Krishna Devi vs The State of Bihar

Court
Patna High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.13429 of 2024
======================================================
Krishna Devi W/o Late Uma Shankar Thakur, Resident of Village Chhakiya,
P.S. Tisiauta, Distt- Vaishali.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Department of Planning
and Development, Govt. of Bihar, Old Secretariat, P.O. Sachivalay, Patna.
2. The Principal Secretary, Department Finance, Govt. of Bihar, Old
Secretariat, P.O. Sachivalay, Patna.
3. The Director, Directorate of Economics and Statistics, Planning and
Development Department, Old Secretariat, Patna, Bihar.
4. The District Magistrate, Muzaffarpur.
5. The District Statistical Officer, Muzzafarpur.
6. The District Magistrate, Aurangabad.
7. The District Statistical Officer, Aurangabad.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Ms.Kriti Pandey, Advocate
For the Respondent/s : Standing Counsel 1
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PURNENDU SINGH
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 24-09-2026
Heard learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner and the learned counsel for the State.
2. The petitioner in paragraph no. 1 of the present writ
petition has sought inter alia following relief(s), which is
reproduced hereinafter:-
“i. For issuance of appropriate writ in the
nature of mandamus, order or direction, for
directions the respondents to pay the full pension
and full retiral benefits, including gratuity, leave
encashment, five months pension arrear (August,
2016 to December, 2016) and other pensionary
benefits after death of husband of the petitioner

Patna High Court CWJC No.13429 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
2/8
dated 29.10.2014 during service period.
ii. To issue an appropriate writ in the
nature of mandamus commanding the respondents to
grant four months (July, 2014 to October, 2014)
salary arrears of the husband of the petitioner.
iii. To any other relief or reliefs for which
the petitioner is found to be entitled and your
lordships may deem fit in the facts and
circumstances of the case.”
3. In respect of the proceeding initiated for recovery
of a sum of Rs.27,04,433/-, the petitioner and others preferred
CWJC No.4540 of 2023, which was heard on 02.05.2024 and
the Court considering the reliefs passed inter alia following
orders : -
“The present writ petition has been filed for the
following reliefs:-
“I. For issuance of appropriate writ in
the nature of certiorari for quashing
certificate proceeding of certificate case No.
15/2013-14 (AnnexureP-1) dated 29.07.2013
by Respondent 5 initially initiated against
husband petitioner no. 1 but after around nine
years of his death, notice issued to his legal
heirs for recovery of the dues amounting to
Rs. 27,04,433/-.
II. For issuance of appropriate writ in
the nature of certiorari for quashing letter
dated 16.08.2022 (Annexure-P2) whereby
recovery of Rupees 27,04,433/- from
petitioners to ensure its deposition in the
account of State Food Corporation,
Aurangabad.
III. To any other relief or reliefs for
which the petitioner is found to be entitled
and Your Lordships may deem fit in the facts
and circumstances of the case.”
3. Learned counsel for the petitioners has stated
that the matter is squarely covered by the judgment of this
Hon’ble Court in case of Lal Chand Panna Lal & Anr. Vs.
The State of Bihar & Ors. reported in 2007(4) PLJR 590
and Prabhakar Tekriwal Vs. The State of Bihar & Ors.
reported in 2024(1) PLJR 622 in wherein this Hon’ble Court

Patna High Court CWJC No.13429 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
3/8
has held as under;
“5. The only consideration in
this particular case is as to whether the
authorities are justified in initiating the
action for recovery and the amount as public
demand after a period of 10 years from the
date of death of a dead person for the
services rendered to him in person.
Admittedly, the services which were rendered
to the father of the petitioner were in the
nature of personal services. i.e., that of
providing personal Body Guards to the
father of the petitioner. A coordinate Bench
in CWJC No. 2317 of 2017 (Pawan Kumar
Singh Vrs. State of Bihar & Ors.) has held as
under :
“Certificate procedure
not to be used where there is any
doubt of debtors liability,-Requiring-
officers should bear in mind that the
certificate procedure is intended only
for the recovery of sums regarding
which there is no doubt of the
liability of the debtor. Cases in which
the debtor is likely with some show
of reason to deny his liability should
be reported with a view to institution
of civil suits. No such certificate
shall be made in respect of any
demand the recovery of which is
barred by any law of limitation for
the time being in force. In the case of
rent due to Wards and Government
estate the period of limitation
depends upon the Tenancy Act
applicable and is determined by
Schedule III part I. of the Bihar
Tenancy Act or Section 234 of the
Chota Nagpur Tenancy Act, as the
case may be. The period of limitation
for certificate filed by the examiner
of Local Account under the Local
Fund Audit is three years from the
date of the order of surcharge”, the
Court held that where the liability of
the petitioner has not been
ascertained by any competent
authority, it cannot be said that the
petitioner is guilty of defalcation and
that too to the amount as indicated
above. The learned coordinate Bench

Patna High Court CWJC No.13429 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
4/8
clearly held that “Certificate
proceedings are proceedings for
recovery of ascertained dues. It is
not a proceeding where the
certificate officer is to act like a Civil
Court and determine the liability.
The liability is, prima facie,
predetermined and the proceeding
are only for recovery of those
predetermined liability.””
4. In this particular case as seen from the
record, the initiation of the certificate proceedings are
after a lapse of more than nine years from the date of
death of the husband of the petitioner No. 1.
5. Admittedly, the period of limitation as
prescribed under Section 11 of the Bihar & Orissa
Public Demands Recovery Act, 1914 and also as per
Article 120 of the Limitation Act, 1963 is only ninety
days.
6. Having regard to the above settled legal
position, the writ petition is allowed and notice before
the certificate officers is quashed.
7. With the above direction, the present writ
petition stands allowed.”
4. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner, in the light of the observation and direction, as
contained in order dated 17.09.2026 passed in the present writ
petition, seeks to file a detailed representation before the
Director, Directorate of Economics and Statistics, Planning and
Development Department, (respondent No.3) .
5. Per contra, learned counsel for the State submitted
that admittedly the petitioner is the wife of deceased Late Uma
Shankar Thakur, who died in harness on 29.10.2014, while he
was in active service and posted as Block Statistical Supervisor,
Kudhani block within the district of Muzaffarpur. The petitioner

Patna High Court CWJC No.13429 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
5/8
is getting provisional pension and gratuity and all other
admissible dues of her husband, Late Uma Shankar Thakur. 7.
While the husband of the petitioner was posted as Block
Statistical Supervisor, Haspura in the District of Aurangabad, he
was saddled with the charges of dues of Rs. 26,58,231/-(Twenty
six lac fifty eight thousand two hundred and thirty one rupees)
related to paddy procurement in the block understate Food
Corporation. When the husband of the petitioner failed to
deposit the aforesaid amount the competent authority initiated a
Certificate Case, bearing Certificate Case No.- 15/2013-14,
dated-29.07.2013 Certificate under Officer, Aurangabad, for
recovery of Rs. 27,04,433/-(Twenty seven lac four thousand
four hundred and thirty three rupees), calculated with interest
upon the amount Rs. 26,58,231/- (Twenty six lac fifty eight
thousand two hundred and thirty one rupees). During pendency
of the Certificate Case the husband of the petitioner died,
resultantly notices have been issued on 16.08.2022 to the legal
heirs of Late Uma Shankar Thakur under certificate proceeding,
including the present petitioner. Apart from above mentioned
certificate case, Rs. 54,278/- (Fifty four thousand two hundred
and seventy eight) was also to be recovered against an advance
taken by the husband of the petitioner while he was posted as

Patna High Court CWJC No.13429 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
6/8
Block Statistical Supervisor in Kesaria Block, District- East
Champaran at Motihari. The petitioner and other legal heirs
have challenged the said notice of the Certificate Proceeding by
filing CWJC No.-4540/2023, which was finally heard and
disposed by an order dated 02.05.2024 passed by this Hon'ble
Court, by setting aside the notice issued in certificate case
bearing no.-15/2013-14. The order dated-02.05.2024, passed by
the Hon'ble Single Judge has been challenged by the State
Respondents under Letters Patent Appellate Jurisdiction of this
Hon'ble Court, by filing LPA No.- 662/2024, which is pending
adjudication before this Hon'ble Court. Admittedly the judgment
dated-02.05.2024 passed in CWJC No. 4540 of 2023 is in
favour of the petitioner though it has not attained the finality in
nature till date and is still pending adjudication under LPA
jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court. A Certificate Case was
initiated against the husband of the petitioner and the order of
the learned single judge is yet to be attained the finality, the final
pension & other benefits could not be granted to the petitioner
and is the subject matter of the outcome of the final judgment.
The husband of the petitioner was charged with recovery of
amount of Rs. 26,58,231/- later on with interest enhanced to Rs.
27,04,433/-, for which notices have been issued in Certificate

Patna High Court CWJC No.13429 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
7/8
Case No.-15/2013-14. The petitioner and others have filed
CWJC No.-4540/2023 challenging the Certificate notice and the
learned single judge has been pleased to set aside the notices by
an order dated 02.05.2024. The respondent authorities have
taken legal recourse against the Hon'ble Court's order dated-
02.05.2024, under LPA 662 of 2024 jurisdiction, which is
pending adjudication before this Hon'ble Court and hence the
present writ petition is fit to be dismissed.
6. Heard the parties.
7. Considering the specific prayer of the petitioner
that he seeks to file representation before the Director,
Directorate of Economics and Statistics, Planning and
Development Department, (respondent No.3), who is directed
to call for the service particulars relating to the petitioner and
take a conscious decision in respect of the reliefs as prayed for
in the present writ petition and ensure that the petitioner’s
grievance is redressed, who is the widow of the deceased
employee, namely, Late Uma Shankar Thakur, who died in
harness on 29.10.2024. The petitioner, being a poor lady, is
entitled for pensionary benefit including pension.
8. In view of the above, the petitioner can not be
penalized, being widow, by withholding the dues, which were

Patna High Court CWJC No.13429 of 2024 dt.24-09-2026
8/8
required to be paid to her husband under different heads because
of pendency of LPA. Non payment will further harass the
petitioner.
9. The Director, Directorate of Economics and
Statistics, Planning and Development Department, (respondent
No.3) must ensure payment of the retiral dues under different
heads in accordance with law, which was due to her husband
and also fix the family pension of the petitioner forthwith and
communicate the same to the Accountant General (Bihar) so
that the PPO can be issued to be credited into the account of the
petitioner subject to the final outcome of the LPA.
10. The present writ petition accordingly stands
disposed of.

(Purnendu Singh, J)
chn/-
AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE NA
Uploading Date 01.10.2026
Transmission Date 01.10.2026