Raj Kumari Malhi vs Gurmukh Singh And Another

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court


1
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH

105 (2 cases)
Date of decision :- 16.11.2026

(1)
CR-8056-2018

Gurmukh Singh .... Petitioner

Versus

Swaran Ram (since deceased) through legal heir Gurmej Kaur, since
deceased through her legal heirs and another

.... Respondents

(2)
CR-9061-2025

Raj Kumari Malhi through her Attorney Nirmal Singh Chamdal

…. Petitioner

Versus

Gurmukh Singh and another …. Respondents

CORAM : HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE AMARJOT BHATTI

Present: Mr. Ankur Bansal and Mr. Lovish Arora, Advocates
for the petitioner in CR-8056-2018 and
for respondents in CR-9061-2025.

Mr. Aditya Dassaur, Advocate
for the petitioner in CR-9061-2025
and for respondents in CR-8056-2018.


AMARJOT BHATTI J.
1. Petitioner/plaintiff Gurmukh Singh filed civil revision no. 8056 of
2018 against impugned order dated 29.09.2018 (Annexure P-1) passed by
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


2
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), NRI Court, Jalandhar in case CIS No.
CM/676/2016, instituted on 30.09.2016 titled “Gurmukh Singh versus Swaran
Ram and another”, whereby application filed by applicants/defendants under
Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC for setting aside exparte judgment
and decree dated 09.09.2016 as well as exparte order dated 17.11.2015 was
partly allowed qua applicant/defendant No. 1 Swaran Ram, now represented
through his legal heir and same is unsustainable in the eyes of law and order to
this extent is liable to be set aside.
1.1 Petitioner Raj Kumari Malhi through her Attorney Nirmal Singh
filed civil revision no. 9061 of 2025 against impugned order dated 29.09.2018
(Annexure P-4), whereby application filed under Order 9 rule 13 read with
Section 151 CPC filed by present petitioner against exparte judgment and
decree dated 09.09.2016 (Annexure P-2) was wrongly dismissed by learned
Civil Judge (Senior Division), Jalandhar and civil miscellaneous appeal
preferred against this judgment and decree was also wrongly declined vide
impugned order dated 09.09.2025 (Annexure P-6) passed by learned
Additional District Judge, Jalandhar.
2. Since, both aforementioned civil revisions are pertaining to same
matter in controversy, therefore, these are taken up together for disposal.
Further, for the purpose of annexures relied upon by the parties, same will be
referred as mentioned in lead case i.e. CR-8056-2018.
3. Learned counsel representing petitioner/plaintiff Gurmukh Singh
in CR-8056-2018 argued that petitioner/plaintiff Gurmukh Singh has filed suit
for specific performance of agreement to sell dated 26.12.2013 with regards to
plot no. 555 measuring 19 marlas 137 sq. feet situated in Mota Singh Nagar,
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


3
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


District Jalandhar against Swaran Ram and Raj Kumari Malhi bearing civil
suit CIS no. 2311 of 2015 instituted on 14.10.2015. Copy of plaint is Annexure
P-2. In the said civil suit, defendants were duly served through registered post
and were proceeded against exparte vide order dated 17.11.2015. Thereafter,
exparte evidence was recorded and suit filed by petitioner/plaintiff Gurmukh
Singh was decreed exparte vide judgment and decree dated 09.09.2016
(Annexure P-3). On the basis of this judgment and decree, execution was filed
by petitioner/plaintiff (Annexure P-4). During the pendency of execution, both
defendants namely Swaran Ram through his legal heir Gurmej Kaur and Raj
Kumari Malhi filed application under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151
CPC for setting aside exparte judgment and decree dated 09.09.2016
(Annexure P-5). Said application was contested by petitioner/plaintiff by filing
reply (Annexure P-6). Application was finally disposed of by learned Civil
Judge (Senior Division), NRI Court, Jalandhar by passing impugned order
dated 29.09.2018 (Annexure P-1), vide which application was partly allowed.
The application filed under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC for
setting aside exparte judgment and decree qua Swaran Ram now represented
through legal heir Gurmej Kaur was allowed and application filed by Raj
Kumari Malhi was declined. In support of his arguments, learned counsel for
petitioner/plaintiff Gurmukh Singh has referred to the judgment of Supreme
Court of India in Civil Appeal No. 6489 of 2002 (Arising out of S.L.P.(C)
No. 2524 of 2001), D/d 3.10.2002 , case titled “ Basant Singh and another
Versus Roman Catholic Mission ” cited in 2002(4) RCR(Civil) 572 , where in
para no. 8 it was observed as under :-
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


4
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


“8. Second proviso to Order 9 Rule 13 casts an emobago on the court
that a decree passed ex-parte shall not be set aside merely on the
ground that there has been an regularity in the service of summons.
Order 5, proviso to sub-rule (2) of Rule 19A of C.P.C. provides that
where the summons are properly addressed, prepaid and duly sent by
registered post with acknowledgement due, notwithstanding the fact
that the acknowledgement having been lost or mislaid, or for any other
reason, has not been received by the Court within thirty days from the
date of the issue of the summons, the Court shall presume that notice is
duly served. Further, Section 27 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 (in
short 'Act') provides similar provision. The presumptions are
rebuttable. It is always open to the defendants to rebut the presumption
by leading convincing and cogent evidence.”

4. It is argued that in fact both defendants were duly served in
aforesaid civil suit and they did not appear before the trial Court to contest the
case and were rightly proceeded exparte. There was no sufficient evidence led
by applicants/defendants to establish that they were wrongly proceeded
against exparte. To support the contention in application, only Nirmal Singh,
Attorney holder of both applicants/defendants was examined as AW1,
whereas, Raj Kumari Malhi, applicant/defendant No.2 was given up.
Applicants/defendants did not give any specific date when they came to know
about passing of exparte judgment and decree dated 09.09.2016. It was merely
mentioned that Gurmej Kaur had come to know about exparte judgment and
decree dated 09.09.2016 when she had visited India in September, 2016. It has
come in cross-examination of Nirmal Singh AW1 that Gurmej Kaur again left
India on 29.09.2016. The Power of Attorney produced by Nirmal Singh is of
30.09.2016. In case Gurmej Kaur had left India on 29.09.2016, there was no
occasion for her to execute Power of Attorney in favour of Nirmal Singh on
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


5
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


30.09.2016. This fact has been totally ignored by learned trial Court while
disposing of application under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC. It
is further pointed out that Nirmal Singh is only Power of Attorney holder, thus,
he had no personal knowledge about the service of defendants who were
residing abroad. Therefore, testimony of Nirmal Singh, Power of Attorney
holder as AW1 cannot be safely relied upon. It is pointed out that both
defendants were duly served through registered post. While filing application
under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC, they have to establish that
they were not residing at the given address. Therefore, it was rightly presumed
that they were served and accordingly, proceeded against exparte vide order
dated 17.11.2015. There was no valid reason to set aside the exparte judgment
and decree dated 09.09.2016 qua Swaran Ram, now represented through legal
heir Gurmej Kaur. Learned counsel representing petitioner/plaintiff Gurmukh
Singh further informed the Court that during execution proceedings pertaining
to judgment and decree dated 09.09.2016 (Annexure P-3), sale deed is already
executed in favour of petitioner/plaintiff Gurmukh Singh. Therefore,
impugned order dated 29.09.2018 passed by learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), NRI Court, Jalandhar (Annexure P-1) requires modification to the
extent that application filed under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC
qua Swaran Ram, now represented through Gurmej Kaur may also be declined
by accepting present civil revision.
5. So far as Raj Kumari Malhi, petitioner in CR-9061-2025 is
concerned, she never stepped into the witness box during the pendency of
application under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC. There is no
evidence led on her behalf that she did not receive registered letter or she was
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


6
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


residing on other address. Therefore, application filed on her behalf for setting
aside exparte judgment and decree was rightly dismissed. The civil revision
preferred by her is without merits.
6. On the other hand, learned counsel representing petitioner Raj
Kumari Malhi through her Attorney Nirmal Singh Chamdal in CR-9061-2025
argued that admittedly at the time of filing of suit seeking specific
performance of agreement to sell dated 26.12.2013, present
petitioner/defendant No. 2 was residing in United Kingdom. The address
which is mentioned in plaint was of her in-laws family, whereas, she was
residing on the different address as detailed in para no. 4 of application filed
under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC. She never received the
summons in aforesaid civil suit. There is nothing on record that registered
letter was received and acknowledgment was received by the Court regarding
service. In fact, on the lapse of 30 days, learned trial Court presumed that
petitioner/defendant No. 2 was duly served and was proceeded against exparte.
No process was ever received by learned trial Court regarding the service of
petitioner/defendant No. 2. Learned trial Court did not make any effort to
procure the service of defendants by way of substitute service. Without
following proper procedure, both defendants were hurriedly proceeded against
exparte on 17.11.2015. It was Gurmej Kaur who had visited India in
September, 2016 and had come to know about passing of exparte judgment
and decree dated 09.09.2016 and immediately, an Advocate was engaged and
application under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC was filed on
29.09.2016. There was no lapse or delay on the part of petitioner/defendant
No. 2. Without appreciating the aforesaid factual position, application filed by
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


7
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


her was wrongly rejected by passing impugned order dated 29.09.2018 and
civil miscellaneous appeal preferred by her was also wrongly declined vide
impugned order dated 09.09.2025. It is submitted that aforesaid orders may
kindly be set aside by accepting present civil revision and petitioner/defendant
No. 2 may be given an opportunity to contest the suit by setting aside exparte
judgment and decree dated 09.09.2016.
7. I have considered the arguments and documents on record.
Gurmukh Singh filed suit for specific performance of agreement to sell dated
26.12.2013 regarding plot no. 555 measuring 19 marlas 137 sq. feet situated in
Mota Singh Nagar, District Jalandhar for total sale consideration of
Rs.1,20,90,000/- and it was further stated that defendant No. 1 Swaran Ram
being General Power of Attorney of Raj Kumari Malhi – defendant No. 2 had
already received full and final sale consideration as referred above along with
suit for permanent injunction and in alternate suit for recovery of aforesaid
amount along with interest as detailed therein. Copy of plaint is Annexure P-2.
Perusal of trial Court record shows that suit was received by learned Civil
Judge (Senior Division), NRI Court, Jalandhar on 14.10.2015. Notice
regarding suit as well as stay was issued to defendants for 28.10.2015, that is
with a gap of two weeks when both defendants were shown to be resident of
England. On 28.10.2015, summons issued to defendants No. 1 and 2 through
registered covered were not received back. Even statutory period of 30 days
did not lapse and again it was adjourned for 17.11.2015. On this date, 30 days
lapsed. No process was received back served or unserved and thereafter, both
defendants were proceeded against exparte. The exparte evidence was
recorded and suit was finally decreed vide judgment and decree dated
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


8
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


09.09.2016 (Annexure P-3). Within 21 days, defendants filed application
under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC dated 29.09.2016
(Annexure P-5) which was finally disposed of vide impugned order dated
29.09.2018 (Annexure P-1). The exparte judgment and decree qua Swaran
Ram now represented through his legal heir Gurmej Kaur was set aside,
whereas, application qua Raj Kumari Malhi was rejected. Civil miscellaneous
appeal preferred by petitioner/defendant No. 2 Raj Kumari Malhi was also
declined by learned Additional District Judge, Jalandhar vide order dated
09.09.2025. Plaintiff Gurmukh Singh filed civil revision no. 8056 of 2018
against impugned order for setting aside exparte judgment and decree qua
Swaran Ram now represented through Gurmej Kaur, whereas, Raj Kumari
Malhi filed civil revision no. 9061 of 2025 for declining her application as
well as civil misc. appeal, as referred above.
8. The contents of plaint (Annexure P-2) further indicate that suit
property regarding which specific performance of agreement to sell dated
26.12.2013 has been filed is owned by Raj Kumari Malhi – defendant No. 2 in
main suit, whereas, Swaran Ram (since deceased) represented through legal
heir Gurmej Kaur was allegedly her General Power of Attorney holder. It is
the case of plaintiff Gurmukh Singh that entire sale consideration to the tune
of Rs. 1,20,90,000/- was paid to Swaran Ram, GPA holder and only sale deed
was to be executed as per terms and conditions of agreement to sell dated
26.12.2013. Therefore, Raj Kumari Malhi – defendant No. 2 in main
suit/petitioner in CR-9061-2025, being owner is main party to contest the
litigation with regards to property in dispute.
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


9
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


9. The main controversy in present civil revisions is whether
defendants were properly served in aforesaid civil suit or not. As per plaint
(Annexure P-2), Swaran Ram is shown to be resident of “ House No. 4 FCI
Colony, GTB Nagar, Jalandhar also resident of White House, Purfleet By pass,
Purfleet Essex, RM19 1TT England ”, whereas, Raj Kumari Malhi is shown to
be resident of “ 58 West Park Road, Smethwick B67 7JH England, U.K. ”.
Firstly, when notice was issued for the first time as per order dated
14.10.2015, defendants were ordered to be served for 28.10.2015 even when
they were to be served in England. There are postal receipts dated 15.10.2015
vide which registered letter was issued. Apart from this, summons were issued
to Swaran Ram on local address in Jalandhar, which were received back with
the report that he was residing in England. There is nothing on record to show
that registered letters were duly served or the acknowledgment was ever
received duly served. On 28.10.2015, case was adjourned for 17.11.2015 as
period of 30 days had not lapsed and finally on 17.11.2015, both defendants
were proceeded against exparte. Since, both defendants were residing abroad,
therefore, mere expiry of 30 days from the dispatch of registered letter by
itself does not mean that both defendants were duly served abroad. There was
no effort on the part of plaintiff Gurmukh Singh or the trial Court to affect the
service of defendants residing abroad by substitute means as provided under
Order 5 Rule 20 CPC. At the time of filing application under Order 9 Rule 13
read with Section 151 CPC (Annexure P-5), Raj Kumari Malhi took specific
stand in para no. 4 of application that she was residing along with her family at
238, DUNCHURCH ROAD, RUGBY, CV22-6HS (U.K.) and in support of
that she also annexed photostat copy of her Driving License which is tagged at
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


10
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


page no. 181 of trial Court record. In support of application under Order 9
Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC, applicants/defendants had examined
Nirmal Singh AW1 as Power of Attorney holder. On the other hand,
respondents now relied upon the Track Consignment record of India Post
(Ex.RX). The fact remains that Track Consignment record of India Post was
not relied upon at the initial stage when they were proceeded against exparte
on 17.11.2015. The suit was decreed on 09.09.2016, whereas, application
under Order 9 Rule 13 read with Section 151 CPC (Annexure P-5) has been
filed within a period of one month from the passing of exparte judgment. It
cannot be ignored that before filing of this application, Swaran Ram expired
and application was filed by Swaran Ram through his wife Gurmej Kaur being
legal heir. Once a person dies, Power of Attorney executed in his favour also
comes to an end. The presence of Swaran Ram now represented through legal
heir has its significance as it is the case of petitioner/plaintiff Gurmukh Singh
that entire sale consideration was received by him at the time of alleged
agreement to sell dated 26.12.2013. Therefore, at this stage, Raj Kumari Malhi
– petitioner/defendant No. 2 is the main contesting party. The application for
setting aside exparte judgment and decree was filed promptly without
inordinate delay especially when both defendants were residing abroad.
10. Considering the aforesaid factual position, it is always in the
interest of justice that case is decided on merits after giving opportunity to
both the parties to present their case. There is nothing on record to establish
that both Swaran Ram now represented through legal heir Gurmej Kaur or Raj
Kumari Malhi were duly served through registered letters when they were
proceeded against exparte on 17.11.2015. Therefore, finding no merits in CR-
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document


11
CR-8056-2018 and other connected matters - -


8056-2018 preferred by petitioner/plaintiff Gurmukh Singh, same is
accordingly dismissed . Whereas, CR-9061-2025 preferred by
petitioner/defendant No. 2 Raj Kumari Malhi is accordingly allowed and
impugned order dated 29.09.2018 passed by learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), NRI Court, Jalandhar and impugned order in CMA/205/2018 dated
09.09.2025 passed by learned Additional District Judge, Jalandhar are,
accordingly, set aside. Consequently, exparte judgment and decree dated
09.09.2016 passed by learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Jalandhar and
subsequent proceedings thereon are, accordingly, set aside. Learned trial Court
is further directed to decide the civil suit bearing CIS case no. 2311 of 2015
titled “Gurmukh Singh versus Swaran Ram and another” expeditiously.
11. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, in both cases shall
stand disposed of accordingly.
12. A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of connected case
mentioned above.

(AMARJOT BHATTI)
JUDGE

16.11.2026
lalit



Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether Reportable: Yes/No
LALIT SHARMA
2026.11.20 11:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document