Vakhtaram S Solanki vs Income Tax Appellate Tribunal
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
:: 1 :: OA No.196/2018
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
AHMEDABAD BENCH
Original Application No. 196/2018
th
Dated this the 30 day of October, 2026.
Reserved On: 26.09.2026
Pronounced On: 30.10.2026
CORAM:
Hon’ble Shri Jayesh V Bhairavia, Member (J)
Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
Shri Vakhtaram,
Son of Samuji Solanki, Age: 61 years,
Residing atA/503, High Court Quarters,
Nr. Prakash School,
Opp. Vinus Tower, Bodakdev, Ahmedabad – 380 054.
… Applicants
(By Advocate Ms. K L Kalwani)
V/s.
1. Union of India, through
The Registrar,
Income Tax appellate Tribunal,
O/o. ITAT, Central Govt Officers Building,
th
4 Floor, Maharshi karve Road, Mumbai – 400 011.
2. The Assistant Registrar,
O/o. Assistant Registrar,
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal,
Ahmedbad Bench, Paldi,
Abhimanyu Building, Ahmedabad – 380 013.
… Respondents
(By Advocate Mr. H D Shukla)
P ANUKUMA
:: 2 :: OA No.196/2018
ORDER
Per: Hon’ble Shri Sanjiv Kumar, Member (A)
1. The applicant has filed this OA under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following reliefs:
“(A) That the Hon’ble Tribunal be pleased to allow this
petition.
(B) That the Hon’ble Tribunal further be pleased to
hold/declare that the impugned ex-facie, illegal,
arbitrary, unjust and unconstitutional action, decision,
order No. F/OA/394/2013 dated 9.2.2018 issued by the
respondents rejecting the claim of the applicant for
financial upgradation during his tenure/service carrier is
nullity in the eyes of law.
(C) That, the Hon’ble Tribunal further be pleased to
quash and set aside the impugned ex-facie, illegal,
arbitrary, unjust and unconstitutional action, decision,
order No. F/OA/394/2013 dated 9.2.2018 issued by the
respondents rejecting the claim of the applicant for
financial upgradation during his tenure/service carrier
and further be pleased to direct the respondents to
give/grant financial upgradation from due date with
arrears and 12% interest thereon.
(D) Such other and further relief/s as may be deemed
just and proper in view of the facts and circumstances of
the case may be granted.”
2. The facts, as stated by the applicant, are briefly as follows.
2.1 The applicant worked as a Staff Car Driver in the Income Tax
Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). He joined service on 13.01.1982 and
retired on superannuation on 31.12.2012. In more than 30 years of
service he received neither a regular promotion nor any financial
upgradation.
P ANUKUMA
:: 3 :: OA No.196/2018
2.2 On 28.08.2012, the applicant made a representation seeking
financial upgradation under the Assured Career Progression
(ACP) Scheme / Modified Assured Career Progression (MACP)
Scheme. As no decision was communicated to him, he filed O.A.
No. 394/2013. By order dated 06.03.2017, this Tribunal directed
the respondents to consider his claim under the applicable
scheme. If he was found eligible, they were to grant the benefit,
re-fix his pay and pay the arrears. If not, they were to pass a
reasoned and speaking order.
2.3 In compliance, the respondents passed the impugned order dated
09.02.2018 (Annexure A/1) rejecting the claim. The order relies
on the proceedings of the Departmental Promotion Committees
(DPCs) held in 2002, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009–2010
and 2012, and on the Office Memorandum of the Department of
Personnel and Training (DoPT) dated 19.05.2009. The applicant’s
grievance is that the adverse reports and the doubts about his
integrity relied upon in that order, were never communicated to
him. Hence, this OA.
3. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the ACP and
MACP Schemes were introduced to give relief to employees who
remain stuck in one grade for want of promotion. The applicant
served for over three decades without any promotion and was
entitled to a fair consideration of his claim. The impugned order
merely refers to old DPC proceedings. The applicant was never
told of any adverse assessment. Had he been told, he could have
P ANUKUMA
:: 4 :: OA No.196/2018
represented against it or improved his performance. Counsel
disputed that the applicant was found unfit in all the DPCs cited.
He also pointed out that the earlier OA was decided in the
applicant’s favour precisely because the respondents had not
given specific and satisfactory reasons.
4. The respondents have filed a reply opposing the OA. Learned
counsel for the respondents first raised three preliminary
objections. First, the applicant retired from the Guwahati Bench
of the ITAT and, as per the revised Pension Payment Order dated
05.01.2018, he resides at Bishangarh, District Jalore, Rajasthan.
The OA, therefore, lies before the Jodhpur Bench and not before
this Bench. Second, the applicant has not impleaded his last
office, and the OA is bad for non-joinder of a necessary party.
Third, the applicant retired on 31.12.2012 but approached this
Tribunal with the present OA only on 27.02.2018, and the claim
is barred by limitation.
4.1 On merits, learned counsel submitted that financial upgradation
under the ACP/MACP Scheme does not follow automatically on
completing a length of service. The employee must meet the
conditions of the scheme, including the benchmark prescribed in
the DoPT OM dated 19.05.2009. The order of 06.03.2017
(Annexure A/2) directed consideration of the claim, not grant of
the benefit. In compliance, the President, ITAT examined the
representation and the service record and passed a reasoned order.
P ANUKUMA
:: 5 :: OA No.196/2018
4.2 The DPCs considered the applicant on several occasions and
found him unfit for confirmation, promotion or financial
upgradation. The reasons recorded are:
(i) Not recommended for confirmation on account of adverse
reports from concerned bench [DPC-2002]
(ii) Not recommended for promotion in the Staff Car Driver
Grade on account of adverse reports on record [DPC-2004]
(iii) Not recommended as he is found unfit for promotion [DPC-
2005]
(iv) Not confirmed due to average confidential reports [DPC-
2006]
(v) The integrity is in doubt. Hence, not recommended [DPC-
2007]
(vi) The integrity is in doubt, his case considered and not
confirmed [DPC-2008]
(vii) Found unfit for confirmation as he is educationally not
qualified, integrity clearance not being received and also being
not qualified as per the relevant Recruitment Rules [DPC 2009-
2010]
4.3 Counsel added that the applicant’s Annual Confidential Report
(ACR) gradings were consistently below the benchmark. As he
was repeatedly found unfit, he cannot claim financial upgradation
on length of service alone, and the OA deserves dismissal.
P ANUKUMA
:: 6 :: OA No.196/2018
5. In the rejoinder, the applicant has specifically stated that the
adverse entries and remarks relied upon by the respondents were
never communicated to him, and has put the respondents to strict
proof of their communication. Otherwise, he has reiterated the
averments made in the OA.
6. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
7. The following points arise for determination:
(i) Whether this Bench has territorial jurisdiction to decide the OA,
and whether the OA fails for non-joinder of a necessary party?
(ii) Whether the OA is barred by limitation?
(iii) Whether the impugned order rejecting the claim for
ACP/MACP is sustainable when the adverse entries relied upon
were not communicated to the applicant?
(iv) To what relief, if any, is the applicant entitled?
8. We first take up the objection to territorial jurisdiction. Such an
objection goes to the root of the matter and has to be decided
before the merits. Rule 6(1) of the Central Administrative
Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 1987 permits an application to be
filed before the Bench within whose jurisdiction the applicant is
posted or the cause of action, wholly or in part, has arisen. Rule
6(2) gives a person who has ceased to be in service by reason of
retirement, dismissal or termination the option to file before the
Bench within whose jurisdiction he is ordinarily residing at the
P ANUKUMA
:: 7 :: OA No.196/2018
time of filing the application. It is true that the applicant retired
from the Guwahati Bench of the ITAT and that his revised
Pension Payment Order dated 05.01.2018 shows an address in
District Jalore, Rajasthan. But the applicant stays at Ahmedabad,
and in the OA he has given his present address at Ahmedabad,
which lies within the jurisdiction of this Bench. A Pension
Payment Order records the address furnished for pension
purposes; it does not by itself show where the pensioner
ordinarily resides when he files the OA. The respondents have
placed no other material to show that the applicant was not
residing at Ahmedabad on that date. The applicant has exercised
the option available to him under Rule 6(2), and this Bench has
territorial jurisdiction.
8.1 As to non-joinder, the impugned order was passed by the
President, ITAT, and the ITAT is arrayed as a respondent. The
relief sought is the setting aside of that order and the grant of
financial upgradation. Both can be carried out by the respondents
already before us. The respondents have not shown what order
only the applicant’s last office could carry out.
8.2 As regards limitation, the applicant made his representation on
28.08.2012, while still in service. When it was not decided, he
filed O.A. No. 394/2013, decided on 06.03.2017 with a direction
to the respondents to pass a reasoned order. The respondents
passed the impugned order on 09.02.2018 in compliance with that
direction. The present OA challenges that order. The Supreme
P ANUKUMA
:: 8 :: OA No.196/2018
Court in Union of India v. M.K. Sarkar , (2010) 2 SCC 59 , has
held that where a court directs consideration of a representation
on a stale or dead claim, the decision taken in compliance does
not furnish a fresh cause of action, and does not extend limitation
or erase the delay and laches; the original cause of action governs.
That is not the case here. The applicant’s claim was not stale
when this Tribunal directed its consideration. It was raised while
he was in service, brought before this Tribunal in O.A. No.
394/2013 when it was not decided, and directed to be considered
on merits. The applicant has pursued his claim without a break
from 2012 onwards. The respondents themselves decided the
claim on merits under the Tribunal’s direction. The present OA,
filed on 27.02.2018 against that decision, is within the period of
one year allowed by Section 21 of the Administrative Tribunals
Act, 1985. The objection of limitation is, therefore, rejected. The
period for which arrears may be paid is a separate matter, dealt
with in para 8.10.
8.3 Under the ACP Scheme and under the MACP Scheme notified by
the DoPT OM dated 19.05.2009, financial upgradation is not
automatic on completing a length of service. It is subject to fitness
and to the benchmark prescribed by the scheme. The applicant
cannot, therefore, claim the benefit on long service alone.
8.4 The question, then, is whether the material on which the applicant
was found unfit could be used against him. The reasons relied
upon by the respondents are mainly adverse or average ACRs
P ANUKUMA
:: 9 :: OA No.196/2018
(DPCs of 2002, 2004 and 2006) and remarks that his integrity was
in doubt (DPCs of 2007 and 2008). The DPC of 2005 records
only that he was found unfit, without a reason. The DPC of 2009-
2010 found him unfit for confirmation for want of the educational
qualification under the Recruitment Rules and for want of
integrity clearance. The impugned order also refers to a DPC of
2012, but records neither its finding nor any reason. Most of these
DPCs were held for confirmation or regular promotion, and not
for screening under the ACP/MACP Scheme. Nothing on record
shows that any of them was a Screening Committee constituted
under either scheme to consider the applicant for financial
upgradation. The applicant’s claim has, thus, never been
examined by the Screening Committee, and against the norms,
prescribed by the schemes.
8.5 The Supreme Court in Dev Dutt v. Union of India, (2008) 8 SCC
725 , has held that every entry in the ACR of a public servant must
be communicated to him within a reasonable time, so that he may
represent against it; an entry not so communicated cannot be used
against him in matters of promotion. This view was affirmed by a
three-Judge Bench in Sukhdev Singh v. Union of India, (2013) 9
SCC 566. In line with this, the DoPT, by OM No. 21011/1/2010-
Estt(A) dated 13.04.2010, directed that where ACRs of a period
before 2008-09 are below the benchmark, a copy shall be given to
the employee for representation before they are placed before a
DPC.
P ANUKUMA
:: 10 :: OA No.196/2018
8.6 The applicant has stated in the OA and again in the rejoinder that
the adverse entries and the remarks about his integrity were never
communicated to him. He has put the respondents to strict proof.
The respondents hold the service record. Yet they have not placed
on record any document showing that these entries were
communicated to him, such as a letter of communication, an
endorsement or an acknowledgement. In these circumstances, we
hold that the adverse entries were not communicated to the
applicant. In view of the law noted in para 8.5, they could not be
used to deny him financial upgradation. The impugned order rests
substantially on such entries and therefore cannot be sustained.
8.7 The DPC of 2009-2010 also recorded that the applicant was not
educationally qualified as per the relevant Recruitment Rules.
That remark was made while considering his confirmation. The
impugned order does not examine whether the educational
qualification prescribed in the Recruitment Rules is a condition
for financial upgradation under the ACP Scheme or the MACP
Scheme. Nor can it be said that the respondents would have
rejected the claim on this ground alone, since the impugned order
rests on the remarks of all the DPCs taken together, most of which
could not be used against the applicant. This ground, therefore,
does not save the impugned order. Whether the applicant fulfils
the conditions of the schemes, including any qualification they
require, is for the review DPC to examine.
P ANUKUMA
:: 11 :: OA No.196/2018
8.8 At the same time, it is not for this Tribunal, but the competent
authority to assess the applicant’s fitness. The proper procedure is
to have the adverse entries communicated to the applicant now,
give him a chance to represent against them, decide his
representation, and then have his case placed before a review
DPC for fresh consideration under the ACP/MACP Scheme.
8.9 The applicant has claimed interest at 12%. As his entitlement is
yet to be decided by the review DPC and the competent authority,
interest is not granted at this stage.
8.10 The claim relates to the fixation of pay, which is a recurring
wrong. The Supreme Court in Union of India v. Tarsem Singh ,
(2008) 8 SCC 648, has held that in such cases the consequential
relief of arrears is normally to be restricted to a period of three
years before the date of filing of the proceedings. The applicant
first approached this Tribunal in O.A. No. 394/2013. If he is
found fit, his pay shall, therefore, be fixed notionally from the due
date(s), and the actual arrears of pay and pension shall be
confined to the period commencing three years before the filing
of O.A. No. 394/2013.
9. In the light of facts and circumstances mentioned above:
(i) The impugned order dated 09.02.2018 (Annexure A/1) is set
aside.
(ii) The respondents shall communicate to the applicant copies of
all adverse and below-benchmark entries, including the remarks on
P ANUKUMA
:: 12 :: OA No.196/2018
integrity, relied upon in the impugned order, within four weeks
from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
(iii) The applicant may submit a representation against those
entries within four weeks of receiving them. The competent
authority shall decide it by a reasoned and speaking order within
four weeks thereafter.
(iv) The respondents shall then convene a review DPC to consider
the case of the applicant for financial upgradation under the ACP
Scheme and the MACP Scheme, as on each due date, in
accordance with the conditions of those schemes and in the light of
the decision on his representation. This shall be done within six
weeks of the decision under (iii).
(v) If the applicant is found fit, his pay shall be fixed notionally
from the due date(s), his pension and retiral dues shall be revised,
and the arrears, confined as stated in para 8.10, shall be paid within
two months of the review DPC’s decision.
10. OA is partly allowed.
11. There shall be no order as to costs.
12. Pending MA(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
(Sanjiv Kumar) (Jayesh V Bhairavia)
Member (A) Member (J)
//Anu//
P ANUKUMA