Adani Transmission (India) Limited vs Central Electricity Regulatory Commission & Ors

Court
Appellate Tribunal For Electricity

IN THE APPELLATE TRIBUNAL FOR ELECTRICITY
(Appellate Jurisdiction)
Court-2
RP No. 3 of 2018
in
Appeal No. 226 of 2016
th
Dated : 17 November, 2026
Present: Hon’ble Mr. Virender Bhat, Judicial Member
Hon’ble Mr. Ajay Talegaonkar, Technical Member


In the matter of:

Adani Transmission (India) Limited
Adani House, Nr. Mithakhali Circle,
Navarangpura, Ahmedabad – 380009
Through its Authorized Representative … Petitioner

Versus

1. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission
Chanderlok Building,
36, Janpath Road, New Delhi – 110001
Through its Secretary

2. Power Gird Corporation of India Limited
Through its Chairman and Managing Director
(Govt. of India undertaking)
Registered Office: B-9,
Qutab Institutional Area,
Katawaria Sarai, New Delhi - 110016

3. National Load Despatch Centre
Through its Chairman and Managing Director
B-9, Qutab Institutional Area,
Katawaria Sarai, New Delhi - 110016
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 1 of 33


4. Northern Regional Load Despatch Centre
Through its Chairman and Managing Director
18-A, ShaheedJeet Singh Sansanwal Marg,
Katwaria Sarai, New Delhi – 110016

5. Western Regional Power Committee
Through its Member Secretary
F-3, MIDC Area, Marol, Opp. SEEPZ,
Central Road, Andheri (East),
Mumbai – 400093

6. Central Electricity Authority
Through its Secretary
Sewa Bhawan, Sector-1,
R.K. Puram, New Delhi – 110066

7. Gujarat Energy Transmission Company Limited
Through its Chairman
Sardar Patel Vidyut Bhavan,
Race Course, Vadodara – 390007

8. Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Limited
Through its Director
1st Floor, Shakti Bhawan,
Sector – 6, Panch Kula – 134109, Haryana

9. Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited
Through its Chairman
Sardar Patel Vidyut Bhawan,
Race Course, Vadodara – 390007

10. Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Co. Limited
Through its Chairman and Managing Director
“Prakashgarh”, Bandra (East),
Mumbai – 400051, Maharashtra

11. Madhya Pradesh Power Management Company Limited
Through its Managing Director
Shakti Bhawan, Vidyut Nagar,
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 2 of 33


Rampur, Jabalpur (MP) – 482008

12. M.P. Audyokik Kendra Vikas Nigam Limited
Through its Secretary
Free Press House, 1st Floor,
3/54-Press Complex,
A.B. Road, Indore – 452008
Madhya Pradesh

13. Chhattisgarh State Power Distribution Company Limited
Through its Chairman
Vidyut Seva Bhawan Parisar,
Dangania, Raipur – 492013, Chhattisgarh

14. Goa State Electricity Department
Through its Executive Engineer
Vidyut Bhawan, Panaji,
Goa – 403001

15. Daman and Diu Electricity Department
Through its Executive Engineer
Administration of Daman & Diu
Near Satya Narayan Temple
Nani Daman – 396210

16. Electricity Department
Administration of Dadra Nagar Haveli
Through its Secretary
Dadra Nagar Haveli UT, Silvasa – 396230

17. Heavy Water Projects
Department of Atomic Energy
Through its Chairman
Heavy Water Board,
Vikram Sarabhai Bhawan,
Anushakti Nagar, Mumbai – 400094

18. Jindal Power Limited
Through its Chairman
Tamnar, Raigarh, Chhattisgarh – 496001
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 3 of 33


19. Torrent Power Limited
Through its Chairman
Torrent House, Opp. Ashram Raod,
Ahmedabad – 380009

20. PTC India Limited
Through its Chairman and Managing Director
2nd Floor, NBCC Tower 15,
Bhikaji Complex, New Delhi – 110066

21. Haryana Power Purchase Centre
Through its Chief Engineer,
Shakti Bhawan, Sector-6
Panchkula, (Haryana)- 134 109

22. Rajasthan Power Procurement Centre
Through its Chief Engineer
Room No. 24, Vidyut Bhawan,
Janpath Jyoti Nagar,
Jaipur - 302 005 Rajasthan

23. Jodhpur Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Limited
Through its Director
New Power House, Industrial Area
Jodhpur - 342 003, Rajasthan

24. Jalpur Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Limited
Through its Director
Vidyut Bhawan, Janpath, Jyoti Nagar,
Jyoti Marg, Jaipur - 302 005, Rajasthan

25. Ajmer Vidyut Vitaran Nigam Limited
Through its Director
Old Power House, Hathi Bhatta,
Jaipur Road, Ajmer - 305 001, Rajasthan

26. BSES Yamuna Power Limited
Through its Director
Shakti Kiran Building,
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 4 of 33


Karkardooma Delhi -110 092

27. BSES Rajdhani Power Limited
Through its Director
BSES Bhavan, Nehru Place
New Delhi-110 019

28. Tata Power Delhi Distribution Ltd.
Through its Director
Cennet Building, 33 kV Sub-station Building
Hudson Lines, Kingsway Camp
Delhi-110 009

29. New Delhi Municipal Council
Through its Chairman
Palika Kendra Building,
Opp. Jantar Mantra Parliament Street,
New Delhi - 110001

30. Uttrakhand Power Corporation Limited
Through its Director
Urja Bhawan, Kanwali Road
Dehradun - 248 001

31. Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation Limited (UPPCL)
Through its Director
Shakti Bhawan, 14, Ashok Marg
Lucknow - 226 001, UP

32. North Central Railway
Through its Director
Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh - 211 012

33. Punjab State Power Corporation Limited(PSPCL)
Through its Director
The Mall, Ablowal, Patiala -147 001

34. Power Development Department
Through its Secretary
Jammu and Kashmir Civil Secretariat,
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 5 of 33


Jammu -180 001

35. Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board
Through its Managing Director
Vidyut Bhawan, Shimla - 71 004

36. Electricity Department UT Chandigarh
Through its Secretary
Sector 9, Chandigarh - 160 009

37. Northern Regional Power Committee
Through its Secretary
18-A, Qutab Institutional Area
Shaheed Jeet Singh Marg
Katwaria Saral New Delhi 110 016

38. Western Regional Power Committee
Through its Secretary
F-3, M.I.D.C. Area, Marol,
Andheri (East), Mumbai - 400 093

39. Kanpur Electricity Supply Company Limited
Through its Director
14/71, Civil Lines, Kanpur - 208 001

40. Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Limited
Through its Director
Vidyut Bhawan, Vidyut Marg
Jaipur - 302 005

41. Delhi Transco Limited (DTL)
Through its Director
Shakti Sadan, Kotla Road
New Delhi - 110 002 Respondent(s)



Counsel for the Petitioner(s) : Sanjay Sen, Sr. Adv.
Hemant Singh
Matrugupta Mishra
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 6 of 33


Shikha Ohri
Nishant Kumar
Divyanshu Bhatt
Ankita Bafna
Biju Mattam
Ananya Mohan
Shourya Malhotra
For Pett. 1



Counsel for the Respondent(s) : Anshul Singh
Nitin Gaur
for Res. 11

Rajiv Srivastava
Garima Srivastava
Gargi Srivastava
For Res. 31

ORDER
PER HON’BLE MR. VIRENDER BHAT, JUDICIAL MEMBER

1. The Review Petitioner M/s Adani Transmission (India) Limited is
th
seeking review of the judgement of this Tribunal dated 8 November, 2017
passed in Appeal No. 226 of 2016. We may note that out of 41 respondents
in this Review Petition, only Respondent No. 11 has appeared through
nd
counsel on 2 July, 2026 who submitted that the said respondent does not
th
wish to file any reply to the Review Petition. On subsequent date i.e. 13
August, 2026, when the Review Petition came out for hearing, we heard
the Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner. Learned Counsel
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 7 of 33


appearing for Respondent No. 11 submitted that he does not wish to
advance any arguments and left it to the wisdom of this Tribunal to take a
call on the contentions raised in the petition by the petitioner.
2. We may note that for evacuation of power under the Power Purchase
Agreements of 1495 MW capacity with Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd.
(UHBVNL) and Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited (DHBVNL), the
petitioner constructed a dedicated transmission system of 500 kV Mundra
– Mohindergarh HVDC bi-pole transmission line including associated 400
kV transmission lines which could evacuate 2500 MW power. Further, the
Petitioner had sought long term access for 200 MW to Maharashtra at
Dehgam sub-station of Power Grid Corporation of India Ltd. (PGCIL). In
order to avail connectivity to Dehgam substation of PGCIL, the petitioner
built a dedicated 400 kV Mundra_Sami-Dehgam D/C transmission line as
well as 400 kV Mohindergarh-Bhiwani transmission line.
st
3. Thereafter, the petition filed a petition before the 1 Respondent –
Central Electricity Regulatory Commission bearing petition No.
44/TL/2012, under CERC Transmission License Regulations, 2009 for
grant of transmission license for the dedicated transmission lines along
th
with associated bays. In terms of the order dated 8 June, 2013 passed by
the Central Commission for the said petition, transmission license was
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 8 of 33


granted to the petitioner in respect of these dedicated transmission lines
th
and transmission bays on 29 July, 2013 after following due process.
4. The petitioner, thereafter, filed petition No. 184/TT/2013 before the
th
Central Commission on 5 September, 2013 for determination of
transmission tariff for the following assets :-
“i. Asset-1 consisting of +/- 500 kV Mundra-Mohindergarh
HVDC bipole transmission line with associated sub-stations,
bays, electrode lines and associated 400 kV lines; and
ii. Asset-2 consisting of 400 kV D/C Mundra- Dehgam
transmission line with associated system.”
5. The petition was disposed of by the Central Commission vide order
th
dated 18 March, 2016 thereby reducing the tariff claimed by the petitioner
on account of date for commencement of tariff, reduction of capital cost of
AC substation tariff and reduction of loan outstanding by cumulative
depreciation till the date of license. Aggrieved by the said order of the
Commission, the petitioner had approached this Tribunal by way of the
th
appeal No. 226 of 2016 which was disposed of vide judgement dated 8
November, 2017, of which review is sought in this petition. Vide the said
judgement, this Tribunal remanded the case back to the Central
th
Commission for allowing the date of grant of transmission licensee i.e. 29
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 9 of 33


July, 2013 as the date of tariff commencement for the transmission assets
of the petitioner and to determine the capital cost of the said transmission
assets including Bhiwani and Dehgam substation as on date of grant of
transmission line including the consequential reliefs to the petitioner.
6. However, this Tribunal did not disturb the findings of the Commission
in the impugned order on the following aspects :-
“i. Capital cost reduction for AC Substation Portion of the
Licensed Asset, except for Dehgam & Bhiwani substation;
ii. Reduction of loan outstanding by cumulative depreciation till
the date of grant of license which has led to reduced recovery of
interest on loan. Further, consideration of cumulative
depreciation has also resulted in perpetual disallowance of
depreciation of Rs. 204.69 Crore for Asset 1 and Rs. 101.92
Crore for Asset 2 for the Review Petitioner.”
7. The instant Review Petition is confined to the above two aspects, on
which the decision of the Central Commission was affirmed by this Tribunal
th
in the above noted judgement dated 8 November, 2017.
8. We have heard Learned Senior Counsel for the Review Petitioner
th
and have perused the judgement dated 8 November, 2017 in Appeal No.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 10 of 33


226 of 2016 as well as written submission on record. We reiterate here that
Review Petition had not been contested by any of the respondents.
9. At the outset, we may note that Section 114 of CPC is the
substantive provision dealing with scope of review and is quoted below:-

“114. Review. —Subject as aforesaid, any person
considering himself aggrieved—
(a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is
allowed by this Code, but from which no appeal
has been preferred.
(b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is
allowed by this Code, or
(c) by a decision on a reference from a Court of
Small Causes, may apply for a review of
judgment to the Court which passed the decree
or made the order, and the Court may make such
order thereon as it thinks fit.”

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 11 of 33


10. The grounds on which review of a judgment / order can be sought,
have been specified in Order XLVII of the CPC which are reproduced
hereinbelow: -

“1. Application for review of judgment. — (1) Any person
considering himself aggrieved—

(a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is
allowed, but from which no appeal has been
preferred,

(b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is
allowed, or

(c) by a decision on a reference from a Court
of Small Causes, and who, from the
discovery of new and important matter or
evidence which, after the exercise of due
diligence was not within his knowledge or could
not be produced by him at the time when the
decree was passed or order made, or on account
of some mistake or error apparent on the face of
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 12 of 33


the record or for any other sufficient reason,
desires to obtain a review of the decree passed
or order made against him, may apply for a
review of judgment to the Court which passed the
decree or made the order.
(2) A party who is not appealing from a decree or
order may apply for a review of judgment
notwithstanding the pendency of an appeal by
some other party except where the ground of
such appeal is common to the applicant and the
appellant, or when, being respondent, he can
present to the Appellate Court the case on which
he applied for the review.

Explanation.—The fact that the decision on a
question of law on which the judgment of the
Court is based has been reversed or modified by
the subsequent decision of a superior Court in
any other case, shall not be a ground for the
review of such judgment.”
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 13 of 33


(Emphasis supplied)

11. A bare reading of these relevant legal provisions would make it clear
that an application for review of a judgment / order is maintainable upon
(i) discovery of a new and important matter or evidence which, after
exercise of due diligence, was not within the knowledge of the review
applicant or could not be produced by him when the judgment / order was
passed; or (ii) on account of some mistake or error apparent on the face
of record; or (iii) for any other sufficient reason.

12. The expression “error apparent on the face of record” used in Order
XLVII Rule 1 indicates an error which is self-evident and staring in the eye.
Any error or mistake which is not self-evident and has to be deducted from
a process of reasoning cannot be said to be an error apparent on the face
of record justifying exercise of power of review. Power of review can be
exercised only where a glaring omission or a patent mistake is found in
the order under review. We may also note that the power of review can
be exercised only for correction of a patent mistake but not to substitute a
view for the reason that a review petition cannot be permitted to be an
appeal in disguise.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 14 of 33


13. In a recent judgment dated 08.09.2025 passed in Malleeswari v. K.
Suguna and Anr. SLP (C) No. 12787 of 2025 (2025 INSC 1080) Hon'ble
Supreme Court has reiterated that court’s power to review its own previous
order is strictly limited to correcting errors apparent on the face of the
record and not to rehear or substitute a different view as if it were an
appeal. It has been held in the said judgment that the power of review is
different from appellate power and is subject to the following limitations to
maintain the finality of the judicial decisions:


“15.1 The review proceedings are not by way of an
appeal and have to be strictly confined to the
scope and ambit of Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC.

15.2 Review is not to be confused with appellate
powers, which may enable an appellate court to
correct all manner of errors committed by the
subordinate court.

15.3 In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule
1 of CPC, it is not permissible for an erroneous
decision to be reheard and corrected. A review
petition, it must be remembered, has a limited
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 15 of 33


purpose and cannot be allowed to be an appeal
in disguise.

15.4 The power of review can be exercised for the
correction of a mistake, but not to substitute a
view. Such powers can be exercised within the
limits specified in the statute governing the
exercise of power.

15.5 The review court does not sit in appeal over its
own order. A rehearing of the matter is
impermissible. It constitutes an exception to the
general rule that once a judgment is signed or
pronounced, it should not be altered. Hence, it is
invoked only to prevent a miscarriage of justice or
to correct grave and palpable errors.”


14. Further, after noticing the distinction between power of review and
appellate power, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has succinctly summed up
the grounds of review as under: -

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 16 of 33


“17.1 The ground of discovery of new and important
matter or evidence is a ground available if it is
demonstrated that, despite the exercise of due
diligence, this evidence was not within their
knowledge or could not be produced by the party
at the time, the original decree or order was
passed.

17.2 Mistake or error apparent on the face of the
record may be invoked if there is something more
than a mere error, and it must be the one which
is manifest on the face of the record. Such an
error is a patent error and not a mere wrong
decision. An error which has to be established by
a long-drawn process of reasoning on points
where there may conceivably be two opinions
can hardly be said to be an error apparent on the
face of the record.

17.3 Lastly, the phrase 'for any other sufficient reason'
means a reason that is sufficient on grounds at
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 17 of 33


least analogous to those specified in the other
two categories.”

15. We may also note that in the words of Justice Krishna Iyer (as his
Lordship then was), “a plea of review, unless the first judicial view is
manifestly distorted, is like asking for the Moon. A forensic defeat cannot
be avenged by an invitation to have a second look, hopeful of discovery
of flows and reversal of result. A review in the counsel’s mentation cannot
repair the verdict once given. So, the law laid down must rest in peace.”
(See Ghanshyam Mishra & Sons (P) Ltd v. Edelweiss Asset
Reconstruction Co. Ltd. (2021) 9 SCC 657).
16. Now, we proceed to discuss in detail the contentions of Review
Petitioner on the issues mentioned in paragraph No. 6 herein above.
“i. Capital cost reduction for AC Substation Portion of the
Licensed Asset, except for Dehgam & Bhiwani substation;
17. Learned Counsel for the Review Petitioner submitted that this
th
Tribunal in the judgement dated 8 November, 2017 which is under review,
while observing that the Commission used benchmark/indicative cost as a
“prudence check” tool and relied on PGCIL deposit works as enabling
actual-cost recovery for certain sub-stations including Bhiwani & Dehgam
AC substations, the capital cost for the remaining AC substation was
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 18 of 33


mechanically clipped to benchmarks as per benchmarking order of the
th
Commission dated 16 June, 2010 without undertaking any prudence
check/detailed analysis of “causes” behind the excess claimed by the
petitioner.
18. It is argued that first proviso to regulation 7(2) of 2009 Tariff
Regulations permits prudence check based on benchmark norms “to be
specified by the Commission”. It is the submissions of the Learned Counsel
that the term “Specified” means specified by Regulations and not by way
nd
of an order. He further referred to 2 proviso of the said Regulation 7(2)
which provides that where benchmark norms have not been specified,
prudence check may be conducted by the Commission for allowing costs.
Learned Counsel would argue that since benchmark norms were not
specified by the Regulations, the Commission was bound to conduct
nd
prudence check of the costs as envisaged by 2 proviso to Regulation 7(2)
th
but the Commission had relied upon benchmarking order dated 16 June,
2010 to clip/prune the capital cost of Mundra, Mohindergarh and Sami
substations. Thus, as per the submissions of the Learned Counsel, the
Commission’s order was contrary to the Regulations which has been
approved by this Tribunal in the judgement under review and, therefore, the
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 19 of 33


said judgement suffers from an error apparent on the face of record,
deserving to be reviewed.
19. In this regard, we may note that this Tribunal has in paragraph No.
16 (c)(i) of the judgement under review noted these contentions of the
Review Petitioner that the Commission should not have used the
benchmarking norms for comparison and reduction of capital cost of its AC
substations. Thereafter, in subsequent sub-para(iii) of said paragraph 16(c)
had discussed all these contentions of Review Petitioner and has observed
as under :-
iii. From the above, it is clear that the Appellant before the
Central Commission has not provided the FR cost estimates
related to the transmission assets in question. We are of the
view that it is not possible having a project FR without
separate estimates for the transmission assets even though
the project is planned to be a combined generating and
transmission project. The Central Commission in absence of
such estimates was forced to apply prudence check based
on the circumstances of the case and the nature of the
assets for which the capital cost can be compared to either
benchmark norms or indicative costs of similar projects as
per the Tariff Regulations, 2009. The Central Commission
has used benchmark norms where indicative costs were not
available and that too based on the submissions made by
the Appellant. In case where model was wrongly used by the
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 20 of 33


Appellant, the Central Commission applied correction to that
for arriving at a fair cost of the assets. Wherever the
indicative costs were available for comparison, the Central
Commission has used them with appropriate escalations as
required. The counsel for the Central Commission has
submitted that the Appellant has submitted the benchmark
norms model for some assets considering that it is beneficial
to it, landed with submitting it with wrong assumptions. We
agree to this argument of the Central Commission.

iv. On this issue the Appellant has also made reference to the
judgements of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Kusumam
Hotel Pvt. Ltd. Vs. KSEB & Ors. (2008) 13 SCC 213 and
Accountant General and Anr. Vs. S. Doraiswamy & Ors.
(1981) 4 SCC 93 regarding retrospective application of
benchmark norms. Since the tariff of the Appellant is
determined in 2013 and the said benchmark norms were
issued in 2010, the contention of the Appellant fails on this
count. In present case there is no link between
commissioning of the assets and date of issue of the
benchmark norms by the Central Commission.

v. In view of the above we are of the considered opinion that
the Central Commission is justified in using benchmark
capital cost while deciding capital cost of the AC sub station
of the Appellant and there is no infirmity in the decision of
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 21 of 33


the Central Commission.”

20. Besides it, this Tribunal had also formulated question Nos. 9.1(a) &
9.1(b) also for its consideration on this aspect which are extracted
hereinbelow:-
9. Questions of law

The Appellant has raised the following questions of law in the
present Appeal:
I. Reduction in capital cost

a) Whether the Central Commission has the ability to
determine capital cost based on the benchmarking orders
dated 27.04.2010 and 16.06.2010, when the same could
only have been done through regulations?
b) Whether the Central Commission could have invoked the
Benchmarking orders dated 27.04.2010 and 16.06.2010 for
determination of capital cost, when the proviso to
Regulation 7(2) of the Tariff Regulations, 2009 stipulate that
the same has to be only through regulations, as the word
used is “specified”?
21. In the discussion, on these sub issues, this Tribunal has noted the
provisions of Regulation 7(2) of Tariff Regulations 2009 and has held as
under :-
“ii. From the above, it is clear that the Tariff Regulations,
2009 provide for prudence check of the capital cost of the
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 22 of 33


transmission assets. While doing so, as per the
Regulations, the Central Commission may carry out
prudence check of capital cost based on benchmark
norms. This becomes more important in cases where
detailed break up of capital cost and their proper
justifications are not provided by the project developer.
Thus, the answer to the Question No. 9. I. a) is yes, the
Central Commission may determine capital cost based on
benchmark norms if the situation so warrants. Further, in
case benchmark norms are not available the Central
Commission need to consider reasonableness of capital
cost etc. for prudence check of capital cost as per second
proviso to the Regulation 7 (2) reproduced above. In case
of the Appellant the benchmark norms were available with
the Central Commission except for that of HVDC line
where it has carried out prudence check of the capital cost
based on comparison with similar line of the Powergrid.
The Central Commission while carrying out the prudence
check of the capital cost has followed benchmark norms
to the extent but for HVDC line in absence of benchmark
norms/model they have determined the capital cost
considering the cost of similar line of PGCIL.”
22. Following observations of this Tribunal in the judgement under review
in paragraph No. 16(h) are also material on this aspect and is extracted
hereinbelow :-
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 23 of 33


i. The Central Commission while comparing the capital
cost of the sub stations have gone into by comparing it
with the indicative capital cost of similar works of
Powergrid and while deciding other cost elements has
used benchmark cost model as the details were
provided by the Appellant itself. The Central
Commission in its wisdom while doing prudence check
in absence of FR cost estimates of the transmission
assets has compared capital cost of the Appellant
based on various available options and concluded the
capital cost based on the options available before it.

ii. We observe that in case of the sub stations (Bhiwani &
Dehgam) where Powergrid has carried out the works
of the Appellant on deposit works basis in the premises
of its existing sub stations, the Central Commission has
compared the capital cost of the Appellant with that of
the indicative cost of similar works carried out by
Powergrid. The Appellant has submitted that the actual
cost of the works was much lower as calculated based
on the benchmark models. The claim of the Appellant
was higher than the indicative cost of Powergrid. The
Central Commission has approved the capital cost of
the said sub stations based on the indicative cost of the
Powergrid. Here it is important to note that the works
were carried out by Powergrid on deposit works basis
and the payments were made by the Appellant on the
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 24 of 33


demands raised by the Powergrid from time to time.
Powergrid being a public sector company must have
adopted prudent utility practices for carrying out the
works at its premises. The Central Commission also
holds similar opinion about the Powergrid. The Central
Commission has also not refuted the claim of the
Appellant that the cost of the said sub stations was
lesser than as derived based on the benchmark model.

iii. We see some merit in the claim of the Appellant that
the Central Commission has subjectively used
indicative cost or benchmark cost as prudence check
for arriving at the capital cost of the Appellant. In view
of our discussions as above, the deposit works carried
out by the Powergrid on behalf of the Appellant and the
cost of those works being less than as derived from the
benchmark model, we are of the considered opinion
that the Appellant is entitled to recover the cost for the
said sub stations where Powergrid has executed the
works on behalf of the Appellant. The Central
Commission is hereby directed to consider the actual
capital cost considering the deposit work executed by
Powergrid for the said transmission assets. Here we
would like to clarify that the capital cost in this case for
the said assets is to be considered as on date of grant
of TL as we have decided the date of tariff
commencement as the date of grant of TL to the
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 25 of 33


Appellant.”

23. Therefore, it is manifest that all the contentions now sought to be
raised by the Review Petitioner on this issue have been duly taken note of
and considered by this Tribunal in the judgement under review and have
been rejected upon finding no merit in the same. Therefore, the Appellant
is precluded from raising the same contentions again in this Review Petition
for the reason that this Tribunal cannot sit in appeal over its own judgement
and in case any party to the appeal finds any error in the observations and
judgement of this Tribunal, the only remedy available is to assail the
judgement by way of statutory appeal provided in the Electricity Act, 2003
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court. There is a clearcut distinction between
an erroneous judgement and the judgement suffering from error apparent
on the face of record. The Review Petition is maintainable only in the later
case while as in the former case the remedy is to file an appeal before the
superior court. In the instant case, the Review Petitioner has failed to point
th
out any error apparent on the face of record in the judgement dated 8
November, 2017 of this Tribunal.
ii. Reduction of loan outstanding by cumulative depreciation
till the date of grant of license which has led to reduced
recovery of interest on loan. Further, consideration of
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 26 of 33


cumulative depreciation has also resulted in perpetual
disallowance of depreciation of Rs. 204.69 Crore for Asset 1
and Rs. 101.92 Crore for Asset 2 for the Review Petitioner.”
24. It is argued by the Learned Counsel for the Review Petitioner that this
th
Tribunal has held 29 July, 2013 i.e. the date of granting of transmission
licensee to the petitioner to be the tariff commencement date and has
directed the Commission to determine capital cost and other tariff
th
components from that date but cumulative depreciation till that date i.e. 29
July, 2013 has been considered for calculation of loan outstanding. He
would argue that in terms of Regulation 7(2) of the Tariff Regulations, 2009
capital cost admitted after prudence check shall form the basis for
determination of depreciation, being a component of tariff. It follows that
there could be only one capital cost, which is admitted by the Commission
and once that is done, there is no scope for any revisit on that admitted
capital cost for purposes of calculating depreciation. It is his submission
that there cannot be a separate capital cost for ROE and normative loan
and a separate cost for depreciation and on this aspect, the judgement
th
dated 8 November, 2017 suffers from any error apparent on the face of
record, which requires to be reviewed.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 27 of 33


25. On this aspect, this Tribunal had formulated question Nos. 9(III) (a)
(b) & (c) which are extracted hereinbelow :-
“III. Reduction of loan outstanding by cumulative depreciation:


a. Whether the Central Commission has failed to appreciate
that the Appellant is not subjected to reduction of loan
outstanding by cumulative depreciation till the date of
license?

b. Whether the Central Commission has failed to appreciate
that norms related to depreciation in CERC (Terms and
Condition of Tariff) Regulations, 2009 is applicable only to
licensed transmission system and not beforehand?

c. Without prejudice to the ground that there is no
depreciation to be considered till the date of license, the
Central Commission ought to have considered physical
depreciation and not as per CERC (Terms and
Conditions of Tariff) Regulations, 2009?”

26. The discussion on these issues is found in sub-paragraph Nos. (i),
(ii), (iv), (v), (vi), (vii) & (viii) of paragraph 16(j) of the judgement under
review which are reproduced hereinbelow :-
i. The Appellant has submitted that the Central Commission
ought not to have considered the cumulative depreciation
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 28 of 33


figure corresponding to the pruned capital cost and reduce
the same from the opening normative loan. The cumulative
depreciation submitted by it upto 30.9.2013 and 1.10.2013
are based on claimed capital cost and cumulative
depreciation also includes pruned capital cost.

ii. The counsel for the Central Commission has submitted that
it has identified the concerned assets for which capital cost
has been pruned. The rate of depreciation is different for
different assets. The learned counsel further submitted that
the adjustments between the estimated depreciation and
actual depreciation shall be carried out at the time of truing
up for which the Appellant shall have to provide the
cumulative depreciation corresponding to pruned capital
cost.
iii.
The learned counsel for the Central Commission further
submitted that if the loan amount limited to cumulative
depreciation as on 1.10.2013 is not adjusted against the
gross loan, then the loan which the Appellant has serviced
prior to 1.10.2013 shall have to be serviced in tariff by all
DICs. As per the Tariff Regulations, 2009 Interest on Loan
as a component of tariff is worked out on net outstanding loan
and net outstanding loan is worked out by adjusting
cumulative repayment of loan prior to the date from which
tariff is to be determined.
iv. On the contention of the Appellant that depreciation should
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 29 of 33


have been computed pro-rata based on actual usage or
actual wear and tear of the transmission system, the Central
Commission has submitted that as per the Removal of
Difficulty (Fifth) Order, 2005, the dedicated transmission line
executed by a generating company is required to comply with
the directions of RLDC regarding its operation. As per the
Central Commission, to meet such operational requirements
there is no need for the Appellant to be compensated. The
Appellant has taken a business risk while constructing
dedicated transmission line and it cannot claim
compensation for losses from beneficiaries on account of
load restrictions imposed by RLDC from point of view of grid
security. Similar load restrictions were also imposed by
RLDC for ensuring grid security even after grant of TL to the
Appellant. On this issue we tend to agree with the arguments
put forth by the counsel for the Central Commission. We also
observe that prior to the grant of TL for the said transmission
assets of the Appellant, their tariff (combined for generation
and transmission assets) was serviced based on competitive
bidding as per Section 63 of the Act. Accordingly, the tariff of
the generating station including the transmission assets of
the Appellant was not regulated by the Central Commission
or the State Commission of Haryana State. We are not sure
of the treatment of depreciation taken by the Appellant in its
tariff bid. In view of this the approach taken by the Central
Commission to reduce opening loan by cumulative book
depreciation is appropriate which is in line with the financial
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 30 of 33


principles adopted in the Tariff Regulations, 2009. Further,
the contention of the Appellant to consider the impact of
unrecovered depreciation (if any) for the period prior to the
date of grant of TL while determining the tariff cannot be
considered as tariff determination under Section 62 of the Act
and adoption of tariff under 63 of the Act cannot be compared.
Accordingly, the reliance of the Appellant on this Tribunal’s
judgment dated 13.06.2007 passed in Appeal No. 139 of
2006 in case of NTPC Vs. CERC & Ors. is misplaced.
v. Accordingly as per the foregoing discussions, we decide that
the opening loan as on date of tariff commencement date is
to be considered after reducing it by cumulative depreciation
as done by the Central Commission and there is no infirmity
in the decision of the Central Commission in this regard.
vi. We have already decided that the tariff commencement date
is to be considered as date of grant of TL i.e. 29.7.2013
therefore, the Central Commission is directed to work out the
capital cost as on 28.7.2013 and the other tariff components
including interest on loan as per the provisions of the Tariff
Regulations, 2009.

vii. On the issue of depreciation on pruned capital cost as on date
of tariff determination, the Central Commission has submitted
that this issue is being dealt in true up petition filed by the
Appellant. Accordingly, with the consent of the parties this
issue is not dealt in the present Appeal. However, it is clarified
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 31 of 33


that the date of tariff commencement is to be taken as
29.7.2013 as decided in this judgement.

viii. Hence, the issues related to depreciation are decided as
discussed above.

27. Perusal of these material paragraphs of the judgement under review
would reveal that each and every contention on the aspect under
consideration raised in this Review Petition has been noted and discussed
in detail in the judgement under review and have been repelled. Merely that
any contention/submission of a party to the appeal is negated by this
Tribunal does not indicate that such rejection constitutes error on the face
of record. Rejection of the contention of the parties in this appeal may be
wrongful which can only be agitated before the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the appeal provided under Electricity Act, 2003. Review petition is not
maintainable in these circumstances.
28. In the judgement under review, this Tribunal has come to a particular
finding upon consideration of relevant contractual provisions as well as the
rival submissions of the Learned Counsels for the parties. A Well reasoned
and well considered judgement, even though erroneous, does not fall within
the ambit of review. There is clearcut distinction between a judgement
suffering from error patent on the face of record and erroneous judgement.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 32 of 33


Review Petition is maintainable only in the former case whereas in the later
case, the remedy available to the aggrieved party to assail the
order/judgement by way of an appeal in the higher forum/court.
29. Manifestly, by way of the instant Review Petition, the petitioner is
actually seeking a re-look of the judgment under review in the hope to
discover any flaw or fault in the same, which is not permissible in law. The
review petition manifestly appears to be appeal in disguise and thus, does
not fall within the scope and ambit of Order XLVII Rule 1 of the CPC.
30. Hence, we are of the considered opinion that the petitioner has failed
to make out any mistake or error apparent on the face of record in the
th
judgment under review dated 8 November, 2017 and has failed to bring the
case within the parameters laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
various decisions referred to hereinabove. The review petition is sans any
merit and is accordingly dismissed.

th
Pronounced in the open court on this 17 day of November, 2026.

(Ajay Talegaonkar) (Virender Bhat)
Technical Member (Electricity) Judicial Member

✓
REPORTABLE / NON REPORTABLE

js

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
R.P. No. 3 of 2018 Page 33 of 33