Ranjit Kaur vs Tehal Singh And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

RSA-572-2024 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
117 RSA-572-2024 (O&M)
Date of decision: 12.11.2026
Ranjit Kaur
....Appellant
Vs.
Tehal Singh and others
....Respondents
CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER
Present: Ms. Kuljeet Kaur Adhen, Advocate
for the appellant.
*
HARSH BUNGER J.
1. For convenience, the parties herein are being addressed as per
their status in the original suit.
2. This is the plaintiff's regular second appeal challenging the
judgment and decree dated 05.07.2019 passed by the learned Civil Judge
(Junior Division), Moga as well as the judgment and decree dated
16.01.2023 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Moga.
3. Briefly, the plaintiff filed a suit for declaration to the effect that
th
she is owner in possession of 1/7 share of the land of Sardara Singh son of
Prem Singh son of Sobha Singh, resident of Village Daudhar Sharki, District
Moga, being natural legal heir of Sardara Singh in respect of the suit
property (as detailed in the plaint) comprising in Khewat Nos. 491, 643,
1279 (as per Jamabandi for the year 2012-13) situated in Village Daudhar
Sharki-I, and also another plot of land measuring 1 Kanal - 18 Marlas
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-572-2024 (O&M) -2-
comprising in Khewat No. 342 (as per Jamabandi for the year 2012-13)
situated at Village Daudhar Sharki-II. A further declaration has been sought
that the Will dated 01.10.2004 and the consequent mutation No. 13357 are
illegal, void and liable to be set aside, and not binding on the plaintiff. A
consequential relief of permanent injunction was also sought.
4. Briefly, the plaintiff filed the aforesaid suit on the plea that
Sardara Singh was recorded as owner of the suit property and the plaintiff is
daughter of Sardara Singh. It is averred that Sardara Singh died leaving
behind plaintiff and defendants, therefore, they are equally entitled to inherit
the estate of deceased Sardara Singh. Plaintiff pleaded that defendants No. 1
to 4 propounded an alleged Will dated 01.10.2004 and on the basis of the
same, they managed to get the mutation No. 13357 sanctioned.
4.1 It is the pleaded case of the plaintiff that Sardara Singh did not
execute any alleged Will in favour of defendants No. 1 to 4 during his
lifetime, which is a forged and fabricated document so as to deprive the
plaintiff of her valuable rights in the suit property. It was also pleaded that
the defendants were bent upon and threatening to alienate/transfer the suit
property by taking law into their hands. It is asserted that the defendants
were asked many times to admit the rightful claim of the plaintiff; however,
they refused to do so. Accordingly, the suit has been filed.
5. Upon issuance of notice in the suit, defendants No. 1, 3 to 5
appeared and filed written statement taking various preliminary objections.
It was stated that the father of the plaintiff, during his lifetime, executed a
Will dated 01.10.2004 in favour of defendants No. 1 to 4 due to love and
affection, as they were taking care and serving Sardara Singh during his
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-572-2024 (O&M) -3-
lifetime. It was further stated that the daughters of Sardara Singh were
already married, and the said fact is duly mentioned in the Will. It was
further contended that the suit has been filed by the plaintiff in connivance
with Boota Singh (defendant No. 2) and Kartar Kaur (defendant No. 6).
They maintained that Sardara Singh executed the Will dated 01.10.2004 in
favour of his sons out of natural love and affection, out of his free will and
consent, and that the plaintiff is not entitled to the property left by Sardara
Singh. It was also stated that the plaintiff had challenged the Will before the
Revenue Authorities, wherein she did not deny the execution of the Will.
Denying other averments of the plaint, prayer for dismissal of the suit was
made.
6. From the pleading of the parties, following issues were framed
by the learned Trial Court:-
“1. Whether plaintiff is entitled to the relief of declaration as
prayed for? OPP
2. Whether alleged will dated 01.10.2014 and mutation
No. 13357 are all together illegal, unjust, void at law and
liable to be set aside? OPP.
3. Whether plaintiff is entitled to consequential relief of
permanent injunction as prayed for? OPP
4. Whether plaintiff has not come to the court with clean
hands and has concealed material facts from this court?
OPD
5. Whether the sons of Sardara Singh used to serve their
father in very good manner? OPD
6. Whether the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable in the
present form? OPD
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-572-2024 (O&M) -4-
7. Whether plaintiff has no cause of action to file the present
suit?
8. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder and mis-joinder of
necessary parties? OPD
9. Relief.”
7. Thereafter, the parties led their respective evidence on the
aforesaid issues.
8. The learned Trial Court, upon consideration of the matter,
dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiff vide judgment and decree dated
05.07.2019.
9. Feeling dissatisfied, the plaintiff preferred an appeal before the
learned Additional District Judge, Moga, which has also been dismissed vide
judgment and decree dated 16.01.2023.
10. In the aforementioned circumstances, the present second appeal
has been filed before this Court.
11. I have heard learned counsel for the appellant/plaintiff and
perused the paperbook with her able assistance.
12. The relationship between the plaintiff and defendants is not
disputed. The plaintiff has filed the suit claiming her share in the estate left
by her father Sardara Singh, by challenging the alleged Will dated
01.10.2004 in favour of defendants No. 1 to 4. In support of her case,
plaintiff examined only herself as PW-1. Whereas, on the other hand, the
defendants, in order to prove the due execution of the Will, examined both
the marginal witnesses of the Will (Exhibit D-1), namely Ranjit Singh
(DW-2) and Jagtar Singh (DW-3). The defendants further examined Rakesh
Kumar, Office Kanungo (DW-1), who brought the record of Will dated
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-572-2024 (O&M) -5-
01.10.2004 and also mutation No. 13357. The marginal witnesses of the Will
identified their signatures on the Will and in their cross-examination, the
plaintiff could not extract anything which could raise a suspicion as regards
the due execution of the Will.
13. The learned Trial Court, after appraisal of the evidence, came to
the conclusion that the defendants had duly met the legal requirements to
prove the Will, whereas except the bald statement of the plaintiff that the
Will is forged and fabricated, nothing has been brought on record in support
thereof. The plea of the plaintiff that Sardara Singh was an illiterate person,
therefore, he could not execute the Will, was not accepted by the learned
Trial Court. Since, the plaintiff failed to highlight any suspicious
circumstances surrounding the Will, accordingly, the learned Trial Court, on
the basis of findings returned on various issues, dismissed the suit filed by
the plaintiff.
14. The findings returned by the learned Trial Court have been
further affirmed by the learned First Appellate Court by observing as under:
“25. In the present case, defendants No.1 to 4 has examined
both the attesting witnesses. As per Section 68 of Indian
Evidence Act 1872, Will has proved on record as per law. The
contention of learned counsel for appellant is that there was no
ground to disinherit the plaintiff from succession. This court is
of the view that there is no force in the contention of the counsel
for the plaintiff in this regard, Will is executed in order to break
natural line of succession, thus, excluding natural heirs from
inheritance ipso facto is no ground to discard Will. If there was
no intention on the part of the testator to break the natural line
then, there was no need to execute a Will. Only on the ground
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-572-2024 (O&M) -6-
that relations between the plaintiff and Sardara Singh, her
father were cordial, it cannot be said that it is suspicious
circumstances to discard the Will. Sardara Singh has
bequeathed his land in favour of his sons excluding his
daughters and wife. This is not a suspicious circumstance. In
the State of Punjab, persons ordinarily do not want their
agricultural land to go out from the family. Moreover, if
daughters of deceased is happily married and if the testator
thought it would be proper to exclude her from his agricultural
property, then he would be bequeath the same in favour of his
sons. Will is a document that speaks the words of the deceased
after his death. The executant of Will though is never available
for deposing in what circumstances, he had executed the Will.
This aspect introduces an element of solemnity in the decision of
a question whether the document propounded is proved to the
last Will of the testator.
26. Next contention learned counsel for appellant is that
regular scribe was available in the village, but despite that Will
was scribed by Kuldeep Singh. This court is of the view that as
per Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, Will must be executed
in the presence of two attesting witnesses and that requirement
has been complied with. Only on the ground that Will was not
scribed by a regular deed writer, it is not a suspicious
circumstance. Only on this ground Will cannot be discarded.
Perusal of Will Ex.D1 shows that Sardara Singh son of Prem
Singh has executed a Will that he is 70 years old and due to his
old age, he is executing the Will. There is a specific mention in
Will regarding exclusion of the daughters and his wife. This
court is of the view that Will was executed with sound and
disposing mind. Thus, there is no force in the contention raised
by learned counsel for appellant in this regard.
27. Next contention raised by learned counsel for appellant
is that Ranjit Singh, attesting witness has stated that he does not
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-572-2024 (O&M) -7-
know the name of any persons, present at the house of deceased
Sardara Singh. DW-2 Ranjit Singh during his cross-examination
has deposed that Will was scribed by Kuldeep Singh at the
instance of Sardara Singh in his presence and in the presence of
Jagtar Singh other attesting witness. Sardara Singh was in
sound disposing mind. Only on the ground that attesting witness
in his cross-examination stated that he does not know the
persons present in the house of Sardara Singh, it does not effect
the case of the defendants. He has named the scribe and
attesting witness namely Jagtar Singh. If he does not know the
name of other persons, who were present at the house of
Sardara Singh other than aforesaid persons, it cannot effect the
case of defendants. Thus, there is no force in the contention
raised by learned counsel for appellant in this regard.
28. Next contention raised by learned counsel for appellant
is that marriage of plaintiff Ranjit Kaur was a simple affair.
Defendant No.3 Gurmeet Singh appeared into witness box as
DW-4. He has deposed that there was a Chuni Chadawa
ceremony performed of his sister Ranjit Kaur. Rs.50,000/- as
cash and dowry given to her at that time. From Will, it is
evident that Sardara Singh stated that his daughters are
comfortable. No doubt other daughter Jeeto is divorcee. There
is general tendency in the State of Punjab, to give property to
the sons instead of daughters. This court is of the view that
defendants had been successful in proving due execution of the
Will and same cannot be said to be surrounded by suspicious
circumstances. On the basis of Will defendants No.1 to 4 has
become the owners. Appellant Ranjit Kaur has no right, title or
interest in the property. She is not entitled for declaration and
injunction, as sought for.
29. In view of above said discussion, no illegality or
perversity has been found in impugned judgment passed by
learned lower court and the same is based on proper
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-572-2024 (O&M) -8-
appreciation of evidence. Accordingly, points of determination
being the issues in this case and findings given by learned lower
court thereon are re-affirmed in favour of the defendants and
against the plaintiff. As such, there is no merit in the present
appeal and the same is hereby dismissed with no order as to
costs….”
15. Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in “Parvathi Nairthi (Dead)
and others v. Laxmi Nairthy (Dead) through LRs. and others”, 2026(3)
RCR (Civil) 96 , has held that a Will’s validity can be upheld when it is
executed in compliance with statutory requirements, attested by witnesses,
and free from suspicious circumstances- Mere exclusion of natural heirs
does not render a will invalid, and concurrent findings by lower courts on its
genuineness should not be interfered with lightly. The relevant observations
of the aforesaid judgment read as under:-
“34. With regard to the prudence to be drawn while determining
the suspicious circumstances, all the Courts have
unambiguously opined that the Will in question was validly
executed. It is trite to state that when the validity of a Will is to
be determined, the overall terms of a Will, the intention of the
testator and the surrounding circumstances have also to be
seen. Mere exclusion of the natural heirs from the property of
the testator, by itself, cannot be construed as a suspicious
circumstance so as to invalidate a Will outrightly. A testator is
legally entitled to dispose of his property according to his own
wishes, and unless the exclusion is accompanied by suspicious
circumstances affecting the genuineness or due execution of a
Will, such exclusion alone does not render a Will invalid. Thus,
we are of the considered view that the exclusion of the natural
heirs cannot be sufficient to vitiate the Will in question,
particularly when the Will clearly specifies that the testator has
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-572-2024 (O&M) -9-
not done any injustice to his wife, children, or other relatives,
and that he has given enough to his wife and children who are
residing at Bombay.”
16. Before this Court, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
has failed to point out any suspicious circumstance surrounding the Will. It
is also not shown as to how the findings returned by the learned Courts
below are either illegal or perverse or based on misreading of evidence.
Apparently, there are concurrent findings returned by learned Courts below.
17. In Jaichand v. Sahnulal, 2025(2) Apex Court Judgments (SC)
336 ; Hon'ble Apex Court observed as under:-
“24. In Navaneethammal v. Arjuna Chetty reported in AIR
1996 S.C. 3521 , it was held by this Court that the High Court
should not reappreciate the evidence to reach another possible
view in order to set aside the findings of fact arrived at by the
first appellate Court.
25. In Kshitisn Chandra Purkait v. Santhosh Kumar Purkait
reported in (1997) 5 S.C.C. 438) , this Court held that in the
Second Appeal, the High Court should be satisfied that the case
involves a substantial question of law and not mere question of
law.
26. In Dnyanoba Bhaurao Shemade v. Maroti Bhaurao
Marnor reported in 1999 (2) S.C.C. 471 , this Court held:-
"Keeping in view the amendment made in 1976, the High Court
can exercise its jurisdiction under Section 100, C.P.C. only on
the basis of substantial questions of law which are to be framed
at the time of admission of the Second Appeal and the Second
Appeal has to be heard and decided only on the basis of such
duly framed substantial questions of law. A judgment rendered
by the High Court under Section 100 C.P.C. without following
the aforesaid procedure cannot be sustained."
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-572-2024 (O&M) -10-
27. This Court in Kondira Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai
Sopan Gujar reported in AIR 1999 S.C. 2213 held:-
"The High Court cannot substitute its opinion for the
opinion of the first appellate Court unless it is found that
the conclusions drawn by the lower appellate Court were
erroneous being contrary to the mandatory provisions of
law applicable or its settled position on the basis of
pronouncements made by the Apex Court, or was based
upon inadmissible evidence or arrived at without
evidence."
28. It is thus clear that under Section 100, C.P.C., the High
Court cannot interfere with the findings of fact arrived at by the
first Appellate Court which is the final Court of facts except in
such cases where such findings were erroneous being contrary
to the mandatory provisions of law, or its settled position on the
basis of the pronouncement made by the Apex Court or based
upon inadmissible evidence or without evidence…”
18. Keeping in view the above discussion, I see no merit in this
appeal nor there is any substantial question of law involved in the present
regular second appeal.
19. Resultantly, the instant regular second appeal fails and the same
is accordingly, dismissed .
20. All the pending application(s), if any, shall also stand closed.
(HARSH BUNGER)
12.11.2026 JUDGE
Ankit
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
ANKIT
2026.11.18 11:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh