Management Committee Of Npsc Cghs Ltd. vs Registrar Of Cooperative Societies And Ors.

Court
Delhi High Court

$~58
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
TH
Date of Decision: 17 November, 2026
th
Uploaded On: 19 November, 2026
# CNR No. DLHC010486832026
+ W.P.(C) 14951/2026
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE OF NPSC
CGHS LTD. .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Aman Sinha and Mr. Sarthak
Pandya and Mr. Varun Pratap Singh,
Advocates.
versus
REGISTRAR OF COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES
AND ORS. .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ashish Aggarwal, Ms. Yashmita
and Ms. Nishtha Verma, Advocates
with Respondent no 3 in person.

CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE DINESH BHATT
Prathiba M. Singh, J. (ORAL)
1. This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
th
2. This matter is being taken up today for hearing as 16 November, 2026
was declared a holiday on account of Chhath Puja vide Notification
th
No.110/G-4/Genl.-I/DHC dated 11 November, 2026.
3. The present petition has been filed by the Petitioner – Management
Committee of NPSC CGHS Ltd. (hereinafter the ‘ Society ’) under Article 226
of the Constitution of India inter alia, seeking quashing of the impugned order
th
dated 17 September, 2026 passed by the Respondent 2-Deputy Registrar,
Office of the Registrar of the Cooperative Societies and the following
directions are sought -
(i) Direct the Respondent 1-Registrar of Cooperative Societies
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DEVANSHU
JOSHI
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 17:40
W.P.(C) 14951/2026 Page 1 of 8

(hereinafter ‘ RCS’ ) to withdraw all proceedings in regards of the
Society from the Respondent 2.
th
(ii) Direct the RCS to give effect to the Inspection Report dated 24
August, 2026
4. Vide order dated 28th October, 2026, the Court had directed the
Observer’s Report to be brought on record and objections to be filed by the
Petitioner, if any.
5. The Court had also directed the Managing Committee which is running
the affairs of the Society, to not make any major expenses and use the funds
of the Society only for day to day expenses.
6. Today, the Observer’s Report has been placed on record.
7. The Petitioner has also filed its objections to the Observer’s Report. In
support of the Petitioner’s objections filed to the Observer’s report, the
certificate of an expert Professor Dr. Naveen Rajpal employed as Professor of
Information Technology, University School of Information Communication
& Technology, Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, Dwarka, New
Delhi, has been filed. The said certificate is furnished along with Hash report
in terms of Section 63(4)(c) of the BSA for proving certain records relied upon
by the Petitioners including CCTV records.
8. Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner has taken serious objection to a letter
th
dated 13 November, 2026 written by Respondent No.3 – Col. Rajinder Singh
Pahwa (Retd.) to the said Expert’s University including the Vice Chancellor
of Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University seeking various clarifications
and in effect making certain imputations against the said Expert. The said
Expert has been asked by the University, to submit pointwise comments on
the issues raised by Respondent No.3 in his letter. It is submitted by ld.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DEVANSHU
JOSHI
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 17:40
W.P.(C) 14951/2026 Page 2 of 8

Counsel that the Respondent no.3 is in effect raising various allegations
against the said Expert, which amounts to threatening the Expert with adverse
consequences, for having furnished a simple certification under Section 63 of
BSA for proving the electronic evidence.
9. Insofar as furnishing of an expert affidavit under Section 63 of BSA is
concerned, recently the Supreme Court has considered the issue of Expert
certifications in W.P.(C) 599/2026 titled Pune Bar Association v. Union of
India & Ors . In the said case, challenge was raised to the constitutional
nd
validity of Section 63(4) of BSA. Vide order dated 22 May 2026, the
Supreme Court has observed as under:
“1. Petitioner, Pune Bar Association, contends that
Section 63(4) of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 20231,
read with the Schedule thereto is unconstitutional as it
imposes undue hardship on an ordinary litigant by
requiring submission of a certificate prescribed in the
Schedule comprising Part A which needs disclosure of
the hash value of digital records, and Part B which must
be signed by an expert. Ld. Counsel argues imposition
of such pre-requisites for admissibility of electronic
records is an extremely onerous obligation on a litigant
and renders the provision manifestly arbitrary and
unjust.
2. With advancement of technology, digital space has
encroached on all spheres of human life. Consequently,
evidence in the form of electronic record has become
commonplace in all litigation. Physical documents are
increasingly replaced with digital records like
electronic mails, audiovisual clips etc. To address the
admissibility of such electronic records, Section 65B
was incorporated in the erstwhile Evidence Act2.
Subsequently, BSA replaced the said provision with
Section 63(4) which inter alia provides that electronic
records must be accompanied by a certificate as set out
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DEVANSHU
JOSHI
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 17:40
W.P.(C) 14951/2026 Page 3 of 8

in the Schedule to the Act. The certificate so prescribed
comprises Part A, which inter alia requires disclosure
of hash value of the electronic records in addition to the
declaration required under the erstwhile Section 65B of
the Evidence Act. Part B of the certificate requires a
further declaration signed by an expert.
3. Electronic record is a unique species of evidence
which is liable to continuous mutation and modification
affecting its authenticity, integrity and intrinsic
evidentiary value. Challenges to admissibility and
probative value of electronic records are further
accentuated with the advent of artificial intelligence and
deepfake technology. Such fast and varied
transformation in technology necessitated reviewing the
erstwhile Evidence Act and the BSA was enacted.
Statement of objects and reasons for enacting the BSA
inter alia emphasises:
“(ii) it provides for admissibility of an
electronic or digital record as evidence
having the same legal effect, validity and
enforceability as any other document;
(iii) it seeks to expand the scope of secondary
evidence to include copies made from original
by mechanical processes, copies made from
or compared with the original, counterparts
of documents as against the parties who did
not execute them and oral accounts of the
contents of a document given by some person
who has himself seen it and giving matching
hash value of original record will be
admissible as proof of evidence in the form of
secondary evidence . ”
4. To achieve such objective, Section 63(4) of BSA
improved upon the certificate envisaged under the old
law by mandating the issuance of a standard-form
certificate prescribed in the Schedule which inter alia
requires the disclosure of hash value of the
electronic/digital record along with a further
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DEVANSHU
JOSHI
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 17:40
W.P.(C) 14951/2026 Page 4 of 8

certification by an expert. Hash value of an electronic
data is synonymous with an electronic fingerprint and
provides a sure way of identifying and verifying digital
data. The necessity of incorporating the hash value of
the electronic record in the certificate is thus to ensure
its authenticity and integrity, and cannot be said to lack
a rational nexus with the object of the Act. Similarly,
certification by an expert in Part B provides an
additional layer of authenticity to the secondary
electronic evidence. For these reasons, we are of the
considered view that the new provision has a clear and
rational nexus with the object of the law and cannot be
said to be either arbitrary or unreasonable so as to
suffer from the vice of manifest arbitrariness.
5. At this juncture, referring to a judgement of the
Madras High Court3, Ld. Counsel submits Part B must
be filled up by an expert notified under Section 79A of
the Information Technology Act, 20004. He contends
that only a handful of entities are authorized by the
Central/State government to examine electronic
evidence under the said provision, thereby causing
undue hardship and rendering its implementation
illusory.
6. We have perused the cited judgment, wherein the
Madras High Court, in a matrimonial case instituted in
2019 inter alia held that the same would be governed by
the erstwhile Evidence Act. Thereafter, it proceeded to
analyse Part B of the Schedule in Section 63(4) to hold
that the certificate by an expert therein must be by an
Examiner of Electronic Evidence under Section 79A of
the IT Act. In doing so, the High Court merely referred
to Section 39(2) of the BSA and not sub-section (1).
Section 39 deals with admissibility of opinions of
experts. Sub-section (1) states when the Court has to
form an opinion on a point of foreign law, science or art
or any other field, or as to identity of handwriting or
finger impressions, the opinion on that point of persons
having special skill in such domain namely foreign law,
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DEVANSHU
JOSHI
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 17:40
W.P.(C) 14951/2026 Page 5 of 8

science or art, or any other field, or in respect of identity
of handwriting or finger impressions becomes a relevant
fact. Subsection (2) provides when in a proceeding, the
Court has to form an opinion on any matter relating to
information transmitted or stored in any computer
resource or any other electronic or digital form, the
opinion of the Examiner of Electronic Evidence under
Section 79A of the IT Act shall be treated to be that of
an expert and be admissible as a relevant fact.
7. If the two sub-sections are read harmoniously, it is
possible to hold, in addition to entities notified as
Examiner of Electronic Evidence under Section 79A,
if the Court is satisfied, on the basis of unimpeachable
material, that any other person has special skill and
expertise in computer science and cyber forensics,
opinion of such person may be held relevant as an
expert with regard to electronic/digital record and such
person may sign Part B of the Schedule as an expert.
We are further fortified to make such observation as
sub-section (2) of Section 39 (unlike 63(4) and
erstwhile 65B) is not prefaced by a non-obstante clause
so as to exclude the operation of sub-section (1) from
the arena of electronic records. The High Court had
deferred adjudication of such issue and directed the
State to notify adequate number of persons under
Section 79A. Under these circumstances, we hold that
the finding of the High Court that Part B must be filled
up by an expert notified under Section 79A of the IT
Act shall not be treated as a binding precedent . As we
are not inclined to admit the matter and issue notice
upon the Union of India, we refrain from giving any
conclusive opinion on this issue and keep the question
of law open. With this clarification, the petition stands
disposed of.”

10. It would be relevant to note that for the purpose of proving electronic
evidence, experts can give certificates under Section 39 read along with
Section 63 of BSA.
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DEVANSHU
JOSHI
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 17:40
W.P.(C) 14951/2026 Page 6 of 8

11. Further, Section 79A of the Information Technology Act, 2000
provides that the Central Government may by notification specify any
department, body or agency as an examiner of electronic evidence.
12. However, such a notification as has been held by the Supreme Court,
in Pune Bar Association (supra) would not be mandatory. Other experts who
may or may not be notified, who have special skills and expertise in computer
science, etc. can also be treated as experts by a Court on the basis of
unimpeachable material. Considering the large number of cases which are
filed across the country where expert certificates would be required to prove
electronic evidence, it is but natural for litigants to approach qualified experts
to give such certificates. Most experts may be in employment of public or
private organisations and if upon giving such certificates, their employment
is jeopardised, the same is likely to result in harassment to such experts.
13. It is usual for litigants who rely on electronic evidence to file expert
certificates from qualified experts before a Court of law, which is what the
Petitioner has done in the present case.
14. The communication written by Respondent No.3 is nothing but a pure
harassment for such an expert who may have merely certified electronic
records.
15. To write an email as has been done by Respondent No.3 to his
University is nothing but a veiled threat and browbeating of a Professor who
is serving in the University.
16. If the Respondent No.3 had any objection to the Expert’s certificate, he
ought to have approached this Court seeking any clarification or directions.
17. Such communications by litigants to employers of such experts would
completely defeat the purpose of the enactment and may result in experts
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DEVANSHU
JOSHI
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 17:40
W.P.(C) 14951/2026 Page 7 of 8

becoming hesitant to give certificates under BSA, which would not be in the
overall spirit of the statute.
18. Respondent No. 3, present today in Court, assures and undertakes to
the Court that the communication written by him to the Guru Gobind Singh
Indraprastha University, Dwarka, New Delhi shall be withdrawn by him by
way of an email today itself. Copy of the said letter handed over in Court
today, is taken on record.
19. In any case the Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University shall not
take any action pursuant to the said letter written by Col. Rajinder Singh
Pahwa (Retd.)-Respondent No. 3 to the University regarding Professor Dr.
Naveen Rajpal.
20. Ld. Counsel for the Respondent is permitted to file reply to the
objections filed by the Petitioner at least one week before the next date of
hearing.
21. RCS shall keep the entire record relating to the Society ready for
reference of the Court by the next date of hearing.
th
22. List on 17 December, 2026 in the supplementary list.

PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE


DINESH BHATT
JUDGE

NOVEMBER 17, 2026/MR/as
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:DEVANSHU
JOSHI
Signing
Date:19.11.2026 17:40
W.P.(C) 14951/2026 Page 8 of 8