Malkiat Singh vs Punjab State

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court



RFA-159-2004 (O&M) & connected cases -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
Item No.203 (21 cases) RFA-159-2004 (O&M)
Decided on: 20.11.2026
Malkiat Singh (deceased) through LR(s) …Appellant
Versus
Punjab State and another …Respondents
With
Sr. Case No. Appellant(s) Respondent(s)
No.

2. RFA-160-2004 (O&M) Gulzar Singh (deceased) Punjab State and
through LR(s) another
3. RFA-162-2004 (O&M) Darshan Singh Punjab State
4. RFA-163-2004 (O&M) Harbhajan Singh Punjab State
5. RFA-164-2004 (O&M) Manjit Kaur Punjab State
6. RFA-165-2004 (O&M) Jaswinder Kaur Punjab State
7. RFA-166-2004 (O&M) Gurdip Kaur Punjab State
8. RFA-167-2004 (O&M) Jagtar Singh Punjab State
9. RFA-168-2004 (O&M) Sarbjit Singh Punjab State
10. RFA-169-2004 (O&M) Mukhtiar Singh Punjab State
11. RFA-170-2004 (O&M) Sukhdev Singh Punjab State
12. RFA-171-2004 (O&M) Rattan Singh Rakhra Punjab State
13. RFA-172-2004 (O&M) Gursewak Singh Punjab State
14. RFA-173-2004 (O&M) Kulwant Singh Punjab State
15. RFA-175-2004 (O&M) Parkash Singh Punjab State
16. RFA-176-2004 (O&M) Baldev Singh and Others Punjab State
17. RFA-177-2004 (O&M) Mehar Singh and Others Punjab State
18. RFA-178-2004 (O&M) Nachhattar Singh Punjab State
19. RFA-179-2004 (O&M) Gurpal Singh Punjab State

20. RFA-161-2004 (O&M) Lal Singh (deceased) Punjab State and
through LR(s) another
21. RFA-174-2004 (O&M) Hari Singh Punjab State

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JAGMOHAN BANSAL
Present: - Ms. Navjot Kaur, Advocate and
Mr. B.S. Bhalla, Advocate for the appellant(s)

Mr. Puru Jarewal, Deputy Advocate General, Punjab
*
JAGMOHAN BANSAL, J . (Oral)

1. These appeals under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 (for short ‘ 1894 Act ’) are directed against award dated 15.03.2003
whereby learned Additional District Judge, Moga (hereinafter referred to as
‘ Reference Court ’) has not granted compensation as claimed by them.
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.21 10:03
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.



RFA-159-2004 (O&M) & connected cases -2-

2. As common issues are involved in the captioned appeals, with
the consent of both sides, the same are hereby disposed of by this common
order. For the sake of brevity and convenience, facts are borrowed from
RFA No.159 of 2004.

3. The State Government issued notification dated 01.12.1997
under Section 4 of the 1894 Act for the acquisition of land measuring 45 Acres
4 Kanals 18 Marlas situated in Village Baghapurana, District Moga with intent
to set up New Mandi Township at Baghapurana. The said notification was
followed by notification dated 06.05.1998 issued under Section 6 of 1894 Act.

4. The Land Acquisition Collector (for short ‘Collector’) vide
Award dated 08.01.1999, in terms of provisions of 1894 Act, determined
compensation payable to the landowners. Market value of the acquired land
₹
was determined @ 8,00,000/- per acre for land adjoining the main road of
₹
Kot Kapura- Baghapurana Highway and 5,50,000/- per acre for remaining
land. Landowners were held entitled to solatium and other statutory benefits.
Feeling dis-satisfied from the award, they preferred petitions before the
Collector which were referred to the Court under Section 18 of the 1894 Act.

5. The landowners as well as State, in support of their contentions,
led their evidence. The State attempted to justify market value determined by
the Collector, however, landowners vehemently pleaded that compensation
payable has been assessed on lower side.

6. The Reference Court while appreciating evidence led by both
sides, by impugned awards adjudicated reference petitions. The Reference
Court vide award dated 15.03.2003 has dismissed landowners’ claim for
enhancement.
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.21 10:03
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.



RFA-159-2004 (O&M) & connected cases -3-

7. Tabulated details of the assessment made till date read as: -
Date of notification under 01.12.1997
Section 4
Date of notification under 06.05.1998
Section 6
Purpose of acquisition Setting up New Mandi
Township at Baghapurana
Area 45 Acres 4 Kanals 18 Marlas
Location Village – Baghapurana
District – Moga
Date of Collector’s (LAC) 08.01.1999
award
₹
8,00,000/- for land adjoining
the main road of Kot Kapura-
Baghapurana Highway and
₹
5,50,000/- for remaining land.
Market value as per LAC
(per acre)
Date of Reference Court (RC) 15.03.2003
Award
₹
Market value as per 8,00,000/- for land adjoining
Reference Court (per acre) the main road of Kot Kapura-
Baghapurana Highway and
₹
5,50,000/- for remaining
land.


8. Learned counsel for the appellants-landowners submits that the
Reference Court has not appreciated evidence in true spirit. The Reference
Court has wrongly recorded that there was no petrol pump, factory, school
college or other important building close to the acquired land. Finding that
cremation ground is close to the acquired land is also incorrect. The Reference
Court has mechanically rejected exemplar sale deeds. The contemporaneous
sale data cannot be mechanically ignored. Sale deed dated 28.10.1998 (Ex. P-
₹
8) is disclosing market price @ 1,00,000/- per marla. Agreement to sell dated
18.07.1997 (Ex. P-2) was executed prior to Section 4 notification still has been
ignored. It has been ignored on the ground that authenticity of agreement to
sell could not be proved. Sale deeds dated 19.11.1993 (Ex. P-4 & P-5) have
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.21 10:03
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.



RFA-159-2004 (O&M) & connected cases -4-
been ignored on the ground of area comprised therein. The Reference Court
could impose reasonable cut to determine market value as per Ex. P-4 and P-
5. Sale deeds dated 19.11.1993 though comprised small piece of land yet
could not be outrightly ignored.

9. Per contra , learned State counsel submits that the Reference
Court has duly examined evidence on record and recorded findings to the
effect that there was a cremation ground close to the acquired land. There was
no school, college, factory, Government office or other establishment close to
the acquired land. In these circumstances, land was not potential for future
development.

10. Learned counsel for the parties are ad idem that delay in filing or
re-filing any appeal which is part of present bunch may be condoned.

Accordingly, delay, if any, in any case, stands condoned.

11. All the arguments raised by both sides have been recorded in the
presence of counsel for the parties. They have not raised any other argument.

12. Heard the arguments and perused the record.

13. A perusal of record reveals that the Collector determined market
₹
price @ 8,00,000/- per acre with respect to land adjoining the main road of
Kot Kapura- Baghapurana Highway . Total acquired land was 45 Acres 4
Kanals & 18 Marlas and a stretch of 7 Acres and 18 Marlas was found
adjoining the main road. The market price of the remaining 38 Acres 4 Kanals
₹
area was determined @ 5,50,000/- per acre. The landowners were granted

addition under Section 23(1A) as well as solatium under Section 23(2).

14. The landowners in support of their contentions relied upon sale
deeds/agreement to sell (Ex. P-2, P-4, P-5 & P-8). Ex. P-2 was agreement to
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.21 10:03
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.



RFA-159-2004 (O&M) & connected cases -5-
sell dated 18.07.1997. Sale deed consequent to aforesaid agreement to sell was
never executed whereas matter was compromised and earnest money was
refunded. In these circumstances, agreement to sell could not be relied upon
though was executed prior to Section 4 notification. Section 4 notification was
issued on 01.12.1997 and it is well known that survey is conducted much prior
to issuance of Section 4 notification. Normally residents come to know about
the acquisition of their land. The aforesaid agreement to sell was not converted
into sale deed whereas earnest money was refunded. In these circumstances,
the Reference Court has rightly declined to rely upon aforesaid agreement.

15. The appellants are relying upon sale deeds (Ex. P-4 & P-5). Both
the sale deeds were executed on 19.11.1993. These deeds could be made basis
for determination of market price of the land in question, however, the
Reference Court has declined to bank upon aforesaid deeds on the ground that
these deeds comprised only 1 Marla land each. Land comprised in aforesaid
sale deeds indicate that these deeds are relating to shops. 25-30 sq. yards land
is used for a small shop. The aforesaid area is not used for residential or
agriculture purpose. Further, in oral evidence, it has come that aforesaid pieces
of land were used for shops. The acquired area was agricultural and measuring
45 Acres 4 Kanals 18 Marlas. Market value of a large tract cannot be
determined as per sale deed of 1 Marla. Type of land is also required to be
considered. 1 Marla land was meant for shop whereas 45 Acres land was large
tract of agricultural land. Sale deed (Ex. P-8) was executed much later than

Section 4 notification, thus, cannot be relied upon.

16. Now the question remains of potentiality. The Courts have
recognized question of potentiality. If it is found that land was potential for
residential or commercial purposes, some additional compensation may be
MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.21 10:03
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.



RFA-159-2004 (O&M) & connected cases -6-
granted. In the case in hand, there are categoric findings of the Reference
Court that there was no school, college, factory, petrol pump or any other
important building in the vicinity of the acquired land. Chances of
development are remote, thus, land is required to be assessed as agricultural
land. There is no contrary evidence and in the absence of concrete evidence,
findings of the Reference Court cannot be disturbed.

17. In the wake of above discussion and findings, this Court is of the
considered opinion that appeals deserve to be dismissed and accordingly
dismissed.

18. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.


(JAGMOHAN BANSAL)
JUDGE
20.11.2026
Mohit Kumar
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No

MOHIT KUMAR
2026.11.21 10:03
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this order/judgment.