PRASANTA BISWAS vs STATE BANK OF INDIA & ORS
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee
WPA 11856 of 2016
Prasanta Biswas
Vs.
State Bank of India & Ors.
For the petitioner : Mr. Sardar Amjad Ali, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Arun Kr. Das,
Mr. Samir Kr. Ghosh.
For the Bank : Mr. S K Sinha,
Ms. Sanchita Dey Pal Chaudhury,
Mr. S Pal Chaudhury,
Ms. S Adak,
Ms. Tithi Paul,
Ms. Baishali Saha.
Heard on : 28.09.2026
Judgment on : 20.11.2026
Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J.:-
Prologue:
1. By way of the present writ petition, the petitioner, a former Customer Assistant of
the respondent State Bank of India (hereinafter referred to as “the Bank”), has
2
called in question the enquiry report dated 19th August, 2015, the final order
dated 5th December, 2015, passed by the Disciplinary Authority (for short, “DA”),
whereby the petitioner was visited with the penalty of removal from service
without disqualification for future employment, and the order dated 17th March,
2016, passed by the Appellate Authority (for short, “AA”), affirming the said
penalty. The petitioner has, inter alia, prayed for issuance of a writ in the nature
of mandamus commanding the concerned respondents to reinstate him in
service, together with all consequential benefits, including full back wages and
wages for the period during which he remained under suspension.
Petitioner’s case:
2. Sans unnecessary details, the facts emerging from the averments in the writ
petition and the documents annexed thereto are that the petitioner was serving as
a Customer Assistant at the Bank’s Bally Durgapur Branch until 2013. On 2nd
September, 2013, while discharging his duties at the cash counter, a sum of
Rs.1,000/- was inadvertently debited twice from the account of one Manoj
Kumar Chauhan, a customer of the Bank. The petitioner claims that he verbally
brought the discrepancy to the notice of the Branch Manager, being the
respondent no. 7, and subsequently deposited Rs.1,000/- in cash into the
customer's account on 13th September, 2013. The customer, by a letter dated
14th January, 2014, acknowledged receipt of the said amount.
3. By a letter dated 16th September, 2013, the respondent no. 7 called upon the
petitioner to explain the incident of double debit, particularly his failure to report
the occurrence to any supervising official or credit the excess amount to the
3
Branch Sundry Deposit Account. Subsequently, by a reminder dated 6th
December, 2013, the respondent no. 7 alleged that the petitioner had failed to
respond to the earlier communications dated 5th September, 2013 and 16th
September, 2013, and had also convened a meeting on 5th December, 2013,
thereby disrupting the smooth functioning of the branch.
4. The petitioner, however, contends that he had verbally explained the factual
position to the respondent no. 7, pointing out that only the first debit transaction
had been effected under his user ID, whereas the second was carried out under
the user ID of the Presenting Officer. He further maintained that, upon coming to
know of the discrepancy, he ensured that the customer was compensated without
undue delay. In the meantime, by a memorandum dated 15th January, 2014, the
petitioner was transferred to the Chandanpur Branch.
5. Subsequently, by a communication dated 17th September, 2014, the respondent
no. 5 called upon the petitioner to explain several alleged irregularities said to
have occurred at the Bally Durgapur Branch between 2nd September, 2013 and
15th January, 2014. In his reply dated 27th September, 2014, the petitioner
contended that no financial loss had been occasioned to the Bank, that any
errors, if committed, had been rectified and that no customer had raised any
grievance. The petitioner alleges that, without duly considering his explanation,
the respondent no. 5, by an order dated 7th January, 2015, placed him under
suspension in terms of Paragraph 12(B) of the Memorandum of Settlement (for
short, MoS) .
4
6. Thereafter, by a charge-sheet dated 23rd April, 2015, the petitioner was informed
that he was prima facie found to have committed acts of major misconduct under
Clause 7(c) of the MoS and was called upon to submit his reply to the articles of
charge within seven days of receipt thereof.
7. The charge-sheet comprised six articles of charge, the substance whereof may be
briefly delineated as follows:
Charge No. 1 alleged that the petitioner had failed to furnish any
reply to the communication dated 16th September, 2013, calling
for his explanation, as well as the subsequent reminder dated
6th December, 2013.
Charge No. 2 pertained to the alleged double debit of Rs.1,000/-
against a single withdrawal slip, although cash to the extent of
only Rs.1,000/- had been disbursed to the customer. It was
alleged that the petitioner refunded the excess amount only
upon the customer raising a complaint on 13th September,
2013, without either crediting the same to the Sundry Deposit
Account or effecting the refund on the very same day.
Charge No. 3 related to an alleged unauthorised transaction
dated 14th September, 2013, whereby the petitioner debited a
sum of Rs.7,000/- from the account of his father, Shri Gobinda
Chandra Biswas, and credited the said amount to two other
accounts without obtaining debit confirmation or an authority
letter. It was, however, alleged that the transaction had also
been permitted by the Accountant, Shri Manas Kumar
Choudhuri, and that debit confirmation was subsequently
obtained from one of the joint account holders.
Charge No. 4 alleged that, on 26th September, 2013, the
petitioner had disbursed a sum of Rs.6,000/- against a
withdrawal slip drawn on the account of Smt. Suchitra Mondal
without verifying the signature appearing thereon with her
specimen signature recorded in the Bank's records.
5
Charge No. 5 concerned an alleged unauthorised debit of
Rs.60,000/- effected on 23rd April, 2013, from the account of a
customer, Shri Goutam Roy, and the subsequent credit of the
said amount to his father's account and two accounts
maintained by the petitioner himself, without obtaining the
requisite debit confirmation or authority letter.
Charge No. 6 alleged that, on 10th January, 2014, Smt. Geeta
Gupta had deposited a sum of Rs.6,000/- at the petitioner's
counter, which was neither credited to her account nor
transferred to the Sundry Deposit Account. It was further
alleged that, only after the customer lodged a complaint on 16th
January, 2014, the petitioner, with the assistance of his brother,
deposited a sum of Rs.6,750/- into her account.
8. The petitioner specifically contends that the charge-sheet did not contain any
distinct articles of charge, list of documents or list of witnesses, and that the
allegations levelled against him were vague. He further submits that Clause 7(c)
of the MoS treats neglect of work or negligence in the discharge of duties as
minor misconduct. According to the petitioner, therefore, although the charge-
sheet was framed in respect of minor misconduct, he was subjected to an enquiry
for major misconduct and ultimately penalised on that basis.
9. Prior to submitting his reply to the charge-sheet, the petitioner, by
communications dated 2nd May, 2015 and 14th May, 2015, requested the
respondent no. 7 to furnish certain documents which, according to him, were
necessary for submitting an effective reply to the charges levelled against him.
However, the said requests did not yield any response.
10. By his reply dated 15th May, 2015, the petitioner furnished his explanation in
respect of the charges levelled against him. With regard to Charge No. 2, he
6
stated that the customer had been compensated immediately upon the
discrepancy coming to his notice. As regards the meeting held on 5th December,
2013, he explained that the same was merely a condolence meeting convened in
memory of a deceased colleague after 5 p.m., upon completion of the cash-related
work of the branch.
11. In respect of Charge No. 3, the petitioner stated that the debit had been effected
against a duly executed voucher bearing his father's signature, which had
subsequently gone missing. He further explained that, on the following day, the
missing voucher was substituted by a debit confirmation voucher signed by his
mother, who was one of the joint account holders.
12. With regard to Charge No. 4, the petitioner explained that the account holder,
accompanied by her father, both of whom were known to him, had approached
the counter in haste on account of a medical exigency. He accordingly effected the
payment in good faith. He further stated that the account holder subsequently
acknowledged receipt of the amount and that the customer had also informed the
Bank that no mistake had been committed by any of its staff members.
13. In answer to Charge No. 5, the petitioner stated that the transaction had been
undertaken on the telephonic instructions of his elder brother, who had also
forwarded an authority letter. He explained that, owing to the ill health of his
parents, he had inadvertently omitted to annex the said letter. He further
asserted that his brother subsequently confirmed the instructions in writing.
7
14. As regards Charge No. 6, the petitioner explained that the deposit voucher had
been returned on account of an incorrect amount being mentioned therein,
although the Bank's stamp had inadvertently been affixed to the same. He further
stated that, acting upon the direction of the respondent no. 5, he deposited a sum
of Rs.6,750/- on 16th January, 2014, although the respondent no. 5 accepted the
depositor's claim of Rs.6,507/- on the following day.
15. Notwithstanding the explanation furnished by the petitioner, a departmental
enquiry was instituted by an order dated 28th May, 2015. Subsequently, by a
corrigendum dated 26th June, 2015, three out of the six charges were modified.
The petitioner contends that the list of documents and the list of witnesses were
furnished to him for the first time on 10th July, 2015, by which time the enquiry
had already commenced, thereby depriving him of a reasonable opportunity to
prepare his defence. He further submits that the arrangement made for
inspection of the documents at the Chandanpur Branch was of little assistance to
him, particularly when the alleged irregularities had occurred at the Bally
Durgapur Branch.
16. Having pleaded not guilty to the charges, the petitioner participated in the
departmental enquiry. On 25th July, 2015, the respondent no. 7, who was
examined as the Prosecution Witness (for short, “PW”), was examined in the
enquiry. According to the petitioner, none of the documents relied upon in
support of the charges was duly proved through the said witness in accordance
with law. He further contends that, during his cross-examination, the PW
admitted that no financial loss had been occasioned to the Bank. Thereafter, on
8
30th July, 2015, the petitioner appealed for a compassionate consideration of his
case, drawing attention to the illness of his father. Subsequently, on 17th August,
2015, his Defence Counsel submitted a written brief in support of his defence.
17. By his report dated 19th August, 2015, the Enquiry Officer (for short, “EO”) held
five of the six charges to have been proved, Charge No. 3 being the sole exception.
The petitioner alleges that, while dealing with Charge No. 1, the EO relied solely
upon the deposition of the prosecution witness (PW), without considering his
explanation; in respect of Charge No. 2, he disregarded documents favourable to
the petitioner and accepted the PW’s testimony without proper scrutiny; while
considering Charge No. 4, he glossed over the concerned customer’s statement
absolving the Bank’s staff of any wrongdoing; and, in relation to Charge No. 5,
rejected the defence document merely because it had been obtained
subsequently.
18. The petitioner further assails the enquiry report as self-contradictory and
substantially a reproduction of the written brief submitted by the Presenting
Officer, allegedly reflecting a predetermined approach in favour of the
prosecution witness (PW). He contends that the EO failed to consider the PW’s
admission that his work was prompt and satisfactory and that he had acted in
accordance with the Bank’s instructions, while placing undue reliance on the
PW’s observation that recurring errors could not be treated as compensatory. The
petitioner thereafter submitted his representation against the enquiry report on
23rd September, 2015.
9
19. By a notice dated 11th November, 2015, the respondent no. 4 called upon the
petitioner to show cause why the penalty of removal from service without
disqualification for future employment, as contemplated under Clause 6(b) of the
MoS, should not be imposed, with the period of suspension being treated as ‘Not
on Duty’. The petitioner replied to the said notice on 17th November, 2015,
whereupon the respondent no. 4, by a final order dated 5th December, 2015,
imposed the penalty of removal from service. The petitioner assails the order as
laconic and devoid of cogent reasons, contending that the DA failed to disclose
the basis for accepting the findings of the EO. He further points out that the order
proceeds on the premise that the alleged irregularities had caused financial loss
and tarnished the Bank’s image, although no charge of financial loss had been
framed against him and, according to him, even the PW’s deposition did not
support such a finding. The petitioner also questions the change in the
disciplinary authority, contending that although the proceeding was initiated by
the respondent no. 5, it was ultimately concluded by the respondent no. 4 owing
to a purported bifurcation of administrative responsibilities, thereby disrupting
the continuity of the decision-making process and reflecting non-application of
mind.
20. The appeal preferred by the petitioner on 18th January, 2016, came to be
dismissed by the respondent no. 3 by an order dated 17th March, 2016, inter alia,
holding that the petitioner had failed to put forth anything that could extenuate
the charges levelled against him and that the punishment imposed was
commensurate with the gravity of the charges. The petitioner assails the appellate
10
order on the ground that the same merely reproduces the charges levelled against
him and the defence advanced in response thereto, without disclosing any
reasons in support of the conclusions arrived at by the Appellate Authority.
21. The petitioner further contends that the report of the EO, the order of the
Disciplinary Authority and the appellate order are perverse, being based on
inadmissible and irrelevant materials while disregarding relevant evidence, and
are otherwise founded on conjectures and surmises. He submits that the Bank
suffered no financial loss and no customer attributed any such loss to him. It is
also contended that the aforesaid orders are non-speaking and that the breach of
natural justice at the disciplinary stage could not have been cured by the
Appellate Authority. According to the petitioner, the charges relate, at best, to
procedural irregularities and do not warrant the extreme penalty of removal from
service, which is grossly disproportionate. He lastly alleges that the authorities
acted vindictively towards him throughout the disciplinary proceedings.
Respondents’ case:
22. In the affidavit-in-opposition filed on behalf of the respondents, it is contended
that, while posted as a Customer Assistant at the Bally Durgapur Branch, the
petitioner had indulged in serious irregularities, resorted to fraudulent practices,
wilfully disregarded the instructions issued by his superiors and misappropriated
depositors’ money for his personal gain. It is further contended that, in the course
of the investigation as well as the disciplinary proceedings, the petitioner had
admitted to having committed such acts.
11
23. It is stated therein that the petitioner had deliberately refrained from furnishing
any reply to the letters calling upon him to explain his conduct. It is further
alleged that the second debit entry in the customer’s account, which forms the
subject matter of Charge No. 2, was effected by the petitioner and that the
amount so withdrawn was misappropriated for his personal gain and refunded
only after the customer had lodged a complaint.
24. In respect of Charge No. 4, it is contended that the petitioner had effected
payment without verifying the signature of the account holder with the specimen
signature available in the Core Banking System and that any subsequent
signature could not have the effect of validating or regularising the payment
already made.
25. As regards Charge No. 5, it is alleged that the petitioner had prepared all the
vouchers without obtaining the signature of the account holder and that neither a
telephonic instruction nor a subsequent letter of confirmation could validate the
transfers so effected.In respect of Charge No. 6, it is contended that the amount
was credited to the customer’s account only after the customer had lodged a
complaint with the Bank.
26. It is the specific case of the respondents that the petitioner had admitted to the
charges levelled against him in his replies to the show-cause notices, the charge-
sheet and the enquiry report, as well as in his written brief and memorandum of
appeal. It is further contended that, in any event, the charges stood
independently established on the basis of the documentary and oral evidence
12
adduced during the course of the enquiry. The respondents, however, fairly
acknowledge that Charge No. 3 could not be established in the enquiry
proceedings.
27. The respondents contend that the reference to Clause 7(c) of the MoS was an
inadvertent incorporation in place of Clause 5(j), as the charge-sheet had
unequivocally characterised the alleged acts as constituting ‘major misconduct’. It
is further submitted that the entire disciplinary proceeding, including the second
show-cause notice and the orders passed by the Disciplinary Authority and the
Appellate Authority, proceeded on that basis. The respondents also contend that
the petitioner never questioned such classification during the disciplinary
proceeding and cannot, therefore, raise the issue for the first time in the present
writ petition.
28. As regards the conduct of the enquiry, the respondents contend that the
petitioner was duly furnished with the list of documents and witnesses, along
with certified copies of the prosecution documents, and was afforded inspection
thereof on 14th May, 2015 and 14th July, 2015. It is further submitted that the
petitioner pleaded not guilty, all prosecution documents were duly produced,
proved and admitted, and the inadvertent addressing of a letter to his last posted
branch occasioned no prejudice. The respondents further contend that,
irrespective of any actual financial loss to the Bank, the acts complained of
tarnished its public image and reputation, and that the petitioner arranged for
refund of the amounts only after the irregularities were detected.
13
29. The respondents contend that the petitioner was duly furnished with the list of
documents and witnesses, along with certified copies of the prosecution
documents, and was afforded inspection thereof on 14th May, 2015 and 14th July,
2015. It is further submitted that the petitioner pleaded not guilty, all prosecution
documents were duly produced, proved and admitted, and the inadvertent
addressing of a letter to his last posted branch occasioned no prejudice. The
respondents further contend that, irrespective of any actual financial loss, the
acts complained of tarnished the Bank's public image and reputation, and that
the petitioner arranged for refund of the amounts only after the irregularities
came to light.
30. The respondents contend that the Enquiry Officer duly considered the
petitioner's explanation and the materials on record, and that the enquiry report
is neither self-contradictory nor a mere reproduction of the Presenting Officer's
written brief. It is further submitted that the subsequent letter issued by the
customer absolving the Bank's staff of liability could not exonerate the petitioner
of the misconduct established. The respondents also assert that the Disciplinary
Authority duly applied its mind to the charge-sheet, the petitioner's replies, the
enquiry report and his response thereto, and afforded him an opportunity of
hearing before passing a reasoned and speaking order, which was not required to
reiterate the findings of the Enquiry Officer.
31. The respondents further contend that the change in the incumbent holding the
office of the Disciplinary Authority neither disrupted the continuity of the
proceedings nor occasioned any prejudice to the petitioner, as the entire record
14
was available to the successor incumbent. It is lastly submitted that proof of
actual financial loss to the Bank was not necessary to establish the misconduct
and that the punishment imposed was commensurate with the gravity of the
charges proved.
Contents of the affidavit-in-reply filed by the petitioner:
32. In the affidavit-in-reply, the petitioner contends that the respondents have failed
to specifically traverse several material allegations in the writ petition,
particularly those relating to the inordinate delay in issuing the charge-sheet on
stale charges, absence of properly framed articles of charge and requisite lists of
documents and witnesses, and non-compliance with Clauses 1 and 12(c) of the
MoS. It is further submitted that the respondents have failed to demonstrate that
the orders passed by the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority are
reasoned and speaking orders. The petitioner also relies upon the affidavit-in-
opposition to contend that no financial loss was occasioned to the Bank.
33. The petitioner denies having admitted to any of the charges and contends that the
Bank has failed to identify any specific admission or demonstrate how the
charges stood established. As regards the alleged inadvertent error in referring to
Clause 7(c) instead of Clause 5(j), it is submitted that the error was never rectified
and Clause 5(j) was never invoked during the disciplinary proceedings. The
petitioner further contends that, despite the charges having been framed as
constituting minor misconduct, he was proceeded against under the provisions
governing major misconduct, in violation of his fundamental right to be dealt
with strictly in accordance with the charges levelled against him and the
15
guarantees under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. It is lastly submitted that
such a fundamental right cannot be treated as having been waived.
Submissions:
34. Mr. Ali, learned Senior Advocate, advanced arguments on behalf of the
petitioner. As crystallised, his principal contention is that the charge-sheet issued
in the instant case specifically indicated that disciplinary proceedings were
contemplated against the petitioner for alleged violation of Clause 7(c) of the
MoS, which, according to him, prescribes a minor penalty for such misconduct.
Clause 7(c) of the MoS treats neglect of work or negligence in the discharge of
duties as minor misconduct. It is, therefore, contended that although the charge-
sheet proceeded on the basis of an allegation constituting minor misconduct, the
entire disciplinary proceeding was conducted with a view to imposing a major
penalty, and the petitioner was ultimately visited with such major penalty.
According to Mr. Ali, such a course of action was impermissible and rendered the
disciplinary action vulnerable to interference.
35. He further contended that the charge-sheet was not accompanied by a list of
documents or a list of witnesses. According to him, the omission was not a mere
procedural irregularity but a fundamental infirmity which vitiated the
disciplinary proceeding from its inception. He also submitted that, despite a
specific written request made by the petitioner for furnishing certain relevant
documents, the disciplinary authority failed to accede to such request, thereby
16
depriving the petitioner of a reasonable and effective opportunity to defend
himself. It was further argued that both the EO and the DA acted mechanically,
without due application of mind, and failed to examine whether the alleged
misconduct had occasioned any financial loss to the Bank. He asserted that
punishment is also disproportionate.
36. On the factual aspect, Mr. Ali submitted that immediately upon detection of the
doubtful debit, the petitioner deposited the amount in question and thereby
made good the alleged deficiency. He further contended that the petitioner had
furnished satisfactory explanations and justifications in respect of the alleged
anomalies in certain transactions as well as the charges levelled against him, but
the same were not duly considered by the authorities concerned. According to
him, the defence taken by the petitioner, both during the disciplinary proceeding
and in the pleadings before this Court, was glossed over, and the findings
recorded by the Enquiry Officer and accepted by the Disciplinary Authority were,
therefore, vitiated by non-application of mind. He further submitted that the
answering respondents, in their affidavit-in-opposition, had resorted to mere
evasive denials without specifically controverting the material averments made
by the petitioner in the writ petition.
37. In rebuttal, Mr. Sinha, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the Bank,
advanced oral submissions and also tendered written notes of arguments. He
contended that, while posted at the Bally Durgapur Branch during the year 2013-
14, the petitioner had committed serious irregularities which constituted major
misconduct. He further submitted that, in his reply addressed to the Regional
17
Manager, the petitioner had admitted substantially all the irregularities
attributed to him and had either refunded or made arrangements for refund of
the amounts misappropriated by him. According to Mr. Sinha, such subsequent
restitution of the misappropriated amounts did not absolve the petitioner of the
misconduct committed by him.
38. Mr. Sinha contended that paragraph 2 of the charge-sheet specifically referred to
the allegations as constituting ‘Major Misconduct’ under the MoS. According to
him, the reference to Clause 7(c) of the MoS, instead of the applicable Clause 5(j),
was an inadvertent error. He asserted that all the six acts of misconduct
enumerated in the charge-sheet constituted major misconduct and that the
disciplinary enquiry was conducted throughout in accordance with the procedure
prescribed for dealing with major misconduct under the MoS, and not minor
misconduct. He further submitted that the petitioner had never raised any
objection in this regard at any stage of the disciplinary proceeding and had
sought to raise the issue for the first time in the present writ petition.Mr. Sinha
relied upon the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in P.K. Palanisami v. N.
Arumugham & Anr. , reported in (2009) 9 SCC 173, and Union of India v. S.C.
Parashar , reported in (2006) 3 SCC 167 and contended that a mere reference to
an incorrect provision of law would not, by itself, vitiate the entire proceeding.
39. Placing reliance upon the decisions, reported in (1995) 6 SCC 749 (B.C.
Chaturvedi vs. Union of India & Ors.) and (2015) 2 SCC 610 (Union of India vs. P.
Gunasekaran), Mr. Sinha submitted that the scope of judicial review in
disciplinary matters is confined to examining the decision-making process and
18
does not extend to the decision itself. He argued that a writ court cannot
reappreciate the evidence adduced during the enquiry or sit in appeal over the
findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer and accepted by the Disciplinary
Authority.
40. He contended that, in the present case, there was no defect in the decision-
making process. According to him, before commencement of the enquiry, the
petitioner was supplied with the lists of documents and witnesses and was
afforded, along with his Defence Representative, an opportunity to inspect the
relevant documents. The petitioner submitted his reply to the charge-sheet,
participated in the enquiry, cross-examined the prosecution witnesses and
thereafter submitted his response to the enquiry report. He was also given an
opportunity of hearing before imposition of the proposed penalty. Aggrieved by
the order of punishment, the petitioner preferred a statutory appeal, which was
duly considered and disposed of by a reasoned order. Mr. Sinha, therefore,
submitted that the petitioner was afforded adequate opportunity at every stage of
the disciplinary proceedings and that no procedural irregularity or breach of the
principles of natural justice could be attributed to the authorities concerned.
41. He contended that the petitioner had failed to demonstrate that any alleged
deficiency in the decision-making process had caused him prejudice or deprived
him of an effective opportunity to defend himself.He argued that mere allegation
that there was or were irregularity in decision-making process would not be
suffice, delinquent employee is to demonstrate that he has been prejudiced
thereby. To lend support to such contention, he relied upon the decisions,
19
reported in (1996) 3 SCC 364 ( State Bank of Patiala & Ors. vs. S.K. Sharma),
(2011) 2 SCC 316 (State Bank of India & Ors. vs. Bidyut Kumar Mitra & Ors.) and
one unreported decision by a coordinate Bench of this Court in WP 33329 (W) of
2014 (Shiv Pujan Gwalia vs. State Bank of India & Ors.).
42. He cited a decision, reported in (2005) 7 SCC 597 (National Fertilizers Ltd. and
Anr. vs. P.K. Khanna)and 2012 (2) CHN (Cal) 541 (Golam Jilani vs. State Bank of
India) and submitted that the disciplinary authority need not to assign reason
while concurring with the enquiry report and the DA is to record reason when he
opts to disagree with the findings of the enquiry officer. He argued that a defence
that bank has not suffered any financial loss is not available to a bank employee
in a disciplinary proceeding initiated against him and in support of such
contention, he relied upon the decisions, reported in (2005) 7 SCC 435 ( State
Bank of India &Anr. vs. Bela Bagchi & Ors.) & (2006) 2 SCC 255 (TNCS Corpn.
Ltd & Ors. Vs. K. Meerabai.).
Analysis and Conclusion:
43. Therefore, having heard the learned Advocates appearing for the respective
parties and upon perusal of the materials on record, the principal issues which
fall for consideration are whether the disciplinary proceeding stood vitiated on
account of the alleged procedural irregularities, whether the findings returned by
the Enquiry Officer suffer from any perversity or lack of evidence, and whether
the penalty imposed upon the petitioner warrants interference in exercise of the
writ jurisdiction of this Court.
20
44. There cannot be any quarrel in accepting the proposition that the scope of
judicial review in disciplinary matters is ordinarily confined to examining the
decision-making process and does not extend to the merits of the decision itself.
However, where the decision is found to be perverse, irrational or grossly
disproportionate, the same would fall within the permissible ambit of judicial
review. Although a writ court cannot sit in appeal over the decision of the
Disciplinary Authority or undertake a reappraisal of the evidence adduced during
the enquiry, it is nevertheless entitled to examine the materials on record to
ascertain whether the finding recorded is based on no evidence or is otherwise
perverse. The requirement of fair play, however, permeates all administrative,
judicial and quasi-judicial functions, including disciplinary proceedings. An
authority exercising quasi-judicial powers is required to act fairly, impartially and
without any preconceived notion or bias. Where the Court finds that the authority
has acted arbitrarily, with a closed mind, or in disregard of the principles of
natural justice or the applicable statutory rules, interference in exercise of the
power of judicial review would be warranted. The aforesaid principles have been
reiterated in the decisions of B.C. Chaturvedi (supra) and P.Gunasekaran
(Supra).
45. Bearing the aforesaid principles in mind, it is necessary to examine whether there
is any flaw in decision-making process and also to address the issues raised by
the petitioner.
46. In the present case, the petitioner has also raised the issue of delay in initiation of
the disciplinary proceeding. Such delay, by itself, does not render the proceeding
21
unsustainable. The question is whether, having regard to the facts and
circumstances of the case, the delay was unreasonable and occasioned any
prejudice to the petitioner in defending himself. In the present case, the incident
of double debit occurred on 2nd September, 2013, in respect whereof the
petitioner was called upon to furnish his explanation on 5th September, 2013 and
again on 16th September, 2013. He was thereafter asked, on 17th September,
2014, to explain certain anomalies in transactions covering the period from 2nd
September, 2013 to 15th January, 2014. The petitioner was placed under
suspension on 7th January, 2015, and the charge-sheet followed on 23rd April,
2015. Having regard to the sequence of events, it cannot be said that the Bank
proceeded against the petitioner on the basis of stale charges. Moreover, the
petitioner has not been able to demonstrate how the interval between the alleged
misconduct and issuance of the charge-sheet prejudiced his defence, particularly
when the allegations relate to identifiable banking transactions and the relevant
records were available for examination.
47. The petitioner has laid considerable emphasis on the reference to Clause 7(c) of
the MoS in the charge-sheet, contending that the said clause deals with minor
misconduct and that the Bank could not have proceeded against him for major
misconduct by subsequently invoking Clause 5(j). The Bank, on the other hand,
maintains that the reference to Clause 7(c) was an inadvertent error and that the
allegations set out in the charge-sheet were intended to constitute major
misconduct within the meaning of Clause 5(j) of the MoS. It is further contended
that the petitioner never raised any objection in this regard during the
22
disciplinary proceedings and has taken this point for the first time in the present
writ petition. Relying upon the decisions cited earlier, the Bank submits that a
mere reference to an incorrect provision would not, by itself, vitiate the
disciplinary proceedings, particularly when the enquiry was conducted
throughout in accordance with the procedure prescribed for major misconduct.
48. This issue cannot be decided merely by looking at the clause number referred to
in the charge-sheet. What is material is the substance of the allegations, the
nature of the misconduct attributed to the petitioner and whether he was made
sufficiently aware of the charges he was required to meet. In the present case, the
charge-sheet expressly described the alleged acts as major misconduct and set
out the individual transactions, their respective dates, the amounts involved and
the manner in which the petitioner was alleged to have acted. The petitioner also
furnished detailed explanations to the charges and participated in the enquiry.
On a reading of the charge-sheet as a whole, it is evident that the petitioner was
made aware of the allegations constituting major misconduct and was afforded
an opportunity to defend himself. The enquiry was also conducted in accordance
with the procedure prescribed for major misconduct. In such circumstances, the
mere erroneous reference to Clause 7(c), instead of Clause 5(j) of the MoS, would
not, by itself, vitiate the disciplinary proceeding, particularly when the petitioner
has failed to demonstrate that such error occasioned any real prejudice to his
defence.
49. The grievance relating to non-furnishing of documents also requires
consideration in the context of the opportunity actually afforded to the petitioner.
23
The respondents maintain that the petitioner was supplied with the list of
documents and witnesses, together with certified copies of the documents relied
upon by the prosecution, and was afforded inspection of the relevant records on
two occasions. The petitioner has not demonstrated with sufficient particularity
which particular document, essential for establishing his defence, was withheld
from him or how its non-furnishing materially impaired his defence. A mere
assertion that certain documents were not supplied, without establishing the
relevance thereof and the prejudice occasioned by such omission, would not be
sufficient to invalidate an otherwise properly conducted enquiry.
50. The petitioner's objection to the change in the incumbent Disciplinary Authority
also does not merit acceptance in the absence of any material demonstrating that
the successor authority failed to consider the records of the disciplinary
proceeding or that such change occasioned any prejudice to the petitioner.
51. As noticed earlier, the petitioner has also assailed the orders passed by the DA
and the AA as cryptic and non-speaking. It is not necessary for the Disciplinary
Authority to reproduce the entire enquiry report while imposing the penalty.
What is required is that the order should reflect due application of mind to the
findings of the Enquiry Officer and the representation submitted by the
delinquent employee. The same principle applies to the appellate order, which
must indicate consideration of the grounds urged in the appeal. Upon perusal of
both the order of punishment and the appellate order, I find no sufficient ground
to accept the petitioner's contention that the authorities failed to apply their mind
or passed non-speaking orders.
24
52. In the present case, it is also significant that the Enquiry Officer found five out of
the six charges to have been established. Charge No. 3, which could not be
established, has not been treated as proved. Such an approach, in my view, does
not indicate that the Enquiry Officer proceeded mechanically to accept every
allegation levelled against the petitioner. Rather, the fact that one of the charges
was held not established demonstrates that the allegations were considered
separately on the basis of the materials available in the enquiry. The petitioner
has not been able to demonstrate that the findings returned in respect of the
remaining charges are wholly unsupported by evidence or are such that no
reasonable person could have arrived at the same.
53. In the present case, it is necessary to bear in mind the nature of the allegations
levelled against the petitioner. A perusal of the six charges would reveal that they
do not relate to any isolated act of inadvertence or an occasional lapse in the
discharge of official duties. Taken cumulatively, the charges concern repeated
instances of unauthorised handling of customers’ accounts, effecting debit entries
without requisite authority, disbursing money without proper verification of the
account holder’s signature and failure to credit a customer’s deposit until a
complaint was lodged with the Bank. If established, such acts strike at the very
foundation of the trust and confidence reposed in a bank employee entrusted
with the handling of customers’ money. There is, therefore, a clear distinction
between an isolated procedural lapse and repeated irregularities involving the
handling of customers’ funds, which cannot be glossed over as mere negligence.
25
54. The contention that subsequent refund of the amounts and the letters issued by
the concerned customers absolve the petitioner of the alleged misconduct is
equally unpersuasive. A bank employee is expected to adhere to the prescribed
procedures at the time of undertaking financial transactions, and subsequent
conduct of the customers cannot dilute that obligation. What is material is
whether the petitioner had acted in accordance with the established norms when
the transactions were effected. Subsequent refund or regularisation of an
irregular transaction may make good the financial loss, but it does not, by itself,
erase the misconduct already committed.
55. The petitioner's repeated reliance on the absence of financial loss to the Bank is
misplaced. The obligation of a bank employee to maintain integrity and adhere to
prescribed norms does not depend upon whether the Bank has ultimately
suffered any monetary loss. The safeguards governing the operation of customers’
accounts are intended to protect not only the Bank's interests but also the money
entrusted to it by its customers. A subsequent refund or adjustment cannot
retrospectively legitimise an unauthorised transaction. The real test is whether
the petitioner discharged his duties with the degree of integrity, care and
diligence expected of an employee entrusted with the handling of customers’
money.
56. Coming to the question of proportionality, the nature and gravity of the
misconduct established against the petitioner cannot be lost sight of. The penalty
imposed must bear a reasonable relationship to the gravity of the misconduct
proved. In the present case, the charges are not confined to an isolated instance
26
of negligence or inadvertence but relate to several transactions involving
customers’ accounts and their money, in which the petitioner failed to observe
the prescribed safeguards. The cumulative effect of such acts assumes
significance in assessing the gravity of the misconduct. Having regard to the
nature and extent of the irregularities established, the penalty of removal from
service cannot be said to be shockingly disproportionate merely because the
amounts were subsequently refunded or the Bank ultimately suffered no financial
loss.
57. In view of the discussions made hereinabove and having regard to the principles
laid down in the decisions referred to in the foregoing paragraphs, I find no
sufficient ground to hold that the disciplinary proceeding, the enquiry report or
the orders passed by the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority
warrant interference in exercise of the extraordinary writ jurisdiction of this
Court.
58. For the reasons aforesaid, this Court is not inclined to accept the challenge
thrown by the petitioner to the disciplinary proceeding or the penalty imposed
upon him. The writ petition, being devoid of merit, accordingly stands dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
(Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J.)
27