DEBJOT NAYAK vs ANURADHA SAMAL

Court
Odisha High Court

WP(C)/32254/2026
ODHC010747982026
2026:OHC:317

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK

WP(C) No.32254 of 2026


CNR No. ODHC010747982026

Debjot Nayak ....... Petitioner

-Versus-
Anuradha Samal ....... Opposite Party


For Petitioner : Mr. D. Panigrahi, Advocate


For Opposite Party : Mr. M.Mohapatra, Advocate

----------------------------

CORAM: JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MISHRA
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Date of Hearing & Judgment: 18.11.2026
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

S.K. MISHRA, J.
1. Mr. Manoranjan Mohapatra, learned Counsel is
present and submits, he has instruction to represent the
Opposite Party-wife.
2. The present writ petition has been preferred by the
Petitioner-husband, who is the Respondent in C.P. No.879 of
2023, assailing the order dated 27.08.2026 passed in C.P.
No.879 of 2023, as at Annexure-7.
3. The learned Court below, vide the impugned order
dated 27.08.2026 has allowed the application dated
1 7
WP(C) No.32254 of 2026 Page of

09.07.2026 filed by the present Opposite Party-wife, who is
the Petitioner in C.P. No.879 of 2023, seeking analogous
hearing of the said proceeding along with C.P. No.180 of
2024, instituted by the present Petitioner-husband seeking a
decree of divorce.
4. Admittedly, the Petitioner-husband preferred
C.P.No. 272 of 2023 under Section-13(1)(ia) & (ib) of the
Hindu Marriage Act,1955, shortly, “the Act, 1955”, before the
Family Court, Jajpur, which has been renumbered as C.P.
No.180 of 2024, on being transferred to the learned Court
below, for passing a decree of divorce. The Opposite Party
wife has preferred C.P. No.879 of 2023 under Section 9 of
the Act,1955 for Restitution of Conjugal Rights.
5. Law is well settled that, when two or more
proceedings are pending in different Courts between the
same parties, such matrimonial proceedings may
appropriately be brought together so as to avoid conflicting
decisions. In N.C.V. Aishwarya Vs. A.S. Saravana Karthik
Sha), reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1199, the Supreme
Court held as follow:
10. Further, when two or more
proceedings are pending in different
2 7
WP(C) No.32254 of 2026 Page of

Courts between the same parties which
raise common question of fact and law,
and when the decisions in the cases are
interdependent, it is desirable that they
should be tried together by the same
Judge so as to avoid multiplicity in
trial of the same issues and conflict of
decisions.”

(Emphasis supplied)

6. So far as question of analogous hearing/common trial of
matrimonial proceeding, it would be appropriate to refer to
the judgment in Guda Vijayalakshmi v. Guda
,
Ramchandra Sekhara Sastry reported in (1981) 2 SCC
646 : AIR 1981 SC 1143, wherein it was held that
matrimonial proceedings may appropriately be brought
together so as to avoid conflicting decisions and observed, in
substance, that it will ordinarily be expedient to have a joint
or consolidated hearing/trial of closely connected
matrimonial proceedings, including a husband’s petition for
restitution of conjugal rights and the wife’s petition for
judicial separation. The said decision also confirms that
Section 21A of the Act, 1955 is not to be read as excluding
the broader procedural power of transfer/consolidation
where justice requires it.
3 7
WP(C) No.32254 of 2026 Page of

7. After hearing the learned Counsel for the parties,
going through the pleadings, documents available on record,
the impugned order dated 27.08.2026 passed in CP No.879
of 2023, so also the settled position of law, this Court is of
the view that there is no infirmity or illegality in the said
order.
8. At this stage, learned Counsel for the Petitioner-
husband submits, in C.P. No.180 of 2024, the Petitioner-
husband has already examined himself as P.W.1 and has
also been partly cross-examined by the Respondent-wife.
However, in C.P. No.879 of 2023, no evidence had been
adduced by either of the parties before the impugned order
was passed, directing for analogous hearing of both the
proceedings.
8.1. He further submits, since the Petitioner–husband
has already filed his affidavit-evidence in C.P. No.180 of
2024 confining the same to his pleadings in the plaint to
justify the prayer for divorce and has been cross-examined in
part, he will seriously prejudiced in the matter of adducing
rebuttal evidence to oppose the prayer made by the Opposite
4 7
WP(C) No.32254 of 2026 Page of

Party-wife for restitution of conjugal right in in C.P. No.879
of 2023 during common trial.
9. In the present case, the fact that the proceeding
in CP No.180 of 2024 has substantially advanced does not,
by itself, compel a completely separate trial of CP No.879 of
2023, which has been preferred under Section 9 of the
Act,1955 by the wife. Indeed, if the later petition raises
substantially the same factual controversy, a separate trial
may multiply evidence and prolong adjudication. That apart
it may nullify evidence already lawfully recorded in CP
No.180 of 2024. Requiring the parties to repeat the same
examination-in-chief and cross-examination in two files
would defeat the very purpose of analogous hearing.
Common evidence should ordinarily be recorded once, which
shall be read in both proceedings insofar as it relates to the
issues therein.
10. In the aforesaid circumstances, it is made clear that
the Family Court is not required to record separate evidence
on the same facts in both proceedings. The evidence should
be recorded once, with appropriate safeguards so that it is
expressly available for adjudication of both petitions.
5 7
WP(C) No.32254 of 2026 Page of

Because the proceeding in CP No.180 of 2024 has
substantially commenced, the Court should preserve the
evidence already recorded and supplement it only where the
later petition introduces genuinely new matters. This
approach would reconcile procedural fairness with
expedition, avoid duplication and conflicting findings, and is
supported by the judgment in Guda Vijayalakshmi (supra).
11. It is made further clear that, during
common/controlled trial, the existing evidence recorded in
CP No.180 of 2024 should be treated as evidence in the
earlier petition; the learned Judge, Family Court, Cuttack
shall permit the parties to adopt/read that evidence in the
later petition to the extent legally permissible and relevant,
subject always to the other party’s right to cross-examine on
matters newly introduced by the later petition, i.e., CP
No.879 of 2023, if so prayed for. If CP No.879 of 2023
contains genuinely new facts or a distinct issue requiring
proof, the Petitioner-husband be permitted to adduce
additional evidence, which should be confined to those facts.
12. Since both the proceedings, i.e., CP No.272 of 2023
(renumbered as CP No.180 of 2024) and CP No.879 of 2023,
6 7
WP(C) No.32254 of 2026 Page of

are of the years 2023 and it has been ordered for common
trial, this Court is hopeful that the learned Court below shall
do well to conclude both the said matrimonial proceedings at
the earliest, in accordance with law.
13. The parties are directed not to seek for unnecessary
adjournments and cooperate with the learned Judge, Family
Court, Cuttack for early disposal of the said proceedings.
14. Accordingly, the writ petition stands disposed of.
Urgent certified copy of this order be granted on
proper application as per rules.


..….………..……………
S.K. Mishra, J.








Orissa High Court, Cuttack .
th
Dated, 18 November, 2026/ Mona
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: MONALISA SWAIN
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC
Date: 20-Nov-2026 18:30:28
7 7
WP(C) No.32254 of 2026 Page of