Bheemanagouda @ Bheemajja vs State By Harapanahalli Police

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 1239

NON-REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
(CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION)

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 5402 OF 2026

(Arising out of SLP(Crl.) No. 13798 of 2025)

BHEEMANAGOUDA @ BHEEMAJJA ... APPELLANT
VERSUS
STATE BY HARAPANAHALLI POLICE ... RESPONDENT
J U D G M E N T
VIPUL M. PANCHOLI, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The present appeal challenges the final judgment and order
dated 09.07.2024 passed by the High Court of Karnataka at
Bengaluru in Criminal Appeal No. 1355 of 2017. By the said
impugned judgment, the Division Bench of the High Court
dismissed the criminal appeal preferred by the appellant and
confirmed the judgment of conviction dated 27.04.2017 and
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
RAHUL KUMAR
Date: 2026.11.18
17:03:29 IST
Reason:
order on sentence dated 28.04.2017 rendered by the II
Additional District & Sessions Judge and Special Judge,
1

Davanagere in Sessions Case No. 101 of 2014. The Sessions
Judge had convicted the appellant for an offence punishable
under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter
“IPC”) and sentenced him to undergo imprisonment for life
with a fine of ₹ 25,000/- and in default, to undergo simple
imprisonment for 1 year. By the same judgment, the Sessions
Judge had acquitted the appellant of the charge framed under
Section 201 IPC.
FACTUAL MATRIX
3. The brief facts material to the disposal of the present appeal
are as under:
3.1. At about 9:00 a.m. on 05.09.2013, the complainant,
Ramappa (PW-1), who ran a limestone kiln along with
others in the tank-bed area of Hirekere near Harihara
Circle, Harapanahalli Town, received a phone call that
a dead body of an unidentified woman was lying inside
an iron drum kept near a lime furnace belonging to one
Huligemma. PW-1 visited the place, saw the dead body
stuffed inside the drum and lodged an oral complaint
at Harapanahalli Police Station.
2

3.2. Based on the said complaint, Crime No. 178 of 2013
was registered by Vasanth V. Asode, Police Sub-
Inspector (PSI - PW-19) against unknown persons for
offences punishable under Sections 302 and 201 IPC
and the FIR was transmitted to the jurisdictional
Magistrate. Mahantesh Sajjan, Circle Police Inspector
(CPI - PW-24) took up the investigation and drew the
spot panchanama and inquest mahazar on 05.09.2013.
A plastic belt-like strap was seized from a nearby Babul
tree and as the identity of the deceased was unknown,
pamphlets containing photographs of the dead body
were published and circulated to the public.
3.3. On 07.09.2013, the family members of the deceased,
including her son Ramesh (PW-8), nephew Lingaraj
(PW-5), niece Kavitha (PW-10) and cousin Ramappa
(PW-11), identified the deceased as one Sharadamma,
wife of Hanumanthappa (PW-7) of Yarabalu village. It
emerged that the deceased had attended the cradle
ceremony of the daughter of PW-11 at Mitlakatte village
on 01.09.2013. On 03.09.2013, PW-8 and the
deceased’s mother returned to Yarabalu, while the
3

deceased stayed behind. On 04.09.2013, at around
11:30 AM, the deceased left Mitlakatte to return home,
wearing gold and silver ornaments, however, she did
not reach her matrimonial or parental village and when
her body was discovered, the ornaments were found
missing.
3.4. According to the prosecution, the appellant,
Bheemanagouda @ Bheemajja, was in an illicit
relationship with the deceased, who had been
estranged from her husband for over a decade. The
prosecution alleged that the appellant harboured
suspicion that the deceased was also involved in an
illicit relationship with another person. On the night of
04.09.2013, at about 12:00 midnight, the appellant
took the deceased to the limestone furnace in Sy. No.
539/B1/BP1 near Hirekere, Harapanahalli, murdered
her by strangulation with a plastic strap, robbed her
ornaments and dumped her dead body inside an iron
drum to screen the offence.
3.5. On 12.09.2013, the appellant was arrested. It is the
case of the prosecution that pursuant to his disclosure
4

statement, the appellant led the police and panch
witnesses to the spot and thereafter to his house at
Yarabalu village, from where he produced a plastic bag
kept in a trunk containing gold and silver ornaments.
The said ornaments were seized under seizure mahazar
in the presence of one Ashok, Mehaboob Basha (PW-12)
and Venkatesh (PW-23) and were subsequently
identified by the relatives of the deceased.
3.6. Upon completion of the investigation, a charge-sheet
was laid against the appellant for offences punishable
under Sections 302 and 201 IPC. The case was
committed to the Court of Sessions and registered as
Sessions Case No. 101 of 2014. Charges were framed
under Sections 302 and 201 IPC, to which the appellant
pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
FINDINGS OF THE TRIAL COURT AND THE HIGH COURT
4. The prosecution examined 24 witnesses (PW-1 to PW-24), 18
exhibits (Ex. P-1 to Ex. P-18) and produced 10 material
objects (MO-1 to MO-10). The defence did not lead any oral or
documentary evidence. The appellant denied all incriminating
5

circumstances in his statement recorded under Section 313
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter
“Cr.P.C.”) and pleaded false implication.
5. its judgment dated 27.04.2017, the Sessions Judge
Vide
recorded the following vital findings:
5.1. Homicidal Death: That the deceased suffered a
homicidal death on account of asphyxia due to
constriction of the neck by ligature strangulation, as
established by the medical evidence of Dr. Raju G.M.
(PW-16) and RFSL reports.

5.2. Rejection of “Last Seen” Theory: The Sessions Judge
rejected the testimonies of Nagappa (PW-13) and
Palakshappa (PW-14) regarding the “last seen together”
theory. The Trial Court recorded that there was an
unexplained and inordinate delay of more than one-
and-a-half months in recording their statements under
Section 161 Cr.P.C. (recorded on 01.11.2013, despite
the incident having occurred on 04.09.2013 and the
arrest being made on 12.09.2013). The Sessions Judge
6

expressly held: “ So, the evidence is not believable to rely
on the last seen theory. ”
5.3. Conviction based solely on recovery under Section 27 of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (hereinafter “Evidence
Act”): Having discarded the “last seen” evidence, the
Trial Court sustained the conviction under Section 302
IPC on the premise of the recovery of the ornaments
from the house of the appellant under Section 27
Evidence Act.
5.4. Acquittal under Section 201 IPC: The Trial Court
acquitted the appellant under Section 201 IPC, holding
that merely dumping the body into a drum kept in an
open yard without any effort to burn, bury or immerse
it in water did not satisfy the requirement of an
intentional act to cause disappearance of evidence.
6. Aggrieved thereby, the appellant preferred Criminal Appeal
No. 1355 of 2017 before the High Court of Karnataka. The
High Court, vide the impugned judgment dated 09.07.2024,
dismissed the appeal. While affirming the conviction, the High
Court reviewed the testimonies of Nagappa (PW-13) and
7

Palakshappa (PW-14) and held that the “last seen together”
circumstance stood proven. The High Court further held that
the recovery of ornaments under Section 27 Evidence Act
remained unexplained by the appellant and completed the
chain of circumstantial evidence.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES
7. Mr. A. Sirajudeen, learned Senior Advocate appearing on
behalf of the appellant, made the following submissions:
7.1. The entire case rests on circumstantial evidence. As per
the case of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of
1
Maharashtra , the prosecution must establish a
complete and unbroken chain of circumstances
pointing to the guilt of the accused and inconsistent
with any hypothesis of innocence.
7.2. The motive alleged by the prosecution that the
appellant killed the deceased because he suspected her
of having an illicit relationship with another man, is
unfounded and unproved. None of the prosecution

1
(1984) 4 SCC 116.
8

witnesses testified that the appellant possessed any
such suspicion. PW-5 (nephew) and PW-7 (husband)
admitted in cross-examination that they had no
personal knowledge of any illicit relationship. Thus, the
courts below accepted motive on conjectures.
7.3. It is submitted that the narrative of the prosecution
regarding the discovery of the deceased’s body inside a
limestone drum is improbable and uncorroborated.
According to the complainant (PW-1), the drum in
question was kept covered to protect the lime from rain
and he only arrived at the kiln after someone informed
him over the phone that a dead body was lying inside.
However, the investigating agency neither traced nor
examined this informant who allegedly approached an
unattended kiln, removed the covering from the drum
at 9:00 AM and alerted PW-1 rather than the
authorities. Further, neither the photographs of the
deceased’s body, nor the inquest report, nor the post-
mortem report, reveal the stain or trace of limestone on
the person or clothing of the deceased.
9

7.4. The High Court committed an error of record in relying
on the “last seen” testimonies of Nagappa (PW-13) and
Palakshappa (PW-14) without adverting to the finding
of the Trial Court that their evidence was unreliable due
to an unexplained delay of 58 days in recording their
statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C.. It is submitted
that the version of the prosecution that the deceased
accompanied the appellant to a relative’s ceremonial
gathering and departed along with him is
uncorroborated by PW-5 (nephew), who was present at
the ceremony and acknowledged in cross-examination
that he had no personal knowledge of any illicit
relationship, nor did he testify to seeing them depart
together.
7.5. It is submitted that the circumstance concerning the
seizure of ornaments under Section 27 Evidence Act
cannot legally form the sole basis for sustaining a
conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC. As laid
down by a three-judge bench of this Court in Sanwat
10

2
Khan v. State of Rajasthan , and subsequently
3
followed in Raj Kumar @ Raju v. State (NCT of Delhi) ,
the unexplained possession of articles belonging to the
deceased merely enables a presumption under
Illustration (a) to Section 114 Evidence Act regarding
theft or receipt of stolen property and such possession
cannot be stretched to infer guilt for murder unless the
prosecution conclusively proves that the robbery and
murder were integral parts of the same transaction. In
the present case, the recovery under seizure mahazar
does not inspire confidence as PW-23 (appraiser)
deposed in cross-examination that he routinely acts as
a stock police witness, that his signature on spot
mahazar was struck out as he signed only once that
day and that he accompanied the team without a
weighing apparatus. Additionally, no independent
public witness attested to the disclosure statement of
the appellant, the co-panch Ashok was kept away from
the witness box, the alleged “last seen” witnesses (PW-

2
(1952) 2 SCC 641.
3
(2017) 11 SCC 160.
11

5, PW-13, PW-14) failed to identify any ornaments on
the deceased and PW-13 admitted that the police had
already brought the ornaments to the village on the day
following the incident, thus disproving discovery after 1
week of the incident from the residence of the appellant.
Learned counsel submitted that in the alternative, in
view of the prosecution’s case that there exists a
relationship between the deceased and the appellant, it
is entirely natural that her belongings might be kept at
his house.

7.6. Lastly, learned counsel for the appellant submitted that
the appellant has already suffered incarceration for
over 13 years and the charge of murder against the
appellant was not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
Therefore, the impugned judgment of conviction of the
appellant is to be set aside.
8. Per contra , Mr. Avishkar Singhvi, learned Additional Advocate
General appearing for the State of Karnataka, supported the
concurrent findings of conviction and made the following
submissions:
12

8.1. It is submitted that in the present case, the death of the
deceased was a homicidal strangulation and the motive
was proved before the courts below. The illicit
relationship between the appellant and the deceased
was deposed by the family members of the deceased
(PW-5, PW-7, PW-8, PW-10, PW-11), who confirmed
that a village Panchayat had also taken place.
8.2. Nagappa (PW-13) and Palakshappa (PW-14) had
natural occasions to see the appellant and deceased
together on 04.09.2013. The following morning, PW-14
saw the appellant alone near the bus stand.
Furthermore, the appellant failed to provide any
plausible explanation regarding the timing and manner
of his departure from the company of the deceased,
thereby attracting the statutory burden under Section
106 Evidence Act. The absence of an earlier Section 161
Cr.P.C. statement in the case diary does not per se
destroy the testimony of PW-14.
8.3. The immediate recovery of the body of the deceased
along with medical and forensic findings conclusively
proves a homicidal death, corroborating the
13

circumstantial case of the prosecution that the crime
transpired shortly following the moment when the
deceased was last seen in the company of the appellant.
Reliance is placed upon the decisions of this Court in
4
the cases of the State of U.P. v. Satish , and
5
Kanhaiya Lal v. State of Rajasthan , to submit that
the principle of “last seen together” constitutes a facet
of circumstantial evidence which requires both
proximity in time and independent corroborative proof
to substantiate a finding of conviction. On the morning
of 05.09.2013, pursuant to details communicated to
Ramappa (PW-1) and supported by Shivamma (PW-2),
the body of Sharadamma (the deceased) was found
stuffed in an iron drum situated near a lime kiln and a
plastic strap was recovered from a neighboring tree at
the place of occurrence. The post-mortem examination
conducted by Dr. Raju (PW-16) demonstrated two
distinct ligature marks encircling the neck, widespread
internal hemorrhage, muscular contusions and trauma

4
(2005) 3 SCC 114.
5
(2014) 4 SCC 715.
14

to the thyroid cartilage, leading to the medical opinion
that asphyxiation due to constriction of neck by ligature
strangulation caused the death. Thus, the medical
testimony negates any theory of accidental or self-
inflicted death, corroborating both the timeline of the
prosecution and the homicidal nature of the incident.
8.4. The depositions of family members of the deceased,
namely PW-8 (son), PW-10 (niece) and PW-11 (cousin)
establish that the deceased was wearing gold and silver
ornaments when last seen alive and upon the discovery
of her dead body, the said articles of jewellery were
found to be missing. The recovery of personal
ornaments of the deceased from the possession of the
appellant within a week of the incident in question
under Section 27 Evidence Act is a clinching evidence
of the crime. Furthermore, the appellant offered no
explanation under Section 313 Cr.P.C. for the
possession of the ornaments worn by the deceased
when she was last seen alive. It is submitted that when
stolen property is recovered shortly after the crime, an
inference under Illustration (a) to Section 114 Evidence
15

Act arises that the person holding it is the perpetrator
and if the evidence shows that the theft and homicide
formed a single continuous transaction, such recovery
justifies an inference of culpability for both offenses as
held in the decisions of this Court in the case of Shri
6
Bhagwan v. State of Rajasthan , and State (NCT of
7
Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu .
8.5. It is submitted that the prosecution established an
unbroken chain of circumstantial evidence pointing to
the guilt of the appellant, thereby satisfying the
principles governing cases of circumstantial evidence
laid down in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of
Maharashtra , (supra) and Abdul Nassar v. State of
8
Kerala .
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
9. The factual matrix of the present case discloses that it is a
case of circumstantial evidence and it is a well-settled

6
(2001) SCC (Cri) 1095.
7
2005 SCC (Cri) 1715.
8
2025 SCC OnLine SC 111.
16

principle of law that in a case founded solely on
circumstantial evidence, the prosecution is required to satisfy
the five golden principles laid down in the landmark case of
Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra
(supra). We have heard learned counsel appearing on behalf
of the parties and perused the material available on record.
Keeping the established principles in mind, we proceed to
examine each link in the chain of circumstantial evidence
relied upon by the prosecution.
10. The first circumstance relied upon by the prosecution is the
motive of the appellant behind the incident in question.
Motive, though not a sine qua non in cases resting on direct
evidence, assumes vital importance where the entire case
rests on circumstantial evidence and it is an important link
in the chain of circumstances, as reiterated in the case of
9
Indrajit Das v. State of Tripura . The case of the
prosecution is that the motive of the appellant behind the
incident in question was that the appellant and the deceased
were in an illicit relationship and the appellant harboured

9
(2023) 18 SCC 506.
17

suspicion regarding her character, suspecting her intimacy
with another person.
10.1. In this regard, the Trial Court held that based on the
evidence of the witnesses examined before the court,
the prosecution proved its case against the appellant
beyond all reasonable doubt, establishing that the
appellant committed the murder of the deceased due to
her illicit relationship with another person, as
submitted by the Public Prosecutor. The High Court
affirmed the said finding, observing that PW-5
(nephew), PW-8 (son) and PW-11 (cousin), relatives of
the deceased, deposed that they were aware of the illicit
relationship between the appellant and the deceased.
Consequently, the prosecution established that the
deceased and the appellant shared an illicit
relationship at the relevant time.
10.2. On perusal, it is clear that both the Trial Court and the
High Court committed an error by treating the general
knowledge of an illicit relationship as proof of the
motive to commit murder. On a careful scrutiny of the
depositions of the family members of the deceased,
18

namely PW-5 (nephew), PW-7 (husband), PW-8 (son)
and PW-11 (cousin), it emerges that the deceased was
living separately from her husband and there were
allegations of an illicit relationship with the appellant.
However, PW-5 admitted during cross-examination that
he did not personally witness any illicit relationship
between the deceased and the appellant and further
admitted that he had informed the police that he merely
suspected the appellant in connection with the
deceased’s death. Similarly, PW-7 admitted that he had
no personal knowledge of the affair. Significantly, none
of the prosecution witnesses testified that the appellant
harboured suspicion that the deceased was involved
with another man or that any quarrel had ever taken
place between them on that account. Thus, we are of
the opinion that the motive alleged by the prosecution
is a matter of conjecture and surmise, which cannot be
accepted as an established circumstance against the
appellant.
11. The second circumstance pressed by the prosecution is the
“last seen together” theory, founded on the testimonies of
19

Nagappa (PW-13) and Palakshappa (PW-14). This Court in
Kanhaiya Lal v. State of Rajasthan (supra), held that the
circumstance of last seen together does not by itself lead to
an inference of guilt unless there is proximate and
independent corroborative material establishing a link
between the accused and the crime.
11.1. A perusal of the record discloses that the incident
occurred on the night of 04.09.2013 and the dead body
was discovered on the morning of 05.09.2013. The
appellant was arrested on 12.09.2013. Significantly,
the statements of PW-13 and PW-14 under Section 161
Cr.P.C. were recorded by the investigating officer on
01.11.2013, which is after nearly 2 months.
11.2. The Trial Court rightly took note of this unexplained
delay and expressly rejected their testimonies, holding
that “ the evidence is not believable to rely on the last
seen theory ”. However, the High Court relied upon their
testimonies without addressing the 58-day delay or
providing any reasoning for reversing the said finding
of the Trial Court. Thus, we are of the view that where
the delay in recording the statements remains
20

completely unexplained, the “last seen” evidence is not
conclusively established and was rightly rejected by the
Trial Court.
12. The prosecution further sought to establish the dumping of
the dead body inside an iron drum near the limestone kiln by
the appellant. It is observed that while the homicidal nature
of the death caused by ligature strangulation is established
by medical evidence, the narrative of the prosecution
regarding the concealment of the body has inconsistencies.
12.1. The complainant (PW-1) stated in his complaint that on
the day before the incident as there was no business,
the remaining lime was placed into a drum belonging to
one Huligemma and was covered with plastic to shield
it from the rain. The following morning, around 9:00 AM
on 05.09.2013, the complainant received a phone call
alerting him that a woman’s body was inside their lime
drum and upon hearing the news, he immediately
arrived at the lime burning site where he discovered the
body of a woman with her limbs folded inside the drum,
after which he alerted all the workers present at the
site.
21

12.2. At this stage, it is relevant to observe that the
investigating agency neither traced nor examined this
informant. Furthermore, neither the inquest report nor
the post-mortem report prepared by Dr. Raju G.M. (PW-
16) reveals any trace or stain of limestone on the
clothing or the person of the deceased. Thus, we are of
the opinion that this circumstance as well creates
doubt as to the veracity of the prosecution version
regarding the discovery of the body.
12.3. In addition, the Trial Court acquitted the appellant of
the charge under Section 201 IPC, observing that none
of the prosecution witnesses examined before the court,
including the investigating officer, stated that the
appellant had placed the dead body of the deceased in
a barrel with the intention of causing the disappearance
of evidence. Significantly, the State did not file an
appeal to the acquittal of the appellant under Section
201 IPC and consequently, the acquittal under Section
201 IPC has attained finality.
13. This brings us to the circumstance heavily relied upon by the
courts below, namely, the recovery of ornaments under
22

Section 27 Evidence Act. The High Court held that the
identification of the ornaments by PW-8 (son), PW-10 (niece)
and PW-11 (cousin), all relatives of the deceased, gives
credibility to the prosecution case that the ornaments
belonged to the deceased, were missing from her person and
were recovered at the instance of the appellant from his
house, thereby connecting the appellant to the crime. The
High Court further observed that, apart from a bare denial,
the appellant offered no explanation for being in possession
of the said ornaments. However, in the present case, we are
of the view that the recovery itself is doubtful in the following
circumstances:
13.1. On perusal of the record, the seizure mahazar (Ex. P-7)
was signed by 3 panch witnesses, one Ashok,
Mehaboob Basha (PW-12) and PW-23 (the
goldsmith/appraiser). Ashok was not examined by the
prosecution and PW-23 in his deposition failed to
mention the attendance of Ashok during the
proceedings. Both PW-12 and PW-23 did not testify to
the disclosure statement made by the appellant in
police custody that led to the discovery during the
23

recovery procedure. Thus, in the absence of cogent
evidence from any independent witness supporting the
statement of disclosure made by the appellant, the
essential prerequisites under Section 27 Evidence Act
remain unsatisfied in the facts of the present case.
Additionally, PW-12 admitted in his cross-examination
that the contents of the seizure mahazar were dictated
entirely by PW-24 (CPI), that he did not personally know
what was written therein and that he did not know the
door number or ownership of the house from which the
trunk was retrieved. While PW-12 claimed that all 3
persons signed both spot mahazar and seizure mahazar
(Ex. P-6 and Ex. P-7), PW-23 admitted in his cross-
examination that his signature on Ex. P-6 (spot
mahazar) was struck out without explanation and that
the police had obtained his signature on only one
document that day. At this stage, it is relevant to note
that if his signature was already affixed on the spot
mahazar (Ex. P-6), the prosecution has failed to explain
how his signature also appears on seizure mahazar (Ex.
P-7). Furthermore, PW-23 admitted that he is a regular
24

police witness who has examined gold and silver
articles and given statements in multiple cases for the
Harapanahalli Police Station over many years, that he
did not even carry a weighing machine with him at the
time of the seizure and that the seized articles were
ordinary ornaments commonly available in the market.
13.2. Additionally, to establish a link through recovery, the
prosecution was required to prove not merely
ownership, but that the deceased was actually wearing
the said ornaments when she was last seen alive.
However, on perusal of the record, it is evident that no
statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. of the relatives of
the deceased was recorded identifying the seized jewels
as those worn by the deceased when she was last seen
alive. PW-13 and PW-14, the “last seen” witnesses, did
not mention any jewellery worn by the deceased.
Further, although PW-8 (the son) identified the
deceased’s jewellery, he had left the deceased a day
earlier and could not testify to what she wore at the time
of leaving. While PW-10 (niece) and PW-11 (cousin)
deposed to having observed certain ornaments on the
25

deceased upon her departure, neither witness deposed
to witnessing her leave with the appellant. It is also to
be noted that according to the I.O. (PW-24), the
statements of PW-10 and PW-11 were not recorded
until after the arrest of the appellant and PW-10 herself
admitted in cross-examination that the police never
examined her. Therefore, the prosecution completely
failed to establish that the deceased was actually
wearing the recovered ornaments when she was last
seen alive with the appellant. In addition, learned
counsel for the appellant rightly submitted that the
foundational premise of the prosecution’s case is that
there existed an ongoing and intimate relationship
between the deceased and the appellant and thus it is
natural and plausible that some of her belongings,
including ornaments, might have been kept or left at
his house in the ordinary course of their association.
13.3. Furthermore, the timeline of the recovery is
contradicted by the deposition of PW-13. The case of the
prosecution is that the ornaments were recovered 8
days after the incident upon arrest of the appellant.
26

However, PW-13 admitted in cross-examination that on
the following day of the incident, the police visited the
village for investigation, asking him to accompany them
and informed him that the deceased’s earrings and gold
effects had already been found at the residence of the
appellant.
13.4. It is also pertinent to note that the sole motive advanced
by the prosecution and accepted by the courts below
was that the appellant committed murder of the
deceased on account of an illicit relationship between
them coupled with suspicion regarding her character.
Thus, where the motive of the offence is rooted in
personal animosity arising out of such a relationship,
the prosecution did not establish any motive or intent
for the appellant to commit theft of her jewellery.
Significantly, no charge was framed against the
appellant under Section 379, 392 or 404 IPC for theft
or robbery, as the prosecution tried him exclusively for
offences punishable under Sections 302 and 201 IPC.
13.5. It is well settled by a three-judge bench of this Court in
Sanwat Khan v. State of Rajasthan (supra) and
27

reaffirmed in Raj Kumar @ Raju v. State (NCT of
Delhi) (supra), that the unexplained possession of
stolen articles belonging to the deceased merely enables
a presumption under Illustration (a) to Section 114
Evidence Act regarding theft or receipt of stolen
property. Therefore, in the present case, in the absence
of cogent evidence showing that the robbery/theft and
murder formed part of the same transaction, we are of
the view that such recovery, by itself, cannot be
stretched to infer guilt of the appellant for murder
under Section 302 IPC.
14. At this stage, it is pertinent to reiterate the observation made
in the decision of this Court in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v.
10
State of Maharashtra , that “ Certainly, it is a primary
principle that the accused must be and not merely may be
guilty before a court can convict and the mental distance
between ‘may be’ and ‘must be’ is long and divides vague
conjectures from sure conclusions. ”

10
(1973) 2 SCC 793.
28

15. On a holistic consideration of the evidence on record, the
chain of circumstantial evidence cannot be said to be
complete and unbroken. The prosecution has failed to
establish the circumstances pointing conclusively to the guilt
of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt. The findings of
guilt recorded by the Trial Court and confirmed by the High
Court are based on conjectures and surmises. Therefore, the
appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt and the conviction
under Section 302 IPC cannot be sustained in law.
16. For the aforesaid reasons, the appeal is allowed. Accordingly,
the conviction of the appellant under Section 302 IPC as well
as the sentence of imprisonment for life and fine imposed by
the Trial Court in Sessions Case No. 101 of 2014 and affirmed
by the High Court of Karnataka in the final judgment and
order dated 09.07.2024 in Criminal Appeal No. 1355 of 2017,
are hereby quashed and set aside, however, the acquittal of
the appellant under Section 201 IPC by the Trial Court is
maintained. Consequently, the appellant is acquitted for the
offence punishable under Section 302 IPC.
29

17. Since the appellant is presently in custody undergoing the
sentence of life imprisonment, he shall be released forthwith,
unless his presence is required for any other case.
18. Pending interlocutory application(s), if any, shall stand
disposed of accordingly.

……………………………………J.
[PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA]

……………………………………J.
[VIPUL M. PANCHOLI]

NEW DELHI
NOVEMBER 18, 2026
30