KAMALESH BHATTACHARYYA vs UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.

Court
Calcutta High Court

04
17.11.2026
Court No. 10
AGM


In The High Court At Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side


W.P.A 7689 of 2025

Kamelesh Bhattacharyya
-versus-
Union of India & Ors.


Mr. Abhratosh Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Avra Mazumder
Ms. Alisha Das
Ms. Elina Dey
Ms. Rupomita Ghosh
Ms. Vedika Agarwal
Ms. Saakshi Shaw
…For the Petitioner.

Mr. Amit Sharma
… For the respondent.


1. In the present writ petition, the petitioner has
inter alia, assailed the legality, validity and the
sustainability of the ex parte order of assessment dated
29.12.2024 passed by the Assessing Officer under
Section 144 read with Section 254 read with Section
144B of the Income Tax Authorities Act, 1961
(hereinafter referred to as the ‘said Act’) whereby an
addition of Rs. 11,34,745/- has been made to the total
income of the assessee as unexplained expenditure
under Section 69C of the said Act.
2. Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Abhratosh Majumder,
appearing for the petitioner submits that the order of

2
assessment passed by the Assessing Officer is in
pursuance of the order of remand dated 29.3.2023
passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal
(hereinafter referred to as the ‘said Tribunal’).
3. Thereafter, the Assessing Officer issued notices on
various dates, i.e., 25.09.2024 and 30.11.2024 much
after the order passed by the Income Tax Appellate
Tribunal.

4. It is further submitted that on 19.12.2024, the
assessee received a show cause notice, requesting him
to file the response electronically by 23.12.2024 at 11
hours.
5. Thereupon, on 24.12.2024, the assessee filed an
adjournment petition electronically, seeking
adjournment of the proceedings on the ground that
preparation of its reply was underway, as the same
could not be filed earlier, due to non receipt of the
earlier notices.
6. Thereafter, the Assessing Officer without
considering the adjournment petition submitted
electronically by the assessee, proceeded to pass the
assessment order ex parte.
7. Main grievance of the petitioner is that the
adjournment petition was not considered before passing
the assessment order ex parte.
8. It is further submitted that despite the order of
remand directing, the Assessing Officer, inter alia, to

3
revisit the issue, the Assessing Officer took no steps in
pursuance thereof for nearly one year. Thereafter, at a
belated stage, he sought to comply with the directions of
the Appellate Tribunal by issuing notices and calling for
a reply thereto. Such arbitrary action of the Assessing
Officer in passing the order ex parte violates the
principles of natural justice, is impermissible in law and
thus the ex parte assessment order is liable to be
quashed and set aside.

9. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
Income Tax Authorities vehemently opposes the
contention of the petitioner and submits that ample
opportunities were afforded to the assessee to reply to
the notices, but the petitioner chose not to file thereto.
It is also submitted that the assessment order passed
ex parte is an appealable order and the petitioner has
an alternative statutory efficacious remedy to assail the
order and to produce the relevant documents to
demonstrate the issue involved herein.
10. Learned counsel places reliance upon the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Commissioner of Income-tax –v.- Chhanil Dass
Agarwal reported in (2023) 36 taxmann. Com 36 (SC)
by relying upon paragraph no 20, which is reproduced
below:
“20. In the instant case , the Act provides complete
machinery for the assessment /re-assessment of tax,
imposition of penalty and for obtaining relief in respect
of any improper orders passed by the Revenue

4
Authorities , and the assessee could not be permitted to
abandon that machinery and to invoke the jurisdiction
of the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution
when he had adequate remedy open to him by an
appeal to the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals ).
The remedy under the statute, however, must be
effective and not a mere formality with no substantial
relief. In Ram & Shyam Co. v. State of Haryana [1985] 3
SCC 267 this Court has noticed that if an appeal is
from “Caesar to Caesar’s wife” the existence of
alternative remedy would be a mirage and an exercise
in futility. In the instant case, neither has the assessee-
writ petitioner described the available alternative
remedy under the Act as ineffectual and non-efficacious
while invoking the writ jurisdiction of the High Court nor
has the High Court ascribed cogent and satisfactory
reasons to have exercised its jurisdiction in the facts of
instant case. ”

11. It is submitted by the Income Tax authorities that
the said judgment lays down that where a statutory
mechanism for redressal of grievance has been created
by law, a writ petition should not be entertained,
ignoring the statutory dispensation.

12. In this context learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the petitioner also places reliance of the same
judgment by relying upon paragraph nos. 5 and 19,
which are reproduced below:
“ 5. The facts in brief are
………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………
…… The assessee sought for an adjournment which
was not granted and the assessments were completed
ex-parte under Section 144 of the Act raising a tax
demand of Rs. 2,45, 87, 625/- and Rs. 6,32,972/- for
assessment Years 1995-96 and 1996-97, respectively
by orders dated 09.07.2001 and 28.03.2001,
respectively. Further, penalty proceedings under Section
271(1)( c ) of the Act were also initiated for both
Assessment Years.

19. Thus, while it can be said that this Court has
recognized some exceptions to the rule of alternative
remedy, i.e. where the statutory authority has not
acted in accordance with the provisions of the
enactment in question, or in defiance of the
fundamental principles of judicial procedure, or has

5
resorted to invoke the provisions which are repealed, or
when an order has been passed in total violation of the
principles of natural justice , the proposition laid down
in Thansingh Nathmal v. Supdt. Of Taxes AIR 1964 SC
1419, Titaghur Paper Mills Co. Ltd. Case (supra ) and
other similar judgments that the High Court will not
entertain a petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution if an effective alternative remedy is
available to the aggrieved person or the statute under
which the action complained of has been taken itself
contains a mechanism for redressal of grievance still
holds the field. Therefore, when a statutory forum is
created by law for redressal of grievances, a writ
petition should not be entertained ignoring the
statutory dispensation.”

13. Having heard the parties at length and perusing
the materials on record including the documents
annexed to the writ petition as well as the
supplementary affidavit filed by the petitioner, this
Court finds that a prima facie case has been made out,
warranting interference at this stage. For balancing the
equities and for the ends of justice, this Court directs
the petitioner to file a reply to the show cause notice
dated 19.12.2024 within two weeks from date before the
concerned Assessing Officer and the same shall be
considered and disposed of within a period of four
weeks from the receipt of the reply by passing a
speaking and reasoned order in accordance with law,
upon affording an opportunity of personal hearing to
the petitioner. Such decision shall be communicated to
the petitioner within a week thereafter.
14. However, it is made clear that upon receipt of a
copy of this order from the petitioner, the Jurisdictional
Assessing Officer shall forthwith open the ITBA portal to

6
enable the petitioner to file the response to the show
cause notice for the assessment year 2017-18.
15. It is further made clear that the Assessing Officer
shall take an independent decision uninfluenced by the
observations made hereinabove. The petitioner shall not
seek unnecessary adjournment.
16. The Assessing Officer is directed to conclude the
entire proceeding peremptorily on or before 10.1.2027.

17. In view of the above, the assessment order passed
for the assessment year 2017-18 is hereby quashed and
set aside.
18. Since no affidavits have been called for, the
allegations made in the writ petition are deemed to have
been denied and not admitted.
19. With the above observations and directions that
the Writ Petition being WPA 7689 of 2025 is disposed
of without going into the merits of the case.
20. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order be
supplied to the parties, if applied for, as early as
possible.
( Smita Das De, J.)