K. Vidwan Reddy vs Bagari Yadagiri

Court
High Court for the State of Telangana

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA ::
AT HYDERABAD
*
Civil Revision Petition No.2168 of 2026
CNR.No.HBHC010489992026
Between:
K. Vidwan Reddy, S/o.K. Raja Reddy
and 8 others
…Petitioners
v.
Bagari Yadagiri, S/o.Balaiah
and 25 others
…Respondents

JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON: 24.09.2026
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY

1. Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
may be allowed to see the Judgments? : Yes
2. Whether the copies of judgment may be
Marked to Law Reporters/Journals? : Yes
3. Whether His Lordship wishes to
see the fair copy of the Judgment? : Yes



____________________
P.SAM KOSHY , J

Page 2 of 16


* THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY

+ Civil Revision Petition No.2168 of 2026
CNR.No.HBHC010489992026

% 24.09.2026

# Between:

K. Vidwan Reddy, S/o.K. Raja Reddy
and 8 others
…Petitioners
v.
Bagari Yadagiri, S/o.Balaiah
and 25 others
…Respondents


! Counsel for Petitioners : Mr. Vadeendra Joshi
^Counsel for the respondents : None


<GIST:


> HEAD NOTE:


? Cases referred ::

1. [AIR 1954 Mad 170]
2. [(2000) 6 SCC 359]
3. Civil Appeal No.3524 of 2026, decided on 18.03.2026

Page 3 of 16

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY

Civil Revision Petition No.2168 of 2026
CNR.No.HBHC010489992026

Reserved on :: 18.09.2026 Pronounced on ::24.09.2026
Uploaded on :: 24 .09.2026

Between :

K. Vidwan Reddy, S/o.K. Raja Reddy
and 8 others
…Petitioners
v.
Bagari Yadagiri, S/o.Balaiah
and 25 others
…Respondents

ORDER:

The instant Civil Revision Petition has been filed by the
petitioners under Article 227 of the Constitution of India assailing the
order dated 11.06.2026 in E.A.No.25 of 2026 in E.P.S.R.No.18189 of
2025 passed by the Chief Judge, City Civil Court, at Hyderabad (for
short, ‘the impugned order’) .

Heard Mr. Vadeendra Joshi, learned counsel for the petitioners.
2.

Page 4 of 16

3. Vide the impugned order, the Trial Court rejected the application
filed by the petitioners herein under Order XLVII Rule 1 and Section 114
of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908, praying the Trial Court to set aside
the order dated 09.01.2026 in E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025, passed by the
Chief Judge, City Civil Court, at Hyderabad.

4. The brief facts relevant for disposal of the instant Civil Revision
Petition are that petitioners had filed E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025 for
execution of the Judgment and Decree dated 22.03.2013 in Land
Grabbing Case No.23 of 2009 passed by the Special Court under the
Andhra Pradesh Land Grabbing (Protection) Act, 1982 (for short, ‘the
Act of 1982) . Vide the said judgment, the respondents were declared to
be land grabbers within the meaning of Section 2(d) and (e) of Act of
1982. While passing the said judgment, the concerned Court had
directed the Judgment-Debtors (respondents) to hand over vacant
possession of the schedule property to the Decree-Holders (petitioners)
within three (03) months. Thereafter, the said judgment and decree was
put to execution by the Decree-Holders (petitioners) by filing E.P., viz.,
E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025 before the Chief Judge, City Civil Court,

Page 5 of 16

Hyderabad. However, the Office of the City Civil Court, at Hyderabad
raised an objection as to the execution petition being barred by limitation
since the same was filed beyond twelve years from the date of passing of
the judgment and decree dated 22.03.2013 in Land Grabbing Case No.23
of 2009. The objection raised by the Office of the City Civil Court, at
Hyderabad was upheld by the Chief Judge, City Civil Court, at
Hyderabad vide order dated 09.01.2026 in E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025,
and the said petition was dismissed holding that the execution petition to
be barred by limitation.

5. Aggrieved, the petitioners herein filed a fresh application before
the Trial Court, viz., E.A.No.25 of 2026 in E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025
under Order XLVII Rule 1 and Section 114 of the Civil Procedure Code,
1908, seeking review of the order 09.01.2026 in E.P.S.R.No.18189 of
2025. It is this application which stood rejected by the Chief Judge, City
Civil Court, at Hyderabad, and which has led to filing of the instant Civil
Revision Petition.

6. The explanation provided by the petitioners explaining the delay
that had caused was that of the Judgment and Decree dated 22.03.2013

Page 6 of 16

in Land Grabbing Case No.23 of 2009 was subjected to challenge by the
respondents (Judgment-Debtors) by filing writ petition before this Court,
viz., Writ Petition No.14625 of 2013. Vide order dated 06.08.2024 in
Writ Petition No.14625 of 2013, a learned Division Bench of this Court
dismissed the said writ petition for non-prosecution. It is only after
dismissal of the aforesaid writ petition that limitation for filing the
execution petition would start afresh. Thus, the finding given by the
learned Chief Judge, City Civil Court, at Hyderabad vide order dated
09.01.2026 in E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025 is erroneous and is liable to be
set aside.

7. Learned counsel for the petitioners further contended that the
Executing Court had in fact wrongly appreciated the decision cited by
the petitioners before the Trial Court, viz., in the case of Kunjammal v.
1
Krishna Chettiar . According to him, the aforesaid decision very
specifically envisages the aspect of limitation to commence from the date
of disposal of the appellate proceedings. He further contended that the
Executing Court had not properly considered the provisions of Section

1
[AIR 1954 Mad 170]

Page 7 of 16

18 of the Limitation Act, 1963; provisions of Section 18 of the
Limitation Act, 1963 do not apply to the facts of the instant case on the
ground that the so-called writ petition that was pending consideration
before this Court since 2013 to 2014 was not at the behest of petitioners.
He further contended that provisions of Land Grabbing Act do not
provide for any provision for execution of the order, neither does the said
Act has any provision for an appeal against an order passed by the Land
Grabbing Court. Since there is no remedy of appeal, the writ remedy is
the only option available to the aggrieved person, and the Writ Petition
filed by the petitioners before this Court where there was a challenge to
the order passed by the Land Grabbing Court stood decided only on
06.08.2024. He, therefore, contended that applying the doctrine of
merger , the limitation would start only from the date of decision passed
by the Writ Court, which in the instant case is 06.08.2024.

8. Learned counsel for the petitioners further contended that since the
challenge to the order passed by the Land Grabbing Court was sub judice
before the Writ Court, and during pendency of the Writ Petition the
judgment passed by the Land Grabbing Court was unenforceable; and

Page 8 of 16

therefore contended that it was for the said pendency of the writ petition
the judgment of the Land Grabbing Court remained unimplemented or
unexecuted.

9. According to learned counsel for the petitioners, the period of
limitation has to be reckoned from the date of order passed by the
Appellate Forum; even if there was no interim stay in the Appellate
jurisdiction, the judgment and decree that can be enforced is that of the
Appellate Forum, and the judgment of the Trial Court gets merged with
the Judgment of the Appellate Court. Hence, the limitation would start
from the date of order passed by the Appellate Forum. Therefore, to that
extent, the finding arrived by the Executing Court is erroneous.

10. Having heard the contentions put forth on either side and on a
perusal of the record, what stands admitted is that there being a
Judgment and Decree from the Land Grabbing Court, dated 22.03.2013
in Land Grabbing Case No.23 of 2009, in favour of petitioners (Decree-
Holders); and when the said Judgment and Decree was subjected to
challenge by the respondents (Judgment-Debtors) vide Writ Petition
No.14625 of 2013, the said Writ Petition finally got dismissed on

Page 9 of 16

06.08.2024; and subsequently, E.P.S.R. was filed by the petitioners in
2025, viz., E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025, for executing the order passed by
the Land Grabbing court; however, the said E.P.S.R. stood rejected and
returned by the Executing Court holding it to be barred by limitation,
vide order dated 09.01.2026 in E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025. Thereafter,
the said order was put to review by filing E.A.No.25 of 2026 in
E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025 which also stood rejected vide the impugned
order dated 11.06.2026 in E.A.No.25 of 2026 in E.P.S.R.No.18189 of
2025.

11. Though the challenge in the instant Civil Revision Petition is to
the order dated 11.06.2026 in E.A.No.25 of 2026 in E.P.S.R.No.18189 of
2025, the substantive challenge is also to the order dated 09.01.2026 in
E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025 whereby the E.P. filed by the petitioners stood
rejected on the ground of being barred by limitation.

12. The core issue to be decided in the instant Civil Revision Petition
is whether for the purpose of reckoning limitation would the date of the
Judgment and Decree dated 22.03.2013 in Land Grabbing Case No.23 of
2009 is to be taken; or whether it is to be reckoned from the date the writ

Page 10 of 16

petition (wherein the order dated 22.03.2013 in Land Grabbing Case
No.23 of 2009 was under challenge) stood dismissed on 06.08.2024”.

13. The fact which needs to be appreciated is that under the Land
Grabbing Act, 1982, there is no remedy of appeal against an order passed
by the Court which decides a land grabbing case. In the absence of any
statutory remedy of appeal, the only recourse to challenge under the
Land Grabbing Act is by way of a writ petition. Admittedly, the
Judgment and Decree dated 22.03.2013 in Land Grabbing Case No.23 of
2009 passed by the Special Court under the Land Grabbing Act was put
to test by the respondents (Judgment-Debtors) in Writ Petition No.14625
of 2013. Therefore, for all practical purposes the said writ petition
would have to be considered to be in the form of an appeal against the
Judgment and Decree passed by the Court hearing land grabbing cases.
The said Writ Petition No.14625 of 2013 finally stood dismissed on
06.08.2024.

14. True it is that there was no interim stay operating from 2013
onwards in Writ Petition No.14625 of 2013 insofar as the order passed
by the Land Grabbing Court which decided Land Grabbing Case No.23

Page 11 of 16

of 2009 dated 22.03.2013. Nonetheless, the said Judgment and Decree
was put to challenge in the aforesaid writ petition, viz., Writ Petition
No.14625 of 2013.

15. At this juncture, it would be relevant to take not of couple of
judicial precedents which have also been referred to by the learned
counsel for the petitioners, as one among them has also been referred to
in the impugned order under challenge, viz., Kunjammal (1 supra),
wherein a learned Division Bench of the High Court of Madras has held
as under, viz.,
“3. The law is well settled that when a decree is taken in appeal to a higher
Court the decree passed in appeal supersedes that of the Court below and
becomes the decree in the suit itself and that thereafter that is the only decree
which is capable of execution and that the period of limitation for execution
would run from the date of that decree. In -- 'Krishtama Chariar v.
Mangammal' , 26 Mad 91 (FB) (A), the question arose how far this doctrine
would be applicable in a case where the appeal was in respect of a portion of the
subject matter of the suit. The contention that was urged was that as regards the
un-appealed portion there was no impediment to execution and therefore as to
that limitation should be reckoned from the date of the decree of the first Court,
and that as that portion was not the subject matter of the appeal the period of
limitation should not be calculated from the date of the decree of the appellate
Court. This contention was rejected by this Court. Bhashyam Ayyangar J. stated
the principle applicable to the case in these terms:

Page 12 of 16

"In my opinion, this is sound from a juridical point of view. When an
appeal is preferred from a decree of a Court of first instance, the suit is
continued in the Court of appeal and reheard either in whole or in part,
according as the whole suit is litigated again in the Court of appeal or only
a part of it. The final decree in the appeal will thus be the final decree in
the suit, whether that be one confirming, varying or reversing the decree of
the Court of first instance. The mere fact that a matter is litigated both in
the Court of first instance and again, though only in part in the Court of
appeal, cannot convert or split the suit into two and there can be only one
final decree in that suit, viz., the decree of the Court of appeal. There
cannot be two final decrees in such a suit, one by the Court of first instance
and the other by the Court of appeal."
16. Coming to the doctrine of merger the Hon’ble Apex Court, in the
2
case of Kunhayammed and others v. State of Kerala and another ,
held at paragraph No.12 as under, viz.,
“12. The logic underlying the doctrine of merger is that there
cannot be more than one decree or operative orders governing the same
subject-matter at a given point of time. When a decree or order passed by
inferior court, tribunal or authority was subjected to a remedy available
under the law before a superior forum then, though the decree or order under
challenge continues to be effective and binding, nevertheless its finality is
put in jeopardy. Once the superior court has disposed of the lis before it
either way - whether the decree or order under appeal is set aside or
modified or simply confirmed, it is the decree or order of the superior court,
tribunal or authority which is the final, binding and operative decree or order
wherein merges the decree or order passed by the court, tribunal or the
authority below. However, the doctrine is not of universal or unlimited

2
[(2000) 6 SCC 359]

Page 13 of 16

application. The nature of jurisdiction exercised by the superior forum and
the content or subject-matter of challenge laid or which could have been laid
shall have to be kept in view.”

17. Recently, the Division Bench of the Hon’ble Apex Court in one of
its judgments dealing with the aspect of limitation in the case of
3
Gajanan v. Pralhad held at paragraph Nos.21 and 22 as under, viz.,
“ 21. The upshot of this discussion is that an appeal is intrinsically a
continuation of the suit and thus, even if an appeal against an order
or decree of the Trial Court is dismissed on any preliminary or
technical ground, such as limitation or non-prosecution, rather than
the merits of the case, it still gives rise to a fresh starting point for
the limitation period for execution of such order or decree. The
original decree of the Trial Court cannot be deemed as "final" as
long as the appeal against the same remains pending. Thus, the order
of dismissal of the appeal finally disposes of the matter and confirms
the decree of the Trial Court, even if such dismissal is for reason of
non-prosecution.

22. The order dated 25.11.2004, which dismissed the appeal in
default, was thus a "final order" as it finally confirmed the decree of
the Trial Court and disposed of the appeal. Therefore, the limitation
period for execution of the decree dated 03.12.1999 accrued on the
date of dismissal of the appeal i.e. 25.11.2004 and the execution.
application filed on 04.12.2015 was within time, if we compute-the
period of 12 years from 25.11.2004.”

3
Civil Appeal No.3524 of 2026, decided on 18.03.2026

Page 14 of 16


18. A plain reading of the aforesaid judicial precedents both on the
aspect of limitation as also on the aspect of doctrine of merger , when
applied to the facts of the instant case would go to establish that the
original Judgment and Decree dated 22.03.2013 in Land Grabbing Case
No.23 of 2009 was subjected to challenge by way of remedy of appeal
by filing Writ Petition No.14635 of 2013, and which stood dismissed on
06.08.2024. The dismissal of the said writ petition even if it is on
technicalities leads to conclusion of the Judgment and Decree dated
22.03.2013 in Land Grabbing Case No.23 of 2009 being affirmed on
06.08.2024 in Writ Petition No.14635 of 2013. Thereafter, from 2013 to
06.08.2024, the Judgment and Decree dated 22.03.2013 in Land
Grabbing Case No.23 of 2009 was sub judice . As long as the matter was
sub judice , the said Judgment and Decree is unenforceable and could not
had been implemented. So, for all practical purposes it is beyond
06.08.2024 that the petitioners would have got a chance of filing
execution proceedings. Merely, because there was no interim order in
operation in Writ Petition No.14635 of 2013, that by itself cannot be
considered to be a strong ground to hold that during the intervening

Page 15 of 16

period the petitioners’ right to move the Execution Court got expired
when substantively the Judgment and Decree dated 22.03.2013 in Land
Grabbing Case No.23 of 2009 was still under challenge in the above writ
petition which got finally dismissed on 06.08.2024.

19. In view of the same, this Court is of the considered opinion that in
the teeth of decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court referred to in the
preceeding paragraphs the rejection of E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025 by the
Executing Court holding it to be barred by limitation is therefore
unsustainable. Therefore, in the opinion of this Court, the order dated
11.06.2026 in E.A.No.25 of 2026 in E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025 passed
by the Chief Judge, City Civil Court, at Hyderabad deserves to be set
aside. Accordingly, the order dated 11.06.2026 in E.A.No.25 of 2026 in
E.P.S.R.No.18189 of 2025 passed by the Chief Judge, City Civil Court,
at Hyderabad, is set aside. The matter stands remitted to the Trial Court
with a direction to register and number the E.P. on its file. The Trial
Court is further directed to decide the E.P. in accordance with law
ignoring the aspect of limitation.

Page 16 of 16

20. With these observations, the Civil Revision Petition stands
allowed. No costs.

21. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending if any, shall stand
closed.
________________
P.SAM KOSHY, J

Date: 24.09.2026

LR copy to be marked : Yes
B/o.

Ndr