Rais Ahmad vs State Of U.P. And 3 Others

Court
Allahabad High Court

Order Reserved On:-15.10.2026
Order Delivered On:-17.11.2026
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
CRIMINAL MISC. WRIT PETITION No. - 21793 of 2026
Rais Ahmad
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
State Of U.P. And 3 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Prarabadh Jain
Counsel for Respondent(s) : G.A.

Court No. - 43
HON'BLE SIDDHARTH, J.
HON'BLE VINAI KUMAR DWIVEDI, J.
(Delivered by Hon'ble Siddharth,J.)
1. Heard Mr. Prarabadh Jain, learned counsel for the petitioner and learned
AGA for State and perused the material on record.
2 The present writ petition has been filed seeking the following reliefs:
.
"(I) Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari, calling for the
record of History Sheet Register No. 8 of Police Station Chandausi and
quashing Entry No. HS-22A maintained at Police Station Chandausi,
District Moradabad;
(II) Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus commanding
the respondents to ensure compliance with the rule of law and restraining
them from making domiciliary visits to the petitioner's house on the basis of
Entry No. HS-22A maintained at Police Station Chandausi, District
Moradabad;
(III) Issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of mandamus commanding
the State respondents to ensure compliance with the rule of law by directing
an inquiry into the illegal retention of Entry No. HS-22A, maintained at
Police Station Chandausi, District Moradabad, without any offence
prescribed under Rule 228, Chapter XX of the U.P. Police Regulations, and
to compensate the petitioner for the mental agony suffered by him;

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
2
(IV) Issue any other writ, order or direction which this Hon'ble Court may
deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the present case."
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the facts giving rise to the
present petition, in brief, are that the petitioner is a permanent resident of
Mohalla Nonwala, Qasba Chandausi, Police Station Chandausi (the then
District Moradabad). However, he shifted long ago and has since been
residing at Mohalla Chevda Nai Basti, Amroha. The petitioner runs a shop
under the name and style of "Shan Bangles Store" at Shop No. 1, Bazar
Shafatpota, Amroha, through which he earns his livelihood and maintains his
family. Although the petitioner is a respectable person in the locality, owing
to electoral enmity and local political rivalry, he was falsely implicated in
Case Crime No. 61 of 2005, under Sections 147, 148, 149 and 307 IPC,
Police Station Chandausi, then District Moradabad. At the time of his arrest
in the aforesaid case, the police also implicated him in another case, being
Case Crime No. 63 of 2025, under Section 25 of the Arms Act, Police
Station Chandausi, then District Moradabad. However, after trial, the
petitioner was acquitted by judgment and order dated 28.03.2006 passed by
the Additional District and Sessions Judge/FTC-5, Moradabad, in S.T. No.
575 of 2005, State versus Rais and others. A true copy of the judgment and
order of acquittal dated 28.02.2006 is being filed herewith and marked as
Annexure No. 2 to the writ petition. The petitioner was also falsely
implicated in Case Crime No. 28 of 2005, under Sections 395, 397, 412 and
120-B IPC, Police Station Chandausi, then District Moradabad. In this case
also, he was acquitted by judgment and order dated 06.02.2007 passed by
the Additional District Judge, Court No. 11, Moradabad, in S.T. No. 862 of
2005, State versus Mohit and others.
4. It has been submitted that, on the basis of the aforesaid two cases, the
concerned police authorities initiated proceedings against the petitioner
under the U.P. Gangsters Act by registering Case Crime Nos. 137 to 140 of
2005, under Section 3(1) of the Gangsters Act, Police Station Chandausi,
then District Moradabad. In these proceedings also, the petitioner was
acquitted by judgment and order dated 27.07.2007 passed by the Additional
District Judge/Special Judge, Gangsters Act, Moradabad, in S.S.T. No. 9 of
2006, State versus Rais and others. A true copy of the judgment and order of
acquittal dated 27.07.2007 is being filed herewith and marked as Annexure
No. 4 to the writ petition. It is relevant to mention that, on account of the
petitioner's implication in the aforesaid cases, including the proceedings
under the Gangsters Act, the respondent authorities recorded his name in the
Class-A History Sheet maintained in Register No. 8, bearing Entry No. HS-
22A. On the basis of the said entry, the respondent authorities have
continuously infringed the petitioner's fundamental rights guaranteed under
Article 21 of the Constitution of India by making frequent domiciliary visits
to his house. Aggrieved by the aforesaid police atrocities, the petitioner
repeatedly approached the District Magistrate and the Superintendent of
Police, requesting them to expunge Entry No. HS-22A. However, his
requests yielded no result.

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
3
5 . Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that, as per the
provisions contained in Chapter XX, Part II of the U.P. Police Regulations,
the petitioner's aforesaid History Sheet ought to have been expunged after
the expiry of two years, as there had been no recurrence of offences relating
to dacoity, burglary, cattle theft, railway goods wagon theft or abetment
thereof. However, owing to the illegal omission on the part of the respondent
police officials, the Class-A History Sheet continues to be maintained
against the petitioner. Taking shelter under the continued maintenance of the
aforesaid Class-A History Sheet, the police personnel of Police Station
Chandausi have been violating the petitioner's fundamental rights by making
frequent domiciliary visits to his residence. At the cost of repetition, it is
submitted that the petitioner earns his livelihood by running a bangle shop
and has not been implicated in any criminal case for nearly two decades.
Nevertheless, his fundamental right to lead a dignified life is being infringed
illegally by the respondents. The respondent police, despite being an
instrumentality of a welfare State, have failed to expunge the petitioner's
Class-A History Sheet in accordance with the prescribed procedure.
Consequently, the petitioner and his family are being subjected to
harassment and mental agony. The petitioner further submits that his
children are growing up in an atmosphere of continuous police harassment,
which may adversely affect their future prospects and personality. The
actions of the respondents are illegal, arbitrary and contrary to law.
Therefore, interference by this Hon'ble Court is warranted to secure the ends
of justice.
6. In the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the State respondents, it has
been stated that, having regard to the criminal antecedents of the petitioner,
History Sheet No. 22-A was opened against him. It has further been
submitted that the petitioner was acquitted in Case Crime Nos. 61/2005,
63/2005, 28/2005 and 137–140/2005 because no one dared to depose against
him. It is, therefore, contended that surveillance of the petitioner is necessary
and that his History Sheet was accordingly opened. It has also been
submitted that the petitioner has an alternative remedy of making a
representation to the Superintendent of Police, Chandausi, under the U.P.
Police Regulations, but instead, he has directly approached this Court. The
respondents deny any violation of law or constitutional provisions and
contend that the writ petition is devoid of merit and deserves to be
dismissed.
7 . Having heard the rival submissions advanced by learned counsel for the
parties, before proceeding further, it is necessary to examine the relevant
legal provisions.
8. A Division Bench of this Court, in Criminal Misc. Writ Petition No. 9174

of 2022, Aftab Alam Vs. State of U.P. and two others , had occasion to
consider the object behind opening History Sheets, observing as follows:-

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
4
"3. When the term "history-sheeter" is mentioned, it conjures an image of a
seasoned criminal with an extensive record. The question arises: who
exactly are these history-sheeters, and how does the police categorize
someone as such? What disadvantages does a criminal face after being
labeled a history-sheeter, and what consequences does it entail? These
queries find answers in the following exploration.
4. In essence, a history sheeter is a designation employed by the police to
identify individuals with a significant criminal history. This label is affixed
to those who have been implicated in numerous offenses, with the details of
their criminal activities duly recorded by the police. Before initiating the
history sheet for any offender, the police verify the individual's current
criminal status.
5. The process begins when an individual, already proven guilty in multiple
cases and/or consistently engaging in criminal activities, attracts the
attention of the police station's SHO. A report is subsequently sent to the
SSP or SP, and upon receiving the necessary orders, the history sheet is
opened. This comprehensive document contains detailed information about
the criminal, including a criminal profile, associates, and known relatives.
In certain scenarios, where individuals hesitate to report crimes related to
organized rackets or extortion, the police, relying on local sources, maintain
surveillance on such potential threats to society. The opening of history
sheets is guided by calls, daily entries in the police control room, and the
ongoing assessment of those posing a danger to society.
6. The presence of a history sheet serves as a deterrent, as it subjects the
criminals to constant police scrutiny. Once a history sheet is opened, the
criminals are required to regularly register their presence at the police
station; failure to comply prompts the police authorities to visit their
residences. Furthermore, a history sheet aids in tracing the source of income
for criminals, enabling authorities to determine whether they have
transitioned to legitimate means of earning. This scrutiny helps identify
instances where an individual, previously engaged in illegal activities,
displays signs of leading a luxurious lifestyle despite being unemployed.
7. The process of opening "History Sheet" is governed by the Police Rules of
the concerned State or the Act governing habitual offenders.
8. Criminals often attempt to evade capture by frequently changing
addresses. To counter this, the police communicate with other districts or
States, sharing information about potential areas of relocation and
requesting vigilant monitoring. Employing various strategies like crime
mapping and identifying hot spots, law enforcement aims to curb criminal
activities and maintain public safety.

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
5
9. History sheets are analogous to our criminal intelligence databases, but
are more subject to legal constraints. At the same time, they are more
vulnerable to public disclosure because they call for intensive and frequently
conspicuous monitoring both by police and civilian leaders.
10. Since the days of the British regime, Indian police departments have
created history sheets for persons believed to pose a risk of future
criminality. The "history-sheeters" may have been convicted, or have
criminal charges pending. History sheeters are subject to monitoring and
surveillance. In India, the system of maintaining criminal record varies from
State to State. All States require automatic creation of a history sheet for
persons with certain criminal records. For example, Tamil Nadu requires
creation of a history sheet for a person convicted once of a serious violent
crime, twice for house breaking, three times for theft and certain other
offenses. The police generally also have discretion to create a history sheet
on an individual who has not been convicted, but whom police consider
"addicted to crime" or a threat to public order. The police must have an
articulate reason for creating a history sheet and they must notify the
record-subject that a history sheet has been opened.
11. The police, with the assistance of the village officials are obliged to
surveil and record information about the activities and movements of
history-sheeters who reside in their jurisdiction. There are court restrictions
and police best practise guidelines, varying from State to State, on the level
of permissible monitoring and surveillance. There are many factors
regulating when a history sheet can be opened, how long it can be kept and
the intensity of surveillance that it authorizes. Courts have held that
surveillance of history-sheeters must not be excessive. For example, some
State courts and some police agencies have issued guidelines stating that
first-time history-sheeters should be especially closely watched; surveillance
should be discrete; domiciliary visits are not permitted; family members
must not be harassed; police officers should make periodic and routine
inquiries about the history-sheeter’s habits, associations, income,
expenses and occupation; the police officers shall record history-
sheeter’s movements and absences from his domiciliary home or area
where he lives, and the like guidelines.
12. The history sheet has been subject to constitutional challenge on privacy
grounds. The Supreme Court has recognized that police surveillance based
upon a history sheet implicates a limited right to privacy implicit in the
Constitutional right to life and personal liberty. According to the Court,
every individual’s autonomy should be respected; there is a right to be
left alone. However, the right to privacy is not absolute and the creation of a
history sheet and surveillance of the history-sheeter is not unconstitutional if
carried out in compliance with legal standards or, in the absence of
standards, if conducted reasonably. In one case, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court struck down home visits as infringing on the right to personal liberty

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
6
and freedom of movement.
13. Police is supposed to update the file periodically with both favorable and
unfavorable information gathered via routine police patrols and enquiries.
Such information should be recorded impartially, not with an eye toward
compiling a negative case against the record-subject. The history sheet,
including a photo of the history-sheeter, is a confidential record. The police
is not authorized to disclose to public or private employers whether a job
applicant or employee is a history-sheeter, much less what information the
history sheet contains. However, the surveillance/crime control purpose of
the history sheet requires that police officers have easy access to the history
sheet. Local police can only monitor and surveil record-subjects if they know
who they are. The history sheet is supposed to be shared with the Railway
Police. If the history-sheeter moves to another jurisdiction, the history sheet
is transferred to the new "jurisdiction" police department. Moreover, for
proper reasons, the police may show the public a history-sheeter’s
photos, when necessary, to capture a fugitive or solve a crime.
14. In sum, Indian law and policy recognize that police records, though
necessary for crime control, implicate privacy and individual autonomy. The
courts have struggled to regulate the history sheet system by providing court
review for individuals objecting to their history sheet designation and by
limiting police discretion to open, maintain and conduct surveillance.
15. When above is the situation and philosophy behind opening of history
sheets and to keep the history sheeters on surveillance depending on the
circumstances, can it be said that opening of history sheet or continuing with
the surveillance is stigmatic in so far as the individual is concerned and
whether permanent closure of history sheet or its quashing by a court of law
would at all be justified? The answer would be " No. The reason is that the
police needs a mechanism to control the crime, both individual and
organized. Surveillance of suspects, habitual and potential offenders, may be
necessary and so the maintenance of history sheet and surveillance register
for the purpose of prevention of crime. Permissible surveillance is only to
the extent of a close watch over the movements of the person under
surveillance and no more. Further, transfer of police officials from one
place to other on frequent basis is a normal phenomenon in India. During
their short tenure at a particular place of posting, concerned police officers
may have some inputs about a criminal but after they leave that particular
place and new officer joins, as to what would be the data available with the
new incumbent to know about the criminal activities in a particular area,
village or city, is a matter of significance. Past record, including a history
sheet as well as record of keeping a history sheeter under surveillance,
therefore, would then be a guiding factor. A history sheet, therefore, is
simply a sacrosanct idea to have inputs and information about criminals and
their past record for a better police administration."

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
7
9. Provisions concerning history sheets, as contained under U.P. Police
Regulations are reproduced as under:-
"228. Part V consists of history sheets. These are the personal records of
criminals under surveillance. History-sheets should be opened only for
persons who are or likely to become habitual criminal or abettors of such
criminals. There will be two classes of history-sheets:
(1) Class A history-sheets for dacoits, burglars, cattle-thieves, railway-
goods wagon thieves, and abettors thereof.
(2) Class B history-sheets for confirmed and professional criminals who
commit crimes other than dacoity, burglary, cattle-theft, and theft from
railway goods wagons, e.g., professional cheats and other experts for whom
criminal personal files are maintained by the Criminal Investigation
Department, poisoners, cattle poisoners, railway passenger thieves, bicycle
thieves, expert pick-pockets, forgers, coiners, cocaine and opium smugglers,
hired ruffians and goondas, telegraph wire-cutters, habitual illicit distillers
and abettors thereof.
History-sheets of both classes will be maintained in similar form, but those
for class B will be distinguished by a red bar marked at the top of the first
page. No history-sheet of class B may be converted into a history-sheet of
class A, though should be the subject of a history-sheet of class B be found to
be also addicted to dacoity, burglary, cattle-theft or theft from railway goods
wagons. A class, as well as B class, surveillance may under paragraph 238
be applied to him. In the event of a class A history-sheet man becoming
addicted to miscellaneous crime his history-sheet may be converted into a
class B history-sheet with the sanction of the Superintendent.
229. This classification of history-sheets as A and B is based on the principle
that, whereas there is always hope of a dacoit, burglar, or cattle thief or
railway goods wagons thief mending his ways, the expert miscellaneous
criminal is as a general rule incapable of reform. The classification,
therefore, solely on the kind of crime to which suspects are addicted and is
designed to regulate only-
(1) the length of time for which a suspect should ordinarily remain, under
surveillance in the absence of complaints against him, (2) the kind of
surveillance which his activities require.
The degree of surveillance of the appropriate kind to be exercised over a
suspect will depend not on his classification, but on the extent to which he is
believed to be active at any particular time.

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
8
230. If the subject of an A class history-sheet is thought to be so dangerous
or incorrigible as to require more protracted surveillance than the
generality of his class, he may be ''started' by the order of the
Superintendent. Here, again, the fact that a history-sheet man is started will
necessarily indicate only that he is to be kept under continuous surveillance
for a longer period. It will not necessarily indicate that his surveillance
while it lasts is to be more intense. The aim is to concentrate the most
intense surveillance on the criminal, whether starred or unstarred, who is
believed to be temporarily active.
Superintendent of district police may not give orders for the starring of or
discontinuance of surveillance over any history- sheeter of a railway police
suspect without the concurrence of the Superintendent of Government
Railway Police.
231. The subjects of history-sheets of class A will unless they are ''starred'
remain under surveillance for at least two consecutive year of which they
have spent no part in jail. When the subject of a history-sheet of class A
whose name has not been ''starred' who has never been convicted of
cognizable offence and has not been in jail or suspected of any offence or
absented himself in suspicious circumstances for two consecutive years his
surveillance will be discontinued, unless for special reasons to be recorded
in the inspection book of the police station the Superintendent decides that it
should continue.
When the subject of a history-sheet of class A is ''starred' he will remain
starred for at least two consecutive years during which he has not been in
jail or been suspected of a cognizable offence or had any suspicious absence
recorded against him. At the end of that period if he is believed to have
reformed he will cease to be ''starred' but will remain subject to surveillance
will be discontinued only if during that period no complaints have been
recorded against him.
In closing the history-sheets of an ''unstarring' ex-convicts and especially ex-
convict dacoits great care should be exercised.
232. "Class History Sheets"- History-sheet of class will be continuously
open records and the subjects of these sheets will, except for very special
reasons remain under surveillance until death. This being so it is
unnecessary to "star" suspects of this class.
233. The discontinuance of surveillance of the subject of a history-sheet does
not entail closing that history-sheet. A history-sheet which is only a record
of information need never be considered closed. In the case of persons
whose surveillance is discontinued a note should be made to this effect in the
history-sheet, and thereafter no periodical or other entries need be made

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
9
unless something comes to notice which it is desirable to enter in the sheet.
Sheets persons whose surveillance has been discontinued should remain in
these village crime-note book but if the number is as much as to make the
volume too bulky, they should be kept in a separate volume attached to the
note-book. They will only be destroyed on the death of the subject of the
sheet, or if, on opinion of the Superintendent their further retention is not
likely to be of any value.
234. No history-sheet of class A may be discontinued without the sanction of
the Superintendent of Police. If it is denied to discontinue the surveillance of
the subject of a history sheet of class B, the sanction of the Deputy
Inspector-General or Superintendent, Railway Police, must be obtained.
Proposals from station officers for the discontinuance of history-sheets and
for the ''starring or unstarring' of a class suspects must be made through the
circle inspector unless dealt with directly by a gazetted officer in the course
of an inspection.
240. History-sheets of both classes may be opened (1) on suspicion or (2) on
conviction or acquittal. No history-sheet may be opened without the orders
of the Superintendent of Police.
(1) On suspicion.- Whenever as a result of investigation into a case of
dacoity, burglary, cattle theft from railway goods wagons or into a case of
miscellaneous crime of a professional type, the officer-in-charge of a police
station applies for the name of any person to be entered in the crime register
as reasonably suspected, he must at the same time report whether the
suspect is under surveillance, and if not, whether a history-sheet should in
his opinion be opened for him. Should the gazetted officer-in-charge of a
subdivision on receiving such a report and after such further inquiry as he
may think necessary consider that a history-sheet is required he will forward
the report to the Superintendent who if he accepts the proposal will define
the class of history-sheet to be opened and pass orders as to whether the
suspect should be ''starred'. Similarly whenever an officer-in-charge of a
police station finds reason to believe, otherwise than in the course of an
investigation, that any resident of his circle is addicted to crime, or
whenever a gazetted officer or circle inspector for any reason believes that a
history-sheet for any person is necessary a report must be submitted to the
Superintendent, who will pass orders on it as laid down above.
(2) On conviction or acquittal.- Whenever any person is sent for trial on a
charge of dacoity, burglary, cattle theft or theft from a railway goods
wagons or of miscellaneous crime of a professional type, the officer-in-
charge of the police station must state in his diary whether the accused has a
history-sheet and if not, whether he recommends that a history-sheet should
be opened for him. It will be the duty of the public prosecutor, if the accused
is acquitted to inform the Superintendent, in his report on the acquittal or
otherwise, whether in his opinion a history-sheet is required. On this the

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
10
Superintendent will pass any orders to the station officer that may be
necessary. If the accused is convicted, the public prosecutor must, in the
remarks column of the daily report of convictions and acquittals (Form No.
107) enter in red ink the words, ''On H.S.' if a history-sheet is already open,
or the letters ''H.S.' if he recommends that one should be prepared. In either
case he must prepare and attach to the daily report of convictions and
acquittals a P.R. slip (Form No. 313). If a history-sheet is already open or if
the Superintendent agrees that a history-sheet should be opened he will sign
this P.R. slip and initial the letters ''H.S.' or ''On H.S.' on the daily report of
convictions and acquittals. The public prosecutor will then communicate the
Superintendent's orders for the opening of a history-sheet to the police
station concerned and will forward the P.R. slip to the Superintendent of
Jail. If no history-sheet is opened and if the Superintendent does not agree
that one should be prepared, he will not sign the P.R. slip, which will be
cancelled"
10. To arrive at a just and proper conclusion, it is necessary to consider what
are the parameters that should be followed by the police before opening
history-sheet of a person.
11. There is a whole chapter in the Police Regulation, namely, Chapter XX
with a Heading called "REGISTRATION AND SURVEILLANCE OF BAD
CHARACTERS". The entire Chapter consists of Regulation 223 to
Regulation 276. Relevant Regulations for our purpose would be Regulations
223 to 252. A perusal of these regulations shows that the entire tone and
tenor of these regulations reflect the then colonial state of mind as it speaks
of "Criminal Tribe Act", (an Act, which has already been repealed in the
year 1956) and further provisions are also reflective of a bygone colonial era
where a group or individuals or castes were recorded as "criminal tribes" and
put under surveillance. It speaks of "habitual criminals" and not only this it
goes on to say that there are certain types of criminals, who are "incapable of
reform".
12. The challenge here is limited, but legality of the various provisions of the
"Police Regulations", appear to be draconian. Reference to the seemingly
repulsive provisions of the Police Regulations is to give an idea of the time
and era when such Regulations were framed under the Police Act, 1861.
13. Regulation 228 of the Police Regulations speaks about two classes of
history-sheets ''Class-A' and ''Class-B'. Class A is a history-sheet for dacoits,
burglars, cattle-thieves, railway-goods wagon thieves, and abettors thereof
and Class B is history-sheet for confirmed and professional criminals who
commit crimes other than dacoity, burglary, cattle-theft, and theft from
railway goods wagons, e.g., professional cheats and other experts for whom
criminal personal files are maintained by the Criminal Investigation
Department.

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
11
14. For the authors of this Police Regulations, the two set of crimes (i.e.
Class ''A' and Class ''B') are of entirely different nature. Regulation 228 of
the U.P. Police Regulations further states that though the manner in which
the records of surveillance and manner in which the history-sheet is to be
opened in Class ''A' or in Class ''B' is the same, yet where a Class ''B' history-
sheet is opened it has to be opened with a red bar mark at the top of the first
page and never can Class ''B' history-sheeter be converted into a Class ''A'
history-sheeter, though in case, a person, who is under Class ''B' is also seen
of indulging in crime relating to history Class ''A' then surveillance of both
types of crimes have to be opened against him. However, it is possible that
the history-sheeter of Class ''A' is converted into a history-sheeter of Class
''B'.
15. Normally one has to assume that since history-sheet of Class ''A' carries
with it crimes of greater magnitude such as dacoity, burglary etc., the
history-sheet opened in such cases is of a more serious nature. But this is not
true, in fact reverse is the truth. As per Regulation 229 of the U.P. Police
Regulations the classification of history-sheet as "Class A" and "Class B" are
based on the principle that whereas there is always hope of a dacoit,
burglars, or cattle thieves or railway-goods wagons thief mending his ways,
the expert miscellaneous criminal (of Class ''B' history-sheet) is as a general
rule "incapable of reform". The classification, therefore, is solely on the kind
of crime to which suspects are addicted to and it is designed to regulate.
Regulation 229 of the Police Regulations reads as under:-
"229. This classification of history-sheets as A and B is based on the
principle that, whereas there is always hope of a dacoit, burglar, or cattle
thief or railway goods wagons thief mending his ways, the expert
miscellaneous criminal is as a general rule incapable of reform. The
classification, therefore, solely on the kind of crime to which suspects are
addicted and is designed to regulate only- (1) the length of time for which a
suspect should ordinarily remain, under surveillance in the absence of
complaints against him. (2) the kind of surveillance which his activities
require. The degree of surveillance of the appropriate kind to be exercised
over a suspect will depend not on his classification, but on the extent to
which he is believed to be active at any particular time."
16. There is a further classification of history-sheeters of Class ''A'. The
more serious nature of the persons under surveillance is the ''starred'
category. Their surveillance is more vigorous and have a greater length of
time whereas since a history-sheeter of Class ''B' is "incapable of reform", as
per the authors of the Police Regulations. The Regulations 232 of the Police
Regulations says that it is not necessary to star suspects of Class ''B'.
Regulation 232 of the Police Regulations reads as under:-
"232. History-sheet of B class will be continuously open records and the
subjects of these sheets will, except for every special reasons remain under

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
12
surveillance until death. This being so it is unnecessary to star suspects of
this class."
17. Director General of Police, U.P., vide communication dated 03.11.2022,
has framed guidelines under the U.P. Police Regulation to be followed by
the respective Police Officers while opening/reviewing the History Sheet
Class A category.
18. The guidelines read as thus:
"
ज्ञातव्य है कि उ०प्र० पुलिस रेगुलेशन के पैरा-228 में अभ्यासिक अपराधियों एवं उसके दुष्प्रेरक
शीर्षक के अन्तर्गत दोनों वर्गों की हिस्ट्रीशीट को वर्गीकृत किया गया है। वर्ग "क" की हिस्ट्रीशीट में
डकैत, सेंधमार, पशुचोर, रेल के डिब्बों के माल चोर और उसके दुष्प्रेरक वर्णित हैं, परन्तु दोनों वर्गों
के लिए शीर्ष पर जो महत्त्वपूर्ण विश्लेषित है, वह अभ्यासिक अपराधी शब्द है। वर्ग "क" की
हिस्ट्रीशीट को पुलिस रेगुलेशन के पैरा-231 के अन्तर्गत 02 वर्ष बाद पुर्नाविलोकित किये जाने की
प्रक्रिया अपनाए जाने का प्राविधान है, अतः मा० उच्च न्यायालय द्वारा निर्गत आदेश के आलोक में
हिस्ट्रीशीट खोले जाने की कार्यवाही को अधिक न्यायसंगत एवं वस्तुपरक बनाये जाने हेतु
निम्नलिखित दिशा-निर्देश निर्गत किये जा रहे हैं-
1-18
वर्ष से कम आयु के किसी भी व्यक्ति की हिस्ट्रीशीट नहीं खोली जायेगी।
2-
हिस्ट्रीशीट खोलने के लिए उ०प्र० पुलिस रेगुलेशन के पैरा 228 से 240 तक का गहन
अध्ययन करके उसी के अनुरूप कार्यवाही की जाये।
3-
हिस्ट्रीशीट ऐसे व्यक्तियों की खोली जाये जिनके बारे में यह विश्वास करने का युक्तियुक्त आधार
हो कि आदतन अपराधी है या हो सकता है। रूटीन में हिस्ट्रीशीट न खोली जाये।
i- Intense Surveillance)
हिस्ट्रीशीट ऐसे व्यक्तियों की खोली जाये जिनकी गहन निगरानी ( की
आवश्यकता हो।
ii-
जो ऐसे अपराधियों के दुष्प्रेरक हों अथवा उनका ऐसा होना सम्भावित हो।
iii-
निजी रंजिश में दर्ज अभियोगों अथवा अन्य असंगत आधारों पर किसी व्यक्ति की हिस्ट्रीशीट न
खोली जाये।

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
13
iv-
उत्तर प्रदेश गिरोहबंद और समाज विरोधी क्रियाकलाप अधिनियम/उ०प्र० गुण्डा नियंत्रण
अधिनियम के अन्तर्गत की गयी कार्यवाहियों को हिस्ट्रीशीट खोलने का आधार न बनाया जाये।
v-
चूंकि हिस्ट्रीशीट जनपद के पुलिस अधीक्षक के आदेश से खोली जाती है, अतः वे पूर्णतया
आधारों से संतुष्ट होने पर ही हिस्ट्रीशीट खोलने का अनुमोदन करें।
vi-
थाना प्रभारी द्वारा प्रेषित हिस्ट्रीशीट का सम्बन्चित क्षेत्राधिकारी एवं अपर पुलिस अधीक्षक द्वारा
सधन परीक्षण करने के उपरान्त ही वरिष्ठ पुलिस अधीक्षक पुलिस अधीक्षक द्वारा हिस्ट्रीशीट खोलने
अनुमोदित किया जाये।
4-
उत्तर प्रदेश पुलिस रेगुलेशन के पैरा 228 में 276 में वर्णित प्रावधानों के अन्तर्गत 18 वर्ष से
अधिक तथा 21 वर्ष तक के अपराधियों की हिस्ट्रीशीट खोलने से पूर्व वरिष्ठ अधीक्षक / पुलिस
अधीक्षक द्वारा सूचनार्थ पुलिस महानिरीक्षक, सी.बी.सी.आई.डी. को इस आशय से प्रेषित की
जायेगी कि उन्हें कोई आपत्ति हो तो पत्र प्राप्ति के दिनांक 15 दिवस के अन्दर वह अपनी टिप्पणी
सहित सम्बन्धित जिला मुख्यालयों को भेजेंगे।
5-
पुलिस महानिरीक्षक, सी.बी.सी.आई.डी. द्वारा यदि कोई आपत्ति व्यक्त की जाती है, तो जनपद
के वरिष्ठ पुलिस अधीक्षक/पुलिस अधीक्षक द्वारा प्रकरण का परीक्षण किया जायेगा एवं यदि अब
भी हिस्ट्रीशीट खोलने के लिए उपयुक्त पाया जाता है तो उसकी हिस्ट्रीशीट खोलकर इसकी सूचना
पुलिस महानिरीक्षक, सी.बी.सी.आई.डी. को प्रेषित की जायेगी।
6-
यदि पत्र की प्राप्ति के 15 दिनों के अन्दर पुलिस महानिरीक्षक, सी.बी.सी.आई.डी. द्वारा उक्त
प्रकरण में कोई आपत्ति नहीं की जाती है तो यह मान लिया जायेगा कि उनको वरिष्ठ पुलिस
अधीक्षक / पुलिस अधीक्षक द्वारा संस्तुत की गयी आख्या पर कोई आपत्ति नहीं है।
अतः आप सभी को निर्देशित किया जाता है कि उ०प्र० पुलिस रेगुलेशन के उपरोक्त पैरा एवं
मुख्यालय स्तर से निर्गत निर्देशों/परिपत्रों का पुनः गहनता से अध्ययन कर लें एवं जनपद स्तर पर
कार्यशाला का आयोजन कर अपने अधीनस्थ राजपत्रित अधिकारियों को विस्तार से अवगत करा दें
और यह भी सुनिश्चित करें कि इन निर्देशों का कड़ाई से अनुपालन किया जाए।
19. In background the facts of this case, this Court finds that the petitioner
was implicated in case crime no. 61/2025 under sections 147, 148, 149 and
307 IPC and connected case crime no. 63/2025 under section 25 of the Arms
Act, but he was acquitted by the trial court of the judgment dated
28.03.2006.

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
14
20. This has not been disputed by the respondent in their counter-affidavit,
thereafter, he was again implicated in case crime no. 28/2005, under section
395, 397, 412 and 120-B IPC and acquitted vide order dated 06.02.2007 by
the trial court on the basis of the aforesaid cases, he was implicated in case
crime no. 137-140 of 2005 under section 3(1) of the U.P. Gangsters Act
wherein also he was acquitted like in the base cases, but his history sheet has
opened in relevant register no. 08 bearing entry number HS-22A. Therefore,
at the time of opening of the history sheet against the petitioner, there was no
criminal case pending against him at all. The communication dated
03.11.2022 by the Director General of Police U.P. provides (3)(i) that
history sheet of person should not be opened routine manner, it should be
opened only where such persons are habitual offenders and need intense
surveillance. Implication in UP Gangsters Act and UP Goonda Act cannot be
ground for opening history sheet. The superintendent of Police should be
satisfied that history sheet of the person is required to be opened in the
present case.
21. We find that there is no reasoned order brought on record by State
showing any application of mind to the case of the petitioner for opening
history sheet.
22. Police regulation is a pre-independence regulation when the Constitution
of India had not come into existence, yet the requirements of Article 14 of
the Constitution of India do not appear to have been observed in the
acceptance of the report aforesaid and direction of opening history sheet
against the petitioners. Even in the statute/regulation/rule/ law where the
application of principle of natural justice has not been provided, the mandate
of Article 14 of the Constitution of India is required to be read in such
provisions.
23. The Apex Court in the case of
Mangi Lal Vs. State of M.P., (2004) 2
SCC 447 , has held in paragraph no.10 regarding the observance of mandate
of Article 14 of the Constitution of India as follows:-
"Even if a statute is silent and there are no positive words in the Act or Rules
made thereunder there could be nothing wrong in spelling out the need to
hear the parties whose rights and interest are likely to be affected, by the
orders that may be passed, and making it a requirement to follow a fair
procedure before taking a decision, unless the statute provides otherwise.
The principles of natural justice must be read into unoccupied interstices of
the statute, unless there is clear mandate to the contrary. No form or
procedure should ever be permitted to exclude the presentation of a litigant's
defence or stand. Even in the absence of a provision in procedural laws,
power inheres in every Tribunal/Court of a judicial or quasi-judicial
character, to adopt modalities necessary to achieve requirements of natural
justice and fair play to ensure better and proper discharge of their duties.
Procedure is mainly grounded on principles of natural justice irrespective of

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
15
the extent of its application by express provision in that regard in given
situation. It has always been a cherished principle. Where the statute is
silent about the observance of the principles of natural justice, such
statutory silence is taken to imply compliance with the principles of natural
justice where substantial rights of parties are considerably affected. The
application of natural justice becomes presumptive, unless found excluded
by express words of statute or necessary intendment. (See Swadesi Cotton
Mills etc. etc. v. Union of India etc. etc., AIR 1961 SC 818). Its aim is to
secure justice or to prevent miscarriage of justice. Principles of natural
justice do not supplant the law, but supplement it. These rules operate only
in areas not covered by any law validly made. They are means to an end and
not an end in themselves. The principles of natural justice have many facets.
Two of them are: notice of the case to be met, and opportunity to explain.
"96. The rule of natural justice with which we are concerned in these
appeals and writ petitions, namely, the audi alteram partem rule, in its
fullest amplitude means that a person against whom an order to his
prejudice may be passed should be informed of the allegations and charges
against him, be given an opportunity of submitting his explanation thereto,
have the right to know the evidence, both oral or documentary, by which the
matter is proposed to be decided against him, and to inspect the documents
which are relied upon for the purpose of being used against him, to have the
witnesses who are to give evidence against him examined in his presence
and have the right to cross-examine them, and to lead his own evidence,
both oral and documentary, in his defence. The process of a fair hearing
need not, however, conform to the judicial process in a Court of law,
because judicial adjudication of causes involves a number of technical rules
of procedure and evidence which are unnecessary and not required for the
purpose of a fair hearing within the meaning of audi alteram partem rule in
a quasi-judicial or administrative inquiry."
24. In the context of Article 19 of the Constitution of India, this Court has
considered the effect of opening of Class- "B" history sheets in the case of
Munna Lal Gupta Vs. State of U.P. and others, reported in 2016 SCC
Online All 3023 as follows:-
"9. It is apparent that there exists no justification for continuance of his
name being mentioned in history-sheet. It is also pertinent to know that four
cases mentioned in history-sheet relate to year 1982,1987 and 1988, but
according to the counter affidavit, this Class-B history-sheet was opened in
year 1979. None of the contentions of affidavit of petitioner filed alongwith
the writ petition was denied in counter affidavit and only this much was
mentioned that :
"However it is submitted that the history-sheet was opened by the
Superintendent of Police on the basis of report submitted before him
regarding involvement of petitioner in criminal case."

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
16
10. Thus it is apparent that without being involved in overt-act or any
criminal activity, the Class-B history-sheet was opened for the petitioner in
year 1979. It is evident that this history-sheet was opened without verifying
the facts and without application of mind. Therefore, we are satisfied that
there were no sufficient grounds for the Superintendent of Police to entertain
a reasonable belief that the surveillance was required in the case of
petitioner and there existed no evidence to support the fact that surveillance
of the petitioner was necessary.
11. Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India protects the fundamental
right of a citizen when it provides that 'all citizens shall have the right to
freedom of speech and expression.' Article 19(1)(d) of the Constitution
provides that 'all citizens shall have the right to move freely throughout the
territory of India.' Article 21 of the Constitution protects the fundamental
right of a citizen regarding his life and personal liberty when it reads that
'no person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according
to procedure established by law'. These fundamental rights are subject to
reasonable restrictions.
12. This leads us to the question as to whether the petitioner's fundamental
right under Art. 19 (1) (d) is also infringed by history sheet and surveillance.
What is the content of the said fundamental right ? It is argued for the State
that it means only that a person can move physically from one point to
another without any restraint. This argument ignores the adverb "Freely" in
clause (d). If that adverb is not in the clause there may be some justification
for this contention; but the adverb "freely" gives a larger content to the
freedom. Mere movement unobstructed by physical restrictions cannot in
itself be the object of a person's travel. A person travels ordinarily in quest
of some objective. He goes to a place to enjoy, to do business, to meet
friends, to have secret and intimate consultations with others and to do many
other such things. If a man is shadowed, his movements are obviously
constricted. He can move physically, but it can only be a movement of an
automaton. How could a movement under the scrutinizing gaze of the
policemen be described as a free movement? The whole country is his jail.
The freedom of movement in clause (d) therefore must be a movement in a
free country, i.e., in a country where he can do whatever he likes, speak to
whomsoever he wants, meet people of his own choice without any
apprehension, subject of course to the law of social control. The petitioner
under the shadow of surveillance is certainly deprived of this freedom. He
can move physically, but he cannot do so freely, for all his activities are
watched and noted. The shroud of surveillance cast upon him perforce
engender inhibitions in him and he cannot act freely as he would like to do.
13. Assuming that Art. 19(1)(d) of the Constitution must be confined only to
physical movements, its combination with the freedom of speech and
expression leads to the conclusion we have arrived at. The act of
surveillance is certainly a restriction on the said freedom? It cannot be

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
17
suggested that the said freedom is also bereft of its subjective or
psychological content, but will sustain only the mechanics of speech and
expression. An illustration will make our point clear. A visitor, whether a
wife, son or friend, is allowed to be received by a prisoner in the presence of
a guard. The prisoner can speak with the visitor; but, can it be suggested
that he is fully enjoying the said freedom. It is possible for him to express his
real and intimate thoughts to the visitor as fully as he would like. But the
restrictions on the said freedom are supported by valid law. To extend the
analogy to the present case is to treat the man under surveillance as a
prisoner within the confines of our country and the authorises enforcing
surveillance as guards, without any low of reasonable restrictions sustaining
or protecting their action. So understood, it must be held that the petitioner's
freedom under Art. 19(1)(a) of the constitution is also infringed.
14. In A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras, AIR 1950 SC 27 Hon'ble Apex
had held :
Court
"If a man's person is free, it is then and then only that he can exercise a
variety of other auxiliary rights, that is to say, he can within certain limits,
speak what he likes, assemble where he likes, form any associations or
unions, move about freely as his 'own inclination may direct', reside and
settle anywhere he likes and practise any profession or carry on any
occupation, trade or business. These are attributes of the freedom of the
person and are consequently attached to the person"
15. The petitioner under the shadow of surveillance is certainly deprived of
this freedom. Due to presence of such history-sheet, the petitioner is
deprived of his freedom of movement as well as right of privacy under the
shadow of surveillance by police. He can move physically, but he could not
do so freely for all his activities because he is watched and noted. After
knowledge of this history-sheet he could not act as freely as he would like to
do in absence of such history-sheet.
16. Where the police officer has not given any reason for his belief that the
petitioner was a desperate character, and a habitual offender, the history-
sheet opened against him is not in accordance with the mandate of the
relevant rules, and as such it would be just to order closure of such history-
sheet. The exercise of the power by the police under the cover of surveillance
which invades into personal liberty of the petitioner as regards his free
movement in day to day life, when there is no material to continue the
history-sheet for him, is violative of Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
17. For the reasons discussed above, we hold that Class-B history-sheet for
the petitioner Munna Lal Gupta was an erroneous act done without the facts
being verified and without reasonable satisfaction being reached or mind
being applied by the then Superintendent of Police. This history-sheet was

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
18
never reviewed because rules provided that Class-B history-sheet shall
continue till death."
25. When the police regulations regarding opening of history sheets were
made for the "subject Indians" by colonial rulers, no requirements of
observance of principles of natural justice were incorporated because the
State at that time was not a democratic State and therefore, whatever the
State decided was final. After promulgation of Constitution of India, the
requirements of observations of the rules of natural justice, enshrined in the
Article 14 of the Constitution of India, has become imperative. Its
observance is more required where the right to life, livelihood and liberty of
an individual is involved. The order of opening of history sheet is passed by
the Senior Officer of Police by only approving the report of the police
station. The opening of history sheet is not the same as implication of an
individual in a criminal case because of committing some crime. By opening
history sheet the police gets the right of surveillance of the history sheeter.
Whether the police report submitted before the higher police authority for
approval is correct or not is not considered nor the person sought to be made
a history sheeter is ever afforded opportunity to put his version against the
police report. After opening of Class-B history sheet, the history sheeter
remains under surveillance for life and his right to liberty is severely effected
in the name of surveillance. He is vulnerable to police dictate, threat and
coercion throughout his life. In such a situation subjecting a citizen of a
sovereign democratic State to surveillance cannot be said to be in
accordance of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India. Such a person
is condemned unheard. The concept of equality of law and equal protection
of law provided under Article 14 of the Constitution of India is brutally
violated. The offence enumerated for opening Class-A history sheet are
dacoity, burglary, cattle-theft railway-goods wagon theft and abetment
thereof. It is notable that the offences enumerated in the Class-A of his
history sheet are not much committed now. Therefore, the police has
unfettered power to implicate anyone on the basis of any offence by making
a report to the higher police authority for opening Class-B history sheet.
Considering the present state of affairs, rampant false implications, because
of personal and political rivalry, provisions regarding opening of history
sheets need to be reviewed. State has realized that the police regulations
regarding opening of history sheets are being misused and therefore the
guidelines dated 3.11.2022 were framed by Director General of Police, U.P.
providing for opening/reviewing of history sheets of Class-A only while no
such guideline has been issued for opening/review of Class-B history sheet.
Therefore, we find that the police has absolute powers of opening Class-B
history sheet against any citizen of the country on any pretext, like
implication in single case under Gangsters Act and implication of other
petitioners in one case of exhortation on account of personal/business rivalry
with the informant and implication in another case under Section 2/3 (1) of
Gangsters Act on its basis. The police is clearly acting against the mandate
of the Constitution of India laid down under Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the
Constitution of India on the basis of pre-independence regulations. It is high

CRLP No. 21793 of 2026
19
time that 23. this practice should be stopped and before opening of history
sheet of Class-A or Class-B against any citizen of the State, he should be
given one opportunity to submit his objection before it is accepted by higher
official of the police and before such officer directs opening of any Class of
history sheet against a citizen. While directing opening of history sheet of
Class -A and Class -B, the higher police authority shall record his reasons
for directing opening of history sheet of any Class after considering the
objection of the citizen filed against the report of the police station.
26. The State Government is directed to look into the procedure of opening
of history sheet and make/ issue necessary amendments/guidelines for
providing opportunity of objection to the person, against whom, the police
submits report recommending the opening of history sheet of Class-A or
Class-B before the Senior Police Official. The State Government will also
provide for review of the history sheets opened against the citizen, every
year, so that, in the cases where implication of persons against whom history
sheet was opened and who have been subsequently exonerated/acquitted of
the criminal charges, their history sheets are closed and shadow of
surveillance by police on their life and liberty gets removed.
27. The Registrar (Compliance) of this Court is directed to communicate this
order to the Principal Secretary (Home) State of U.P., Lucknow, within a
period of one week.
28. In view of the above consideration, the impugned history sheet opened
against the petitioner is hereby quashed.
29. The petition is .
allowed
29. The surveillance of the petitioner shall be stopped forthwith.
November 17, 2026.
Abhishek
(Vinai Kumar Dwivedi,J.) (Siddharth,J.)
Digitally signed by :-
ABHISHEK YADAV
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad