M/S MAGNASOFT CONSULTING PVT LTD vs MR AMRUTESH G S

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021






IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 18 DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR

REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 265 OF 2021

BETWEEN:

1. M/S MAGNASOFT CONSULTING PVT LTD
A COMPANY INCORPORATED AND
DULY REGISTERED UNDER THE PROVISIONS
OF THE COMPANIES ACT, 1956
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT
SEZ TOWER-1, FIRST FLOOR,
GLOBAL VILLAGE TECHNOLOGY PARK,
MYLASANDRA, PATTANAGERE VILLAGE,
BANGALORE – 560 059.
REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORISED
REPRESENTATIVE
MR. SIDDARAMANNA MB

…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. SWAROOP ANAND R, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. MR AMRUTESH G S
S/O. MR. SATYAN GANJIGUNTE VENKATESH,
R/AT NO. 43/A,
TH
12 MAIN, AGS LAYOUT,
AREHALLY, SUBRAMANYAPURA POST,
BANGALORE – 560 061.

2. MR. VENKATESH BABU Y A
S/O. MR. ASATHAIAH T V,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
R/AT NO. 448,
SREE SAPTHAGIRI NIVASA,











Digitally
signed by N
UMA
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


TH TH
4 MAIN, 4 CROSS,
NEAR ANAND ALTAIR APARTMENT,
BCMC LAYOUT, RAGHUVANAHALLI,
DODDAK, BANGALORE – 560 109.
3. MR. MUSTAK AHMMAD M PATIL
S/O FATHER’S NAME NOT KNOWN
AGEB ABOUT 37 YEARS
R/AT NO. 35, ROYAL MANOR APARTMENT,
FLAT NO. G-4, RANJAI RAO ROAD,
BASAVANAGUDI,
BANGALORE – 560 004.

4. MR. SUDEEP SINGH RATHORE
S/O. MR. KRISHNA PAL SINGH RATHORE,
R/AT NO 186,
D1 BLOCK,
DLF WESTLAND HEIGHTS,
DLF NEW TOWN,
AKSHAYNAGAR, BANGALORE – 560 068.

5. MR. PHALGUNA M R
S/O. RAMAKRISHNAPPA,
ST TH
R/AT NO. 163, 1 MAIN, 5 CROSS,
TH RD
6 BLOCK, 3 PHASE,
NEAR KAMAKYA,
RD
BANASHANKARI 3 STAGE,
BANGALORE – 560 098.

6. M/S. SCOUTTERRA TECHNOLOGIES INDIA PVT. LTD.,
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT
RAJESHWARI ALTIUS, SITE NO. 638,
TH TH
18 MAIN ROAD, 24 CROSS,
IDEAL HOME,
RR NAGAR, BANGALORE – 560 098.
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTORS

…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. M R NAGAYAN, ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R6)

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SEC.96 OF CPC., AGAINST
THE ORDER DATED 17.12.2020 PASSED ON IN OS
No.5498/2019 ON THE FILE OF THE XVIII ADDL. CITY CIVIL
JUDGE AT BENGALURU CITY (CCH-No.10) AND ETC.,

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FURTHER ARGUMENTS,
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR

ORAL JUDGMENT

This Regular First Appeal is filed by the appellant /
plaintiff calling in question the order dated 17.12.2020 in O.S
No.5498/2019 passed on I.A No.5 by the XVIII Additional City
Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru City (CCH-10), whereby
the application filed by the defendants under Order VII Rule
11(a) and (d) of CPC came to be allowed and rejected the
plaint filed by the plaintiffs.

2. For the sake of convenience and easy reference, the
parties are referred to as per their rankings before the Trial
Court.

3. It is the brief case of the plaintiff that the
defendants are employees and they are appointed on certain
terms and conditions. One of the non-soliciting conditions is

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


that, during the employment of the defendants for the period of
one year after cessation of employment, the defendants
directly or indirectly, shall not attempt in any manner to solicit
from any client/customer of the company and/or its
subsidiaries, the business of the type carried on by the
company and/or its subsidiaries or to persuade any person etc.,
to employ any person who is in the employment of the
company and/or its subsidiaries at the time of the alleged
prohibited conduct or was in the employment of the company
and/or its subsidiaries at any time, failing which, the employees
will compensate the company for the losses incurred by way of
damages.

4. It is alleged that, after cessation of their
employment with the plaintiff company, the defendants had
started trade and commenced a new industry by stealing the
information and data of the plaintiff company and solicited the
clients of the company and thus caused loss and reputation to
the plaintiff company. Therefore, the plaintiff filed suit for
permanent injunction. The defendants filed application – I.A

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


No.5 under Order VII Rule 11(a) and (d) of CPC praying to
reject the plaint.

5. It is contended by the defendants in the application
that, denying all the averments in the plaint and commencing a
new trade and business by the defendants does not affect the
interests of the plaintiff company and that any such
restriction restrains the fundamental rights of the defendants
to carry any trade or business. Therefore, the plaintiff has no
cause of action to institute a suit. Thus, the defendants prays
to reject the plaint.

6. The grounds urged in the application are that there
is no cause of action to institute suit and that the suit is barred
by law.

7. The Trial Court after considering the averments
made in the plaint has opined that though defendants No.1 to 5
were employees under the plaintiff company and after
cessation of employment they have started their own trade
or business and that any such restriction or restraintment

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


carrying out business or trade by defendants is nothing
but contrary to section 27 of the Indian Contract
Act. Therefore, it is held that there is no cause of action to
institute the suit. Accordingly, the plaint was rejected.

8. The Trial Court observed that when a Court is
encountered with dispute as to decide whether a former
employees have to be restrained from carrying on new business
which are not in violation of any existing law, the same do not
require arduous trial to decide such facts. Therefore, there
cannot be any restraintment restraining the defendants to carry
out new trade or business. Therefore, the plaint filed is nothing
but causing a restraintment to defendants to carry on new
trade or business. This cannot be permitted, as such non-
solicitation clause violates section 27 of the Indian Contract
Act. Thus, the Trial Court rejected the plaint.

9. Being aggrieved by the rejection of plaint, the
plaintiff has filed the appeal by raising various grounds and the
learned counsel for the appellant in consonance with the
grounds raised, has argued that the defendants after leaving

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


the plaintiff company have started a new business and trade by
making use of the information and data collected by the
company. Therefore, it is the arguments canvassed by the
learned counsel for the appellant that, when the defendants
were working as employees of the plaintiff company, they had
stolen the data information and left the company and started
new business which contravenes the non-solicitation
clause. Therefore, it is submitted that the plaintiff is entitled
to damages and thus, the suit is maintainable. Therefore, the
learned counsel prays to allow the appeal and remand the case
for trial for adjudication of the suit.

10. The learned counsel for the appellant has placed

reliance on the following judgments:
1. The Judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in
the case of Madhav Prasad Aggarwal and Ors. Vs.
1
Axis BAnk Ltd. And Ors .
2. The Judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in
the case of Sejal Glass Ltd. Vs. Navilan Merchants
2
Pvt. Ltd.

1
(2019) 7 SCC 158
2
(2018) 11 SCC 780

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


3. The Judgment of the High Court of Delhi in the case of
Wipro Limited Vs. Beckman Coulter
3
International S.A .

11. On the other hand, learned counsel for the
respondents/defendants submitted that though the non-
solicitation clause was for a period of one year but now already
eight years is lapsed. Therefore, such non-solicitation clause is
not applicable.

12. Further, it is submitted that the plaintiff cannot
restrain the defendants from carrying on any business, as the
commencement of new business or trade by the defendants is a
fundamental right as per Article 19 (1)(g) of the Constitution
of India. Therefore, the plaintiff cannot restrain the defendants
from carrying on their business by filing the suit. Therefore, it
is submitted that the suit filed is illusory one and the facts
pleaded in the plaint do not constitute any cause of action to
institute the suit.

13. Further, it is submitted that there is no cause of
action at all to institute the suit and whatever the cause of

3
OMP 463/2005 Decided on 11.07.2006

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


action raised to file the suit is illusory one and the Trial Court
has considered this aspect correctly. Hence, the learned
counsel justified the order passed by the Trial Court and prays
to dismiss the appeal.

14. Upon hearing the submissions of learned counsel for
both the parties, the following points arise for my
consideration:
i) Whether, under the facts and circumstances
involved in the case, the defendants prove
that for instituting the suit there is no cause of
action?
ii) Whether, under the facts and circumstances
involved in the case, the plaintiff proves that
there is a cause of action to institute suit for
claiming relief of injunction as claimed in the
plaint?
iii) Whether, under the facts and circumstances
involved in the case, the defendants prove
that the restraintment made by the plaintiff as
claimed in the plaint causes any restraintment

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


and is in violation of Section 27 of the Indian
Contract Act and thus the suit is not
maintainable having no cause of action to
institute the suit?
iv) Whether the order passed by the Trial Court in
rejecting the plaint requires interference by
this Court?

15. Upon considering the facts pleaded in the plaint, the
whole averments of the plaint reads that the plaintiff is a
company and the defendants were employees working for quite
some time in the plaintiff company. The defendants, after
leaving the plaintiff company, started their own business or
trade. For this purpose, the defendants are alleged to have
used the data and information of the plaintiff company for
starting new business. It is pleaded that the defendants had
stolen the data and information while they were working as
employees in the plaintiff company and after leaving the
company had started new business by making use of the
company’s data and information. Therefore, the plaintiff has
pleaded that there is non-solicitation clause in the terms and

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


conditions of the appointment under Employees Proprietary
Information, Non-Compete and Inventions and Undertaking
Agreement and by invoking the said non-solicitation clause, the
suit is filed for permanent injunction and damages.

16. It is worthwhile to mention here what is pleaded in

paragraph No.31 of the plaint regarding cause of action, which
reads as under:


“CAUSE OF ACTION AND JURISDICTION
31. The cause of action arose when the Plaintiff issued
Appointment letters dated August 01, 2003; July 01,
2004; March 19, 2008; June 30, 2008 and August 01,
2013 to Defendants No. 1 to 5 respectively, on every
such date when Defendants No. 1 to 5 were given access
to confidential proprietary information of the Plaintiff, on
April 06, 2018 when Defendants No. 1 to 5 were relieved
from the services of the Plaintiff, on April 19, 2019 when
Defendant No. 6 was incorporated by Defendants No. 1
to 5, on May, 19 2019 when Defendant Nos. 1 to5 were
issued legal notices by the Plaintiff;on June 17, 2019
when Defendants No. 1 and 5 have responded to the
legal notice, and subsequently, each time that the
Defendants used the confidential and proprietary
information belonging to the Plaintiff and approached the
customers and employees of the Plaintiff and attempted

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


to induce them to switch their allegiance to the
Defendant No. 6.”

17. Upon considering the plaint averments, it is pleaded
that, the defendants were employees of plaintiff company and
had worked for sometime and have stolen the data and
information from the plaintiff company. After leaving the
company, they started new business by soliciting the clients of
plaintiff company and also soliciting the employees of the
plaintiff company. According to the plaintiff, this bundle of
facts stated in the plaint constitutes the above stated cause of
action to institute the suit. Therefore, upon considering the
facts pleaded and cause of action stated in the plaint which is
found to be making allegations against the defendants that
they have stolen the data and information of the plaintiff
company for which the plaintiff has other remedy available
under law. But upon considering the reasons for the cause of
action as pleaded in the plaint, the same do not disclose the
cause of action to institute the suit for claiming the reliefs
sought in the plaint.

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


18. It is worthwhile to mention the prayers made in the
plaint, which reads as follows:

“WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff prays that this Hon'ble Court
be pleased to pass a Judgment and Decree in favour of
the Plaintiff:

a. Of Permanent Injunction restraining the Defendant
Nos.1 to 5 from soliciting the Plaintiff's customers or
inducing the Plaintiff's customers to shift their
allegiance from the Plaintiff to the Defendant No.6 or
to any competitor of the Plaintiff; or any other entity
or company, which is involved in a business which is
similar or identical to the business of the Plaintiff
Company;
b. Of Permanent Injunction restraining the Defendant
Nos.1 to 5 from soliciting the Plaintiff's employees or
inducing the Plaintiff's employees to shift their
allegiance from the Plaintiff to the Defendant No.6 or
to any competitor of the Plaintiff; or any other entity
or company, which is involved in a business which is
similar or identical to the business of the Plaintiff
Company;
c. Of Permanent Injunction restraining the Defendant
Nos.1 to 5 from using the Plaintiff's confidential and
proprietary information within the knowledge and
possession of theDefendant Nos.1 to 5 during the
course of their employment, retainership or
consultation with the Defendant No. 6 or any other

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


competitor of the Plaintiff or any other entity or
company, which is involved in a business which is
similar or identical to the business of the Plaintiff
Company;
d. Of Permanent Injunction restraining the Defendant
Nos.1 to 5 from using the Plaintiff's customer details,
advertising content, products research and
manufacture, potential market information and other
intellectual property within the knowledge and
possession of the Defendant Nos.1 to 5 during the
course of their employment, retainership or
consultation with the Defendant No.6 or any other
competitor of the Plaintiff or any other entity or
company, which is involved in a business which is
similar or identical to the business of the Plaintiff
Company;
e. Pass such other or further order(s) as this Hon'ble
Court may deem just and necessary given the facts
and circumstances of the captioned matter; and
f. Award costs of the instant legal proceedings, payable
jointly or severally by the Defendants.

19. Therefore, the plaintiff filed the suit for injunction
restraining the defendants from carrying on new business by
making use of the knowledge gained in the plaintiff company
and the skills acquired by the defendants while they were
working in the plaintiff company. Therefore, the relief claimed

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


in the plaint is nothing but making restraint on the defendants
to carry out business or trade which is found to be contrary to
Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act.

20. Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, reads as
under:
“27. Agreement in restraint of trade, void.—
Every agreement by which any one is restrained from
exercising a lawful profession, trade or business of any
kind, is to that extent void.
Exception 1.—
Saving of agreement not to carry on business of which
goodwill is sold.—
One who sells the goodwill of a business may agree with
the buyer to refrain from carrying on a similar business,
within specified local limits, so long as the buyer, or any
person deriving title to the goodwill from him, carries on
a like business therein, provided that such limits appear
to the Court reasonable, regard being had to the nature
of the business.”

21. According to the plaintiff, the non-soliciting clause
as stated in sub-paragraph 6.2 of paragraph 6 of the
Employees Proprietary Information, Non-Compete and
Inventions and Undertaking Agreement, reads as follows:

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


“6.2. During my employment and on and upto one year
after cessation of employment, I promise, represent,
and covenants that I shall not, directly or indirectly
attempt in any manner to solicit from any
client/customer, of the Company and/or its
Subsidiaries, the business of the type carried on by the
Company and/or its Subsidiaries or to persuade any
person, firm or entity which is a client/customer of the
Company its Subsidiaries to cease doing business or to
reduce the amount of business which any such
client/customer has customarily done or might propose
doing with the Company its Subsidiaries, whether or
not the relationship between the Company and/or its
Subsidiaries and such client/customer was originally
established in whole or in part through his or its efforts
or employ or attempt to employ or assist anyone else
to employ any person who is in the employment of the
Company and/or its Subsidiaries at the time of the
alleged prohibited conduct, or was in the employment
of the Company and/or its Subsidiaries at any time,
failing which I will compensate the Company of the
losses incurred by way of damages.”

22. Even according to the said non-solicitation clause,
the period is only one year after cessation of employment. But,
now already eight years is lapsed. Though the non-solicitation
clause is one year but whether such non-solicitation clause for

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021


one year could be imposed as per law, is the question for
consideration. If any person working in a company or any
industry acquires some knowledge and skills and if he aspires
to come out of the company and start a new business or trade,
he cannot be restricted by the terms and conditions of the
employment under the name as ‘non-solicitation clause’. Such
non-solicitation is amounting to violation of Section 27 of the
Indian Contract Act.

23. Therefore, when considering the whole pleadings of
the plaint and its averments, the plaint denotes that the
defendants while working in the plaintiff company had stolen
the data and information, started new business and solicited
the clients of the plaintiff company. Upon considering the
plaint averments that, partial information and data stolen and
collected by the defendants and they were made use of by
them for starting new business or trade, therefore, in this
regard, the plaint is silent. Therefore, considering the plaint
averments itself there is no cause of action to institute the suit
and this is rightly considered by the Trial Court and rejected the
plaint.

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021



24. The judgments relied upon by the learned counsel
for the appellants are not applicable in the present case having
difference in factual matrix held in the above said judgment
and in the present case. Therefore, the said judgments are not
applicable to the present case.

25. It is the averments made in the plaint that the
defendants worked as employees for sometime in the plaintiff
company, acquired skill and knowledge and thereafter left the
company and started a new business by making use of
information and data which is stolen during the course of their
employment. This is the whole averments made in the plaint.
These bundle of facts made in the plaint do not constitute the
cause of action to institute the suit as stated above. Further,
the restraint on the defendants from carrying on such new
trade is violative of Article 19 of the Constitution of India. As
such, non-solicitation clause in the agreement is ultravires to
Section 27 of Indian Contract Act. Therefore, the Trial Court is
correct in rejecting the plaint. Accordingly, I answer point
No.(i) and (iii) in the affirmative and point No.(ii) and (iv) in
the negative . Thus, the appeal is liable to be dismissed.

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:51480
RFA No. 265 of 2021

CNR: KAHC010117812021



26. Accordingly, I proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
The Regular First Appeal is dismissed.




Sd/-
(HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR)
JUDGE



UN
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 33