Smt. Sushma Kalra vs Registrar Of Co-Operative Societies, Delhi & Ors.

Court
Delhi High Court

$~59
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
th
Date of Decision: 17 November, 2026
th
Uploaded On: 19 November, 2026
# CNR No. DLHC010546612026
+ W.P.(C) 16819/2026, CM APPL. 78667/2026 & CM APPL.
78668/2026
SMT. SUSHMA KALRA .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Ashwani Kumar and Mr. Puneet
Sharma, Advocates.
versus
REGISTRAR OF CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES, DELHI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Shashi Pratap Singh and Ms.
Shagun Aggarwal, Advocates for
RCS.
Mr. Gurbachan Singh, Advocate for
R-3.
Ms. Mrinalini Sen, Standing Counsel
for DDA, Mr. Pranay Lakhanpal, Adv.
Ms. Gauri Rajput, Adv.
Mr. Ashwani Kumar, Adv. for R-4.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE DINESH BHATT


Prathiba M. Singh, J. (ORAL)
1. This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
th
2. This matter is being taken up today for hearing as 16 November, 2026
was declared a holiday on account of Chhath Puja vide Notification
th
No.110/G-4/Genl.-I/DHC dated 11 November, 2026.
3. The present petition has been filed by the Petitioner Smt. Sushma Kalra
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India inter alia seeking a direction to
the Respondents to decide the complaints dated 15th September, 2026 and
06th October, 2026 filed by her before the Respondent No.1-Registrar of
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 1 of 12

Cooperative Societies (hereinafter ‘ RCS ’).
4. Petitioner is a member of the Mianwali District Co-Operative House
Building Society Limited (hereinafter ‘ Society ’).
5. It is her allegation that vide resolution dated 14th September, 2026 the
Managing Committee of the Society has decided to implement the order
passed by the Financial Commissioner as also of this Court and recommend
the case of Smt. Sushma Kalra to the DDA for allotment of the plot. The said
resolution is extracted as under –


Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 2 of 12

6. In addition, certain other recommendations were made by the
Managing Committee, which according to the Petitioner, are not in
accordance with law.
7. Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner submits that a complaint has been filed
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 3 of 12

th
by the Petitioner dated 15 September 2026 to the RCS which deserves to be
considered by the RCS and decided expeditiously.
8. Ld. Counsel Mr. Ashwini Kumar has appeared for Smt. Sushma
Sharma-Respondent No.4. Mr. Gurbachan Singh, ld. Counsel has entered
appearance for Society-Respondent No. 3.
9. The Court has heard the submissions of the parties.
10. The Petitioner's allegations are both general against the Managing
Committee of the Society and also against Smt.Sushma Sharma-Respondent
No. 4.
11. Insofar as the case of Sushma Sharma-Respondent No. 4. is concerned,
the issue of her membership has already been decided in W.P. (C)
th
No.3529/1989 vide order dated 15 January 2009 by a Division Bench of this
Court. The said order reads as under:-

“The Petitioner is aggrieved by the cessation of her
membership from the Respondent-Society by a letter
dated 10th November, 1987 issued by the Respondent-
Society.
It appears that the Petitioner applied for membership
of the Respondent- Society on 16th October, 1975 when
she was a minor. Her application was not processed
but apparently kept pending. On 8th August, 1981, a
letter was sent to the Petitioner by the Respondent-
Society in which she was told that her name is on the
Waiting List at serial No. 8 in the list of applicants
awaiting membership to the Respondent- Society. She
was also told that she should submit a proper
application in the prescribed form along with necessary
documents on or before 28th August, 1981, failing
which any representation from her claiming
membership of the Respondent-Society would not be
entertained.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 4 of 12

In response to this letter, the Petitioner sent an
th
application on 28 August, 1981 along with a draft of
Rs.35,865.73 and other necessary documents. On this
basis, her membership papers were processed and she
was granted membership of the Respondent-Society. It
appears that certain members of the Respondent-Society
made representations to the Registrar, Cooperative
Societies (for short ‘RCS’) making certain allegations in
respect of the functioning of the Respondent-Society.
On the basis of the allegations made, the RCS appointed
an Enquiry Officer under the provisions of Section 55 of
the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, 1972 (for short
‘the Act’) to go into the functioning of the Respondent-
Society. The Enquiry Officer examined all the relevant
material and submitted his findings, which were
accepted by the Assistant Registrar (House Building) of
the office of the RCS on 9th October, 1986 for
implementation. In so far as the Petitioner is concerned,
the report of the Enquiry Officer states that the
management of the Respondent-Society had considered
the application of the Petitioner dated 28th August,
1981 which is incorrect. It is not clear from the extract
of the Enquiry Report whether the Enquiry Officer felt
that the application submitted by the Petitioner when
she was a minor was incorrect or whether it was
incorrectly stated that the Petitioner had submitted an
application on 28th August, 1981. The extract of the
Enquiry Report in so far as it pertains to the Petitioner
reads as follows:-
‘As alleged in due exercise of power under S. 55 of the
Act I have given an opportunity to Smt. Sushma vide my
letter No. 891 dated 12.8.86 which was received back
with the comments of the postal authority (incomplete
address). As record of the society her address is 1/48,
Subash Nagar, New Delhi. I made another reference on
4.9.86 and requested her to appear before me on 18.9.86
alongwith documents of proof of age at the time of
enrollment of the society. In response to my letter she
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 5 of 12

has made a reference on 11.9.86 instead of her
appearance before me and forwarded employers
certificate of Railway Authority where in it is mention
they her date of birth as per their record is 1.3.1958. She
submitted an application to the society for enrollment on
16.10.1975 when she was only 17 years and 7 months
old. The then Management has considered the
membership and recommended for clearance vide their
letter dated 15.3.85 alongwith simplified proforma in
which the then Management have shown her application
dated 28.8.81 which is incorrect. In view of the above
facts, the then Management, have enrolled a minor
member Miss. Sushma and killed the rights of adult
members who were awaiting for allotment of plots in the
waiting lists. In my opinion, the membership of Smt.
Sushma d/o of Shri H.B. Sapra M.S. No. 1022 be
disqualified because she was minor at the time of
enrollment and dependent on her father.
Sd/-
Hon. Secretary,
The Mianwali Distt. Co-op.
House Bldg. Society Ltd.”
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the RCS has
drawn our attention to the counter affidavit filed on
behalf of the RCS and we find from a perusal thereof
that there is no dispute about the fact that the Petitioner
did make an application on 28th August, 1981 seeking
membership of the Respondent-Society. Learned
counsel who appears on behalf of the Respondent-
Society also says that as per his instructions the
application filed on 28th August, 1981 was received
from the Petitioner seeking membership of the
Respondent-Society. It follows from this that the
Enquiry Officer had proceeded on the basis that the
original application made by the Petitioner, when she
was a minor, was an incorrect application and ought not
to have been acted upon by the Respondent-Society. We
are of the opinion that regardless of the application
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 6 of 12

made by the Petitioner when she was a minor, the fact
remains that she was invited to make an application by
the Respondent-Society by its letter dated 8th August,
1981. Even if no such invitation was extended to the
Petitioner, there is no doubt that she did make a valid
application for membership on 28th August, 1981, on
which date she was admittedly a major (her date of birth
being 1st March, 1958). The chronology of events, in so
far as the Petitioner is concerned, would, therefore,
start either from 8th August, 1981 when she was invited
to make an application for membership by the
Respondent- Society or, in any case, from 28th August,
1981 when she actually submitted that application. On
both dates she was a major. There is no dispute that the
application made by the Petitioner on 28th August, 1981
was procedurally complete and was acted upon and
accepted by the Respondent-Society. That being the
position, we do not find any error in the Respondent-
Society admitting the Petitioner to its membership. In
so far as the report of the Enquiry Officer is concerned,
the finding against the Petitioner is based solely on the
fact that the original application was made by the
Petitioner at a time when she was only a minor. It is on
this basis that the Enquiry Officer has given a finding
against the Petitioner. However, since we have
concluded that the application made by the Petitioner
on 16th October, 1975 when she was a minor was
irrelevant, the edifice on which the report of the Enquiry
Officer is based itself falls to the ground. Therefore, the
report of the Enquiry Officer in so far as it pertains to
the Petitioner cannot be sustained. Our conclusion,
therefore, is that the Petitioner was validly inducted as
a member of the Respondent-Society on the basis of the
application made by her on 28th August, 1981.
Consequently, the cessation of her membership from the
Respondent-Society by its letter dated 10th November,
1987 on the basis of the report of the Enquiry Officer is
not justified. The natural consequences of quashing of
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 7 of 12

the letter dated 10th November, 1987 will follow and the
name of the Petitioner may be shown in the draw of lots
at the appropriate stage depending on her seniority and
eligibility. The letter dated 10th November, 1987 is
quashed and the writ petition is allowed. No costs.”
(extracted as is)

12. After the said order was passed, a further order has been passed on 18th
August 2026 by the RCS wherein it clearly records that the Petitioner had also
challenged the same issue before the Financial Commissioner and the
Financial Commissioner had decided the same in favour of Respondent No.4
th
vide order dated 19 July 2013 in Revision Petition No.144/2012.
13. In view of the order of the High Court and the order of the Financial
th
Commissioner, the RCS in its order dated 18 August 2026 came to the
following conclusion:-

“In view of the foregoing discussion, I am of the
considered opinion that the objections raised by the
respondent Society do not furnish any lawful basis for
denying the petitioner the benefit of the judgment dated
15.01.2009 passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi
and the order dated 19.07.2013 passed by the Ld.
Financial Commissioner.
The finding of the Hon'ble High Court that the petitioner
was validly inducted as a member of the respondent
Society and that cessation of her membership was
unjustified remains binding. The subsequent order dated
13.02.2012 passed by the RCS, which sought to take a
contrary view, already stands set aside by the Hon'ble
Financial Commissioner.
Accordingly, the petitioner continues to be recognized
as a valid member of the Mianwali District Cooperative
House Building Society Ltd. and her membership cannot
be treated as ceased or disqualified on the basis of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 8 of 12

objections raised by the respondent Society in the
present proceedings.
The respondent Society and this office are bound to give
effect to the final judicial directions and cannot reopen
or nullify the issues already adjudicated. The
petitioner's case is therefore required to be processed in
accordance with the judgment dated 15.01.2009,
including consideration of her name in the draw of lots
at the appropriate stage, subject to her seniority and
eligibility as directed by the Hon'ble High Court.
Therefore, in compliance with the judgment dated
15.01.2009 passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi
in W.P.(C) No. 3529/1989 and the order dated
19.07.2013 passed by the Hon'ble Financial
Commissioner in Revision Petition No. 144/2012, it is
hereby ordered that Smt. Sushma shall continue to be
recognized as a valid member of the Mianwali District
Cooperative House Building Society Ltd. The objections
raised by the respondent Society seeking cessation or
disqualification of the petitioner's membership on the
grounds of alleged financial dependence, source of
funds or alleged benami membership are hereby
rejected. The order dated 13.02.2012 passed by the
RCS, having already been set aside by the Hon’ble
Financial Commissioner vide order dated 19.07.2013,
shall not constitute any impediment to the
implementation of the judgment dated 15.01.2009.
The respondent Society shall not reopen or raise
objections on issues which already stand finally
adjudicated by the Hon’ble High Court and the ld.
Financial Commissioner, except on the basis of any
subsequent order of a competent court or any legally
sustainable ground arising independently after the
aforesaid judgments. The Society shall comply with this
order and submit a compliance report to this office
within 30 days from the date of receipt of this order.
Accordingly, the proceedings initiated vide Notice dated
16.03.2020 are hereby disposed of in favour of Smt.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 9 of 12

Sushma, with a direction to the respondent Society and
all concerned to ensure due and effective
implementation of the judgment dated 15.01.2009
passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi and the order
dated 19.07.2013 passed by the Ld. Financial
Commissioner. The Society shall take all consequential
steps strictly in accordance with the aforesaid judicial
directions and applicable law.”

14. As can be seen from the above, the RCS has decided that there is no
lawful basis for denying Respondent No.4 i.e. , Smt. Sushma Sharma the
th
benefit of the judgement dated 15 January 2009 of the High Court and the
th
order dated 19 July 2013 passed by the Financial Commissioner.
15. Accordingly, the Society was directed not to reopen or raise objections
on issues which were already decided.
16. Respondent No. 4 - Smt. Sushma Sharma has also sought
implementation of these orders in W.P. (C) 7912/2026 in which this Court
had already directed that the name of the Respondent No. 4 was to be
forwarded to the DDA by the RCS. The observations made in the said order
are set out below:-

“7. Thus, the case of the Petitioner is that only a letter
needs to be issued by the RCS to the DDA for conducting
the draw of lots. Hence, the present application.
8. The present petition is listed for hearing on 20th
November, 2026. However, since the Society has
already issued a letter dated 15th September, 2026,
requesting the RCS to forward the name of the
Petitioner to the DDA, for conducting a draw of lots for
allotment in favour of the Petitioner at the earliest, let
status reports be filed by the RCS and the DDA by the
next date of hearing.
9. At this stage, Ms. Shashi Pratap Singh, ld Counsel
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 10 of 12

appearing for the RCS has appeared and submits that a
letter dated 15th October, 2026, has been issued to the
Petitioner, calling upon the Petitioner and the Society to
furnish the requisite documents.
10. Heard. Considering that most of the formalities have
already been completed, let the Petitioner and the office
bearers of the Society appear before the office of the
RCS on 12th November, 2026, at 2:30 PM.
11. The Petitioner and the Society shall produce all the
records and documents as sought by the RCS. The RCS
shall expeditiously examine the same and forward its
recommendations for allotment to the DDA.
12. The application is disposed of in the above terms.”

17. Ld. Counsel for the RCS, Mr. Shashi Pratap Singh and Ms. Shagun
Aggarwal, have placed on record a compilation of documents in which it
th
becomes clear that pursuant to the order dated 30 October 2026 a hearing
th
has been conducted by the RCS and the matter is now listed on 25
November, 2026 before the RCS where the society has been directed to
appear.
18. Thus, insofar as Respondent No.4-Smt. Sushma Sharma is concerned,
the issues raised by the Petitioner can no longer be reopened.
19. Insofar as other allegations against Respondent No. 5-Mr. Vikas
Dhamija, the person to whom Plot No. 8, Block NS, Mianwali Nagar came to
be allotted / transferred and who sold the same in the open market, are
concerned, since there is a complaint dated 15th September, 2026 and 06th
October, 2026 filed by the Petitioner, let the same be considered by the RCS
and the complaint be disposed of within a period of 3 months from today.
Needless to add, in addition to the Petitioner, the Respondent no.5 and the
Society shall be heard by the RCS, before any orders are passed.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 11 of 12

20. The petition is disposed of. All pending applications, if any, are also
disposed of.

PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE


DINESH BHATT
JUDGE
NOVEMBER 17, 2026/MR/AS
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 16:15
W.P.(C) 16819/2026 Page 12 of 12