from the principal, this Act shall apply as if
references to the principal were substituted for
references to the employer except that the amount of
compensation shall be calculated with reference to
the wages of the employee under the employer by
whom he is immediately employed.”
28. The contention of the respondents that they had engaged
the services of Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj to carry out
the work , therefore, the injured have to claim any compensation
from them and not under the respondents as principal employer. As
discussed above, there is no written contract or agreement between
__________
Page  18  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
the respondents and principal employer. For the alleged contract
with Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj, no steps taken by the
respondents to implead the said Nachimuthu and Dharmar @
Dharmaraj as parties to the proceedings, at least to establish that the
respondents have given contract work to them.
29. Further the respondents failed to examine any one of
Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj as witness before the
Tribunal to establish those facts. Having failed to prove the
contention of the respondents that they have not engaged service of
Murugaraj/ injured, given contract to Nachimuthu and Dharmar @
Dharmaraj and non filing of any agreement / contract non examining
any one of Nachimuthu and Dharmar @ Dharmaraj, the contention
of the respondents is ruled out and thereby, the Tribunal has rightly
concluded that the first respondent being the owner of the land, in
which the injured worked for sludge and slit removal, there was an
employer and employee relationship and, therefore, section 12(1) of
the 1923 Act is not squarely applicable to the contention canvassed
by the respondents.
30. In view of the above factual scenario, evidence coupled
with the failure of the respondents to prove their defence, the
__________
Page  19  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
Tribunal had rightly come to the conclusion, answering all the issues
in favour of the claimant and thereby nothing found to interfere into
the Tribunal order. Therefore, this Court is of the firm view that all
the substantial questions of law are answered against the
respondents. Thereby, the appeal is liable to be dismissed by
confirming the Tribunal order. The parties shall bear their own
costs.
27. In the result:
(i) This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is dismissed;
(ii) The order passed in E.C.No.80 of 2018, dated 27.02.2023
on the file of the Commissioner, Employees Compensation Tribunal,
Dindigul, hereby confirmed; and
(iii) There shall be no order as to costs.
18.11.2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
LS
__________
Page  20  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
To
The Commissioner,
Employee’s Compensation Tribunal,
Dindigul.
Copy To :
The Section Officer,
VR Section,
Madurai Bench of Madras High Court,
Madurai
__________
Page  21  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )

CMA(MD) No. 629 of 2023
DR. P. MURUGAN, J.
LS
C.M.A.(MD) No. 629 of 2023
18.11.2026
__________
Page  22  of  22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:45:22 pm )